Professional Documents
Culture Documents
History Notes: Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
History Notes: Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
Q2. Which of the following services of Sir Syed played the most important role in
the revival of Muslims in the subcontinent? (14)
1. Political
2. Educational
3. Social
Ans. In the darkest hours of their life, the Muslim community produced a great
and courageous leader in the person of Sir Syed Ahmad Khan who rendered
invaluable services for the cause of downtrodden Muslims of his time. His
educational, political and social services played a great role for the revival of
Muslim community in the subcontinent.
He did a great deal to improve the relations between the British and the Muslims.
The war of 1857 had developed great mistrust between the British and the
Muslims. The British blamed the Muslims for starting the revolt. To clarify the
causes of the war Sir Syed wrote ‘Essay on the Causes of the Indian Revolt’ in
which he stated that the Muslims were dragged into the war by the Hindus. He
also issued the ‘Loyal Muhammadan of India’ to remove the wrong perception of
the British that the Muslims were disloyal. In it he outlined the loyal services the
Muslims had rendered to the British Empire. The British resented being called
Nadarath but Sir Syed clarified that Nadarath came from an Arabic word Nasir
meaning helper. He wrote a book ‘Tabyin-ul-Kalam’ which was a commentary on
Bible. In it he also pointed out the similarities between Islam and Christianity.
Through this book he proved that Muslims could eat with Christians. He also
issued an Urdu journal called ‘Tahzib-ul-Akhlaq’ which contained articles from
influential Muslims. In it he also criticized the conservative attitude of the
Muslims and emphasized the need to study.
In 1885 when the Indian National Congress was founded, Sir Syed soon came to
know that it was to work only for Hindu interests. As it was a threat to Muslims,
Sir Syed openly demanded for separate seats for Muslims in local elections so
they had the right to speak out. He restrained Muslims from joining the Congress
instead he organized an alternative body called the United Patriotic Alliance
which in 1893 became the Muhammadan Defense Alliance. In the beginning,. Sir
Syed was a great advocate of Hindu-Muslim Unity but the Hindi-Urdu controversy
of 1867 had brought a change in his political thinking. In it Hindus openly
demonstrated against Urdu language and instead wanted Hindi to become the
official language. In response to this he developed his Two-Nation Theory in
which he clarified that Muslims and Hindus were two separate nations who could
never live together. This Theory later on became the base of Pakistan Movement.
In view of the services rendered by Sir Syed to the Muslim community, his social
services were the most important. His social services improved the relations
between Muslims and British. Had the relations not improved, the Muslims would
have still been considered as disloyal. They would not have got the right to
express their demands nor would they have been able to counter the Hindus.
With the help of these services, the Muslims recognized their identity as a
separate nation.
Q3. Why did Sir Syed present his Two Nation Theory? (7)
Q4. Why was Sir Syed accused of being pro- British? (7)
Ans. After the War of Independence in 1857, sir Syed started working to bridge
the gap between Muslims and British but he was accused of being pro-British.
This perception was due to some reasons. When the war of 1857 had broke out,
sir Syed was working as a chief judge in Bijnaur. He saved the lives of many British
women and children. This made the Muslims unhappy and they labeled him as a
traitor. Another thing which may have become the reason was that he advocated
scientific ideas and western education. In his Urdu journal Tahdbib-ul-Akhlaq he
asked Muslims to gain scientific knowledge and western education whereas the
Muslims at that time considered scientific education as un-Islamic. Thirdly he
advocated English as the medium of education and that Muslims could only get
their right when they will know how to speak English. Also to counter the Hindus,
they would have to know how to speak English. These reasons may well support
that why was Sir Syed Ahmad accused of being pro-British.
Q6. For what services do Muslims remember Sir Syed Ahmad Khan? (10)
Ans. In the darkest hours of their life, the Muslim community produced a great
and courageous leader in the person of Sir Syed Ahmad Khan who rendered
invaluable services for the cause of downtrodden Muslims of his time. His
educational, political and social services played a great role for the revival of
Muslim community in the subcontinent.
In 1885 when the Indian National Congress was founded, Sir Syed soon came to
know that it was to work only for Hindu interests. As it was a threat to Muslims,
Sir Syed openly demanded for separate seats for Muslims in local elections so
they had the right to speak out. He restrained Muslims from joining the Congress
instead he organized an alternative body called the United Patriotic Alliance
which in 1893 became the Muhammadan Defense Alliance. In the beginning,. Sir
Syed was a great advocate of Hindu-Muslim Unity but the Hindi-Urdu controversy
of 1867 had brought a change in his political thinking. In it Hindus openly
demonstrated against Urdu language and instead wanted Hindi to become the
official language. In response to this he developed his Two-Nation Theory in
which he clarified that Muslims and Hindus were two separate nations who could
never live together. This Theory later on became the base of Pakistan Movement.
In short, sir Syed came forward to guide the Muslims when they were on the
verge of elimination from the Indian society because of Hindu and British
domination. He awakened the Muslims to animate their dormant spirits in order
to put up a resolute struggle for the revival of their past position of eminence. He
can rightly be called the father of the ‘Pakistan Movement’.
Q7. What were Sir Syed’s most significant contributions to the improvement of
education among Muslims? (10)
Q8. Why did Sir Syed try to improve relations between the Muslims and the
British? (7)
Partition of Bengal
Q2. Why did British reverse the partition of Bengal in 1911? (7)
Ans. While the Muslims benefited from the Partition of Bengal, the Hindus were
totally against it. They regarded the partition as part of British divide and rule
policy. Some also considered as a British attempt to weaken Hindu unity by
establishing a Muslim majority province. The annulment of Bengal partition was
for a number of reasons. The Partition had led to a huge political crisis. In West
Bengal there were factories which belonged to Hindus. On the other hand the
people working in theses factories were Muslims living in East Bengal. This
created economic problem for the Hindus. 16 October the day the partition was
put into effect became a day of mourning. There were hundreds of protest
meeting and many petitions sent to the government. Later there was even an
assassination attempt on future viceroy Lord Minto. Protest movements led by
the Indian nationalist and the Congress like the Swadeshi movement pressurized
the British and they were forced to reconsider the wisdom of their decision. At
the hands of these protest movements the British suffered a great economic loss.