Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for
Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness 1
This standard is issued under the fixed designation E 446; the number immediately following the designation indicates the year of
original adoption or, in the case of revision, the year of last revision. A number in parentheses indicates the year of last reapproval. A
superscript epsilon (e) indicates an editorial change since the last revision or reapproval.
This standard has been approved for use by agencies of the Department of Defense.
1. Scope
1.1 These reference radiographs2 illustrate various types
and degrees of discontinuities occurring in steel castings that
have section thicknesses up to 2 in. (51 mm) (Note 1).
NOTE 1—Reference radiographs previously used for this thickness
range carried the designation E 71, but included a now rarely used gamma
source, that is, radium. The current document is also updated by inclusion
of several recognized shrinkage or C categories and by elimination of the
crack and hot tear categories except for one example of each of these
discontinuity types. Reference radiographs for thicker sections may be
found in E 186 and E 280.
1.2 These reference illustrations consist of three separate
sets (Note 2) as follows: (1) medium voltage (nominal 250-
kVp) X rays. (2) 1-MV X rays and Iridium-192 radiation, and
(3) 2-MV to 4-MV X rays and cobalt-60 radiation. Each set is
for comparison only with radiographs produced with equiva-
lent radiation. It should be recognized that each energy level is
not applicable to the entire thickness range covered by this
document. Each set consists of 6 categories of graded discon-
tinuities in increasing severity level and 4 categories of
ungraded discontinuites furnished as examples only, as fol-
lows:
1.2.1 Category A—Gas porosity; severity levels 1 through
5.
1.2.2 Category B—Sand and slag inclusions; severity levels
1 through 5.
1.2.3 Category C—Shrinkage; 4 types:
1.2.3.1 CA—Severity levels 1 through 5.
1.2.3.2 CB—Severity levels 1 through 5.
1.2.3.3 CC—Severity levels 1 through 5.
1.2.3.4 CD—Severity levels 1 through 5.
1.2.4 Category D—Crack; 1 illustration.
1.2.5 Category E—Hot tear; 1 illustration.
1.2.6 Category F—Insert; 1 illustration. 1.2.7
Category G—Mottling; 1 illustration.
NOTE 2 — The illustrations consist of the following:
1
These reference radiographs are under the jurisdiction of ASTM Committee
E-7 on Nondestructive Testing and are the direct responsibility of Subcommittee
E07.02 on Reference Radiographs.
Current edition approved May 10, 1998. Published July 1998. Originally
published as E 446 – 72. Last previous edition E 446 – 93.
2 6
For ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code applications see related Reference
Radiographs SE-446 in Section V of that Code.
Copyright © ASTM, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959, United States.
Page
1 1 of 22
A n A me ri c a n Nati on al S ta n da rd
Volume I: Medium Voltage (Nominal 250 kVp) X-Ray Reference
Radiographs—Set of 34 illustrations (5 by 7 in.) in a 15 by 17-in. ring
binder.
Volume II: 1-MVXRays and Iridium-192 Reference Radiographs—Set
of 34 illustrations (5 by 7 in.) in a 15 by 17-in. ring binder.
Volume III: 2-MV to 4-MV X Rays and Cobalt-60 Reference
Radiographs—Set of 34 illustrations (5 by 7 in.) in a 15 by 17-in. ring
binder.
NOTE 3—Although Category G–Mottling is listed for all three volumes,
the appearance of mottling is dependent on the level of radiation energy.
Mottling appears reasonably prominent in Volume I; however, because of
the higher radiation energy levels mottling may not be apparent in Volume
II nor Volume III.
1.3 The values stated in inch-pound units are to be regarded
as the standard.
1.4 This standard does not purport to address all of the
safety concerns, if any, associated with its use. It is the
responsibility of the user of this standard to establish appro-
priate safety and health practices and determine the applica-
bility of regulatory limitations prior to use.
2. Referenced Documents
2.1 ASTM Standards:
E 94 Guide for Radiographic Testing3
E 142 Method for Controlling Quality of Radiographic
Testing3
E 186 Reference Radiographs for Heavy-Walled (2 to 41/2-
in. (51 to 114-mm)) Steel Castings3
E 242 Reference Radiographs for Appearances of Radio-
graphic Images as Certain Parameters Are Changed3
E 280 Reference Radiographs for Heavy-Walled (41⁄2 to 12-
in. (114 to 305-mm)) Steel Castings3
E 1316 Terminology for Nondestructive Examinations3
2.2 ASTM Adjuncts :4
Reference Radiographs for Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51
mm) in Thickness:
Volume I, Medium Voltage (Nominal 250 kVp) X Rays5
Volume II, 1-MV X Rays and Iridium-1926
Volume III, 2-MV to 4-MV X Rays and Cobalt-607
3
Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol 03.03.
4
Available from ASTM Headquarters.
5
Order PCN 17- 50446 -22.
Order PCN 17- 50446 -22.
7
Order PCN 17- 50446 -22.
22/05/08
3. Terminology
3.1 Definitions—for definitions of terms used in this docu-
ment, see Terminology E 1316, section D.
4. Significance and Use
4.1 These reference radiographs are intended to provide a
guide enabling recognition of discontinuities and their differ-
entiation both as to type and severity level, where applicable.
4.2 They also provide example radiographic illustrations of
discontinuities, that are ungraded, for reference in acceptance
standards, specifications and drawings.
4.3 Sets of reference radiographs from which purchasers
and suppliers may, by mutual agreement, select particular
illustrations to serve as standards representing minimum ac-
ceptability are provided. At the same time, the standards so
established may be unambiguously identified by alphabetic
defect category (or type) designation and severity level.
4.4 The use of this document is not intended to be restricted
to the specific energy level or to the absolute thickness limits
that are contained in the document title. The title is intended to
be descriptive and not restrictive. The document may be used,
where there is no other applicable document, for other energy
levels or thicknesses or both, for which it is found to be
applicable and for which agreement has been reached between
purchaser and manufacturer.
5. Method of Preparation
5.1 The original radiographs used to prepare these three sets
of reference illustrations were made from selected sections of
actual production castings by the respective use of 250-kVp X
rays, iridium-192 radiation, and cobalt-60 radiation on Class I
and II film with a sensitivity as determined by standard 2-2T
penetrameters (Guide E 94 and Method E 142). The illustra-
tions have been prepared to an H and D density of from 2.00
to 2.25 and have been made to retain the contrast of the original
radiographs.
5.2 Film Deterioration —Radiographic films are subject to
wear and tear from handling and use. The extent to which the
image deteriorates over time is a function of storage condi-
tions, care in handling and amount of use. Reference radio-
graph films are no exception and may exhibit a loss in image
quality over time. The radiographs should therefore be peri-
odically examined for signs of wear and tear, including
scratches, abrasions, stains, and so forth. Any reference radio-
graphs which show signs of excessive wear and tear which
could influence the interpretation and use of the radiographs
should be replaced.
6. Determination of Radiographic Classification
6.1 For purposes of evaluation of castings, a determination
must be made of the radiographic classification to be assigned
to individual castings or specific areas of castings. The deter-
mination of the applicable radiographic classification shall be
based on an evaluation of the casting applications, design, and
service requirements. In these evaluations, consideration shall
be given to such factors as pressure, temperature, section
thickness, applicable design safety factor (preferably based on
stress analysis), vibration, shock, resistance to corrosion,
involvement of penetrating radiations or radiation
products,and involvement of dangerous gases or liquids.
Page 22 of 22
6.2 For each portion of casting radiographed, the severity
level for each class of discontinuity category should be clearly
specified. Thus, Severity Level 2 might be specified for
shrinkage, Category CA, and Severity Level 3 for Gas Poros-
ity, Category A, since the latter are generally much less
deleterious to tensile properties.
7. Classification Specifications
7.1 The applicable radiographic severity classification
should be designated by the contracting agency in formal
specifications or on drawings and in specific contracts or
orders. The specifications, drawings, contracts, or order should
also designate the sampling plan for the castings to be
radiographed and the extent of radiographic coverage, radio-
graphic practice to be followed (Guide E 94 and Method
E 142), image quality desired (Note 4) as well as the severity
of the acceptable discontinuity for the graded categories.
NOTE 4—For description of sensitivity or quality levels, see Guide
E 94, Method E 142, and Reference Radiographs E 242.
8. Procedure for Evaluation
8.1 Compare the production radiographs of the casting
submitted for evaluation with the reference radiographs of
similar thickness that were exposed at an equivalent energy
range.
8.2 When the severity level of discontinuities in the produc-
tion radiograph being evaluated is equal to or better than the
severity level in the specified reference radiograph, that part of
the casting represented by the production radiograph shall be
acceptable. If the production radiograph shows discontinuities
of greater severity than the reference radiograph, that part of
the casting shall be rejected.
8.3 An area of like size to the reference radiograph shall be
the unit area by which the production radiograph is evaluated,
and any such area or any area that shares a discontinuity with
an adjacent film area shall meet the requirements as defined for
acceptability. When the are of interest of a production radio-
graph is less than the unit area, such area of interest shall be
prorated to the reference radiographic area.
8.4 When two or more categories of discontinuity are
present in the same production radiograph, the predominating
discontinuities, if unacceptable, shall govern without regard to
the other categories of discontinuities, and the casting rejected
until satisfactorily repaired.
8.5 When two or more categories of discontinuity are
present to an extent equal to the maximum permissible level as
shown in the pertinent standards for each category, then that
part of the casting shall be judged unacceptable until satisfac-
torily repaired.
8.6 Reference radiographs are provided showing a variety
of forms of shrinkage cavities. Production radiographs show-
ing shrinkage shall be judged by the most representative
reference radiograph.
8.7 Production radiographs showing porosity, gas, or inclu-
sions shall be evaluated by the overall condition with regard to
size, number, and distribution. The aggregate size of disconti-
nuities shall not exceed the total accumulation in area of the
discontinuities of the reference radiograph. It is not the intent
22/05/08
that the maximum size of the illustrated discontinuity shall be
the limiting size for a single production radiographic discon-
tinuity, or that the number of discontinuities shown on the
reference radiograph shall be the limiting number for produc-
tion radiographs. Also, caution should be exercised in judging
a large discontinuity against a collection of small discontinui-
ties on the basis of size alone. Each of the factors of size,
number, and distribution must be considered in balance.
8.8 Reference radiographs in this standard do not illustrate
elongated or “worm hole” type of gas discontinuities. When
this condition occurs in a production radiograph, it shall be
evaluated by comparison with the most representative refer-
ence radiograph.
8.8.1 When the source has been placed perpendicular to the
length of the gas hole, evaluate the production radiograph with
a shrinkage reference radiograph.
8.8.2 When the source has been placed diametrically
or“into” the diameter of the gas hole, evaluate the production
radiograph with a gas reference radiograph.
8.9 A diffraction mottling pattern can occur on films of parts
and sections where the grain size is large enough to be an
appreciable fraction of the material thickness (Note 5). If
diffraction mottling is suspected, there are a number of ways to
demonstrate its presence. The diffraction mottling pattern
shown in these cases is dependent principally upon the crystal
geometry and the orientation of the crystals to the incident
radiation. Therefore, for a given specimen, any change in this
orientation will affect the diffraction pattern dramatically. This
can be accomplished by a slight, 1 to 5° tilt of the part, with
respect to the radiation beam or simply by shifting the
centerline of the radiation beam to a slightly different location
The American Society forTesting and Materials takes no position respecting the validity ofany patent rights asserted in connection
with any item mentioned in this standard. Users ofthis standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such
patent rights, and the risk of infringement of such rights, are entirely their own responsibility.
from the first exposure. Indications from any porosity,
shrinkage, or other discontinuity will move only slightly, while
any mottling patterns present will change dramatically. If it is
necessary or desirable to eliminate the mottling, the kV may
be raised to reduce the amount of diffraction radiation.
However, caution should be used so that the kV is not raised
to the point that sensitivity is reduced excessively. If
diffraction mottling is demonstrated to be present on a
radiograph, this condition shall not be considered as prejudicial
in evaluating the radiograph.
NOTE 5—Mottling is often associated with thin sections of austenitic
steels, and copper base alloys such as copper nickel, tin bronzes, and
nickel copper.
8.10 Hot tears and cracks exhibited on production radio-
graphs may at times resemble linear type shrinkage. When
doubt exists whether such indications are cracks or tears, or are
linear shrinkage, all surfaces in the area of interest shall be
ground and magnetic particle or liquid penetrant inspected as
applicable. The extent and depth of grinding may require
engineering judgment. If the indication does not appear on the
surface, it shall be considered to be shrinkage.
8.11 The radiographic density of discontinuities in compari-
son with background density is a variable dependent on
technical factors. It shall not be used as a criterion for
acceptance or rejection in comparison with reference radio-
graphs.
9. Keywords
9.1 castings; discontinuities; gamma ray; reference radio-
graphs; steel; x-ray

This standard is subject to revision at any time by the responsible technical committee and must be reviewed everyfive years and
ifnot revised, eitherreapproved or withdrawn. Yourcomments are invited eitherfor revision ofthis standard orfor additional standards
and should be addressed to ASTM Headquarters. Your comments will receive careful consideration at a meeting of the responsible
technical committee, which you may attend. If you feel that your comments have not received a fair hearing you should make your
views known to the ASTM Committee on Standards, at the address shown below.

This standard is copyrighted byASTM, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959, United States.
Individual reprints (single or multiple copies) of this standard may be obtained by contacting ASTM at the above address or at 610-
832-9585 (phone), 610-832-9555 (fax), or service@astm.org (e-mail); or through the ASTM website (www.astm.org).

Page 3
3 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY A1 – GAS POROSITY

CATEGORY A2 – GAS POROSITY

Page 4 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY A3 – GAS POROSITY

CATEGORY A4 – GAS POROSITY

Page 5 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY A5 – GAS POROSITY

CATEGORY B1 – INCLUSION

Page 6 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY B2 – INCLUSION

CATEGORY B3 – INCLUSION

Page 7 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY B4 – INCLUSION

CATEGORY B5 – INCLUSION

Page 8 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CA1 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CA2 – SHRINKAGE

Page 9 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CA3 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CA4 – SHRINKAGE

Page 10 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CA5 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CB1 – SHRINKAGE

Page 11 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CB2 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CB3 – SHRINKAGE

Page 12 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CB4 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CB5 – SHRINKAGE

Page 13 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CC1 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CC2 – SHRINKAGE

Page 14 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CC3 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CC4 – SHRINKAGE

Page 15 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CC5 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CD1 – SHRINKAGE

Page 16 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CD2 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CD3 – SHRINKAGE

Page 17 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY CD4 – SHRINKAGE

CATEGORY CD5 – SHRINKAGE

Page 18 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY D – CRACK

CATEGORY E – HOT TEAR

Page 19 of 22 22/05/08
 Designation: E 446 – 98
Standard Reference Radiographs for An American National Standard

Steel Castings Up to 2 in. (51 mm) in Thickness

CATEGORY F – INCERT

CATEGORY G – MOTTLING

Page 20 of 22 22/05/08
VALVES — FLANGED
THREADED, AND WELDING END ASME B16.34-1996

ANNEX B
RADIOGRAPHY PROCEDURE AND ACCEPTANCE STANDARDS

(This Annex is an integral part of ASME B16.34-1996 and is placed after the main text for convenience.)

B1 RADIOGRAPHY PROCEDURE

B1.11 The radiographic sensitivity shall be 2-4T for

B1.1 ASTM E 94, Recommended Practice for Radio-
graphic Testing, and ASTM E 142, Controlling Quality of thickness up to and including 0.75 in. and 2-2T for thick-
Radiographic Testing, shall be used as a guide. ness 1 greater than 0.75 in.

B1.2 The film shall be as close as practical to the part

being radiographed. B2 ACCEPTANCE STANDARDS

B1.3 Any commercially available intensifying screen,

B2.1 Acceptance shall be based on the following.
except those of the fluorescent type, may be used.
B2.1.1 Wall Thickness Less Than 2 in. The fol-
B1.4 All film shall bear identification markers to properly lowing comparative plates of ASTM E 446 define
orient the film for interpretation and to denote the actual acceptable indications as follows.
part under examination. Film shall be marked to identify
the organization producing the radiograph and the date Acceptable
exposed. Comparative
Discontinuity Type Category
Plate, ASTM
E 446
B1.5 Penetrameters shall be used on each radiograph. Gas A A2
Penetrameters shall conform to the requirements of Sand B B3
ASTM E 142. Shrink, Type 1 C CA2
Shrink, Type 2 C CB3
B1.6 Any commercially available film may be used, pro- Shrink, Type 3 C CC3
vided it is equal to or finer grained than Type 2, ASTM E Shrink, Type 4 C CD3
94. Hot tears and cracks D&E None
Inserts (chills, chaplets) F None
B1.7 The manufacturer, at his option, may use a double
film technique and a combination of a single and double B2.1.2 Wall Thickness 2 in. to 4.5 in. The
viewing so as to cover a greater latitude in part thickness following comparative plates of ASTM E 186 define
with a single exposure. acceptable indications as follows.

B1.8 Radiographs shall be within the following photo- Acceptable

graphic (H & D) density range: Comparative
Discontinuity Type Category
Plate, ASTM
(a) single film viewing — 1.5 minimum, 4.0 E 186
maximum; Gas porosity A A3
(b) superimposed viewing of double film, each single
Sand and slag inclusions B B3
film — 1.00 minimum, 2.5 maximum, with a double film
Shrink, Type 1 C CA3
— 4.0 maximum.
Shrink, Type 2 C CB3
Shrink, Type 3 C CC3
B1.9 Surfaces shall be such that radiographic contrast due Crack D None
to surface condition cannot mask or be confused with that Hot tear E None
of any defect. Insert F None
81.10 Single wall thickness shall be radiographed wher-
ever practical.

Page 21 of 22 22/05/08
VALVES — FLANGED,
THREADED, AND WELDING END A S ME B1 6. 34 -19 9 6

B2.1.3 Wall Thickness 4.5 in. to 12 in. The following

comparative plates of ASTM E 280 define acceptable
indications as follows.
Acceptable
Discontinuity Type Category Comparative Plate,
ASTM E 280
Gas porosity A A3
Sand and slag inclusions Shrink,
Type 1 Shrink, Type 2 Shrink, B B3
Type 3 Crack
Hot tear C CA3
Insert C CB3
Gas porosity C CC3
Sand and slag inclusions Shrink,
Type 1 Shrink, Type 2 Shrink, D None
Type 3 Crack
Hot tear E None
Insert F None

Page 22 of 22 22/05/08