You are on page 1of 3

inside

March 21, 2018 | $1.50


TIBURON • BELVEDERE • STRAWBERRY
County backs list of Farmers market to
Named among the nation’s
bike-walk projects return for third year
Six projects in Strawberry and along Tiburon The market earned a tentative $20,000
best small weekly newspapers Boulevard are in the update to Marin’s master funding commitment from Tiburon, but with a
2014-2018 General Excellence finalists, National Newspaper Association
2018 Best Local News Coverage, National Newspaper Association plan — but none have funding so far. shorter season and booth realignment.
Volume 46, Issue 12 | thearknewspaper.com Page 5 Page 5

national school walkout

Del Mar and Redwood kids In major shift,


stand against gun violence library to seek
But Del Mar students say administrators co-opted event, cut it short
taxpayer money
for expansion
Officials claim there was Belvedere City Council March 12,
even though there was no discussion
no promise financing item on the council’s agenda and the
would be entirely private Library Agency board had not yet
deliberated on it at a meeting of its
By MATTHEW HOSE own.
mhose@thearknewspaper.com “We want to see everybody in the
——— community put some skin in the
Proponents of the Belvedere-Ti- game,” Jeff Foran, the chair of the
buron Library expansion are plan- Library Agency board of trustees,
ning to ask Tiburon and Belvedere said in an interview.
to give taxpayer dollars to acceler- Foran did not present any specific
ate construction — a major policy numbers on the amount the agency
shift after library officials made re- would request, saying officials want-
peated assurances before and since ed to wait until the agency’s March
the plans were approved in 2012 that 19 meeting — after The Ark’s press
MATTHEW HOSE / THE ARK the expansion would be privately deadline — to discuss a figure.
Hundreds of Redwood High School students raise their hands when asked by a student speaker whether the school funded. But in several letters to the Bel-
needs more transparency in its safety procedures. The high-schoolers braved the rain at 10 a.m. March 14 as part Representatives from the Belve- vedere council ahead of its meet-
of the National School Walkout to demand action on gun violence, spurred by the slaying of 17 students at Marjory dere-Tiburon Library Agency un- ing, community members accused
Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., on Valentine’s Day. The nationwide walkouts were scheduled to last veiled their plans for a new financial the Library Agency of betraying its
17 minutes, one minute to honor each of the victims. structure to fund the 15,725-foot ———
expansion at a presentation to the See Library, page 23
By JEFF DEMPSEY
jdempsey@thearknewspaper.com
———
Hundreds of Tiburon Peninsula
Nonprofit launches to fundraise for
students left class at 10 a.m. March
14 as part of the National School
new Strawberry community center
Walkout, joining tens of thousands By EMILY LAVIN its immediate goal is to help raise
around the U.S. in demanding action elavin@thearknewspaper.com money for a new facility to replace
ELLIOT KARLAN / FOR THE ARK

on gun violence after the Valentine’s ——— the now-demolished pool house on its
Day slaying of 17 students at Mar- After two failed ballot measures property at 118 E. Strawberry Drive.
jory Stoneman Douglas High School to publicly finance the Strawberry The district knocked down the
in Parkland, Fla. Recreation District’s planned com- 1,100-square-foot 1960s-era pool
But at Del Mar Middle School, munity center, a nonprofit created to house in November. It wants to re-
some students were upset with the help find private donors has kicked place it with a 4,700-square-foot,
administration’s changes to the stu- off its fundraising efforts. two-story facility that would include
dent-organized event, accusing offi- ible show of unity — including at Summer Sun (front) and her The Strawberry Recreation and a 1,500-square-foot sun deck, out-
cials of co-opting and softening the Redwood High School in Larkspur Del Mar Middle School class- Parks Foundation launched its web- door showers, locker rooms, a family
protest as they moved it indoors and — while students across the East mates gathered in the gym site the weekend of March 10 and is changing area and a courtyard, as
cut it short. Coast including Vermont and Maine March 14 in a demonstration now soliciting donations from the well as meeting rooms and a kitchen
against gun violence and to
Despite the rain, thousands of braved freezing temperatures and honor the 17 students killed public. and snack bar.
students across the Bay Area par- ——— Feb. 14 in Florida. Established to help the district fi- ———
ticipated outdoors in a public, vis- See Walkout, page 20 nance capital-improvement projects, See Nonprofit, page 31

Belvedere 5 | Environment 14 | Strawberry 15 | Police Logs 17 | ArkBeat 25 | Classifieds 27 Weekend Weather | H Friday 57° 45° | H Saturday 57° 45° | H Sunday 59° 47°
f23
a c e b o o k NEWS |
. c o m / t h e a r k nT eH wE s Ap Ra pK e r • M ar c h 2 1 , 2 0 1 8 March 21, 2018 • | r k n e w s p a p e r . c23
T he A R K t h e aNEWS om

Library, continued from page 1 further comment.


Belvedere resident Bill Rothman, speaking at the council
———
meeting, also pointed to a July 2012 publication of the li-
promise to rely only on private donations raised by the Bel- brary’s newsletter, “In the Stacks,” which states: “All costs
vedere-Tiburon Library Foundation and not on public funds. are expected to be paid by the Library Foundation from pri-
Significant community discussion leading up to and after vate donations, with no cost to taxpayers.”
the expansion’s approval — including dozens of letters to Rothman said the willingness of residents to allow for the
The Ark — revolved around the funding source, fear of bal- expansion was prefaced on the assumption there would be
looning future costs and concern taxpayers would be forced no tax money used at all, including the money in the city’s
to foot a portion of the bill, on top of concerns about the size coffers.
of the expansion itself. “The money that Belvedere has … doesn’t come out of the
“Now … it appears that this is a promise that is proposed sky,” he said. “It comes from taxes.”
to be broken,” wrote San Rafael Avenue resident Nate Lane.
Those letters came in response to Library Director Debo- Sunshine law issues with
rah Mazzolini’s March 6 email blast, circulated within the ‘informal conversations’
community — and to Library Agency board members — Several people also wrote letters to the council in sup-
that indicated the agency would seek $500,000 from Belve- port of the expansion; however, a vast majority of those
dere and asked residents to turn out at the council meeting were members of the Library Agency board, the foundation
and write letters in support, as well as to forward the email board or their spouses, or they were residents of Tiburon.
to other residents and groups to encourage the same. Like the letters opposing the proposal, those in favor also
In an interview after the meeting, Mazzolini disavowed started trickling in shortly after Mazzolini sent her email
the figure to be requested, saying she didn’t know where it blast.
came from. That email and the Library Agency presentation raised
However, Belvedere Mayor Marty Winter said in an inter- a number of potential issues with the Ralph M. Brown Act,
view that it was his idea to have the city kick in that amount California’s open-meetings laws.
for the project, spread over a period of five years. First, the Belvedere council was only scheduled to hear
“We’re asking the public wherever they are to join us in a presentation from the Library Foundation about expan-
getting this library built, and we’re very excited about it, and sion efforts, with no item on the agenda about the Library
it’s going to happen one way or another,” Winter said. Agency, a separate entity, discussing its financial struc-
It remained unclear at press time how Mazzolini learned
ture or requesting funding. After Foran spoke on behalf
of Winter’s proposed figure and who directed her to send the
of the agency and sought direction from the council, The
email to the board and to community members.
Ark was forced to call a point of order and warn the coun-
The controversial expansion of the existing 10,500-square-
cil it could not proceed with discussion without potentially
foot library to a total of 26,225 square feet calls for a two-
violating state law, a position shared at the meeting by
story attached addition to be built in what is now the library
Belvedere’s deputy city attorney. The council held no fur-
and Tiburon Town Hall parking lot. The Library Agency,
ther discussion and took no action based on the Library
a public government entity, oversees day-to-day operations
Agency’s presentation.
and is separate from the Library Foundation, the private
Additionally, Mazzolini’s email indicated the Library
nonprofit that acts as the main fundraising arm of the li-
Agency as a whole had taken a major policy position and
brary.
would be asking for money from the cities — despite the
The proposal to ask for public funding comes on the heels
fact the agency board had yet to hold a public meeting to
of the Library Agency obtaining a $4 million loan to make
deliberate on that matter.
up the difference between the nearly $14 million they’ve
Foran told councilmembers the idea had mostly been dis-
raised in private donations and the estimated $18 million
cussed within a small working group of the board — but in
cost of the project.
That figure ballooned due to rising construction costs an interview, he said members of the larger agency board
from an estimated $12 million to $15 million when the ex- also had “informal conversations” that asking for money
pansion was approved six years ago. from the cities “looks like a good idea to us,” but he dis-
Foran said in an interview that library officials were try- missed those talks as “chitter-chatter.”
ing to expedite the process so they can break ground as It was unclear how many on the seven-member board took
soon as possible, as costs are expected to continue to rise if part in those discussions outside the three-member subcom-
the project continues to be delayed. mittee.
“We’re just getting worried that construction prices could Board member Bill Smith of Belvedere — one of three for-
cause us some real challenges to get enough money to build mer mayors on the board, including subcommittee members
(the) building,” Foran said. Tom Gram of Tiburon and Tom Cromwell of Belvedere —
declined to speak on the record about such discussions.
‘There are no plans to use public funds’ Postle said he wasn’t part of any discussions outside of
Several who attended the Belvedere council meeting and board meetings.
wrote letters balked at the idea of the city giving money to Several other members did not respond to requests seek-
the project. ing comment.
“If the library expansion will include city money, there Under state law, boards like the Library Agency’s must
should be a re-evaluation of the scale of the project, includ- hold properly noticed public meetings to “hear, discuss,
ing input from Belvedere residents,” wrote Cove Road resi- deliberate or take action” on any item within their subject-
dents John and Juli Tantum in a letter. matter jurisdiction, with a majority of them together at the
Foran disputed any promise was broken, saying the origi- same time and place. The public has the right to attend these
nal promise was that the library wouldn’t put a new tax base meetings and to add to the discussion via public comments
on the cities, not that it wouldn’t try to get some “existing and letters.
revenue flows” within the city governments’ budgets for the The Ark has submitted a California Public Records Act
project. request to the Library Agency board asking for all commu-
“(It) was said then, I say it again today: No new taxes, no nications about the expansion and its funding since fall 2017;
levies, no special appropriations,” Foran said at the meeting. the agency was still within its 10-day window to respond to
However, that statement does not mesh with what the that request by The Ark’s press deadline.
seven then-members of the Library Agency wrote to the Foran separately said giving the presentation was per-
community in a letter to The Ark published in October 2011, haps premature for what the agency wanted to do, because
just before a major Town Council hearing on the expansion the full board hadn’t yet deliberated on the idea of asking
project. Tiburon and Belvedere for money for the project.
“The nonprofit Belvedere-Tiburon Library Foundation in- But he said Winter, the Belvedere mayor, had asked them
tends to fund this entirely through private donations,” they to come give a presentation on the status of the expansion
wrote. “There are no plans to use public funds.” project, which is why they gave the presentation at the time
Ric Postle of Tiburon is the only 2011 member who still they did — despite the item not being on the Belvedere coun-
sits on the agency board. In an interview, he said he couldn’t cil agenda.
remember what the library promised regarding financing ———
before the project was approved; when pressed, he declined See Library, page 24
24 NEWS | THE ARK • M ar c h 2 1 , 2 0 1 8 thearknewspaper.com

Market, continued from page 5 publicizing where to park.”


For instance, she said, parking at the Main Street Parking
Judith Ets-Hokin, the retired founder of a cooking school
and 10 stores she sold to Viking, also thinks the market
———
Lot is free for up to 20 minutes and just $2 for 20-40 minutes, should be moved to a weekend day. She said the market
will create a more sustainable flow of customers.” enough time to shop for produce and leave. should have more organic produce and it was awkwardly
Chanis and Smith are members of the informal committee “People spend more than twice that for a latte,” she said. laid out. She said she went once or twice and stopped going.
that meets frequently to assess the operation and develop Mark Carlson, the manager at the Pedego electric-bikes “It gave me a sad feeling,” she said.
suggestions for improvements. They came to the consensus store at Main Street and Tiburon Boulevard, said he was In Futch’s poll, at least half a dozen residents said they
that the market should continue about two weeks ago. worried about the farmers market because it doesn’t get
would like the market to move to Blackie’s Pasture, which
The group also includes Mayor Jim Fraser; town adminis- many shoppers.
they said is more central and where parking is more plenti-
tration assistant Patti Pickett; Tiburon Peninsula Chamber “I didn’t know how they make a profit,” he said.
of Commerce board President Steve Sears, the former owner ful.
of Sam’s Anchor Cafe; and Melanie Haddad, the chamber’s Residents offer their own feedback But moving the market would defeat the purpose of put-
executive director. The Ark also contacted residents who commented on ting it downtown in the first place, Chanis said.
In a survey of merchants conducted last fall after the final Futch’s Nextdoor.com post. “The overall goal is to get people to realize there is a
market of the season, the chamber found that most down- “The Tiburon farmers market is a fabulous family, health- downtown Tiburon.”
town Tiburon business owners don’t think the market is oriented addition to our community,” Juliette Decker Roden- “We’re creating new habits,” said Smith, the operator. “We
helping to drive customers to their doors. beck said in an interview. She wants it to stay on Main Street. want to get people in the habit of coming downtown.”
“Most did not feel it benefited their businesses directly, Toby Marion said he and his wife, Eileen, try to go the Chanis didn’t rule out Blackie’s Pasture completely.
while others didn’t like having the market there,” Haddad market every week for produce and for great bread. “I think there would be some potential positives, but (we)
said, adding that about half of businesses felt the market “The only thing I’d like to see that I don’t see now is sea- would also have to consider whether it’s appropriate and
should continue anyway because they feel it’s good for the food, but I’m not sure that seafood is a good thing to buy in whether there is enough parking,” he said.
community. a farmers market unless there’s a big turnover.” John Corcoran, a local lawyer who serves on the Tiburon
Optician Karen Glader at Enlightened Optometry at 46 Marion doesn’t find parking a problem because he either Planning Commission, was among those who responded to
Main St., said she and optometrist-owner Celia Futch want parks at the Corinthian Yacht Club, where he is a member, or Futch’s poll. He said he thinks the market eventually will
to see the market continue but that they had some serious he and his wife walk down from their home in Old Tiburon.
increase foot traffic for the local businesses and boost their
issues with the current operation. Complaints included the “We like to walk around and see what’s going on and eat
revenue, even if it does create competition.
layout of the vendors’ booths and the decibel level of the gen- at the local restaurants,” he said. “We’ve been a little worried
The town’s $20,000 subsidy pays for help with setup and
erator that powered the inflatable bounce house, which sat that it hasn’t been as busy as it could be, but I think it’s a
outside their front door for two hours every Thursday. great thing and I hope it continues. It encourages us to eat cleanup. Because the town’s fiscal year begins July 1, half of
Futch’s concerns prompted her to take an informal survey a lot of fruit.” this year’s funding of the market actually was approved by
of residents on the Nextdoor.com neighborhood website ear- “I think it needs to be on a weekend,” Todd Jackson of Bel- the Town Council last June. The other half will be approved
lier this year, which prompted nearly three dozen comments. vedere said. “I commute into San Francisco, and by the time this coming June.
Glader said she hears complaints from people that it’s I get off the ferry, they’re winding up and folding their tents.
hard to park, but she thinks that’s a misperception. What they should do is pull it off Main Street and move it Deirdre McCrohan has reported on Tiburon local govern-
“There is lots of parking,” she said. “People might have to around the corner onto Fountain Plaza and Tiburon Boule- ment and community issues for more than 30 years. Reach
pay for it, but it’s not that expensive. The town could help by vard.” her at 415-944-4634.s

Library, continued from page 23 million line of credit and thus incurring fees.
Lane, the San Rafael Avenue resident whose letter object-
said. “We’ve largely as a community already got this done.”
As to whether those contributions should be a community-
———
ed to public financing, said the request for money from the led effort, as Lane suggested, rather than a top-down approach
Fundraising, a loan and the public sector towns was particularly inappropriate given the library has with an allocation from the council, Winter said: “You’re wel-
At the council presentation, Foran — the third member of the been doing a “private and some might say even secret” fun- come to do it, go for it, but this is what we’re doing.”
Library Agency executive committee with Gram and Crom- draising campaign for the past several years — known as a But Justin Faggioli, a member of the city’s finance com-
well — unveiled a financial structure he referred to as three “quiet phase” of fundraising — with no open, public attempt mittee, former mayor and former member of the Library
tranches of potential funding sources for the library expansion. at raising additional money. Agency board of trustees, said the city needs to look at the
“If those who favor the expansion in its present form be- request in the big picture of its finances. He said the city
Those included the fundraising by the Library Founda-
lieve that there’s this strong support from the community needs to factor in a potential multimillion-dollar project to
tion, the $4 million bridge loan the library took out earlier
for the library, then the community will fund it, and there’s raise the flood protections in the city, an attempt to further
this year and, now, the “public sector,” to include the poten-
no need whatsoever to come to the city or even to the town fund the city’s pension liabilities and a way to deal with the
tial contributions from the city and the town along with a
of Tiburon for further support,” he said at the presentation. anchor-outs on Richardson Bay.
contribution from the Library Agency itself.
Moss, the Library Foundation treasurer, said the founda- “It’s just really trying to put this request within the con-
Foran said the Library Agency in October set aside $1 tion would likely be entering into the public phase of fund- text of the city’s financial capabilities,” he said.
million in agency reserves for the expansion. raising soon, but he said it made sense to ask for the city and In an interview, City Councilmember Bob McCaskill said
In previous interviews, Foran said a big reason why the li- town to give a “responsible” amount as well. he felt Faggioli made a “very valid point” about the city’s
brary took out the $4 million loan is because it needs to demon- finances.
strate to Tiburon 100 percent of the library-expansion financing Can Belvedere afford it? “We’ve got huge, huge costs coming up with respect to
is in place before the town will deed over the town-owned land Winter, the Belvedere mayor, said in an interview the li- flood protection,” McCaskill said.
behind the existing library building at 1501 Tiburon Blvd. brary was an integral part of both cities, and he wanted to
Barry Moss, the treasurer for the Library Foundation, said see greater community involvement in the project. Reporter Matthew Hose covers the city of Belvedere, as well
the foundation felt it was important to talk with Tiburon and “I think that ultimately we, as a library community, are as crime, courts and public safety issues on the Tiburon
Belvedere to see if they could give toward the project so the asking Belvedere, the greater community, to participate in Peninsula. Reach him at 415-944-4627 and on Twitter at
library could avoid as much as possible dipping into the $4 some small way in the undertaking of the expansion,” he @matt_hose.

Legal Notices
LEGAL NOTICE Advertising Rates
Fictitious business name statements are $65 for one business and one registrant, $5 each additional name, for four weeks;
name changes are $120. Trustee sales start at $170. The deadline for the next issue is 10 a.m. Thursday.
Call 415-435-2652 or email legals@thearknewspaper.com for additional pricing and to place your notice today!

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS FILED: February 5, 2018 8 STETSON AVE. #1 The regularly scheduled Meeting of 41 MAIN ST No. CIV1704556
Name Statement Richard N. Benson KENTFIELD, CA 94904 the Board of Directors of the Tiburon TIBURON, CA 94920 ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE FOR
No. 2018143893 Marin County Clerk This business is conducted by an Fire Protection District scheduled TANOSHI SUSHI CHANGE OF NAME
Notice: This statement expires on By:L. Vawter, Deputy individual for Wednesday, April 11, 2018 has 41 MAIN ST petition of LACEY ROSE
2/5/2023. A new FBN statement Ark Legal 2972 February 28, /s/ Andya Reuterdahl been changed to April 4, 2018, at TIBURON, CA 94920 SLATTERY
must be filed no more than 40 days March 7, 14, 21, 2018 P.O. Box 804 6:30 p.m. at the District headquar- This business is conducted by a TO ALL INTERESTED PERSONS:
from expiration. Mill Valley, CA 94942 ters station located at 1679 Tiburon corporation 1. Petitioner LACEY ROSE SLATTERY
The following person is doing busi- FILED: February 1, 2018 Boulevard, Tiburon, California. /s/ Mei Hua Chen filed a petition with this court for
FICTITIOUS BUSINESS Ark Legal 2976 March 7, 21, 2018
ness as: Name Statement Richard N. Benson 41 Main St. a decree changing names as fol-
CULTURE FOR CARE No. 2018143881 Marin County Clerk Tiburon, CA 94920 lows: Present name LACEY ROSE
550 NICASIO VALLEY ROAD Notice: This statement expires on By:J. Mannion, Deputy FICTITIOUS BUSINESS FILED: March 2, 2018 SLATTERY to LACEY ROSE LONGO.
NICASIO, CA 94946 2/1/2023. A new FBN statement Ark Legal 2975 March 7, 14, 21, Name Statement Richard N. Benson THE COURT ORDERS that all per-
SURYA KRAMER must be filed no more than 40 days 28, 2018 No. 2018144102 Marin County Clerk sons interested in this matter appear
550 NICASIO VALLEY ROAD from expiration. Notice: This statement expires on By:C. Sanchez, Deputy before this court at the hearing indi-
NICASIO, CA 94946 The following person is doing busi- 3/2/2023. A new FBN statement Ark Legal 2977 March 14, 21, 28, cated below to show cause, if any,
This business is conducted by an ness as: PUBLIC NOTICE must be filed no more than 40 days why the petition for change of name
CHANGE OF DATE OF REGULAR April 4, 2018
individual BEANCOUNTESS from expiration. should not be granted. Any per-
/s/ Surya Kramer 8 STETSON AVE. #1 MEETING OF THE BOARD OF THE The following person is doing busi-
P.O. Box 98 KENTFIELD, CA 94904 TIBURON FIRE PROTECTION DIS- ness as: SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA ———
Fairfax, CA 94978 ANDYA REUTERDAHL TRICT WATARU SUSHI COUNTY OF MARIN See Legals, page 28

You might also like