You are on page 1of 15

CHAPTER XVI

SPECIAL WRITS

There are four special writs which the courts may issue. These writs essentially involve the violation or threatened violation of certain
constitutional rights. The Supreme Court promulgated the rules by which these writs may be issued pursuant to its power to promulgate rules
concerning the protection and enforcement of constitutional rights. These four writs are as follows:
(1) Writ of Habeas Corpus
(2) Writ of Amparo
(3) Writ of Habeas Data
(4) Writ of Kalikasan

Habeas Corpus, Amparo, Habeas Data and Kalikasan


The Writs of Habeas Corpus, Amparo, Habeas Data and Kalikasan may be distinguished as follows:

Habeas Corpus Amparo Habeas Data Kalikasan


Essence The writ of habeas corpus The writ of amparo involves The writ of habeas data The writ of kalikasan
involves the right to liberty. It the right to life, liberty, and involves the right to privacy involves the right to a
extends to all cases of illegal security. It covers in life, liberty, and security. balanced and healthful
confinement or detention by extrajudicial killings, enforced ecology involving
which any person is deprived disappearances, and threats environmental damage of
of his liberty, or by which the thereof. such magnitude as to
rightful custody of any prejudice the life, health or
person is withheld from the property of inhabitants in
person entitled thereto. two or more cities or
provinces.
Definition “Habeas corpus” literally “Amparo” traces its origin “Habeas data” translates to
means “you have the body” from the Spanish word “you have this data.
in Latin. “amparer,” to which
translates “to protect.”

1
Availability It is a writ directed to the The writ of amparo is a It is a remedy available to any It is a special remedy
person detaining another, remedy available to one person whose right to privacy available to a natural or
commanding him to produce whose right to life, liberty, in life, liberty, or security is juridical person, entity
the body of the prisoner at a and security are violated or violated or threatened by an authorized by law, people’s
designated time and place, threatened with violation by unlawful act or omission of a organization, non-
with the day and cause of his an unlawful act or omission public official or employee, governmental
caption and detention, to do, of a public official or or of a private individual or organization, or any public
submit to, and receive employee, or of a private entity engaged in the interest group accredited
whatever the court or judge individual or entity. The writ gathering, collecting or by or registered with any
awarding the writ shall covers extralegal killings and storing of data or information government agency, on
consider in that behalf. enforced disappearances or regarding the person, family, behalf of persons whose
threats thereof. home and correspondence of constitutional right to a
the aggrieved party. balanced and healthful
ecology is violated, or
threatened with violation
by an unlawful act or
omission of a public official
or employee, or of a
private individual or entity
involving environmental
damage of such magnitude
as to prejudice the life,
health or property of
inhabitants in two or more
cities or provinces.
Available (1) Deprivation of liberty; A violation or threatened A violation or threatened A violation or threatened
Against and violation by an unlawful act violation of the right to violation of the right to a
(2) Withholding the rightful or omission of: privacy in life, liberty, and balanced and healthful
custody of any person (1) A public official; security violation by an ecology by an unlawful act
unlawful act or omission of: or omission of:

2
(2) A public employee; (1) A public official; (1) A public official;
and (2) A public employee; (2) A public employee;
(3) A private individual or and and
entity (3) A private individual or (3) A private individual
entity or entity
Engaged in the gathering,
collecting, or storing of data
or information regarding the
person, family, home and
correspondence of the
aggrieved party.
Coverage (1) All cases of illegal (1) Extrajudicial killings (1) Gathering Environmental damage of
confinement or detention (2) Enforced disappearances (2) Collecting such magnitude as to
by which any person is (3) Storing of data or prejudice the life, health or
deprived of his liberty information property of inhabitants in
(2) The rightful custody of Regarding: two or more cities or
any person withheld from (1) Person provinces.
the person entitled (2) Family
thereto (3) Home
(4) Correspondence
Who May File Party for whose relief it is Aggrieved party, or any General Rule: Aggrieved (1) A natural or juridical
intended, or by some person qualified person or entity in party person;
on his behalf. the following order: Exception: In cases of (2) Entity authorized by
(1) Any member of the extralegal killings and law;
immediate family, enforced disappearances, the (3) People’s organization,
namely: the spouse, petition may be filed by: non-governmental
children, and parents of (1) Any member of the organization, or any
the aggrieved party; immediate family of the public interest group
(2) Any ascendant, aggrieved party, namely: accredited by or
descendant or collateral registered with any

3
relative of the aggrieved the spouse, children, and government agency, on
party within the fourth parents behalf of persons
civil degree of whose constitutional
consanguinity or affinity, right to a balanced and
in default of those healthful ecology is
mentioned in the violated or threatened
preceding paragraph; or with violation.
(3) Any concerned citizen,
organization, association
or institution, if there is
no known member of the
immediate family or
relative of the aggrieved
party
Venue (1) Regional Trial Court (1) Regional Trial Court of (2) Regional Trial Court (1) Supreme Court
where the person is the place where the where the petitioner (2) Court of Appeals
detained threat, act, or or respondent
(2) Sandiganbayan omission was resides, or that which
(3) Court of Appeals committed or any of has jurisdiction over
(4) Supreme Court its elements occurred the place where the
(5) Or any Justice of the data or information is
the three preceding gathered, collected,
courts or stored, at the
option of the
petitioner
(3) Sandiganbayan
(4) Court of Appeals
(5) Supreme Court

4
when the action concerns
public data filed of
government offices
Enforceability Issued by the Sandiganbayan, Anywhere in the Philippines Anywhere in the Philippines
of the Writ Court of Appeals, Supreme
Court: Anywhere in the
Philippines issued by the
Regional Trial Court: Judicial
district
Where Writ is Issued by: Regional Trial Issued by: Regional Trial Issued by: Regional Trial
Returned Court or judge thereof: Court or judge thereof: Court or judge thereof:
Before such court or judge Before such court or judge Before such court or judge
Sandiganbayan, Court of  Sandiganbayan, Court Sandiganbayan, Court of
Appeals, or any of its justices: of Appeals, or any of Appeals, or any of its justices:
 Before such court or its justices:  Before such court or
justice thereof  Before such court or justice thereof
justice thereof  Any Regional Trial
 Any Regional Trial Court where the
Court where the petitioner or
threat, act, or respondent resides,
omission was or that which has
committed or any of jurisdiction over the
its elements occurred place where the data
or information is
gathered, collected,
or stored
Supreme Court or any of its
justices:
 Before such court or
justice thereof

5
 Before the Court of
Appeals or the
Sandiganbayan, or
any of its justices
 Any Regional Trial
Court where the
petitioner or
respondent resides,
or that which has
jurisdiction over the
place where the data
or information is
gathered, collected,
or stored
When to On any day and at any time On any day and at any time Only indigent petitioner is Exempt from payment of
File/Docket Exempt from docket and exempt from docket and docket fees
Fees other lawful fees other lawful fees
Contents of (1) Person in whose behalf of (1) Personal circumstances of (1) Personal circumstances of (1) Personal circumstances
Petition the application is made is the petitioner; the petitioner and the of the petitioner;
imprisoned or restrained (2) Name and personal respondent; (2) Name and personal
on his liberty; circumstances of the (2) Manner the right to circumstances of the
(2) Officer or name of the respondent responsible privacy is violated or respondent or if the
person by whom he is so for the threat, act or threatened and how it name and personal
imprisoned or restrained; omission, or if the name affects the right to life, circumstances are
or, if both are unknown is unknown or uncertain, liberty or security of the unknown and
or uncertain, such officer the respondent may be aggrieved party; uncertain, the
or person may be described by an assumed (3) Actions and recourses respondent may be
described by an assumed appellation; taken by the petitioner to described by an
appellation, and the (3) Right to life, liberty and secure the data or assumed appellation;
person who is served security of the aggrieved information;

6
with the writ shall be party violated or (4) Location of the files, (3) Environmental law,
deemed the person threatened with violation registers or databases, rule or regulation
intended; by an unlawful act or the government office, violated or threatened
(3) Place where he is so omission of the and the person in charge, to be violated, the act
imprisoned or restrained, respondent, and how in possession or in or omission
if known; such threat or violation is control of the data or complained of, and the
(4) A copy of the committed with the information, if known; environmental damage
commitment or cause of attendant circumstances (5) Reliefs prayed for, which of such magnitude as
detention of such person, detailed in supporting may include the updating, to prejudice the life,
if it can be procured affidavits; rectification, suppression health or property of
without impairing the (4) Investigation conducted, or destruction of the inhabitants in two or
efficiency of the remedy; if any, specifying the database, information, or more cities or
or, if the imprisonment or names, personal files kept by the provinces.
restraint is without any circumstances, and respondent; (4) All relevant and
legal authority, such fact addresses of the (6) In case of threats, the material evidence
shall appear. investigating authority or relief may include a consisting of the
The petition shall be signed individuals, as well as the prayer for an order affidavits of witnesses,
and verified. manner and conduct of enjoining the act documentary evidence,
the investigation together complained of; and scientific or other
with any report; (7) Such other relevant expert studies, and if
(5) Actions and recourses reliefs as are just and possible, object
taken by the petitioner to equitable. evidence;
determine the fate or The petition shall be in (5) Certification against
whereabouts of the writing and must be verified. forum shopping; and
aggrieved party and the (6) Reliefs prayed for,
identity of the person which may include a
responsible for the prayer for the issuance
threat, act or omission; of a Temporary
and Environmental
(6) Relief prayed for Protection Order.

7
The petition must be signed The petition must be
and verified. verified.
Issuance of  Writ shall be issued if it  Writ shall be issued if on  Writ shall be issued if on  Within three days from
the Writ appears that the writ its face it ought to issue its face it ought to issue the date of filing of the
ought to issue  The clerk of court shall  The clerk of court shall petition, if the petition
 The clerk of court shall issue the writ under the issue the writ under the is sufficient in form and
issue the writ under the seal of the court; or in seal of the court and substance, the court
seal of the court; or in case of urgent necessity, cause it to be served shall give an order: (a)
case of emergency, the the justice or the judge within three days from issuing the writ; and (b)
judge may issue the writ may issue the writ under the issuance; or in case of requiring the
under his own hand, and his own hand, and may urgent necessity, the respondent to file a
may depute any officer or deputize any officer or justice or the judge may verified return.
person to serve it. person to serve it. issue the writ under his  The clerk of court shall
own hand, and may forthwith issue the writ
deputize any officer or under the seal of the
person to serve it. court including the
issuance of a cease and
desist order and other
temporary reliefs
effective until further
order.
Summary Not later than seven days Not later than ten working The hearing including the
Hearing from the date the writ was days from the date the writ preliminary conference
issued. was issued. shall not extend beyond 60
days and shall be given
priority as petitions for the
writs of habeas corpus,
amparo, and habeas data.
How Writ is By leaving the original with The writ shall be served upon The writ shall be served upon The writ shall be served
Served the person to whom it is the respondent by a judicial the respondent by a judicial upon the respondent by a

8
directed and preserving a officer or by a person officer or by a person court officer or any person
copy on which to make deputized by the court, deputized by the court, deputized by the court,
return or service. If that justice or judge who shall justice or judge who shall who shall retain a copy on
person cannot be found, or retain a copy on which to retain a copy on which to which to make a return of
has not the prisoner in his make a return of service. In make a return of service. In service. In case the writ
custody, then the service case the writ cannot be case the writ cannot be cannot be served
shall be made on any other served personally on the served personally on the personally on the
person having or exercising respondent, the rules of respondent, the rules of respondent, the rules of
such custody. substituted service shall substituted service shall substituted service shall
apply. apply. apply.
Return  The return or statement  Within 72 hours after  Verified written return  Within a non-
shall be signed by the service of the writ, the together with supporting extendible period of
person who makes it. respondent shall file a affidavits within five ten days after service
 The return shall also be verified written return working days from the of the writ, the
sworn by him if the together with supporting service of the writ. respondent shall file a
prisoner is not produced. affidavits.  The period may be verified return which
 In all other cases unless reasonably extended by shall contain all
the return is made and the Court for justifiable defenses to show that
signed by a sworn public reasons. respondent did not
officer in his official violate or threaten to
capacity. violate, or allow the
violation of any
environmental law,
rule or regulation or
commit any act
resulting to
environmental damage
of such magnitude as
to prejudice the life,
health or property of

9
inhabitants in two or
more cities or
provinces.
 All defenses not raised
in the return shall be
deemed waived.
 The return shall include
affidavits of witnesses,
documentary evidence,
scientific or other
expert studies, and if
possible, object
evidence in support of
the defense of the
respondent.
 A general denial of
allegations in the
petition shall be
considered as an
admission thereof.
Effect of Hearing of the petition shall  Hearing of the petition Hearing of the petition
Failure to File proceed ex parte shall proceed ex parte shall proceed ex parte
a Return  The court may also grant
the petitioner such relief
as the petition may
warrant unless the court
in its discretion required
the petitioner to submit
evidence.

10
Prohibited (1) Motion to dismiss (1) Motion to dismiss (1) Motion to dismiss
Pleadings and (2) Motion for extension of (2) Motion for extension of (2) Motion for
Motions time to file return, time to file return, extension of time
opposition, affidavit, opposition, affidavit, to file return,
position paper and other position paper and other opposition,
pleadings; pleadings; affidavit, position
(3) Dilatory motion for (3) Dilatory motion for paper and other
postponement; postponement; pleadings;
(4) Motion for a bill of (4) Motion for a bill of (3) Motion for
particulars; particulars; postponement;
(5) Counterclaim or (5) Counterclaim or (4) Motion for a bill of
crossclaim; crossclaim; particulars;
(6) Third party complaint; (6) Third party complaint; (5) Counterclaim or
(7) Reply; (7) Reply; crossclaim;
(8) Motion to declare (8) Motion to declare (6) Third party
respondent in default; respondent in default; complaint;
(9) Intervention; (9) Intervention; (7) Reply; and
(10) Memorandum (10) Memorandum (8) Motion to declare
(11) Motion for (11) Motion for respondent in
reconsideration of reconsideration of default
interlocutory orders or interlocutory orders or
interim relief orders; and interim relief orders; and
(12) Petition for certiorari, (12) Petition for certiorari,
mandamus or prohibition mandamus or prohibition
against any interlocutory against any interlocutory
order. order.
Available (1) Temporary Protection (1) Ocular Inspection
Interim Reliefs Order Order
(2) Inspection Order (2) Inspection Order
(3) Production Order (3) Production Order

11
(4) Witness Protection Order
Judgment When the court or judge has The court shall render The court shall render The court shall render
examined into the cause of judgment within ten days judgment within ten days judgment granting or
caption and restraint of the from the time the petition is from the time the petition is denying the privilege of the
prisoner, and is satisfied that submitted for decision. If the submitted for decision. If the writ of kalikasan within 60
he is unlawfully imprisoned allegations in the petition are allegations in the petition are days from the time the
or restrained, he shall: proven substantial evidence, proven substantial evidence, petition is submitted for
 Forthwith order his the court shall grant the the court shall enjoin the act decision. The reliefs that
discharge from privilege of the writ and such complained of, or order the may be granted under the
confinement reliefs as may be proper and deletion, destruction, or writ are the following:
 Such discharge shall not appropriate; otherwise, the rectification of the erroneous  Directing respondent
be effective until a copy privilege shall be denied. data or information and to permanently cease
of the order has been grant other relevant reliefs as and desist from
served on the officer or may be just and equitable; committing acts or
person detaining the otherwise, the privilege of neglecting the
prisoner the writ shall be denied. performance of a duty
 If the officer or person Upon its finality, the in violation of
detaining the prisoner judgment shall be enforced environmental laws
does not desire to appeal. by the sheriff or any lawful resulting in
The prisoner shall be officers as may be designated environmental
forthwith released. by the court, justice or judge destruction or damage;
within five working days.  Directing the
respondent public
official, government
agency, private person
or entity to protect,
preserve, rehabilitate,
or restore the
environment;

12
 Directing the
respondent public
official, government
agency, private person
or entity to monitor
strict compliance with
the decision and orders
of the court;
 Directing the
respondent public
official, government
agency, private person
or entity to make
periodic reports on the
execution of the final
judgment; and
 Such other reliefs
which relate to the
right if the people to a
balanced and healthful
ecology or to the
protection,
preservation,
rehabilitation or
restoration of the
environment, except
the award of damages
to individual
petitioners.

13
Appeal 48 hours from notice of Any party may appeal from Any party may appeal from Any party may appeal from
judgement appealed from by the final judgement or order the final judgement or order the final judgement or
ordinary appeal. to the Supreme Court under to the Supreme Court under order to the Supreme
Rule 45. Rule 45. Court under Rule 45.
The appeal may raise The appeal may raise The appeal may raise
questions of fact or law or questions of fact or law or questions of fact or law or
both. both. both.
The period of appeal shall be The period of appeal shall be The period of appeal must
five working days from the five working days from the be taken within 15 days
date of notice of the adverse date of notice of the adverse from the date of notice of
judgment. judgment. the adverse judgment or
denial of motion for
reconsideration.
Institution of The Rule does not preclude The Rule does not preclude The filing of a petition for
Separate the filing of separate the filing of separate the issuance of the writ of
Actions criminal, civil, or criminal, civil, or kalikasan shall not
administrative actions. administrative actions. preclude the filing of
separate criminal, civil, or
administrative actions.
Effect of Filing When a criminal action has When a criminal action has
a Criminal been commenced, no been commenced, no
Action separate petition for the writ separate petition for the writ
shall be filed. The reliefs shall be filed. The reliefs
under the writ shall be under the writ shall be
available by motion in the available by motion in the
criminal case. criminal case.
Consolidation When a criminal action is When a criminal action is
filed subsequent to the filing filed subsequent to the filing
of a petition for the writ, the of a petition for the writ, the

14
latter shall be consolidated latter shall be consolidated
with the criminal action. with the criminal action.
When a criminal action and a When a criminal action and a
separate civil action are filed separate civil action are filed
subsequent to a petition for a subsequent to a petition for a
writ of amparo, the latter writ of habeas data, the
shall be consolidated with petition shall be consolidated
the criminal action. with the criminal action.
After consolidation, the After consolidation, the
procedure under this Rule procedure under this Rule
shall continue to apply to the shall govern the disposition
disposition of the reliefs in of the reliefs in the petition.
the petition.

15

You might also like