You are on page 1of 13

SCANNING VOL.

32, 61–73 (2010)


& Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Application of AFM in Microbiology: A Review


SHAOYANG LIU AND YIFEN WANG
Biosystems Engineering Department, Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama

Summary: Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a The basic idea of AFM is to use a sharp tip
powerful tool for microbiological investigation. This scanning over the surface of a sample while sensing
versatile technique cannot only image cellular sur- the interaction between the tip and the sample
faces at high resolution, but also measure many (Dufrene 2008a). The tip with a flexible cantilever or
forms of fundamental interactions over scales ran- the sample is mounted on a piezoelectric scanner
ging from molecules to cells. In this work, we review which can move precisely in three dimensions.
the recent development of AFM applications in the During the test, a laser diode emits a laser beam onto
microbial area. We discuss several approaches for the back of the cantilever over the tip. As the can-
using AFM scanning images to investigate mor- tilever deflects under load from the laser, the angular
phological characteristics of microbes and the use of deflection of the reflected laser beam is detected with
force–distance curves to investigate interaction of a position-sensitive photodiode. Magnitude of the
microbial samples at the nanometer and cellular beam deflection changes in response to the interac-
levels. Complementary techniques used in combi- tion force between the tip and the sample. The AFM
nation with AFM for study of microbes are also system senses these changes in position and can map
discussed. SCANNING 32: 61–73, 2010. r 2010 surface topography or monitor the interaction force
Wiley Periodicals, Inc. between the tip and the sample (Fig. 1).
AFM has some advantages compared with other
forms of microscopes. The optical microscope is a
Key words: atomic force microscopy, microbiology, convenient tool for observation of microbial sam-
topography, force–distance curve, tip modification ples but its resolution is limited by the wavelength of
the light source to a maximum resolution of ca.
250 nm. Compared with the optical microscope,
Introduction AFM has a much higher spatial resolution (up to
sub-nanometer), which provides the ability to map
Atomic force microscope (AFM) is a scanning the distribution of single molecules (Dufrene 2008b;
near-field tool invented in 1986 for nanoscale in- Engel and Muller 2000). Scanning electron micro-
vestigation (Binnig et al. 1986). Two decades after scopy and transmission electron microscopy can
the development of AFM, this versatile technique also provide high resolution, but their complex
has been successfully applied in widespread bran- sample preparation (e.g. chemical fixing, dehydra-
ches of science and technology such as nanofabri- tion, metal coating and ultrathin section) could
cation (Simeone et al. 2009; Tseng et al. 2008), distort the sample substantially. As AFM measures
material science (Bhushan et al. 2008; Johnson 2008; through direct contact between the tip and the
Withers and Aston 2006), food science (Yang et al. sample, minimum or even no sample preparation is
2007) and microbiology (Cohen and Bitler 2008; required. Furthermore, AFM provides true 3-D
Dufrene 2003, 2008a; Muller et al. 2009). images, whereas only limited ranges in heights can
be ‘‘in-focus’’ at any one time with optical and
Address for reprints: Yifen Wang, Biosystems Engineering electron microscopies. Most importantly for biolo-
Department, 200 Tom E. Corley Building, Auburn University, gical applications, AFM can investigate samples in
Auburn, AL 36849-5417.
E-mail: wangyif@auburn.edu
buffer solution, which provides opportunities for
monitoring live cells in real-time.
Received 1 December 2009; Accepted with revision 28 January AFM usually provides two imaging modes,
2010
known as contact mode and dynamic mode, to
DOI 10.1002/sca.20173
visualize topography of microbes. In contact mode,
Published online 31 March 2010 in Wiley Online Library (wiley the AFM tip raster scans over the sample to obtain
onlinelibrary.com) high-resolution images (Fig. 2(A)); however, the
62 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

including intermittent contact and noncontact


modes, the cantilever is oscillated near or slightly
above its resonance frequency during the scan
(Martin et al. 1987; Zhong et al. 1993). Conse-
quently, the lateral force between the tip and sample
can be significantly reduced (Fig. 2(B)). Recent ad-
vances in noncontact techniques have led to spatial
resolution up to the atomic level in vacuum and
in liquids (Fukuma et al. 2005; Giessibl 2003;
Sugimoto et al. 2007). Therefore, dynamic mode is
preferred in biological sample analysis.
Some AFM users, including Yang et al. (2008),
further classify the dynamic imaging mode into two
subcategories: intermittent mode and noncontact
mode. In both techniques, the AFM tip is attached
to the end of an oscillating cantilever. For the
intermittent contact technique, the cantilever is
vibrated near its resonance frequency. The ampli-
Fig 1. Diagram of AFM work principle.
tude of the oscillation is typically 100–200 nm with
the tip intermittently contacting the sample surface
during the scan. This reduces the force exerted by
the tip on the cell surfaces remarkably in compar-
ison with the contact mode. In the noncontact
mode, the cantilever is vibrated slightly above its
resonance frequency with typical amplitude of sev-
eral nanometers up to less than 10 nm. The tip never
actually contacts the sample surface during the scan,
but van der Waals forces, and other long-range in-
teractions extending above the surface influence
the motion of the tip and provide information on
topography.
Besides topography imaging, AFM can also be
used in force spectroscopy mode to measure inter-
action force and physical properties of biological
samples. In this mode, the cantilever deflection (i.e.
force signal) is recorded as a function of its vertical
displacement (i.e. distance signal) as the tip ap-
proaches toward and retracts from the sample to
obtain a force–distance curve (Fig. 2(C)). Moreover,
spatial resolution can be achieved by generating a
force–volume image through acquiring force–
distance curves at multi-locations. The new frontier
in this area is using specifically functionalized AFM
tips to study protein unfolding/folding mechanisms
and recognize molecular groups on cell surface
(Dufrene 2008a; Muller et al. 2009).
Because of the above-mentioned unique features
Fig 2. Diagrams of different AFM operating modes. (A):
Contact mode and (B): dynamic mode for topographic AFM has been used in the investigation of micro-
imaging (Note: The actual oscillation frequency in dynamic biological samples since the late 1980s, and it has
mode is much higher than that in the schematic diagram. It is become a rapidly growing field in the past decade
much greater than scanning speed so that the tip oscillates (Dufrene 2003; Dupres et al. 2009; Hinterdorfer and
many times at each pixel, and does not hit distant points on Dufrene 2006; Morris et al. 1999). In this work, we
the sample with each oscillation period). (C): Force spectro-
scopy mode for interaction probing. review advances in application of AFM to micro-
biology with the focus mainly on publications
continuous direct contact between the tip and within the last 2–3 years. Different approaches of
sample causes significant lateral force which can using AFM scanning images for morphological
distort soft biological samples. In dynamic mode, observations and using force–distance curves for
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 63

interaction investigations are elucidated, and the inhibition effect of ferricyanide on microorganisms.
combinations of AFM and other complementary Dubrovin et al. (2008) developed protocols to in-
techniques are discussed. vestigate bacteriophage infection of bacterial cells
using AFM and studied different phases of this
process for three types of bacterial hosts: Gram-
Morphological Observation negative E. coli 057, Salmonella enteritidis 89, and
Gram-positive B. thuringiensis 393. The whole lytic
One of the most common applications of AFM in cycles of the three hosts, from phage adsorption on
microbiology is to visualize morphology of micro- the cells and flagella to complete cell lysis accom-
organisms. AFM has been widely used to monitor panied by the release of a large number of newly
numerous kinds of microbes and related processes to formed phages, was observed in AFM images of
provide low-distortion and high-resolution images. infected cells. For example, the AFM images of
E. coli cells during the lytic cycles are shown in
Figure 3. These experiments have demonstrated
AFM Images from Dried Microbial Samples AFM is an effective technique for investigation of
phage infection of bacteria, demonstrating its ability
Acquisition of AFM images in air is much more to resolve phage particles in detail, characterize and
convenient and typically has higher resolution than compare bacterial surfaces in different phases of
that in liquid. Air-dried microbial samples often infection, and easily distinguish intact cells from
provide a suitable hardness for AFM scans without infected ones.
significant topographic changes; therefore, much AFM is also widely used in observation of mi-
research has been carried out with air/nitrogen- croorganism behaviors. Yuan and Pehkonen (2009)
dried samples. used AFM to study biofilm colonization dynamics
AFM has been widely applied to evaluate mor- of Pseudomonas NCIMB 2021 and Desulfovibrio
phological effects of treatments on microbes. To desulfuricans on 304 stainless steel coupon. The re-
elucidate the antimicrobial activities of chitosan sults showed that the biofilm formed on the stainless
with different molecular weight, Eaton et al. steel coupons by the two strains of bacteria in-
(2008) and Fernandes et al. (2009) investigated creased in coverage, heterogeneity and thickness
the morphology changes of two Gram-positive with exposure time. The corrosion pits formed by
(Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus cereus) and one D. desulfuricans were deeper than that induced by
Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) microorganisms Pseudomonas NCIMB 2021, which was mainly
before and after chitosan treatments. Samples were attributed to the enhanced corrosion by biogenic
air-dried on a clean glass surface and scanned with sulfide ions. Zhao et al. (2009) investigated
AFM in air. Chitosans with high molecular weight the morphology of a strain of marine bacteria,
surrounded microbe cells and formed a polymer Shewanella sp., on different self-assembled mono-
layer during the treatments. The polymer layer layers. Interesting fingerprints were observed on
prevented their uptake of nutrients and eventually different surfaces. Evidence of morphological
led to their death, which was confirmed by cell wall changes and recessed spots surrounding the bacteria
collapse observed with AFM, but this effect did not were observed on hexadecanethiol, a hydrophobic
significantly influence the B. cereus spores as they compound monolayer, whereas these phenomena
can survive for extended periods without nutrients. did not occur on more hydrophilic monolayers.
On the other hand, chitosans with low molecular Hu et al. (2008) carried out a study on anaerobic
weight (chitooligosaccharides) probably affected degradation of lignin in waste straw by rumen
microbes by penetrating the cells, which provoked microorganisms. AFM was employed to image the
more visible damage. Rougher cell surface and lysed treated straw to illustrate the effects of rumen
cells were observed with AFM after the treatments, microbes. The results showed that wax flakelets and
but the use of chitooligosaccharides by itself on lignin granules covering the straw surface were
B. cereus spores was not enough for the destruction removed by the microorganisms and cellulose fibers
of a large number of cells. The observation also located inside the straw were exposed (Fig. 4). This
revealed the response strategies used by the bacteria. study provides direct visual evidence to prove the
The microbe clusters increased both in amount and lignin digestion ability of rumen microbes. After a
size during the treatments to resist the effects of careful observation of two strains of E. coli (B and
chitosans. Liu et al. (2009) evaluated the effects of K12) with AFM, Yang and Wang (2008) proposed
ferricyanide on E. coli DH 5 a cell growth and viable an AFM-based procedure for rapid detection and
rate. Cell collapse and rough cell surface were quantification of microorganisms in food samples.
observed with AFM after the bacteria were exposed This promising method may be useful as an emer-
in 50 and 100 mM ferricyanide, demonstrating the gency food safety test to help ensure food security.
64 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

Fig 3. AFM images of E. coli cells during its whole lytic cycles caused by phage infection. (A) before mixing with phages, (B–D)
incubated with bacteriophages A157 at 371C (B) for 5 min, (C) for 30 min (insets demonstrate zoomed bacteriophages) and (D) for
60 min. Arrows show the regions of phage release. Insets in panel d present zoomed regions of phage release, indicated by the
arrows. Insets in panel d are height images (height range is 300 nm); others are deflection images. Reprinted with permission from
Dubrovin et al. (2008).

AFM Images of Live Cells and diameter ranging from 1 to 1.8 mm. Confinement
effects are reduced in this new anchoring approach
One of the most attractive advantages of AFM compared with trapping the cells in porous mem-
over other nanoscale microscopy is its capability of branes or soft gels. The trapped S. aureus cells were
monitoring live cells in real time. Typically, a liquid monitored under growth media using AFM and a cell
cell is employed to keep live microbes in buffer so- division was successfully imaged over time. Pepti-
lutions. This provides the opportunity for direct doglycan stretching across the septum was observed
in vitro investigation of microbial processes. Hao during the division. Many other studies have been
et al. (2009) used AFM to carry out an in situ ob- published describing experiments that have employed
servation of Acidiphilium acidophilum on a pyrite live microbial sample imaging with AFM. Most of
surface in solution during an investigation of phos- them, however, focus more on the analysis of for-
pholipid effects on pyrite oxidation. A syringe pump ce–distance curves than surface imaging and will be
was integrated with an AFM-liquid cell to flow so- discussed in the following section of the review.
lutions across samples during measurements. Dis-
placement of microcolonies was observed after
phospholipid addition, whereas individually bound Interaction Investigation
bacteria showed little displacement (Fig. 5). The re-
sults revealed that the majority of the bacteria that Besides morphology imaging, AFM can also be
are displaced from the pyrite surface were initially used to determine the interaction between its tip and
bound in microcolonies. To image dynamic cellular a sample through a force–distance curve acquired in
processes, Kailas et al. (2009) mechanically trapped force spectroscopy mode. This unique ability of
coccoid cells of the bacterial species S. aureus in a AFM has opened up a new method by which the
lithographically patterned silicon wafer which con- physical properties and interactions of biological
sists of a square lattice of holes of 450 nm depth samples can be investigated.
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 65

reaction progressed, which was probably due to an


overall decrease in the stiffness of the cell surface
during the synthesis. Young’s modulus was ex-
tremely sensitive to the surrounding environment of
the cells. It tended to decline as the reaction pro-
gressed, showing mostly a decreasing trend in elas-
ticity of the cells. Vadillo-Rodriguez et al. (2008,
2009) used a novel AFM-based technique to in-
vestigate the local viscoelastic properties of in-
dividual gram-negative (Pseudomonas aeruginosa
PAO1 and E. coli) and gram-positive (B. subtilis)
bacterial cells. Time-dependent deflection of the
AFM tip was monitored under constant loading in
fluid conditions. The cells exhibited a viscoelastic
solid-like behavior characterized by an in-
stantaneous elastic deformation followed by a
slower, delayed elastic deformation. The viscoelastic
properties of the bacterial cells were modeled well
using a three-component mechanical model con-
sisting of an elastic spring in series with a parallel
combination of a spring and dashpot. Comparison
of the results obtained for the different strains sug-
gested that the instantaneous elastic response might
be dominated by the properties of the peptidoglycan
layer and the nature of its association with the
membranes, whereas the delayed elastic response
was more likely to arise from the liquid-like char-
acter of the cell membranes. This result will be
helpful in understanding the structure–property
relationships of bacterial cell envelopes, which is
responsible for many important biological func-
tions. Cerf et al. (2009) established a fast, simple and
reproducible procedure to generate a functionalized
Fig 4. AFM deflection images of straws treated by rumen pattern for controlled bacteria immobilization based
microorganisms for (A) 5 days and (B) 9 days. Arrows in (A) on a conventional microcontact printing process
indicate the exposed cellulose fibers inside the straw. and a simple incubation technique. A selective ad-
Reprinted with permission from Hu et al. (2008). sorption of bacteria on these local chemical patterns
was achieved, producing highly ordered arrays of
single living bacteria at a success rate close to 100%.
Force Spectroscopy Acquired with Bare AFM Tip The controlled immobilization method was used to
study the mechanical properties of living and dead
Force–distance curves obtained between a bare E. coli DH5 a cells in an aqueous environment with
AFM tip and microbe surface can be used to esti- AFM. Young’s modulus of the same cells was
mate a wide range of physical properties of micro- measured using force spectroscopy before and after
organisms. Kumar et al. (2009) studied the changes heating. The cells with a damaged membrane (after
of surface-adhesion, indentation depth and Young’s heating) presented a Young’s modulus twice as high
modulus of a metal-tolerant marine bacterium, as that of healthy bacteria. The mechanical prop-
Brevibacterium casei, after its exposure to the Co21 erties provided an additional approach to distin-
ions during a synthesis of Co3O4 nanocrystals. A set guish between a living or a dead cell, something
of force–distance curves was collected with AFM impossible to do using an AFM topographic image.
from the microbial samples during the synthesis Volle et al. (2008) investigated elasticity and adhe-
process and these data were used in calculation of sion to the AFM tip of cells in five simple biofilms
adhesion forces. These forces were found to be 10, on glass surfaces formed by three Gram-negative
40, 15 and 25 nN after 0, 24, 48 and 72 h of exposure and two Gram-positive strains. Cellular spring
of the cells to the metal ions during microbial constants, which represented the cell elasticity,
synthesis, respectively. Indentation depths of varied between 0.1670.01 and 0.4170.01 N/m,
the cells showed an overall increasing trend as the where larger spring constants were measured for
66 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

Fig 5. In situ AFM images of a pyrite platelet (A) after a 4 day exposure to a A. ferrooxidans (2  107/ml) containing solution; (B)
10 min, (C) 30 min and (D) 1 h after the introduction of 0.1 mM phospholipid. The solution flow rate through the AFM cell was
0.2 ml/min. The images suggest that microcolonies (enclosed in ovals) were displaced upon phospholipid addition, whereas
individually bound bacteria (enclosed by squares) show little if any displacement. Reprinted with permission from Hao et al. (2009).

Gram-positive cells than for Gram-negative cells. analysis based on electrophoretic mobilities of the
Adhesive interactions between the retracting silicon bacteria monitored in the experiments. For both
nitride tip and the cells varied between cell types in bacterial strains, the experimental force curves
terms of the adhesion forces, the adhesion distances agreed with the theoretical ones only when the in-
and the number of adhesion events. The Gram-ne- terfacial heterogeneity was considered in the model.
gative cells’ adhesion to the tip showed the longest This demonstrated that it is necessary to account for
adhesion distance, sometimes more than 1 mm, the spatial distribution of the electrohydrodynamic
whereas the shortest distance adhesion events were parameters in modeling to interpret AFM and
measured between the two Gram-positive cell types electrokinetic data consistently. It is known that
and the tip. These physical properties were related AFM contact mode imaging does not accurately
to the first stages of biofilm formation. The results locate the apical surface and periphery of the cell
showed that all of the biofilm-forming cells had a because a lateral component of the applied load on
high cellular spring constant, indicating they were an AFM tip deforms the cell during the raster scan.
quite stiff. It appeared from the extension and re- This may cause some difficulty in accurately locat-
traction curves that all of the biofilm-forming cells ing the cell surface when acquiring a force curve at
were coated by a soft layer of associated extra- an interest point based on a contact mode image. To
cellular polymeric substances (EPSs). Such EPS solve this problem, Gaboriaud et al. (2008b) em-
layers are known to facilitate bacterial adhesion to a ployed a force–volume mode to image live bacterial
surface during biofilm formation, and indeed, they cell Shewanella putrefaciens. The mode involved
adhere strongly to the tip as it is retracted. Gabor- measurement of a grid of force profiles in which an
iaud et al. (2008a) measured the interaction forces individual force–distance curve was acquired at each
between an AFM probe and two types of live She- pixel and the AFM tip was completely detached
wanella bacterial strains with different outer gel-like from the cell surface before being moved to the next
layers. The interaction forces were also calculated pixel. As the tip was only moved vertically when
through an advanced soft particle electrokinetic it contacted the sample (as shown in Fig. 2(C)),
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 67

no lateral force was applied. Accurately located was noted, reflecting a dramatic decrease of hydro-
force curves were obtained in this study, and me- phobicity (Fig. 6). In another article from the same
chanical properties of the cell (e.g. Young’s mod- research group, Dufrene (2008c) presented proto-
ulus, cell turgor pressure, and elastic and plastic cols for analyzing spores of the pathogen A. fumi-
energies) were extracted from the data of the for- gatus using real-time AFM imaging and CFM. The
ce–volume measurements. However, the resolution use of porous polymer membranes for immobilizing
of the topographic image, which was reconstructed single live cells and the modification of gold-coated
from the zero-force height at each probed point on tips with alkanethiols for CFM measurements were
the cell surface, was very low (10  10 pixels in discussed, as well as the recording conditions and
4.5  4.5 mm2 area). data interpretation.
Dorobantu et al. (2008, 2009) investigated two
live bacterial species, Acinetobacter Venetianus
Force Spectroscopy Acquired with Functionalized RAG-1 and Rhodococcus erythropolis 20S-E1-c.
AFM Tip A hydrophobic AFM tip functionalized to expose
methyl groups was used to measure adhesion forces
Although measurements of the interaction be- on the cell surfaces. A. Venetianus RAG-1 showed
tween a bare AFM tip (typically a silicon nitride tip) an irregular pattern with multiple adhesion peaks
and a sample provides useful information, the ad- suggesting the presence of biopolymers with differ-
hesion forces may not necessarily reflect the inter- ent lengths on its surface. R. erythropolis 20S-E1-c
action involved in real microbial processes, exhibited long-range attraction forces and single
especially when adhesion forces between cells and a rupture events suggesting a more hydrophobic and
certain chemical group, molecule or surface are of smoother surface. Heterogeneity at a length scale of
interest. To monitor interaction forces of interest, 50–100 nm was observed on the surfaces of both
modified AFM tips were introduced. AFM tips can strains. As the force curves were not successfully
be functionalized using specific functional groups, described by the classical Derjaguin–Landau–
molecules or even cells. Based on the materials used Verwey–Overbeek (DLVO) theory, two types of
to coat the tip, these corresponding techniques are extended DLVO models were proposed. The first
called chemical force microscopy (CFM), single- modification considers an additional acid–base
molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) and single-cell component that accounts for attractive hydrophobic
force spectroscopy (SCFS). This development has interactions and repulsive hydration effects, and the
greatly extended applications of AFM in micro- second model considers an additional exponentially
biology. decaying steric interaction between polymeric bru-
In CFM, AFM tips are modified with specific shes in addition to the acid–base interactions. The
functional groups to monitor microscale interac- predictions of those extended DLVO models agreed
tions (Frisbie et al. 1994, Noy 2006). Alsteens et al. well with the AFM experimental data, indicating
(2007) used CFM with hydrophobic, methyl-termi- that bacterial adhesion is significantly influenced by
nated tips to measure local hydrophobic forces on the presence of extracellular structures. Herzberg
organic surfaces with different hydrophobicities. et al. (2009) studied the interactions between a car-
The results were well correlated with the macroscale boxylate-modified latex (CML) particle functiona-
wettability of the surfaces determined by water lized AFM tip and an EPS-fouled reverse osmosis
contact angle, demonstrating the ability of CFM for (RO) membrane surface. A significant increase of
sensing microscale hydrophobic interactions. The the adhesion force was observed with the presence
hydrophobic tip was then used to probe the surface of calcium ions, indicating a bridging effect between
of mycobacteria. Strong hydrophobicity was found the EPS and the CML probe due to the complexa-
on the surface, which may have been due to the tion or binding of calcium ions to carboxylic groups.
presence of the hydrophobic mycolic acid in the This effect may play a major role in biofouling of
outermost layer. The discovery supports the notion RO membranes.
that these hydrophobic compounds represent an In SMFS, AFM tips are modified using mole-
important permeation barrier to drugs. Dague et al. cules with specific biochemical activities to char-
(2007, 2008) employed the same hydrophobic tips to acterize molecular interactions and distributions
map the hydrophobicity of a live human opportu- in biological systems (Muller and Dufrene 2008;
nistic pathogen, Aspergillus fumigatus, at the na- Neuman and Nagy 2008). Francius et al. (2008)
noscale. The conidial surface in an aqueous solution investigated the clinically important probiotic
displayed densely packed rodlets and was uniformly bacterium Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG (LGG)
hydrophobic. Moreover, continuous observation on wild-type and the CMPG5413 mutant which
a single spore during its germination was achieved, was impaired in adherence, biofilm formation
and a substantial reduction of adhesion contrast and polysaccharide production. Cell surface
68 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

Fig 6. High-resolution deflection images (left) and adhesion force maps (right, scale bars: 100 nm; z range 5 5 nN) recorded on a
single A. fumigatus spore during germination. The conidial surface had a crystalline rodlet look and was uniformly hydrophobic
before the germination. After 2 h, both rodlet and amorphous regions were found to coexist (separated by dash line), and
heterogeneous contrast was observed in the form of hydrophobic patches surrounded by a hydrophilic sea. Within 3 h, the
crystalline rodlet layer changed into a layer of amorphous material. The substantial reduction of adhesion contrast reflected a
dramatic decrease of hydrophobicity. Reprinted with permission from Dague et al. (2008).

polysaccharides were probed at the molecular level extensions. The polysaccharide chains on LGG
to elucidate the differences. For this purpose, AFM wild-type had much larger adhesion forces, longer
tips were functionalized to expose the lectin con- rupture distances, and were more densely dis-
canavalin A (Con A) and the lectin from P. aeru- tributed compared to those of the mutant. This
ginosa (PA-I) via a 6 nm-long polyethylene glycol study demonstrated the crucial role played by cell
chain. Two kinds of polysaccharide chains were wall polysaccharides in determining nanoscale sur-
identified on the cell surfaces of both strains: poly- face properties. Alsteens et al. (2008) studied two
saccharides rich in mannose (recognized by Con brewing yeast strains, Saccharomyces carlsbergensis
A-terminated tips) having moderate extensions, and S. cerevisiae with in situ AFM in three different
and polysaccharides rich in galactose (recognized modes. Although both strains are smooth and
by PA-I-terminated tips) having much longer homogeneous, an evident difference in cell wall
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 69

elasticity was revealed in nanomechanical measure- and molecular level are useful to explain the different
ments (Fig. 7(A–D)). In SMFS analysis with Con aggregation properties of the two organisms.
A-modified tips, major differences in polysaccharide Another remarkable application of SMFS is to
properties of the two strains were discovered. Poly- study unfolding forces and mechanics of proteins.
saccharides on S. cerevisiae surface were more ex- The pioneering work in measuring mechanical
tended, suggesting that not only oligosaccharides but properties and unfolding force of individual titin
also polypeptide chains of the mannoproteins were molecules was achieved with SMFS in the late 1990s
stretched (Fig. 7(E, F)). These findings at the nanoscale (Rief et al. 1997). These molecular mechanisms of

Fig 7. AFM images recorded on bud scar region of S. carlsbergensis (left) and S. cerevisiae (right). (A), (B): deflection images;
(C), (D): corresponding elasticity maps (z-range 5 3 MPa); (E), (F): three-dimensional reconstructed maps of polymer properties
obtained by combining adhesion force values (expressed as false colors) and rupture distance (expressed as z level). Reprinted with
permission from Alsteens et al. (2008).
70 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

cell adhesion proteins are important for the identi- alive during the force spectrum measurements. Re-
fication of potential drug targets. Alsteens et al. sults showed that bacterial interactions with quartz
(2009) explored the adhesive and mechanical prop- surfaces measured with probes prepared through the
erties of the widely expressed Als5p cell adhesion new method were greatly different from those ob-
protein from the opportunistic pathogen Candida tained with the glutaraldehyde-treated cell probes.
albicans. The forces required to unfold individual Great influence by the bacterium exocellular poly-
tandem repeats of the protein were determined to be mers and solution chemistry on the interactions was
150–250 pN. The unfolding probability increased observed.
with the number of tandem repeats and correlated
with the level of cell adherence. The authors sug-
gested that this modular elongation mechanism
Combining AFM with Other Analytical
imparted both strength and toughness to the pro-
Techniques
tein, making it ideally suited to function as an ad-
hesion molecule.
Although AFM is a powerful technique with
In SCFS, AFM tips are replaced or modified with
many advantages, this stand-alone tool has its own
one or more living cells that are used to measure
limitations. Combinations of AFM with other
interactions toward other cells or substrates
complementary techniques provide great opportu-
(Helenius et al. 2008). The force–distance curve re-
nities for obtaining more comprehensive informa-
corded when pulling the cell back from its objective
tion from interesting samples, which further
can detect different unbinding events and discrete
expands AFM applications in microbiology (Flores
force steps can be assigned to the rupture of
and Toca-Herrera 2009; Oreopoulos and Yip 2008).
single cell adhesion molecules. Boks et al. (2008)
investigated adhesion forces of four strains of
S. epidermidis to hydrophobic and hydrophilic sur-
faces. Significant differences of initial adhesion for- Combining AFM with Optical Microscopy
ces were observed between the two surfaces.
Over time, bond strengthening on hydrophobic As a sensing technique, AFM uses its tip to ‘‘feel’’
dimethyldichlorosilane-coated glass was fast (less samples (Morris et al. 1999). Combination of AFM
than 10 s), limited to a minor increase in adhesion with transmitted light optical microscopes, e.g.
force, and likely governed by hydrophobic interac- fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy (FLIM)
tion. However, bond strengthening on hydrophilic and total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy
glass occurred within 5–35 s to maximum adhesion (TIRFM), can enable researchers to ‘‘look’’ at the
forces of 1.970.7 nN and was concurrent with the samples simultaneously.
development of multiple adhesion peaks upon In biological applications, organelles and mole-
retract. This was attributed to progressive formation cular complexes can be selectively labeled with
of hydrogen bonds made possible by ongoing fluorescent dyes to make them visible. The combi-
rearrangements of outer cell surface structures. As a nation of AFM topography and fluorescence images
consequence, adhesion forces strengthened con- provides a unique tool for correlating organelles and
siderably more on hydrophilic glass than on chemical components with cell morphology. Micic
hydrophobic glass. Poisson analysis of the multiple et al. (2004) carried out an investigation on living
adhesion peaks allowed separation of contributions Gram-negative S. oneidensis MR-1 cells with high-
of hydrogen bonding from other nonspecific inter- resolution AFM-tip-enhanced FLIM. A gene fusion
action forces and revealed a force contribution of of yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) to the methyl
0.8 nN for hydrogen bonding and 10.3 nN for accepting chemotaxis protein (MCP) was con-
other nonspecific interaction forces. The time-de- structed before the test. The AFM height image,
pendent bacterial adhesion forces were comparable fluorescence intensity image and fluorescence life-
for all four staphylococcal strains. Kang and time image of single cells in the same sample region
Elimelech (2009) developed a novel procedure for are shown in Figure 8(A–C), respectively. The AFM
preparing live bacterial cell probes for AFM using a image showed higher surface topography at both
bioinspired polydopamine wet adhesive. Traditional ends of the cells. Fluorescence images also showed
adhesion methods, which use various chemical ap- higher intensities at both ends of the cells, which
proaches, likely denature bacterial surfaces by cross- suggests polar localization of the MCP-YFP fusion
linking proteins during glutaraldehyde treatment, protein. Therefore, a correlation between the sur-
rearrange bacterial cell surface structure by the ad- face protuberances in MR-1 cells and polar locali-
sorption of cells onto positively charged surfaces, zation of the MCP-YFP fusion protein could be
and inactivate cells glued to the end of the canti- concluded based on the combination of the AFM
lever. The new method could keep the attached cells and fluorescence images.
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 71

Fig 8. AFM-confocal FLIM image of S. oneidensis bacterial cells on poly-L-lysine surface: (A) topographic AFM image, (B)
confocal fluorescence intensity and (C) confocal fluorescence lifetime image. The differences of the fluorescence intensity and
lifetime are presented by the brightness and color (inset), respectively. The ploy-L-lysine was used as an immobilizer of the cells.
Reprinted with permission from Micic et al. (2004).

TIRFM uses evanescent waves to selectively consisting of calcium alginate fibers to evaluate the
illuminate and excite fluorophores in a restricted feasibility of the combination of AFM and TERS in
region of the specimen immediately below the total biological systems. Alginates are stabilizing com-
reflection interface (typically a few tens of nan- pounds in the extracellular polymeric substances of
ometers). As a consequence, a high-resolution certain biofilms. The mainly guluronic acid-rich
fluorescence image of a sample surface can be ob- parts of alginate can interact with Ca21 ions and
tained. Shaw et al. (2006, 2008) investigated how a cross-link different alginate strands resulting in a
cationic antimicrobial peptide, indolicidin, inter- three dimensional network-like structure, which is a
acted with model membranes, mixed zwitterionic good model system for investigation of microbial
planar lipid bilayers, with AFM-confocal-TIRFM. aggregates. The investigation of calcium alginate
The results indicated that the peptide rearranged the fibers showed that Raman frequencies in TERS
model membranes in a concentration- and lipid- spectra of biopolymers do not necessarily resemble
dependent manner. At low peptide concentration, it band positions in the normal Raman spectrum of
appeared to reduce the interfacial line tension at the the bulk material. Additionally, analyte decom-
domain boundary between the liquid-ordered and position due to laser heating and carbon con-
liquid-disordered domains. Peptide-induced mem- tamination were observed. Fortunately, strategies
brane remodeling only occurred under high peptide for spectra correction, choice of appropriate
concentration. These works demonstrated that cor- reference samples and data interpretation were
related AFM-confocal-TIRFM imaging is an at- presented by the authors. With this approach,
tractive approach for tracking preferential characteristic frequency ranges and specific marker
localization of fluorescent lipid probes and well bands can be found for biological macromolecules,
suited for tracking and characterizing protein– which can be employed for their identification in
membrane interactions. complex environments.

Conclusions
Combining AFM with Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectro-
scopy AFM is a versatile tool that images cellular sur-
faces at high resolution and also measures funda-
AFM alone is not sufficient to provide informa- mental interactions giving cells their characteristic
tion on the chemical identity of features on a sur- structure–function relationship (Muller et al. 2009).
face. Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is Although a topography measurement of air-dried
a label-free nanoscale chemical characterization samples is still the most common application of
technique. It uses a sharp metal tip (e.g. Ag or Au). AFM in microbiology, morphology probing on
When the tip is sufficiently close (ca. 1 nm) to the living cells will be more frequently employed in the
sample, the near field can optically excite nearby future given improvements in the instrument and
molecules on the sample surface, and thus, local operators’ skill. Besides imaging, force–distance
Raman spectra can be obtained. Combining AFM curves generated using AFM show great potential
with TERS should be a promising way to improve for elucidating microbial interactions and physical
chemical recognition ability for AFM. Schmid properties. Through modification of the AFM tip, it
et al. (2008) employed a well-defined model system is possible to investigate many forms of interactions
72 SCANNING VOL. 32, 2 (2010)

over scales ranging from molecules to cells. The Dufrene YF: Atomic force microscopy and chemical force
applications of CFM, SMFS and SCFS have been microscopy of microbial cells. Nat Protoc 3, 1132–1138
(2008c).
dramatically expanded in the last few years and will Dupres V, Alsteens D, Andre G, Verbelen C, Dufrene YF:
remain a focus of investigation in the near future. Fishing single molecules on live cells. Nano Today 4,
Combinations of AFM with other complementary 262–268 (2009).
techniques are being considered by more and more Eaton P, Fernandes JC, Pereira E, Pintado ME, Malcata FX:
Atomic force microscopy study of the antibacterial ef-
researchers and developments in this area will open fects of chitosans on Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus
new ways to look at biological samples. In sum- aureus. Ultramicroscopy 108, 1128–1134 (2008).
mary, AFM-based measurements will continue to Engel A, Muller DJ: Observing single biomolecules at work
play an important role in future microbiological with the atomic force microscope. Nat Struct Biol 7,
715–718 (2000).
research, and improve our understanding of the Fernandes JC, Eaton P, Gomes AM, Pintado ME, Malcata FX:
structures and properties of microbial cell surfaces Study of the antibacterial effects of chitosans on Bacillus
and the mechanisms involved in microbial behavior cereus (and its spores) by atomic force microscopy ima-
at the molecular level. ging and nanoindentation. Ultramicroscopy 109, 854–860
(2009).
Flores SM, Toca-Herrera JL: The new future of scanning
probe microscopy: combining atomic force microscopy
References with other surface-sensitive techniques, optical micro-
scopy and fluorescence techniques. Nanoscale 1, 40–49
(2009).
Alsteens D, Dague E, Rouxhet PG, Baulard AR, Dufrene YF:
Francius G, Lebeer S, Alsteens D, Wildling L, Gruber HJ,
Direct measurement of hydrophobic forces on cell sur-
et al.: Detection, localization, and conformational ana-
faces using AFM. Langmuir 23, 11977–11979 (2007).
lysis of single polysaccharide molecules on live bacteria.
Alsteens D, Dupres V, Klotz SA, Gaur NK, Lipke PN, et al.:
Unfolding individual Als5p adhesion proteins on live ACS Nano 2, 1921–1929 (2008).
cells. ACS Nano 3, 1677–1682 (2009). Frisbie CD, Rozsnyai LF, Noy A, Wrighton MS, Lieber CM:
Alsteens D, Dupres V, Mc Evoy K, Wildling L, Gruber HJ, Functional group imaging by chemical force microscopy.
et al.: Structure, cell wall elasticity and polysaccharide Science 265, 2071–2074 (1994).
properties of living yeast cells, as probed by AFM. Fukuma T, Kobayashi K, Matsushige K, Yamada H: True
Nanotechnology 19, 384005 (2008). molecular resolution in liquid by frequency-modulation
Bhushan B, Kwak KJ, Palacio M: Nanotribology and atomic force microscopy. Appl Phys Lett 86, 193108
nanomechanics of AFM probe-based data recording (2005).
technology. J Phys—Condens Matter 20, 365207 (2008). Gaboriaud F, Gee ML, Strugnell R, Duval JFL: Coupled
Binnig G, Quate CF, Gerber CH: Atomic force microscopy. electrostatic, hydrodynamic, and mechanical properties
Phys Rev Lett 56, 930–933 (1986). of bacterial interfaces in aqueous media. Langmuir 24,
Boks NP, Busscher HJ, van der Mei HC, Norde W: Bond- 10988–10995 (2008a).
strengthening in staphylococcal adhesion to hydrophilic Gaboriaud F, Parcha BS, Gee ML, Holden JA, Strugnell RA:
and hydrophobic surfaces using atomic force micro- Spatially resolved force spectroscopy of bacterial
scopy. Langmuir 24, 12990–12994 (2008). surfaces using force-volume imaging. Colloid Surf
Cerf A, Cau JC, Vieu C, Dague E: Nanomechanical B-Biointerfaces 62, 206–213 (2008b).
properties of dead or alive single-patterned bacteria. Giessibl FJ: Advances in atomic force microscopy. Rev Mod
Langmuir 25, 5731–5736 (2009). Phys 75, 949–983 (2003).
Cohen SR, Bitler A: Use of AFM in bio-related systems. Hao J, Murphy R, Lim E, Schoonen MAA, Strongin DR:
Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci 13, 316–325 (2008). Effects of phospholipid on pyrite oxidation in the pre-
Dague E, Alsteens D, Latge JP, Dufrene YF: High-resolution sence of autotrophic and heterotrophic bacteria. Geo-
cell surface dynamics of germinating Aspergillus chim Cosmochim Acta 73, 4111–4123 (2009).
fumigatus conidia. Biophys J 94, 656–660 (2008). Helenius J, Heisenberg CP, Gaub HE, Muller DJ: Single-cell
Dague E, Alsteens D, Latge JP, Verbelen C, Raze D, et al.: force spectroscopy. J Cell Sci 121, 1785–1791 (2008).
Chemical force microscopy of single live cells. Nano Lett Herzberg M, Kang S, Elimelech M: Role of Extracellular
7, 3026–3030 (2007). polymeric substances (EPS) in biofouling of reverse os-
Dorobantu LS, Bhattacharjee S, Foght JM, Gray MR: mosis membranes. Environ Sci Technol 43, 4393–4398
Atomic force microscopy measurement of heterogeneity (2009).
in bacterial surface hydrophobicity. Langmuir 24, Hinterdorfer P, Dufrene YF: Detection and localization of
4944–4951 (2008). single molecular recognition events using atomic force
Dorobantu LS, Bhattacharjee S, Foght JM, Gray MR: microscopy. Nat Methods 3, 347–355 (2006).
Analysis of force interactions between AFM tips and Hu ZH, Liu SY, Yue ZB, Yan LF, Yang MT, et al.:
hydrophobic bacteria using DLVO theory. Langmuir 25, Microscale analysis of in vitro anaerobic degradation of
6968–6976 (2009). lignocellulosic wastes by rumen microorganisms. Environ
Dubrovin EV, Voloshin AG, Kraevsky SV, Ignatyuk TE, Sci Technol 42, 276–281 (2008).
Abramchuk SS, et al.: Atomic force microscopy in- Johnson LL: Atomic force microscopy (AFM) for rubber.
vestigation of phage infection of bacteria. Langmuir 24, Rubber Chem Technol 81, 359–383 (2008).
13068–13074 (2008). Kumar U, Vivekanand K, Poddar P: Real-time nano-
Dufrene YF: Recent progress in the application of atomic mechanical and topographical mapping on live bacterial
force microscopy imaging and force spectroscopy to cells—brevibacterium casei under stress due to their ex-
microbiology. Curr Opin Microbiol 6, 317–323 (2003). posure to Co21 ions during microbial synthesis of Co3O4
Dufrene YF: AFM for nanoscale microbe analysis. Analyst nanoparticles. J Phys Chem B 113, 7927–7933 (2009).
133, 297–301 (2008a). Liu C, Sun T, Zhai YM, Dong SJ: Evaluation of ferricyanide
Dufrene YF: Towards nanomicrobiology using atomic force effects on microorganisms with multi-methods. Talanta
microscopy. Nat Rev Microbiol 6, 674–680 (2008b). 78, 613–617 (2009).
S. Liu and Y. Wang: Application of AFM in microbiology 73

Kailas L, Ratcliffe EC, Hayhurst EJ, Walker MG, Foster SJ, Simeone FC, Albonetti C, Cavallini M: Progress in micro-
et al.: Immobilizing live bacteria for AFM imaging of and nanopatterning via electrochemical lithography.
cellular processes. Ultramicroscopy 109, 775–780 (2009). J Phys Chem C 113, 18987–18994 (2009).
Kang S, Elimelech M: Bioinspired single bacterial cell force Sugimoto Y, Pou P, Abe M, Jelinek P, Perez R, et al.:
spectroscopy. Langmuir 25, 9656–9659 (2009). Chemical identification of individual surface atoms by
Martin Y, Williams CC, Wickramasinghe HK: Atomic force atomic force microscopy. Nature 446, 64–67 (2007).
microscope—force mapping and profiling on a sub 100- Tseng AA, Jou S, Notargiacomo A, Chen TP: Recent de-
Å scale. J Appl Phys 61, 4723–4729 (1987). velopments in tip-based nanofabrication and its road-
Micic M, Hu DH, Suh YD, Newton G, Romine M, et al.: map. J Nanosci Nanotechnol 8, 2167–2186 (2008).
Correlated atomic force microscopy and fluorescence Vadillo-Rodriguez V, Beveridge TJ, Dutcher JR: Surface
lifetime imaging of live bacterial cells. Colloid Surf viscoelasticity of individual gram-negative bacterial cells
B-Biointerfaces 34, 205–212 (2004). measured using atomic force microscopy. J Bacteriol
Morris VJ, Kirby AR, Gunning AP: Atomic Force Micro- 190, 4225–4232 (2008).
scopy for Biologists, Imperial College Press, London Vadillo-Rodriguez V, Schooling SR, Dutcher JR: In situ
(1999). characterization of differences in the viscoelastic re-
Muller DJ, Dufrene YF: Atomic force microscopy as sponse of individual Gram-negative and Gram-positive
a multifunctional molecular toolbox in nanobiotech- bacterial cells. J Bacteriol 191, 5518–5525 (2009).
nology. Nat Nanotechnol 3, 261–269 (2008). Volle CB, Ferguson MA, Aidala KE, Spain EM, Nunez ME:
Muller DJ, Krieg M, Alsteens D, Dufrene YF: New frontiers Spring constants and adhesive properties of native bac-
in atomic force microscopy: analyzing interactions from terial biofilm cells measured by atomic force microscopy.
single-molecules to cells. Curr Opin Microbiol 20, 4–13 Colloid Surf B-Biointerfaces 67, 32–40 (2008).
(2009). Withers JR, Aston DE: Nanomechanical measurements with
Neuman KC, Nagy A: Single-molecule force spectroscopy: AFM in the elastic limit. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 120,
optical tweezers, magnetic tweezers and atomic force 57–67 (2006).
microscopy. Nat Methods 5, 491–505 (2008). Yang H, Wang Y: Application of atomic force microscopy
Noy A: Chemical force microscopy of chemical and biolo- on rapid determination of microorganisms for food
gical interactions. Surf Interface Anal 38, 1429–1441 safety. J Food Sci 73, N44–N50 (2008).
(2006). Yang H, Wang Y, Zhou P, Regenstein JM: Effects of alka-
Oreopoulos J, Yip CM: Combined scanning probe and total line and acid pretreatment on the physical properties and
internal reflection fluorescence microscopy. Methods 46, nanostructures of the gelatin from channel catfish skins.
2–10 (2008). Food Hydrocolloids 22, 1541–1550 (2008).
Rief M, Gautel M, Oesterhelt F, Fernandez JM, Gaub HE: Yang HS, Wang YF, Lai SJ, An HJ, Li YF, et al.: Appli-
Reversible unfolding of individual titin immunoglobulin cation of atomic force microscopy as a nanotechnology
domains by AFM. Science 276, 1109–1112 (1997). tool in food science. J Food Sci 72, R65–R75 (2007).
Schmid T, Messmer A, Yeo BS, Zhang WH, Zenobi R: Yuan SJ, Pehkonen SO: AFM study of microbial coloniza-
Towards chemical analysis of nanostructures in biofilms tion and its deleterious effect on 304 stainless steel by
II: tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy of alginates. Anal Pseudomonas NCIMB 2021 and Desulfovibrio desulfur-
Bioanal Chem 391, 1907–1916 (2008). icans in simulated seawater. Corrosion Sci 51, 1372–1385
Shaw JE, Alattia JR, Verity JE, Prive GG, Yip CM: (2009).
Mechanisms of antimicrobial peptide action: studies of Zhao C, Brinkhoff T, Burchardt M, Simon M, Wittstock G:
indolicidin assembly at model membrane interfaces by in Surface selection, adhesion, and retention behavior of
situ atomic force microscopy. J Struct Biol 154, 42–58 marine bacteria on synthetic organic surfaces using self-
(2006). assembled monolayers and atomic force microscopy.
Shaw JE, Epand RF, Hsu JCY, Mo GCH, Epand RM, Ocean Dyn 59, 305–315 (2009).
et al.: Cationic peptide-induced remodelling of model Zhong Q, Innis D, Kjoller K, Elings VB: Fractured polymer
membranes: direct visualization by in situ atomic force silica fiber surface studied by tapping mode atomic-force
microscopy. J Struct Biol 162, 121–138 (2008). microscopy. Surf Sci 290, L688–L692 (1993).

You might also like