Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction Description
A fluid is a substance which undergoes continuous de- The Brookfield HBT viscometer measuresconsistency by
formation when subjected to a shear stress. The resistance measuring the force required to rotate a spindle in the ma-
offered by a real fluid to such deformation is called its con- terial under test. The force or drag is indicated by a pointer
sistency, K. For gases and for Newtonian liquids, the con- which is attached to the spindle shaft. The speed of rotation
sistency is constant if static pressure and temperature are and the dial reading are directly proportional to the rate of
fixed and for such materials, the consistency is called the shear and shearing stress respectively; thus a speed of ro-
viscosity. However, for many liquids used in chemical pro- tation versus dial reading plot is comparable with a flow
cesses, the flow curve (a plot of shear stress vs shearingrate) curve. Conversion factors supplied with the instrument en-
is not linear through the origin and they are known as non- able dial readings to be convertedto common viscosity units.
Newtonian fluids. If the flow curve has a slope decreasing The viscometer was calibrated for Newtonian fluid and any
with increasing rate of shear,the fluidis calledpseudoplastic. fluid will be considered to be Newtonian if measurement is
The rheology of pseudoplastics can be described by a num- made only at one speed. It is necessary to relate the shear
ber of models, the most commonly used beingthe Ostwald- rate and stress to the torque and rotational speed if the fluid
de Waele or power law model: is non-Newtonian.
The spindles which can be used with the Brookfield HBT
r = (dO)"for n < 1
K dt (1) viscometer are of different geometrical form and size. The
spindles generally used for low consistency fluids have the
The flow behaviour index, n, is a measure of the degree form of a cylinder (cylindrical spindle Tl) or the form of a
of departure from Newtonian behaviour. The further n de- disc (disc spindles T2, T3 and T4). The spindles used for
parts from unity, the more pronounced are the non-New- solids suspensions and also for high consistency fluids have
tonian properties. the form of a T and are called T bar A, Band C. To allow
the T bar spindle to cut continuously into a fresh sample,
Literature review the spindle can be submitted to an upward and downward
There are a number of different viscometric techniques movement whileunder rotation, creatingan helicoidal path.
for measuring the flow behaviour of fluids and many dif- This overcomes the separating effect of the particles in sus-
ferent types of commercial instruments are available. A re- pension whereprogressive disentanglementoccursunder the
view of the various techniques applied in the sugarindustry influence of shearing forces, the particles tending to orient
is given by Nessi, Mathlouthi and Kasprzky-. themselves and move in the direction of the shear.
Any rotational viscometer like the Brookfield HBT vis- Methodof measurements
cometer assumes the fluid to be Newtonian. If the fluid is A Brookfield HBT viscometer model was used for the
non-Newtonian, the viscosity is shear rate dependent and it determination of the consistency of C-products, ie C-mas-
is necessary to relate the shear rate and stress to the torque secuite, C-nutsch and C-molasses samples.
and rotational speed. Calibration of the Brookfield HBT vis-
cometer by the manufacturer was apparently conducted The sample in a container of diameter 110 mm wasplaced
using a Newtonian fluid and it is from here that the an- into a water bath to allow the temperature to stabilise. The
omalies arise (Behne'). consistency was then measured using different spindles and
different rotational speeds. The spindle wasallowed to rotate
In the literature, the use of the words consistency and in the sample for 10 minutes before the reading was taken
viscosity is confusing. Consistency is an intrinsic character- to avoid variations in the measurement due to thixotropic
istic of the fluid independent of the shearing strain applied effects (Taylor"). The molasses consistency was measured
during the measurement period whereas viscosity is a meas-
urement of the resistance to flow of the fluid under specific
conditions of shear. • Present address: Mondi Paper Company. Merebank. Durban
32
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
, = -
f2H
JJ
r 'fOr rdrd8 (2)
plasticity than molasses. The crystals in the massecuite rep-
resent a discontinuity in the solid matrix and reduce the
o o elasticity by creating a breaking tie. In the same way, water
seems to reduce the plasticity of the solid matrix by sepa-
The shear rate is obtained from the tangential component rating the lines of preferential shear and the value of n for
of the "rate of deformation tensor", .1, for the Ostwald-de the nutsch has been found generally smaller than for the
Waele model? as: molasses.
(d8)n _
(dt) - -
fR
J
[i I v"2~
or (.1:.1)
I(n-I) 8(.1)J
or dr (3)
Table 2
Different values of n
o
Author Range ofn Mean Value of Product
The consistency of the fluid is determined by applying the n
equation of a power law fluid:
Done? 0,85 + 0,04 Massecuite
t Adkins" 0,6/0,9 Massecuite
K=-- (4) Kot et aFO 0,8/1 Massecuite
(~~r
Bhattacharyya et aI' 0,8/0,9 Molasses
Awang and White" 0,92 + 0,07 Massecuite
Broadfoot et al 22 0,81/0,88 Molasses
Rouillard and Koenig') 0,8/0,93 C-massecuite
The equations for the determination of the consistency with low at
for the various spindles have been derived from equations 0,68
(2) to (4) and are shown in Table 1. This work 0,67/0,81 0,77 C-massecuite
0,56/0,81 0,73 C-molasses
0,60/0,66 0,63 C-nutsch
Results
Determination of the consistency
Determination of theflow behaviour index For Newtonian fluids, the viscosity is calculated by mul-
It is possible to determine the flow behaviour index, n, of tiplying the torque reading by the conversion factor given
a sample showing pseudoplastic characteristics from various by the manufacturer of the Brookfield HBT viscometer. The
measurements of the consistency at different speeds with the conversion factor depends on the spindle used and the ro-
same spindle and at the same temperature: tational speed.
Table I
Equations for the determination of the consistency
Consistency
Spindle Shear stress Shear rate
Literal form Simplified form
C + )(~)"
-1
-(~~) ~ (~)"
Cylindrical 1
TI 2IrR' G+ R L) 2nR' 3" R L nN
C + )(~)"
-1
-C~) (~)"
1
Disc spindle
n, n, T4 2nR' G+ R L) 2irR' 3" R L nN S:
T bar spindle
TA, TB, TC
-1
--
3R'L -(~~) 1
3R'L
CO)"
nN S: (~)"
33
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
The value of the consistency can be determined using the consistency are more consistent and independent ofthe spin-
conversion factor of the manufacturer and simplified equa- dles and speeds used for the measurement, thus giving an
tion of Table 1 as: intrinsic characteristic of the fluid. The use of Equation 6
does not modify the calculation of the flow behaviour index
K = Sd X C = B
Sd X (NA)" when determined using measurements done with the same
spindle.
with C being the conversion factor at a speed N. The sim-
plified equation for the consistency. can be used for New- Thixotropic effects of the molasses
tonian fluids (n = 1) and after mathematical manipulation The molasses showed thixotropic effects, with reading of
and using the conversion table from the manufacturer, the the torque falling with increasing time of flow (Figure 1).
value ofB can be determined for the various spindles (Table Nevertheless, this effect is a function of the shear rate and
3). as the rotational speed was reduced, the thixotropy was not
so pronounced. Done 10 commented on thixotropic effects for
Table 3 the massecuite but no such effect has been found with the
helipath. To avoid variations in the measurement of the
Values of the new constant for the different spindles
consistency due to thixotropy, it is recommended that the
Constant manufacturer sample be left to reach a steady temperature and allowed to
Spindle (at 0,5 rpm) New constant
rotate for at least 10 minutes after immersion of the spindle
before reading the torque.
HBTA 3200 502,65
HBTB 6400 1005,31
HBTC 12800 2010,62 Variation of torque reading usingan helipath spindle
HBTI 160 25,13
HBn 640 67,0 The reading of the massecuite and nutsch viscosity using
HBT3 1600 167,6 the helipath need to be averaged because the value changes
HBT4 3200 335,1
during the rising and descending motion (Ness"), As the
shear stress is dependent on the length of spindle immersed
in the fluid, it is normal that the readings are affected by
the depth of penetration (Figure 2). However, the way in
The consistency is now determined by: which the value of the readings varied was contrary to that
reported by Ness, the value was decreasing gradually as the
K = Sd X (new constant) X (~)" (6)
spindle moved downwards and increasing on withdrawal
which is in agreement with Equation 4, K being a function
of IlL where L is the immersed length of the spindle. Gen-
Values of the consistency of C-products measured at dif- erally, a higher value of the readings was found somewhat
ferent speed and using different spindles calculated by Equa- after the top position due to the elasticity of the connection
tion 6 are shown in Table 4 and compared to the viscosity between the spindle and the viscometer. The readings need
value obtained using the manufacturer's method. The max- to be done during a complete cycle of the helipath and av-
imum error encountered is 9%. The values of the calculated eraged to obtain the value of the torque.
Table 4
Comparison between Brookfield consistency *
and calculated consistency **
Temp. Reading Speed Value Value
Sample n 'C average Spindle rpm Brookfield" calculated**
* Brookfield consistency calculated by multiplying the torque reading by the manufacturer conversion factor.
** Calculated consistency from Equation 6.
34
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
29
28
27
~ 26
OJ
c
~Ql 25
IX:
Ql
~ 24
(J)
23
22
21
20 L-._ _I.-.._ _.L.-_ _.L.-_ _..l.-_ _...L-_ _...I-_ _....L-_ _- l -_ _-L.._ _--J
o 2 4 6 8 10
69
68
67
66
~
OJ
c
i5 65
ttl
~
Ql
iii 64
o
(J)
63
62
61
60
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 B
Top Bottom Top
35
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
exp (D + ~)
(7)
K = (l _ TS)X
1000
"
"
)c
-
50 55
Sample temperature ("C)
60 70 80 90
The coefficients of the correlation linking consistency of FIGURE 4 Consistency versus total solids
any C-product to the total solids content, crystal content,
pol and temperature have been determined by statistical
analysis done on 43 samples of molasses, nutsch and mas-
secuite taken during the 1985/86 season at Maidstone mill.
The correlation in the form of Equation 7 is written as:
6802,37 + 3618,15(TS - CC) - 13129,53CC + 3042,79(1- TS) + 19356,86(pol- CC)(1 - TS»)
exp ( - 21,33 + 15,90pol- 35,49CC + «4,187 _ 2,3(pol- CC)(1- TS»(1- TS) + 1,19CC + 1,7(TS - CC»T
K= (I _ TS)2.88
(8)
with K : consistency (Pa.s-) The multiple correlation coefficient of the linearised func-
TS : total solids by mass (fraction) tion is 0,972 with a residual error ofO,465. This means that
CC : crystal content (fraction) 68% of the calculated consistency will fall between 0,63 and
pol : pol of the product (fraction)
1,59 times the measured consistency (0,63 X Kmcosurcd <
T : temperature ("K)
KCOIcui01Cd < 1,59 X Kmcasurcd)' The values of calculated con-
The crystal content is calculated from the apparent pu- sistency using the above correlation versus measured con-
rities and brixes of the nutsch and massecuite. sistency are plotted in Figures 5 and 6.
36
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
5 6 7 8 , I 5 6 7 8 9 1 5 • 7 8 !I I
! ...,1 1/
.. ::::
:
. .. :.: .:::: :/
rrrt';'.:r~ ;;;,g~+; .;.~;:.. "1' l.tl: ...., .....
.... ,.. ; ( : .... ,. / ;
......
1;;+.::j....;-;...:;.+7-;..;..;..+~db+T"*rljrtriH 5
( j , ' ; .. :
.,..r- ,'
, .... J
H-!nr~
.,.
,... ·'·1··'· ..··
~!;
1.. :,::1:::.....
<II
"...
U
CJ
M
M
~1 000 '
U
>-
U
M
.
'"
o en
C .:: .... .. ,.
-' I1l
~
>
U
i.
.. :.:
C
Ql
i,:·
.;en .: .... .: Ii.,
C
o
U
I···
.:.
"0
, .:1::
M Ql
M ....
~ ~ I::
::J
" EI1l
CC
::: U
~
c
...
:.::::: . ...
: :: ... :: · f J ' .: .. . -;: i··
::<;>17 :..I:j:":: . : .. .:
V')./ · · ·.·.
. . . . . . ,.
.:r:..... ;; ~
· H" ,··,1·· ..
10 ,I
5 6 7 8 9 I 567891 5 b 1 8 9 I
10 100 1000
Measured consistency K (Pa.sn)
FIGURE 5 Calculated consistency versus measured consistency samples C-massecuite and C-nutsch.
37
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
5 6 7 8 9 I 5 b 1 it 9 I
100 I
,, ,
I
, ,,, ... .. . . I'·
'u. L ., ::': . ..... I. :", /,
~
; _. __. - ...
..
.:
/
7 -
... .. ........
" .' , ..'. ........ ..
, .....
'-r' '
/ / /
/
/
..
:' '"./
1
• ..••, .
68% calculated consistency
I
.. ..
)(
,"
/,;
..
A >/
I
{ ,59
f-
1 X k measured -.y'.
2
between
.... ,...
.
0,63 X k measured
...
.-.-. ... . .... .... .
,
;~ .....: ..;~
..
'. . ~ V ..
.
/
I~V'
.... ...
..
<II .... oO .-.... ,_ ..• " ... ...... : .......
,.,- .... ... ....
.. ....
, -
.. .. ... .. .•..• -t ... --
oO' 'oO
u ..
..,
•••• 1 .. •
.... .." ..
... .~
.. .. r--'
•-.-_ -"-0"
.... .... ... .,. .. ..
oO.
"'f'~:
M .... " .. .. . ..
" ... ..
N
<II'
.... . ..... .••.•.)c
~ 10 I , , ,, .... / /
.>
U
u
•
il
',"." , ...... ... ..
/, / /
M .. ..
':J'" ......... .. / ,,' / ~
.. ::'::' .. -
'
7
Ol-
.....
e c
6
..
..
.. - ... :.::::::.~
/"" ~.,
/.. :
'" <fl
(0 ..
: : :':. : : : r:......... .,-'.
x.: ::'::'
...
.....
y.. .. /
e:. 5
..,:.:. ':, ... : :"'.", .,', ..
>- j /
u
C • ,'/, ""/':
...
... " . /:
..
Ql
., .. , .," : /: ..
CIl X ')
'iii 'j
Iyg:/rl('/
c X. .r: I
·0 ':. .. ~ ..
.... K::: :'.)(
o ::: I .. ....
...
~ "0
7.
...
,:::
i"
oO
'" Ql
'"
~
...
i
a: U
-S x I
;; . (ij ...•..
~ U ~
Q
"5- , ._---- /
~
o - - - - - -- z I
s
/ ~. .:
- ,, :. ,
..
:f: 1
. , B
,.
1 / '/". ~ .... .. .... -c.:':
<:;/1
-:'1 .... 7
------t---~-'///
I?
"
----- ---- .......
i" /
6
..
.':
d/,
.I'" J
,
', .. .... 5
t·
.~ ..'
/ ..
J'X t/J
- - - - - ---iL-'
,
/1 rr
, .. 1
I·
oO
.. ...I
~~t-~
I
2
..
I ..
0,1 , .\ ,• b 7 8 9 1 ~ b 7 8 !:I 1
1
5 b 7 6
L
.
~ 1
I
0,1 10 100
Measured consistency K (Pa.sn)
FIGURE 6 Calculated consistency versus measured consistency samples C-nutsch and C-molasses.
dB
=
=
=
exponent in Equation 7
torque (Nm)
shear stress (Nm 3)
= shear rate (sec -I)
N = rotational speed (rpm) dt
n = flow behaviour index () = angular cyclindrical co-ordinate (rad.)
38
Proceedings of The South African Sugar Technologists' Association - June 1987
39