Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Concise Oxford Dictionary defines ‘conscience’ as our ‘moral sense of right
and wrong’ especially as felt by a person and affecting behaviour or an inner feeling as
to the goodness or otherwise of one’s behaviour. On the subject of our moral conscience
the philosopher John Fiske observed that ‘We approve of certain actions and disapprove
of certain actions quite instinctively. We shrink from stealing or lying as we shrink from
burning our fingers’.
Pope John Paul II tells us that conscience is an “interior dialog of man with himself”
about right and wrong. It “is also a dialog of man with God”: it is “the witness of God
himself” calling him to obey the moral law, and is a person’s “witness of his own
faithfulness or unfaithfulness.” This is the basis of the great dignity of the conscience: it
derives from its witness to objective moral truth. Conscience is awareness of God’s call
to know and to do good. Conscience is a basic awareness of good and evil. “Always
summoning him to do good and avoid evil, the voice of conscience can when necessary
speak to his heart more specifically: ‘do this, shun that’ (John)
1
I. CONSCIENCE IS THE VOICE OF GOD
Most people would agree that conscience is the reasoned voice inside us that
guides and tells us what we should and shouldn’t do. However people’s views on the
origins of conscience can differ a lot; whether people belief if it’s Gods doing or whether
it’s innate or even whether it is acquired. Ultimately, conscience is not the voice of God.
However, John Henry Newman believed that conscience was the voice of God, and that
following the suggestions of your conscience gives the same significance as to follow
God’s laws and values. He believed conscience can make mistakes if it not provided with
all necessary information when making decisions.
Thomas Aquinas saw conscience as 'right reason '. For him, reason was
fundamental to the moral life and to understanding the differences in the middle of right
and off-base. He did not concur that the conscience was an inner voice telling us what is
right and what is wrong, he believed that it was 'reason making right decisions ' and used
effectively it helps us to understand what God sees as great and right. His belief was that
individuals attempt to do great and avoid evil, called the Synderesis rule. In all situations
our subconscious actions are to do great, then again he said that because of faulty
reasoning of will some individuals perform awful actions thinking that they are great, and
therefore commit sinful acts (for instance a man who commits infidelity). Aquinas said
that conscience, when correctly applied, will also lead us to discover the natural moral
law within human nature. Reason moves from knowledge of very general precepts to
more specific secondary precepts. Developing our conscience is about acquiring, through
repeated actions, for example, an honest person becomes honest through continuously
repeating honest actions as Aquinas believed that practice makes it perfect. Aquinas said
that most people would generally say conscience is separated: moral codes are set by
God and humans work out how to follow them.
Another philosopher who believed that conscience was the voice of God was
Joseph Butler, an Anglican Bishop. For Butler there are two basic principles of human
influence: self-love and benevolence. Conscience is the balancing force of these two
influences; it directs us towards the interests of others and away from ourselves. Like
Aquinas, Butler argued that we have been made in the image of God with the ability to
reason. Conscience is based on moral reason - a component of the conscious mind. It is
innately God-given and gives us the capacity to make our own decisions based on Gods
influence.
Conscience is something that is intrinsic to our regular lives. The origin and part
of the conscience is something that divides individuals and something that has been used
to justify some exceptionally terrible acts, approaches to conscience change, including
numerous religions who claim that it is God given. This is the belief that either at
conception God gave every person a conscience or that it is imparted to us at some stage
to empower us to discern morally right and incorrect actions.
2
II. THE MORAL PRINCIPLE OF CONSCIENCE AND WISDOM
Throughout the life of a human being the conscious is being formed; as a child an
individual learns the basic moral rules, such as, “do not steal” and through formal
education they gain the wisdom to abide by certain virtues, rather than their vices. The
Catechism continues by stating, “the conscience must be informed and moral judgement
enlightened. A well-formed upright and truthful.” Without the possession of an informed
conscience human beings are liable to give into their temptations, which are based on
their own judgements, not the judgement of their conscience. The contributing factor to
the formation of the conscience is the involvement of God. It is through the maintenance
of an uninformed conscience that persons believe that as long as the behaviour performed
does not hurt anyone else it is morally acceptable.
3
IV. ELEMENTS OF CONSCINCE DESERVE PROTECTION FROM LEGAL
PERSPECTIVE
Conscience is a person's considered and sincere judgment about right and wrong,
and an enlightened constitutional regime would try to protect it from regulation (Steven D.
Smith). ‘Conscience’ is sometimes talked about as if it were just a ‘feeling,’ or ‘sense,’
about what a person thinks is important, or wants to do. I don't think this is quite right.
‘Conscience’ is an intellectual faculty, a kind of capacity, to identify what ought to be done
(because it is good) or what should not be done (because it is wrong). ‘Conscience’ is not
a personal power to define or determine what is right and wrong, but is instead the
capacity to appreciate, to realize, what is actually right and wrong (Richard W. Garnett).
Conscience is the dimension of the intellect that guides an individual to choose truth over
falsehood, right over wrong, good over evil. So as long as it is understood as an aspect
of human choice that is ordered to objective truth—i.e., as more than the modern
understanding of conscience, which is too often “doing what I want to do because I really
want to do it”—conscience deserves the protections provided in the Bill of Rights. Because
of the First Amendment, the American constitution privileges protection of the religious
conscience over other forms. If that is to change, it should be done via democratic means,
not by judicial fiat. (Thomas F. Farr).
According to Marc O. DeGirolami, Conscience is a difficult term to define for legal
purposes, making it an equally complicated affair to know what does and does not
deserve protection. At the very least, we might say that a person who acts from
conscience acts on the basis of some deeply held moral conviction. ‘Morality’ seems
especially important here—the basis for the behavior must be ethically motivated in order
to be described as conscience-based. If it is based in pragmatic judgment, then it is not
conscience-based. The trouble with this description is exactly that it makes our
understanding of what morality is the touchstone of what conscience is. And then there
is the issue of describing the reason that a state ought to defer in some circumstances—
which ones?—to individual claims of conscience.
The first problem is one of meta-ethics—how would one describe the nature of a
‘moral’ objection to, say, mandatory conscription in the army? How we describe the
nature of that objection, and what we feel counts as a conscience objection, is very
difficult. The second problem relates to political philosophy—the issue is why a state
should care about conscience objections. And one might give pragmatic as well as
principles reasons that a state might care.
A person’s conscience can be thought of as an internal moral guide. To say that
someone has a conscience is to say that: (1) the person has deeply held moral beliefs.
(2) The person’s decisions and actions generally are consistent with her deeply held moral
beliefs (Mark R. Wicclair).
4
V. AN INDIVIDUAL’S MORAL CONSCIENCE
Righteousness Majority of man’s belief creates laws to govern and protect the
people, but an individual’s own belief can do just as much while staying true to justice.
In the play Antigone by Sophocles, shows the confliction of both an individual and
majority’s moral conscience through the rightness of justice. The citizens of Thebes seeks
justice for their past king, but others respect the law and deny his burial. As time forwards
there are changes, but law is at a standstill and can only change if the majority chooses
to do so. An individual’s moral conscience changes and develops the moment that
individual is born, so the justice they strive for is more modern and thoughtful. The
characters from Antigone try to achieve justice by their own belief or by the law and in
result true justice becomes far from reach. As a king, Creon guides and conducts his
people by the law in order to protect, he would throw human morals away for the greater
good. As a single individual, Antigone thinks by her own belief and creates her own form
of justice. The more they progress towards their justice, the conflict between each other
starts to form because of how their justice diverges from basic justice. For Creon and
Antigone, their justice cannot coincide with each other due to human morals and
relationships will not change this fact. The characters must either fight for the justice
they believe in or give up on trying to do so.
5
image. People respect a company that makes ethical choices. Customers like doing
business with an organization that they can trust.
Magisterium. The Catholic faith tells one that if one follows the Church’s teachings
on moral issues, one will become a more loving and Christ- like person. A Catholic has a
responsibility to pay attention to what the church teaches and take into consideration
how this will affect our relationships with God. When one solves a problem through
magisterium, one must solve this problem with humility. This means that one can admit
that they need help, and turn to the Catechism of the Catholic Church to help solve the
problem. When one does this, it is difficult to admit to God and the Church that one needs
help.
Scripture is the teachings of God and Jesus in the bible. Scripture helps to solve
problems because it reminds one of the moral problems Jesus faced. The teachings of
scripture have set guidelines on how a person may solve a problem. This helps one to
analyze their own problems and relate them to the teachings of Jesus, God and the bible.
The Scripture teaches one what to do in a Christ- like way.
Tradition sometimes makes it difficult for a person to solve a problem through
magisterium and scripture. Tradition is the way the world around us is and a person is
often influenced by their society. When one is faced with moral dilemma and the decision
is based on tradition, it can make us further away from God. These decisions are normally
based on family and friends doing the same thing, and one may feel that they should do
something, because everyone else is.
Magisterium, Scripture and Tradition are the three important components that we
take into consideration when facing a problem. They shape and develop ones conscience.
6
The prudent choice of a course of action in conformity with the judgment and Man is
obliged to follow faithfully what he knows to be just and right.
CONCLUSIONS
7
Today, we have encounter different perspectives or understanding of human
conscience. Even it differ a lot, it makes them the same in many things. The intentions,
purpose and the foundation where it came – God.
Forming our human conscience is part of our journey. It is important to make a
judgment before doing an action in order to avoid regrets and the feeling of guilt.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
https://www.123helpme.com/common-understanding-of-the-human-conscience-
preview.asp?id=755169
https://www.humancondition.com/conscience/
https://www.cram.com/essay/Ethics-Human-Conscience-Morals-And-Good-
Will/PKBZBRXKGYKQ
https://www.cram.com/essay/An-Individual-s-Moral-
Conscience/P35UYCHF2BXZQ
https://www.cram.com/essay/Conscience-Is-The-Voice-Of-God/F37Z663XJ
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/philosophy/defining-the-moral-conscience-
philosophy-essay.php