You are on page 1of 7

Applied Geochemistry, Vol. 11,pp.355-361.

1996
Pergamon Copyright 0 1996 ElsevierScienceLtd
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved
0883-2927/96$15.00+ 0.00

Impacts of mining on the environment; some local, regional and global


issues
Iain Thornton
Environmental Geochemistry Research, Centre for Environmental Technology, Imperial College of Science,
Technology and Medicine, London SW7 2BP, U.K.

Abstract-The mining, processing and utilisation of metals dates back to Roman times and earlier with
extensive developments in many parts of the world by the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Many
mineral&d areas are no longer worked leaving a legacy of dereliction and contaminated land and drainage.
This paper discusses the sources and dispersion of metals from mining and smelting activities, factors
influencing their pathways into the foodchain and potential impacts on plant, animal and human health. The
importance of mineral and chemical forms of metals in soils is discussed in relation to their bioavailabihty.
Reference is made to research in the U.K., Greece and Brazil. Copyright 0 1996 Elsevier Science Ltd

INTRODUCTION defined fugitive emissions, and from the storage and


transport of metal-rich materials. The question we
The general area of environmental geochemistry have to ask today is to what degree is the impact of this
encompasses the many factors that influence the contamination acceptable or unacceptable in terms of
sources, dispersion and distribution of elements in sustainable agriculture and food production, the
the environment, their pathways into soils, foodstuffs quality of surface and ground waters used for potable
and water supplies and their influence on plant, supplies and for irrigation, and possible adverse
animal and human health (Thornton, 1993a). It is effects on human health. Other concerns are possible
now recognised that the mining of metalliferous damage to natural ecosystems, including soil degrada-
mineral deposits and associated smelting and metal tion and damage to wildlife and native flora.
processing activities has lead to perturbations in the In this context, it is important to remember that
cycling of metals in the surface environment. Con- metals are ubiquitous in the environment, being
tamination arising from such activities is a global or present usually in small amounts in rocks and soils,
world-wide problem; understanding the processes that air, water and food. Some geological materials,
control the behaviour and impacts of this will provide including marine black shales and basic igneous
a major challenge to the environmental geochemist for rocks, often contain large amounts of metals and are
the next decade or more. associated with what has recently been described as
Man’s first use of metals for the manufacture of “natural contamination”. Although many metals
simple tools, weapons and ornaments dates back to have an essential role as nutrients for plants, animals
the Bronze Age, and during the period of the Roman and man, some if present in sufficient quantities and in
Empire mining of Fe, Au, Ag, Sn, Cu and Pb was certain forms may also be toxic. Copper and Zn
active. The expansion of the manufacturing industry provide clear examples, both being essential micro-
during the Industrial Revolution brought about an nutrients and both being toxic to plants and animals in
increasing need for metals which has continued into high concentrations.
the 20th Century. Their use in the manufacturing and This paper focusses on some local and regional
other industries is now a normal part of industrial life. studies undertaken at Imperial College into the
Metals are now mined in the majority of the countries environmental impacts of mining. These concern the
of the world and primary production of many metals Pb, Cd, and Hg, and the metalloid As, their
continues to rise (see Table 1). The production of Pb pathways in the soil-plant-animal system and impli-
provides a useful example. In 1990, 155 mines in 35 cations to health. The results of these investigations
countries produced 3.3 million tonnes. However are extrapolated into the broader global picture,
recycling plays an increasingly important role. Of the drawing attention to gaps in present day knowledge
total world production in 1990 which exceeded 5.6 and identifying research priorities for the future.
million tonnes in over 50 countries, over 41% was
derived from recycled materials.
By the very nature of the large quantities of GEOCHEMICAL MAPS
materials handled, mining and smelting activities
give rise to some degree of contamination of soil, air Geochemical maps and atlases provide both sys-
and water. This may result from controlled emissions, tematic baseline information on the natural distribu-
subject to the regulatory process, from less well tion of metals and data showing the extent and degree

355
356 I. Thornton

Table 1. Changes in the primary production of metals (lo3 tonnes/a)

Year

Metal 1930 1950 1980 1985 1990

Al 120 1500 15,395 13,690 16,420


Cd 1.3 6 15 19 20
Cf 560 2270 11,248 11,630 12,850
CU 1611 2791 7984 8933 9458
Fe 80,180 1189,000 7‘18,070 714,800 842,710
Pb 1696 1752 3096 3558 3314
Mn 3491 5800 22,950 23,400 23,856
H8 3.8 4.9 7.1 6.8 5.1
Ni 22 144 744 744 949
Sn 179 172 198 158 211
V - 1.8 35 ? 33.8
Zn 1394 1985 6155 6849 7100

Source:
U.S. Bureau of Mines.
Metallgesellschaft.
American Bureau of Metal Statistics.

of regional contamination arising from man’s activ- between individual animals, broadly reflect the Pb
ities (Webb, 1964; Thornton, 1993a). In the context of content of the soils on which the animals have grazed.
this paper, the prototype Wolfson Geochemical Atlas Faecal analysis has shown accidently ingested soil to
of England and Wales (Webb et al., 1978) clearly be the major source of Pb intake (Thornton and
shows anonomalies for Pb, Zn, Cd, Cu and As in Abrahams, 1983). Soil ingestion usually ranges from
mineralised areas within which mining and smelting l-15% of the dry matter intake ofcattle and may be as
operations have resulted in extensive contamination large as 20 or 30% in sheep, which graze closer to the
of the surface environment, as illustrated for As (Fig. ground. There would however seem to be little impact
1). Geochemical maps continue to be compiled by the on the composition of meat and dairy products, with
British Goelogical Survey in Britain and by other the exception of liver and kidney. However since offal
institutions in some 30 other countries (Plant et al., is normally a minor part of the diet, it is unlikely to
1989). result in any significant increase in human uptake
(Alloway et al., 1988).
Concentrations of Pb in garden vegetables in
LEAD mining areas of Derbyshire were 2 to 4 times higher
than those studied in urban gardens with 13% of the
The metal Pb is not essential to either plant or vegetables, in particular lettuce and spinach, exceed-
animal life. If present in large amounts, in certain ing the current statutory limit of 1 pg/g fresh weight in
mineral and chemical forms, it may be toxic and saleable food (Moir, 1992).
indeed is a powerful neutrotoxin. In inner city areas, the main route of Pb exposure to
Some 4000 km* of agricultural and urban land in young children, aged 6-36 months, arises from direct
Britain is contaminated with Pb to varying degrees, ingestion of dust and soil by hand to mouth activity
mostly arising from historical mining and smelting (Davies et al., 1990). It has been estimated that a 2 a-
activities (Thornton, 1980). This includes an area of ca old child will ingest approximately 100 mg of dust per
250 km* in the old mining/smelting area of Derbyshire day by this route. However, within the old mining
in central England, where surface soils on farmland village of Winster in Derbyshire, children’s blood Pb
and in local village gardens contain from several values were within a normal range even when Pb in
hundred to several thousand ppm Pb, with around garden soils and housedust was highly elevated.
l-3% Pb immediately adjacent to old workings Analysis of individual particles of soil and dust by
(Colboume and Thornton, 1978; Cotter-Howells and scanning electron microscopy and X-ray analysis
Thornton, 1991). showed the mineral pyromorphite [Pbs(PO&Cl] to
Agricultural studies have shown uptake of Pb into be a principle Pb-bearing constituent (Cotter-Howells
pasture herbage varies appreciably throughout the and Thornton, 1991). This Pb-phosphate mineral has
year, though it is relatively low throughout the grazing a very low solubility and its abundance almost
season of cattle. A marked seasonal rise in winter is a certainly contributes to the low bioavilability of Pb
possible hazard to grazing sheep. Blood Pb levels in in these soils, limiting the uptake of Pb by the child. In
cattle, although showing considerable variation this location, total concentrations of Pb in garden soils
Fig. 1. Map showing the distribution of arsenic in England and Wales.

ranged from 2400 to 22,800 pg/g (geometric mean and/or exposure routes to the young child is different
7140), while the mean blood value for ten l-8 a-old in this situation to that in Derbyshire.
children was 9.4 pg/lOO mL.
In contrast, a study of Pb and other heavy metals in
the town of Lavrion, 54 km to the SE of Athens, where CADMIUM
mining and smelting activities ranged from ancient to
recent times, showed markedly raised concentrations Cadmium is also a natural component of the
of Pb in blood and deciduous teeth. Here, where the ecosystem and has a similar geochemical behaviour
median value for Pb in garden soil is 6400 pg/g and in to Zn. It is present as a constituent of several Zn
house dust 3200 pg/g, the mean blood value in 255 minerals particularly the sulphide, sphalerite, and the
primary school children was 19.24 pg/lOO mL carbonate, smithsonite. Where Zn mining has taken
compared with 5.14 in a control group (Stavrakis et place in the past, it is common for soils to be enriched
al., 1994). It is obvious that the bioavailability of Pb in both Zn and Cd, normally showing ratios between
358 I. Thornton

100: 1 to 4OO:l. Mining at Shipham in SW England been related to increased risks of skin and internal
within the period 1700-1850 has resulted in extremely cancers (Chen et al., 1985, 1992). This concern is
high concentrations of both Cd and Zn in soils, compounded by similar reports from India (Chakra-
ranging up to 600 pg/g Cd and 6% Zn (Thornton, borti and Saha, 1987), and has led to a reduction in the
1988). Several agricultural and garden plants exhibit Provisional Guideline Value for As in potable waters
symptoms of leaf chlorosis in spring due to Zn from 50 to 10 ppb (World Health Organisation, 1993)
toxicity. However, the Cd content of pasture grasses and a proposal to markedly reduce the permissible
rarely exceeded 3 pg/g DM. This has been ascribed to level of As in drinking waters in the United States
a restricted uptake by roots, high concentrations of Ca (Shank-Givens, 1994). This worldwide concern has
and Zn in the soils, and limited translocation from refocussed attention on possible health effects of As
root to shoot (Matthews, 1982). Although grazing contamination from mining and smelting.
cattle had a low Cu status possibly induced by Arsenic, together with Cu and Sn, has been mined
elevated Zn and Cd intake, there was no measurable and smelted in SW England for centuries. Over 700
increase in the Cd content of milk (Alloway et al., km* of agricultural and urban land are contaminated,
1988). A survey of over 300 houses in Shipham ranging up to 2500 pg/g As in soils and up to 460 pg/g
showed 90% of the garden soils to range from 20- in household dusts (Colboume et al., 1975; Abrahams
200 pg/g Cd, though uptake into locally grown and Thornton, 1987). A normal range for As con-
vegetable crops was relatively low due to the specia- centrations in agricultural soils in England and Wales
tion of the metal in the soil and the high soil pH (7.5- has been reported as 2-53 pg/g, with a median value of
7.8) which reflected the calcareous nature of the parent 10 fig/g (Archer and Hodgson, 1987). In the mining
material. However Cd concentrations were elevated in area, As uptake into pasture herbage showed a
leafy vegetables, including cabbage, kale, spinach and maximum concentration of 9.6 pg/g DM, possibly
lettuce, being 50-60 times the normal value for reflecting some degree of soil contamination (Thor-
elsewhere in the U.K. Shipam potatoes had about 4 esby and Thornton, 1979). Large contamination of
times the Cd concentrations normally found and these herbage by soil particularly in spring was later
comprised about 50% of the total home grown confirmed (Abrahams, 1983). Soil generally contrib-
vegetables consumed (Alloway et al., 1988). uted around 50-80% of the total As ingested by cattle,
Diary and duplicate diet studies showed Cd dietary up to a maximum of 97% (Thornton and Abrahams,
intakes to be higher than the average for the U.K., 1983; Abrahams and Thornton, 1994). Arsenic uptake
with some residents exceeding the Provisional Toler- into barley grain was very small, not exceeding 0.4 pg/
able Weekly Intake (PTWI) value of 0.4 mg per week g DM; As increased both in lettuce and strawberries
Cd. There were no overt effects on health and little or with soil content, peaking at 1.4 and 0.7 pg/g DM
no correlation was found between the biochemical respectively (Thoresby and Thornton, 1979).
parameters measured, including Bz microglobulin and In home gardens with soils ranging from 150 to 900
either Cd in soil or Cd in diet (Strehlow and Barltrop, pg/g total As, concentrations in onion, beetroot,
1988). It has previously been argued that the large carrot, pea and bean did not exceed 1 pg/g As fresh
amounts of Zn and Ca present in Shipham soils may wt., only exceeding this in lettuce (Xu and Thornton,
give some protection against possible adverse effects 1985) (Table 2). It was concluded that in this
of Cd, by competing for exchange sites on the root “geochemical hotspot” in Cornwall, plants were
surface and within the gastro-intestinal tract (Thorn- acting as “geochemical barriers” in the environment
ton, 1993a). and were only making a small contribution to human
exposure (Xu and Thornton, 1985). Speciation and
bioavailability in these soils has yet to be determined.
ARSENIC Some attempts have been made to determine As
exposure of young children from dusts and soils.
Recent concern with possible adverse effects of As Where housedusts ranged from 9-330 pg/g, it was
exposure has arisen as a result of case-control studies calculated that a young child could ingest as much as
in Taiwan, in which high concentrations of As in 42 pg per day (Johnson, 1983). It has been suggested
artesian well waters, ranging up to 600 fig/L, have that a young child in this heavily contaminated

Table 2. Concentrations of As in garden soils and vegetables in mineralised areas of Cornwall, England

Total As in Lettuce Onion Beetroot Carrot Pea Bean


soil olglg)
@g/g dry matter)

Range l&892 0.15-3.88 0.10-0.49 0.02-0.93 0.10-0.93 0.01-o. 11 0.02-0.09


Geometric mean 322 0.85 0.20 0.17 0.21 0.04 0.04
No. of samples 32 28 23 23 19 19 7
Mining on the environment; local, regional and global issues 359

environment may well have an As intake approaching European/Brazilian research team, with funding
or even exceeding the WHO PTDI for inorganic As of from the European Commission, investigated Hg
2 pg/kg body weight (World Health Organisation, levels in river sediments and waters, in fish and in
1983). However there are as yet no proven health blood and urine of Au miners and traders and in a
effects associated with As in the local populations, local fish-eating community in the valley of the river
though there is a need for careful assessment of Tapajos. Environmental samples again showed Hg
exposure and for epidemiological studies (Thornton, contamination, with several samples of floor dust
1993b). A recent pilot study has shown a small and taken from Au-trading houses, sometimes exceeding
non-significant increase in the prevelance of bladder 1% Hg with visible Hg in dusts at 2 locations (Cleary
cancer for residents in “high-As” areas of Devon and et al., 1994). Mercury levels in fish from 3 locations
Cornwall, where stream sediment concentrations were averaged 0.84,0.47,0.30 mg/kg fresh weight, ranging
above or equal to 100 pg/g As, in comparison with up to 2.6 mg/kg Hg (Table 3). Twenty-one of 52 fish
areas of lower concentration (Leonardi, 1994). samples exceeded the European Community Quality
Standard of 0.3 mg/kg Hg for a basket of fish
(Thornton et al., 1991).
MERCURY The data presented in Table 3, partly reported
previously (Cleary et al., 1994; Thornton et al.,
Mercury is a natural constituent of the ecosystem 1994), demonstrate excessive Hg exposure in a
though is not essential to plant or animal life. The significant number of the population resulting both
general population is mainly exposed to Hg through from fish consumption and from burning amalgam. It
the diet with the dominant source being CH3 Hg in could be expected that this exposure will lead to
fish. adverse health effects, including erethism, mercurial
Mercury has been used in the mining of Au for tremor, protinuria or contact dermatitus. Current
countless years to form an amalgam aiding the work, again funded by the European Commission,
separation of Au from other mineral phases. The includes an evaluation of the health impact of this
present day Au rush in Amazonia has led to losses of exposure in both Au miners and traders inhaling
Hg in the region of 1000 tonnes in Brazil alone over inorganic Hg vapour and in communities consuming
the last 10 or more years. Approximately 2 g of Hg are Hg contaminated fish and thus exposure to organic
used for each gram of Au reclaimed, of which some Hg (Thornton et al., 1994).
50% then passes into the river in the suspended slurry Similar Au-mining activities by the informal sector,
effluent. Studies by Brazilian research workers have using Hg in the mining process, are taking place within
clearly shown severe Hg contamination of river the Amazonian regions of Guyana, Venezuela, Ecua-
sediments and waters downstream from Au mining dor, Bolivia and Colombia. The problem is obviously
activities in the Maderia river basin (Lacerda et al., a regional one needing coordinated efforts by local
1990; Malm et al., 1990; Pfeiffer et al., 1989; Nriagu et Governmental and State organisations.
al., 1992). There is also evidence of Hg contamination
in carniverous fish that are then consumed by riverine
populations (Lacerda et al., 1990; Cleary et al., 1994). GLOBAL ASPECTS
Elevated human exposure to inorganic Hg in Au
miners and traders results from burning the Au/Hg The mining and smelting of metals is a worldwide
amalgam (Cleary and Thornton, 1993). activity and indeed may be regarded as “global” -
A pilot study undertaken in 1991 by a joint defined by the U.K. Inter-Agency Committee on

Table 3. Total Hg concentrations -geometric means and ranges (number of samples)

Category CUIU CUIU JACAREACANGA ITAITUBA CREPORI

Sediment (ppm) 1.1 (28) 0.34 (13) 0.28 (7) 0.97 (49)
0.21-3.93 0.16-0.90 0.05-0.62 0. I l-20.9
Filtered water 3.6 (7) 3.1 (13) 2.9 (10) 2.9 (7)
(pegL-‘) N.D.-5.89 1.9-4.22 1.22-5.11 2.0-3.56
Dust @pm) 31.0(15) 11.0(7) 150(11) 210 (16)
5-l 554 2-228 l-121,600 7-12,855
Fish (ppm fresh weight) 0.58 (5) 0.47 (17) 0.30 (30) No samples
0.334.72 0.01-2.58 0.01-1.47 taken
Human samples
Blood (j&L) 13.14 (25) 80.85 (25) 28.67 (28) 28.59 (28)
2.1-25.8 9.9-254.4 2.5-108.3 1.1-144.0
Urine (jig/L) 21.1 (25) 15.33(25) 3 1.35(28) 82.66 (28)
1.6-102.2 2.5-108.3 1.8-99.0 0.7-843.0
360 I. Thaimton

Global Environmental Research to include matters of Chakraborti D. and Saha K. C. (1987) Arsenic dermatosis
a local or regional nature that are repeated with from Tubewell Water in West Bengal. Indian J. Med. Res.
85, 326-334.
sufficiant frequency to give them global significance. Chen C.-J., Chen C.-W., Wu M.-M. and Kuo T.-L. (1992)
In addition to the studies outlined above, which are Cancer potential in liver, lung, bladder and kidney due to
based mainly on experience in the U.K., there are well inorganic arsenic in drinking water. Br. J. Cancer 66(S),
documented case histories involving contamination of 888-892.
Chen C.-J., Chuang Y. C., Lin T.-M. and Wu H.-Y. (1985)
the food chain in Canada, United States, Korea, Malignant neoplasms among residents of a blackfoot
China and Australia. Investigations into environmen- disease-endemic area in Taiwan: high artesian well water
tal impact have to date been largely limited to those in and cancers. Cancer Res. 45, 5895-5899.
the industrialised wealthy countries of the west in Cleary D. and Thornton I. (1993) The environmental
which the nutritional status of the population is more impact of gold mining in the Brazilian Amazon In
Mining and its Environment Impacts (eds R. E. Hester
than adequate. Priority in the future should be given and R. M. Harrison). Royal Society of Chemistry,
to the investigation of possible impacts through the London.
food chain to populations in developing countries Cleary D., Thornton I., Brown N., Kazantzis G., Delves T.
where nutrition is often poor and where environ- and Worthington S. (1994), Mercury in Brazil. Nature
369,613-614.
mental considerations usually take second place to
Colbourne P., Alloway B. J. and Thornton I. (1975) Arsenic
economic growth. and heavy metals in soils associated with regional
There is also a need for a greater research effort to anomalies in South-West England. Sci. Total Environ.
increase our understanding of the mineral and 4, 359-363.
chemical forms of metals in soils and plant materials Colbourne P. and Thornton I. (1978) Lead pollution in
agricultural soils. J. Soil Sci. 29, 5 13-526.
and the influence of these on pathways leading to Cotter-Howells J. and Thornton I. (1991) Sources and
human exposure through the consumption of food pathways of environmental lead to children in a Derby-
and water. It is appreciated that processes influencing shire mining village. Environ. Geochern. Health 13(2), 127-
these forms will vary greatly under different climatic 135.
Davies D. J. A., Thornton I.. Watt J., Culbard E. B.,
conditions.
Harvey P. G., Delves H. T., Sherlock J. C., Smart G. A.,
While both government and industry now place the Thomas J. F. A. and Quinn J. M. (1990) Lead intake and
environmental impact of mining and smelting as a blood lead in two year old UK urban children. Sci. Total
matter of priority, there is still a long way to go before Environ. 90, 13-29.
the extent of global impacts are realised and the effects Johnson L. R. (1983) A Study of Arsenic in Housedusts and
Garden Soils with Relation to Geochemistry and Health.
on food and water quality, human exposure and
MSc Thesis, University of London.
health effects are fully evaluated. A multi-disciplinery Lacerda L., DePaula F., Ovalle A., Pfeiffer W. and Malm
approach to these problems is essential, in which the 0. (1990) Trace metals in fluvial sediments of the Madeira
environmental geochemist will work with engineers, River watershed Amazon, Brazil. Sci. Total Environ. 971
98, 525-530.
agricultural and medical scientists and others to
Leonardi G. (1994) Arsenic contamination in Cornwall and
minimise future pollution and its impacts and to Devon and bladder cancer: a geographical study.
decide on the necessity and appropriate methods for Unpublished MSc Thesis, London School of Hygiene
remediation. and Tropical Medicine.
Malm O., Pfeiffer W. C., Souza C. M. M. and Reuther R.
(1990) Mercury pollution due to gold mining in the
Editorial handling: Dr Ron Fuge.
Madeira River basin, Brazil. Ambio 19(l), 1l-l 5.
Matthews H. (1982) The Distribution of Cadmium and
Associated Elements in the Soil-Plant System at Sites in
Britain Contaminated by Mining, Smelting and Metal-
rich Bedrock. Ph.D. Thesis, University of London.
Moir A. M. (1992) The Influence of Soil Factors and
REFERENCES Atmospheric Deposition on the Cadmium and Lead
Contents of Vegetables. Ph.D. Thesis, University of
Abrahams P. W. (1983) Distribution, Dispersion and Agri- London.
cultural Significance of Metals in Soils of the Mining Nriagu J., Pfeiffer W., Maim O., Souza C. and Mierle G.
Regions of Southwest England, Ph.D. Thesis, University (1992) Mercury pollution in Brazil. Nature 356, 389.
of London. Pfeiffer W., Lacerda L., Malm O., Sousa C., Silveira E. and
Abrahams P. W. and Thornton I. (1987) Distribution and Bastos W. (1989) Mercury concentrations in inland
extent of land contaminated by arsenic and associated waters of Rondonia Amazon, Brazil. Sci. Total Environ.
metals in the mining regions of southwest England. Trans. 87/88,233-240.
Inst. Min. Metall.. Sect. B. 96, l-8. Plant J. A., Hale M. and Ridgeway J. (1989) Regional
Abrahams P. W. and Thornton I. (1994) The contamination geochemistry based on stream sediment sampling. In
of agriculltural land in the metalliferous province of Proceedings of Exploration ‘87 (ed. G. D. Garland), Spec.
southwest England: implications to livestock. Agri., Vol. 3, pp. 384404. Ontario Geol. Surv.
Ecosyst. Environ. 48, 127-137. Shank-Givens H. (1994) The Arsenic Drinking Water
Alloway B. J., Thornton T., Smart G. A., Sherlock J. C. and Regulation Background Information 16/5/1994. OtXce of
Quinn M. J. (1988) Metal availability. Sci. Total Environ. Ground Water and Drinking Water, US EPA.
17‘5,
41-69. Stavrakis P., Demetriades A., Vergou-Vichou K., Thornton
Archer F. C. and Hodgson I. H. (1987) Total and I., Fosse G., Makropoulos V. and Vlachoyiannis N.
extractable trace element content of soil in England and (1994) A multidisciplinary study on the effects of
Wales. J. Soil Sci. 38, 421431. environmental contamination on the human population
Mining on the environment; local, regional and global issues 361

of the Lavrion urban area, Hellas. In Environmental grazing contaminated land. Sci. Total Environ. 28, 287-
Contamination, Proceedings of 6th International Confer- 294.
ence. Deluhi. Greece (ed. S. P. Vamavas). vn. 20-22. Thornton I., Brown N., Cleary D. and Worthington S.
Strehlow C: D. and Barltrop D. (1988) Heal% studies. Sci. (1991) Mercury Contamination in the Brazilian Amazon:
Total Environ. 75, 101-133. A Report for the Commission of the European Commu-
Thoresby P. and Thornton I. (1979) Heavy metals and nities, Directorate-Generale l-K-2 Environment, Contact
arsenic in soil, pasture herbage and barley in some Reference B946/90, Brussels.
mineralised areas of Britain: significance to animal and Thornton I., Cleary D. and Kazantzis G. (1994) Mercury
human health. In Trace Subs. Environ. Health (ed. D. D. contamination from gold mining in the Brazilian Ama-
Hemphill), Vol. XIII. University of Missouri, Columbia, zon: health implications. In Environmental Contamina-
Missouri. tion, Proceedings of the 6th International Conference,
Thornton I. (1980) Goechemical aspects of heavy metal Delphi, Greece (ed. S. P. Varnavas), pp. 7-12.
pollution and agriculture in England and Wales. Inor- Webb J. S. (1964) Geochemistry and life. New’Scientist 23,
ganic Pollution and Agriculture, pp. 105-125. HMSO, 504-507.
London. Webb J. S., Thornton I., Thompson M., Howarth R. J. and
Thornton I. (1988) Metal content of soils and dusts. Sci. Lowenstein P. L. (1978) The Wolfson Geochemical Atlas
Total Environ. 75, 21-39 (Special Issue: The Shipham of England and Wales. Oxford University Press.
Report). World Health Organisation (1993) Guidelines for Drinking
Thornton I. (1993a) Environmental geochemistry and Water Quality, 2nd edn, Vol 1. Recommendations WHO,
health in the 1990s: a global perspective. Appl. Geneva.
Geochem. Suppl. 2, 203-210. World Health Organisation (1983). 27th Report of the Joint
Thornton I. (1993b) Sources and pathways of arsenic in FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, 29.
South-West England: health implications. Proceedings of Technical Report Series 696, World Health Organisation,
the International Conference on Arsenic Exposure and Geneva.
Health Effects, New Orleans, July 1993. Xu J. and Thornton I. (1985) Arsenic in garden soils and
Thornton I. and Abrahams P. (1983) Soil ingestion- vegetable crops in Cornwall, England: implications for
a major pathway of heavy metals into livestock human health. Environ. Geochem. Health 7(4), 131-133.

You might also like