Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 Latticeenergyf
2 Latticeenergyf
Prof.P. Ravindran,
Department of Physics, Central University of Tamil
Nadu, India
http://folk.uio.no/ravi/CMP2015
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Introduction
Cohesive energy
energy required to
break up crystal into
neutral free atoms.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
P.Ravindran,
Kcal/molPHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung
= 0.0434 eV/molecule constants
KJ/mol = 0.0104 – Born Haber cycle
eV/molecule
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
6
CPE12
z1e z 2 e
z1z 2 e 2
4 0 r12 4 0 r12
Total PE of ionic solid is sum of CPE interactions between all ions
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Electronegativity and Chemical Bonds
1. Ionization enthalpy
The enthalpy change when one mole of
electrons are removed from one mole of
atoms or positive ions in gaseous state.
+ - st
X(g) X (g) + e H 1 I.E.
+ 2+ - nd
X (g) X (g) + e H 2 I.E.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Electronegativity and Chemical Bonds
2. Electron affinity
The enthalpy change when one mole of
electrons are added to one mole of atoms
or negative ions in gaseous state.
- - st
X(g) + e X (g) H 1 E.A.
- 2 nd
X (g) + e X (g) H 2 E.A.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
I.E. and E.A. only show e- releasing/attracting
power of
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Electronegativity and Chemical Bonds
3. Electronegativity
The ability of an atom to attract electrons in a chemical bond.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Pauling’s scale of electronegativity
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Pauling’s scale of electronegativity
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Pauling’s scale of electronegativity
IA IIA IIIA IVA VA VIA VIIA VIIIA
H He
2.1 -
Li Be B C N O F Ne
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 -
Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar
0.9 1.2 1.5 1.8 2.1 2.5 3.0 -
K Ca Ga Ge As Se Br Kr
0.8 1.0 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.4 2.8 -
Rb Sr In Sn Sb Te I Xe
0.8 1.0 1.7 1.8 2.0 2.1 2.5 -
Cs Ba Tl Pb Bi Po At Rn
0.7 0.9 1.8 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.2 -
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
What trends do you notice about the EN values in
the Periodic Table? Explain.
IA IIA IIIA IVA VA VIA VIIA VIIIA
H He
2.1 -
Li Be B C N O F Ne
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 -
Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar
0.9 1.2 1.5 1.8 2.1 2.5 3.0 -
K Ca Ga Ge As Se Br Kr
0.8 1.0 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.4 2.8 -
Rb Sr In Sn Sb Te I Xe
0.8 1.0 1.7 1.8 2.0 2.1 2.5 -
Cs Ba Tl Pb Bi Po At Rn
0.7 0.9 1.8 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.2 -
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
What trends do you notice about the EN values in
the Periodic Table? Explain.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
What trends do you notice about the EN values in the Periodic
Table? Explain.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Bonding
The equations that we will use to predict lattice energies for crystalline solids are the
Born-Mayer equation and the Kapustinskii equation, which are very similar to one
another. These equations are simple models that calculate the attraction and
repulsion for a given arrangement of ions.
Born-Mayer Equation:
U0 = (e2 / 4 0) * (N zA zB / d0) * A * (1 – (d* / d0))
Kapustinskii equation :
U0 = (1210 kJ Å / mol) * (n zA zB / d0) * (1 – (d* / d0))
Where:
e is the charge of the electron, 0 is the permittivity of a vacuum
N is Avogadro’s number
zA is the charge on ion “A”, zB is the charge on ion “B”
d0 is the distance between the cations and anions (in Å) = r+ + r-
A is a Madelung constant
d* = exponential scaling factor for repulsive term = 0.345 Å
n = the number of ions in the formula unit
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Bonding
The origin of the equations for lattice energies.
U0 = Ecoul + Erep
The lattice energy U0 is composed of both coulombic (electrostatic) energies and an additional
close-range repulsion term - there is some repulsion even between cations and anions because of
the electrons on these ions. Let us first consider the coulombic energy term:
In this case the energy of coulombic forces (electrostatic attraction and repulsion) are:
because for any given ion, the two adjacent ions are each a distance of d away, the next two
ions are 2d, then 3d, then 4d etc. The series in the square brackets can be summarized to
give the expression:
For a 3-dimensional arrangement, the geometric factor will be different for each different
arrangement of ions. For example, in a NaCl-type structure:
Ecoul = (e2 / 4 0) * (zA zB / d) * [6(1/1) - 12(1/2) + 8(1/3) - 6(1/4) + 24(1/5) ....]
The geometric factor in the square brackets only works for the NaCl-type structure, but
people have calculated these series for a large number of different types of structures
and the value of the series for a given structural type is given by the Madelung constant,
A.
This means that the general equation of Coulombic energy for any 3-D ionic solids is:
Ecoul = (e2 / 4 0) * (zA zB / d) * A
Note that the value of Ecoul must be negative for a stable crystal lattice.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Bonding
The numerical values of Madelung constants for a variety of different structures are
listed in the following table. CN is the coordination number (cation,anion) and n is the
total number of ions in the empirical formula e.g. in fluorite (CaF2) there is one cation
and two anions so n = 1 + 2 = 3.
lattice A CN stoich A/n
Notice that the value of A is fairly constant for each given stoichiometry and that the
value of A/n is very similar regardless of the type of lattice.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Bonding
If only the point charge model for Coulombic energy is used to estimate the lattice energy (i.e. if U0 = Ecoul) the
calculated values are much higher than the experimentally measured lattice energies.
But the experimental energy is -788 kJ/mol. The difference in energy is caused by the repulsion between the
electron clouds on each ion as they are forced close together. A correction factor, Erep, was derived to
account for this.
Erep = - (e2 / 4 0) * (zA zB d*/ d2) * A and since
Ecoul = (e2 / 4 0) * (zA zB / d) * A the total is given by
U0 = (e2 / 4 0) * (zA zB / d0) * A * (1-(d*/d0))
Note: d* is the exponential scaling factor for the repulsive term and
a value that we will use for this is 0.345 Å.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Bonding
Using the Born-Mayer equation, for our example with NaCl.
Kapustinskii observed that A/n is relatively constant but increases slightly with
coordination number. Because coordination number also increases with d, the value of
A/nd should also be relatively constant. From these (and a few other) assumptions he
derived an equation that does not involve the Madelung constant:
Kapustinskii equation :
U0 = (1210 kJ Å / mol) * (n zA zB / d0) * (1 – (d* / d0))
One advantage of the Kapustinskii equation is that the type of crystal lattice is not
important. This means that the equation can be used to determine ionic radii for non-
spherical ions (e.g. BF4-, NO3-, OH-, SnCl6-2 etc.) from experimental lattice energies. The
self-consistent set of radii obtained in this way are called thermochemical radii.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
24
N A z1z2 e 2 d *
PE min 1 A
40d d
d* = 34.5 x 10-12 m
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionic Crystals
R/ q2
e n.n.
R
Ui j 2
q otherwise
pi j R
Utot NUi
q2
For N pairs of N z e R/
z ﹦number of n.n.
ions: R
ρ ~ .1 R0
﹦Madelung constant
j i pi j
dU tot z R / q 2
At equilibrium: 0 N e 2 R0 / q2
→ 2
R e
dR R 0
z
N q 2 N q 2
U tot 0 1 Madelung Energy
R0 R0 R0
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Evaluation of Madelung Constant
App. B: Ewald’s method
i fixed
j i pi j
1 1 1
2 1 2ln 2
2 3 4
KCl
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Kcal/mol = 0.0434 eV/molecule
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
31
Madelung Constant
31
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Total Coulombic potential:
e2 e2 e2 e2
U A 6 12 8 6 ...
4 0 r 4 0 2 r 4 0 3r 4 o (2r )
e 2 1.748e 2
4 0 r 4 0 r
32
32
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
33
Crystal Potential
V (r ) U R (r ) U A (r )
e 2
B Repulsive energy ER
n
r 4 o r
Interatomic separation r
Net energy EN
Ed
Attractive energy EA
33
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Exclusion repulsive force UR
Crystal Potential V(r)
equilibrium position
r = ro
V(r)
Coulombic attraction UA
distance r
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Equilibrium position
dV nB e 2
0
dr r ro ron 1 ro2
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
The equilibrium position is then
given by
nB
ro n 1
e 2
And the minimum energy is
e 2 1
Vmin V (ro ) (1 )
4 o ro n
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
37
Example
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Definitions
Sodium ion
Ionization Energy Na+
Sodium atom
+
Eion
Capture
electron
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Cohesive energy
Sodium
atom
Chlorine
dissociation atom
NaCl molecule
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Equilibrium position of Sodium Chloride Crystal
nB
ro n 1
e 2
96
9 x1.209x10
8 19
1.7476x1.609x10
41
41
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
There is no mistake. Sine the unit of B is eV m9. It must be
converted into Joule by multiplying the electron charge e. The
electron charge cancels out one of the e factor in the
denominator.
Effectively, it can express B in eV m9, while eliminating one e
in the denominator.
The calculation result for ro becomes
r0 = 2.887x10-10 m
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
The energy required to dissociate a sodium
chloride molecule into separate ions:Ed
2
NaCl Ed Na Cl
Why e instead of e ?
e 1 2
Ed V (ro ) (1 )
4 o ro n
19
1.747565x1.602x10 8
12
x
4 x 4.1416x8.85x10 9
= 7.96 eV
43
43
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Ionization energy of Na
Electron affinity of Cl
Cl e Cl Eaff Eaff = 3.61 eV
Na Cl Na Cl Eion Eaff
recall
Na Cl NaCl Ed
44
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Na Cl NaCl Ed Eion Eaff
Na Cl Na Cl NaCl Ecoh
where
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Lattice enthalpy terms
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Born-Haber cycles
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
What do we mean by lattice enthalpy?
For an ionic compound the lattice - - -
enthalpy is the enthalpy change - -
when one mole of solid in its
- - -
standard state is formed from its
ions in the gaseous state.
The lattice enthalpy cannot be measured
directly and so we make use of other
known enthalpies and link them together
with an enthalpy cycle.
+600
1 Sublimation of Sodium
+500
+400
+300
+200
Na(g) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
+100 θ
HS = +107kJmol-1
0 Na(s) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
-100
-200
-300
-400
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
kJmol-1
+800
Born-Haber Cycle for Sodium Chloride
+700
+600
+500
+400
2 Bond Dissociation of Chlorine
+300
Na(g) + Cl(g)
½ HθD = +121kJmol-1
+200
Na(g) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
+100
0 Na(s) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
-100
-200
-300
-400
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
kJmol-1
+800
Born-Haber Cycle for Sodium Chloride
Na+(g) + Cl(g)
+700
e-
+600 e-
+500
3 First Ionisation of Sodium e-
θ
+400 H I = +502kJmol-1 e-
e-
+300
Na(g) + Cl(g)
+200
-100
-200
-300
-400
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
kJmol-1
+800
Born-Haber Cycle for Sodium Chloride
Na+(g) + Cl(g)
+700
+400
Na+(g) + Cl-(g)
+300
Na(g) + Cl(g)
+200
+100
0
Na(g) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
-200
-
-300
-400
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
kJmol-1
+800
Born-Haber Cycle for Sodium Chloride
Na+(g) + Cl(g)
+700
+600
+500
+400
- -
Na+(g) + Cl-(g)
+300
Na(g) + Cl(g)
+200
-
-100
θ
-200 HF = -411kJmol-1
-300
5 Formation of Sodium Chloride
-400
NaCl(s)
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
kJmol-1
+800
Born-Haber Cycle for Sodium Chloride
Na+(g) + Cl(g)
+700
+600
+500
+400
Na+(g) + Cl-(g)
+300
Na(g) + Cl(g)
+200 Lattice Enthalpy for
Na(g) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
+100 Sodium Chloride
0 Na(s) + 1/2 Cl2(g)
- -
-100
H θ = -786 kJmol-1
-
-200 L
- -
-300
-400
NaCl(s)
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Born-Haber cycles
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Lattice Enthalpy Values (kJ mol-1)
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Lattice Enthalpy Values
Cl¯ Br¯ F¯ O2-
Na+ -780 -742 -918 -2478
K+ -711 -679 -817 -2232
Rb+ -685 -656 -783
Mg2+ -2256 -3791
Ca2+ -2259
Smaller ions will have a greater attraction for each other because of their
higher charge density. They will have larger Lattice Enthalpies and larger
melting points because of the extra energy which must be put in to separate
the oppositely charged ions.
The sodium ion has the same charge as a potassium ion but is smaller. It has a higher
charge density so will have a more effective attraction for the chloride ion. More energy
will be released when they come together.
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
Calculating Lattice Enthalpy
SPECIAL POINTS
greater charge
densities of ions = greater attraction
= larger lattice enthalpy
Effects
(H°ie1 + H°ie2)
NaCl2(s)
H°f
H°f = H°sub + H°ie1 + H°ie2 + H°d + H°ea + Uo
2 7
6 Electron Affinity of chlorine
Mg(s) + Cl2(g)
Cl(g) + e¯ ——> Cl¯(g) x2
1
7 Lattice Enthalpy of MgCl2
Mg2+(g) + 2Cl¯(g) ——> MgCl2(s)
MgCl2(s)
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle
CaO
Ca2+ (g) + 2 e- + O (g)
H H electron affinity/ies
590 H ionisation –142
energy/ies
1150 Ca (g) + O (g) +844
H Ca2+ (g) + O2- (g)
193
atomisation(s)
248 Ca (s) + ½ O2 (g) H lattice
? energy
of formation
–635 H formation
CaO (s)
(0,1,0)
(1,0,0)
P.Ravindran, PHY074- Condensed Matter Physics, Spring 2016 July: Lattice Energy-Madelung constants – Born Haber cycle