Comparative Essay

According to David Foreman, “My three main goals would be to reduce human

population to about 100 million worldwide, destroy the industrial infrastructure and see

wilderness, with its full complement of species returning throughout the world.” In the Hunger

Games by Suzanne Collins and The Lottery by Shirley Jackson. The purpose of the reaping and

the lottery is to get rid of one person each year. The process is conducted by doing a raffle to

start. The basic outcome is that one person gets beat to death every year. It left communities

feeling unsure about the games. In the hunger games and the lottery, two key similarities were

the raffle, and they have to kill a person every year, while a major difference was the way they

killed the people. They impact the reader's experience because they don’t realize that the hunger

games and the lottery have similarities.

It is a similarity because one person dies every year. It is the same because every year one

person dies. In the hunger games they get six girl and six boy to fight to the death, and in the

lottery whoever gets the winning paper, they get beat to death. My evidence to support this is

"All right, folks," Mr. Summers said. "Let's finish quickly.” ​The stories are all about how they do

a game every year and one person has to die. We can inference that the games are terrifying and

people want to quit but they think it's wrong to do so. They are terrified because they do not want

to die but they do not have a choice, they have to participate. The inference we can make is that

they do not have a choice because if they do not participate they will get a punishment. The

lottery and the Hunger games have similarities, one of the similarities is that one person dies

every year.
 Comparative Essay

It is a similarity because they both have a raffle at the beginning of their stories. My

evidence to support this is “S​he reaches in, digs her hand deep into the ball, and pulls out a slip

of paper.” ​It is the same because whoever gets the winning card wins the lottery and right after

they get beat to death. The Raffle is in both stories because that is how there tradition is. This is

clear that everyone is excited about the raffle but nobody wants to get picked. They do not want

to get picked because they already know how they die and they are scared. They would be scared

because they have a fear of dying. The Lottery and the Hunger Games have similarities and

differences one similarity is they have a raffle in the begging of the game.

There is a major difference between the two stories. The major difference is the way

people kill each other. They kill each other because they have been doing that like a tradition for

many years. In the Hunger Games, they kill each other in a battle and in the Lottery they kill the

people with pebbles. The inference we can make regarding this evidence is that they did not have

the same idea as the other village becasue their way of killing people is so much different than

the Hunger Games. My evidence to support this is in the lottery it states “​The pile of stones the

boys had made earlier was ready; there were stones on the ground with the blowing scraps of

paper that had come out of the box​.” In the Hunger Games it states “​In punishment for the

uprising, each of the twelve districts must provide one girl and one boy, called tributes, to

participate.” ​ They have not stopped it because they think it's the right thing to do. They do not
 Comparative Essay

stop it because they think that one person should die each year as a punishment. One thing that is

a major difference in the Lottery and the Hunger Games is the way they kill the people.

The Hunger Games and the lottery are not much different. They have similarities and

differences, two similarities and one difference. These texts taught me about humanity and

society by showing me two different villages and how they respond to human development. In

my opinion, I think that people should be fair to each other and treat people how they want to be

treated.