RUBRIC FOR SHORT STORY PRESENTATION

Criteria A+ A, A- B, B- C, D
(4) (3) (2) (1)

Summary of the Student thoroughly Student Student gave a brief Student gave an
Plot (25%) summarized five summarized the five summary of the unsatisfactory
essential parts of essential parts of plot and characters summary of the
plot. plot. in the story. story's plot.

Analysis of the Student identified Student identified Student identified six Student identified
Elements of the eight elements seven or less or less elements of five or less elements
Fiction (30%) of fiction and elements of fiction fiction but did not of fiction but did not
demonstrated and did demonstrate deep demonstrate deep
exceptional demonstrate comprehension. comprehension.
understanding. comprehension.
Shows a passable Shows an
Shows an excellent Shows a competent degree of unsatisfactory
degree of degree of understanding of degree of
understanding of understanding of ideas, concepts, and understanding of
ideas, concepts, and ideas, concepts, and information. ideas, concepts, and
information. information. information.

Communication Presents ideas and Presents ideas and Presents ideas and Presents ideas and
and information with information with information with information with
Organization excellent competent passable insufficient
(25%) effectiveness. effectiveness. effectiveness. effectiveness.
Introduction is Introduction is clear Organization is only Organization is
strong and inviting, and effective, body partly effective and lacking.
body is focused and is focused, and transitions are
clearly manipulated, closing assists in lacking. Uses academic
and closing is unifying the language
effective in unifying presentation. Uses academic appropriately with
the entire language insufficient
presentation. Uses academic appropriately with effectiveness.
language passable
Uses academic appropriately with effectiveness.
language competent
appropriately with effectiveness.
excellent
effectiveness.

Visual Aids/ Student's visual aids Student used visual Student used visual Student used visual
Powerpoint were excellent and aids that showed a aids to enhance the aids to enhance the
Presentation clearly good presentation, but presentation, but the
(20%) demonstrated understanding of could have presentations were
mastery of the the work and the developed them lacking in depth
assignment. concepts involved more. Errors in and understanding.
No grammar or in the work. grammar or Numerous errors in
punctuation errors. Minor grammar or punctuation grammar and
punctuation errors. detracted from punctuation.
powerpoint.
 PEER EVALUATION SHEET

Name: ______________________________________
Section: _____________________
Date: __________________________

This peer evaluation is for the short story presentation of your classmates. Please review the
rubric at the back of this page. Listen intently as your classmates do their presentation.
Afterwards, put the score that corresponds to your evaluation under each criterion,
4 being the highest, 1 being the lowest. Please be objective at all times.

The final grade will be composed of the following:

60% - from the teacher

40% - from your rating

GROUP Summary of Analysis of the Communication Powerpoint

the Plot Elements of and Presentation
Fiction Organization
Group 1 3 2 1 4
Group 2
Group 3
Group 4
Group 5
Group 6
Group 7
Group 8
Group 9
Group 10

SUMMARY TABLE

LETTER GRADE SCORE

A+ 16
A 14 to 15
A- 12 to 13
B 10 to 11
B- 8 to 9
C 6 to 7
D 4 to 5
 PEER EVALUATION SHEET

Name: ______________________________________
Section: _____________________
Date: __________________________

This peer evaluation is for the short story presentation of your classmates. Please review the
rubric at the back of this page. Listen intently as your classmates do their presentation.
Afterwards, check the box for that corresponds to the score you wish to give your classmates,
4 being the highest, 1 being the lowest. Please be objective at all times.

The final grade will be composed of the following:

60% - from the teacher

40% - from your rating

GROUP Summary of Analysis of the Communication Powerpoint

the Plot Elements of and Presentation
Fiction Organization
Group 1
Group 2
Group 3
Group 4
Group 5

SUMMARY TABLE

LETTER GRADE SCORE

A+ 16
A 14 to 15
A- 12 to 13
B 10 to 11
B- 8 to 9
C 6 to 7
D 4 to 5