Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract In the summer of 2008, serious illnesses and deaths of methods is 0.05-100 ppm. The maximum acceptable
babies in China were linked to melamine-tainted powdered concentration in food has been set at 50 ppb by the US FDA. A
infant formula. Melamine contains several metabolites, such as fast and ultrasensitive procedure for screening, detection, and
ammeline, ammelide, and cyanuric acid, and has been used for characterization of melamine and its derivative compounds
the adulteration of foods or milk to increase their apparent needs to be established. Currently, mass- spectrometry
protein content. It is assumed that melamine and its metabolites technologies provide an alternative to derivati- zation for
are absorbed in the gastrointestinal tract, and precipitate in the regulatory analysis of food.
kidney to form crystals. A new tolerable daily intake of 0.2 mg
kg 1 body weight was adapted by the World Health
- Keywords Melamine . Cyanuric acid .
Organization in 2008. This paper reviews the variety of High-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass
analytical methods that have been used for the analysis of spectrometry . Gas chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry
.
melamine in food. The limit of detection of these various Isotope dilution
Springer
2 Y.-C. Tyan et al.
Springer
Melamine contamination 3
N O
,N N„ NN /Nx/N\
H H H H
H -
NN
O NN
N' NX N
i
H H
H
i
O
,N,
i
NN
i
NN NN NN
i
H
N
N
N^,N
Fig. 2 The chemical structure of melamine-cyanuric acid crystal O
bladder and kidney stones, crystalluria, and epithelial dosing because of acute renal failure. The results demonstrate
hyperplasia of urinary bladder [13]. However, no kidney that the combination of melamine and cyanuric acid is
failure or clinical symptoms of kidney failure were observed responsible for acute renal failure in cats [19]. Melamine
in current studies [14-16]. Melamine has been studied for cyanurate compounds crystallize in animal kidneys when
carcinogenicity in mice and rats for each sex by oral animals are dosed with the combination of melamine and
administration. It produced urinary bladder and ureteral cyanuric acid [20].
carcinomas in male rats and urinary bladder hyperplasia in Unlike heavy metals, such as mercury, which accumulate in
male mice. Bladder tumors occurred only in male rats after animal bodies in very low amounts, melamine does not build
prolonged irritation of the epithelium by the bladder stones. up in an animal's body for a significant length of time.
The occurrence of urinary bladder tumors in male rats Information from the US FDA suggests melamine is excreted
correlated strictly with calculus formation and high-dose from an animal within 10-15 days after ingestion. In mammals,
exposure [17]. High and continuous dietary exposure (4,500 the toxicity of melamine alone is low, with a halflife of
ppm or 263 mg kg-1 body weight day-1, 2 years) to melamine in approximately 3-4 h [20]. In addition, the US FDA states that a
controlled studies is associated with an increase in the low level of melamine in food does not pose a health risk to
production of bladder stones and an increased incidence of humans [21].
urinary bladder tumors. The two incidences are closely related
to each other [16].
It has been hypothesized that the formation of melamine Interim safety and risk assessment
cyanurate crystals in the kidney is due to the extremely low
water solubility of this compound (2.2mg L-1) in comparison US food and drug administration
with the parent compounds melamine (3,240 mg L-1) and
cyanuric acid (2,000 mg L-1). It is assumed that melamine and According to a report form the US FDA, dated 25 May 2007,
cyanuric acid are absorbed in the gastrointestinal tract, the base for determining melamine levels was set at 50 ppb.
distributed systemically, and, for reasons that have not yet been The 50-ppb level represents a conservative estimate of the limit
fully determined, precipitated in the kidneys to form of detection (LOD) for the methods employed, a value that will
nephrotoxic melamine cyanurate crystals [18]. Another report ensure the exposure scenarios are conservative. Currently this
also characterized the toxicity potential of melamine, method is designed to only detect melamine in meat; however,
cyanurate, and a combination of melamine and cyanuric acid in it is presumed that other melamine derivatives are present in
cats. The study results showed that no effect on renal functions the tissue. For the purposes of this assessment, the
was observed in cats fed with melamine or cyanuric acid alone. concentration of melamine assumed in the tissue (50 ppb) is
Cats dosed with a combination were euthanized at 48 h after doubled to 100 ppb to account for cyanuric acid, which was not
Springer
4 Y.-C. Tyan et al.
actually measured by the test. Doubling the measurable tissue new number is also lower than the TDI set by the US FDA and
melamine level was based in part on the relative levels of the EFSA for melamine alone.
melamine compounds observed in the contaminated feed and Recently, it was determined that melamine, along with
in part on the identification of the crystals in the kidneys being several analogues, may have been responsible for deaths after
a mixture of melamine and cyanuric acid [14]. In addition, it ingestion of adulterated food. Melamine is associated with
was also indicated that the resulting tolerable daily intake renal toxicity owing to crystal formation and with carcinoge-
(TDI) is 0.63 mg kg-1 body weight day-1. Infants are more nicity secondary to urolithiasis. Urolithiasis is very common
sensitive than adults to exposure; thus, the US FDA has applied when melamine is combined with other analogues such as
an additional tenfold safety factor. This results in a TDI/10 of cyanuric acid [19, 24]. The current safe level, as set by the US
0.063 mg melamine kg-1 body weight day-1. In the report by the FDA, is 50 ppb based on the sensitivity of the analytical test
US FDA, melamine is not approved for direct addition to [14]. The EFSA also indicated that all products from China
human or animal foods and no manufacturer is allowed to containing more than 15% milk as an ingredient, or products
deliberately add it to any food for US consumers. The US FDA where the percentage of milk content cannot be established,
will examine protein- containing products beyond dairy and will be subjected to documentary, identity, and physical
dairy-containing products for contamination with melamine checks, including laboratory analysis, to determine that any
and melamine- related compounds [12]. levels of melamine present in the product do not exceed 2.5
ppm. Those products with more than 2.5 ppm will be destroyed
European food safety authority [25].
*£} Springer
Melamine contamination 5
Table 1 Summary of the detection methods used for melamine and cyanuric acid
The units of the limit of detection (LOD) and the linear range were obtained from the references.
UPLC ultraperformance liquid chromatography, HPLC high-performance liquid chromatography, LC liquid chromatography, ESI electrospray ionization, MS
mass spectrometry, DART direct analysis in real time, DAD diode-array detection, GC gas chromatography, SERS surface- enhanced Raman spectroscopy,
ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, EIA enzyme immunoassay
The most common methods for melamine detection utilized ANP conditions. Detecting the melamine content with the
were by GC-MS or HPLC combined with UV or MS detectors. HILIC mode results in better retention of this polar molecule
The LOD and linear ranges of the calibration than reversed-phase chromatography. Both compounds,
curves of these methods were 0.1-0.01 ppm and 0.015 ppm, melamine and cyanuric acid, were analyzed in one run by
respectively. The US FDA laboratories have used analytical utilizing the chromatographic system, based on a zwitterionic
tools such as GC-MS and LC-MS to identify melamine as a HILIC LC column [35-37]. In its combination with
contaminant in foods [27-33]. electrospray ionization MS/MS, the negative ion (cyanuric
In selected ion monitoring mode, the GC-MS/MS method acid) and positive ion (melamine) modes were detected. The
can obtain a limit of quantification (LOQ) of about 100 igg in methods are described in laboratory information bulletin 4421,
melamine. Using selected reaction monitoring of GC-MS/ MS, “Determination of melamine and cyanuric acid residues in
this method can reach a lower LOQ of 10 ig g-1. The minimum infant formula using LC-MS/MS,” and bulletin 4422, “Interim
reporting level for the GC-MS/MS procedure to screen for the method for determination of melamine and cyanuric acid
presence of melamine and related compounds is defined as 10 residues in foods using LC-MS/MS.” With use of this
ig g-1. The GC-MS/MS procedure has been evaluated with procedure, the amounts of melamine and cyanuric acid
protein materials, pet foods, and animal feeds, and provided determined from sample extracts from fortified infant formula
semiquantitative analysis of all four target compounds in one were from 0.25 to 5 ig g . The LOQ and the limit of
sample preparation [34]. confirmation were 0.25 ig g 1 for both analytes in dry infant
A method for the determination of melamine residue in food formula [38].
was developed using LC-MS/MS. For sample extraction However, these analyses required extensive sample prep-
procedures, a mixed-mode strong cation exchange with solid aration because the foods were complicated matrices composed
phase extraction cartridge was used to clean up sample extracts of many compounds. To enhance the sensitivity and accuracy,
and remove interfering compounds in dirty matrices such as the isotope dilution method was the most advantageous [6, 39].
seafood and meat. Melamine is a polar molecule, which is a New methods for the routine determination of melamine in
good candidate for aqueous normal phase (ANP) LC. In ANP foods have been proposed. Several kinds of isotope-labeled
LC, a polar hydrophilic analyte partitions between a relatively melamine (Fig. 3) are used for isotope dilution: [ 15N6]melamine
polar stationary phase and a relatively nonpolar mobile phase. [6], [13C3]melamine [39], [15N3] melamine [10, 36], [13C3,
ANP LC is commonly referred to as hydrophilic interaction amino-15N3]melamine, and [13C3, 15N3]cyanuric acid [40]. By
chromatography, or HILIC, but the term HILIC implies a utilization of the isotope dilution method, the matrix effect in
mechanism that is one of several that may be operative under different samples could be prevented. The technique of stable
Springer
6 Y.-C. Tyan et al.
isotope dilution LC-MS/ MS used in previous studies
demonstrates the application of
*£} Springer
Melamine contamination 7
Springer
8 Y.-C. Tyan et al.
1. Zhang L, Zhang J, Li ZJ, Cheng JK, Yin PX, Yao YG (2007) 24. Buur JL, Baynes RE, Riviere JE (2008) Regul Toxicol Pharmacol
Inorg Chem 46:5838-5840 51:324-331
2. Bann B, Miller SA (1958) Chem Rev 58:131-172 25. Food Standards Agency (20008) Melamine contamination of milk &
3. Chapman RP, Averell PR, Harris RR (1943) Ind Eng Chem 35:137 - milk products from China
138 26. Muniz-Valencia R, Ceballos-Magana SG, Rosales-Martinez D,
4. Kennaway EL (1921) Biochem J 15:510-512 Gonzalo-Lumbreras R, Santos-Montes A, Cubedo-Fernandez-
5. Abernethy DR, Sheehan C, Griffiths JC, Williams RL (2008) Clin Trapiella A, Izquierdo-Hornillos RC (2008) Anal Bioanal Chem
Pharmacol Ther 85:444-447 392:523-531
6. Dobson RLM, Motlagh S, Quijano M, Cambron RT, Baker TR, Pullen 27. Filigenzi MS, Puschner B, Aston LS, Poppenga RH (2008) J Agric
AM, Regg BT, Bigalow-Kern AS, Vennard T, Fix A, Reimschussel R, Food Chem 56:7593-7599
Overmann G, Shan Y, Daston GP (2008) Toxicol Sci 106:251-262 28. Ehling S, Tefera S, Ho IP (2007) Food Addit Contam 24: 1319-1325
7. IUCLID (2008) IUCLID chemical data sheet: substance ID 10878-1, 29. Cai Q, Ouyang Y, Qian Z, Peng Y (2008) Se Pu 26:339-342
pp 30-98 30. US Food Emergency Response Network (2007) LC/MS/MS screen for
8. OECD (2002) OECD SIDS analysis UNEP publications: melamine the presence of melamine in swine and poultry tissues
9. Hammond BG, Barbee SJ, Inoue T, Ishida N, Levinskas GJ, Stevens 31. Ding T, Xu J, Li J, ShenC, Wu B, Chen H, LiS (2008) Se Pu 26:6 -9
MW, Wheeler AG, Cascieri T (1986) Environ Health Perspect 69:287- 32. Vail TM, Jones PR, Sparkman OD (2007) J Anal Toxicol 3 1 : 304 -3
292 12
10. Puschner B, Poppenga RH, Lowenstine LJ, Filigenzi MS, Pesavento 33. Neal-Kababick J, Goodman W (2007) Screening for melamine
PA (2007) J Vet Diagn Invest 19:616-624 adulteration in protein-based foods by GC/MS. PerkinElmer Appli-
11. Cianciolo RE, Bischoff K, Ebel JG, Van Winkle TJ, Goldstein RE, cation Note, http://las.perkinelmer.com/content/applicationnotes/
Serfilippi LM (2008) J Am Vet Med Assoc 233:729-737 app_melamineadulterationscreeninginfoodsgcms.pdf
12. US Food and Drug Administration (2009) Melamine contamination in 34. US Food and Drug Administration (2008) LIB no. 4423: GC-MS
China screen for the presence of melamine, ammeline, ammelide, and
13. US Food and Drug Administration (2007) FDA warns staff on major cyanuric acid
melamine health risks 35. Heller DN, Nochetto CB (2008) Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom
14. US Food and Drug Administration (2007) Interim melamine and 22:3624-3632
analogues safety/risk assessment 36. Andersen WC, Turnipseed SB, Karbiwnyk CM, Clark SB, Madson
15. Clayton GD, Clayton FE (1982) Patty's industrial hygiene and MR, Gieseker CM, Miller RA, Rummel NG, ReimschuesselR(2008) J
toxicology, 3rd edn. Wiley, New York Agric Food Chem 56:4340-4347
16. US Department of Health and Human Services (1983) NTP technical 37. Karbiwnyk CM, Andersen WC, Turnipseed SB, Storey JM, Madson
report, TR 245 MR, Miller KE, Gieseker CM, Miller RA, Rummel NG,
17. Rice JM, Baan RA, Blettner M, Genevois-Charmeau C, Grosse Y, Reimschuessel R (2009) Anal Chim Acta 637:101 -111
McGregor DB, Partensky C, Wilbourm JD (1999) Toxicol Sci 49:166 - 38. US Food and Drug Administration (2008) LIB no. 4421: determination
171 of melamine and cyanuric acid residues in infant formula using LC-
18. WHO-IARC (1999) Monographs 73:329-338 MS/MS
19. Puschner B, Poppenga RH, Lowenstine LJ, Filigenzi MS, Pesavento 39. Varelis P, Jeskelis R (2008) Food Addit Contam 25:1208-1215
PA (2007) J Vet Diagn Invest 19:616-624 40. US Food and Drug Administration (2008) LIB no. 4422: interim
20. US Food and Drug Administration (2008) Interim safety and risk method for determination of melamine and cyanuric acid residues in
assessment of melamine and its analogues in food for humans foods using LC-MS/MS: version 1.0
21. Alaska Department of Fish and Game (2007) Alaska 's hatcheries and 41. He L, Liu Y, Lin M, Awika J, Ledoux DR, Li H, Mustapha A (2008)
melamine in fish food Sens Instrum Food Qual 2:66-71
22. European Food Safety Authority (2008) EFSA assesses possible risks 42. Garber EA (2008) J Food Prot 71:590-594
related to melamine in composite foods from China 43. Kim B, Perkins LB, Bushway RJ, Nesbit S, Fan T, Sheridan R, Greene
23. New Zealand Food Safety Authority (2008) New Zealand melamine V (2008) J AOAC Int 91:408-413
response update
*£} Springer