Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Announcer: Welcome to the Creative Piano Teaching Podcast, the place where teachers from around the
world meet to share innovative ideas about music education. Listen and learn as we help you
motivate your students, grow your income, expand your studio, and become a more creative
piano teacher.
Tim Topham: Good day, everyone, and welcome back to the Creative Piano Teaching Podcast. You're
listening to Episode #102, and if you're one of my Inner Circle piano teaching community
members, a special welcome to you. My name is Tim Topham, your host for the show, and if
this is your first time here, thank you so much for tuning in. I definitely recommend that you
subscribe, because we've got lots of awesome content coming up as we finish composition
month and move into group teaching focus for September. The Creative Piano Teaching
Podcast is of course a place where you can get weekly inspiration, ideas, business and teaching
strategies to help support your teaching and grow your studio.
Remember that the best place to listen to podcasts like this is on your phone or tablet, as you
drive, cook, exercise, or walk the dog. So if you're watching this while staring at a screen on
your computer, I'd encourage you to reconsider a good way to listen to these, which is on the
go. Just use the podcast app on your phone, search for "creative piano" and click subscribe.
You'll automatically be notified when new episodes go live. And thanks to everyone who has
left reviews on Facebook and iTunes recently. I really appreciate all your feedback and the time
you spent to make and create those. Find out how you too can support the work I'm doing by
leaving a review. You can find out how to do that at timtopham.com/review. Today's show
notes and a full transcript are now available at timtopham.com/episode102.
New just before we dive into this week's episode, I want to take this opportunity to let you
know that the Creative Teaching Podcast is brought to you by the Inner Circle, the world's
leading professional development and training community for piano teachers. Inner Circle
members get access to an extensive library of courses, teaching videos, lesson plans, and
downloads that cover everything you need to know, not only to teach piano creatively and
inspire students of all ages and abilities, but also to support you in building and growing your
studio. On top of that you also get access to our monthly online Masterminds, exclusive
member discounts on products and software and sheet music, plus our active community
forums where you not only get advice and input from me but also from hundreds of fellow
piano teachers from around the world and my hand picked team of experts ready to help you
whenever you need it.
So if you're serious about expanding your teaching repertoire, learning the best strategies to
motivate and inspire students while growing a thriving studio, the Inner Circle is the place to
be. You can find out more about it at timtopham.com/community, and remember that you as a
podcast listener can use the code "piano podcast" to take $100 off an annual subscription,
locked in for the life of your membership. I look forward to seeing you there.
Let's get stuck into today's episode. It's all about modes. And I've decided to create an episode
on modes because I know that there's a lot of confusion around modes. People are really not
sure what they are, how to work out if a piece of music's in a mode, what relevance they have
to teaching, if they should introduce them to their students, how they should do that, all those
kinds of questions. So that's what we're getting stuck into today. And you're going to love
today's freebie download that I've created for you. It's my modes worksheet. It's just two pages
ready to pop on your piano bench or next to your piano for teaching, and I actually have this on
my piano all the time with my circle of fifths. And I use both, as you probably know, quite
regularly.
The mode worksheet of course is going to be a great way for you to quickly reference if a piece
of music's in a particular mode, or what notes are in a mode, and how they sound, and what
they can do, and those kinds of things. So grab that. Whenever you've got a chance, you can
head to timtopham.com/episode102, that's the show notes page, and you'll be able to scroll
down and find the download link for the piano modes worksheet. I really hope that's helpful
for you, and I'm going to be referencing it a few times in today's episode.
I've actually really enjoyed digging into modes in preparation for this episode. As you probably
realize, I put a fair bit of thought into all my podcasts, and I like to see this as a little mini free
training for you. And so hopefully today's episode is no exception to that. And I posted on
Facebook in a couple of groups and on my own page about questions that people had about
modes, and there was a lot of questions, there was a lot of great ideas that came out, too, so
it's a topic of interest.
Now, I do want to preempt this whole episode with the fact that I am not a musicologist or
specialist in modes, or scales, series, or patterns or anything to do with the technical side of
scales. I'm not a specialist in it, I'm just a piano teacher who has got some ideas about it and
will be sharing these in this episode. So if you have a different approach to the way you teach
modes, or you've studied it all your life and you realize that I've got some inconsistencies or
whatever it is, totally fine. I put my hand up and say right from the beginning I'm not a
specialist in this, but hopefully what I give you today is practical, useful advice that you can use
in your studio, because that's what my whole website is about, right? Helping you with
practical advice you can use straightaway. So I'm going to try and cut through all the confusion
and just give you what you need to know.
We'll be talking through six different sections today. The first one is "what are modes?" A little
bit of an introduction that's not too long, and some confusing stuff to ignore, which is going to
be talked about in that section. In part two, I'm going to go through the modes, so some
characteristics and examples of them. Section three is all about how to work out if music you're
playing is in a mode, and what mode that is. Section four is how to use modes in your teaching.
Section 5 is most popular questions from readers and listeners, and I've actually distilled them
down to very few, because all the questions really were very similar. And finally, in section five
of this podcast, I'm going to be talking about resources. So compositions that are written in
modes, music to explore, and some of those great links. And all those links to the music that I
suggest will all be on the show notes page of course at timtopham.com/episode 102.
Alright, so let's get into section one, what are modes? Well, a mode is just a series of notes like
a scale. A mode is a specific sequence of whole steps and half steps, or tones and semi-tones if
you're here in Australia or the United Kingdom. Historically, the term "mode" and not "scale"
was used for all of these kinds of note sequences, going back to the ancient Greeks. Over time,
the term for two particular modes, Ionian and Aeolian, came to be called scales. And today we
call the Ionian mode the major scale, and the Aeolian mode the minor scale, or more
specifically the natural minor scale.
The term "mode" is still used for the other note sequences, so both mode and scale are simply
a sequence of eight notes, with the intervals between two successive notes varying in distance
from one step ... a whole step or a half step. Now there's lots of history around church modes
and how they relate to Gregorian chant and all that kind of stuff, but look, to be honest, I don't
really have all the detail about the history and to me it's not 100% relevant to what I'm doing
with my students anyway. But if you're interested in that, I'm sure you'll be able to find lots of
information about it online and how these modes have developed out of church modes or
Gregorian chant and those sorts of things.
Today there are seven commonly recognized musical modes, each with a different sequence of
notes, whole and half steps as we've said, and each with a characteristic note and sound as
well. As my good friend Forrest Kinney says, Lydian is more springlike than major, while
Phrygian is more wintry than minor. Dorian has a sweet, hopeful, melancholic nature that
minor doesn't know, while Mixolydian has a sassiness that a major key wouldn't dare expose.
What a poet Forrest Kinney is. Many of you will be aware of Forrest's fantastic creative work,
and you can find him online, and the great news is that he's actually appearing on our podcast
here in two weeks time. So do stay tuned for that. That's going to be episode #104.
While modes may be demonstrated and explored by starting on specific white notes on the
keyboard and playing only white notes until you get to the same note an octave higher, in my
opinion it's actually better to consider how the notes of the scales are related to the major and
minor scales that they're built on. We'll get to more of that later.
Modes are not that typical in most Western music, although they're quite common in folk
tunes. Dorian and Mixolydian are definitely the most common, and we'll talk about what that
actually means in the next section.
Now I just want to cover some confusing things that you can probably ignore. So just back to
this white note thing. I'm not such a fan of talking about Dorian is the white notes from D to D,
and Phrygian's from E to E and all that kind of stuff on the keyboard. I mean, that is true;
however, I tend to think of the various modes as being related to some changes, so they're
changed from the major scale or changed from the natural minor scale. So for example, Dorian
has a flattened 3rd and a flattened 7th note. So you could either consider playing any major
scale, so we could play a G major scale, and if you flatten the 3rd and the 7th note, you'll get G
Dorian. That's the easy way for me to think about it.
However Dorian, given that it's got that flat 3rd, you might want to think of it as a natural
minor scale with a raised 6th note. So on the piano modes worksheet that I've given you to
print out, you can actually see on the front page I give the name of the modes, the notation as
it looks on white notes, and the notation in C. And also on that, I give the alterations of the
major scale. So Phrygian would be a major scale with a flat 2, 3, 6, and 7. That's all you have to
remember. Lydian is a major scale with a sharp 4, and so forth. And we'll go into a little bit
more detail of that later.
Now again, the purists and people who take a different approach to this, might well say that
the Phrygian scale, it's got a flat 2, 3, 6, and 7, is actually a natural minor scale with a flat 2,
because a natural minor scale already has flat 3, 6, and 7. Okay, so there's two ways to think
about it. I think it's up to you 100% which way you want to go, and I've included both on the
worksheet for you to download. So you can decide which approach you would like.
Another confusing thing you might have seen around is talk of things like Hyperlydian or Lydian
Dominant and various other permutations and combinations of mode-speak. I'm not going to
cover any of that because I just don't understand it, and I haven't got time to learn it, and I
don't think it's all that relevant to most teachers today. So we're just going to keep it nice and
simple and practical. One other point of nomenclature is that sometimes jazz musicians might
refer to a mode as being part of a different scale set. So my good friend Bradley Sowash, when
we were talking about this, says that, for example, the jazz altered dominant scale, which
would be A, B-flat, C-sharp, D, E, F, G, A, can be described as the 5th mode of the D harmonic
scale, right? Now again for me, too confusing. I'm not going to worry about it, but I do want to
mention and just reiterate again that there's far more depth to this topic that you could
research if you want to, but for me we're just going to keep it nice and simple today, and for
you hopefully to make sure it's usable in your studio.
Okay, so my next question is who cares about modes anyway? What is the point of worrying
about it? Well, I think first and foremost, students will come across music that is written in a
mode, and they should have a grasp of how it works and what that actually means. Also,
teachers will often need to help students with their ... we call them general knowledge for
assessments and exams. That's where the examiner can ask them, what key's this in or what's
the form of this piece. And we need to know as teachers that just because a piece of music has
a key signature at the start, if it begins and ends on a different note that's not the major and
minor related to that key signature, and it just doesn't seem to fit the key, it may well be in a
mode and we need to know what that is and how to work it out.
Modes are used for creativity and improvising. And if you want to get creative with a piece of
music in a mode, you (1) need to know it's in a mode and (2) you need to know what notes are
available for improvising with. So for example, if a piece of music has A as the tonic and a
whole lot of A minor, D and G chords, with clearly no E7 and a sharp G, then the music's
probably in A Dorian. And that gives you some knowledge about how you could get a little bit
creative with it. Now I've been actually exploring this concept in the new AMEB Piano for
Leisure Series 4 books, which over here in Australia are some of our Exam Board books, with
regard to my performance notes. And these are notes that I've included on every piece, with
some teaching strategies and ways that you can get creative about that piece with your
student.
And so part of the reason for this podcast is because as part of that work, I needed to get my
own head around modes for the purposes of writing and editing those books. And so I had to
dig deeply and make sure that I knew what I was talking about when it came to saying, "Well
this piece is actually in E Phrygian, and here are the notes that you can use to improvise with
it." And look, modes are great to explore if you want new moods or sounds. And perhaps
you're working with your students on improvising and they've done a fair bit in major and
minor, and perhaps the pentatonic scale, and maybe they can improv in the blues scale. Maybe
the next thing you can do is to start getting a bit more creative with some modes, and as the
student's creativity develops they can learn more and more. So that's just another take on,
again, why I think understanding modes is relevant to teachers.
All right, so now let's go through each of the modes, and I'm going to be referring to my
worksheet here, so if you have that handy and you're not cooking or walking the dog or
whatever it is, feel free to grab it out and you can explore it with me. Now the first mode is the
Ionian mode. This is simply the major scale. So I'm not actually going to talk about that at all,
because I think we all know the major scale, how it sounds, and pieces of music in that mode.
So let's move straight on to Dorian. As I said before, you can think of Dorian in two ways. You
could think of it as a major scale with a flattened 3rd and 7th note, or you can think of it as a
natural minor scale with a raised 6th note. Either way, if I'm playing in C major, I'm going to be
playing C, D, E-flat, F, G, A, B-flat, and C. Here's how a Dorian sounds in C. There's a number of
pieces that you'll recognize probably that are in this mode. "Scarborough Fair" is one of the
more popular ones. "What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor" is another one of them. And it
tends to work really well over minor 7th chords. So a little chord progression or a couple of
chords that you could use, let's work in D Dorian, that's all the white notes, and in my left hand
I'm just going to explore D minor and G chords while I improvise a little bit on D Dorian. So I'm
using the white notes now from D to D. Have a listen.
So those chords in my left hand were just simply a D minor in root position and a G chord in
second inversion. Nice and easy for any student pretty much to play. And you can hear it's got
that kind of sense of lift as per the Drunken Sailor. I think of it, and Daniel McFarlane podcast
episode 1 was talking about it having a nautical kind of feel to it. That characteristic note of
course is the raised 6th. So if you're thinking about it from the natural minor scale, it's a natural
minor scale with a raised 6th, and that's kind of the key, the characteristic note of the Dorian
mode.
All right, let's move on. Phrygian now. So Phrygian is a natural minor scale with a flattened 2nd
note. And so if you're just thinking from major scale, you're going to be flattening the 2nd, 3rd,
6th, and 7th notes. So let me play Phrygian mode in the key of C. So I'm playing the notes C,
D-flat, E-flat, F, G, A-flat, B-flat, and C. And again, I've got the worksheet in front of me, so this
is nice and easy. So make sure you grab that download. It's got a little bit of a kind of Spanish
sound, and I used this to effect in my "No Book Beginners" course, and you can find out more
about that at timtopham.com/beginners, if that's of interest to you. My No Book Beginners
course is a creative way of starting beginner students without any reading or method books for
up to about 10 weeks. And one of the improv activities that I do in there is an "Around the
World" improv.
And so I used this Phrygian mode for improvising in that course. So I used just the first five
notes. If I add some chords like that you can obviously hear that Spanish-y kind of influence
really, really clearly. Interestingly enough, for the Egyptian part of that Around the World
improv, I used a harmonic minor scale, and for an Asian kind of feel I used pentatonic, and
always fun, an alien sound. Do you know what kind of scale you'd use for an alien sound on the
piano? It's this one. Tell me what it is. Do you know what that scale is? Yes, that's the whole
tone scale, great fun. C, D, E, and then G-flat, A-flat, B-flat. Good fun to play. All right, so that's
the Phrygian mode. Flat 2, 3, 6, and 7 from the major scale, that's how you might like to think
of it.
All right, now the next one is the Lydian, and the characteristic note of the Lydian scale is a
sharp 4. So to play a Lydian scale, all we need to do is play a major scale and raise the 4th note
by a semitone. Here's how it sounds again in C. So the notes I was playing there, C, D, E,
F-sharp, G, A, B, C. And explore these at home in your own time. I think you'll really enjoy
working with these. The Lydian scale has a kind of uplifting, a little bit quirky sound. It's used in
"The Simpsons Theme". It's actually a Lydian dominant, so I'm told. And what that means or
how to work it out I'm again not sure. I'd have to research it. So don't worry about it. But just
know that that (sings) is very much a Lydian characteristic and adds to that quirkiness. Actually,
I think the Lydian dominant has a B-flat in it as well from memory. But again, go easy on me,
musicologists who are out there listening.
So it's got that kind of uplifting sound, and there's a great piece by my good friend here in
Australia, Elissa Milne called "Gold Rush". It's in our grade 2 Australian examination series over
here. It's in a Lydian mode. So C major with an F-sharp, that raised 4th of course sounding very
cool. Let me just see if I've got it here on the piano. Yeah, here's a little bit of "Gold Rush" by
Elissa Milne. As always with Elissa, beautifully written, great pedagogical music. If you're
interested in her books, they are called "Little Peppers" and highly recommended for all kind of
students. Sorry, Elisa, is you're listening to my botched rhythm right at the start there. But you
get the idea of that sound. It's kind of quirky, it's kind of fun and uplifting. So that's the Lydian
mode, just a major scale with a sharpened 4th note.
The next scale is Mixolydian. So all you have to do to create a Mixolydian mode is lower the 7th
note of a major scale. That's just one note different, nice and easy. And that flattened 7th note
is really the characteristic note of this scale. And so it tends to work quite well over dominant
7th chords. It used to be one that certainly The Beatles tended to use a fair bit in their work. So
here's how it sounds, Mixolydian. I'll play it again in C. So I'm going to play a C scale with a
B-flat. And you could improvise over a few simple chords. I'm just going to try playing this in G,
because that's just white notes, G to G on the piano. And I'll try G, F, E minor and F chords in
my left hand. Let's see if this works.
By the way, these little chord progressions that I'm exploring over these modes are all written
on the worksheet. So on the back side of the worksheet, the table is divided into five columns.
We've got six, sorry: the name of the mode, songs that use it, changes from the major scale,
changes from the natural minor scale, the sound or mood that it conveys, and in the final
column chord progressions to improvise over. So let me see if this works. I'm going to play
around with G Mixolydian. You get the idea. Very simple. All I was playing was G and F chords,
and an E minor thrown in there. It's quite a bright sound, little bit edgy, and it's kind of
pop-sounding too. A fair bit of pop music's written with this kind of lowered 7th note these
days. So that's the Mixolydian mode.
Now the next mode in the set is Aeolian. Now Aeolian is simply your natural minor scale. And
as I tell anyone who comes to workshops in the last year or so, I recommend highly teaching
natural minor scales before you teach harmonic minor scales. Why? Because the natural minor
of course is exactly the same set of notes as the relative major, so it makes the connection for
students between key signatures and sharps and flats in a key much more understandable, and
it allows you to do great improvising, because it's a really cool sounding scale. So here's the
Aeolian scale. I'm just going to play C Aeolian. So that would be the notes C, D, E-flat, F, G,
A-flat, B-flat, and C. Here's how it sounds, versus of course the harmonic minor with the raised
7th, which sounds like this.
So the natural minor, I'm not going to talk too much about that, because I think most people
are familiar with that sound. And again, make sure your students, if they're learning minor and
major scales, get them to learn the natural minor first and be really confident with it. It should
be easier, because again, if they know the notes for G major, they already know the notes for E
natural minor, because they're the same. All right? So it's a good little trick for you.
Now finally we get on to everyone's favorite, Locrian, or Locrian, depending on how you want
to say it. The Locrian mode is the only modern diatonic mode in which the tonic chord is a
diminished chord, resulting in a tonic chord that is considered dissonant. So for example, the
tonic chord of B Locrian is B, D, and F, and the interval between the tonic B and the dominant F
is a diminished 5th, which is why it's a little bit controversial. Let me play you a Locrian scale in
the key of C. So in order to play this, I'm going to play C, D-flat, E-flat, F, G-flat, A-flat, B-flat, C.
So this is a major scale with a flattened 2, 3, 5, 6, and 7. Here's how it sounds.
It's actually really quite fun to play, because it's a little bit like B major to play, because you've
got the two flat notes and the three flat notes in patterns, but you're playing the C and the F
instead of the B and the E. So explore it. It's quite fun ... as I say, quite fun to play. Much harder
to explore improvising with. And it's also quite hard to find examples of music written in this,
because it's actually quite hard to write in this mode and stay in it. So much music will tend to
perhaps have elements of Locrian in it without staying in it too long, because it's not the most
pleasant way to write music. As my good friend Bradly Sowash said the other day, the Locrian's
just plain messed up and hardly ever used. And he's a jazz musician, so that kind of tells you
that you probably don't need to worry ... Sorry, Bradley, if you didn't want me to say that,
because I know you're probably listening. Look, I don't really use the Locrian mode or explore it
with students. I haven't yet found a piece of music that I've needed to work out that it is in
Locrian mode, so, to be honest, I don't think you need to worry about it.
So really all you need to learn about that might be new, if we take out the Ionian and the
Aeolian, the natural minor and the major, and then really all you've got is Dorian, Phrygian,
Lydian, and Mixolydian. That's only four modes that you should probably get used to and get
comfortable playing and exploring. The other ones you don't need to worry about too much.
Okay, so part two is how to work out if music you're playing is in a mode, and I get asked this
by teachers a fair bit. The first thing to look at is the key, and the notes in the piece of music. If
they don't kind of correlate too well, then chances are you might be in a mode. And this is
without even playing and listening to the music, of course. What you'll find is that if the key of
the piece of music looks like a D major key signature, so F-sharp and C-sharp, and yet it doesn't
start and end on D or D chords, or its relative minor, B minor, then it starts on ... maybe it starts
on an E or something like that, chances are you're using some kind of mode. And there's a
couple of ways to work out which mode that is.
Also, I think it's a great idea to use sound too. And if we go from kind of brightest sounding to
darkest, although this is subjective listening of course, we're probably thinking from brightest
Lydian, Ionian, Mixolydian ... to getting darker, Dorian, Aeolian, Phrygian, and Locrian. Often
the sound of it would definitely tell you that something's a bit funny. It's like oh, I was
expecting an F-sharp there in that G major piece and there isn't one. That's kind of weird. I
wonder what that means. And then you can dig a little bit deeper.
Interestingly enough, I worked out a trick only recently about you can actually work this out.
Now I don't particularly like tricks in music, so I'd use these as a test to see if you're right. So
here's how it works. What you need to know is the order of modes in order. So it's Ionian,
Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, Mixolydian, Aeolian, and Locrian. I-D-P-L-M-A-L. And you know how
much I love mnemonics, I was researching a little bit of this and found some people talking
about mnemonics of these, so I thought these were kind of funny. "I don't particularly like
middle aged ladies" was one that somebody said. And that's a little bit ageist, of course. And
another one was "I don't play loud music at lessons." Now again, I'm not too worried about ...
There's no reason I can see why students would need to learn these, I just thought they were
funny. So don't go and suddenly start feeling you've got to teach all your students mnemonics
of the order of modes, please, whatever you do. Again, I'm using this as a test.
So we've got the order though. So then step two, work out the major key according to the key
signature. So if it's a G major key signature so it's got an F-sharp, we're talking about G. Step
three, work out the tonic note of the piece. So if the key signature is G, seems to be G major
with an F-sharp, and the first note is A, then all you need to do is count the interval from the
major tonic key to the tonic note of the piece and move that many places along the order of
modes. So here's an example. We've got a piece of music written with a G major key signature,
but the first note is A. So between G and A I'm moving one place along. That means I start with
Ionian, I move one place along in my list of modes, and I end up on Dorian. This piece is in A
Dorian.
Here's another example. I see a D major key signature. D major, so C-sharp and F-sharp. But
the first note is G. So I'm going to count between D and G upwards. D, E, F, G, that's four. And
I'm going to move along my order of modes: Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian. That's four along.
This piece of music is in G Lydian.
So here's a couple of examples of actual pieces of music written in modes, and interestingly
enough, these three all feature in the next Piano for Leisure series here in Australia. So my first
example is one called "Sea Bird" by my good friend Christopher Norton. Looks like it's in C
major, but it starts on D. So what key's this one in? Don't have time to play the whole piece, of
course. So there's no key signature, but clearly centered around D. What was the mode? Well,
we've moved one along the list. We're in D Dorian.
The other way to check this of course is to look through the music and go, "It seems to be
centered around D, but there's no F-sharp or C-sharp, and those two notes are the 3rd and the
7th. It seems to have a flattened 3rd and a flattened 7th. What mode has a flattened 3rd and
7th? Ah, Dorian. Let's do that check, and we can check the order."
Here's another one from the books. This one is called ... in fact, you'll know this one. I'm not
even going to tell you the name of it. The key signature is D, but it starts on an E. Have a listen
to it, and I'm going to ask you what mode is this and what's the name of the piece. So did you
work out what mode this was in or what's the name of the piece? We should be doing like a
quiz show here. So this was "Mad World". Key signature of D but it starts on an E, so this is in E
Dorian.
One more example. This is a piece of music called "Jazz Train" by Wynn-Anne Rossi, and this
has a key signature of C, but definitely starts in a G position. So have a listen to this and see
whether you can work out what mode this one's probably in. You get the idea. Great fun little
piece that one. Called "Jazz Train". It's in the key of C, starts in a G position, so that one is in G
Mixolydian. We've gone up C, D, E, F, G, we've gone up five positions in our order, so we're in
Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, Mixolydian. So that's written in a major scale position with no
sharp 7th, a flattened 7th in other words. And that one's in G, so I should be expecting mostly
white notes and no F-sharp.
So there you go. I hope that has helped you to work out if the music you're playing is in a
mode, the best way to do this is to explore music and find the answers yourself. See if you can
work out these modes without sort of jumping on Google, either using your ears or the
changed notes in the actual piece of music. Like I said, it seems to be in D major but there's no
F-sharp or C-sharp, what does that mean? And then finally, you could use this trick that I've
taught you about the order. Don't worry about those mnemonics please though.
So, let's get to the juice of now using this in your teaching. You've got a few options here,
depending on how you want to approach this. You could add modes to students' scale practice.
So you could start on the white notes, and just like adding pentatonic and blues scales as
they're exploring those creative activities around blues or some chordal composing with some
simple pentatonic melodies over the top, these give them more options to explore.
Interestingly enough, some exam boards are starting to use these too now and introduce them.
Rockschool and ANZCA, which is our Australia New Zealand exam board here, both are
exploring modes with students, which is great.
Now the other thing you could do is play scales in the right hand, so modal scales with the
students and just some left hand chords. And that's why I wanted to include the chord
progressions that work with these modes in the freebie download. Again, you can get that at
timtopham.com/episode102. So if a student is exploring A Aeolian, they could use A minor and
G chords in the left hand. Or they could just use fifths. Let me play around with A Aeolian, so
that's white notes on A, and I'll just use fifths in my left hand, moving around between A and G
positions. Okay, again, very simple and just doing this off the top of my head. Your students
and you, I'm sure, could make things much more interesting. But you get the idea.
Another way, an important part of using this in your teaching is to get used to them yourself.
So you could potentially learn a new pattern each week in all forms, just like for an exam. I've
been working on my mode playing two hands together. Interestingly you've got to change
fingering, particularly for things like C Lydian with that F-sharp. So you'll have some new
fingerings to learn. You could play these hands together, hands separately, contra motion, all
those kinds of things. Just get used to them. If you've been playing piano for a long time, then
why don't you just forget playing scales for a while ... if you were playing them at all, I struggled
through myself, and just explore modes for a month. A new one every few days and you'll soon
have the idea of them.
Another way you can use this in your teaching is getting students to create with them. As I
mentioned before, my No Book Beginners have this Around the World improv idea, giving the
student a little motif and then asking them to create something, often using pedal, simple fifths
in the left hand and notes from the modes. And again you could start on the white notes if
that's easier for your student and then move to helping them understand how to create the
modes in any key.
I've got a comment from Elizabeth Davis on Facebook. She says, "I love teaching modes. I use
common folk tunes like those mentioned in some earlier posts, but also have students do social
media profiles for the modes, to learn their names and differences. Some even come up with
unique names for the modes and even a profile picture. So Lydian becomes a picture of a
person called Lydia." She has a lot of fun with it. I thought that was a kind of cool little trick.
Look, it's only limited, of course, by your creativity what you do with these.
I think the last thing I would say is anytime you find a piece of music in a mode that you're
teaching a student or they're learning somehow, then see if you can get creative with it. Pull it
apart a little bit, and the simplest way to do that, as I've said before ... in either training or
podcasts, I can't remember ... is to keep the left hand the same and noodle around in the mode
with the right hand. So if I go back to that Christopher Norton example, if I just play the left
hand as he wrote it originally and just muck around a little bit with the right hand, you'll get the
idea.
It's one of the things that I have really put some time and effort into in the series of books that
I've been producing for the AMEB, and that's to come up with little creative ideas like that for
pieces of music like that for pieces of music. But you can do this yourself. So I want to challenge
you, any time you're teaching a student now a piece of music in a mode, try out that idea of (1)
getting them to learn the mode as a scale and (2) getting them to noodle around in the key of
the mode while they keep the left hand for the piece of music the same.
We're coming up to the end of the episode today, so one of the biggest questions that I got
asked from Facebook when I popped out the question, "I'm going to be doing a podcast on
modes, what do you need help with?" The kinds of questions that I got the most were like this
one from Christina who said, "At what level do you begin introducing modes?" And Felicity, a
similar question, "How do you introduce the concept and at what level? When do you discuss it
and in relation to what? Is it in the context of a piece the student's learning or a crash course in
all of them at a certain point?" If you've been listening to me for a little while, you'll probably
guess my thinking on the crash course in all of them at a certain point. I wouldn't be
approaching it in that way, because again, I'm always trying to find a relevance for the student.
A student isn't going to, unless they're quite advanced and really enjoying music theory and
scales and technical work, they're probably not really going to enjoy suddenly having to learn
another five different scale patterns.
So I think it's much more relevant to discuss it and explore it in relation to pieces of music that
they're learning, and in this last part of the podcast I'm about to tell you where you can find a
lot of music in modes if you'd like to explore this with students. As to Christina's question, at
what level do you begin introducing modes, again it's up to you and the level of competence of
your student and their interest in it. I think most times ... I mean there are certainly beginner
pieces of music that include an exploration of modes, and I'm thinking in particularly there's a
series over here called "P Plate Piano" again by the fantastic Elissa Milne, and a lot of music in
that has modal context. And so if your student is old enough to understand and explore it, then
that's the time I would do it.
Again, in answer to this question, I would say at what level? Well, at a level appropriate to your
student but in relation to something that they're learning. So if it's a little bit of composing that
you'd like to do and you'd like to explore a mode with them, then great. You could perhaps use
the first five notes of the Phrygian mode and do some kind of little Spanish improv. So that was
these notes. Could a student relatively early on, rather than or alongside doing some blues
improvisation, maybe they could do a little "Spanish" improvisation using one of the modes, or
a different mode, whatever it is. So again, up to your student. Just try and find ways to relate it
to the other work that you're doing. So music that they're learning, a pop piece that they've
heard on the radio, music that they think sounds cool. Why does it sound cool? Actually, it's in
a Mixolydian mode. Let's explore that. Those are the kinds of connections that I love making
with students.
Now there obviously were other questions, but I'm conscious of keeping these podcasts around
45 minutes if I possibly can, so if you do have other questions then of course ask away. I'll do
my best to answer them. I'm sure there's other people who are probably eminently more
qualified to answer them than me, but I will certainly do my best to make it a practical answer
as much as I can rather than a theoretical answer.
So let's move on to the last section of today's podcast, which is talking about resources, books
and music that you might like to explore with your students. Here is a list of people who have
written books about modes and including pieces in all the different modes. The first one that
comes to mind is Daniel McFarlane at supersonicspiano.com. I can't remember the title of his
series, but he definitely has pieces of music written in every single mode, including, I believe,
Locrian. He did try to do that. I think he's joked about how hard it was at times. But if you'd like
to explore a piece of music written solely in Locrian mode as much as he could, then you could
check out his work at supersonicspiano.com. By the way, we'll put links to all these resources
that I'm about to tell you about in the show notes alongside your piano worksheet download.
Robert Vandall has created two great books about modes. There is an easier one, which is
called "Modal Expressions", and there's a slightly harder one called "Modes and Moods", both
worth checking out on Amazon or Sheet Music Plus. There's a funny little download, quirky
little download called "Emoji Modes" from Anne Crosby Gaudet, I think her name is probably
pronounced. G-A-U-D-E-T. And you can find out her ... and download her resource at
musicdiscoveries.ca and you'll be able to find it on there. As I say, a fun little download
connecting modes to emojis. I thought that was kind of cool. And some things there for both
teachers and students to explore.
"Music Moves for Piano" by Marilyn Lowe features a pattern vocabulary for tonal patterns,
rhythmic patterns based on the language of music learning theory, and so a number of the
songs that students sing, the patterns they learn in that, are based on modes. So if you're
interested in that approach, then you could certainly do some more research about music
learning theory. If you Google that you'll be able to find both some of by podcasts. when I've
interviewed a number of people we had a focus on that last year on the blog and podcast. We
had a focus month on music learning theory, so check that out. Or you could Google "Music
Moves for Piano" and I'm sure you'll be able to find out where to grab Marilyn's books.
Willard A. Palmer has a book called "Fun with Modes", a little bit of an older book, but again a
whole lot of different pieces written in modes. Forrest Kinney, who I mentioned earlier, his
"Pattern Play" series of books, which are all about improvising with little pattern ideas at the
piano, definitely features some modal ideas, pentatonic ideas, all sorts of things like that. You
can Google "Pattern Play" or go to the show notes and grab the link for that. Lisa Donovan
Lukas, who is published over at Piano Pronto, has some duets in modes, which I thought would
be kind of fun to explore. Her book is called "Duets a la Mode", and you can find that over at
pianopronto.com.
Margaret Brandman, an Australian composer over here, has a book called "Contemporary
Modal Pieces", another one worth trying. And [Rami Bahniv 00:46:22] has his "Toccata in
Phrygian Mode", and I'll put a YouTube link to that. It's pretty exciting. Another person I'll just
finish with is Debra Wanless, who has written several books of music that are purely in modes
and explains what they are and how to improvise with them. It's really quite a step by step. I
really like the approach that she's used here, and they're perfect for little kids improvising at
sort of that elementary level. You can find out about her series "In the Mood for Modes, Book
One". There's definitely a Book Two. I'm not sure how many more there are. "In the Mood for
Modes". You can find that at debrawanless.com and you'll be able to find out more about her
resource for teaching and exploring modes.
So I really hope you've enjoyed today's episode and it's been helpful to you in your studio.
Make sure you do leave a comment on the show notes page if you've got any questions or you
need more information or anything like that, or just to tell me whether you liked it or not.
Make sure of course you get your freebie download. It's my two page piano modes worksheet.
It's the thing I've been using through this podcast and use each day. It's up on my piano with
the circle of fifths. Really, really handy reference. And you can grab that of course at
timtopham.com/episode102. That's also where you'll find the show notes and links to all those
books and resources that I mentioned. So you can go there and just with one click go and buy
whatever you'd like.
A quick reminder too that you can now subscribe to updates from me about my podcast and
blog on Facebook Messenger. If that's of interest, it's a pretty handy way to get notified when
I've released a new article or podcast. You can head to timtopham.com/facebook and there
I've got the link. It's a one-click link and you'll literally be able to access all my podcasts and
download straight into your Facebook Messenger.
Next week we're getting started with our group teaching work, and it's all about group
teaching with one of the pioneers of group teaching, Mayron Cole. Many of you if you've
taught group piano will have heard of the Mayron Cole Method. She has a substantial website.
She's been teaching groups for about 40 years, back when nobody was teaching groups, and I
was very lucky to have this conversation with her that I will enjoy sharing with you, same time
next week.
Thank you very much for joining me today. Again, if you do have time to leave a review, you
can find out about how to do that at timtopham.com/review. Until then, enjoy your teaching.
Announcer: Ladies and gentlemen, we'll conclude this evening's entertainment. Oh thank you. Thanks for
listening to the Creative Piano Teaching Podcast. We'd love to help take your teaching to the
next level as a member of our supportive community. Use the coupon "piano podcast" for $100
off an annual membership of Tim's Inner Circle today. To find out more, head to
timtopham.com/community.
If you’re looking for more resources and training like this, make sure you check out my Inner
Circle Professional Development Community for teachers just like you. As an Inner Circle Member,
you can:
● Access hundreds of resources, training courses, videos and downloads, lesson plans and PDFs
to give you confidence to be a more creative teacher.
● Avoid overwhelm by setting and achieving your goals through the Growth Journal and our
regular Challenges.
● Join our monthly online mastermind meetings where you can share your goals, ask questions
and interact with special guest teachers and experts from around the world.
● Be a ‘fly on the wall’ of my studio: watch how I teach and get creative with students so that you
can feel confident about trying out the same things.
● Ask any question and get the answers and support you need for your teaching and business
from both other community members and my team of Expert Teachers.
● Avoid the distractions of Facebook Groups, find the information you need quickly and get
involved in rich discussions with other dedicated teachers without any of the complaining and
time wasting you find on Facebook!
● And that’s just the start...
To find out more, click the image below. If you’re using a printout, just type:
timtopham.com/community into your browser. See you on the inside!