Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter4 PDF
Chapter4 PDF
CHAPTER 4
1
SEQUENCE NETWORKS AND
UNSYMMETRICAL FAULTS ANALYSIS
NETWORK
2
1 SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS AND SEQUENCE NETWORKS
When a symmetrical three phase fault occurs in a three phase system, the
power system remains in the balanced condition. Hence single phase
representation can be used to solve symmetrical three phase fault analysis.
But various types of unsymmetrical faults can occur on power systems. In
such cases, unbalanced currents flow in the system and this in turn makes
the bus voltages unbalanced. Now the power system is in unbalanced
condition and single phase representation can not be used.
3
Sequence voltages and currents
According to symmetrical components method, a three phase unbalanced
system of voltages or currents may be represented by three separate system
of balanced voltages or currents known as zero sequence, positive sequence
and negative sequence as shown in Fig. 1
Ia
(0) I (1) I (1)
a
I (2)
a
I a
c
I (0)
=
b
+ + I (2)
b
Ic I (0)
c
Ib (1) I (2)
c
I b
Fig. 1
4
Defining operator ‘ a ‘ as
a = 1 120 0 (1)
it is to be noted that
Hence 1 a a 2 0 (4)
5
Ia
I (1) I (1) I (2)
a
I (0)
a
c
a
I (0)
=
b
+ + I (2)
b
Ic I (0)
c
Ib (1) I (2)
c
I b
b a Ia
I (1) 2 (1)
c a Ia
I (1) (1)
(5)
b a Ia
I (2) (2)
c a Ia
I (2) 2 (2)
Therefore
I a I (0)
a Ia Ia
(1) (2)
I b I (0)
b Ib
(1)
I (2)
b Ia a Ia a Ia
(0) 2 (1) (2)
I c I (0)
c Ic
(1)
I (2)
c Ia a Ia a Ia
(0) (1) 2 (2)
Thus
I a I (0)
a a
I (1) I (2)
a
I b I (0)
a a Ia a Ia
2 (1) (2)
(6)
I c I (0)
a a Ia a Ia
(1) 2 (2) 6
I a 1 1 1 I (0)
a
(1)
i.e. I b = 1 a 2 a I a i.e. I a , b , c A I 0 , 1 , 2 (7)
I c 1 a a 2 I (2)
a
I (0)
a
1 1 1 I a
(1) 1 a a 2 I
1
I
a = b i.e. I 0 , 1 , 2 A 1 I a , b , c (8)
3
I (2) 1 a 2 a I c
a
Va , b , c A V0 , 1 , 2 (9)
and V0 , 1 , 2 A 1 Va , b , c (10)
z aa z ab z ac
z a,b,c = z ba z bb z bc (11)
z ca z cb z cc
Then v a,b,c z a,b,c i a,b,c
i.e. A v 0,1,2 z a,b,c A i 0,1,2
v 0,1,2 A 1 z a,b,c A i 0,1,2
v 0.1,2 z 0,1,2 i 0,1,2
where z 0,1,2 A 1 z a,b,c A
Thus for any three phase element having the impedance z a,b,c the corresponding
sequence impedance z 0,1,2 can be obtained from
z (0) 0 0
z 0,1,2 = 0 z (1) 0 (13)
0 0 z (2)
Zn +
Ea n
In Ec n
+
+ Eb n Ib
c
b
Ic
Fig. 2
Ec
Let E an be its generated voltage in phase a . Then
Ea
E a 1
E = a 2 E This gives Eb
b an
E c a
10
E (0)
a
1 1 1 1 0
(1) 1
E
a = 1 a a 2 a 2 E = E
an an (14)
3
E (2)
1 a 2
a a 0
a
This shows that there is no zero sequence and negative sequence generated voltages.
b
Reference bus ( Neutral )
c I (c1 )
Positive sequence network
Note that In = 0
11
a
I a( 2 ) I a( 2 )
Zn Z2
Z2 Va( 2 )
In 0
Z2
Z2 I b( 2 )
c
b
Reference bus ( Neutral )
I c( 2 )
Negative sequence network
Note that In = 0
a I a( 0 ) I a( 0 )
Zn Zg0
Zg0
n Va( 0 )
In 3I (0)
a
Z0
Zg0
3 Zn
I b( 0 )
c Zg0
b
Reference bus ( Ground )
I c( 0 )
Note that In = 3 Ia(0) Zero sequence network
Fig. 3 12
Z 1 and Z 2 are the positive sequence and negative sequence impedance of the
generator. Z g 0 is the zero sequence impedance of the generator. Total zero sequence
impedance Z 0 = Z g 0 + 3 Z n .
Va( 0 ) Z 0 I (a0 )
Va( 1 ) E a n Z 1 I (a1 ) (15)
Va( 2 ) Z 2 I (a2 )
As far as zero sequence currents are concerned, the three phase system behaves as
a single phase system. This is because of the fact that at any point the zero
sequence currents are same in magnitude and phase. Therefore, zero sequence
currents will flow only if a return path exists.
13
The connection diagram and the zero sequence equivalent circuit for star
connected load is shown in Fig. 4.
Z
Z Z
3 Zn
Z Zn
Reference
Fig. 4
The connection diagram and the zero sequence circuit for delta connected
load is shown in Fig. 5.
Z Z
Z
Reference 14
Fig. 5
Special attention is required while obtaining the zero sequence
network of three phase transformers. The zero sequence network
will be different for various combination of connecting the
windings and also by the manner in which the neutral is
connected.
15
Connection diagrams Zero sequence equivalent circuit
P Q
Z0
P Q
ZN Zn
Reference
P Q
Z0
P Q
ZN
Reference
16
P Q
Z0
P Q
Reference
P Q
Z0
P Q
ZN
Reference
17
P Q
Z0
P Q
Reference
Fig. 6
Example 1
For the power system shown in Fig. 7, with the data given, draw the zero
sequence, positive sequence and negative sequence networks.
T1 T2 M1
M2
Fig. 7
18
Per unit reactances are:
Transformer T1 X 0 X1 X 2 0.08
Transformer T2 X 0 X1 X 2 0.09
19
T1 T2 M1
M2
j0.2
j0.27 j0.55
+ + +
Eg Em1 Em 2
Reference
20
T1 T2 M1
M2
j0.25
j0.27 j0.55
Reference
21
T1 T2 M1
M2
j0.05
j0.06 j0.12
j0.96 j0.66
Reference
22
2 UNSYMMETRICAL FAULTS AT GENERATOR TERMINALS
Single line to ground fault ( LG fault ), Line to line fault ( LL fault ) and Double
line to ground ( LLG fault ) are unsymmetrical faults that may occur at any
point in a power system. To understand the unsymmetrical fault analysis, let us
first consider these faults at the terminals of unloaded generator. This treatment
can be extended to unsymmetrical fault analysis when the fault occurs at any
point in a power system.
Va(1) E a n I (1)
a Z1 (16)
Va(2) I (2)
a Z2 (17)
Va(0) I (0)
a Z0 (18)
23
Va(1) E a n I (1)
a Z1 (16)
Va(2) I (2)
a Z2 (17)
Va(0) I (0)
a Z0 (18)
The above three equations apply regardless of the type of fault occurring at the
terminals of the generator.
For each type of fault there will be three relations in terms of phase components
of currents and voltages. Using these, three relations in terms of sequence
components of currents and voltages can be obtained. These three relations and
the eqns. (16), (17) and (18) are used to solve for the sequence currents
I (0) (1) (2)
a , Ia , Ia and sequence voltages Va(0) , Va(1) , Va(2) . Sequence components
relationship will enable to interconnect the sequence networks to represent the
particular fault.
24
Single line to ground fault ( LG fault )
Ia
a
Zf
Zn +
_E a n
Ec n +
Eb n Ib
+
c
b
Ic
Fig. 9
25
The fault conditions are
Ib 0 (19)
Ic 0 (20)
Va Z f I a (21)
a 1/3 ( I a I b I c ) I a /3
I (0)
a 1/3 (I a a I b a I c ) I a /3
I (1) 2
a 1/3 ( I a a I b a I c ) I a /3
I (2) 2
a Ia Ia
Thus I (0) (1) (2)
(22)
I (0)
a Z 0 Ea n I a Z1 I a Z 2 3 Z f I a
(1) (2) (1)
i.e.
I (1)
a Z 0 Ea n I a Z1 I a Z 2 3 Z f I a
(1) (1) (1)
i.e.
Ea n
a
I (1) (24) 26
Z1 Z 2 Z 0 3 Z f
Ea n
I (1)
(24)
Z1 Z 2 Z 0 3 Z f
a
Z1
I (1) +
+ a
Ea n Va(1)
_ _
Z2
+
(2)
I a Va(2) 3 Zf
_
Z0
(0)
+
I a Va(0)
_
Fig. 10
27
Line to line fault
+
Zn
Ea n
_
Eb n
+
Ec n Ib
c +
b
Zf
Ic
Fig. 11
The fault conditions are
Ia 0 (25)
Ib Ic 0 (26)
Vb Z f I b Vc (27)
28
Ia 0 (25)
Ib Ic 0 (26)
Vb Z f I b Vc (27)
a 1/3 ( I a I b I c ) 0
Then I (0) (28)
a 1/3 (I a a I b a I c ) I b /3 ( a a )
I (1) 2 2
a 1/3 ( I a a I b a I c ) I b /3 ( a a )
I (2) 2 2
Since I (0)
a = 0 , Va(0) = - Z0 I (0)
a = 0 (29)
a Ia
I (2) (1)
Further (30)
From eqn. (27)
( a 2 a ) Va(1) Z f ( a 2 a ) I (1)
a ( a a) Va
2 (2)
i.e. Ea n ( Z1 Z 2 Z f ) I (1)
a
Ea n
Therefore a
I (1) (32) 29
Z1 Z 2 Z f
Ea n
Therefore a
I (1) (32)
Z1 Z 2 Z f
I (2) (1)
a = - Ia
and I (0)
a = 0; Va(0) = 0
Zf
Z1 Z2 Z0
Fig. 12
30
Double line to ground fault
a
Ia
+
Zn
E
_ an
Eb n
+
Ec n Ib
c +
b
Ic
Zf
Fig. 13
The fault conditions are
Ia 0 ; Vb Z f ( I b I c ) and Vc Z f ( I b I c ) (33)
31
The fault conditions are
Ia 0 ; Vb Z f ( I b I c ) and Vc Z f ( I b I c ) (33)
Because of I (0)
a 1/3 ( I a I b I c ) , I b I c 3 I (0)
a
Therefore
Vb 3 Z f I (0)
a (34)
Vc 3 Z f I (0)
a (35)
32
Further Va(0) 1/3 ( Va Vb Vc ) i.e.
1 1 Z 2 Z 0 3Z f
Therefore I (1) Va(1) ( ) Va(1)
Z 0 3Z f Z 2 Z 2 ( Z 0 3Z f )
a
Z 2 ( Z 0 3 Z f ) (1)
i.e. Va(1) Ia (38)
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
Z 2 ( Z 0 3 Z f ) (1)
i.e. Ea n I (1) Z Ia
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
a 1
Ea n
Thus I (1) (39)
a
Z ( Z0 3 Zf )
Z1 2
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf 33
Ea n
Thus I (1)
(39)
a
Z ( Z0 3 Zf )
Z1 2
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
Z 2 ( Z 0 3 Z f ) (1)
From eqn. (38) Va(1) Va(2) Z 2 I (2) Ia
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
a
Z0 3 Zf
a Ia
I (2) (1)
Therefore (40)
Z2 Z0 3 Zf
Again substituting eqn. (37) in eqn. (38)
Z 2 ( Z 0 3 Z f ) (1) Z2
( Z 0 3 Z f ) I (0) I Thus I (0)
I (1)
(41)
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
a a a a
For this fault, the sequence networks are to be connected as shown in Fig. 14.
Z1 Z2 Z0
+ I (1)
a I (2) (2)
I (0)
a
Ea n Va(1) a
V a Va(0)
_
3 Zf
34
Fig. 14
3 SUMMARY OF UNSYMMETRICAL FAULTS AT THE GENERATOR
TERMINALS
Va(1) = E a - Z 1 I (1)
a I a = I (0)
a + I (1)
a + I (2)
a
Va(2) = - Z 2 I (2)
a I b = I (0) 2 (1)
a + a Ia + a I (2)
a
Va(0) = - Z 0 I (0)
a I c = I (0)
a + a I (1)
a + a 2 I (2)
a
I
Fault current f I a 3 I (1)
a
Va(1) = E a - Z 1 I (1)
a
Va(2) = - Z 2 I (2)
a
Va(0) = - Z 0 I (0)
a
36
Line to line fault
Ib Ic = - Ib
Zf
Vb - Z f I b = Vc
Ic
Zf
Z1 Z2 Z0
I (1) I (2)
a I (0)
a
Ea n a
Va(2)
Va(1)
37
Ea n
I (1)
; I (2) I (1)
a ; a 0
I (o)
Z1 Z2 Zf
a a
Fault current
(0) 2 (1) (2) 2 (1) (1)
I f I b I a a I a a I a (a a) I a j 3 I a
Va(1) = E a - Z 1 I (1)
a
Va(2) = - Z 2 I (2)
a
Va(0) = - Z 0 I (0)
a
Ia 0
Ib
Vb ( I b I c ) Z f
Zf
Ic
Vc ( I b I c ) Z f
Z1 Z2 Z0
+ I (1) I (2)
a I (0)
a (2) a
Ea n Va(1) V
a Va(0)
-
3 Zf 39
Ea n Z 0 3 Zf
I (1)
I (2) I (1)
a
Z 2 ( Z0 3 Zf ) a a
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
Z1
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
Z2
I (0)
I (1)
Fault current I f I b I c 3 I a
(0)
Z 2 Z0 3 Zf
a a
Va(1) = E a - Z 1 I (1)
a
Va(2) = - Z 2 I (2)
a
Va(0) = - Z 0 I (0)
a
40
Example 2
The reactances of an alternator rated 10 MVA, 6.9 kV are
X 1 = X 2 = 15 % and X g0 = 5 %. The neutral of the alternator is
grounded through a reactance of 0.38 . Single line to ground
fault occurs at the terminals of the alternator. Determine the line
currents, fault current and the terminal voltages.
Solution
X1 = = 0.15 p.u.
X2
10
X n = 0.38 x = 0.0798 p.u.
6.9 2
X 0 = X g0 +3 X n = 0.05 + 0.2394 = 0.2894 p.u.
a = Ia
I (1) = = 1.0 / j ( 0.2894 + 0.15 + 0.15 ) = - j 1.6966 p.u.
(2)
I (0)
a
6.9
Multiplying by
3
Va = 0; Vb = 4.5359 130.38 0 kV ; Vc = 4.5359 130.38 0 kV
42
Example 3
The reactances of an alternator rated 10 MVA, 6.9 kV are
X 1 =15 %; X 2 = 20 % and X g0 = 5 %. The neutral of the
alternator is grounded through a reactance of 0.38 . Line to line
fault, with fault impedance j 0.15 p.u. occurs at the terminals of
the alternator. Determine the line currents, fault current and
the terminal voltages.
Solution
X1 = 0.15 p.u. ; X2 = 0.2 p.u. ; XF = 0.15 p.u. X0 =?
a =
I (1) 1.0 / j ( 0.15 + 0.2 + 0.15 ) = - j 2 p.u.
I (2)
a =- I (1)
a = j 2 p.u. and I (0)
a =0
Corresponding phase components are
Ia = 0 ; Ib = - 3.4641 p.u. ; Ic = 3.4641 p.u.
43
Base current = 836.7 A
Line currents are Ia =0; Ib = - 2898.4 A ; Ic = 2898.4 A
Fault current If = Ib = - 2898.4 A
Va(1) = 1.0 – ( j 0.15 ) (- j 2 ) = 0.7 p.u.
Va(2) = - ( j 0.3 ) ( j 2 ) = 0.4 p.u.
Va(0) = 0
Corresponding phase components are
Va = 1.1 ; Vb = 0.6083 154.72 0 p.u. ; Vc = 0.6083 154.72 0 p.u.
6.9
Multiplying by , Va = 4.3821 kV
3
Vb = 2.4233 154.72 0 kV
Vc = 2.4233 154.72 0 kV
44
Example 4
An unloaded, solidly grounded 10 MVA, 11 kV generator has
positive, negative and zero sequence impedances as j 1.2 Ω,
j 0.9 Ω and j 0.04 Ω respectively. A double line to ground fault
occurs at the terminals of the generator. Calculate the currents in
the faulted phases and voltage of the healthy phase.
Solution
11 2
Base impedance = = 12.1 Ω ;
10
Z1 = j 0.09917 p.u. ; Z2 = j 0.07438 p.u. ; Z0 = j 0.00331 p.u.
Z2 Z0
Z1 + = j 0.10234 p.u.
Z2 Z0
I (1)
a = 1.0/ j 0.10234 = -j 9.7714 p.u.
0.00331
I (2)
a = j 9.7714 = j 0.4163 p.u.
0.07769
(0)
0.07438
I a = j 9.7714 = j 9.3551 p.u.
0.07769 45
I (1)
a = 1.0/ j 0.10234 = -j 9.7714 p.u.
0.00331
I (2)
a = j 9.7714 = j 0.4163 p.u.
0.07769
(0)
0.07438
I a = j 9.7714 = j 9.3551 p.u.
0.07769
Corresponding phase components are
Ia =0; Ib = 16.5758 122.16 0 p.u. ; Ic = 16.5758 57.84 0 p.u.
10 x 1000
Base current = = 542.86 A
3 x 11
Ic = 8998.3 57.84 0 A
Va(1) = Va(2) = Va(0) = - ( j 0.07438 ) ( j 0.4163 ) = 0.03096 p.u.
11
Voltage of the healthy phase Va = 0.09288 x = 0.5899 kV
3 46
EE 0308 POWER SYSTEM ANALYSIS
SURPRISE TEST 1 March 2010
1 Obtain the bus admittance matrix of the transmission system with the
following data.
Line data
1 2 3
1
2
2 j 6 2.7 j 8 0.7 j 2
3 1 j 3 0.7 j 2 1.7 j 5
The slack bus voltage is 1.04 0 0 . At bus 2, real power generation is 0.7,
real power load is 0.2, reactive power generation is 0.1 and reactive power
load is 0.3. Taking flat start and using Gauss Seidel method, find the bus
voltage V2 after first iteration.
2. V1 = 1.04 0 0 ; V2 = 1.0 0 0 ; V3 = 1.0 0 0
PI2 = 0.7 – 0.2 = 0.5; QI2 = 0.1 – 0.3 = - 0.2; PI2 + j QI2 = 0.5 – j 0.2
1 PI2 QI 2
V2(1) = [ (0) *
Y2 1 V1 Y2 3 V3 ]
Y22 V2
1
= [ (0.5 j 0.2) (2 j 6) (1.04) (0.7 j 2)
2.7 j 8
This method is not suitable for large scale power systems as it involves
network reduction in positive, negative and zero sequence networks.
52
5 UNSYMMETRICAL FAULT ANALYSIS USING Z bus matrix
When an unsymmetrical fault occurs in a power system, three phase network has
to be considered. Any three phase element can be represented as shown in Fig.
15.
p q
a,b,c
a
z pq
V p b b Vqa
Vp V
q
c c
V p
V
q
Fig. 15
It can be described as
v a,p qb,c z a,p qb,c i a,p qb,c i.e. (42)
v ap q z ap aq z ap bq z ap cq i ap q
b ba b
v p q = z p q z bp bq z bp cq i p q (43)
v cp q z cpaq z cpbq z cpcq i cp q
53
Voltages at bus p and q can be denoted as
Vpa Vqa
Vpa,b,c Vpb ; Vqa,b,c Vqb (44)
Vpc Vqc
Considering the impedance of each three phase element as z a,p qb,c , using building
algorithm, the bus impedance matrix of transmission-generator can be obtained
as
1 2 N j
1 Z a,b,c
Z a,b,c
Z a,b,c
11 12 1N
Z ai ja Z ai jb Z ai jc
ba
a,b,c a,b,c a,b,c
2 Z Z Z
Z a,busb,c 21 22 2N
where Z a,i jb,c i Z i j Z bi jb Z bi jc
a,b,c Z ci ja Z ci jc
a,b,c Z ci jb
N Z N1 Z a,N2b,c Z NN
The bus impedance matrix Z a,busb,c will be normally full with non-zero entries.
Since impedance of any element in sequence frame, z p0,1,2
q is decoupled,
0,1,2
computationally it is advantage to use the matrix Z bus instead of Z a,busb,c .
54
For two bus system
1 2 1 2 1 2
1 Z 11
(0) (0)
Z 12 1 Z 11
(1) (1)
Z 12 1 Z 11
(2) (2)
Z 12
0
Z bus (0) ; Z 1bus (1) ; Z 2
bus (2) (2)
2 Z 21 Z (0)
22 2 Z 21 Z (1)
22 2 Z 21 Z 22
Then
1 2
0 1 2 0 1 2
(0) (0)
0 Z 11 Z 12
(1) (1)
1 1 Z 11 Z 12
0,1,2
Z bus 2 (2)
Z 11 (2)
Z 12 (45)
0 Z (0)
21 Z (0)
22
2 1 Z (1)
21 Z (1)
22
2 Z (2)
21 Z (2)
22
0
Normally Z bus , Z1bus and Z bus
2
are constructed and stored independently. It is
evident that as compared to Z a,busb,c , construction of Z bus
0,1,2
requires less computer
time and less core storage. For a 100 bus system, Z a,busb,c will be a 300 x 300 full
0,1,2
matrix; whereas for Z bus , we need 3 numbers of 100 x 100 matrices. Thus only
0,1,2
1/3 rd of the core storage is required for Z bus as compared to Z a,busb,c . Hence for
0,1,2 55
unsymmetrical fault analysis, use of Z bus is more advantages than Z a,busb,c .
Further, when unsymmetrical faults occur, the currents
and voltages are unbalanced and using symmetrical
components transformation, we can handle them
conveniently. Therefore, symmetrical components are
invariably used in the study of unsymmetrical fault analysis.
0,1,2
In order to obtain Z bus , first the three sequence networks
are be drawn as discussed earlier. Considering the zero
sequence, positive sequence and negative sequence networks
separately, using bus impedance building algorithm,
are to be constructed independently . Of course special
attention is necessary while drawing the zero sequence network.
56
Example 5
Solution
j0.05
j0.06 j0.12
j0.96 j0.66
Reference
0 57
Element 0-1 is added: 0
Z bus j 1 1.01
1 2
1 1.01 0
Element 0 – 2 is added: 0
j 0 0.08
Z bus
2
1 2 3
1 1.01 0 0
Element 0 – 3 is added: 0
Z bus j 2 0 0.08 0
3 0 0 0.09
1 2 3
1 1.01 0 0 0
2 0 0.08 0 0.08
Z 0
j
bus
3 0 0 0.09 0.09
0 0.08 0.09 0.69
58
1 2 3
1 1.01 0 0
0
Eliminating the th bus, Z bus j 2 0 0.07 0.01
3 0 0.01 0.08
1 2 3 4
1 1.01 0 0 0
2 0 0.07 0.01 0
Z 0
j
bus
3 0 0.01 0.08 0
4 0 0 0 0.72
59
j0.08 j0.18 j0.09
j0.2 1 2 3 4
j0.27 j0.55
+ + +
Eg Em1 Em 2
Reference
1 2
1 0.2 0.2
Element 1 – 2 is added: Z bus
1
j 0.2 0.28
2
1 2 3
1 0.2 0.2 0.2
Element 2 – 3 is added: Z bus
1
j 2 0.2 0.28 0.28
3 0.2 0.28 0.46
60
1 2 3 4
1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
2 0.2 0.28 0.28 0.28
Element 3 – 4 is added: Z 1
j
bus 3 0.2 0.28 0.46 0.46
4
0.2 0.28 0.46 0.55
1 2 3 4
1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2
2 0.2 0.28 0.28 0.28 0.28
1
Z bus j 3 0.2 0.28 0.46 0.46 0.46
4 0.2 0.28 0.46 0.55 0.55
0.2 0.28 0.46 0.55 0.73
1
Eliminating the th bus, final Z bus is obtained as
1 2 3 4
1 0.1452 0.1233 0.0740 0.0493
2 0.1233 0.1726 0.1036 0.0690
1
Z bus = j
3 0.0740 0.1036 0.1701 0.1134
61
4 0.0493 0.0690 0.1134 0.1356
Similarly, considering the negative sequence network shown in Fig. 8(c)
j0.25
j0.27 j0.55
Reference
0
2
Its bus impedance Z bus can be obtained as
1 2 3 4
1 0.1699 0.1442 0.0866 0.0577
2 0.1442 0.1904 0.1143 0.0761
2
Z bus = j
3 0.0866 0.1143 0.1765 0.1177
4 0.0577 0.0761 0.1177 0.1384
62
0,1,2
6 UNSYMMETRICAL FAULT ANALYSIS USING Z bus MATRIX
0,1,2 1
For unsymmetrical fault analysis using Z bus the first step is to construct Z bus ,
2 0
Z bus and Z bus by considering the positive sequence, negative sequence and zero
sequence network of the power system. They are
1 2 p N
1 Z 11
(1) (1)
Z 12 (1)
Z 1p (1)
Z 1N
(1)
2 Z 21 Z (1)
22 Z (1)
2p Z (1)
2N
1
Z bus (1) (1)
(46)
p Z p1 Z (1)
p2 Z (1)
pp Z pN
(1)
Z N1 Z (1) Z N N
(1) (1)
N N2 Z Np
63
1 2 p N
1 Z 11
(2) (2) (2) (2)
Z 12 Z 1p Z 1N
(2)
2 Z 21 Z (2)
22 Z (2)
2p Z (2)
2N
2
Z bus (2)
and (47)
p Z (2)
p1 Z (2)
p2 Z (2)
pp Z pN
(2)
N Z N1 Z (2) Z (2) Z N N
(2)
N2 Np
1 2 p N
1 Z 11
(0) (0) (0) (0)
Z 12 Z 1p Z 1N
(0)
2 Z 21 Z (0)
22 Z (0)
2p Z (0)
2N
0
Z bus (48)
p Z (0)
p1 Z (0)
p2 Z (0)
pp Z (0)
pN
(0)
N Z N1 Z (0) Z (0) Z N N
(0)
N2 Np
64
Suitable assumptions are made so that prior to the occurrence of the fault, there
will not be any current flow in the positive, negative and zero sequence networks
and the voltages at all the buses in the positive sequence network are equal to
Vf .
The currents flowing out of the original balanced system from phases a, b and c
at the fault point are designated as I f a , I f b and I f c . We can visualize these
currents by referring to Fig. 16 which shows the three lines a, b and c of the
three phase system where the fault occurs.
P
a
If a
b
If b
c
If c
Fig. 16
65
The currents flowing out in hypothetical stub are I f a , I f b and I f c . The
corresponding sequence currents are I (0) (1) (2)
f a , I f a and I f a . These sequence currents
at any bus j of the system during the fault are Vj a , Vj b and Vj c . Corresponding
sequence components of voltages are Vj(0)
a , V (1)
ja and V (2)
ja .
1
- Vf +
Positive
sequence
network 2
- Vf +
having p
bus
impedance I (1)
fa
matrix N
- Vf +
Z (1)
bus
66
1 1
Negative Zero
sequence sequence
2 network 2
network
having having p
p
bus bus
impedance impedance
matrix matrix N
N
I (2)
fa
I (0)
fa
Z (2) Z (0)
bus
bus
Fig. 17
67
Consider the Positive Sequence Network:
1 V1a(1)
(1)
2 V2a
(1)
Vbus (1) (49)
p Vp a
(1)
N VN a
68
It is to be noted that
1 0 1
2 0 1
0 1 V
bus
I (1) and pre-fault voltage = (50)
p I f a
(1) 1 f
0 1
N 0 1
V1a(1) Z 11
(1) (1)
Z 12 (1)
Z 1p (1)
Z 1N 0 1 Vf Z 1p If a
(1) (1)
69
(51)
Consider the Negative Sequence and Zero Sequence Networks:
In a much similar manner, the negative sequence and the zero sequence bus
(2) (0)
voltages in the faulted system, namely Vbus and Vbus , can be obtained considering
the negative sequence and the zero sequence networks. Knowing the pre-fault
voltages are zero in the negative and zero sequence networks we get
V1a(2) Z 1p If a
(2) (2)
V1a(0) Z 1p If a
(0) (0)
70
When the fault occurs at bus p , it is to be noted that only the p th column of
1 2 0
Z bus , Z bus and Z bus are involved in the calculations. If the symmetrical
components of the fault currents , namely I (1) (2) (0)
f a , I f a and I f a , are known, than the
Vj(0)
a Z (0) (0)
jp I f a (53)
Vj(1)
a Vf Z (1) (1)
jp I f a (54)
Vj(2)
a Z (2) (2)
jp I f a (55)
71
General procedure for unsymmetrical
fault analysis
72
PRELIMINARY CALCULATIONS
DATA REQUIRED
Vpa 1 1 1 Vp a (0)
1 a 2 (1)
Vp b = a pa
V
V p c 1 a a 2 V (2)
pa
74
TO COMPUTE BUS VOLTAGES AT BUS j i.e V j a, V j b and V j c
V ja 1 1 1 V j a (0)
1 a 2 (1)
V
jb = a Vj a
V jc 1 a a 2 V (2)
ja
75
Single line to ground fault
I (f 1)a
+ Z (1)
pp
Vf Vp(1)a
_
(2)
3 Zf
Z pp
Vp(2)a
I (f 0)a
Z (0)
pp
Vp(0)a
76
Line to line fault
Zf
Z (1)
pp
Z (2)
pp
+ I (1)
fa I (2)
fa I (0)
fa
Vf Vp(1)a Vp(2)a
_
77
Double line to ground fault
Z (1)
pp Z (2)
pp Z (0)
pp
+ I (1)
fa I (2)
fa I (0)
fa
Vf Vp(1)a Vp(2)a Vp(0)a
_
3 Zf
78
SINGLE LINE TO GROUND FAULT
For a single line to ground fault through impedance Z f , the hypothetical stubs
on the three lines will be as shown in Fig. 18 The fault conditions are
P
a
Zf
If a
b
If b
c If c
Fig. 18
If b 0
If c 0 (56)
Vp a Z f I f a
79
Using the above conditions ( similar to conditions for the LG fault at generator
terminals through impedance ) and also knowing that
from eqns. (51) and (52), similar to eqns. (22) and (23), we can get the relations
I (1)
fa = I (2)
fa = I (0)
fa and (60)
Vp(1)a Vp(2)a Vp(0)a 3 Z f I (1)
fa = 0 (61)
Therefore
Vf
fa
I (1) (62)
Z (1)
pp Z (2)
pp Z (0)
p p 3 Zf
80
I (f 1)a
+ Z (1)
pp
Vf Vp(1)a
_
(2)
3 Zf
Z pp
Vp(2)a
I (f 2)a
Z (0)
pp
Vp(0)a
Fig. 19
a Vf Z j p I f a
Vj(1) (1) (1)
a Z jp I f a
Vj(2) j 1,2,....... N
(2) (2)
(64)
a Z jp I f a
Vj(0) (0) (0)
jp
Phase components of voltage and current can be calculated from the relations
Va , b , c A V0 , 1 , 2
I a , b , c A I 0 , 1, 2
82
Example 6
The positive sequence, negative sequence and zero sequence bus impedance
matrices of a power system are shown below.
1 2 3 4
1 0.1437 0.1211 0.0789 0.0563
0.1211 0.1696 0.1104 0.0789
2
bus Z bus
Z (1) (2)
j
3 0.0789 0.1104 0.1696 0.1211
4 0.0563 0.0789 0.1211 0.1437
1 2 3 4
1 0.1553 0.1407 0.0493 0.0347
0.1407 0.1999 0.0701 0.0493
2
bus
Z (0) j
3 0.0493 0.0701 0.1999 0.1407
4 0.0347 0.0493 0.1407 0.1553
A bolted single line to ground fault occurs on phase ‘a’ at bus 3. Determine the
fault current and the voltage at buses 3 and 4.
83
Solution
Vf
I (1) = I (2)
= I (0)
fa =
Z (2)
33 Z 33
fa fa
Z (1)
33
(0)
Let Vf 1.0 0 0
1.00 0
Then I (1)
= I (2)
= I (0)
= = j1.8549
j (0.1696 0.1696 0.1999 )
fa fa fa
V3(0)a Z (0)
33 I f a ( j 0.1999 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.3708
(0)
V3(1)a Vf Z (1)
33 I f a 1.0 ( j 0.1696 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.6854
(1)
V3(2)a Z (2)
33 I f a ( j0.1696 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.3146
(2)
84
Phase components of line to ground voltage of bus 3 are computed as
V3 a 1 1 1 0.3708 0
1 a 2
V3 b = a 0.6854 =
1.0292 122.710
V3 c 1 a a 2 0.3146 1.0187 122.710
V4(0)a Z (0)
43 I f a ( j 0.1407 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.2610
(0)
V4(1)a Vf Z (1)
43 I f a 1.0 ( j 0.1211 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.7754
(1)
V4(2)a Z (2)
43 I f a ( j0.1211 ) ( j1.8549 ) 0.2246
(2)
85
LINE TO LINE FAULT
To represent a line to line fault through impedance Z f the hypothetical stubs on
the three lines at the fault are connected as shown in Fig. 20.
P
a
If a
b
If b
Zf
c (
If c
Fig. 20
Fault conditions are
I fa 0
If b If c 0 (65)
Vp b Z f I f b Vp c 86
Using the above conditions along with the relations
fa 0
I (0) (67)
I (1)
fa I (2)
fa (68)
Vp(1)a Z f I (1)
f a Vp a
(2)
(69)
Vf
and hence fa
I (1) (70)
Z (1)
pp Z (2)
pp Zf
87
To satisfy the above relations the sequence networks are to be connected as
shown in Fig. 21.
Zf
Z (1)
Z (2) Z (0)
pp
pp pp
+ I (1)
fa I (2)
fa I (0)
fa
Vf Vp(1)a Vp(2)a
_
Fig. 21
using eqn. (63). The corresponding phase components are then calculated using
the symmetrical component transformation matrix. 88
Example 7
Consider the power system described in example 6. A bolted line to line fault
occurs at bus 3. Determine the currents in the fault, voltages at the fault bus
and the voltages at bus 4.
Solution
fa 0
For line to line fault I (0)
Vf 1.0
I (1) I fa
(2)
j 2.9481
Z33 Z33 j 0.1696 j 0.1696
fa (1) (2)
I f b a 2 I (1)
f a a I f a j 3 I f a - 5.1061
(2) (1)
I f c I f b 5.1061
Sequence components of voltage at bus 3 are
89
Phase components of voltage at bus 3 are
V4(0)a Z (0)
43 I fa 0
(0)
(1)
V4a Vf Z (1)
43 I f a 1 ( j 0.1211 ) ( j 2.9481 ) 0.643
(1)
V4(2)a Z (2)
43 I f a ( j 0.1211 ) ( j 2.9481 ) 0.357
(2)
For a double line to ground fault, the hypothetical stubs are connected as shown
in Fig. 22.
P
a
If a
b
If b
c (
If c
Zf
Fig. 22
The relations at the fault bus are
I fa 0
Vp b Z f ( I f b I f c ) (71)
91
Vp c Z f ( I f b I f c )
Further the relations are also applicable.
Using eqns. (71) and (62) the following relations can be obtained.
Vp(1)a Vp(2)a
Vp(1)a Vp(0)a 3 Z f I (0)
fa
I (0)
fa I (1)
fa I fa 0
(2)
Vf
fa
I (1) (73)
pp ( Zpp 3 Zf )
Z (2) (0)
pp
Z (1)
Z (2)
pp Z pp 3 Zf
(0)
92
To represent the above relations, the sequence networks must be interconnected
as shown in Fig. 23.
Z (1)
pp Z (2)
pp Z (0)
pp
+ I (1)
fa I (2)
fa I (0)
fa
Vf Vp(1)a Vp(2)a Vp(0)a
_
3 Zf
Fig. 23
The sequence currents I (2) (0)
f a and I f a can be obtained from
p p 3 Zf
Z (0)
I (2)
I (1)
(74)
Z 3 Zf
fa fa (2) (0)
Z pp pp
Z (2)
I
(0) (1) pp
I (75)
Z 3 Zf
fa fa (2) (0)
Z pp pp 93
Knowing I (1)
fa , I (2)
fa and I (0)
fa sequence components of voltage at fault point are
calculated from
Vp(1)a Vf Z (1)
pp I (1)
fa
a Vf Z j p I f a
Vj(1) (1) (1)
a Z jp I f a
Vj(2) j 1,2,....... N
(2) (2)
(77)
a Z jp I f a
Vj(0) (0) (0)
jp
The positive sequence, negative sequence and zero sequence bus impedance
matrices of a power system are shown below.
1 2 3 4
1 0.1437 0.1211 0.0789 0.0563
2 0.1211 0.1696 0.1104 0.0789
bus Z bus
Z (1) (2)
j
3 0.0789 0.1104 0.1696 0.1211
4 0.0563 0.0789 0.1211 0.1437
1 2 3 4
1 0.19 0 0 0
0 0.08 0.08 0
2
bus
Z (0) j
3 0 0.08 0.58 0
4 0 0 0 0.19
95
A double line to ground fault with Z f 0 occurs at bus 4. Find the fault
current and voltages at the fault bus.
Solution
Vf 1.0
fa
I (1) (2) (0)
j 4.4342
Z Z ( j 0.1437 ) ( j 0.19 )
Z (1) (2)44 44(0) j 0.1437
44
Z 44 Z 44 j 0.1437 j 0.19
Z (0) j0.19
I (2)
I (1) 44
( j4.4342 ) j2.5247
Z 44 Z 44
fa fa (2) (0)
j0.1437 j0.19
Z (2) j0.1437
I (0)
I (1) 44
( j4.4342 ) j1.9095
fa fa
Z (2)
44 Z (0)
44 j0.1437 j0.19
96
Phase components of current at the fault bus are
I f a I (0)
f a If a If a 0
(1) (2)
I f b I (0)
f a a I f a a I f a j1.9095 4.4342150 2.5247210
2 (1) (2) 0 0
= - 6.0266 + j 2.8642
I f c I (0)
f a a I f a a I f a j1.9095 4.434230 2.5247 30
(1) 2 (2) 0 0
= 6.0266 + j 2.8642
Noting that Z f 0
I a 7.031159.85 0
Ib 4.3733203.840
Ic 2.6810160.750
graphically.
21 6 6
z j 6 21 6
a,b,c
6 6 21
Denoting the neutral point as n and the ground as o , draw the phasor
fault current to 2500 A for single line to ground fault. Find the additional
T1 T2
1 2 3 4
1 2
On a chosen base of 100 MVA, 345 kV in the transmission line circuit, the
line reactances are X1 = X2 = 15 % and X0 = 50 %. Draw each of the three
sequence networks and find Zbus0, Zbus1 and Zbus2.
100
10. The one-line diagram of a power system is shown below.
T1 T3
1 2 3 5 6
1 3
T2
Transformer 1: X0 = X1 = X2 = 0.12
Transformer 2: X0 = X1 = X2 = 0.24
Transformer 3: X0 = X1 = X2 = 0.1276
T1 T2 S
1 2 P 3 4
1
Switch open
On a chosen base of 100 MVA, 345 kV in the transmission line circuit, the
line reactances are:
From T1 to P: X1 = X2 = 20 %; X0 = 50%
From T2 to P: X1 = X2 = 10 %; X0 = 30%
ANSWERS
1. Ia0 Ib0 Ic0 21200 ; Ia1 3.5300 ; Ib1 3.52700 ; Ic1 3.51500
3. Z 0 j 33; Z 1 Z 2 j15
4. Ia = -j 3586.1 A Ib = 0 Ic = 0 If = -j 3586.1 A
Vab = 8.0694 77.780 kV; Vbc= 15.7724 900 kV; Vca= 8.0694 102.220 kV
Va = 5.6720 kV Vb = 0 Vc = 0
If = 3347 900 A
Va = Vb = Vc = 0
8. 0.9655 Ω
j0.04
j0.04
j0.15 j0.15
104
Reference
Positive sequence network:
j0.2
j0.2
+
+
- -
Reference
j0.2 j0.2
Reference
105
1 0.19 0 0 0
2 0 0.08 0.08 0
Zbus0 = j
3 0 0.08 0.58 0
4 0 0 0 0.19
1 2 3 4
1 0.1437 0.1211 0.0789 0.0563
2 0.1211 0.1696 0.1104 0.0789
Zbus1 = Zbus2 = j
3 0.0789 0.1104 0.1696 0.1211
4 0.0563 0.0789 0.1211 0.1437
4 j0.072
j0.15
j0.225
j0.45
106
Reference
0.3 0 0 0 0
2
0 0.104468 0.031065 0 0.031065
Zbus0 = j 3 0 0.031065 0.177871 0 0.177871
4
0 0 0 0.6 0
5 0 0.031065 0.177871 0 0.654271
j0.24
4 j0.15
j0.25
j0.2
Reference 107
Zbus1 = Zbus2 =
1 2 3 4 5 6