You are on page 1of 51

LTE Tool based radio design

LTE Tool Implementation

Hans Jörg Hamers

TSO Access Design

1 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
LTE Tool Implementation

Understand VF-Group approach on


Tool approach -tool strategy
- proposed tools

Get an overview on
ATOLL - LTE implementation in Atoll

ATOLL Understand required settings to


Vendor Adaptation -adapt Atoll to vendor network configuration and implementation

Get an overview on
Capesso
- LTE implementation in CAPESSO

Capesso Understand required settings to


Vendor Adaptation -adapt Capesso to vendor network configuration and implementation

2 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
Planning Tools
LTE Tool based radio design

Planning tools Understand VF-Group approach on

- tool strategy

- proposed tools

3 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
Planning Tools
LTE Tool based radio design
Tool approach

VF-Group strategy: A single tool to be used for each step of the LTE deployment

Proposed Tools:
High level analysis Radio Network Planning
Business case
analysis Detailed
Case a planning
1
DVB-H mode = 4k; GI = 1/8; C/(I+N) = 10dB; RX level = -94dBm
Atoll
Performance requirement fulfilled

0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 5 10 15 20
Implementation plan STEPS

Case B
DVB-H mode = 4k; GI = 1/8; C/(I+N) = 15dB; RX level = -94dBm

1
Performance requirement fulfilled

0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0 5 10 15 20
Implementation plan STEPS

¾ quick evaluation for network concepts and business ¾ Atoll 2.8.x for detailed LTE planning
case analysis ¾ use of GSM/UMTS site data base (Adaptation to 2.8.x)
¾ use of GSM/UMTS site data base possible ¾ support for co-planning of different radio access
¾ high level coexistence analysis between different technologies (GSM/UMTS)
radio access technologies
¾ fast and easy interworking with Atoll (import /export)

4 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll

Atoll Understand

- workflow of an LTE planning

- modelling of the network

- Monte Carlo Simulations

- Neighbour Allocation

- PCI Planning

- RSI Planning

5 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Workflow

Open an existing project or


create a new one

Network Configuration
- add network elements ACP
- change parameters

Basic predictions
(Signal level, Best server)

Automatic or manual Neighbour Allocation

Automatic or manual Frequency Planning

Automatic or manual PCI Planning


Traffic Maps
Monte Carlo User-defined
and / or values
Simulations
Cell Load
Subscriber Lists Conditions

Frequency Plan Signal Quality and Prediction Study


Analysis Throughput Predictions Reports

6 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Frequency Bands

¾ Atoll can model multi-band networks within the same document

¾ TDD (Time Division Duplexing) or FDD (Frequency Division Duplexing)

¾ One frequency band assigned to each cell

7 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

LTE Frame Structure Settings

please see “power boost” (slide )

8 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Transmitter Parameters

MIMO reception and


transmission settings

9 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Cell Parameters
Cell order used for carrier
selection

Physical Cell ID + resulting


PSS/SSS

Power and energy offsets


from computed reference signal

Inter-Cell Interference
Coordination and Fractional
Power Control parameters

Cell capacity gain in case of


MU-MIMO

10 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Power Boost

define offsets to implement


“Power Boost” used by the vendors

11 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Predictions: Available Studies (1)

12 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Prediction: Available Studies (2)

¾ Principles of the studies based on traffic

¾ Study calculated for

• Given load conditions


– UL noise rise
– DL traffic load

• A non-interfering user with


– A service
– A mobility
– A terminal type with a directive antenna (oriented towards the serving cell)

13 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Parameters used (1) – Load Conditions

¾ Load conditions are defined in the cells table

Values taken into consideration in


14 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential
Predictions for each cell
25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Parameters used (2) – Service Properties

¾ Parameters used in predictions


• Highest bearers in UL and DL
• Body loss
• Application throughput parameters

15 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Parameters used (3) – LTE Bearer Properties

¾ Support for Multiple Modulation and Coding Schemes (MCS)

• User-selective modulations (QPSK, 16QAM and 64QAM)


• User-definable coding rates (e.g. ½, 2/3, ¾, etc.)
• User-definable bearer efficiencies (useful bits per resource elements)
– Used for channel throughput evaluation

Important!

Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
implementation!

16 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Fast Link Adaptation: Modelling (1)

¾ Atoll determines on each pixel, the highest bearer that each user can obtain

¾ No soft handover

¾ Connection to the best server in term of signal level (C)

¾ Bearer chosen according to the radio conditions (PDSCH and PUSCH CINR levels)

¾ Process: prediction done via look-up tables

Reference Signal Level


1 evaluation (C) Throughput prediction
4 (Peak RLC, effective RLC and
application throughput)
Service Area determination
(PDSCH and PUSCH CINR
Best Server Area determination
2 (min RSRP)
3 calculation + service settings
limitation to find the highest
bearer)
Quality indicator prediction
4 (BER and BLER)
CINR = SINR

17 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Fast Link Adaptation Modelling (2) – Bearer Selection

¾ When PDSCH and PUSCH CINR are evaluated the bearer is selected according to

¾ The LTE reception equipment defined at reception (cell for UL, terminal for DL)

¾ The CINR threshold to access each bearer

¾ Scheduler parameters of the serving cell

• Bearer selection criterion


• The uplink bandwidth allocation target

¾ The highest possible bearer according to the service settings

Important!

Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
implementation!

18 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Fast Link Adaptation Modelling (3) – Throughput Estimation

¾ When the bearer is selected the channel throughput is calculated according to:

¾ The channel bandwidth

¾ The frame definition considering hard coded parameters and user-defined ones (global
parameters tab or the Transmitter folder properties box)

¾ The cyclic prefix ratio

¾ The bearer efficiency defined in the selected bearer

Important!

Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
implementation!

19 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Examples (1) – General Studies

Number of servers
(based on reference signal power)

Coverage by signal level


(based on reference signal power)

20 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Examples (2) – Dedicated Studies

Coverage by PDSCH CINR


(Directional receiver antenna)

Coverage by PDSCH CINR


(Isotropic receiver antenna)

21 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

MIMO Settings (1) - Transmitters

MIMO reception and


transmission settings

22 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

MIMO Settings (2) - Cells

Reference signal CNR or


CINR used as
-Thresholds to switch from
SU-MIMO to Tx/Rx Diversity
-Minimum required for using
MU-MIMO

Definition of the MIMO


support type

Uplink capacity gain due to


MU-MIMO. The cell capacity
is multiplied by this gain at pixels
where MU-MIMO is used

23 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

MIMO Settings (3) - Terminals

Reception equipment defining


SU-MIMO and diversity gains

Number of Antenna ports


in UL and DL in case
MIMO is supported

24 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

MIMO Settings (4) – Transmit and Receive Diversity Settings


¾ Diversity Gain depending on the MIMO configuration

Important!
¾ Additional Diversity Gain per Clutter Class (DL and UL)
Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
implementation!

¾ Sum of the gains applied on PDSCH/PUSCH CINR


25 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential
25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

MIMO Settings (3) – SU-MIMO Settings


¾ Maximum Possible Gain in Channel Capacity

¾ SU-MIMO Gain Factor per Clutter Class


Important!

Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
implementation!

MIMO Throughput = SISO Throughput (1 + SU-MIMO Gain (max MIMO gain -1))

26 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll
Modelling a network

Example

¾ Coverage Prediction Examples (MIMO system)

Coverage by DL CINR
(MIMO with 2*2 antenna)

Coverage by DL CINR
(without MIMO)

CINR improved for low values


(due to Tx/Rx diversity)

27 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll

Monte Carlo Simulations - no major difference to UMTS regarding

- required input
- workflow

Neighbour Planning - no major difference to UMTS regarding

- required input
- allocation algorithm
- workflow

PCI Planning - major difference from SC-Planning in UMTS

- please see dedicated “PCI planning” slides

RSI Planning - neither nor required in GSM or UMTS


- planning of Root Sequence Index (RSI) of the PRACH
in the Uplink

28 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll Vendor
Adaptation

ATOLL
Understand required settings to
Vendor Adaptation

- adapt Atoll to vendor network configuration and implementation

29 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll Vendor
Atoll Vendor Adaptation Adaptation

Bearers
 Index Name Modulation Channel Coding Rate Bearer Efficiency Bearer Selection
1 QPSK 1 QPSK 0.11 0.23
2 QPSK 2 QPSK 0.15 0.3 Thresholds
3 QPSK 3 QPSK 0.18 0.37
Best Bearer SINR
4 QPSK 4 QPSK 0.24 0.49
1 ‐8
5 QPSK 5 QPSK 0.3 0.59
2 ‐7
Global Parameters 6
7
QPSK 6
QPSK 7
QPSK
QPSK
0.36
0.44
0.73
0.88 3 ‐6
8 QPSK 8 QPSK 0.51 1.01 4 ‐4.82
Cyclic Prefix [us] 4.69
9 QPSK 9 QPSK 0.6 1.19 5 ‐3.64
Overhead PDCCH [Syms] 3 10 16QAM 1 16QAM 0.34 1.34 6 ‐2.62
11 16QAM 2 16QAM 0.37 1.49
Overhead PUCCH [RB] 2 7 ‐1.48
12 16QAM 3 16QAM 0.42 1.68
Uplink power control margin [dB] 1 8 ‐0.45
13 16QAM 4 16QAM 0.47 1.88
14 16QAM 5 16QAM 0.54 2.15 9 0.63
15 16QAM 6 16QAM 0.6 2.38 10 1.82
11 2.72
Transmitter 16
17
64QAM 1
64QAM 2
64QAM
64QAM
0.43
0.45
2.58
2.68 12 3.94
18 64QAM 3 64QAM 0.5 2.98 13 4.92
Noise Figure (dB) 2.3 19 64QAM 4 64QAM 0.55 3.28
14 5.61
20 64QAM 5 64QAM 0.59 3.53
21 64QAM 6 64QAM 0.64 3.83
15 6.48
22 64QAM 7 64QAM 0.69 4.13 16 7.41
23 64QAM 8 64QAM 0.74 4.43 17 8.5
Cell 24 64QAM 9 64QAM 0.8 4.78 18 9.43
25 64QAM 10 64QAM 0.86 5.17 19 10.23
Max UL Noise Rise (dB) 3 26 64QAM 11 64QAM 0.89 5.37 20 11.2
27 64QAM 12 64QAM 0.93 5.57
Traffic Load (DL) (%) 40 21 12.16
Traffic Load (UL) (%) 40 22 13.1
23 13.94
24 14.97
25 15.96
26 16.94
27 18.21

30 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design Atoll Vendor
Atoll: Relation RS-SINR to PDSCH-SINR Adaptation

PDSCH - SINR

RS - SINR

RSoff

RSoff - TxDiv

TxDiv AMS MIMO Important!


threshold
Table needs to be adapted:
- to vendor implementation
- in case AMS threshold or RSoff change

31 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Capesso

Capesso Understand

- workflow of an Capesso planning

- data exchange to Atoll

- required network settings

- required optimisation settings targets

- results

32 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Workflow
Capesso

Open an existing project or


create a new one

Initial Studies

UMTS Network Configuration LTE Network Configuration


- add network elements - add network elements
- change parameters - change parameters

Conversion into LTE project

Define Define
Optimisation settings and targets Optimisation settings and targets

Run
Predictions / Optimisation

Analyse results

33 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Atoll export to Capesso
Capesso

start Capesso

Define:
- Frequency Band
- Carrier

34 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Define network settings Capesso

UMTS project LTE project

convert into LTE adapt Capesso to Vendor implementation


+
adapt Capesso to Vendor implementation

35 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Define optimisation settings / targets Capesso

Optimisation ranges (1)

Transmitter selection

allow “Site activation”


- y/n
- consider site specific dates

define
-parameters to be optimised
-optimisation ranges

define “Antenna grouping


(antenna families)

36 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Define optimisation settings / targets Capesso

Optimisation targets (1) RSRP

RSRP target:
Rx Pilot >= -120 dBm

Vodafone: -114 dBm


optimisation weight: 1

37 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Define optimisation settings / targets Capesso

Optimisation targets (2) SINR

optimise SINR

Vodafone -3dB
(Cell edge)

optimisation weight: 2

select:
- Terminal
- Mobility
-Service
(as defined in Atoll)

optimise SINR only in areas with


fulfilled coverage target
(do not extend footprint)

38 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Define optimisation settings / targets Capesso

Optimisation targets (3) Throughput

define / load modulation thresholds

Important!

Table needs to
be adapted
to vendor
optimise throughput optimisation weight: 0 select: implementation!
Vodafone -3dB (SINR) (only calculate - Terminal
(Cell edge) coverage) - Mobility
39 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential -Service
25 August 2014 (as defined in Atoll)
LTE Tool based radio design
Results Capesso

Result Analysis (1) - RSRP

final

final difference

40 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Results Capesso

Result Analysis (2) – C/(I+N)

final

final difference

41 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Results Capesso

Result Analysis (3) – Throughput

final

final difference

42 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Alternative Optimisation Approach Capesso

Optimisation targets (1) RSRP

RSRP target:
Rx Pilot >= -108 dBm

optimisation weight: 1

43 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
Customer Experience

LTE Tool based radio design


Design Target

Peak PDSCH throughput by number of measured neighbours (10dB window)

Optimise overlapping within network with target:  1st to 4th server outside 10dB 


window 
44 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential
25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Alternative Optimisation Approach Capesso

Optimisation targets (1) Overlapping

Overlapping target:
1st to 4th Server
>= 10dB

optimisation weight: 5

apply traffic weighting

45 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Capesso
Result Analysis (1) - RSRP

stable coverage

46 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Result Analysis (1) - RSRP

Overlapping Area - Initial


30

25 INI

50%
20

16%
Area [%]

15

34%
10

5 Overlapping Area - Optimised


35

0
>= 6 5 4 3 2 30 1
INI
E
>
EM
EMA
25

20 >
Area [%] 15 <
10

0
>= 6 5 4 3 2 1

47 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Results Capesso

Atoll Update

48 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Capesso Vendor
Adaptation

Capesso Understand required settings to


Vendor Adaptation
-adapt Capesso to vendor network configuration and implementation

49 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
LTE Tool based radio design
Capesso Vendor Adaptation
Capesso Vendor
C/(C+N) Threshold Bits per Symbol Code Rate MIMO factor Error Rate Adaptation
‐8 2 0.11 1 0.01
‐7 2 0.15 1 0.01
‐6 2 0.18 1 0.01
‐4.82 2 0.24 1 0.01
‐3.64 2 0.3 1 0.01
‐2.62 2 0.36 1 0.01
‐1.48 2 0.44 1 0.01
‐0.45 2 0.51 1 0.01
0.63 2 0.6 1 0.01
1.82 4 0.34 1 0.01
2.72 4 0.37 1 0.01
3.94 4 0.42 1 0.01
4.92 4 0.47 1 0.01
5.61 4 0.54 1 0.01
Modulation Thresholds 6.48 4 0.6 1 0.01
7.41 6 0.43 1 0.01
8.5 6 0.45 1 0.01
9.43 6 0.5 1 0.01
10.23 6 0.55 1.15 0.01
11.2 6 0.59 1.15 0.01
12.16 6 0.64 1.18 0.01
13.1 6 0.69 1.18 0.01
13.94 6 0.74 1.18 0.01
14.97 6 0.8 1.23 0.01
15.96 6 0.86 1.23 0.01
16.94 6 0.89 1.25 0.01
18.21 6 0.93 1.25 0.01
19 6 0.93 1.6 0.01
20 6 0.93 1.72 0.01
21 6 0.93 1.8 0.01
22 6 0.93 1.84 0.01
23 6 0.93 1.85 0.01

50 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014
Chhhrrrrr….
I need a schhhhzz
coffee!!
Questions?

51 LTE tool based radio design (Atoll) Vodafone confidential


25 August 2014

You might also like