Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Submitted by:
Tiangco, Czarina M.
Date:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents………………………………………………………………….............. i
Chapter 1 Introduction………………………………………………………..... 4
Definition of Terms……………………………………………. 6
Hypotheses…………..……………………………….................... 7
Chapter 2 Method......................................................................................... 8
Research Design…………………………..…………………..... 8
Participants………………………………..……………………... 8
Sampling Procedure……………..…………………………..... 8
Measures………………………..………………………………….. 8
Procedure…………………………………………………………... 9
Data Analysis…….………………..………………………………. 9
Chapter 3 Results……………………………………………………………… 10
Preliminary…………………………..…………………………...... 10
Primary …………………………..………………………………..... 12
Supplementary…………………………………………………. 16
3
Chapter 4 Discussion………………………………………………………….. 17
Discussion…………….……………...…………….……………............. 18
Summary …………………………........................................................ 22
Conclusion……………………………………………………................. 22
Recommendation……………………................................................ 23
References ……………….………………………………………………………… 24
Appendices…………………………………………………………………………. 26
j
4
Introduction
unemployment rate, in the countries from the Southeast Asian nation and from which, 16.9%
of which are college students. Researchers presume that misfit graduates are one of the
considered reasons why the country has high unemployment and underemployment rate.
According to (Chickering 1969; Chickering & Reisser, 1993) Individuals are attending
college at a time when they are subsequently in the process of developing autonomy,
competence, and identity. One of the aspects of their identity growth is based on their
career. One wrong decision regarding individual’s career can change the fate of a person.
Individuals who are in the wrong career path have a higher tendency to feel unsatisfied on
his future job. We currently living in a society where in the status are in high rate of
unemployment and underemployment. These kinds of problems can affect the economic
To know the root cause of these problems a lot of studies were done.
approach stated a good match, or “congruence” between a person’s personality and his or
(Caplan, 1987) which states that a person is more successful in work and learning when the
5
environment best suits them. If the developmental needs of the person are not considered
their family. For a country like Philippines who is collectivist in culture it not easy to avoid
psychology examined the wide range of influence that affect the career decision-making
process of young adults, Among those factors, family influence has been given increasing
attention (e.g., Paa & McWhirter, 2000; Schulenberg, Vondracek, & Crouter, 1984; Whiston
& Keller, 2004). A study conducted by (Lee, Hung-Chang, Chou, Mei-Ju) their findings states
that family influence was correlated in expected ways with family obligation, work volition,
work values, calling, and occupational engagement. For better understanding and to
The purpose of this study is to (1) describe the relationship between parental
Conceptual Framework
Academic Fit
Career
Exploration
Adolescent-Parent
Congruence
Definition of Terms
Conceptual Definition
Academic fit is consistent concerns of students perception towards to their academic needs
Operational Definition
congruence scale.
The study aims to answer and analyze the following questions below.
Hypothesis:
Career Exploration
CHAPTER II
Research Design
Participants
A total of 150 chosen male and female students of first year students of Bataan
Peninsula State University took part in the experiment. Participants were given certificates
Sampling Procedure
Measures
a6-point Likert-like scale (1= strongly disagree to 6 = strongly agree). Higher scores show
higher levels of each construct. A sample item, “My parents want the same career for me as
To measure the Academic fit we use a 6 item scale developed by Schmitt et al. A
To evaluate Career exploration of the respondents we use two subscales from Stumpf
et al.’s Career Exploration Survey. The subscales assess individual’s degree of self and
career exploration behavior. A sample item from the 6-item career exploration subscale:
Procedure
The experiments provide all the materials needed before the experiment and used
random assignment to assign 150 respondents for answering three Scales the Academic Fit
Scale, Parent- Adolescent Congruence and Career Exploration. Respondents are classified
The researchers provided an inform consent for the respondents with a preview of the
study. After giving consent form, the researchers will distribute the provided survey
Data Analysis
CHAPTER III
RESULTS
Preliminary
Scale Reliability
The internal consistencies of the original scales were α = .72 for academic fit α =. 88 for
adolescent parent career congruence. The items of criterion variable, career exploration
table 1). Meanwhile, the scales we measure present a reliability score of α =0.449 for
academic fit, α =0.593 for adolescent-parent career congruence, α = 0.963 for career
exploration.
Original Cronbach's N of
Variables Alpha
Descriptive Statistics
The participant was first year college student of Bataan Peninsula State University.
There were 93 female participants (63%) and 57 male participants (38%) a total of 150
participants (100%). (see tables 3). In terms of age, both gender fall under the age range of
(18-21 years old).Participants were classified under the late adolescence period (15-21
years old). (see tables 2).In addition, frequencies and percentages of the demographic
Table 2
18 92 61.3
19 50 33.3
20 5 3.3
21 3 2
Table 3
Gender of participants
Female 93 62
Male 57 38
Primary
Table 3
Hypotheses
Table 3 shows that two variables namely Academic fit and Adolescent-Parent Career
Congruence were all significant predictors of Career Exploration. Meanwhile, Academic fit
Congruence. With the supporting result of p=value of Academic fit Scale which is .001 and
congruence and academic fit predicts career exploration alternative hypothesis are
accepted.
13
of BPSU
Exploration
Table 4 present the frequency distribution of the predictor variables, academic fit and
adolescent-parent career congruence and the criterion variable career exploration has a
lastly, adolescent parent career congruence having only a mean of 49.87 (SD=9.77962)
14
Table 5 shows the multiple regression to see if the two predictor variables predict the
variability of the criterion variable which is Career Exploration. The result of the analysis
revealed that the combination of the two variables explains 12.2% of the variance in the
Table 5
Adjusted R
Model R R Square Square sig. F change
Table 6
Analysis of Variance
Sum of Mean
Model Squares df Square F Sig.
1 Regression 20587.105 2 10293.552 11.396 .000b
Total 149
Table 7 present the standardized Beta coefficients of the predictor variable the table
below present the statistical significance and relative importance of each predictable
variable. Academic fit is significant with a statistic of β=.270 t (3.488), this implies the
more academically fit a individual the more an individual become involved to his/her
Table 7
Coefficient table
Standardized
Coefficients
Model Beta t Sig.
1 (Constant) 2.011 .046
Supplementary
Analysis of variances between groups was performed to determine if there were any
significant differences between the categorical variables in the study. In terms of Academic
fit there were no significant differences between the age. LSD Post-Hoc analysis was used
Dependent Variable:
AFS
Mean Sig.
(I) age Difference Std. Error
18 19 -0.57428 0.53272 0.283
20 -1.15761 1.39232 0.407
21 -1.99094 1.77885 0.265
19 18 0.57428 0.53272 0.283
20 -0.58333 1.42214 0.682
21 -1.41667 1.80229 0.433
20 18 1.15761 1.39232 0.407
19 0.58333 1.42214 0.682
21 -0.83333 2.21428 0.707
21 18 1.99094 1.77885 0.265
19 1.41667 1.80229 0.433
20 0.83333 2.21428 0.707
17
CHAPTER IV
Discussion
This study tested the role of adolescent parent career congruence and academic fit on
Filipino adolescent’s career exploration, whether there were specific factors that predicted
career exploration. The researcher used three scales namely 12-item adolescent-parent
career congruence scale, academic fit (Schmitt) and career exploration survey (Stumpf).
Academic fit and adolescent-parent career congruence was both found significant predictor
of career exploration. However, result revealed that Academic fit were found to be most
significant predictor of career exploration. The more academically fit an individual the
The results may support the person environment fit theory which people seek out and
create environments that allow them to behaviorally manifest their traits (e.g., dominant
individuals seek leadership positions); the extent to which people fit their work
productivity, turnover), with better fit associated with better outcomes; and P-E fit is a
reciprocal and ongoing process whereby people shape their environments and
environments shape people (Rounds & Tracey, 1990). Another theory Hollands (1997)
theory of vocational personalities and work environments is one of the most prominent
create work environments that allow them to manifest their work personalities.
18
The finding also extends previous research which found a positive relationship between
academic fit and academic satisfaction. We also found a positive relationship between
adolescent-parent career congruence and career exploration, suggesting that students who
are congruent with parents regarding career matters are more likely to engage in career
exploration, Despite of this result the analysis revealed the combination of two variables
which can only predict a 12.2% of the variance in scores of the criterion variable (career
exploration).
Academic fit was measured using a six item scale developed by Schmitt et al. The result of
the scores revealed that academic fit predicts career exploration. Academic fit has vital role
in students which result in career exploration. Astin (1993) argues that students with
certain personality characteristics are more likely to choose particular majors. For example,
he suggests that those who rated high on a social activism scale were more likely to major
in the social sciences and education. Those who had artistic inclinations were most likely to
major in the fine arts, music, theater, journalism and English. Students scoring high on a
hedonism scale were most likely to major in business, nursing, health technologies and
secretarial studies. Leaders were most likely to major in pre-law, communications and
military science. Status-striving students were most likely to major in architecture and
agriculture.
19
Several recent studies of students have applied Holland’s theory of careers (Holland, 1966,
relation to academic major choice. The basic premise of Holland’s theory is that human
Applying Holland’s theory, Smart, Feldman, and Ethington, suggest that students ‘‘choose
academic environments compatible with their personality types’’ and in turn ‘‘academic
environments reward different patterns of student abilities and interests.’’ Recent research
suggests that congruence between person and environment is critical to the success of
college students (Feldman, Smart, and Ethington, 1999; Smart et al., 2000). They argue,
satisfaction, and achievement’’ (Feldman et al., 1999, p. 643). Based on preferred activities,
interests and competencies, Holland has developed six model environments that can be
Adolescent parent career congruence is one of the factors that result of career
the adolescent perceive parents as fulfilling career exploration, planning and goal setting
needs and the degree to which they perceive their parents happy proud, contended, or
agreeable with their career progress, and the perceived similarity between adolescents and
20
their parents, that is, the level to which the adolescents perceive that their parents possess
similar or corresponding ideas regarding career interests, values, plans, and goals. Family
influence is a powerful factor affecting students’ decisions to attend college (King, 2012).
proposed that parents play the strongest role in the college decision-making process.
interest in and expectation to attend college along with a higher likelihood of college
enrollment (Hallett &Griffen, 2015; Perna& Titus, 2005). Research indicates that when
parents and adolescents agree on future plans, career development is more positive and
when disagreement occur career development can be impeded (Leung, Hou, Gati, & Li,
2011).Parental support can have many positive outcomes on students’ futures; however,
the literature suggests that the benefit of parental influence depends on whether or not
adolescents view their parents’ influence as supportive and congruent with their own
Limitation
The present result of this study cannot be generalize the population of whole first
year college students in the Philippines because of sample mostly came from Bataan
Peninsula state university. In addition to this the total number of sample is fewer than the
encountered several flaws in scale such as career exploration scale that contained some
items are irrelevant to the college students and only applicable for the workers and
employee’s. The questionnaires that we have given to the respondents were too long that
21
makes them bored that is why they didn’t took the following test seriously. We had no
Implications
The finding of our study suggests that academic fit and adolescent-parent career
congruence are factors that predict career exploration. For the Philippines which
making. It is one of the most significant factors that individual considered when it comes in
decision making. On the other hand academic fit found most significant factors. Academic
fit is a sense of belongingness of individual. People who have high academic fit tend to excel
and do much better than the people who are not academically fit.
22
CHAPTER V
The findings of the study revealed the influence of two predictor variable academic fit and
results shows support in our hypothesis, both can be predictor variable of the criterion
variable career exploration. Fascinatingly, academic fit turned out to be grater predictor
than adolescent-parent career congruence. In addition, we used LSD post-Hoc analysis for
differences across the age of the participants. It turned out that there is no significant
CONCLUSION
Holland (1997) theory of vocational personalities and work environments is one of the
to seek and create work environments that allow them to manifest their work personalities.
This may be true for our study because predictor variable academic fit appeared to be
say that theory is true the results of the study have weaknesses point we missed some
factors. The results of study may add to the current body of literature.
23
RECOMMENDATION
We recommend to the future researchers to use a scale that is suitable for their country.
For them to ensure that participants will clearly understand their scales. We also suggest to
them to have a greater numbers of participants. Researchers must come up with several
References:
[1] Ericta, Carmelita. Employment rate in January 2013 is estimate at 92.9 percent (Results
friom the January 2013 Labor Force Survey) www.census.gov.ph[March 25, 2013]
Chickering, A.W. (1969). Education and identity. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Chickering, A. &
Reisser, R. (1993). Education and identity (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey- Bass.
Evans, N.J., Forney, D.S. & Guido-DiBrito, F. (1998). Student Development in College: Theory,
Research, and Practice. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Dawis, R. V., & Lofquist, L. H. (1984). A psychological theory of work adjustment. Minneapolis:
University of Minnesota Press.
Swanson JL, Fouad NA. Applying theories of person-environment fit to the transition from
school to work.Career Development Quarterly1999;47: 337-347.
Schmitt N, Oswald FL, Friede A, Imus A, Merritt S. Perceived fit with an academic
environment: Attitudinaland behavioral outcomes. Journal of Vocational Behavior2008;72:
317-335.
Sawitri DR, Creed PA, Zimmer-Gembeck MJ. The Adolescent-Parent Career Congruence
Scale: Developmentand initial validation. Journal of Career Assessment2013;21: 210-226.
25
Blustein DL. A context-rich perspective of career exploration across the life roles. Career
DevelopmentQuarterly1997;45: 260-274.
Stumpf SA, Colarelli SM, Hartman, K. Development of the Career Exploration Survey (CES).
Journal of Vocational Behavior1983;22: 191-226.
Zikic J, Klehe UC. Job loss as a blessing in disguise: The role of career exploration and career
planning inpredicting reemployment quality. Journal of Vocational Behavior 2006;69:
391-409.
Hoffman, L. R., & McDaniels, C. (1991). Career development in the elementary schools: A
perspective for the 1990s. Elementary SchoolGuidance & Counseling, 25, 163-171.
Kammer. P. (1985). Career and lifestyle expectations of rural eighth grade students. The
School Counselor, 33(1), 18-25.
Betz, N. E., Klein, K., & Taylor, K. (1996). Evaluation of a short form of the Career
Decision-Making Self-Efficacy Scale. Journal of Career Assessment, 4, pp. 47-57.
Appendices
OCTOBER, 2018
Dear Sir/Madam
Warmest Greetings!
We would like to ask your permission to allow us to conduct a survey among the Students
in your school. This is in view of our thesis entitled Academic Fit, Adolescent-Parent Career
Congruence as predictor of Career Exploration in University Students. I am conducting this
survey among Senior High-school Students in Bataan. Attached herewith is the survey
questionnaire for this study.
The survey would last only about 10-15 minutes and would be arranged at a time
convenient to the teacher’s schedule (e.g. during break). Participation in the survey is
entirely voluntary and there are no known or anticipated risks to participate in this study.
All the information provided will be kept in utmost confidentiality and would be used only
for academic purposes. The names of the respondents and the name of your school will not
appear in any thesis or publication resulting from this study.
If you agree, kindly sign below acknowledging your consent and permission for us to
conduct this study/survey at your school and returned the signed form on an enclosed
enveloped.
Your approval to conduct this study will be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance for
your interest and assistance with this research.
Sincerely,
27
We are the fourth year BS students from College of Social and Behavioral Sciences. We are
conducting an experiment title Academic fit and Adolescent-parent congruence as
predictor Career exploration of students.
It is our requirement for our research psychology. We would like you to be our participants
as we conduct our experiment.
This research study will only take maximum of 10-15 minutes. We are asking for your time
by answering the survey. There would be no risk on this research project because there is
no need for the participants to go other places. Every participant will receive a reward of
certificate of participation from the experimenters for participating.
We want to stress that your participation in this experiment is voluntary. If you agree to
participate, you are free to withdraw from the experiment anytime without penalty. All the
information you provide in this study will be anonymous. Your identity and the
information you gave will be confidential.
I have enclosed a consent form for your review to have a copy of this form to keep. Please
read the form and feel free to approach us if you have further questions about the
experiment. Your participation will be greatly appreciated.
I have read the inform consent form and I understand the requirements of the study.
_____ I agree to participate in the study.
_____I do not agree to participate on the study.
_______________________________________
(Participant’s name and Signature)
Date: ___________________
29
disagree agree
Questions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1. My parents encourage
me to explore the career
areas I am interested in.
2. My parents support me in
my career plan.
4. My parents approve of
the plans I am making for
my future career.
6. My parents help me
explore my career
interest.
disagree agree
Questions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Environmental exploration
To what extent have you behaved in the following situation?
Not at To a To To a To a
all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
1 2 3 4 5
1.Investigated career possibilities
Self exploration
To what extent have you done the following in the past three months?
Not at To a To To a To a
all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
1 2 3 4 5
1.Reflected on how my past integrates with
my future career
Intended-Systematic Exploration
To what extent have you behave in the following ways over the last three months ?
Not at To a To To a To a
all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
1.Experimented with the different career
activities
2.Sought opportunities to demonstrate skills
3.Tried specific work roles just to see if I like
them
Amount of Information
How much of information do you have on what one does in the career areas have been
investigated?
Not at To a To To a To a
all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
1. I currently have a moderate amount of
information on jobs, organizations and job
markets.
2. I currently have a lot of information
3. I currently have a moderate amount of
information on how ill fit into various career
paths
4.I have thoroughly explored myself and
know what to seek and what to avoid in
developing career path
Focus
How sure are you?
Not at To a To To a To a
all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
1.That you know the type of organization
you want to work for
Exploration stress
How much undesirable stress have the following caused you relative to other significant issues
with which you have had to content?
Not To a To To a To a
at all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
Decisional stress
How much undesirable stress have the following caused you relative to other significant issues
with which you have had to contend?
Not To a To To a To a
at all small some moderate large
extent extent extent extent
What is the probabilities that each of the following activities will result in obtaining your career
goals
Not To a To some To a To a
at all small extent moderate large
extent extent extent
1.Obtaining information on the labor
market and general job opportunities in
my career area.
4.Focusing my thoughts on me as a
person.
Method Instrumentality
What is the probability that each of the following activities will result in obtaining your career
goals?
Not To a To some To a To a
at all small extent moderate large
extent extent extent
37
Transcription
Ma’am Fatima: what is the difference of your study to the study you replicated?
Quecia: we use k-12 as our participant rather than using university students. Because in
our replicated study they use students in college who has program such as fishery courses.
Maam Fatima: so only the participant angbinagonyo, you didn’t add or change or remove
any variables.
Quecia : and also ma’am we change the number of our participant. We don’t copy the
numbers of participant in our study rather we use 50 participants each variable so that we
have 150 participants all in all.
Sir Huevos : paki update nyo yung RRL nyo make it more recent. Then paki ayos yung
conceptual framework nyo mukhag tatakbo yung bilog e
US: Okay po
Dean: Ahh for me, let me just point out the things you need to change, Uhmm statement of
the problem how do academic fit, adolescence career congruence affects student career
decision. First of all dapat naka bullet points tapos qualitative, correlational
US: Predictive po
Dean: So it should be how does per variable noh, predictor 1 and then criterion, predictor 2
and criterion isa-isa, so how does academic fit predict not affect student career decision
making and how does parent adolescence congruence predicts career decision making of
students. Ano tong number 3? May competence? Wala nayun, wala nayung problem 3 and
wala na din yung problem number 4. Okay so tandaan niyo yung word na affect is for
experiments so ito predicts to predicts, so academic fit does not predict students career
decision making and the next one and adolescence career congruence does not predicts in
decision making ganun, Dalawalangnaman2 hypothesis 2 statement of the problem
US: Opo
Dean: Yung tanong ko academic fit ba talaga yun o yung adolescence congruence yung
pangalan ng scale
Dean: Pero parang pwede din gawing academic fit congruence ano? Parang kapareho ng
parent career congruence, pero kung iyun ang pangalan okay naman din.Sa operational
definition walang box, sa inform consent walang box , ang hilig niyo sa box.
US: Laughing
Dean: Sa research design walang box , mahilig kayong mag kahon-kahon e. Tapos
randomly ba talaga?
US: Opo
Dean: Bakit randomly? Ibihsabihin you will be getting a list and from the list you will draw
a names and then you will find the names. Kung sino lang pwede niyo makuha
convenience sampling yun.
US: Convenience po
Dean: Random ibig sabihin meron kayong systematic way of gagawin niyong sample and
everyone pwede maging member ng sample so hindi siya random okay,Next APA format,
nakalabas yung unang line and naka pasok ang mga sumusunod na line ha. APA format mga
journal, author, pati letter niyo naka box pa rin ang hilig niyo sa box
Quecia: Yan po maam ginawa po namin ganyan ung sinabi niyo po. Ay maam yan po yata
yung luma na pinasa namin, nagpasapo kasi kami kahapon, diba sir?
Quecia: Ayan po yung luma, iyun po yung bago kasi po diba po nagpa-consult po kami
sainyo tas po nirevise po namin lahat, ayan po
Dean: Kaya pala, O sige. Ayun ah tandaan niyo yung mga sinabi. Okay that’s all, you can go