Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Naomi Saito-Comm 480 Paper 2
Naomi Saito-Comm 480 Paper 2
Naomi Saito
1
0. Collective identity preliminary: Snap Judgements
To me, America is a melting pot and global superpower with a huge influence everywhere. Its
cooks. In my mind, Florence is home, the heart of the Renaissance, and museum of a city; People from
Florence are annoyed with tourists, traditional, and proud of being Florentine. Europe is old, white,
historic, and the center of the world (in their mind) and Europeans are traditional, xenophobic, and
diverse in culture. When I first think of it, a“Cosmopolitan” is a magazine and a drink, but realizing that it
is a “citizen of the world,” I see it as a goal and state we should all be working to achieve. Although it is
easy to go with my gut reactions to how I would describe each of these groups, I see how these
judgements make broad generalizations of a large number of people based only on my own personal
experiences and perceptions. It is easy for me to talk about the negatives especially because, although I do
fit into some of the first groups, I do not strongly identify with them.
1. Departure: Escape
I first decided to consider a study abroad experience for this Fall when I decided that I did not
want to spend the quarter at my home university. My major allows all students to take on quarter off from
our studies without consequence in order to encourage students to take advantage of study abroad,
internships, and other opportunities. Part of me wanted to get out of Seattle to avoid getting stuck in the
same routine and do something that was different from anything else I was experiencing in Seattle. I
honestly thought that I would feel lame if all my peers were out experiencing the world and I was sitting
2
in Seattle doing the same thing every day. So when the opportunity to study abroad in Florence with
My situation coming into this study abroad program is very unique. My mother works for
Gonzaga University and my family lived in Florence when she was teaching here for a semester in 2008. I
very soon. I looked into a couple other options, but at the end of the day, a free study abroad experience
in a program I experienced as a child came out on top as the best option. I pay for my education at the
University of Washington on my own, so the fact that this would be a free piece of my education was an
important element in my decision making. Once I thought about the fact that I would be able to travel the
world (or at least) Europe how I had always wanted to, I knew that I had made the right decision.
Many of the images that I had of Florence and Italy were based on what I had experienced as a
child. The only pieces of Italian culture that I had really seen or experienced before we moved to Florence
This meant that all of my images from personal experience were formed
that I had of Florence and Italy held true but I found that I had to learn
about other parts of the cultures that most people don’t pay much
that showed Italy and all of Europe painted in a different light than I had
3
overrode the ones I already had, but I do think that they created more stereotypes in my head of what
people from different European countries are like. In preparing for my travels to Florence, I began to look
for lists of places to visit and tips for travel. I found these lists on places like Pinterest of the best places to
visit and things that you have to see in every city. A common post I would find would be centered around
the best spots for getting a shot for your Instagram rather than how to experience the culture.
Even though I had all of these elements leading me to embarking on this study a broad experience,
I had a moment after getting on the plane where I asked myself, “What the heck am I doing here?” I saw
the group of Zags excitedly talking about travelling to Florence but I only knew one person on the
program. I would consider myself a huge extrovert but I was anxious to go into this program as a total
outsider and try to integrate myself into the community. Luckily, on the first flight I began to meet zags
who were all very friendly and I already started to feel like the students were very welcoming. From when
Finding my place and making friends during the opening tour was an intimidating and slow process, but I
feel very fortunate that I settled in with some wonderful friends that I have maintained closeness with
The opening tour was a key part of me beginning to feel like I was actually supposed to be here
and not crazy for dropping everything to spend a semester abroad. I think that without it, I would have
had a hard time meeting people and getting a feel for the group. Especially since I knew I would be
travelling all semester, I was especially grateful begin travelling with a group where I knew that other
4
people would know exactly what was going on as well as making sure we were seeing all that we needed
to see. Although I was anxious to get to Florence and get settled into the routine, the opening tour
provided a space that was not present any other time throughout the program. We also got to see parts of
Italy I never would have thought to visit if not for the opening tour.
Arriving in Florence meant we got to move into our pensiones, one of my favourite parts of the
whole program. Our hosts Massimo and Silvia are some of the most welcoming and hospitable people I
have ever met. I could write a whole essay on how much they have done for me this quarter. But in
summary, they were able to make this place feel like it was truly our home. Hearing about other
find their own place to live and cook for themselves, and I think that having a place to live with such
caring hosts alongside other students has kept me from getting too homesick because I love living here
My first walk through the city was a very nostalgic experience for me. The center of the city is
the part that I remember best so I wanted to walk by the front of the Duomo to Piazza della Signoria. I
was basically jumping with excitement to see the places I remembered from 10 years ago. The Duomo
never fails to amaze me even now. There is absolutely nothing quite like experiencing it in person. The
city has changed a lot since I was last here but I the city still has a grandiose feel unlike any other city I
have been to. This same day, we had our Gonzaga-in-Florence orientation. Here the staff introduced us to
all the information we would need to know to survive our first few days in Florence and get ready to
begin classes. The orientation was an expectation coming from doing so many orientations at universities
5
in America. Throughout the quarter I have found myself asking why they didn’t mention certain things
during the orientation, but it is not a given that they will tell us everything that we could need to know,
especially when it is not a normal practice here. Nonetheless, this orientation made me feel more
My first day of school felt much more relaxed than any other I have had since being at university.
Having the time of the opening tour allowed me to meet people who would be in many of my classes so
my first classes weren’t as awkward as they could have been. I have been around the building hosting
Gonzaga-in-Florence as a child so the school itself felt very familiar. Since I am studying urban design at
UW, none of my classes here are really applicable to my major, so I just chose ones that sounded
interesting to me. I have also spent my entire college career on the fast-paced schedule of the quarter
system. Receiving my syllabi from my professors, I was surprised that we were not learning more
material in a week. Although I am sure it is much different at Gonzaga in Spokane, the schedules for the
classes were accommodating of the fact that students are abroad and travelling every weekend. Something
I did not expect since I lived here with my mother who is an American professor, is that all of my
professors were Italian and most of them even Florentines. Since I got to take classes that I was just
especially enjoyed that we got to talk about Italians as they exist now as opposed to how they were during
the Renaissance. I found it interesting to explore the idea that Italy truly is viewed through the lense of the
grand tour painting Italians in the light of romance and perpetuating the narrative that people can go to
Italy to “find themselves” (Birindelli). I certainly had this narrative in my head without ever realizing it.
This class taught me so much without me even realizing it because we learned in the form of discussions.
6
Although very few things were able to beat my pensione host Silvia’s cooking, we went out to eat
on the weekends in Florence or wherever we were in Europe at that moment. Being students, we tended
to eat at places that were cheap and relatively quick or places that we could also study in. Some favorites
shops. We never wanted to walk too far at night so we latched onto a gelato shop called My Sugar.
They’ve come to recognize us and we genuinely enjoy giving them our patronage.
Something my mom had told me about coming into the program was that the drinking culture
would be very different here. This is not even a merit of the way Italians drink, but rather American
students bringing the culture of binge drinking here combined with the new ability of many students to
drink legally at bars. Obviously a large difference also lies in the drinking practices themselves with
Italians enjoying alcohol with meals and American students drinking to get drunk. I am also not used to
going out on Tuesday nights, but this is the night when the entire school seems to go out. Since I was
already 21 before arriving to Italy, I have found that the bars are pretty similar to the ones in America.
The biggest difference I have found is in the clubs. Although like most everywhere in Italy, the clubs play
American music (with the occasional Italian or Latin pop song), you would still not mistake the clubs
here for the ones in America. This is mostly based on the people in the clubs. In America, a man coming
up from behind me and grabbing me to trying to kiss me and get me to dance with him would be
abnormal. I have come to expect this in Italian clubs with pushing men off me and my friends being a
7
Over the course of the semester, there were only 3 weekends where I did not travel to another city
or country. My first weekend trips remained in Italy where I visited the Amalfi Coast, Sicily, and Venice.
what we did during our time there and experience the pieces of the culture that I was most interested in.
My favorite trip was by far to see my friend studying in St. Andrews. I loved the country, the people were
so incredibly friendly, and I got to see my friend who is always living abroad. At the end of the semester
there are many other places I wish I also had the time to visit, but I know that this is not the last or only
Keeping up on things back home mostly took the form of barely keeping up on the news and
staying in touch with my family and friends. Although I kept up on the main events happening in the
United States, I have not been keeping up as well as I should because I have been in some ways trying to
avoid all of the issues happening in the United States. The most common way I knew if something big
was happening, is when I would get a notification on my phone from the news app. Something I have
especially been current on was the election. Although I was willing to skim over other pieces of the news,
I knew that it was very important to me that I fulfill my civic duty of voting even while abroad. My
parents would also let me know when something big was happening or when important news to my
8
family would come in. I feel very fortunate to be studying abroad during a time where we have
technology like facetime where I can call up my family anytime they are awake and
see their faces. I call my mom at least twice a week but facetime with my family
closer to every other week. We have an ongoing group chat as well as a photo album
of my travels that I update for them that allows me to keep them updated about what
Although I did facetime my friends on occasion, the most common way I kept up
with them was through social media. Mostly through Instagram and Facebook I was
able to see what my friends were up to back home and send them messages when I
A small thing that I managed to keep up with very well all semester was the UW Football team.
American football is my favorite sport to watch so I would wake up at 3 or 4 in the morning just to watch
the game. Since I am still a student there, I wanted to feel included in the comradery that watching this
sport creates and wanted to watch my team succeed. Although I started to slack on watching games
further into the semester, I kept up on how each game went and what it meant for them making it to a
the greatest (if not the greatest) soccer players to ever live play in his home stadium. Barca is the team I
I have learned many new practices from my time in Florence that I would like to take home to
America. First of all, the pace of life here is much more relaxed and focused on the current moment rather
9
than the future. As a student living in a huge tech city, I am used to everyone being go-go-go all the time.
Even little things like taking time while eating and walking at a pace where you can enjoy the walk and
the views makes a huge difference for living in the moment. To add more to that point, I would also like
to continue to walk as my main form of transportation whenever possible and not shying away from
something just because I will have to walk a lot. I wish I could take all the food home with me, but I have
seen changes in the way food is treated here as an experience and thing to be shared. I think this is so
much better than the grab and go food habits Americans hold.
During this semester I have had the privilege to volunteer with a 5th grade class at Scuole Pie
Fiorentine. Visiting once a week, I worked with their teacher to teach the students English as well as how
my culture differs from theirs. Some weeks I simply assisted the teacher with the lesson she already had
planned and other weeks I gave a presentation on American customs of some kind or gave a presentation
on a grammar structure. Through this experience I have learned so much more about Italian culture and
values. Seeing how education works here, I am able to see how differently education is approached in
different countries and how values and ideals are instilled in children beginning early in their education.
Although an uncomfortable experience at times, this experience pushed me in my Italian abilities as well
as working across a language barrier in order to still be able to communicate and get my ideas across and
understand theirs.
My social life revolved entirely around GIF students and the new friends I had made within that
group. There are certain social aspects that are a given due to the nature of the program like living with
two dozen other students in my pensione as well as having class with the same students all semester.
These groups were the people I interacted with the most due to the mere effect of proximity. Although I
feel that I was included into many groups fairly quickly in the program, I still am not a Gonzaga or LMU
student so there was not my previous experience with anyone other than the one person I knew on the
program. Although I did not feel excluded for this reason, there are many people that I had no base for
getting to know them and never met throughout the course of the entire semester. I have made many
friends over the semester that I will be very sad to leave because I have grown so close to them over the
10
course of the semester. I already have plans to visit Spokane to see some of them and have made promises
to keep in touch with even more. Even though I know it is impossible to maintain all these friendships
forever, there are many more that I will be able to keep up with through social media.
Overall I have had mostly positive experiences with locals who bother to actually give me a
chance. Although those that only see me as a tourist usually interact with me with annoyance or
indifference, I have met a few who have treated me with consistent kindness and friendliness. The first of
these is the Italian student with whom me and a few classmates met with as a part of our Italian class. We
coming in so many times and actually bothered to try and remember my name. Although she often forgot,
she always greeted me with the recognition of the interactions we have had in the past and felt bad if she
had to ask for my name again. Finally, many gelato shop owners have come to recognize me and my
Experiencing beauty in Florence is easy because we are constantly surrounded by it. Especially
the layout of the city was planned. I will never get over the
of the Renaissance, the art in Florence is unparalleled. Although I only experienced a very small fraction
11
of all the art Florence has to offer, I was overwhelmed by the great cultural heritage this place holds and
how many pieces of absolute mastery are contained in this city. I especially thought highly of the pieces
in Piazza della Signoria that are pieces of immense cultural importance entrusted to be viewed and
protected by the people without ever having to pay for a ticket. And although not in the city of Florence,
what I would consider to be my happy place in Florence is Fiesole. I came here as a child so it holds
many memories for me, but it also has an incredible view of the city and is set in the beautiful Tuscan
hills.
Even though I have not interacted with a great deal of young Italians that I have actually had
conversations with, I have some idea of how they differ from Americans. A huge difference I have noted
is that they live at home for a much longer time than Americans do with Italians continuing to live with
their parents past graduating from college. They also then get married and start families much later in life.
Although individualistic like Americans, they are much more pessimistic and realistic about their futures
because of the lack of jobs available in Italy. In many ways they are similar to Americans as young adults,
especially because of America’s influence on the rest of the world, but live in and adhere to another
country’s culture. This goes along with some of the positives and negatives of Italy. The positives center
around the beautiful things the culture has to offer such as the art, food, landscape, and people. Another
positive is the approach to life that the Italians have. A big negative I would consider Italy to have is that
it is still a masculine-dominated culture so there is a lot of sexism ingrained in the culture. Another
negative I perceive is that Italians are very proud of their own culture to the point where they become
something that everyone wants to do and those that are luckily enough to
do so, make sure to tell every that asks about it. Gonzaga in Florence as a
interacting with the cultures, the nature of travelling so often for such short
12
amounts of time make it so that we cannot do much more than make sure we see and eat everything on
our bucket lists. A recent development to how my generation travels is that we more often base our
travels around where we are going to eat. I would also refer to my generation as the photo generation and
this definitely applies to the GIF group. No matter where we are, it takes longer to get anywhere because
people stop to take picture and so many of them. This is so bad to the point that students will not visit
places if they are not “Instagrammable.” Luckily, most all of Europe is beautiful in this regard.
Although I bonded well with so many students on the program, I know that they are in reality all
Americans and will be returning to the states after all of the program is through. Therefore the people that
because of their hospitality, I felt that I was actually able to call this place my home. Because they take
care of us and look after us in a way that makes us genuinely feel that they care for our well-being, I have
created a strong bond with them. Knowing that I have people that I really care about in Florence and I
know care about me makes me feel connected to the city and want to return in the future.
I have always felt a special connection to the city of Florence since this place was an important
part of my childhood. Although this bond still remains, it has changed with all of the new experiences I
have had during my study abroad. I now have even more memories and experiences of what a wonderful
city this is. Although I have not experienced all that this place has to offer, it will always be somewhere
that feels familiar and is still my home. Even though people come and go and friends change, the city of
13
Florence and the treasures it contains will not change unless some catastrophe occurs. I can always count
on the Duomo to impress me and the works of the great artists of the Renaissance to leave me in awe.
Knowing how much this place has meant to me past and present has solidified my bond to this great city.
This place has too much to offer and too many sweet memories for it not to be on my mind often.
My place in Florence falls into a role that has been well established over the years. Students
studying abroad have been coming to Florence for decades and there are thousands of us here at any
given time. Locals have come to expect us and come to expect us to behave in certain ways. American
culture and customs differ greatly from those of Italy creating a kind of friction and discomfort in many
interactions. Even so, many Florentine’s love that American students study abroad and greet us in their
shops and businesses with excitement. Although living here for over 3 months, I never felt that it was
totally my place to try to integrate myself into the community, but rather try to blend in as much as
possible knowing full well that I am still mostly a tourist. Especially since I mainly stayed in the comfort
of the Gonzaga community, I feel that my place was in Florence was very much dominated by my role as
a student. Being a student meant I got to experience this place alongside my academics and see the things
As the time has come to return home, I am filled with sadness to be leaving this place and
excitement to be be home once again. Although when first planning my flight home, I thought that I
Seattle for school. Although a bit down the road, I will be finishing up my final quarters at the University
14
of Washington before I graduate in June. This is a big part of my life I will be returning too that will be
I believe that I get to give as much value as is necessary to my study abroad. Although other
factors are in play, the most important aspect of this experience was personal growth and expanding my
worldview. Although others can judge this from an outside perspective, I am the only one who can truly
judge how well I have accomplished these things. In addition to the value I give it, other people will give
value to it in their perception of me. I think that many people view those who study abroad as returning
home more “cultured” than before. Although likely true, I think this glazes over many of the important
aspects of what we learn abroad. A piece of this also has to do with the fact that we are a
photograph-based generation, so we will give more value to people’s experience if we can see the cool
places they got to visit and experience. Finally, value can be given from a professional perspective. This
study abroad can be seen as a valuable experience in communicating across cultures and being able to
navigate far outside of my comfort zone. Studying abroad is something that I can add to my resume that
will give employers more information about me based on their own perception of a study abroad.
I would like to say that I have a plan of where I think I will realistically be 10 years from now, but
I have so many paths I am interested in following I am unsure of where I will end up. By the time I am
31, I expect that I will probably be married, or at least close to marriage, and beginning to think about
starting a family. I think that I will most likely be living in the United States, on the West coast, but also
like to entertain the idea of moving to Japan and entering the workforce there. My current goal for
employment is to be working in the field of urban design and likely with a private company. My dream
would be to work for one of the Disney parks working as a master planner to design the interior of the
parks. I hope that by this point in my life, I will have continued to travel the world and pursue my
Ten years from now I hope that I will look back on my study abroad experience with the same
fondness I view my time living abroad 10 years prior to now. I have heard many times that students who
study abroad get the “travel bug” and continue to travel as much as they can for the rest of their lives. I
15
really do enjoy travelling and hope that I will continue to have the freedom (and funds) in my life to
continue travelling and return to this place. I also hope that 10 years
from now I can look back on this time and realize how much I
just how much I have learned yet because I still haven’t returned to
my home country and seen just how much my own habits and
that it still holds the same special place in my heart and reminds me
wonderful program.
Thinking about myself as a person as well as a student studying abroad, I would describe myself
as a wanderer. Of the many places I have lived and visited I have found none that I feel that I truly fit
into. I have plenty of people that make me feel at home in my identity, but these tend to be few in a sea of
others. The piece of myself I feel is wandering and searching for belonging the most is in my ethnicity.
Being half white and half Japanese, I have found it difficult my entire life to find places where I could
express and live into my full identity without having to choose one half or the other. Part of why I came
on this trip was to continue to seek that belonging and understanding. Unfortunately, I feel that I did not
find any of this understanding I was searching for and if anything felt more confused. European heritage
is a part of my ethnicity as much as the Japanese part, but I have never felt connected to it because my
family’s European identity changed after the American revolution. Even though I am as white as
Japanese, I did not feel that I was able to relate to this part of my background because I know that I will
never be seen as being completely white. I kind of expected this, but I hoped that learning about more
cultures outside my own would help me to see how the differences in cultures can be bridged. Although
this did happen to an extent, I think it was ineffective because I was bridging the gap between the white
culture of America and the white culture of Europe. A little sad in the final result, but this has inspired me
16
to travel to Japan to see the difference in experiencing that culture to bridge the gap instead. Since being
biracial is a newer phenomenon and I come from two cultures that have underlying ideals about not
mixing blood, I understand that I may be wandering for a while before I truly find the place I feel that I
belong.
Nationality: American
Age: 21
Parents’ experience abroad (if they lived in another country, which country, for how long): My mother
went to high school in London, she also lived abroad in Singapore for a few years, and both my parents
lived here in Florence for 4 months while my mom was teaching for the program
Siblings’ experience abroad (if they lived in another country, which country, for how long): My younger
brother lived with all of us in Florence for 4 months while my mom was teaching for the program
Returning home (ex. vacations), when and for how long (approximately): December 20
Foreign countries that you visited (in all your life): Italy, France, England, Scotland, Spain, Czech
Republic, Mexico, and Canada
Foreign countries and cities where you lived for a while (ex. US, New York, 1 month; …): Florence, Italy,
4 months
Books you read (last year, max. 3): Frankenstein, Everybody Always, and Lord of the Rings
Movies you’ve seen at the theatre or at home (last year, max 3): 3 Billboards Outside Ebbings, Missouri,
Crazy Rich Asians, and Incredibles 2
Art galleries/exhibitions/museums visited (last year): (Pre-Europe) Henry Art Gallery, Wing Luke
Museum, Gould Court Gallery
Concerts (last year): Jon Bellion, Lewis del Mar, Penny and Sparrow
17
Participation to social-political events/manifestations (last year): Women’s March
All-time Top 3
Cities where you would like to live (Florence can be included): Los Angeles, Seattle, and Tokyo
Quotes (scholarly and non-scholarly, it does not matter): “Raise your words not your voice, it is rain that
grows flowers not thunder.” -Rumi, “Adventure is out there!” -Up, “Not all who wander are lost.” J.R.R.
Tolkien
Music (songs): Thunder-Penny and Sparrow, Can’t Help Falling in Love-Elvis, Feel It Still-Portugal. the
Man
Movies: Moulin Rouge, Star Wars: A New Hope, Crazy Rich Asians
Arts (fine, popular, any field): Wanderer Above the Sea of Fog-Caspar David Friedrich, Winged Victory
of Samothrace, Girl at the Window-Salvador Dali
Beauty (anything that meaning beauty to you): Glacier National Park, the Grand Canyon, Venice
18
Bibliography
Birindelli, P. (2017) American Cultural Experiences in Florence and Italy: Reality and Perpetuation
of a Myth, in P. Prebys and F. Ricciardelli (eds.) “A Tale of Two Cities: Florence and Rome from
the Grand Tour to Study Abroad”. Ferrara: Edisai, 47-63. ISBN: 9788896714416 / 8896714419
Zaruba, Sydney. “8 Must-Instagram Spots in Florence.” The Boho Traveller, 20 Oct. 2016,
www.bohotravel.org/2016/10/20/8-must-instagram-spots-florence/.
19