You are on page 1of 12

Polymer Testing 60 (2017) 229e235

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Polymer Testing
journal homepage: www.elsevi er.com/ locate/po ly t est

Material Properties

Creep-ratcheting behavior of PTFE gaskets under various


temperatures
Xiaotao Zheng*, Xiang Wen, Wei Wang, Jiuyang Gao, Wei Lin, Linwei Ma, Jiuyang Yu
Hubei Provincial Key Laboratory of Chemical Equipment Intensification and Intrinsic Safety, School of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, Wuhan
Institute of Technology, Wuhan 430205, PR China

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history:
Compressive creep-fatigue experiments on PTFE gaskets with small
Received 3 March 2017
Accepted 5 April 2017 stress amplitude were tested. The effects of peak holding times and
Available online 6 April 2017
temperatures on creep-ratcheting behaviors were further discussed.
Keywords: Results showed that at room temperature, the accumulated creep-
Creep-fatigue
Peak holding time
ratcheting strain corresponding to 400 cycles for peak holding 1min is
PTFE gaskets nearly 1.06 times that for peak holding time 0.5min and 1.3 times that
Compressive loads
Ratcheting without peak holding. While, at 100 C, 150 C and 200 C, they are
almost 1.1 times and 1.6 times, 1.1 times and 1.7 times, 1.05 times and 1.9
times, respectively. This means although the accumulated creep-
ratcheting strains for peak holding 0.5min and 1min are very close to
each other, but short peak holding time still has obvious effect on the
accumulated deformation comparing that without peak holding.
Moreover, the creep-ratcheting deformation with short peak holding time
and small stress amplitude for PTFE gaskets can be simply estimated by
the corresponding compressive static creep strain at the same peak
stress in practical engineering with relatively good accuracy.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction has become an important index for engineering


design to avoid excessive accumulated plastic
Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) materials, which deformation [4,5]. Until now, many researchers
have excellent corrosive resistance and electrical investigated the ratcheting behaviors of metal
resistance and so on, are widely applied as gaskets, materials considering the impacts of temperature-
cladding or other functional components in and time-dependency [6,7], multiaxial feature [8,9],
petrochemical engineering, chemical engineering anelastic effect [10], mean stress [11] and so on.
and electrical fields, especially as gaskets in bolted Recently, the ratcheting deformation of polymer
flange connection joints. In practical engineering, materials has also been
bolted flange connection joints are usually subjected
to creep, fatigue or creep-fatigue loading, especially
with small stress amplitude [1e3]. Therefore, it is
* Corresponding author.
necessary to investi- gate the mechanical behavior of
E-mail address: xiaotaozheng@163.com (X.
PTFE gasket to evaluate its safety under the these Zheng).
loads.
Ratcheting deformation is a typical mechanical
behavior of materials under reversed loads, which
investigated. The accumulated deformation of an should be considered to assess the tightness of
epoxy polymer under cyclic tension and compression bolted flange connection joints under these loads.
has been studied by Shen and Xia [12,13], and Chen et al. [20,21] investigated the ratcheting
viscoelastic constitutive models were proposed to behavior of PTFE under cyclic compression
predict its ratcheting response. Tao et al. [14,15] considering the influence of stress rate. However,
investigated the ratcheting behavior of an epoxy there are still few researches on the ratcheting
polymer and its effect on fatigue life. Moreover, PTFE behavior of PTFE materials under cyclic
materials exhibit significant temperature- and time- compressive loads with small stress amplitude.
dependence under relatively high temperature In the previous study, time- and temperature-
[16,17]. Tem- perature- and time-dependent dependent ratcheting of PTFE gasket under cyclic
ratcheting behavior at elevated temperature and compressive loads with small stress amplitude has
room temperature of PTFE have further been been investi- gated by authors of this paper [22].
studied by Zhang and Chen [18,19]. In practical Furthermore, PTFE gaskets are also usually subjected
engineering, PTFE gaskets are always subjected to to creep-fatigue loads with small stress amplitude.
compressive loads, especially with small stress The creep-ratcheting deformation of PTFE gasket
amplitude under vibration loads. Therefore, under
tempera- ture- and time-dependence of PTFE gaskets

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.2017.04.005
0142-9418/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
230 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 230

as shown in Fig. 3. Results show that the static


compressive creep-fatigue loads with small stress compressive
amplitude was further discussed in the following
paper.
In this study, uniaxial stress-controlled cyclic
compression ex- periments of PTFE gaskets were
tested under creep-fatigue loads with small stress
amplitude. Moreover, the creep-ratcheting de-
formations were discussed considering the effects of
peak holding times and temperatures.

2. Experimental procedures

The PTFE materials were machined to be circular


gaskets with inner diameter of 18 mm, outer
diameter of 45.6 mm and thickness of 3 mm.
Geometrical parameters of creep-fatigue specimens
are shown in Table 1. Additionally, geometrical
parameters of static creep specimens and ratcheting
specimens can be found in the previous literature
[22]. It should be noted that small machining errors
were produced, but the same peak stress were used
for each specimen. A plate compression clamp
was designed in RPL50 creep-fatigue machine to
test those specimens, as shown in Fig. 1. The axial
compressive strain was measured by a
tension- compression extensometer from room
temperature (RT) to elevated temperature. The
applied load path of compressive creep- fatigue
loading is shown in Fig. 2. The peaking holding
time in- cludes 0min, 0.5min, and 1min, and the
experimental temperatures are RT, 100 C, 150 C
and 200 C. To ensure the uniformity of
temperature distribution at high temperature, the
specimen was first heated to the experiment
temperature, and then held for
30 min before applying the compressive loading.
Except the peak holding stage, the applied
cyclic compressive loading is 6.46 ± 0.34 MPa
and the loading and unloading stress rate in each
test is 0.2 MPa/s. It should be noted that all the tested
strains and stresses are multiplied by 1 in the
following paper for clear expression.

3. Results and
discussion

3.1. Static creep under different


temperatures

To choose the peak holding time during creep-


fatigue experi- ments under various temperatures,
static compressive creep tests of PTFE gasket under
the same peak stress 6.8 MPa were performed firstly,
231 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 231

Fig. 2.
Loading
path.

Fig. 1. Testing set-up and


specimens.

Table 1
Geometrical parameters of PTFE specimens and loading conditions.

Temperature Loads (MPa) Peak holding (min) Parameters Before Testing (mm) After Testing (mm)

RT 6.46 ± 0.34 0.5 Outer radius 45.50 45.70


Inner radius 17.72 17.76
Thickness 3.02 2.98
100 C 6.46 ± 0.34 0.5 Outer radius 45.52 46.38
Inner radius 18.22 17.72
Thickness 3.00 2.87
150 C 6.46 ± 0.34 0.5 Outer radius 45.51 47.32
Inner radius 18.22 17.53
Thickness 2.93 2.62
200 C 6.46 ± 0.34 0.5 Outer radius 45.49 49.64
Inner radius 18.17 16.72
Thickness 3.03 2.41
RT 6.46 ± 0.34 1 Outer radius 45.52 45.73
Inner radius 18.22 18.33
Thickness 2.98 2.90
100 C 6.46 ± 0.34 1 Outer radius 45.35 46.11
Inner radius 18.09 17.92
Thickness 2.95 2.86
150 C 6.46 ± 0.34 1 Outer radius 45.47 45.37
Inner radius 18.11 17.25
Thickness 3.02 2.7
200 C 6.46 ± 0.34 1 Outer radius 45.61 49.70
Inner radius 18.13 16.69
Thickness 3.05 2.13
232 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 232

creep is sensitive to temperature. At room 0min, 0.5min, and 1min are considered as peak
temperature, the creep strain is only 3.3% when the holding times for various creep-fatigue loads.
holding time is 1min. As the temper- ature
increases, the creep strain reaches 7.4% at 100 C,
3.2. Stress-strain responses under compressive creep-
10.4% at fatigue loads
150 C and 15.3% at 200 C, respectively, with the
same holding time. Moreover, the compressive The cyclic stress-strain curves of PTFE gaskets
creep curve with time can be divided into the under compres- sive creep-fatigue conditions with
primary stage and the steady stage. Namely, the the same peaking holding 1min and different
compressive creep strain increases rapidly in the temperatures of RT, 100 C, 150 C and 200 C are
primary stage, but increases slowly during the presented in Fig. 4. It should be noted that the stress
subsequent steady stage under various temperatures. and strain of this paper are average stress and
Especially, the compressive creep increases rapidly average strain due to small machining errors. It can
in the first 1min, but tends to be stable be seen from Fig. 4 that the cyclic stress- strain
subsequently. This means the key time for curves under compressive creep-fatigue loads are
compressive creep is the first 1min. Therefore, obviously influenced by peak holding times and
temperatures. This indicates the creep-ratcheting
behaviors of PTFE gaskets are typically tem-
perature- and time-dependent. Although short peak
holding time (1 min) is applied, significant creep
deformations take place at the first 3 to 5 cycles
under different temperatures, but slight creep
strains occur during the subsequent cycles.
Furthermore, according to the previous study [22],
ratcheting deformations increase with increasing
number of cycles even without peak holding due
to slight

opening of stress-strain curve, which shifts the


Fig. 3. Static creep strain of PTFE gasket under different temperatures. stress-strain curve to the right-hand direction.
Nearly the same phenomenon can be found for those
stress-strain curves with short peak holding time
after the first 3 to 5 cycles. This indicates although
slight creep deformations are produced for the
subsequent cycles, ratcheting strains due to slight
opening of stress-strain curves become sig- nificant.
It should be noted that the strain increment of each
cycle becomes increasingly smaller with increasing
number of cycles due to the compressive hardening
behavior of PTFE material.
233 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 233

Fig. 4. Cyclic stress-strain curve of PTFE gasket under various creep-fatigue loads.
234 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 234

Fig. 5. Compressive stress-strain curves of PTFE gasket for the first cycle.

The stress-strain curves for the first cycle with the


same peak holding time and different temperatures
are shown in Fig. 5. It can be seen that the creep
strain as well as the mechanical strain for the first
cycle increase significantly with the increase of
temperature. The maximum strain for the first cycle
is about 3.64% at room temperature. As the
temperature increases from 100 C to 200 C, the
maximum strain for the first cycle increases rapidly
(8.12% at
100 C; 12.51% at 150 C; 19.88% at 200 C), as shown in Fig. 5.

3.3. Accumulated creep-ratcheting responses


Compressive creep-ratcheting experiments were C, and 15.9%, 28.4% and 29.8% at 200 C,
performed under the same mean stress 6.46 MPa, correspondingly. This in- dicates that the steady
the same stress amplitude ratcheting strains corresponding to 400 cycles at
0.34 MPa, the same stress rate 0.2 MPa/s, but 100 C, 150 C and 200 C are nearly two, three
different tempera- tures (RT, 100 C, 150 C and and five times that at room temperature when the
200 C) and different peak holding times (0min, peak holding time is zero. While the accumulated
0.5min and 1min). All tests were performed up to 400 strains are nearly three, four and eight times that
cycles to assure accumulated creep-ratcheting at room temperature when the peak holding time
strains become stable. To obtain the accumulated is
creep-ratcheting deformation, the maximum 1min. The above observation means that the
compressive strains for each cycle with the same accumulated compressive strain is sensitive to
peak holding time under different temperatures are temperature. Furthermore, only slight creep-
presented in Fig. 6. It can be seen clearly that ratcheting strain accumulates at room temperature,
significant creep-ratcheting de- formations are while the accumulated creep-ratcheting strain of
produced even if small stress amplitude and short PTFE gaskets in- creases rapidly when the
peak holding time are applied. Moreover, the temperature is raised, especially over
accumulated creep- ratcheting deformation for each 100 C. That is reasonable because the time-
case becomes stable after about dependent creep strain and material softening are
100 cycles. At room temperature, the accumulated significantly influenced by temperature. Therefore,
creep-ratcheting strains corresponding to 400 cycles the compressive creep-ratcheting behavior of
for peak holding times of 0min, PTFE gaskets should be considered when they are
0.5min and 1min are, respectively, 2.9%, 3.6% and applied over 100 C.
3.8%. As the temperature increases, the To investigate the effect of peak holding time on
accumulated creep-ratcheting strains reach 7.0%, the accumu- lated compressive strains under creep-
9.7% and 11.0% at 100 C, 9.9%, 15.1% and 16.8% at 150 fatigue loads, the maximum
235 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 235

Fig. 6. Accumulated strain of PTFE gasket with the same peak holding time under
different temperatures.

strain for each cycle with the same temperature and


different peak holding times are presented in Fig. 7.
Results show that the accu- mulated creep-
ratcheting strain corresponding to 400 cycles for
peak holding time 0.5min is relatively approach to
that for peak holding time 1min, but both of them
are obvious greater than that without peak holding
under various temperatures. This indicates the
creep strain produced during peak holding time
must be considered to investigate the accumulated
deformation of PTFE gasket, even very short peak
holding times are used, such as 0.5min or 1min. At
room temperature, the accumulated strain corre-
sponding to 400 cycles for peak holding 1min is
nearly 1.06 times
236 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 236

Fig. 7. Accumulated compressive strain of PTFE gasket with the same temperature and different peak holding times.

that for peak holding time 0.5min and 1.3 times


that for peak holding time 0min. While, at 100 C,
150 C and 200 C, they are almost 1.1 times and Fig. 8. Accumulated strain rate of PTFE gasket under different creep-fatigue
conditions.
1.6 times, 1.1 times and 1.7 times, 1.05 times and 1.9
times, respectively. This means although the
accumulated creep-ratcheting strains for peak
holding time 0.5min and 1min are very close to each
other, the short peak holding time still has sig-
nificant effect on the accumulated deformation
comparing that without peak holding.
Creep-ratcheting evolutions with number of
cycles in these cases are similar to those static
creep curves, which can also be
237 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 237

mainly divided into two stages: the primary stage and the steady
stage. In the primary stage, the accumulated creep-ratcheting de-
formations under various temperatures and peak holding times
increase obviously in the first 100 cycles and, subsequently, reach a
steady stage with an almost constant strain rate per cycle. To
research the two stages of creep-ratcheting evolution with
increasing cycles systematically, the strain rates as a function of
cycles under various creep-fatigue conditions are illustrated in
Fig. 8. From the figure, the strain rate per cycle in the primary stage
decreases rapidly during about the first 20 cycles, especially about
the first 3 cycles, and then it reaches a steady stage with an almost
constant strain rate per cycle, which represents the steady stage.
That's reasonable because only the small stress amplitude was
applied on those creep-fatigue specimens, the creep strains pro-
duced during peak holding are obvious greater than ratcheting
strains due to slight opening of stress-strain curves. Moreover, the
creep strains under various temperatures only increase rapidly
during about the first 1 min, and then increase slowly. It should be
noted that the steady creep-ratcheting rates per cycle under various
conditions are much less than that in the primary stage. Therefore,
the influence of deformation on the sealing performance of PTFE
gaskets under creep-fatigue conditions with small stress amplitude
can be characterized by the accumulated strain produced in the
primary stage, especially over 100 C.

3.4. Comparison of accumulated creep-ratcheting strain and static


creep

In order to compare the accumulated creep-ratcheting strains


and the static creep strains at the same holding time, the
238 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 238

Fig. 9. Comparison of accumulated creep-ratcheting strain and static creep of PTFE gaskets.

accumulated creep-ratcheting deformations with time were 6.8 MPa and the same stress rate 0.2 MPa/s under 150 C, but they
calculated based on the stress rate and the peak holding time, are obviously greater than the static creep strain at 200 C. More-
which are superposed on the static creep evolutions with time over, the ratcheting deformations at the stress rate 0.1 MPa/s and
under various temperatures, as shown in Fig. 9. Considering the 0.15 MPa/s are nearly equal to the corresponding creep strain at the
effect of stress rate on the accumulated deformations, the ratch- same peak stress. This indicates that the accumulated creep-
eting deformations at the stress rate of 0.1 MPa/s, 0.15 MPa/s and ratcheting deformations with short peak holding time and small
0.2 MPa/s were further depicted at 100 C, as shown in Fig. 10. stress amplitude and the ratcheting deformation under cyclic loads
Results indicate that the accumulated creep-ratcheting strains with with small stress amplitude are both relatively approach to the
small stress amplitude for peak holding 0.5min and 1min are static compressive creep with the same peak stress under 150 C,
slightly greater than the static creep strain at the same peak stress although a little errors can be found considering the effect of stress
rate and peak holding time. In the previous study [22], although the
static compressive creep strains at 100 C, 150 C and 200 C are
almost two, three and five times of that at room temperature, they
are still slightly greater than the corresponding ratcheting strain at
the same temperature. Therefore, the creep-ratcheting deforma-
tion with short peak holding time and small stress amplitude for
PTFE gaskets can be simply estimated by the corresponding
compressive static creep strain at the same peak stress in practical
engineering with relatively good accuracy under various temper-
atures. It is very useful for the safety assessment of bolted flange
joints with PTFE gaskets under high temperature and small fluc-
tuation loads with short peak holding time.

4. Conclusions

Stress-controlled compressive creep-ratcheting deformations of


PTFE gaskets under small stress amplitude and short holding times
Fig. 10. Comparison of accumulated strain of PTFE gaskets under different stress rates were investigated and discussed systematically. The main conclu-
and peak holding times at 100 C. sions are as follows:
239 X. Zheng
X. Zheng
et al.
et /al.Polymer
/ Polymer
Testing
Testing
60 (2017)
60 (2017)
229e235
229e235 239

(1) The creep-ratcheting deformations with short peak holding prediction from short term stress relaxation tests, ASME J. Press. Vessel
Technol. 138 (2016). #031401.
time and small stress amplitude for PTFE gaskets are slightly
[4] X.T. Zheng, F.Z. Xuan, Shakedown analysis of multilayered beams coupled
greater than the static creep strain at the same peak stress with ductile damage, Nucl. Eng. Des. 250 (2012) 14e22.
6.8 MPa, which can be simply estimated by the corre- [5] X.T. Zheng, C.F. Peng, A unified shakedown assessment method for butt
welded joints with various weld groove shapes, J. Press. Vessel Technol. 137
sponding compressive static creep strain at the same peak
(2015) 021404.
stress in practical engineering with relatively good accuracy [6] W. Wang, X.T. Zheng, J.Y. Yu, W. Lin, C.G. Wang, J.M. Xu, Time-dependent
under 150 C. ratcheting of 35CrMo structural steel at elevated temperature considering
stress rates, Mater. High. Temp. 34 (2017) 172e178. http://dx.doi.org/10.
(2) The static compressive creep curve is sensitive to tempera- 1080/09603409.2016.1261511.
ture. The creep strain is only 3.3% when the holding time is [7] X.T. Zheng, K.W. Wu, W. Wang, J.Y. Yu, J.M. Xu, L.W. Ma, Low cycle fatigue and
1 min at room temperature, which reaches 7.4% at 100 ratcheting behavior of 35CrMo structural steel at elevated temperature, Nucl.
C, Eng. Des. (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2017.01.016. NED
9129.
10.4% at 150 C and 15.3% at 200 C, respectively. Especially, [8] X. Chen, R. Jiao, Modified kinematic hardening rule for multiaxial ratcheting
the compressive creep increases rapidly in about the first prediction, Int. J. Plasticity 20 (2004) 871e898.
1min, but tends to be stable subsequently. This means the [9] X. Chen, R. Jiao, K.S. Kim, On the Ohno-Wang kinematic hardening rules for
multiaxial ratcheting modeling of medium carbon steel, Int. J. Plasticity 21
key time for compressive creep is the first 1min. (2005) 161e184.
(3) At room temperature, the accumulated creep-ratcheting [10] X.T. Zheng, F.Z. Xuan, P. Zhao, Ratcheting-creep interaction of advanced 9-12%
strain corresponding to 400 cycles for peak holding 1min is chromium ferrite steel with anelastic effect, Int. J. Fatigue 33 (2011)
1286e1291.
nearly 1.06 times that for peak holding 0.5min and 1.3 times [11] D.L. Wu, F.Z. Xuan, S.J. Guo, P. Zhao, Uniaxial mean stress relaxation of 9-12%
that without peak holding. While, at 100 C, 150 C Cr steel at high temperature: experiments and viscoplastic constitutive
and modeling, Int. J. Plast. 77 (2016) 156e173.
[12] X. Shen, Z. Xia, F. Ellyin, Cyclic deformation behavior of an epoxy polymer.
200 C, they are almost 1.1 times and 1.6 times, 1.1 times and Part I: experimental investigation, Polym. Eng. Sci. 44 (12) (2004) 2240e2246.
1.7 times, 1.05 times and 1.9 times, respectively. This means [13] Z. Xia, X. Shen, F. Ellyin, Cyclic deformation of an epoxy polymer. Part II:
although the accumulated creep-ratcheting strains for peak prediction of viscoelastic constitutive models, Polym. Eng. Sci. 45 (2005)
103e113.
holding 0.5min and 1min are very close to each other, short
[14] G. Tao, Z. Xia, Ratcheting behavior of an epoxy polymer and its effect on fa-
peak holding time still has significant effect on the accu- tigue life, Polym. Test. 26 (2007) 451e460.
mulated deformation comparing that without peak holding. [15] G. Tao, Z. Xia, Biaxial fatigue behavior of an epoxy polymer with mean stress
effect, Int. J. Fatigue 31 (2009) 678e685.
[16] A.S. Khan, H. Zhang, Finite deformation of a polymer: experiments and
Acknowledgments modeling, Int. J. Plasticity 17 (2001) 1167e1188.
[17] P.J. Rae, D.M. Dattelbaum, The properties of poly(tetrafluoroethylene) (PTFE)
in tension, Polymer 45 (2004) 7615e7625.
This work was financially supported by Hubei Provincial
[18] Z. Zhang, X. Chen, Multiaxial ratcheting behavior of PTFE at room tempera-
Department of Education Science and Technology Research Pro- ture, Polym. Test. 28 (2009) 288e295.
gram (D20161508). [19] Z. Zhang, X. Chen, Y.P. Wang, Uniaxial ratcheting behavior of polytetra-
fluoroethylene at elevated temperature, Polym. Test. 29 (2010) 352e357.
[20] X. Chen, S. Hui, Ratcheting behavior of PTFE under cyclic compression, Polym.
References Test. 24 (2005) 829e833.
[21] Z. Zhang, X. Chen, T. Wang, A simple constitutive model for cyclic compressive
[1] J.Q. Guo, X.T. Zheng, Y. Zhang, H.C. Shi, W.Z. Meng, A unified continuum ratchetting deformation of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) with stress rate
damage mechanics model for predicting the stress relaxation behavior of effects, Polym. Eng. Sci. 48 (2008) 29e36.
high-temperature bolting, ASME J. Press. Vessel Technol. 136 (2013). [22] X.T. Zheng, X. Wen, J.Y. Gao, J.Y. Yu, W. Lin, J.M. Xu, Temperature-dependent
#011203. ratcheting of PTFE gaskets under cyclic compressive loads with small stress
[2] J.Q. Guo, W.Z. Meng, X.T. Zheng, L. Tian, H.C. Shi, Prediction of stress relaxation amplitude, Polym. Test. 57 (2017) 296e301.
from creep data in terms of average creep rate, J. Strain Analysis Eng. Des. 50
(2015) 15e24.
[3] J.Q. Guo, F. Li, X.T. Zheng, H.C. Shi, W.Z. Meng, An accelerated method for creep

You might also like