No Nama pengarang (Sumber dan
Tahun)
Penulis siapa?
Sumber bacaan apa ?, tahun
brp?
1 Md. Nurul Kabir, Andrew
Worthington, Rakesh Gupta credit risk in Islamic and
Comparative Credit Risk in
Islamic and Conventional
bank (2015)
2 Ali Mirzaei, Tomoe Moore
Banking performance and
Tujuan Penelitian Variabel Kesimpulan Saran/kelemahan
Penelitian
Apa tujuan penelitain? Depneden? Apa kesimpulan? Apa saran penelitian
Independen? Hrus menjawab tujuan sealnjutnya atau apa
penelitian kelemahan utama nya
To consider the level of Dependen : - Islamic bank have Policymakers and
Credit Risk lower credit risk regulators should
conventional banks Independen : than their employ both sets of
market-based counterparts. measures in any system
credit risk Islamic bank have of prudential credit risk
measure, significantly lower management
accounting Z-scores and
information higher NPLs than
conventional
banks, suggesting
Islamic bank have
higher credit risk
- There isn’t any
significant
difference in credit
risk between the
two banking
systems during the
most recent
financial crisis
To investigate whether Dependen : The view that nothing
bank performance industry competition,
 Industry Growth in an oil-rich
economy : Evidence from
Qatar (2016)
3 Fredj Jawadi, Nabila Jawadi,
Waael Louhichi
Conventional and Islamic
Stock Price Performance : An
Empirical Investigation
(2014)
measures of competition, growth efficiency, and
efficiency, profitability Independen : stability in the
and stability are competition, banking sector offer a
contributory to industry efficiency, qualifying impact on
growth for oil-rich profitability, the finance-growth
countries stability relationship
The mere increase of
credit allocation is
unlikely to contribute
to the growth of non-
oil and gas industries
Investigates the financial Dependen : Islamic investments Improving performance
performance of Islamic Independen : appear to outperform measures and extending
and conventional indexes performance conventional finance, the performance analysis
in three major region (the ratio particularly during to microeconomic
USA, Euro area and the turbulent times, while Islamic fund data
whole World) during standard funds seem
periods of calmness and to be preferred in calm
turbulent times periods
The performance
appreciation varies
according to the
performance measure,
which indicates that
great care is needed in
applying and
analyzing
performance ratios,
notably in relation to
risk type
 There are noted
heterogeneous results
for the three regions
under consideration,
which could be due
the state of
development of
Islamic funds in the
regions, the degree of
screening of Islamic
funds and the Islamic
Index selected, and
the definition of the
crisis date that can
vary according to
regions

Islamic Finance has

not escaped the recent
global financial
downturn but that the
latter’s impact on
Islamic return is less
significant than its
impact on
conventional returns
4 Hamidah Ramlan, Mohd To analyze the Dependen : 1. Based on T-test
Sharrizat Adnan profitability in Islamic ROA, ROE model, Islamic
The Profitability of Islamic Banks and Conventional Independen : Banks is more
and Conventional Bank : Banks in Malaysia Total Loan to profitable than
Case Study in Malaysia Total Asset, Conventional
(2016) Deposit to Banks whereas
total assets, Total Loan to Total

5 Abdul Rashid, Sana Jabeen
Analyzing Performance
Determinants : Conventional
Versus Islamic Banks in
Pakistan (2016)
and conventional banks in
total equity to Asset for Islamic
total asset bank is Higher
than Conventional
bank and
significant at level
10%
2. ROA isn’t
significant, ROE is
significant
3. Based on
correlation test all
variable is
significant
Empirically examine the Dependen : 1. overheads and 1. Islamic banks should
bank-specific, financial, Financial operating efficiency align their practice with
and macroeconomic Performance negatively affects maqashid al-shariah to
determinants of Independen : the FPI. Bank with magnify the
performance of Islamic Bank-spesific high ratios of effectiveness of the
variables operation expenses Islamic financial system
Pakistan (overheads, to net interest and advance the
deposits, income and excellence of services
reserves, overheads to total offered
bank size, assets are less likely 2. Investigate how newly
operating to perform well in developed financial
efficiency), terms of CAMEL’s instruments are in
Financial parameter agreement with maqasid
Indicators 2. bank reserves are al-shariah and how the
(market positively related to methods of aligning
capitalization the FPI, more bank practices to shariah
, Market reserves are more principles affect
Concentratio likely to perform performance and
n Ratio), better financial progress of Islamic
Marco performance of banks

6 Nasif Ozkan, Sinan Cakan,
Murad Kayacan
Intellectual Capital and
Financial Performance : A
Study of the Turkish Banking
Sector (2016)
Indicators banks 3. Islamic banks may
(GDP, Real 3. banks size and emphasize on the bank
Interest deposits do not size by increasing their
Rate{RI}), significantly assets and market share
influence the because small bank size
financial seems a one of the
performance of reason high costs
banks
4. GDP negatively
affects the FPI
Analyze the relationship Dependen : 1. CEE and HCE 1. Various methods
between the intellectual ROA affect the financial (tobin’s Q Ratio,
capital performance and Independen : performance of balanced scorecard)
financial performance of VAICi, VAi, banks in a positive 2. Cover all companies
44 banks operating in CEE, HCE, way. CEE has operating in the
turkey between 2005 and SCE more influence on finance sector and
2014 the financial apply to other
performance methods to measure
compared to HCE intellectual capital
2. SCE doesn’t have performance of
a significant effect financial in situations
on the financial
performance of
banks
3. The study provides
significant inputs
to the current
literature by
including 44 banks
in the sample and
analyzing the
VAIC values
according to bank

8 Maurizio Polato, Josanco
Floreani, Andrea Paltrinieri,
Flavio Pichler
Religion, Governance, and
Performance: Evidence From
Islamic and Conventional
Stock Exchange (2016)
9 Md Ejaz Rana, Waheed
Akhter
Performance of Islamic and
Conventional Stock Indices :
Empirical Evidence From an
Emerging Economy (2015)
10 Mrityunjay Sharma
Survey on Stock Market
Prediction and Performance
Analysis (2014)
11 Vincent Okoth Ongore,
Gemeehu Berhanu Kusa
Investigate the extent to
which the conditional
volatilities of both
Shari’ah compliant stock
and conventional stock are
related to those of interest
rate and exchange rate in
the emerging economy of
Pakistan
types
Dependen : IEs and CEs have
Independen differences as for the
:CEs, IEs business models
Dependen : *Positive and Initiated by examining
Independen : statistically significant impact of other
effect of interest rate macroeconomic factors,
volatility on KSE-100, such as inflation and
whereas KMI-30 GDP
remains unaffected by
the same
*KMI-30 is
marginally
underperforming
KSE-100 as indicated
by statistically results
on risk and returns
*there isn’t no
significant
performance
difference and
movements of both
indices
Dependen : Capital adequacy,
ROA,ROE,N asset quality and
 Determinants of Financial
Performance of Commercial
Bank in Kenya
12 Dr. Ong Tze San, The Boon
Heng
Capital Structure and structure and corporate
Corporate Performance of performance of firm before
Malaysian Construction
Sector
IM management
Independen : efficiency
CAMEL, significantly affect the
GDP, performance of
Inflation commercial bank in
Kenya.
Performance is not as
such about keeping
high liquid asset;
rather it is about asset
quality, capital
adequacy, efficiency
and others
GDP had a negative
correlation with ROA
and NIM and positive
with ROE
Inflation had
relatively strong
negative correlation
with financial
performance
Investigates the Dependen : There is relationship Nambah sampel
relationship of capital Independen : between firms capital Nambah variable dari
structure and capital structure ama
corporate performance corporate performance
and during crisis Demv, ldc, dc, have
direct impact on
corporate performance
of large companies
and other independent
variables do not affect
the dependent

13 Shanling LI, Feng Liu, Suge
Liu, G. A Whitmore
Comparative Performance of
Chinese Commercial Banks:
Analysis, Findings and Policy
Implications
14 Peter J. Buckey, Xiaowen
Tian
Transnationality and
Financial Performance in the
Era of the Global Factory
15 Yunieta Nainggolan, Janice
How, Peter Verhoeven
Ethical Screening and
Financial Performance : The
Case of Islamic Equity Funds
16 Mahesh Joshi, Daryll Cahill,
Jasvinder Sidhu, Monika
Kansal
Intellectual capital and
financial performance : an
evaluation of the Australian
financial sector
variables
To investigates the Dependen : Sampel hanya untuk
financial performance of Independen : bank besar, bank
Chinese banks by using menengah dan kecil
financial ratio analysis tidak teranalisis
To examine the Dependen : The paper rejects a Lokasi dan peluasan
relationship between Independen : direct effect of sampel
transnationality and ROA, ROS, transnationality on
financial performance in ROI, financial performance,
the era of the global and supports an
factory, and test indirect effect of
hypotheses against recent transnationality on
experience of leading financial performance
transnational enterprises through knowledge-
based assets
conditional on R&D
intensity
To examining the Dependen : Investor in Islamic
performance of a large Independen : equity funds must
global sample of Islamic trade-off financial
equity funds (IEFs) performance for non-
financial utility.
Holding-based
measure of ethical
To examine the intellectual Dependen : The ic performance of
capital performance of the average the financial sector in
Australian financial sector financial Australia is highly
for the period 2006-2008 performance influenced by HCE.
Examine the relationship of companies SCE and CEE have a
between IC performance Independen : noticeably lesser role
and the financial average in the creation of
 performance of the HCE, value in the financial
financial sector average SCE, sector in Australia
average CEE,
sub-sector
financial
industry in
Australia,
Average Vaic
17 Daniele Dandara To examine the impact of Dependen :
Banking Performance. IFRS transition from RAS to financial
and RAS comparative IFRS on the financial position,
analysis for the Romanian position and performance financial
banking system of credit institution performance
Independen :
RAS, IFRS
18 Paul Tae-Woo Lee, Cheng- Financial
Wei Lin, Sung-Ho Shin ratios
A Comparative study on …..
financial positions of Financial
shipping companies in performance
Taiwan and Korea using
entropy and grey relation
analysis
19 Halit Gonenc, Bert Scholtens To investigate the Environment Baca di abstract aja,, Ganti sampel ama
Environmental and Financial relationship between al, financial kebanyakan populasi doing
Performance of Fossil Fuel environmental and performance
Firms: A Closer Inspection of financial performance of
Their Interaction fossil fuel firms
20 D. Nakou, A. Benardos, D. To analyses modern Dependen : These two systems
Kaliampakos technique available as the Independen : have roughly the same
Assessing the financial and underground automated cost performance
environmental performance vacuum waste collection using the equivalent
of underground automated system (AVAC) and annual cost analysis
 vacuum waste collection present the financial and
system encironmental assessment
of a proposal system in
replacement of an existing
conventional waste
collection scheme in
Athens
21 Salvador Carmona, Govind Examine three biases Dependen :
Iyer, Philip M.J Reckers across two distant cultures Independen :
Performance evaluation bias : along the individualistic-
A comparative study on the collectivist dimensions
role of financial fixation,
similarity-to-self and
likeability
22 Kun Chen, Peng Luo,
Dongming Xu, Huaiqing
Wang
The dinamyc predictive
power of company
comparative networks for
stock sector performance