You are on page 1of 185

MOC Approach for

Open Cooling Water System


Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air SM

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 1
Agenda

• Mechanical
– Cooling tower
– Heat exchanger
– Metallurgy

• Operation
– pH
– Cycle

• Chemical

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 2
Only if you understand the ‘basic principles,’ you
can solve the difficult and complex problems

Dr. M.S. Willis Ph.D., Thermodynamic and Transport Phenomena, 1974

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 3
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 4
Cooling Tower
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air SM

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 5
Why cooling is important?

• Cooling tower performance provide significant


contribution to the plant performance and efficiency

• Poor cooling tower performance could limit the plant


production

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 6
Cooling Tower
What We Need to Know ?

• How it works
• Type of cooling tower
• Major components and impact
• Performance monitoring

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 7
Cooling Tower – Why Important?

• A loss of 2.8 degrees C in


approach to wet bulb
temperature will result in
a 10-15% loss in cooling
load.
– Tower
o
water increase of
0.56 C = 2% increase in
energy use.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 8
Function of Cooling Towers

• Remove heat from process operation

• Mostly by evaporation (80%)


– partially by sensible heat loss (20%)
• contact of hot water with cooler air

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 9
Cooling Tower Process

• As ambient air is drawn past a


flow of water, a small portion of
the water evaporate. The energy
released by water for
evaporation reduces the
remaining water temperature

• Evaporation results in saturated


air conditions and lowers the
temperature of the water to a
value close to wet bulb air
temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 10
Types of Cooling Towers

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 11
Crossflow Cooling Tower

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 12
Counterflow Cooling Tower

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 13
Cooling Tower Fill

• Purposes of Tower Fills


– Increases the water surface
area for air contact
– Increases contact time

• Main Types of Fill


– Splash Fill
– Film Fill

Tower Fill
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air
SM
14
14
Splash Bar and Film Fill

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 15
Fill Characteristics

SPLASH FILM

EFFICIENCY Medium High

DURABILITY Medium Low/Medium

FOULING Low High

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 16
Problems with Film Fill

• Easily fouled with


microbio and solids

• Hard to clean once


fouled

• Quick loss of
efficiency

Tower Fill
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air
SM
17
Factors Affecting Cooling Tower Performance

• Wet bulb temperature


• Dry bulb temperature
• Plant (heat) load
– Cooling water ∆T
• Cooling water flow
– No of pump running
• Air flow
– Fan (tip, angle, motor; etc)
• Cooling water distribution
– Distribution system
– Fill cleanliness

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 18
Wet Bulb Temperature Measurement

Sling Psychrometer

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 19
Temperature Range and Approach

Note: typically 2.8 0C to design wet bulb is the coldest water temperature
that cooling tower manufacturer guarantee

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 20
Air Flow Issue

• Air flow is a critical component to


Air Recycling
(Incorrect Tip)
ensuring the proper heat
rejection from a cooling system

• Many cooling tower performance


issues may well be airflow
problems

ROTATION
Air In-leakage
From Fan Shaft Fan Stall
(Incorrect Pitch)

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 21
21
Liquid to Gas Ratio

• L/G = Liquid to Gas Ratio


– L = cw mass flow
– G = air mass flow

• The higher it is, the worst


tower perform or

• Typical range 1 – 2.5


– L/G < 1: tower oversized
– L/G > 2.5: tower undersized

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 22
What is the Correct Way to
Evaluate Cooling Tower Performance ?

1) CW temperature range (∆T)

2) Cooling tower heat load


• M x Cp x ∆T

3) CW supply temperature

4) Approach temperature

5) Evaporation rate

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 23
Performance Monitoring – Cooling Tower

GPSA Nomograph:
(require ∆T& wet bulb
temperatures)

Performance Factor proportional to:

• L/G ratio (L = CW flow, G = air


flow both in kg/hr)
• RR (or L)
• 1/(Fan Power)1/3

Performance Factor > design means


performance deteriorated

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 24
Summary of Factors Affecting Operation

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 25
Heat Exchanger
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air SM

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 26
Why is This Important?

• A critical component of the cooling system


– Directly affect production and product quality
– Fouled exchangers decrease throughput and capacity
– Leaking exchangers can force unscheduled shutdown

• Also affect water treatment options


– product selection and control limits

Water Distribution System


SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 27
27
Heat Exchanger
What We Need to Know ?

• Type of heat exchangers


• Hydraulic, mechanical and
metallurgical
• Mechanical stress to cooling water
treatment
• Performance monitoring

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 28
Type of Heat Exchangers

There are several general types of heat exchangers:

• Shell-and-tube

• Plate-and-frame

• Spiral flow

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 29
29
Heat Transfer Principle

Process In

Warm Chilled BTU's


Cold Chilled
Water In Water Out

Process Out

Open recirculating systems work on the basis


of two principles...
Ä Evaporation in Cooling Tower
Ä Heat transfer in heat exchangers
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 30
Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger (Water in Tube)

• Most common heat


exchanger type found
in cooling water
system

• Typically has
adequate velocity
– Throttle and spatial
relationship could
create problem

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 31
A shell side heat exchanger offers challenges

• Low velocity
• High skin temperatures

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 32
Mechanical “Stresses”

Three main mechanical stress factors that impact the


efficiency of heat transfer in heat exchanger are:

1) Cooling Water Velocity

2) Skin Temperature

3) Heat Flux

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 33
33
Cooling Water Velocity Stress Range
Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability > 1 m/s
Moderate Stress Needs to be considered 0.6-1 m/s
High Stress Will typically be a problem 0.3-0.6 m/s
Severe Stress Typically a problem < 0.3 m/s

• Scale and fouling deposition is more prone to occur at low


velocity

• Lower flow rate, lower turbulence that can lead to static


thicker film of water at metal surfaces à reduces heat
transfer

• Lower velocity = higher skin temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 34
34
Heat Flux Stress Range

Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability < 7.5 kW/m2


Moderate Stress Needs to be considered 7.5-25 kW/m2
High Stress Will typically be a problem 25-40 kW/m2
Severe Stress Typically a problem > 40 kW/m2

• High heat flux will lead to high skin temperature

• Typically
v 3.15 – 15.8 kW/ M2 : mild steel
v 15.8 – 31.5 kW/ M2 : alloy
v 31.5 – 63.1 kW/M2 : copper or stainless steel

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 35
35
Skin Temperature Stress Range

Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability < 500C


Moderate Stress Needs to be considered 50 - 600C
High Stress Will typically be a problem 60 - 700C
Severe Stress Typically a problem > 700C

• Reasons:
– Corrosion rates ~double for each 10°C increase in metal
temperature
– Scaling tendencies become much more pronounced at high
temperature
– Film boiling may occur as skin temperature
– Some treatment chemicals break down at high temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 36
36
Other Important Mechanical Factors

1) Spatial Relationship

2) Metallurgy

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 37
37
Spatial Relationship and CW Distribution

115C
108C 146C

101J
Coolers
128C 2nd
116C
3rd
1st
124C

101JC 2002JC
127C

Primary Cooling Water Header Tertiary Cooling Water Header


Secondary Cooling Water Header Cooling Water Return Header

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 38
Spatial Relationship

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 39
Metallurgy
– Copper alloys
• High thermal conductivity
• Sensitive to ammonia and oxidant
• Need film forming inhibitor
– Titanium
• Self passivating metal Ammonia
• Extremely brittle with very thin walls Grooving
• Leaks common (especially during initial
commissioning and startup)
• ANY mechanical impingement can cause leaks
– Stainless Steel
• Self passivating metal Under Deposit
• Subject to chloride stress corrosion Corrosion / MIC
• Must ensure cooling water chloride level
remains within limits
• Under-deposit corrosion, MIC issues
Pitting / MIC

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 40
Chloride and Stainless Steel

PLANT DATA

Duty 3,286,000 Btu/hr


Area 424 ft2
Btu/hr.ft2
U 91.2 .C
Heat Flux 7750 Btu/hr.ft2
Velocity 6.111 ft/s
T CW in 91 F
T CW Out 100 F
Process In 637 F
Process Out 300 F

CALCULATIO
N
T Skin 106.34 F
41.3 C
Max T Skin 146 F
62 C

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 41
Importance of Heat Exchanger Monitoring

Ø Prevent the loss of process cooling


Ø Predict Onset of Problems
Ø Potential Surprises - scaled exchanger
Ø Loss of production

Ø Useful to troubleshoot problems


Ø Methodology using appropriate data
Ø Documentation

Heat Exchanger SMTraining


Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 42
42
Heat Exchanger Monitoring

• Approach Temperature
– Generally could represent HE performance
– Approach = T Process Exit – T Cooling Water Inlet
(counter current)

• Terminal Temperature Difference (TTD)


– Represent surface condenser performance
– TTD = T Condensing – T Cooling Water Outlet
– Typically 3-60C

• Others: C Factor, U Value, Fouling Factor; etc

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 43
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 44
Cooling Water Operation
What We Need to Know ?

• Basic mass balance calculation


• Cycle management
• Operational stress factor

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 45
SYSTEM SUMMARY

System Summary
Customer : PT.ECOGREEN OLEOCHEMICAL
Evaporation Efficiency 85 % Location : MEDAN PLANT
Evaporation Rate 8.01 m3/hr System : ICW

Return Temperature 38 C

Heat Source

Heat Load 5280000 Kcal/hr


Cycles 1.7
Corrosion Scale Delta T 8 C
Holding Time Index 27.24 hr
Tower pH 8
Make up Tower Ca 27.2 ppm Ca as CaCO3 Blow Down 11.45 m3/hr
19.53 m3/hr Tower Alkalinity 121.96 ppm HCO3- as CaCO3 Drift & Leak 0.07 m3/hr
Microbio Rate

System Volume 450 m3 Recirculating Rate 660 m3/hr

Basin Temperature 30 C

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 46
Cooling Tower Mass Balance

Drift Evaporation

Windage Windage

Makeup Cycled Water Blowdown

Leaks Loss

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 47
47
Evaporation

- Process by which hot water returns from the unit heat


exchangers, releases it’s heat to the atmosphere, is cooled, and
returns back to the process.

- Each 10°F [6°C] drop in temperature results in an average


0.85% of recirculated cooling water evaporated.

ER = (RR)*(•T/6)*(0.85%)

Where:
– ER : Evaporation Rate [gpm]
– RR : Recirculation Rate [gpm]
– •T : Temp drop across tower [Deg C]

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 48
Temperature Range or Delta T (∆T)

Temperature Difference Between Water Entering the


Cooling Tower and Water in
the Tower Basin

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 49
Concentration of Dissolved Solids

• Only pure water can evaporate


• No dissolved solids leave the liquid water
• If there are no other water losses from the system,
the evaporation process causes an increase in the
concentration of dissolved solids in the
recirculating cooling water. Constant
Evaporation
6
5
4
3
2
1

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 50
Blow Down and Cycle
• Blow down – portion of the water ejected or drained from a
system to control solids in cooling water

• Cycle – number of times that dissolved minerals in cooling


water are allowed to concentrate. Cycle is controlled by
blowdown

• Cycle = Dissolved Solids Concentration in Cooling Water


Dissolved Solids Concentration in M-Up

• In general, the cycle of concentration allowed depends on both


the level of solids in the make-up and the level of solids that
can be tolerated in cooling water

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 51
Blowdown to Reduce Cycles

1000 ml 500 ml Cycles = 125/100


150 umhos 150 umhos = 1.25 Cycles

500 ml 500 ml 1000 ml


150 umhos 100 umhos 125 umhos

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 52
Makeup Water

• Amount of water required to replace water lost by


evaporation and blowdown

MU = (ER x CR)/(CR – 1) Evaporation

Makeup
Makeup = Evaporation +
Blowdown

Blowdown

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 53
Holding Time Index (HTI)

• HTI is indicate the time required to


reduce the chemical added to the
system to 50% of its original
concentration 10
9

Concentration (ppm)
8
• HTI = 0.693 x Holding Volume 7
Blowdown Rate 6 T½ = 60 hours
5
4
• It is important to select the right
3
chemical program
2
1
0
0 24 48 72 96 120
Time (hours)

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 54
Basic Cooling Tower Calculations

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 55
55
Operational “Stresses”

Variation of operational and control parameters also


cause stress in cooling water system. The key
examples of operational stresses as follows

1) Variation of cycle

2) Variation of pH

3) Variation of HTI

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 56
56
Variation of Cycle

Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability <20%


Moderate Stress Needs to be considered 20-50%
High Stress Will typically be a problem 50-80%
Severe Stress Typically a problem > 80%

% Out of Spec
Low High Total
17.7% 5.3% 23.0%

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 57
Variation of pH

Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability + 0.1


Moderate Stress Needs to be considered + 0.2
High Stress Will typically be a problem + 0.4
Severe Stress Typically a problem + 0.6

Control Lower Upper Statistical Calculations


Parameter Spec Spec LCL Mean UCL STD
pH 7.50 8.00 7.16 7.72 8.28 0.19

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 58
Cycle and pH – Operating Window

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 59
Variation of HTI

Mild Stress Minimal effect of reliability < 40 hrs


Moderate Stress Needs to be considered 40 - 100 hrs
High Stress Will typically be a problem 100 - 200 hrs
Severe Stress Typically a problem > 200 hrs

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 60
Cycle Management

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 61
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 62
Main Problems in Cooling Water Operation
Related to Water Treatment
There are basically four inter-related problems in the operation of a
cooling water system as depicted by the Cooling Water Treatment
Triangle below. Each problem affects and is affected by the other
problems.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 63
Corrosion

• A natural process converting


processed metals to their
native states

• Factors affecting:
- Water chemistry
- Physical environment
(temperature, velocity,
hydrodynamic)
- Dissolved gases
- Halogen or other oxidizers
- Deposit

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 64
Consequences of Corrosion

• Reduced Heat Transfer (Lost Efficiency)

• Increased Cleaning (Added Costs and


Hassle)

• Equipment Repair and Replacement


(Lost Revenue)

• Process or Water-Side Contamination


(Poor Product Quality)

• Unscheduled Shutdown (Lost Revenue)

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 65
Corrosion Mechanism

Corrosion:
An electrochemical process in which a metal in it’s elemental
form returns to it’s native (i.e., oxidized) state.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 66
“Corrosion Never Sleep”

©2003 Brooks/Cole, a division of Thomson Learning, Inc. Thomson Learning™ is a trademark used herein under license.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 67
Types of Corrosion

1. General (uniform)

2. Localized Corrosion

3. Stress Corrosion Cracking

4. Corrosion Related to
Mechanical Factors

5. Corrosion Related to
Materials

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 68
General Corrosion

• The most common form of corrosion experienced in


industry

• Metal loss in which a given area is alternately a


cathode and an anode. Metal loss occurs uniformly
over the entire surface.

• The least dangerous and most easily prevented form


of corrosion.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 69
Localized Corrosion

• Tuberculation

• Pitting Corrosion

• Oxygen Corrosion

• Under Deposit Corrosion

• Acid Corrosion

• Alkaline Corrosion

• Crevice Corrosion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 70
Localized Corrosion
Tuberculation
• Tubercles are mounds of corrosion
product and deposit that cap
localized regions of metal loss

• Tubercles form on steel and cast


iron when surfaces are exposed to
oxygenated waters, as do as do
high concentrations of sulfate,
chloride, other aggressive anions
and biological interactions (SRB;
etc)

• Location:
– Service water system piping, w
water boxes, storage tanks; et

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 71
Tuberculation
Iron Deposition Structures

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 72
Localized Corrosion
Pitting
• Extremely localized corrosive attack
• Usually occur under deposit
• But also can happen in clean metal surfaces in high
concentration of aggressive ions (chloride, sulfate; etc)

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 73
Localized Corrosion
Under Deposit Corrosion

• Localized Corrosion occurs under the deposit

• Deposits can cause corrosion both directly and


indirectly.
– Directly: deposits contain corrosive substances
– Indirectly: shielding of surfaces below deposits produces
indirect attack (concentration cell)

• Concentration cell mechanisms


– Different Aeration Cell
– Different Ion Concentration Cell

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 74
Localized Corrosion
Concentration Cell Mechanism

Different Ion Concentration Cell

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 75
Localized Corrosion
Crevice Corrosion

• Crevice corrosion is a
localized form of corrosion
usually associated with a
stagnant solution on the
microenvironmental level

• Stagnant microenvironments
tend to occur in crevices
(shielded areas) such as
those formed under gaskets,
insulation materials, coating,
surface deposits; etc

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 76
Localized Corrosion
Crevice Corrosion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 77
Stress Corrosion Cracking

• Cracking resulting from a


synergistic interaction of a
tensile stress and a specific
corrodent to which metal
sensitive

• Concentrating mechanism
of corrodent (mainly
chloride for stainless steel)
that occur in under deposit
enhance the corrosion
process

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 78
Stress Corrosion Cracking
Temperature & Chloride Concentration

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 79
Factors Influencing Corrosion
Mechanical, Operation and Chemistry
• Mechanical Stress
– Metallurgy
– Temperature
– Velocity
– Hydrodynamic and Spatial Relation

• Operational Stress
– Variation of pH, cycle and HTI

• Chemical Stress
– Water quality
• pH
• Conductivity
• Aggressive ions (Cl, SO4)
• Hardness and alkalinity
• Dissolved gases
• Oxidants
– Inhibitor capability
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 80
Mechanical:
Temperature and Velocity Impact to Corrosion

Temperature Velocity

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 81
Mechanical Stress and Impact to Scale

• Skin Temperature
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability < 48 deg C
Moderate Needs to be Considered 48-60 deg C
High W ill Typically be a problem 60-70 deg C
Severe Typically a problem >70 deg C

• CW Velocity
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability 0.9-1.8 mps
Moderate Needs to be Considered 0.6-0.9 mps/1.8-3.65 mps
High Will Typically be a problem 0.3-0.6/>3.65 mps
Severe Typically a problem <0.3 mps

• Heat Flux
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability < 6780 KCal/hr-m2
Moderate Needs to be Considered >6780 < 20338 KCal/hr-m2
High Will Typically be a problem >20338 < 33896 KCal/hr-m2
Severe Typically a problem >33896 KCal/hr-m2

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 82
Operational Stress and Impact to Corrosion

Operational Stress Level Impact of Variation


Stress High Side Low Side

Variation of Cycle of • Mild < 20% Increases potential of Low Ca and Alkalinity
Concentration • Moderate 20-50% corrosion potential on could lead to high
• High 50-60% stainless steel as corrosion
chloride increase
• Severe > 80%
Variation of pH • Mild + 0.1 unit - Increase potential for
• Moderate + 0.2 units corrosion
• High + 0.4 units
• Severe + 0.6 units
Variation of Holding • Mild < 40 hrs • Increases potential -
Time Index (HTI) • Moderate 40 – 100 hrs for inhibitor
• High 100 – 20 hrs degradation
• Severe > 200 hrs • Increases potential
for deposition and
under deposit
corrosion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 83
Chemical:
Conductivity and pH Impact to Corrosion
Conductivity pH

Its not linear


because it also
depend on ionic
species

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 84
Chemical: Make-Up Water Quality

• Make-up water quality


– Source: river, sea water, brackish, swamp water, deep
well, recycle
• Variability is important !
Parameter Unit Jan-March April-June July-Sept Oct-Dec

pH - 7.80 8.00 8.30 7.60


Ca-Hardness ppm CaCO3 242.00 264.00 286.00 220.00
Mg-Hardness ppm CaCO3 99.00 108.00 117.00 90.00
M-Alkalinity ppm CaCO3 93.50 102.00 110.50 85.00
Sulfate ppm SO4 66.00 72.00 78.00 60.00

Chloride ppm Cl 88.00 96.00 104.00 80.00


Silica ppm SiO2 22.00 24.00 26.00 20.00

Aluminum ppm Al 0.11 0.12 0.13 0.10


Manganese ppm Mn 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.05
Total Iron ppm Fe 0.11 0.12 0.13 0.10
Conductivity µS/cm 572.00 624.00 676.00 520.00
Turbidity NTU 3.20 3.40 2.50 3.60

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 85
Corrosion Prevention Methods

• Use corrosion resistant


materials
– Copper, stainless steel,
titanium, FRP; etc

• Apply Inert Barrier or


Coating
– Organics, metallics; etc

• Use Sacrificial anode/


cathodic Protection

• Adjustments to Water
Chemistry
– pH, conductivity, and
alkalinity

• Corrosion Inhibitors
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 86
Corrosion Inhibitor Classification

• Anodic Inhibitor
– Chromate
– Nitrite
– Orthophosphate
– Bicarbonate
– Silicate
– Molybdate

• Cathodic Inhibitor
– Carbonate
– Polyphosphate
– Zinc

• Film forming inhibitors/ Organic Inhibitors

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 87
Mild Steel Corrosion Protection

Water - Conductive Media

Worse with High Conductivity


O2
CaCO3
O2 Ca-PO4
Fe-PO4, Fe-OrgPO4, Fe-MoO4,
etc
FeOOH Zn(OH)2
Ca-HEDP
No electron flow
Electron
Insulator
Anodic Inhibitor Cathodic Inhibitor

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 88
Corrosion Inhibitors – Cathodic & Anodic

Cathodic inhibition
Prevents the transfer of electrons à
prevent the reduction of oxygen.

Anodic inhibition
prevents the dissolution of the base metal,
iron.

• Combinations of both anodic and cathodic inhibitors generally provide the best
protection.

• These combinations are called “synergistic” because the combination provides


lower corrosion rates than either inhibitor could alone,

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 89
Film Forming/Organic Inhibitor

• Organic materials that form and


maintain barrier between the
water & metal phases to
prevent corrosion

• Should be injected continuously


to prevent small break of the
film

• Azoles compounds (TT,BZT,


MBT) for copper metallurgy

• Soluble Oil for closed cooling


water with low conductivity
requirement

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 90
Copper Corrosion Protection

O2

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 91
Corrosion Inhibitor Feed and Control

• Conventional method
– Continuous feed
– Routine testing of inhibitor
residual

• Automation
– Chemical feed is adjusted
automatically based on actual
(real time) inhibitor level in the
system
– Nalco 3D TRASAR Technology

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 92
General Methods for
Corrosion Inhibition

• Use Corrosion Resistant Materials

• Apply Inert Barrier or Coating

• Use Cathodic Protection

• Adjustments to Water Chemistry

• Application of Corrosion Inhibitors

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 93
mpy

0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3/20/03
3/25/03
3/30/03
4/4/03
4/9/03
4/14/03
4/19/03
4/24/03
4/29/03
5/4/03
XLP-170/N-23263

5/9/03
5/14/03
ManualManual

5/19/03
Control

5/24/03
Control

5/29/03
6/3/03
6/8/03
6/13/03
6/18/03
6/23/03
6/28/03
7/3/03
7/8/03

Date

Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air


7/13/03
Corrosion Rates

SM
7/18/03
7/23/03
7/28/03
8/2/03
8/7/03
Slaved
Control

8/12/03
8/17/03
8/22/03
8/27/03
9/1/03
9/6/03
N-23263 Trasar Control/ XLP-170 Slaved
3D TRASAR Corrosion Control

9/11/03
9/16/03
9/21/03
9/26/03
10/1/03
10/6/03
3DT Automation Control

10/11/03
N-73292 Tagged Control/ N-73284 Trasar Control

10/16/03
10/21/03
10/26/03
94
Corrosion Control Program Monitoring

• Corrosion rate
– Coupon
– On line corrosion meter

• Corrosion products
– Total Iron
– Copper

• Eddy current test

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 95
Corrosion Rate Monitoring and Classification

Note: monitor by using corrosion coupon

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 96
Scale

• A dense, adherent layer of


minerals tightly bound to
itself and to metal surface

• Factors influences
- pH
- Minerals concentration (Ca,
Mg, SiO2, Alkalinity;etc)
- Temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 97
Scale vs. Deposits/Fouling

• Scales from mineral • Deposits/Fouling from


suspended matter:
precipitation:
“water borne”
“water formed”
• Precipitated minerals can
• Calcium carbonate - CaCO3
form sludge (CaCO3)
• Calcium sulfate - CaSO4
• Tri-Calcium phosphate - • Metal oxides
• Bulk precipitants
Ca3(PO4)2
• Present in make up
• Silica / silicates
• Corrosion products
• Mud, silt, clay
• Make up
• Airborne dust
• Biological fouling
• Algae mats, plant matter

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 98
Problems Caused By Scale & Deposits

• Reduced heat transfer


• Loss of cooling capacity
• Restriction of water flow
• Higher back pressure
• Higher heat rate
• De-rating / reduced peak
capability
• Under-deposit corrosion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 99
Types of Scale Found in Cooling Water

• Calcium Carbonate

• Calcium Phosphate

• Silica and Silicate

• Calcium Sulfate

• etc

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 100
CaCO3 Scale Formation

• Ca concentration a function of
make up and cycles

• CO3 concentration a function of


pH, Alkalinity

• Less soluble in high pH and


high temperature

• Acid for pH control

• Blow down for cycle control

• Scale inhibitors
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 101
Calcium Phosphate Scale Formation

• Calcium Phosphate
– Phosphate source from make
up or corrosion treatment
• Gray water sources may have
high, variable PO4
– Solubility decreases as pH
increases (> 8.0)
– Solubility inversely proportional
to temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 102
Silica / Silicate Scale Formation

Silica
Silica will form in the coldest
• Silica concentration is a function
areas.
of make up and cycles
• Blow down for cycle control Also seen in condenser tubes
• More soluble in high pH and high that circulate cold water, off line.
temperature
• Spesical scale inhibitors /
dispersants for SiO2 > 150 ppm

Silicate
• Mainly MgSiO3
• Less soluble in high pH (> 8.3)
and high temperature
• Acid for pH control – prevent
silicate formation

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 103
Factors Influencing Scale
Mechanical, Operation and Chemistry
• Mechanical Stress
– Temperature
– Velocity

• Operational Stress
– pH, cycle and HTI and its
variation

• Chemical Stress
– Water Chemistry
• pH
• Hardness
• M-Alkalinity
• Silica
• Phosphate
• Sulfate
• Saturation Index
– Inhibitors capability

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 104
Mechanical: Impact of Temperature

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 105
Mechanical Stress: HE Design and Impact to Scaling
CW in Tube Side Plate & Frame CW in Shell Side

Hot Process Inlet

Baffles

Hot Water Outlet

Cold Water Inlet

Cold Process Outlet

• Typically low velocity • Typically low velocity


• Moderate velocity are
• Low to high skin • Typically high skin
common
temperature temperature
• Throttled valve,
vertical HE; etc can
lead to low velocity

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 106
Mechanical Stress and Impact to Scale

• Skin Temperature
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability < 48 deg C
Moderate Needs to be Considered 48-60 deg C
High W ill Typically be a problem 60-70 deg C
Severe Typically a problem >70 deg C

• CW Velocity
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability 0.9-1.8 mps
Moderate Needs to be Considered 0.6-0.9 mps/1.8-3.65 mps
High Will Typically be a problem 0.3-0.6/>3.65 mps
Severe Typically a problem <0.3 mps

• Heat Flux
Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability < 6780 KCal/hr-m2
Moderate Needs to be Considered >6780 < 20338 KCal/hr-m2
High Will Typically be a problem >20338 < 33896 KCal/hr-m2
Severe Typically a problem >33896 KCal/hr-m2

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 107
Operational Stress and Impact to Scale

Operational Stress Level Impact of Variation


Stress High Side Low Side

Variation of Cycle of • Mild < 20% Increases potential -


Concentration • Moderate 20-50% of scale and
• High 50-60% deposition
• Severe > 80%
Variation of pH • Mild + 0.1 unit Increases potential -
• Moderate + 0.2 units of scale and
• High + 0.4 units deposition
• Severe + 0.6 units
Variation of Holding • Mild < 40 hrs • Increases potential -
Time Index (HTI) • Moderate 40 – 100 hrs for inhibitor
• High 100 – 20 hrs degradation
• Severe > 200 hrs • Increases potential
for scale formation
& deposition

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 108
Chemical: Impact of pH

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 109
Chemical: Make-Up Water Quality

• Make-up water quality


– Source: river, sea water, brackish, swamp water, deep
well, recycle
• Variability is important !
Parameter Unit Jan-March April-June July-Sept Oct-Dec

pH - 7.80 8.00 8.30 7.60


Ca-Hardness ppm CaCO3 242.00 264.00 286.00 220.00
Mg-Hardness ppm CaCO3 99.00 108.00 117.00 90.00
M-Alkalinity ppm CaCO3 93.50 102.00 110.50 85.00
Sulfate ppm SO4 66.00 72.00 78.00 60.00

Chloride ppm Cl 88.00 96.00 104.00 80.00


Silica ppm SiO2 22.00 24.00 26.00 20.00

Aluminum ppm Al 0.11 0.12 0.13 0.10


Manganese ppm Mn 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.05
Total Iron ppm Fe 0.11 0.12 0.13 0.10
Conductivity µS/cm 572.00 624.00 676.00 520.00
Turbidity NTU 3.20 3.40 2.50 3.60

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 110
How to Predict Scaling Tendency ?

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 111
Saturation Index as a Tool

SYSTEM
pH TEMPERATURE
WATER DESIGN
CHEMISTRY
SATURATION INDEX

PROGRAM DESIGN

VARY VARY
CYCLE VARY VARY CHEMISTRY
pH TEMPERATURE

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 112
Saturation Index Reference Chart

From saturation index data we could select


the right scale inhibitors type and dosage

Mineral Low Medium High


Scale Stress Stress Stress
Calcite 6 80 140
Aragonite 7 80 140
Anhydrite 1.2 3 4
Gypsum 1.2 4 6
Tricalcium Phosphate 50 1000 1500
Hydoxyapetite Insufficent Data Insufficent Data Insufficent Data
Flourite Insufficent Data Insufficent Data Insufficent Data
Silica 1.1 1.2 1.5
Brucite 1.1 1.2 1.5
Magnesium Silicate 6 7 8
Iron Use of SI not indicative of iron fouling problems

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 113
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 114
Fouling

• Fouling is formed from material


suspended in water, while scaling
deposits involve precipitated
minerals

• Types:
– Suspended Solids
• Clays (dirt and silt)
• Clarifier sludges
– Corrosion Products
• Metal oxides, hydroxides (Fe,
Mn)
• Location:
– Low velocity areas
• Heat exchangers
• Tower basins, hot decks, film
fill

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 115
Factors Influencing Fouling:
Mechanical, Operation and Chemistry

• Mechanical Stress
– Velocity

• Operational Stress
– Cycle and HTI and its variation

• Chemical Stress
– Water Quality
• Turbidity and Suspended Solids
– Iron, Manganese, Aluminum
– Oil, organics, microbiological
– Contamination (process and air borne)
– Inhibitor capability

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 116
Mechanical: Impact of Spatial Relationship to Fouling

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 117
Mechanical: Impact of Hydrodynamic to Fouling

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 118
Mechanical: HE Design and Impact to Fouling
CW in Tube Side Plate & Frame CW in Shell Side

Hot Process Inlet

Baffles

Hot Water Outlet

Cold Water Inlet

Cold Process Outlet

• Typically low velocity • Typically low velocity


• Typically moderate
velocity (>0.6 m/s)
• Throttled valve,
vertical HE; etc can
lead to low velocity

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 119
Mechanical Stress Impact to Fouling: Velocity

Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability 0.9-1.8 mps


Moderate Needs to be Considered 0.6-0.9 mps/1.8-3.65 mps
High Will Typically be a problem 0.3-0.6/>3.65 mps
Severe Typically a problem <0.3 mps

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 120
Cooling Tower Filler Design and Impact to Fouling

• Low velocities
• High cycles – locally higher than bulk
water
• Excellent environment for bacterial
slime growth
• Formation of mixed deposit
–Bacterial slime traps suspended solids
–Scale formation

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 121
Cooling Tower Filler Design and Impact to Fouling

High Efficiency High Efficiency


Splash Bar Cross Flow Fill Cross Corrugated Fill

Low fouling tendency High fouling tendency Very high fouling tendency

Tower Fill
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air
SM
122
Cooling Tower Filler Design and Impact to Fouling

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 123
MOC Impact to Fouling: Pretreatment System

• System design and flow


path
– No pretreatment
– Clarifier
– Clarifier + MMF

• Performance
– Carry over issue ?
– Overfed of coagulant ?

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 124
Scale and Fouling Control

• Pretreatment

• Side stream filtration

• Operational management

• Mechanical modification

• Chemical inhibitors

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 125
Scale and Fouling Control - Pretreatment

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 126
Scale and Fouling Control: Side Stream Filtration

• Lowering fouling tendency


by reduce suspended solids
concentration

• Saving in microbio control

• Saving in inhibitor cost

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 127
Scale and Fouling Control:
Mechanical Modification

• Increasing velocity
– Providing more flow
– Avoiding throttle
• Lowering heat flux
• Air rumbling
• Reverse flow
• Change spatial relationship
• Ball cleaning

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 128
Scale and Fouling Control
Operational - Water Chemistry Management

Low Cycle = high High Cycle =


operating costs operational
• Cycle control problems

– Low cycle à low


scale/fouling ~ high
High
cost
– High cycle à high
scale/ fouling ~ low
operating cost

• pH control for scale


– Low pH à low scale
à CaCO3, Ca3PO4; etc
Minimum TCO

Low
Low Cycle High

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 129
Scale and Fouling Control:
Chemical Inhibitors

• Scale inhibitors

• Fouling inhibitors
– Dispersant
– Surfactant

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 130
Mechanism of Chemical Scale & Fouling Inhibitors

• Scale Inhibitor Mechanisms


– Treshold Inhibition & Crystal Modification
– Sequestration
– Scale conditioner (dispersant)

• Fouling Inhibitor Mechanisms


– Dispersant
– Surfactants

Calcium Phosphate Crystal

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 131
Mechanism of Chemical Scale & Fouling Inhibitors

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 132
Performance Comparison Scale Inhibitors

Capability AMP PSO HEDP PBTC PAPEMP


Corrosion Inhibition 2 5 3 1 1
CaCO3 SI 105 80 100 180 200+
CaSO4 734 483 130 257 574+
Cl2 Stab 2 5 3 5 3
Thermal Stability 3 5 2 5 4

Note:
5 Best, 1 Worst

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 133
Main Function of Dispersant
• Prevent deposition commonly found
minerals & inorganic particulates such as
– Calcium phosphate
– Iron,
– Silt
– Zinc

• Keep corrosion inhibitor “soluble”


– To be able function the inhibitors must be
dispersed in the water otherwise localized
deposition will occur

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 134
Polymer Dispersant Enhance
Corrosion Inhibition

Fe-PO4
Ca-PO4,Zn(OH)2
FeOOH

Anodic Inhibitor Cathodic Inhibitor

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 135
Performance Comparison Polymer Dispersant

Condition Conventional High Stress


Dispersant Limit Polymer Limit

Bulk Temperature, 0C 57 82

Velocity*, m/s 0.6 0.3

Holding Time Index*, hr 72 168

Calcium* (ppm) 750 1200

Iron (ppm) 2 8

Aluminum (ppm) 0.5 2

Note
* Depend of corrosion inhibitor program

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 136
Scale Inhibitor Feed and Control

• Conventional method
– Continuous feed
– Routine testing of inhibitor
residual

• Automation
– Chemical feed is adjusted
automatically based on actual
(real time) “ active” inhibitor
level in the system
– Nalco 3D TRASAR Technology
with tagged polymer control

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 137
3D TRASAR Scale Control

Scale Inhibitor Fed

System
Stress
Dosage

Active Polymer
Controlled by 3D TRASAR

Performance
Maintained
Time

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 138
Scale/Fouling Monitoring

• Deposit Monitor(s)

• Deposit Analysis

• Tagged polymer (3DT)

• Performance Monitoring
– Heat exchanger
– Cooling tower

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 139
Nalco Chemical Programs for
Scale and Corrosion

PSO-Phosphate

Stabilized Phosphate
pHreedom

All organic
Alkaline Zinc

Under-saturated Calcium Carbonate Over-saturated


(corrosive) (Calcite)Saturation (Scale)

Low pH High pH
Low Alkalinity High Alkalinity
High environmental impact Least environmental impact

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 140
Microbiological
Fouling

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 141
Microbio Fouling

• The most prevalent problems in


industrial cooling water systems

• A good control of microbial


growth is essential if we are to
control the other water
chemistry problems

• Factors affecting:
– Suspended solids
– Contaminants (organics,
ammonia, phosphate; etc)
– Physical factor (velocity and
hydrodynamic)
– pH

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 142
Types Microbio Found in Cooling Water

• Bacteria
– Aerobic bacteria
– Anaerobic bacteria
– Iron depositing bacteria
– Nitrifiers bacteria
• Algae
• Fungi
• Protozoa

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 143
Biofilm Development

Attaches Merges and grows Covers surface


(minutes) (hours) (days)

• Phases of biofilm formation:


1. Adsorption of organic film onto clean surface
2. Microorganisms attach themselves by the production of exopolymers
3. Microorganisms multiply, trap silt, corrosion products, scale, organisms
4. Shear forces cause biofilm to spread over surface

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 144
Biofilm Development

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 145
Biofilm, Bacterial Slime
• Typically 99% of the bacteria in a cooling water system live
within biofilm
• Comprised of aerobic and anaerobic species
• Extremely low thermal conductivity
– A 25 micron biofilm can reduce heat transfer up to 50%
• Causes under-deposit corrosion, MIC
• Can initiate mineral scale formation

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 146
Bacteria – Aerobic Slime-Forming

• Require oxygen for growth


– Aerated water in cooling
water system
• Description
– Sticky, slimy, masses usually
colored by suspended solids
• Problems/impact
– Fouling. Produces conditions
for anaerobic corrosive
bacteria
• Types
– Psedomonas
– Pigmented Mucoids
– Aerobacter

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 147
Bacteria – Anaerobic Corrosive

• No required oxygen for


growth. Indicating stagnant
condition or deposition
• Description
– Black appearance.Rotten
egg odor (H2S)
– Grow best under slime/
deposits
• Problem/Impact:
– Corrosion pH reduction
• Type:
– Desulfovibrio
– Clostridrium

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 148
Iron Depositing Bacteria

• Use soluble iron as source of


energy and convert it to
insoluble iron
• Live under low oxygen or
interfaces between aerobic and
anaerobic
• Description
– White or rust-colored
– Stringy, slippery; oftern forms
voluminous red deposit
• Problem/impact
– Iron deposition
– Under deposit corrosion
• Types
– Sphaerotilus
– Gal;ionella

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 149
Bacteria: Nitrifiers/Denitrifiers

• Driving energy through


oxidation of nitrogen
compound
• Found in ammonia
contamination system or
closed loops with nitrite
inhibitor
• Description
– Produce acids in NH3
contaminated system
• Problem/Impact
• Types:
– Nitrosifiers: NH3 à NO2-
– Nitrifiers: NO2 à NO3-
– pH reduction. Corrosion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 150
Acid Production in Biofilms
Aerobic Bacteria
•Consume oxygen and produce organic slime
Facultative Bacteria
•Use organic matter to produce acid
Anaerobic Bacteria (includes SRB)
•Produce more organic and inorganic acids

Aerobic
Facultative
R-COO-
R-COO-
H+
H+ R-COO- Anaerobic
H+
R-COO- R-COO-
H H H
H +
+ +
+ H
H +
+

Propagating Pit Metal

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 151
Algae

• Found living only in sunlight or


source of light.
• Grown on submerged or
periodically wetted areas
• Description
– Loose, slimy, rubbery
– Often green or brown
• Problem/impact:
– Plugging of distribution deck
holes
– Living or dead algae can feed
bacteria
• Types
– Oscilatorria
– Chlorococcus

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 152
Fungi – Mold and Yeast
• Produce hard and rubbery slime
• Common in air washers
• Grow in water-wetted, rather than submerged areas
• May reproduce by spore formation
• Mold and spores are very resistant to biocides
• Degrade wood to weaken cooling tower structure
• In closed loop systems occur as fluffy floc

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 153
Microbes – Where do they come from ?

• They are already there!

• They continuously enter water systems via:


– Make-up water
– Air-borne contaminants
– Process leaks OIL PRODUCTION
INDUSTRY PAPER
INDUSTRY
CLINICAL/
– Other debris HEALTH

MICRO-
ORGANISMS
MARINE

FOOD & DRINK PAINTS


INDUSTRY
COOLING
Microbes are everywhere. WATERS

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 154
Why Microbio Growth in Cooling Water ?
Microbial populations rapidly adapt to changes in their environment

• Existence of nutrients: essential elements


– carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, sulphur

• Suitable conditions
– Temperature: 10 - 50 °C
– pH: 3 -10

• Other factors - e.g. sunlight for algae

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 155
Consequences of Microbio Fouling

• Loss of cooling capacity


• Increased energy consumption -
higher pump pressures
• Under deposit corrosion – reduce
equipment life time & unscheduled
shut down
• Plugging - Unscheduled
maintenance
• Degradation of treatment
chemicals
• Wood decay in the cooling tower
• Pathogen growth promotion

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 156
Microbio Norms – Tower Fill

• A loss of 2.8 degrees C in


approach to wet bulb
temperature will result in
a 10-15% loss in cooling
load.
– Tower
o
water increase of
0.56 C = 2% increase in
energy use.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 157
Factors Influencing Microbio Fouling:
Mechanical, Operation and Chemistry

• Mechanical Stress
– Cooling tower: fill, basin, drift; etc
– Stagnant areas
– Low velocity
– Filters

• Operational Stress
– HTI: high HTI impact to biocide
effectiveness
– Intermittent operation

• Chemical Stress
– Contamination
• Process: Organics, Ammonia, Oil;etc
• Make-up: Organics and Microbio
• Air: Organics and suspended solids
– Biocide capability

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 158
Mechanical Stress Impact to Microbio: Velocity

Mild Minimal Effect on Reliability 0.9-1.8 mps


Moderate Needs to be Considered 0.6-0.9 mps/1.8-3.65 mps
High Will Typically be a problem 0.3-0.6/>3.65 mps
Severe Typically a problem <0.3 mps

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 159
FILM FILL Biofilm are Adhesive

FILM FILL
FILM FILL

FILM FILL
corrosion
products
calcium 7%
scales
15% biological
37%

silt
41%
FILM FILL

FILM FILL
FILM FILL

FILM FILL

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 160
Operational Stress Impact to Microbio: Contaminants

Free Chlorine

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 161
Microbio Fouling Cycle

1.
Contamination
(HC, NH3,S)

6. Heat
Exchanger 2. Biocide
Leak Out of
Control

5. High
Corrosion 3. Microbio
Rate Fouling

4. Drop in
Efficiency

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 162
Microbiological Control
The goal is not to STERILIZE the system, but

to MANAGE microbial fouling to a level that


minimizes mechanical, operational, and chemical
problems at an acceptable cost.

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 163
163
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 164
Biocides

• Oxidizing Biocides
– Usually the primary biocide

• Non-Oxidizing Biocides
– Algae control
– Biofouling control
– Pathogen control

• Biodispersant & bio-detergents


– Improved biofouling control

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 165
Biocide – Oxidizing Biocide

• Oxidizers (are usually the primary biocide)


– Chemically oxidize organic
components of the cell
– Effective against nearly all
microorganisms
– Chlorine: as gas or bleach
– Bromine: as NaBr or other bromine
donors
– Chlorine Dioxide
– Hydrogen Peroxide
– Ozone
– etc

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 166
166
Oxidizing Biocides
Chemically oxidize organics component of the cell

Advantages Disadvantages
• Broad spectrum of activity. • Un-stabilized chemistry
Effective against nearly all - Corrosive
microorganisms - Aggressive toward inhibitor
• Resistance to oxidants rare - Volatile
and limited - Ineffective for biofilm removal at
• Inexpensive use concentrations
• Lower environmental impact • Could contribute AOX
• Simple to monitor and control • React with most of organics
(except ClO2)
• Ease of Dosing: Slug or
maintain a residual • Low efficacy against algae at low
concentrations
• Can be deactivated prior to
discharge

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 167
Oxidizing Biocides on Biofilm Penetration

• Most of oxidizers react mostly of


the surface of the biofilm to form
an oxidized layer, like charring on
wood. This precludes further
penetration

• Stabilized oxidants (Stabrex)


contain stabilizer that enhances
penetration of biocide into the
biofilm

• Chlorine dioxide is a dissolved


gas that penetrates biofilm and
cell wall of the micro-organisms by
molecular diffusion and disrupt
metabolic functions

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 168
Impact of pH to Oxidizing Biocides

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 169
Impact of Oxidizing Biocides to “High Demand”
(Contamination)

Source: Cooling Water Treatment with Chlorine Dioxide, Siemens

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 170
General Guide Line

Oxidizing Biocides Speed of pH Toxicity NH3 Organics Sulfide


Kill
Chlorine Fast 6.5 – 7.6 Med •• •• ••
Activated Bromine Fast 7.6 – 9.0 Non • •• ••

Stabilized Bromine Medium 7.6 – 9.0 Med x •• ••

Solid Stabilized Medium 7.6 – 9.0 High x •• ••


Chlorine/Bromine

Chlorine Dioxide Fast 6.0 – 10.0 High - • ••

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 171
Microbio Fouling Cycle

1.
Contamination
(HC, NH3,S)

6. Heat
Exchanger 2. Biocide
Leak Out of
Control

5. High
Corrosion 3. Microbio
Rate Fouling

4. Drop in
Efficiency

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 172
Bio-Control Practices in
Recirculating Cooling Water
Isothiazoline DBNPA
• Non-Oxidizing biocides
– Organic compounds, react
with cell components
enyzm enyzm – Disrupt cell wall, metabolism,
or reproduction
– Effective to control specific
amino
organisms
• Algae control
• Biofouling control
• Pathogen control
– Improved Bio-Control / Bio-
Quat Glut Manage practices

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 173
173
Non Oxidizing Biocides
React with cell components, disrupt cell wall,
metabolism, or reproduction

Advantages Disadvantages
• Selective • High cost per kilogram
• Not corrosive • Special handling precautions
• Lower AOX • Chemical inactivation can occur
• Ease of Slug Dosing • Not broad spectrum
• Storage for contingency • Local discharge limitations may
• Essential in high-demand apply
situations • Resistant populations may
• Active in wide pH range develop at low doses
• Some have dispersancy
capability

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 174
Algae Fouling Control with N-90001

Before After weekly 25 ppm algaecide slug


SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 175
Biodispersant/ Biodetergent

Biodispersants (biodetergents) can disperse deposited


particles, and may improve the efficacy of biocides

Before addition of biodetergent

After addition of biodetergent

Biodetergent is a Nalco term for newer generation technology


SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 176
Fill Fouling Control with Biodetergent

Fouled film fill prior to trial Film fill after six-weeks of


biodetergent treatment
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 177
Selecticide Test

• Test to evaluate the efficacy of different biocides


• Both oxidizing and non-oxidizing biocides are included
• Good tool to identify appropriate biocide program for the system

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 178
Microbio Monitoring

Laboratory Monitoring
• Plant:
– Oxidizer residuals
– ORP
– Dip slides / plates
– Bio-box or sessile coupon
– ATP liquid or swab
– 3DT Bio-Index
• Lab:
– Nalco DMA
– Deposit analysis
– Pathogen / Legionella

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 179
Laboratory - DMA
(Differential Microbiological Analysis)

Nalco DMA Report

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 180
Microbio Monitoring

Unit Monitoring
• Visual, Tactile:
– Algae in basin, on tower
structure
– Slimy feel on tower, basin,
or equipment surfaces
– Inspections
• Performance:
– Condenser cleanliness
factor
• Backpressure, TTD
– Hx performance
• Lube oil, Hydrogen
– Tower performance
• Approach to wet bulb

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 181
Microbio Monitoring: CT Temperature Approach

CT Approach Temperature Trend

10

6
Ap p ro ach T

0
09
08

08

09
8

0
08

09
/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/0

/1

/1

/1

/1
8/
9/

8/

0/
20

20
28

28

23

21

18

28

29

23

29

30

29

26

29

/2

30

30

30

30
7/
/2

/2

/3

12
1/

1/
4/

5/

6/

7/

7/

8/

9/

4/

5/

5/

6/

8/

9/

4/

5/

6/

7/
10

12

10
/1

/1
28

30
Date

Note: typically 2.8 0C to design wet bulb is the coldest water temperature
that cooling tower manufacturer guarantee

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 182
SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 183
Summary

Scale

Corrosion

Microbio

Fouling

Fouling Bio Fouling

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 184
Thank You

SM
Essential Expertise for Water, Energy and Air 185

You might also like