Humans v/s Machines
Vikas Rajput
Tanmay Khandait
Mary’s Room
Experiment
Mary’s Room
Experiment
Intelligence
def.
the ability to learn from experience, solve
problems, and use knowledge to adapt to
new experiences.
Can a machine display general intelligence?
4
Dreyfus'
four assumptions of
Artificial intelligence research
5
The biological assumption
The brain processes information in
discrete operations by way of some
biological equivalent of on/off switches
Dreyfus refutes the biological assumption by citing
research in neurology that suggested that the
action and timing of neuron firing had analog
components
6
The psychological assumption
The mind can be viewed as a device
operating on bits of information
according to formal rules
Dreyfus refuted this assumption by showing that
much of what we "know" about the world consists
of complex attitudes or tendencies that make us
lean towards one interpretation over another.
7
The epistemological assumption
All knowledge can be formalized
Dreyfus argued that there was no justification for
this assumption, since so much of human
knowledge was not symbolic.
8
The ontological assumption
The world consists of independent
facts that can be represented by
independent symbols
Dreyfus calls this the ontological assumption
9
Intelligence Is Embodied
Does Intelligence require a body?
Can Intelligence only develop with the
aid of a body?
10
Alchemy and AI
Dreyfus in his paper “Alchemy and AI” flatly
ridiculed AI research, comparing it to
alchemy.
It ridiculed the grandiose predictions of
leading AI researchers, predicting that there
were limits beyond which AI would not
progress and intimating that those limits
would be reached soon
11
Computers
12
The Classical Paradigm of
Artificial Intelligence
● Symbolic AI had as its goal the
construction of intelligent computer
systems.
● The aim was a system that possessed
universal intelligence; that is, had a
universal ability to reason, solve
problems, understand language, and
carry out other intelligent tasks the way
an intelligent human adult could.
13
Symbolic AI assumes, as its principal
point of departure, that intelligence is
a matter of manipulating symbols
following fixed and formal rules
14
Expert System
● A computer system that emulates the decision-
making ability of a human expert.
● Expert systems are mainly built according to the
assumptions.
But they can’t exaclty replace Humans
because Humans employ rules in early
stages of learning, but in later stages
replace this with an intuitive and holistic
manner of problem solving.
15
Neural Networks & Deep Learning
● It rejects from the start the idea that
intelligent behavior springs from the
manipulation of symbols according to
formal rules.
● The neural network approach derives its
inspiration for the modeling of intelligent
processes not from the digital computer,
but from the structure and operation of the
human brain
16
AlphaGo (Google’s Deep Mind)
● Go is an abstract strategy board game for two players.
● Players take turns to place black or white stones on a
board, trying to capture the opponent's stones or
surround empty space to make points of territory.
There are
1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 possible
positions—that’s more than the number of atoms in the universe,
and more than a googol times larger than chess.
17
AlphaGo defeated Fan
Hui(three-time European Go
champion) by 5 games to 0.
18
Unanswered Questions
● Can a machine have emotions?
● Can a machine be self-aware?
● Can a machine be original or creative?
● Can a machine be benevolent or
hostile?
● Can a machine have a soul?
19
Food for thought
Consider a scenario where you met a
new person and interact with him/her
for few days. You really like this
person. But then you find out that this
person is not a human but a machine.
How will you respond? Will you treat
that person/machine differently? And
Why would you treat that
person/machine differently?
20
