You are on page 1of 6

Doston peechle ek saal se rafale saude par jang chal rahi hain.

Kabhi Rahul Gandhi toh kabhi


kuch media Samuh alag alag daleel dekar rafale saude pe sawal utha rahein hain. Mamla
peechli congress Sarkar virudh nayi bjp Sarkar dwara hui rafale deal ko lekar hain.

Sacchai doondhne ke liye humne do hazaar saath se lekar do hazaar attarah tak ke sabhi
sarvajanik jankarioyon ka adhyan kiya, aur aap dekhenghe sabooton ke saath ki Kis prakar
Congress janta ko rafale deal par galat facts aur figures dekar bhramit kar rahin hain.

Rahul Gandhiji ne Pradhanmantri modi par chor, darpok, brastachar, deshdrohi yeh sabhi
lanchan llagaye hain. Aaye dekhtein hain kuch aise kshan -

<play video>

Waise Rahul Gandhiji alag alag jagah, congress dwara hui rafale deal mein ek jet ki keemat
ke alag alag figures diye hain. 520 crore se lekar 700 crore tak. Is video mein hum Rahul
Gandhiji ke dwara diya gaya sabse latest figure ,janwari 2, 2019 ka twitter post ka, hi lenge.

Janwari 2, 2019 ko Rahulji ne ek twitter post ke madhyam se Pradhan mantri ke saamne


chand sawal rakhein. Inmein se ek sawal – 560 karor ki. Jagah 1600 karor kyun, ek behad hi
Gambhir aarop hain. Is sawal ke jariye Rahul yeh janna chahtein hain, ki jab congress ke deal
mein ek jet 560 crore mein mil raha tha, toh BJP ussi jet ke liye usse lagbhag tiguni keemat
yaani ki 1600 crore kyun de rahin hain? Yehi sawal filhaal humare is video ke investigation
ka topic hain.

doston sawal ka jawaab dein use pehle yeh jannna jaroori hain
ki - ररररर ji 560 crore रर figure रर रररररर रररर. Iske
liye doston mujhe aapko 2007 se 2012 mein lekar jaana hoga.
2007 mein medium multiple role combat aircraft (MRCA) tender
launch Hua tha. Us waqt kai jaankaron nein pure saude ka
“andajit” aakar 10 billion dollar se 12 billion dollar ke aas
paas bataya tha.
India today, France 24, business standard aise aapko tamam
shotro mil. jayenge.

Chaliye hum maanke chaltein hain 10 billion dollar ki deal


thi. Isse Bhartiya rupaye mein parivartit karne ke liye hum
dollar rupee exchange rate lete hain. 2018 mein ek dollar ki
keemat takreeban ekhattar rupaye thi. Us hisaab se Bhartiya
rupayon mein sauda bharat ko ekhattar hazaar crore ka padta.
Ab prati jet ki keemat janne ke liye is rakam ko hum 126 se
bhag kartein hain, jo humein ek jet ki keemat dega. Yeh
takreeban panch sau teersat crore hoti hain. Issi Figure ko
round off karke 560 crore bola ja raha hain. Ab chahein aaap
2015 ke dollar rupee exchange rate lein jo ki chaasat rupaya
tha, toh aapko takreeban 520 crore prati jet ki keemat
millegi. Jaise Rahul Gandhiji ki shraddha. Yehi formula shayad
congress istemal kartein aayi Hain.

Lekin kya wakai mein sauda 10 billion dollar ka tha?

<play video>

Times of india, telegraph uk, live mint, dna ityaadi shotro se


hume dekh saktein hain ki saude $20 billion dollar aur shayad
usse Adheek ho gaya tha.

Ek aur fact hum dekh saktein hain – flyaway costs. “रररररररर


कॉस्ट” ररररर रर रररर समझने रर रर रररर ररर रर ररररर रर
रररररर रररर (मार्जिनल कॉस्ट) रर ररररर रररर रर, रररररर ररर
रररर रर ररररररर रर ररर रररररर ररररररर रर ररररररर
रररररर रर रररर ररररर ररर
रर रररररररर रर ररररर, रररररररररररर रररर रररर
रररररर ररररर रर रररररर रर रररर रररर - ररररररर रर
रररररर रर रररररर रर रररर रररर ररर

France ki senate jo Bhartiya parliament ki tarah hain, Rafale


aur anya defence deals ki keemat beech beech Mein public karti
hain. Agar hum 2013 ki published Data dekhein toh humein
rafale ke teen variants ki keemat milti hain. Rafale C ek
purana single seater version hain. Chaliye hum rafale C jo ki
sabse sasta number dikh raha hain, usko lekar challtein hain.
Ek rafale c ki flyaway cost 68.8 million euro batayi gayi
hain. 31 dec 2012 ko ek euro ke Bhartiya rupaye mein keemat –
85.30 tha. Us hisaab se Bhartiya rupaye mein hum dekhein toh
ek rafale C – 587 crore minimum ka aata hain.

Ab rahulji yeh kehna chahtein hain ki Fracne bharat ko isse


bhi kam daam mein, sare modifications jo Bhartiya vayusena ki
jaroorat hain, missiles ke saath, ररररररररर रररररर ke
saath, maintenance aur spare parts ke saath, operational
guarantee technology transfer ke saath … 560 crore prati jet
ke keemat mein dega?

Doston ya toh hum Bhartiya bewakoof hain, ya France wale. Ya


in dono se koi nahin, balki humein bewakoof banana ka prayas
kiya jaa raha hain.

Prakhyat defence industry daily ek jaani maani antarashtriya


publication hain jo ररररर रररररररर mamllo रर ररर
ररररररर hain mein Abhijet Iyer-Mitra ka bayan chaapa hain –
jisme unhone saaf kaha hain ki ररर रर ररररररररर ररररररर
ररररर ररररररररर ररर रर रररररर रररररर रर रररररर
रररर रर रररर रररर hoti toh wah 2009 रर ररररर ररर 27
रररररर रररर रर रररर रर kiya hota... ररर ररररर रर,
रररर रर रररर ररररर रर रररररररररररर रररर रर
रररररररर ररर

27 billion dollars doston … 27 billion !!

Toh doston aapne dekha ki kis prakar 2013 ko hi anumaneet


saude ka akaar 10 billion dollar se dugana se jyada hokar 20
billion dollar ke paar ho gaya tha. Toh Jab andajeet sauda ke
aakar hi dugana ho gaya Tha, tab prati jet keemat bhi 560
crore se badkar 1100 crore ke paar ho jaati hain. Yadi hum 25
billion dollar bhi le – toh ek jet ki andajeet keemat 1400
crore ke upar hogi.

Ek aur reference hum le saktein hain, wah hain brazil ka.


Brazil ko 2010 mein heavy discount mein 36 rafale Dassault
dena chahtha tha. Haalanki brazil gripen jets liye, lekin 2010
ki yeh price humein kuch andaaza de sakti hain – brazil ko ek
rafale jet 2010 ke version ka 1200 crore mein lagbhag padta.

Doston saaf hain ki Rahul Gandhiji ka kehna ki congress dwara


tay ek jet ki keemat 560 crore thi sarasar galat hain aur ek
jet ki keemat 1200 crore ke paar takreeban 1300-1400 crore
hoti.

Ab doston, hum yeh jaanenge ki modiji dwara hue rafale saude


mein ek jet ke keemat 1600 crore hain, ke figure Tak Rahul
Gandhiji kaise pahunche.

Hum jaante hain ki modi dwara tay kiye gaye purey sauda ka
aakar takreeban 58000 crore rupay. tha. Is saude mein 36 jet
hi liye jaane the. Agar saude ke aakar ko 36 se bhag kiya
jaaye toh hum dekhtein hain ki ek jet humein 1600 crore mein
milti hain.

Doston phir bhi keemat 200-300 crore jyaada hain.

Lekin kya yeh wahi jet hain jo congress ne 2012 mein chuna tha
aur jiske liye negotiations ho rahin thi? Kya Maruti ka swift
ka purana model aur naye model ki keemat ek hoti hain? Dono
modelon mein farak nahin hota?

issi prakar se modi dwara Bhartiya vayusena ke liye liya gaya


jet F3 R version pe aadharit hain. Yeh hum iss liye keh
saktein hain kyun modiji ke rafale saude 2019 mein jab uska
upgrade aur development khatam ho jaata toh delivery tay thi.

Doston yeh hain F3 R versions mein naye features.

Doston humein maloom hain ki rafale ka f3 R version 2014


january mein announce hua tha, aur pehli udaan Dec 10, 2018 ko
hui thi. Rafale se pehli baar meteor missile test fire issi
saal, 13 february ko kiya gaya. Bharat ko pehla rafale 2019
mein milne wala hain.

Humein yeh bhi maloom hain ki congress dwara hui rafale deal
agar 2013 mein sign ho gayi hoti, toh 2015 mein 18 rafale jet
jo France mein banenge, mil jaate. Jaahir si baat hain yeh
purana version hota. Upgrade ke liye humein alag se paise dene
hotein. France mirage 2000 ke upgrade free mein nahin deta toh
kya rafale ka upgrade khairat mein dega?

Toh pehli baat toh yeh hain ki jet Purane model ka nahin tha.
Sarvajanik jankari se yeh pata chalta hain ki naye model ka
prati jet ki keemat takreeban pachas pratishat badh gayi thi,
in upgrades ke karan. France senate ne rafale f3 r ka flyaway
cost abhi tak public nahin kiya hain.

Doston, iske alawa modiji dwara is deal mein har jet ke liye
missillein bhi shameel Hain. Kuch stotro dwara yeh jaankari
hain ki Congress dwara hue saude mein kewal fracne mein nirmit
18 rafale jet missile package ke saath aate hote. Lekin kaunsi
aur. Kitni yeh jaankari nahin hain. Bharat mein nirmit hone
wali baaki ki 108 jets ke saath koi missile package nahin thi.

Aaye missilles k e baare mein aur unki andazit keemat ke


baarein mein jaane.
Scalp ek - low-observable air-launched cruise missile hain,
jiski range 560 km tak hain. Ek missile takreeban 6 crore 90
lakh Ki aayegi.

Meteor missile – ek european radar guided beyond-visual-range air-to-air


missile jiski range 100 km se adhik hain. Iska matlab ki dushman jets pe humare
pilots 100 km se bhi jyaada duri se fire kar saktein hain. Bharat ki astra missile ki
filhaall range 60 km hain. Ek aur farak hain ki meteor missile ramjet engine istemal
karti hain. Aur maujuda air to air missiles se iska pradarshan 3 se 6 guna behtar
maana gaya hai. Ek meteor missile ki keemat lagbhag saade atharah crore hain.

MICA missiles – yeh ek anti-air multi-target, all weather, fire-and-forget short aur
medium-range missile system. hain. Iski ek round takreeban 19 crore
rupay Ki aati hain.

Sarvajanik jaankari ke aadhar par hum keh saktein hain ki


modiji ne takreeban panch hazaar teen sau crore ki missilein
li hain, jo ki lagbhag prati jet 148 crore padti hain. Yeh
dhanrashi us 1600 crore ke andaar hi aati hain.

Doston ek aur tareeka hain humein dekhne ke liye ki kya modi


dwara rafale deal wakai mein ghaate ka sauda hain. Congress ne
Yeh aarop lagaya gaya hain ki katar aur misra nein humse saste
mein rafale deal ki hain. M
2015 mein Qatar aur Egypt ne rafale jet liye the aur bharat ne
final deal 2016 mein ki thi. Deal ke size ko dollar se rupaye
mein convert karke, us deal mein liye gaye jet ki sankhya se
bhag. Karein toh. hum dekhtein hain ki Qatar ko prati jet 1925
crore mein padta hain. Qatar ki yeh deal bharat se milti julti
hain, aur Qatar ko bhi pehla jet 2019 mein deliver hona hain.

Doston Egypt mein bhi rafale jet ki deal thi. Is deal mein ek
frigate bhi shamil tha, jo ki sarvajanik jankari dwara maana
jaaye toh 670 million euro ka tha. Chaliye egype ke is deal
mein se 700 million euro nikal dete hain toh 5.2 billion mein
bachta hain 4.5 billion euro. Feb 2015 ko rupaya euro
exchange rate 70.5 tha, aur is aadhar par hum dekhtein hain
Egypt ko yeh jet 13218750000, takreeban 1322 crore mein padta
hain. Yeh purana version that kyun ki Egypt ko yeh jet. 2015
se hi deliver ho rahin thi. Ek aur baat ki Egypt ke rafale
mein nuclear missile le jaane ki aur fire karne ki kshamta
nahin hain.

Qatar ne haal hi mein 12 aur rafale ka order kiya hain, jo


usse prati jet 92 miilion euro mein mil rahe hain – jo
Bhartiya rupaye mein prati jet 741 crore lagbhag hoti hain jo
missiles ke bina hain. Bharat ke pass bhi 18 units aur
kharidne ke options hain. Yeh options issi range mein honge,
kyunki logistic support, assembly, maintenance infrastructure,
training, ityaadi pehle hi base saude mein cover ho chuke
hain.

Agar in dono deal ko dekha jaaye toh bharat ka deal aisa nahin
dikh raha hain jo ek bade scam ki taraf Issara kar raha ho.
Bharat ko prati jet 1600 crore rupaye mein padti hain aur
package mein yeh sab cheezen shaamel hain.

5 साल के रखरखाव की प्रर्िबद्धिा, डसॉल्ट एर्वएशन की र्जम्मेदारी के रूप में लडाकू


र्वमान की 75% उपलब्धिा (वििमान उपलब्धिा के आं कडे 45-55% के बीच हैं ), 10
IAF पायलट ं का प्रर्शक्षण, द IAF र्िकान ं पर logistic support, मौजूदा र्मराज
लडाकू र्वमान अपग्रेड और भारि में 50% ऑफसेट र्नवेश शार्मल हैं ।

राहुल गां धीजी के राफेल सौदें की कीमिें 2007-11 के अनुमान ं पर आधाररि हैं , र्जसमें
जीवन चक्र (लाईफ-साइर्कल) और र्मसाइल ं की लागि शार्मल नहीं है ।
कां ग्रेस बुर्नयादी र्वमान की कीमि बिािे हुए भ्रम पैदा कर रही है , जब यह स्पष्ट रूप
से 1200 कर ड से परे था। 2013 में ही, सौदे की लागि बढ़कर 20 बिबियन डॉिर
से कहीं ज्यादा अर्धक ह गई थी।
560 करोड़ रुपये प्रबि बिमान के आं कड़े का दािा करने में कांग्रेस गिि है।
हालााँ र्क, पैकेज अलग-अलग हैं - साविजर्नक सूत् ं और र्वमान ं की इकाइय ं के साथ
पैकेज लागि ं क र्वभार्जि करने की पद्धर्ि का उपय ग करके, हम दे ख सकिे हैं र्क
भारि ने प्रत्येक लडाकू र्वमान के र्लए किर से अर्धक का भुगिान नहीं र्कया है ।
katar bhartiya package ke sabse nazdeek aata hain.

aane wale satyanweshi videos mein hum dekhenge –


126 rafales ki jagan 36 kyun?
HAL ko rafale na dekar, Anil Ambani ko kyun?
manohar parrikar ke 90,000 crore ya 1 lakh 30 hazar crore ka
raaz kya hain?
kya technology transfer na milna, bharat ke liye nuksandeh
saabbeet hoga?
rafale hi kyun? kya rafale ke liye niyamo ki andhekhi ki gayi?

You might also like