Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RSTV The Big Picture - One Nation One Election
RSTV The Big Picture - One Nation One Election
insightsonindia.com/2019/06/18/rstv-the-big-picture-one-nation-one-election
June 18,
2019
Introduction:
Chairing an all-party meeting on the eve of the first session of the new Lok Sabha, Prime
Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday invited heads of all parties to a meeting on June 19 to
discuss the “one nation, one election” idea and other important matters. Noting that there
are many new faces in this Lok Sabha, PM Modi said the first session of the Lower House of
Parliament should begin with “fresh zeal and new thinking”. Addressing the media later,
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Prahlad Joshi said the prime minister has requested all
parties, especially the opposition, for their cooperation for the smooth functioning of
both Houses of Parliament. Apart from “one nation, one election” the all party meeting has
been called to deliberate on other matters like – celebrations of 75 years of India’s
Independence in 2022 and 150 years of Mahatma Gandhi’s birth anniversary this year.
Simultaneous elections refer to holding elections to Lok Sabha and State Legislative
Assemblies simultaneously, once in five year.
The idea of holding elections simultaneously is in news after it got a push from Prime
Minister Narendra Modi.
Background:
Simultaneous elections were held in the country during the first two decades after
Independence up to 1967.
Dissolution of certain Assemblies in 1968 and 1969 followed by the dissolution of the
Lok Sabha led to the “disruption of the conduct of simultaneous elections.”
Money and administrative expense will be drastically cut, political parties spend a
lot on elections campaigning
In 1951 elections, 53 political parties contested and the expense declared was 11
crores.
In recent 2019 elections, 610 political parties contested and the expense as per
1/3
ADR is 60,000 crores
Government will have time for some constructive work because imposition of model
code of conduct for such a long time is hampering developmental and welfare
activities.
The ruling parties will be able to focus on legislation and governance rather than
having to be in campaign mode forever.
The entire State and District level administrative and security machinery will be busy
with the conduct of elections twice in a period of five years as per the current practice.
Large numbers of teachers are involved in the electoral process which causes
maximum harm to the education sector.
Recommendations:
Challenges:
Political parties were divided on the issue of holding simultaneous elections during
consultations with the Law Commission of India.
Simultaneous elections would involve arbitrary curtailment or extension of the
tenure of a House — the legal propriety of which is questionable.
Such a measure would undermine federalism as well as representative democracy.
The core problem is Parliamentary form of government in which government is
accountable and can fall before it completes its term.
Our parliamentary system is complex, different and difficult compared to other parts
of the country.
Need of political consensus because it requires constitutional amendment.
Way forward:
‘One India One Election’ would be a good change if it could be carried out with the
proper execution of policies and rules, taking care of the rising need for good
administrative staff and security.
A focused group of constitutional experts, think tanks, government officials and
representatives of political parties should be formed to work out appropriate
implementation related details.
Elections in India are celebrated as festival and if they happen once in every 5 years all
together throughout the country then it would be Maha-Festival.
3/3