Peer and Self Evaluation Form for Article Review

Topic: _________________________________________________________ Deadline: _______________

Participant’s Name: _______________________________________ Section: __________ Group No.: ____

Write down the names of your group members in the space provided below. Follow the instructions in the table.

SURNAMES OF ALL THE MEMBERS (In alphabetical order)

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
CRITERIA

Rate all members of the group based on the list of statements on the first column. Write down the number from 1 to 5 to
express how each member meets the statement on the left. After you indicate the number, you may write brief comments
to explain your evaluation. Think carefully about assigning rating values for each of the statements.
1-Strongly Disagree 2-Disagree 3-Neutral 4-Agree 5-Strongly Agree

i. Dependable and
reliable
ii. Did work
accurately and
completely
iii. Contributed a
fair share of the
work
iv. Worked well
with other
members
Overall value in
the team
Assess the contribution made by each member to the tasks listed on the left, by indicating that person’s contribution as a
Total
percentage of the total input required for a given task. For instance, Member 1 wrote 20% of the paper; Member 2
100%
wrote 50%; while Member 3 wrote 30%. Each row should total 100%.

i. Conceptualization
100%
of the argument

ii. Participation in
100%
discussions

iii. Writing of the

100%
paper

iv. Editing of the

100%
paper

v. Encoding/typing
100%
of the paper

Overall
contribution to 100%
the paper
Indicate below the letter grade (A, B, C, D, E, F) for each group member. You are required to rank each member;
hence, no two members of the group can receive the same letter grade.

Letter grade for

each group
member