Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dissertation Social Media Marketing Consumers Perception
Dissertation Social Media Marketing Consumers Perception
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
MBA 2009 Dissertation
[Type text]
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Purpose: To determine the Indian Social Media consumer profile and to evaluate the
effectiveness of Social Media as marketing communication channel
Design/methodology/approach: Quantitative research was conducted among Indian urban
social media users through an online questionnaire. Findings: The profile of Indian
Urban social media consumers was discovered. Also their usage patterns were
identified. Hypotheses regarding usability of social media as a marketing
communication channel were proven. Research limitations/implications: This research
should specially interest small and medium scale enterprises as it provides
interesting insight about social media: important tools, strategic framework,
implementation and measurement, rules of communication and others. It gives an
overview about how other SMEs are taking on social media and identifies Indian
Urban Social Media consumers & their usage patterns. Originality/value: The
conducted study provides academic as well as practical information about social
media marketing and thus tries to fill in the gap in academic literature about
social media marketing. Keywords – Social media, Web 2.0, Social Media Marketing,
social media optimization, Marketing Communications, socio-technographic profile
2
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I acknowledges the help and support of companies, experience with whom, led the
foundation of this research. Experiencing social media marketing with UK SMEs-
Mydeco and Quba New Media gave a basic understanding of the requirements of a small
company and challenges faced by them. Researcher also shows gratitude to Indian
Urban social media consumers who took time out of their schedules to take part in
the research and provided useful insight by leaving comments to the survey
questions. I am deeply indebted to my supervisor and MBA Director, University of
Sheffield, Dr. John Kawalek, whose help, stimulating suggestions and encouragement
have been instrumental in completing this research work.
3
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Contents
Executive Summary/
Abstract ..........................................................................
.................... 2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ...................................................................
................................. 3 Chapter 1:
Introduction ......................................................................
................................. 5 1.1 Rationale for the
research ..........................................................................
................ 5 1.2 Aims & Objectives of the
research ..........................................................................
..... 7 Chapter 2: Literature
Review.............................................................................
................... 9 2.1 Internet: where from it came, where is it
going? ......................................................... 9 2.2 E-commerce
and online
interactivity .....................................................................
. 12 2.3 Web
2.0 ...............................................................................
.................................. 14 2.4 Social
Media..............................................................................
............................ 16 2.5 Social media
marketing..........................................................................
................ 18 2.6 Social media and
Enterprises .......................................................................
.......... 22 2.6.1 Social media strategy for marketing
communication........................................... 25 2.6.2 Application of 4
way cyclic strategical framework (Using Twitter) .................... 27 2.6.3
Integrating social media pltforms: Social media optimization (SMO) of Blog ..... 30
2.7 Benefits of using social media
marketing .................................................................. 33 2.8
Adoption of social media by
enterprises ................................................................ 33
Chapter 3:
Methodology .......................................................................
.............................. 36 3.1 Description and justification of the
methods.............................................................. 36 3.2
Research
design.............................................................................
........................... 37 3.2.1 Primary and secondary
data ..............................................................................
. 37 3.2.2 Questionnaire
design ............................................................................
.............. 38 3.2.3 Target population and sampling
design .............................................................. 39 3.2.4 The
pilot
survey ............................................................................
..................... 40 3.2.5 Validity, Reliability and
Practicality ................................................................... 40
Chapter 4: Research process and
findings ..........................................................................
. 42 4.1The consumer profile of Indian Urban Social Media
Users ........................................ 42 4.1.3 Where and how frequently
SMPs are being used in India? ..................................... 44 4.2 The
Techonographic profiles of Indian social media
consumers ................................ 45 4.3 The Influence of Social Media on
Indian Consumers ................................................. 48 Chapter 5:
Theorization ......................................................................
................................ 53 Chapter 6: Critical
Reflection ........................................................................
..................... 56 Chapter 7: Conclusion and further
implications .................................................................. 57
4
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
References and
Bibliography ......................................................................
........................ 58
Chapter 1: Introduction
Past decade has been a golden period for communication technology development. With
the widespread of internet, people have almost instant access to all the
information around the globe. New technologies are evolving everyday and shaping
the way world communicates; Web 2.0 is one of them. It has given people power to
communicate, express opinion and mold the information flow the way they want. In
words of Lee and Bernoff (2008, p.1)Customers are writing about your (companies’)
products on blogs and re-cutting commercials on YouTube. They’re defining you
(company brand) on Wikipidia and ganging up on you (company) on social networking
sites like Facebook…that has created a permanent shift in the way the world works.
Here it is worth mentioning that technology is just an enabler and ever-changing
but the key elements which will always remain dominant are people and their urge to
socialize. It gives rise to another media- Social Media, which though have some
similarities with traditional mass media, is different in many aspects. In past few
years social media has become the hottest topic in marketing arena. Big companies
like IKEA, IBM, Hyundai, HSBC, Ford, Dell, BskyB, AT&T, Apple and many more along
with American President Barack Obama himself, have produced success stories of
harnessing power of social media for communication and marketing purposes (Kim,
2008). For small businesses it is said to be a boon as most of the social media
itself is free of cost for use and if utilized effectively can prove to be sales
driving goldmine for small businesses. But, unfortunately there is a clear shortage
of academic literature defining social media and answering questions like how it
can be used in marketing? What should be the strategy? How to implement?
5
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
How should a company communicate on social media? What could be the measuring
instruments or Key Performance Indicators? Some research has been done about
consumer perception and socio-technological profile of consumers of social media,
but that too is limited to US market. Still there is no finding of the
technographic profile of Indian Urban Social Media users and how effective social
media marketing is in Indian landscape. This research project will try to fill the
gap between limited academic literature and practical information needed about
strategic implementation and measurement issues in social media marketing. It will
try to discover profile and general usage patterns of Indian Urban social media
consumers. It will find out how effective social media marketing is in Indian
landscape. The interest in the topic ‘Social Media Marketing’ was influenced by
working first with a digital agency as an external consultant for business
development plan of social media marketing services and then as a Social Media
Marketing consultant with a leading UK e-retailer.
6
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
outcomes for the company. via SMPs generates positive word of mouth.
-technographics) prefer different channels for marketing communication.
Statements of Hypotheses
In order to realize aim 2 following hypotheses were made and tested against the
primary data collected via the survey: Hypothesis 1 – Marketing communications done
through social media generates outcomes for the company. H0: There is a connection
between SMPs used for marketing communication and actions taken by customers after
the communication.
7
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
H1: There is no connection between SMPs used for marketing communication and
actions taken by customers after the communication.
8
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
9
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Image 2.1.1: World Internet Penetration Rates Source: Internet World States 2009-
http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm
10
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Future forcasts say more and more people would be online in the coming time. Table
below shows the future projection by eTforecast. Image2.1.2 Future forecast:
Internet users (in Ms) in different locations
11
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
2.2
Anderson (1999) cited in Cox and Dale (2001) defines E-commerce as ``the conduct of
business among e-enterprises and consumers''. Any business enterprise which has
capability of exchanging money, goods, services or/and information electronically
might be considered as ‘e-enterprise’ in the above definition. Internet has
provided companies a robust means of spreading there scope of business beyond the
imagination. Linda Peters (1998) affirms that, the “Web”, if seen from the
traditional communication channel perspective is both Market and Medium. It creates
a market space for selling and also serves the medium of exchange. More and more
websites are popping up every single second and new ways of conducting businesses
online are being explored. Following table shows that more than 111 M websites are
active presently.
A new era of communication has emerged with Internet. Seemingly there is very less
time gap between information creation, transfer, reception, notification and
reaction. Internet has become the universal source of information in business and
education around the globe, Information which is instant and easily accessible. Liu
& Shrum (2002) accept that Internet has given birth to two sorts of interactivity:
user-to-message and user–to-user. Here user-to-message interaction refers to the
12
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
extent to which users can alter the form and content of informative media (Steuer,
1992). The second sort of interactivity is between users (user to user) and
according to Ha and James (1998) more the interaction resembles to interpersonal
communication more interactive it becomes. Many authors have talked in detail about
communication and online interactive. A concise summary is presented by Lee (2005)-
This revolution in communication has changed the behavior of people. Internet has
provided multiple ways of Communication and above all this communication is free
and instant. Online people are connected to one another at all the time and can
communicate their message across the globe without practically paying any money.
Constantinides (2008) claims that internet has become daily reality for over a
billion of users worldwide because it offers following advantages Transparency and
abundant information: It provides easy, fast and inexpensive information about
businesses, products, persons and services which is necessary to make informed
purchasing decisions
More alternatives and choice: Buyer can choose products/services from around the
world sitting in his/her home and engage in any transactional conversation
13
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Easy contacts and business deals: Transactions can be made with a click of mouse.
The public trust in online commerce is increasing and the confidence in online
payments is higher than ever before.
Control over the transaction process: The buyer has absolute control on all
processes leading to commercial transactions (information search, product
comparison, purchasing, delivery, payment) without intervention of
2.3
Web 2.0
The term “Web 2.0” was first coined by O’Reilly in 2004 and in his words“Web
2.0 is the business revolution in the computer industry caused by the move to
the internet as platform and an attempt to understand the rules for success on that
new platform. Chief among those rules is this: Build applications that harness
network effects to get better the more people use them’’ (Musser and O’Reilly,
2006).
Based upon above definitions it can be stated that core ability of a Web 2.0
application is to allow users to network together and facilitate them to use the
content the way they want (creating, editing, sharing, and refining). Levy (2009)
while
14
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
reviewing web 2.0, points out three important factors which resulted in formation
of the phenomenon called web 2.0
Over one billion people are internet users and worth considering is the fact that
mobile internet users are much more than those having access of internet through
desktop computers.
After dot com crash of 2001 software industry attempted to build a new positive
apprehension.
O’Reilly (2005) describes that “Web 2.0 doesn’t have a fixed boundary but a
gravitational core” and in order to be classified as a web 2.0 application, an
internet based application should posses following characteristics (if not
completely then to some flexible distance from the ‘gravitational core’)
Web is just a platform and main emphasis of an application should be the services
provided, which creates value for the customer. Content is no more authority of a
sole person. Users of the content play an active role in content creation also.
Service improves itself as used by more and more users. Collective Intelligence of
people should be utilized. Although previous characteristics suggest that content
is created by collective intelligence, but still the main content remains the core
and creates most of the total value. Other users’ contribution should be seen as
additional supplement which creates competitive advantage. (Levy, 2009) Such
websites remain in perpetual Beta i.e. services are developed and released
continuously. While some experts support the idea of Web2, many stand in
opposition. Originator of web and director of World Wide Web consortium Tim
Berners-Lee in an interview with Laningham (2006) counter attacks web2 advocates,
saying it is just “A PIECE OF JARGON, NOBODY EVEN KNOWS WHAT IT MEANS…” According
15
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
to McLean (2007) ‘‘WEB 2.0 is the catch-all descriptor for what is essentially much
more dynamic Internet computing. Weinberger (2007) looks at Web 2.0 not as a
revolution but rather as an evolution or already existing idea of web. As the
debate on web 2.0 being something new or evolution of something already existing
continues, it remains a hot topic of research and center of discussion. Articles
are being written, search engines are sending new alerts and a new spirit is out on
the World Wide Web. (Levy, 2009)
2.4
Social Media
Boyd
(2009)
identifies
Social
Media
as
the
latest
buzzword
in
connected with people they might not even know. They are the most important player
in this phenomenon as affirmed by Constantinides & Fountain (2008) as they are
both- content generators and content consumers. Li and Bernoff (2008) identify this
new trend; which they name Groundswell as “a spontaneous movement of people using
online tools to connect, take charge of their own experience, and get what they
need- information, support, ideas, products, and bargaining power from each other
rather than from traditional institution.” They further claim that this phenomenon
is strong, self evolving, ever growing and unstoppable. Bowman and Willis (2003)
apply Moslow’s Need Theory on online community and present a deep insight about the
motivating factors of those participating in social mediaImage 2.4.1: Online
community needs
Drury (2008) recognises that with the popularity of social media a new age of
“dialogue” instead of “monologue” has emerged. Instead of shouting advertisement
messages now marketers tend to deliver content which is relevant and customized (if
possible) to receiver and leads to a discussion between the company and customer.
17
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Marketing Gurus like Kotler(2003) recognize the strength of two-way marketing for
advertisement, sells, market research and customer relationship Management. Social
Media by taking user interaction to a new level provides an environment for two-way
marketing. Hoffman and Novak (1996) recognize this shift in the marketing
communication model as one-to-many to many-to-many. This clearly signifies the
empowerment of customer in marketing communication in current environment.
Consumers are talking about brands and companies and have potential to influence
others’ behaviour. Peters (1998) agrees to it and identifies the ‘ability of
consumers to control both contact and content’ as the key feature of new electronic
communication media.
2.5
Examples:
www.facebook.com,
www.myspace.com,
3. Content communities- Websites designed for organizing some typical contents like
photo, video or social bookmarking or encyclopedia. Examples: www.flickr.com,
www.youtube.com, http://del.icio.us, www.wikipedia.org.
18
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
4. Forums- Websites for sharing ideas and information about any specific interest.
Examples: www.epinions.com, www.python.org.
Basically all these are different platforms to connect, communicate and share
content with people and thus provide marketers a powerful means of reaching
customers. In social media marketing above mentioned venues are used for different
marketing practices by leveraging the power of consumer itself instead of paying
for advertisement. It makes consumers more powerful as they the main actors in any
marketing campaign on social media. Core of any social media marketing practice is
to create a content that creates buzz in public, making relationship with customers
and encouraging and empowering them to promote the message among peers. Basic
motivation for people generating content in social media is their need of self
actualization as per Trendbureo (2008). They may generate content (free generally)
to
interact with others or to get recognition or admiration by others. This content
can have high level of viral/word of mouth effect. Promotional Campaigns in social
media if handled carefully can help companies progress swiftly and persuasively in
niche communities. As research reports (RazorFish, 2008; Internet Consumption
Report, 2008) say that consumers are highly affected by what other consumers talk
about the company or product. Li and Bernoff (2008) suggest that companies can make
use of Social Media Properties for five purposes (p. 69) Listening: To
understand consumers and their behavior better (Research). Talking: To spread
message about company or product (Marketing). Energizing: To generate word of mouth
effect (Sales). Supporting: To enable customers help each other (Supporting).
Embracing: To work together with customers to come up with ideas for
product/service improvement (Development)
19
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Lee and Bernoff (2008) suggest that it’s a common myth among professionals that
social media is NOT for B2B organizations while it does affect every one as
business people are people, too and social media provides them a platform to
connect, communicate and share content/opinion. However, the extent to which a
specific platform or social media as a whole could be beneficial for a company
varies depending upon company’s goal and techno-graphic profile of company’s target
customer. Another kind of segmentation is logical to understand the level of
involvement of customers in social media. Li and Bernoff (2008) categories
participants of social media in 6 groups and present them as a ‘Social Techno-
graphic Ladder’ with level of participation increasing upwards. This categorization
is as follows-
Category
Activity
With time both number of internet users and the percentage of online users active
on social media are increasing. According to Forrester research (2008) year after
year a shift is evident from bottom to top of social techno-graphic ladder (Image
2.5.1). A similar shift can be noticed in India and other countries with social
media websites gaining popularity with time. Web 2.0 sites like- Orkut, Youtube,
Facebook, LinkedIn, Blogger, Wikipedia, Wordpress are among top 20 Indian websites
(Alexa data, 2009) It is evident that social media websites are attracting people
from all walks of life. As a marketer’s job is to understand, contact or
communicate to customers, social media
20
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
becomes an important phenomenon with many of the potential customers spending time
there.
Source: www.forrester.com
In past few years numerous social media platforms have poped up and the number is
still increasing. The picture below lists and categorizes some of the most famous
platforms:
21
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Soure : social media landscape, flickr.com Image 2.5.3: Social media landscape
2.6
How social media could be used by enterprises? This question could be answered in
numerous ways depending upon the enterprise and its goals. Not a single strategy or
plan could work for all; social media it self may be very effetive for one
enterprise while not that useful for other. An organisation considering to have
presence on certain social media platform must ask following questions before
moving ahead with it What’s the goal? How are we going to achieve it with the
help of social media? Who is the target? How is the target consumer is going to
react? What are the social media activities they are already engaged in?
22
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Which social media platform is best suited for a speific goal? Who is the incharge?
How are you going to measure your efforts? Is it going to affect any of your
existing operations; to what extent? Is your company and employees ready for this
change?Who is the encharge for social media project? Could anything go wrong?
What’s the contingency plan?
Lee and Bernoff (2008) give a four step planning process for building a social
media strategy- POST. People: access how your customers will engage based upon what
they are already doing i.e. analyse your customers and determine their social
technographic profile. Objectives: What you want to use social media for? (As
discussed before- listening, talking, energizing, supporting or/and emberacing)
Strategy: what changes you want? How are you going to implement and how to measure?
Technology: what web2.0 technology you are going to use or build?(applications,
wiki, blog, twitter, social network etc.)
23
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Rules of Communication on social media Jim Tobin (2008) calls social media a
cocktail party and affirms that communication on social media has to be just like
one. Social media is not for shouting messages or telling your customer rather it
is for talking. Technologies are many and ever evolving, but still are just
enablers, CONVERSATION is the essential human element.
24
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
New Visitor
Listen
Learn
Share
•technology
Interact
•technology
25
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
KPIs, techniques, processes Social Value Tunnel: Social media marketing leaverages
the power of consumers to influence peers. In contrast to traditional marketing
communication where focus is on reaching as much customers as possible through mass
communication channels like TV, billboard, newspaper etc., the social media
marketing tries to build relationship with consumers and uses them as a carrier of
marketing message to other customers. Customerner itself becomes a messanger and
spreads the word of mouth. It is influential marketing where power of internet is
used to spread the word with the help of web 2.0 technology. A customer depending
upon the socio-technological profile and extent of engagement with company can
create different value for company from social marketing perspective. Concept of
“Social Value Tunnel” categorieses the customers on the basis of value creation for
social media marketing. Vlaue increases from tail to head along the tunnel. At each
point company should facilitate the customer and encourage advancement to next
point towards head thus leading to stronger relationship. Category Company’s push
New Visitor: attracting new visitors to the communication platform (blog, social
network etc.) Lurker: facilitating easy discovery Searcher: Facilitating
transcation (it could be any- fiscal, informational, social) Participant:
Facilating contribution (ease the two way communication, encourage comments,
uploading content, mash-ups, question-answers etc.) Advocate: Empower customers to
share the content, encourege them to influence others’ perception
Listen: identify your customers,what are they talking, which platform they are
using, monitor brand mentions on social media Learn: who is already influential,
understand tone of conversations, understand brand sentiment, understand tone for
competitors, how can you start Interact: build relationship, create content that
customers value, respond to customers, solve problems, be authentic, encaurage
participation, acknowledge sincere suggestions Share: Share remarks, comments,
mesh-ups, content created by ‘Advocates’ with others, empower customers to share
the content/company’s message with their network on the platform of their choice
Measurement and improvement: Performance measurement is necessary in all above
discussed four directions to ensure progress in right direction. Key Performance
Indicators are to be set inorder to insure ROI. Improvements are to be made
wherever and whenever required. Depending upon the function for which social media
is being used there could be different sets of KPIs. Enterprises also need to look
at which technology is appropriate for the measurement purposes.
27
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Source: Compete.comhttp://siteanalytics.compete.com/www.twitter.com/?metric=uv
According to Nielsen Online report (April 28th, 2009 Posted in Nielsen News, Online
And Mobile) 60% of first time users of twitter don’t use it again Sysomos Report
(2009) analyzed 11.5 million Twitter accounts and concluded that the top 10 percent
of Twitter users produce 86 percent of the Tweets.
Depending upon the brand, product and industry there could be several ways twitter
can be useful for a company. Following is a generic list of marketing functions it
is being utilized
Listen
Learn
Share
Interact
•Hootsuit: multiple user, pre-scheduled tweets, stats •Bit.ly- shorten URL, analyze
click through •TwitPic- share pics
Measurement
KPIs: # followers, # positive mentions, # RTs, Hits, Click through rate, Rate Of
Conversion, Average Order Value, Customer Lifetime Value. Analysis: Google
analytics, additional plug-ins enabling analytics to follow social media mentions
and report like Tealium social media measurement, bit.ly, Hootsuit,
29
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
2.6.3 Integrating social media pltforms: Social media optimization (SMO) of Blog
Quick Facts:
30
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Since 2002, 133 million blogs are indexed by most popular Blogosphere search engin
Technoratti. (Singer, 2009). Worldwide 346 Million people read blogs regularly.
(ComScore, 2008) So far 3.4 Million readers have subscribed to most famous
technology blogTechcrunch. (techcrunch, 2009)
Brief: Marketing objectives are diverse, so are the ways a blog could be used.
Blogs are being used by companies in sales, customer relations, advertisement,
promotions and many more. A blog should be seen as a central point for social media
marketing efforts that, with the help of new technologies and APIs (Application
Programming Interface), incorports features of all above discussed social media
platforms. SMO helps unlock the potential of a blog by empowering customers to
share the content (with hidden company message) with peers and thus bringing more
qualified traffic to site. Rules of SMO Although the content of a blog is the prime
factor and only if creates value for the customers, they will be reading or sharing
but SMO helps unlock the real potential of blog content. Bhargava (2006) founder of
digital influence group coined this term and laid down 5 rules of social media
optimization as1) Increase your linkability 2) Make tagging and bookmarking easy 3)
Reward inbound links 4) Help your content travel 5) Encourage the mashup Owyang
(2006) strategy consultant at Altimeter Group added two more rules6) Be a User
Resource, even if it doesn’t help you 7) Reward helpful and valuable users
31
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Sharing: So that viewers can post and share with their network on social media
RT & Tweet button: Adding these buttons along the blog post posts, allows and
encourages readers to directly re-tweet to their followers about the blog
Feature/allow Rankings for blog posts Comment Box: Simple and effective comment
aggregator
consider Disqus (disqus.com) it aggregates and shows all reactions about any post
on any platform. • Use widgetbox to design widget to aggregate videos, twitter feed
and all other channels
32
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Use card.ly to make e-card containing all the channel info. (Paid service, 2.5 $/
month) place it on blog.
2.8
It’s not very late since marketers started looking seriously at social media.
Rollyson (2009), MD of a leading management consultancy firm for web 2.0, talks
about adoption social media by government and commercial enterprises in Global
Human
33
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Capital Journal. He points out that following the hype and experimentation phase of
Social media in 2009 there will be a steep fall in perceived value of social media
as most social media marketing efforts will fall short of exptation. Thereafter,
with continued experimentation and learning, companies will gradually start
deploying technologhy in right way and curve will go up slowely untill it achieves
a sustainable value.
Initial Discovery (2006-2007) - While some enthusiasts recognized the value of web
2.0 in marketing, others wrote off social media as something for “kids”. Skills
were limited and most of the work related to deploying social media for marketing
was outsourced.
Hype & Experimentation (2008-2009) - During this phase marketers grasp some key
fundamentals of social media and realize the potential. Some of the efforts get
success and organizations keep experimenting. According to Rollyson, by 2009 this
reaches the ‘apex of immature adoption’ as shown in the graph and market would be
flooded by web 2.0 service providers and
34
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
agencies advocating social media who barely know more than client leading
initiatives which often fail.
Failure & Disappointment (2010) - Most web 2.0 initiatives will fail because of
limited knowledge of implementation and measurement but over expectation and falls
assumptions. This will bring a decline in perceived value of social media among
practitioners. Most will sit on sidelines while some visionaries will keep
investing and learning. As per Rollyson (2009)“This gap can be a significant
competitive advantage to those who manage their risk and plan to invest throughout
the period.”
Above discussed theory is based upon Rollyson’s personal experiences with leading
organizations worldwide and no substantial reasoning or proofs are given in
support. It could be hypothesized out of the above discussed theory that presently
enterprises are failing in their web 2.0 initiatives and social media marketing.
They believe that it is useful but fail to realize the full potential of social
media as they lack in strategic expertise required for successful implementation
and measurement. But these remain just assumptions unless they are validated by
large sample of enterprises trying to deploy social media marketing.
35
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Chapter 3: Methodology
Scientific approach for research often uses deductive logic to reach new knowledge.
In deductive logic a given set of rules are applied on data to prove a hypothesis.
As long as reasoning is sound it allows reaching a more definitive result. In
contrast the Inductive logic helps reaching a conclusion that is believed to be
true but not guaranteed. It is used to observe a particular case and make
generalizations thus creating knowledge in the process of research.
media marketing. The main objective of research is twofold, first to identify the
profiles and usage patterns of Indian urban social media users and secondly to
check how effective is social media marketing in Indian landscape.
Blackmon and Maylor (2005) assert that there are merits and demerits of both
quantitative and qualitative research. Which method works best for certain research
work depends upon the purpose and nature of research itself. Quantitative method is
used for answering questions like ‘what’, ‘how’, ‘how much’, ‘which’ etc. while
qualitative method is more suitable for in depth analysis and answering ‘Why’. As
this research is Scientific in nature quantitative method of data collection and
interpretation is used. Another reason of choosing scientific paradigm for research
is its cooperation with quantitative research method.
Success of quantitative research is very much dependent over the validity and
statistical significance of data. According to Maylor and Blackmon (2005), most
common way to verify research hypotheses and capturing opinion, behavior and
attitudes is conducting a survey. A self administered online questionnaire is used
for data collection because it is regarded as one of the best ways of collecting
authentic data from large sample base within a short time frame.
Data can be classified in to two types: primary and secondary. According to Ghauri
et al. (1991) Primary data is the fresh data collected by researcher himself during
the research while secondary data is the one that has already been collected and
analyzed by other researchers. Secondary data sets the ground of further research.
As this work
37
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
has already done by others it saves time and cost of researcher, that’s the reason
it is often proposed that this set of data should be collected prior of conducting
research for primary data. Ghauri et al (1991) states that collection of primary
data along with secondary data is necessary sometimes as the secondary data in
itself doesn’t provide the answer of all questions. Both primary and secondary data
are used in this research. While secondary data serves as the foundation of early
hypothesis, primary data verifies the hypothesis and answers the questions arrived
during study of secondary data. This secondary data was collected from a range of
academic and professional resources. As mentioned earlier, because of limited
academic literature in the field of social media; established practitioners’ blogs,
companies’ white papers, web stats, journals, websites and reports were analyzed
and data collected from them became basis of some of the key hypotheses. While
collecting data from these sources the researcher has been critical and only
authentic information has been included in the literature review. In order to find
the answers of key questions and to verify the hypotheses made in review of
literature, an online survey is used to collect the primary data.
When resources are limited and large scale data is to be collected in short time
frame; a self-administered questionnaire is best tool to collect authentic data
(Easterby-Smith 1991). Sekaran (2003) claims that three aspects are vital while
designing a questionnaire- wording, categorization of variables and general
appearance. Therefore, simple and generally accepted terms were used in order not
to confuse responders. Where ever necessary, definitions or additional description
was provided to make responders understand exactly what is meant by any question.
Questionnaire was designed using the already available templates of Survey Gizmo
(www.surveygizmo.com). Questionnaire was made on the patterns of questionnaires
used for similar research in US by Forrester Research Group. This questionnaire is
made of 11 questions and can further be divided in two sections- Perception and
Application. Question number 1-6 i.e. ‘Profile Section’ is determined to define the
profile and usage pattern of Indian social media consumers. Question number 6- 11
i.e. ‘Action Section’ takes a deeper view and tries to find out
38
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
39
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
any error because of biased sampling. Random selection was made possible because of
Facebook’s inbuilt function- network selection.
Malhotra and Brick (2003) while advocating pilot study, state that it helps a
researcher identify potential problems associated with the questionnaire. It helps
identify any problem with wording, layout, and sequence of questionnaire and helps
estimate response rate and time taken by responders. (Veal, 1997).
Chisnall (1997) suggests that the size of pilot survey should be at least 10% of
actual survey size. Thus pilot survey invitation was sent to 10 random Delhi
Facebook users. This pilot survey was sent 1 month before the planned starting date
of actual survey and was left open for two weeks to collect responses. Out of these
10 professionals only 4 responded, giving a response rate of 40 %. Two of whom
filled correctly and also left comments on survey questionnaire while one did not
answer 3 of the questions. Learning from these experiences questionnaire was
amended. Some questions were reframed and additional notes were added with
questions to make them clearer to understand.
Bhojanna (2007) asserts that validity, reliability and practicality are the three
essential attributes of a survey design. Validity here refers to the extent, to
which an instrument measures what it is intended to measure. Reliability means that
the measuring instrument should give consistent results and by Practicality the
author means that the measuring method has to be economical and in accordance with
the resources available to the researcher.
40
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
41
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Analysis of first question revealed that social media is dominated by males. While
42% users reported as female, majority 58% of the responders were recorded as male.
Male Female
Majority of the survey responders were from 15-24 age group, followed by 25-34 year
olds. Assumption could be made that these two groups are most active users of
social media properties. Although this couldn’t be stated with 100% confidence as
results could be affected by survey distribution method.
42
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
9% 17%
43%
15-24 25-34 35-44
31%
over 45
4.1.2 Popular Social Media Properties being used by Indian Social Media Consumers
‘Content Communities’ (36%) and ‘Social Networks’ (34%) are amongst the most
popular social media properties for Indian consumers. ‘Blogs’ (19%) are also being
used by significant number of Indian consumers. ‘Micro Blogs’ (6%) and ‘Opinion
Networks’ (5%) are not yet much popular among them.
43
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
4.1.3 Where and how frequently SMPs are being used in India?
Social Media sites are gaining popularity in India and it can be assumed that they
are becoming part of daily routine of those who consume them. Survey results show
that 67% are using them at Cyber Cafes (internet surfing centers). 58% are using
them ‘at home’, 25% are using in offices, 11% in school/university, while only 5%
of responders are using them ‘on mobile devices’.
10%
0% In Cyber Cafes At home In office School/Uni On the go
Research suggests that in India, users are spending less time on social media sites
compared to US consumers. Only 6% users accepted that they spend over 20 hours on
social media sites per week while 8% spend less than 1 hr.
44
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Less than 1 hr 1-3 hrs 4-6 hrs 7-9 hrs 10-20 hrs over 20 hrs
Figure 4.1.4 Time spent on SMPs by Indian Urban Social Media consumers
Major consumers of social media in India are ‘Joiners’ (54%). This big percentage
suggests that most of the Indian consumers are beginning with social media in
India. On the other hand, only a small number of respondents 6% and 4% respectively
stated that they consider themselves belonging to Critic and collector
sociotechnographical profile. It could be deduced that in Indian consumer market
social media is still a new phenomenon compared to US market. As suggested by the
research carried by Li and Bernoff, 2008; similarities can be found in both the
markets in regards of social media usage as both ‘Joiner’ and ‘Spectators’ are in
majority in both the countries.
45
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Analysis of research results reveals some interesting insight about these different
socio-technographic profiles. Let’s discuss in detail major groups and their
perceptions.
Creators
Creators are of the biggest interest for marketers as they generate content on
social media and are most likely to spread word of mouth. As discussed earlier only
12% of the Indian social media consumers fall in to this category. But even then
they are important from marketing perspective and should be observed in details.
Research suggests that creators prefer to consume and interact with company through
user generated content and are more responsive to company’s communication
initiatives on social media. Also the research suggests that these people are more
likely to recommend to peers and spread the Word Of Mouth.
46
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Interact more with that company 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Figure 4.2.4 Indian Creators' most likely actions after interaction on SMPs
Blog and content communities are most popular among this group. Marketers may
consider targeting these two SMPs to convey their message and to strengthen
relation with this group of consumers.
47
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Joiners
Majority of social media activists in India belong to the ‘Joiners’ category.
Particularly for mass communication, this group is important for marketers. Not a
surprise, Social networks and content communities are most favored social media
properties among members of this group. Marketers may consider these two SMPs in
order to reach this group. It’s worth noticing here that no responder in this
category reported to be using forums/bulletins.
H0: There is a connection between SMPs used for marketing communication and actions
taken by customers after the communication. H1: There is no connection between SMPs
used for marketing communication and actions taken by customers after the
communication. Analysis of research showed that there is a strong relationship
between the social media properties used and the actions taken by customers after
the communication. Results of question number 4 were compared against with that of
question 9 and Two Factor ANOVA without replication revealed that there is a
significant relationship
48
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
between SMP used and the action taken after communication as p value is quite
small. Unstacked data from question number 4 and 9
Interact more Interact with that with other company companies 9 5 2 3 17 4 27 1 2 5
2 1 Recommend that Buy form Trust company/brand that that to friends company
company 14 4 13 15 3 5 22 9 12 21 2 2 13 1 0 22 3 3
Anova: Two-Factor Without Replication SUMMARY Row 1 Row 2 Row 3 Row 4 Row 5 Row 6
Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Count 5 5 5 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 6 Sum 45 28
64 88 9 8 58 20 76 30 58 Average 9 5.6 12.8 17.6 1.8 1.6 9.666667 3.333333 12.66667
5 9.666667 Variance 20.5 28.8 48.7 74.8 0.7 1.3 109.4667 2.666667 78.26667 25.2
55.86667
H0: There is a significant relationship between the SMP used for marketing
communication and communication desired by customers. H1: There is no significant
relationship between the SMP used for marketing communication and communication
desired by the customers. Different answers of question number 4 and 8 were
analyzed using two factors ANOVA and results showed (p value << .05) that there
lies a strong co-relation. Thus rejecting H1 and confirming that different SMPs
should be used for different marketing communication purposes. Social networks and
blogs were found favorable for advertisement and PR. Unstacked data from question 4
and 8
Customer Market Advertising Sales Relationship Research Branding 15 12 19 16 13 3 4
3 1 5 17 12 22 11 14 23 1 2 15 2 1 24 2 2 13 1 0 22 3 3
Anova: Two-Factor Without Replication SUMMARY Row 1 Row 2 Row 3 Row 4 Row 5 Row 6
Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Count 5 5 5 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 6 Sum 75 16
76 97 9 8 Average 15 3.2 15.2 19.4 1.8 1.6 Variance 7.5 2.2 19.7 25.3 0.7 1.3
ANOVA 50
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
To determine if social media could be used to create positive word of mouth about
the company/brand, hypothesis 3 was tested against the data of question 7 and 10.
H0: There is a significant relationship between those who start communication with
company through social media and positive word of mouth generated about the
company. H1: There is a significant relationship between those who start
communication through social media and positive word of mouth generated about the
company. Survey data of question 7 and 10 when compared and analyzed and it was
observed that those who initiate the conversation were strongly related with those
who ‘agree’ or ‘strongly agree’ that messages received on social media stimulates
them to further spread it to friends. P value was found to be very less, thus
assumption could be made that social media users who communicate with company/brand
after friends’ recommendation are very likely to spread words.
51
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Press 5 3 0 16 15
Radio 2 1 0 4 4
Anova: Two-Factor Without Replication SUMMARY Row 1 Row 2 Row 3 Row 4 Row 5 Column
1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5 Column 6 Column 7 Count 7 7 7 7 7 5 5 5 5 5 5
5 Sum 35 16 6 108 67 69 39 11 19 15 24 55 Average 5 2.285714 0.857143 15.42857
9.571429 13.8 7.8 2.2 3.8 3 4.8 11 Variance 7.333333 2.904762 0.809524 131.619
41.61905 168.7 52.7 3.2 8.7 8.5 35.2 101
ANOVA Source of Variation SS Rows 986.4571 Columns 580.1714 Error 525.5429 Total
2092.171
df
52
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Chapter 5: Theorization
The research was aimed towards analyzing the changing marketing dynamics in Indian
landscape because of emergence and increasing popularity of social media in the
country. It was analyzed in literature review that with the emergence of Internet
in the country more and more consumers are spending time on it and social media
sites are among the top few most popular websites in the country. It becomes
imperative for marketers to understand usage pattern/behavior of these social media
consumers. Urban population especially is among major social media consumers.
Research identified the profile and usage pattern/behavior of Indian Urban Social
Media consumers. Their gender, age group, time spent on social media sites,
preferred social media properties, place of consuming social media etc. were
discovered. This information could be beneficial for marketers to better understand
their targeted consumer segment and customize marketing communication on social
media sites. It was discovered that male users dominate social media in India.
Social media sites are being used in Cyber Cafes and at homes primarily. Majority
of social media users belong to 15-24 years age group and content communities and
social networks are most popular SMPs being used. Most of the Indian urban social
media users spend 4-6 hrs per week on social media websites. As described by Li and
Bernoff (2008) and discussed in literature review social media users are different
and can be classified in five categories. Applying the same theory, Indian urban
social media consumers were asked in which category they think they belong.
Characteristics of each category were also given to them, so that they could better
classify themselves. Indian urban social consumers were segmented in five different
social media users’ groups- Creator, Joiner, Spectator, Critic and Collector
keeping the same terminology (literature review); depending upon their usage
patterns. SMPs preferred by each group were identified. As suggested in literature
review, there was found to be a great difference in usage pattern of differ
categories. Majority of Indian urban social media consumers are Joiners, who
maintain their profile on social media sites and consume content (images, videos,
text etc.) on content communities. This is worth noticing here that Indian urban
population is lagging behind US or UK population on socio-technographic ladder
(Forrester research, 2008). Figure 5.1 shows the socio-technographical profile of
US citizens. In
53
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
contrast figure 5.2 shows the technographical profile of Indian urban social media
consumers as per the research findings.
Spectetor
Joiner 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
The research findings suggest that social media is quite a new phenomenon in the
country compared to western nations like US. Majority of social media users are
best defined as ‘Joiners’. Only a handful of users fall in to the category of
‘Collector’ or ‘Critic’. Further ‘Creator’ profile and its usage patterns were
explored in detail. This is perhaps the most important category for any marketer
because they create content on social media possibly about company/brand or product
which is further consumed by other categories of social media users. Blogs and
content communities are most popular among Indian ‘creator’ group of social media
users. Since marketers may wish to build relationship with this group of users and
encourage them to spread word of mouth about the company/brand; blogs and content
communities are SMPs to be focused to reach them. Further the research revealed
that after a communication with company on social media they are most likely to
recommend the company/brand to friends and also they are likely to talk more with
company & trust more the brand. ‘Joiner’ is the biggest group among Indian urban
social media consumers. This group becomes of significant importance for marketers
for mass communication purposes. Research revealed that Social networks and content
communities are most popular SMPs being used by this group, so in order to target
them, marketers should pay special attention to these SMPs in India. Hypotheses
were tested to evaluate the effectiveness of marketing communication on social
media channels. Survey data revealed that there lies a connection between SMPs used
for marketing communication and actions taken by customers after the communication.
It could be assumed that marketing communication done through social media
generates positive outcome for the company. Thus it could be assumed that in Indian
urban landscape social media is becoming an important communication channel and in
years to come, it may be imperative for marketers to include social media marketing
in to their overall marketing campaign. Research proved the hypothesis that
interaction through social media leads to positive word of mouth promotion, as a
significant number of respondents accepted that after a positive conversation with
company/brand on social media they are likely to recommend the product/brand to
their friends.
55
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Also the research shows that different SMPs should be used for different marketing
purposes. Social networks and blogs were found favorable for advertisement and PR
among Indian urban social media users. Hypothesis was proved that different
consumers prefer different channels for marketing communication as per their socio-
techno-graphic profile.
56
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Social media is gaining popularity, with customers and with marketers. New people
are joining the social media users group and are also progressing upwards on the
‘social-techno-graphic ladder’. In the form of social media they have power to
influence other customers’ behavior. It becomes imperative for marketers to take
care of this phenomenon. Negative sentiments are to be converted in to positive and
positives are to be used for promotion. Marketers understand this, but real
difficulty is with knowledge, experience and competence. Like any new concept or
technology, social media marketing is also going through ups and downs of adoption
curve. Those who will keep learning and improving with experiments will develop
competitive advantage over others. This research lists academic literature
available about social media and provides a strategic framework for implementation
and measurement and thus tries to fill the gap between academic literature and
practical information needed about social media marketing. This research had two
aims: first, to identify Indian Urban Social Media Consumers, their usage patterns
and socio-technographic profile and Second, to analyze the effectiveness of social
media marketing in Indian landscape. Research analyzes that Indian urban population
which consumes social media is very different from that of US. This research
findings can be affected by two factors- first, the research methodology and second
the limited sample size. Questionnaire was sent through social networking site
Facebook, which is second most popular social networking site in India (after
Orkut). All responders were inevitably active on one SMP- social networking. But as
discussed earlier Facebook has in it all the social media properties that a blog,
content community, micro-blog or RSS may have. Thus this particular method of
distributing survey questionnaire is justifiable up to a fair extent. This research
should specially interest small and medium scale enterprises as it provides
interesting insight about social media marketing which itself has been very
57
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
attractive for small businesses because social media comes as a free media where
anyone could share ideas with others.
58
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Domain tools. (2009). domain counts and internet statistics. Available at:
http://www.domaintools.com/internet-statistics/. [Accessed on 18 july 2009]. Drury,
G. (2008), “Opinion piece: Social media: Should marketers engage and how can it be
done effectively?”, Journal of Direct, Data and Digital Marketing Practice, Vol. 9,
pp. 274 – 277. Easterby-Smith, M., Thorpe, R. and Lowe, A. 1991. Management
Research: An Introduction. London, Sage. eTforecast. (2009). internet users
forecast by country. Available at:
http://www.etforecasts.com/products/ES_intusersv2.htm.[Accessed on 2 july 2009].
60
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
Nilsen online. (2009). Twitter Quitters Post Roadblock to Long-Term Growth Nielsen
Wire. Available from: http://blog.nielsen.com/nielsenwire/online_mobile/twitter-
quitters-postroadblock-to-long-term-growth. [Accessed on: 2nd september 2009].
61
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
O’Reilly, T. (2005), ‘‘What is WEB 2.0 – design patterns and business models for
the next generation of software’’, Available from:
www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/09/30/what-is-web20.html[Accessed on
5 Aug 2009] Owyang, J. (2006). Rules of social media optimization.Available from:
http://www.web-strategist.com/blog/2006/08/13/rules-of-social-mediaoptimization/
[Accessed on: 5th September 2009]. Peters, L. (1998), “The new interactive media:
one-to-one, but who to whom?”, Marketing Intelligence & Planning, Vol. 16/1, pp 22–
30. Peters, L. (1998), ―The new interactive media: one-to-one, but who to whom?
Marketing Intelligence & Planning, Vol. 16/1, pp 22–30.
Indian Urban social Media consumers & their perception of social media marketing
Feb. 2
63