Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Advanced Turbine Systems: Advancing The Gas Turbine Power Industry
Advanced Turbine Systems: Advancing The Gas Turbine Power Industry
Advanced
Turbine
Systems
Advancing
The Gas Turbine
Power Industry
In 1992, the U.S. Department of Energy forged partnerships with industry
and academia under the Advanced Turbine Systems (ATS) Program to go be-
yond evolutionary performance gains in utility-scale gas turbine develop-
ment. Agreed upon goals of 60 percent efficiency and single digit NOx
emissions (in parts per million) represented major challenges in the fields of
engineering, materials science, and thermodynamics—the equivalent of break-
ing the 4-minute mile.
Today, the goals have not only been met, but a knowledge base has been
amassed that enables even further performance enhancement. The success
firmly establishes the United States as the world leader in gas turbine tech-
nology and provides the underlying science to maintain that position.
ATS technology cost and performance characteristics make it the least-cost
electric power generation and co-generation option available, providing a
timely response to the growing dependence on natural gas driven by both
global and regional energy and environmental demands.
Introduction
Through the Advanced Turbine Laboratory (NETL) for the DOE development, under cost-shared co-
Systems (ATS) Program, lofty vi- Office of Fossil Energy. operative agreements between DOE
sions in the early 1990s are now and turbine manufacturers, was con-
In 1992, DOE initiated the ATS
emerging as today’s realities in the ducted in parallel with fundamental
Program to push gas turbine perfor-
form of hardware entering the mar- (technology base) research carried
mance beyond evolutionary gains.
ketplace. An investment by govern- out by a university-industry consor-
For utility-scale turbines, the objec-
ment and industry in partnerships tium and national laboratories.
tives were to achieve: (1) an effi-
encompassing universities and na-
ciency of 60 percent on a lower Major systems development
tional laboratories is paying signifi-
heating value (LHV) basis in com- began with turbine manufacturers
cant dividends. This document
bined-cycle mode; (2) NOx emis- conducting systems studies in Phase
examines some of the payoffs
sions less than 10 ppm by volume I followed by concept development
emerging in the utility sector result-
(dry basis) at 15 percent oxygen, in Phase II. Today, one major system
ing from work sponsored by the
without external controls; (3) a 10 development is in Phase III, tech-
U.S. Department of Energy (DOE).
percent lower cost of electricity; and nology readiness testing, and an-
Both industrial and utility-scale (4) state-of-the-art reliability, avail- other has moved into full-scale
turbines are addressed under the ability, and maintainability (RAM) testing/performance validation.
ATS Program. The DOE Office of levels. To achieve these leapfrog Throughout, the university-industry
Fossil Energy is responsible for the performance gains, DOE mobilized consortium and national laborato-
utility-scale portion and the DOE the resources of leaders in the gas ries have conducted research to ad-
Office of Energy Efficiency and Re- turbine industry, academia, and the dress critical needs identified by
newable Energy is responsible for national laboratories through unique industry in their pursuit of systems
1
the industrial turbine portion. The partnerships. development and eventual global
focus here is on utility-scale work deployment.
The ATS Program adopted a two-
implemented under the auspices of
pronged approach. Major systems
the National Energy Technology
Turbine
System Concept Technology
Full-Scale Testing/ Global
Studies Development Readiness Testing
Manufacturers (Phase I) (Phase II) (Phase III)
Performance Validation Deployment
COMBUSTION SYSTEM
FUEL TRANSITION
GAS COMBUSTION
TEMPERATURE
FIRING TEMPERATURE
(TURBINE INLET)
SHAFT
AIR
NOZZLE
VANE
TURBINE
BLADE
HEAT
RECOVERY
STEAM
GENERATOR
GAS TURBINE
STEAM
General Electric Power Systems ATS Turbine
General Electric Power Systems (GEPS), one of two turbine manu-
facturers partnering with DOE to bring the ATS into the utility sector, has
successfully completed initial development work, achieving or exceeding
program goals. The resultant 7H ATS technology—a 400-MWe, 60 hertz
combined-cycle system—is part of a larger GEPS H System™ program,
which includes the 9H, a 480-MWe, 50 hertz system designed for over-
seas markets.
The H System™ is poised to enter the commercial marketplace. GEPS
has fabricated the initial commercial units, the MS9001H (9H) and
MS7001H (7H), and successfully completed full-speed, no-load tests on
these units at GE’s Greenville, South Carolina manufacturing facility.
Having completed testing in 1999, the 9H is preceding the 7H into com-
mercial service. The MS9001H is paving the way for eventual develop-
ment of the Baglan Energy Park in South Wales, United Kingdom, with
commercial operation scheduled for 2002. The MS7001H ATS will pro-
vide the basis for Sithe Energies’ new 800-MWe Heritage Station in Scriba,
New York, which is scheduled for commercial service in 2004.
Early entry of the 9H is part of the H System™ development strategy
to reduce risk. The 9H incorporates critical ATS design features and pro-
vided early design verification. Also, because ATS goals required ad-
4 vancements in virtually all components of the gas turbine,
GEPS incorporated its new systems approach for the
H System™—the “design for six sigma” (DFSS)
design process. DFSS accelerated development
by improving up-front definition of perfor-
mance requirements and specifications
for subsystems and components, and by
focusing the research and development
activities. Downstream, the benefits
will be improved reliability, avail-
ability, and maintainability due to
integration of manufacturing and
operational considerations into the
DFSS specifications.
GEPS’ 400-ton
MS7001H in transit to
full-speed, no-load testing
Meeting the
Technical Challenges
Turbine
The need to address the conflict-
ing goals of higher efficiency and
lower NOx emissions required sys-
temic changes. The major driver was
to increase the firing temperature
(temperature into the first rotating
turbine stage) without exceeding the
NOx formation combustion tem-
perature of 2,800 oF. To do so, GEPS
introduced closed-loop steam cool-
ing at the first and second stage
nozzles and turbine blades (buckets)
to reduce the differential between
General Electric’s H SystemTM gas turbine showing the 18-stage compressor
combustion and firing temperatures.
and 4-stage turbine
The closed-loop steam cooling re-
placed open-loop air cooling that porates several design features from in stages three and four. Ultrasonic,
depends upon film cooling of the aircraft engines. infrared, and digital radiography
airfoils. x-ray inspection techniques are now
Single crystal (nickel superal-
in the hands of the turbine blade
In open-loop air cooling, a sig- loy) turbine bucket fabrication is
nificant amount of air is diverted used in the first two stages. This
supplier. Moreover, to extend the 5
useful component life, repair tech-
from the compressor and is intro- technique eliminates grain bound-
niques were developed for the single
duced into the working fluid. This aries in the alloy, and offers supe-
crystal and directionally solidified
approach results in approximately rior thermal fatigue and creep
airfoils.
a 280 oF temperature drop between characteristics. However, single
the combustor and the turbine rotor crystal material characteristics con- Even with advanced cooling
inlet, and loss of compressed air en- tribute to the difficulty in airfoil and single crystal fabrication,
ergy into the hot gas path. Alterna- manufacture, with historic applica- thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) are
tively, closed-loop steam improves tion limited to relatively small hot utilized. TBCs provide essential in-
cooling and efficiency because of section parts. The transition from sulation and protection of the metal
the superior heat transfer character- manufacturing 10-inch, two-pound substrate from combustion gases. A
istics of steam relative to air, and aircraft blades to fabricating blades ceramic TBC topcoat provides ther-
the retention and use of heat in the 2–3 times longer and 10 times mal resistance, and a metal bond
closed-loop. The gas turbine serves heavier represents a significant coat provides oxidation resistance
as a parallel reheat steam generator challenge. Adding to the challenge and bonds the topcoat to the sub-
for the steam turbine in its intended is the need to maintain very tight strate. GEPS developed an air
combined-cycle application. airfoil wall thickness tolerances for plasma spray deposition process and
cooling, and airfoil contours for associated software for robotic ap-
The GEPS ATS uses a firing
aerodynamics. plication. An e-beam test facility
temperature class of 2,600 oF, ap-
replicated turbine blade surface
proximately 200 oF above the most GEPS developed non-destruc-
temperatures and thermal gradients
efficient predecessor combined- tive evaluation techniques to verify
to validate the process. The TBC is
cycle system with no increase in production quality of single crystal
now being used where applicable
combustion temperature. To allow ATS airfoils, as well as the
throughout the GEPS product line.
these temperatures, the ATS incor- directionally solidified blades used
Compressor
To meet H System™ air requirements, GEPS turned to the high-pres-
sure compressor design used in its CF6-80C2 aircraft engine. The 7H
system uses a 2.6:1 scale-up of the CF6-80C2 compressor, with four stages
added (bringing it to 18 stages), to achieve a 23:1 pressure ratio and 1,230
lb/sec airflow. The design incorporates both variable inlet guide vanes,
used on previous systems, and variable stator vanes at the front of the
compressor. These variable vanes permit airflow adjustments to accom-
modate startup, turndown, and variations in ambient air temperatures.
GEPS applied improved 3-D computational fluid dynamic (CFD) tools
in the redesign of the compressor flow path. Full-scale evaluation of the
7H compressor at GEPS’ Lynn, Massachusetts compressor test facility
validated both the CFD model and the compressor performance.
H System™ compressors also circulate cooled discharge air in the ro-
tor shaft to regulate temperature and permit the use of steel in lieu of
Inconel. To allow a reduction in compressor airfoil tip clearance, the de-
sign included a dedicated ventilation system around the gas turbine.
Combustion
To achieve the single digit NOx emission goal, the H System™ uses a
lean pre-mix Dry Low NOx (DLN) can-annular combustor system similar
to the DLN in FA-class turbine service. The H System™ DLN 2.5 combus-
6 tor combines increased airflow resulting from the use of closed-loop steam
cooling and the new compressor with design refinements to produce both
single digit NOx and CO emissions.
GEPS subjected full-scale prototype, steam-cooled stage 1 nozzle seg-
ments to extensive testing under actual gas turbine operating condi-
tions. Testing prompted design changes including application
of TBC to both the combustor liner and downstream transi-
tion piece, use of a different base metal, and modified
heat treatment and TBC application methods.
GEPS compressor
rotor during assembly
Control System
The H System™ uses an inte-
grated, full-authority, digital control
system—the Mark VI. The Mark VI
also manages steam flows between
the heat recovery steam generator,
steam turbine, and gas turbine;
stores critical data for troubleshoot-
ing; and uses pyrometers to moni-
tor stage 1 and stage 2 turbine
bucket temperatures. The pyrometer
system offers rapid detection of rises
in temperature, enabling automatic
turbine shutdown before damage
occurs. The demonstrated success
of the Mark VI has prompted GEPS
to incorporate it into other (non-
steam cooled) engines. Energy Secretary Bill Richardson, flanked by Robert Nardelli of GE and South
Carolina Senator Ernest Hollings, introduced GE’s gas turbine at a ceremony
in Greenville, South Carolina. Richardson stated: “This milestone will not only
help maintain a cleaner environment, it will help fuel our growing economy,
and it will keep electric bills low in homes and businesses across our country.”
The design for this “next generation” power generation system is now
established. Both the 9H (50 Hz) and the 7H (60 Hz) family members
are currently in the production and final validation phase. The exten-
sive component test validation program, already well underway, will
ensure delivery of a highly reliable combined-cycle power generation
system.
Siemens Westinghouse Power Corporation
ATS Turbine
Siemens Westinghouse Power The first step in the evolution- onstration of the W501ATS in 2005,
Corporation (SWPC) has intro- ary process was commissioning of which builds on the improvements
duced into commercial operation the W501G. This unit introduced incorporated in the W501G.
many key ATS technologies. Oper-
ating engine demonstrations and
key ATS technologies such as
closed-loop steam cooling, ad-
Leveraging
ongoing technology development vanced compressor design, and ATS Technology
efforts are providing solid evidence high-temperature materials. After
The following discusses the
that ATS program goals will be undergoing extensive evaluation
ATS technology introduced during
achieved. at Lakeland Electric’s McIntosh
commissioning of the 420-MWe
Power Station in Lakeland, Florida,
In response to input from its W501G and currently being incor-
the W501G entered commercial ser-
customer advisory panel, SWPC is porated in other SWPC gas turbine
vice in March 2000. Conversion to
introducing advanced technologies systems. The combustion outlet
combined-cycle operation is sched-
in an evolutionary manner to temperature in these tests was
uled for 2001.
minimize risk. As performance is within 50 oF of the projected ATS
proven, SWPC is infusing ATS tech- The next step is integration of temperature.
nologies into commercially offered additional ATS technologies into the
machines to enhance cost and per- W501G, with testing to begin in Closed-Loop
formance and expand the benefit of 2003. The culmination will be dem- Steam Cooling
the ATS program.
8 The W501G unit applied closed-
loop steam cooling to the combus-
tor “transitions,” which duct hot
combustion gas to the turbine inlet.
Four external connections route
steam to each transition supply
manifold through internal piping.
The supply manifold feeds steam to
an internal wall cooling circuit.
After the steam passes through the
cooling circuit, it is collected in an
exhaust manifold and then is ducted
out of the engine.
Testing at Lakeland proved the
viability of closed-loop steam cool-
ing, and confirmed the ability to
Siemens Westinghouse
W501G switch between steam and air cool-
ing. The steam cooling clearly
demonstrated superiority over air
cooling.
Steam-cooled “transition”
Optimizing Aerodynamics The roots of the compressor
design are in three-dimensional vis-
In parallel with W501G testing, cous flow analyses and custom de-
SWPC validated the benefits of ap- signed, controlled-diffusion airfoil
plying the latest three-dimensional shapes. Controlled-diffusion airfoil
design philosophy to the ATS four- design technology evolved from the
stage turbine design. This was con- aircraft industry. The airfoils emerg-
ducted in a one-third scale turbine ing from these analytical methods
test rig, incorporating the first two are thinner and shaped at the ends
stages. SWPC conducted the test- to reduce boundary layer effects.
ing in a shock tube facility at Ohio
State University, which was instru- To verify the aerodynamic per-
mented with over 400 pressure, tem- formance and mechanical integrity
perature, and heat flux gauges. An of the W501ATS compressor, a full-
aerodynamic efficiency increase at- scale unit was manufactured and
tributed to the use of “indexing” sur- tested in 1997. SWPC confirmed
passed expected values. performance expectations through
extensive, highly instrumented tests
High-Temperature TBCs in a specially designed facility at the
TBCs are an integral part of the Philadelphia Naval Base.
W501ATS engine design. An on- The ATS compressor technol-
going development program evalu- ogy has been retrofitted into the
Aerodynamic redesign
ated several promising bond coats W501F product line using analyti-
and ceramic materials prior to the cal techniques developed and
W501G tests. The selected ad- proven under the ATS program. 9
vanced bond coat/TBC system un- This significantly expands the ben-
derwent 24,000 hours of cyclic efit of the ATS program,
accelerated oxidation testing at given projected sales
1,850 oF. The W501G incorporated for this popular
the selected TBC on the first and sized unit.
second row turbine blades. Plans
are to incorporate the TBC system
into other SWPC engines.
Compressor
The W501G incorporates the
first 16 stages of the 19 stage ATS
compressor, designed to deliver
1,200 lb/sec airflow with a 27:1
pressure ratio. SWPC slightly
modified the last three stages for the
W501G compressor and changed
vanes 1 and 2 from modulated to
fixed. This resulted in air delivery Siemens
at the ATS mass-flow rate of 1,200 Westinghouse
lb/sec, but at a pressure ratio of 19:1, ATS compressor
which optimizes the compressor for
the W501G system.
ATS Row 4 Abradable coatings on turbine
Turbine Blade and compressor blade ring seals are
also a part of the W501ATS design.
To accommodate the 25 percent This approach permits reduced tip
increase in mass flow associated clearances without risk of hardware
with the ATS compressor, the damage, and provides more uniform
W501G uses the ATS Row 4 turbine tip clearance around the perimeter.
blade assembly. The new design Stage 1 turbine ring segment condi-
uses a large annulus area to reduce tions present a particular challenge,
the exit velocity and capture the requiring state-of-the-art thermal
maximum amount of the gas flow barrier properties while providing
kinetic energy before leaving the abradability. Engine testing verified
turbine. The uncooled ATS Row 4 the targeted abradability, tip-to-seal
turbine blade assembly met pre- wear, and erosion characteristics.
dicted performance levels through- The coatings have been incorpo-
out the W501G test program and rated into the compressor and the
established a new level in gas tur- first two turbine stages of
bine output capability. both the W501F and
Brush Seals and W501G machines.
Abradable Coatings
The W501ATS design applies
brush seals to minimize air leakage
and hot gas ingestion into turbine
10 disc cavities. Seal locations include
the compressor diaphragms, turbine
disc front, turbine rims, and turbine
interstages. SWPC used test rigs to
develop effective, rugged, and reli-
able brush seals for the various ap-
plications. ATS compressor tests at Siemens
the Philadelphia Naval Base veri- Westinghouse
W501G at
fied brush seal low leakage and wear
Lakeland Electric’s
characteristics, which resulted in McIntosh Power
application of the seals to W501F Station, Lakeland, Florida
and W501G product lines. Retrofit-
ted units have demonstrated signifi-
cantly improved performance.
Completing Plans for the W501ATS are to Materials
incorporate closed-loop steam cool-
ATS Development ing into both stage 1 and stage 2 An active materials develop-
vanes and ring segments. ment program has been ongoing to
Development activities are fo- support incorporation of single
cused on extending the W501G per- Catalytic Combustion crystal and directionally solidified
formance to ATS efficiencies by turbine blade alloys and steam cool-
introducing additional technology To achieve NOx emission tar-
ing into the ATS design. The pro-
advancements and increasing the gets across a wide range of ATS
gram has addressed the effect of
firing temperature to 2,750 oF. operating conditions, SWPC is de-
steam cooling on materials, blade
veloping a catalytic combustor in
Closed-Loop conjunction with Precision Com-
life prediction, advanced vane al-
Steam Cooling bustion, Inc. (PCI) under DOE’s
loys, single crystal and directionally
solidified blade alloy properties,
Small Business Innovation Re-
The next major step will be in- and single crystal airfoil casting.
search Program. Catalytic com-
corporation of closed-loop steam Single crystal casting trials, using a
bustion serves to stabilize flame
cooling into the W501G stage 1 tur- CMSX-4 alloy on first stage vanes
formation by enhancing oxidation
bine vane. This addition will extend and blades, demonstrated the viabil-
under lean firing conditions. The
the benefits of the existing steam ity of casting these large compo-
SWPC/PCI piloted-ring combustor
cooled transition by eliminating nents with their thin-wall cooling
will replace the standard diffusion
cooling air at the turbine inlet, rais- designs. But alternative manufac-
flame pilot burner with a catalytic
ing the firing temperature, and free- turing methods and alloys are be-
pilot burner. Initial atmospheric
ing more compressor air to reduce ing explored to reduce cost.
pressure combustion testing deter-
NOx emissions.
mined turndown and emission SWPC plans to use a new ce-
Prior to retrofitting into the characteristics. Follow-on tests ramic TBC emerging from the Oak
W501G, the ATS steam cooled vane successfully demonstrated catalytic Ridge National Laboratory Thermal 11
underwent evaluation in a test rig combustion at full-scale under ATS Barrier Coatings Program—a part
incorporating a single full-scale combustion temperatures and pres- of the ATS Technology Base Pro-
combustor and transition capable of sures. Engine testing is planned for gram. The ceramic TBC, compat-
achieving ATS temperatures and early 2001. ible with ATS temperatures, will be
pressures. The tests were con- integrated with the new bond coat
ducted at the Arnold Air Force evaluated by SWPC earlier in the
Base-Arnold Engineering De- W501G tests.
velopment Center in Tennes-
T
as internships, fellowships, faculty
working research activities, AGTSR
studies, and special studies. To date, he creation of a national net-
has exponentially increased the in-
16 separate universities around the work of universities under
teractions among researchers and
country have sponsored workshops AGTSR mobilized the scientific
interested parties, breaking the mold
on key topics. All interns were talent needed to understand
16 of traditional one-on-one university
eventually employed by the gas tur- the fundamental mechanisms
research (researcher and funding
bine industry or by a university. Well impeding gas turbine perfor-
agency). Moreover, AGTSR has not
over 400 university personnel and mance gains and to identify
only established a body of scientific
over 100 industry experts have pathways for overcoming them.
excellence in gas turbine technology,
participated directly in the AGTSR
but provided for continued U.S. lead-
program.
ership in turbine technology through
an ongoing education program.
With DOE oversight and indus-
try guidance, the South Carolina In-
stitute for Energy Studies (SCIES)
administers the AGTSR Program,
providing the linkage between uni-
versities, industry, and government.
A 10-member Industry Review
Board (IRB) provides corporate
leaders who define the thrust of the
research program and technical
experts to evaluate research pro-
posals. IRB membership includes
gas turbine manufacturers, parts
suppliers, customers, and indus-
try research and development or-
ganizations. SCIES coordinates the AGTS professor and graduate student reviewing progress on their project
Examples of Success
1.5 Control Off Identification Control On
The successes in the AGTSR
program are too numerous to re- 1
count. The following examples are
offered to exemplify the work car- 0.5
Combustion -0.5
Abbie W. Layne
Product Manager
National Energy Technology Laboratory
Advanced Turbines & Engines Systems
(304) 285-4603
alayne@netl.doe.gov
Heather Quedenfeld
National Energy Technology Laboratory
Communications and Public Affairs Division
(304) 285-5430
heather.quedenfeld@netl.doe.gov
November 2000