Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Experimenting the Bactericidal Capability of Coleus blumei (Mayana) Leaves Against S. aureus,
Carlo F. Agas
Researcher
Research Adviser
Ferbruary 2019
1
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This scientific investigatory project wouldn’t be possible without the support and help of
those who took time just to help, give ideas and motivation. First of all, The researcher would
like to give tanks to our Almighty God Jehovah for giving us such wisdom and guidance
unconditionally. The researcher would also like to thank his parents and his family who
supported me on doing this SIP financially and morally. The researcher would also like to
express his gratitude towards his research adviser, Ms. Cristine S. Sañada, for guidance and
assistance throughout the whole time. Thanks to Mrs. Mary Grace Lumame and Ms Michele
Hababag, the laboratory custodians of the chemistry and physics laboratory for allowing the
researcher to use such facilities for the sake of the experimentation of the study. Thanks also to
Nicole Anne Alayon for letting the researcher borrow equipment for experimentation such as
blender. The researcher would also like to show recognition to the efforts of their class adviser,
Mrs. Rubilyn Diane Umali for all the motivation and support she gave us. And lastly to my
friends, Zaki T. Pinili, Ivy Katrina Malañgen, Franxine Camacho, Shaira Balanza, for
supporting and helping do these SIP by helping me with writing the paper and giving advices on
practical writing. Not just that but also helping me but also for giving me motivation and
C.F.A.
2
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
ABSTRACT
A lot of people suffer from diseases made by infection related diseases such as strep
throat, urinary tract infection, tuberculosis, skin diseases pneumonia, etc. This diseases are
caused by a lot of different pathogenic microbes like bacteria. As these problem progress and
happen, it gave the researcher to have a chance to have a significant and important research
study. This research project was conduct because it aims to determine possible alternatives to
commercial antibacterial substances without spending a lot using crude leaf exract from Colues
blumei. It was also conducted to text or experiment if the said substance is effective against
various bacteria. First of all, the researcher gathered leaves then brought some samples to UP
Diliman for Plant Identification to confirm such plant. Then the extract was obtained by blending
the leaves and filtering it after. After that, it was immediately brought to UP Diliman, Natural
Sciences Research Institute (NSRI)-Microbiological Department for an Antimicrobial Assay, a
test if the substance can show antimicrobial properties against other microbes. The microbes that
were used in the Assay were K. pneumoniae, P. aeruginosa, and S. aureus. The results showed
that the crude leaf extract wasn’t able to inhibit K. pneumoniae with an anti-microbial index of 0,
the same with P aeruginosa with an anti-microbial index of 0. In the other hand, it was able to
inhibit S, aureus with an anti-microbial index of 1.6. While the controlled sample which is the
Chloramphenicol disc has a clearing zone of 5.3, 1.5, and 4.5 to the said bacteria respectively. As
the investigation’s results state, it can be concluded that Coleus blumei crude leaf extract can’t
inhibit various bacteria. It can also be concluded that compared to the antimicrobial property
shown by Chloramphenicol, the crude leaf extract has a low antibacterial property. And another
conclusion is that, the crude leaf extract have a low to no effectivity to those bacteria that the
crude leaf extract failed to inhibit compared to S. aureus.
3
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
At our times, getting diseases is such a struggle, since getting medication and cure for these
diseases are too expensive. Most of these diseases are caused by bacteria. Some of the bacteria
that gives diseases to humans are S. aureus, K. pneumonia, P. aeruginosa etc. These bacteria
give worldwide health problems, from typhoid to skin diseases and diarrhea (Mayoclinic
website, 2018).
According to Alliance for the Prudent Use of Antibiotics (2018), these bacteria reacts
negatively to some substances that cause them lethality such as alcohols, chlorine, peroxides, and
aldehydes.
metabolites known as phenols. One of them is Rosmarinic acid (RA), a phenylpropanoid that is
naturally occurring to most plants and well known as therapeutic and cosmetic agent.
Coleus blumei or commonly called as Mayana, is a common ornamental plant here in the
Philippines. This plant can be seen often from front yards or gardens of households. This plant is
commonly used to treat wounds and bruises here in our country (Stuartxchange, 2018).
4
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
As said by Sivamani, Ma, Wehril and Maverkis (2012), most products that are naturally
processed for wound healing possess antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, angogenic, and cell
synthesis-modulating components.
In lieu of these statements, the researcher came up with the thought of testing the
antimicrobial activity of the crude leaf extract of Mayana leaves against S. aureus, K.
5
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Statement of the Problem
The general statement of the problem is: Did the crude extract of Coleus blumei leaves
1. To test if the crude leaf extract of Coleus blumei leaves will show antimicrobial property
2. To determine the difference between the effects of the crude leaf extract of Coleus blumei
3. To test the effectivity of the crude leaf extract of Coleus blumei leaves as a bactericidal
6
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Significance of the Study
The main purpose of this study is to test the anti-bacterial activity of the crude leaf extract of
Coleus blumei leaves against various bacteria. This discovery might give a great aid for
antibacterial problems that is far cheaper and accessible than the commercial ones.
Aside from that, it might also give cure to diseases that are caused by bacteria which could be
helpful for those people who don’t have an access with anti-bacterial solutions. It gives equal
opportunities to all the citizens to acquire a cure for their diseases caused by bacteria.
This study can also give information or help for future studies that might be related to the
topic. It would be a good reference and basis for the innovations and new discoveries in the
future.
7
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Scope and Limitations
This study will only be focusing on the bactericidal activity of the crude extract of Coleus
blumei leaves against various bacteria, specifically, to test the difference between different
bactericidal agent, and the efficiency of the extract between those different bacteria. These are
the only ones that is discussed in the study, anything not included are beyond the scope and
limitations. The testing for the extract which is the Antimicrobial Assay will be done on the
NSRI-Microbiology on UP Diliman.
8
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Hypothesis
Chloramphenicol and the crude extract from the Coleus blumei leaves against various bacteria.
HA= There is a significant difference between the inhibition zone made by the Chloramphenicol
and the crude extract from the Coleus blumei leaves against various bacteria.
9
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Definition of Terms
1. Crude extract
Operational Definition
Actual Definition
It is concentrated form of an herb that is derived from the crude of the herb then
mixed with water, alcohol or any solvent then distilled or evaporated (thefreedictionary.com,
2019)
2. Antimicrobial Assay
Operational Definition
It is used to measure the bactericidal capability of the crude extract against the
bacteria.
Actual Definition
quantitatively determining the concentration of an antibiotic by its effect in inhibiting the growth
of a susceptible microorganism.”
10
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
CHAPTER II
conceptual framework, hypothesis of the study, and definition of variables deemed relevant to
this study. The concepts, ideas and principles presented give credence to the fact support the
aeruginosa.
Based on the reports of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2018),
Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) are bacteria that causes intoxication which develops after the
ingestion of the food contaminated, wherein, the bacteria produces enterotoxin. The bacteria also
causes more diseases such as skin infections to infection of the lungs or the heart.
commonly observed in the gut. But if the bacteria go to other body parts, it causes sickness. They
can be “superbugs” which are bacteria that are almost impossible to be beaten with common
antibiotics. It can give pneumonia, wound infection, blood infection and others. Most cases of
11
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
the said diseases are commonly got from direct contact with an infected person (webmd.com,
2018).
such as Pseudomonas infection. This is cause by strains of bacteria found widely in the
environment. People can be infected when they have weaker immune systems. If infected or
followed by a surgery, this might lead to severe illness and death. Some might get ear infection,
mostly children and skin rashes might occur after exposure to contaminated swimming pools or
chlorinated hot tubs. There some eye infection cases because of extended-wear contact lenses
(CDC, 2018).
Coleus blumei is an erect, branched, fleshy, annual herb that is about one (1) meter high.
Stems are purplish and are four- angled. Their leaves are usually blotched or colored variously. It
is mostly more or less hair, ovate and usually 5 to 10 centimeters long, coarsely toothed in the
margins or the side, and commonly uniformed in a velvety-purple color. Its flowers are purplish,
2019).
It was introduced to the Philippines and cultivated to become an ornamental plant. It was
used and popular because of its incredibly wide range of foliage colors. It is also native to Java
12
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
region. Nowadays, it used for ornamental uses, specifically a pantropic ornamental plant
(stuartxchange.org, 2019).
Previous studies already proven that a new abietane type diterpenes yielded antimicrobial
activity against B. subtilis and C. albicans. It is also proven that isolated mixtures of sterols and
triterpenes from Coleus blumei shows not only antimicrobial properties but also anti-
According to the study of to Saraswati, Katnoria, Jatinder, Nagpal, and Avinash (2016),
the Coleus species are such a great amount of medicinally important constituent such as
rosmanic acid which showcases biochemical activities. Specifically, Coleus blumei contains
rosmarinic acid. One study even supported the statement that was said before and even said that
it is the major phenolic compound of the said plant (Bauer, Vuković, Likić, & Jelaska, 2015).
Rosmarinic Acid
polyphenolic substances that is commonly found contained by culinary herbs such as Perilla
13
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
As stated in the review of Park, Uddin, Xu, Kim, and Lee (2008), Rosmarinic acid, a vital
phenolic compound, is often found in species of the Boraginaceae and the subfamily
Nepetoideae of the Lamiaceae. It is also found in species of other plant groups and in some fern
and hornwort species. Rosmarinic acid has a lot of captivating biological activities, those are
observed against S. aureus and MRSA. RA showed great inhibition on the surface proteins of
MSCRAMM's. However, although RA was shown to exhibit a synergistic effect with antibiotics,
Air-drying
Dictionary, 2019). It is done so it will give free bonding of solvents with the phytochemicals
based on its polarity, compared to wet materials which lacks of separation of secondary
It also prevents further enzymatic or metabolic alteration on the material since the
material is already dry. Addition to that, even though all compounds can be can be extracted in
unaltered and natural form, there is a possibility of forming new compounds or intermediates or
secondary metabolites even if there is a presence of chlorophyll because of the response to light
Other than that, dry weights from plants give less error compared to fresh ones. Because
fresh one can still change from the condition of the climate, the weather, and from the
14
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
transportation of the plant from the place where the plant is obtained to into the laboratory where
the extraction method will be done. For this reason, the plants moisture can vary in a lot of ways
(Poonsawat, 2014).
15
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Conceptual Framework
The researcher’s independent variables for different setups are the amount of the crude
extract from the Mayana leaves and the substance used. These will be conducted in separate
setups and will be interpreted in statistical means in order to find out the changes in the
dependent variable, the antibacterial activity of the mayana leaves against the three bacteria
16
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
CHAPTER III
This chapter includes the research methodology of the study. In a detailed overview, this
part is where the researcher highlights the methods of data collection, extraction of plant
research design.
The researcher collected leaves of Coleus blumei. The said plant can be found near the
researcher’s home or the researcher’s vicinity. The plant material was then washed with distilled
water to remove any substance or chemicals that might affect the study. After that, the leaves
Plant Identification
The acquired plant material will be brought into UP Institute of Biology for testing of Plant
Identification. This is needed to verify similar and misleading plants from the original plant
The crude extract that is used for the Agar Diffusion Assay is prepared by putting it into a
blender. 25 grams of Coleus blumei were put into a blender. Then the result will be strained and
the liquid substance strained from the resulting solution from the blended leaves of the plant
material will be the one that is used for the Agar Diffusion Assay
quantitatively determining the concentration of an antibiotic by its effect in inhibiting the growth
17
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
of a susceptible microorganism”. Agar plates were inoculated with the microorganism by
swabbing the agar surface. The cotton swab on an applicator stick was dipped into the microbial
suspension, rotated several times and pressed firmly on the inside wall of the tube above the fluid
level to remove excess inoculum from the swab. The swab was streaked over the entire agar
surface. This procedure was repeated two more times, rotating the plate 60o each time to ensure
even distribution of the inoculum. Three (3) equidistant wells were made on the agar plate using
a cork borer (10 mm diameter). The plates were incubated at 35o and observed after 24 hours.
The clearing zone was measure in millimeters and the average diameter of the clearing zones
was calculated. The antimicrobial was computed using the following formulas:
Statistical Treatment
The statistical treatment that was used is chi-square independence test. According to spss-
tutorials.com (2019), a chi-square independence test is “a procedure for testing if two categorical
18
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
CHAPTER IV
RESULTS
NSRI- Microbiology Department after a week. The required acquired by the NSRI showed:
Table 1. Inhibition Zone of the Coleus blumei Leaf Crude Extract compared to Chloramphenicol
Chloramphenicol
Clearing zone, mm
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
P. aeruginosa K. pneumoniae S. aureus
19
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
The table and graph shows the inhibiting capacity of Coleus blumei leaf crude extract
compared to Chloramphenicol.
Table 3. Chi-square of Independence between Coleus blumei leaf Crude Extract and
1 2 3 Total
Coleus blumei 26 26 26 78
leaf crude extract
Chloramphenicol 33 33 33 99
disc
TOTAL 59 59 59 177
1. Ho: The scores obtained don’t depend on the kind of extract used.
2. 5 % level of significance
=2
4. df=2
5% level of significance
grand total
=26 =26
=26 =26
20
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
E5=(59) (99) / 177 E6=(59) (99) / 177
=26 =26
X2= (O-E)2 / E
X2=0
6. Since 0 < 5.99, reject the null hypothesis. The scores depend on the extract used.
21
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
DISCUSSIONS
The results of the Antimicrobial Assay given by the NSRI was presented through a table
which shows that |Chloramphenicol disc is used as the controlled sample which is a commercial
solution for anti-bacterial and anti-fungal that inhibits P. aeruginosa, K. pneumoniae and S.
aureus.
Based on the table, the crude extract of Coleus blumei leaves cannot inhibit P. aeruginosa
in the 1st replicate. It didn’t inhibit the 2nd and 3rd replicate too. It shows that the extract’s
Based on the table, the crude extract of Coleus blumei leaves cannot inhibit K.
pneumoniae in the 1st replicate. It didn’t inhibit the 2nd and 3rd replicate too. It shows that the
Based on the table, the crude extract of Coleus blumei leaves inhibited S. aureus in the
1st replicate by 26 mm. It also inhibited the 2nd and 3rd by the same inhibition zone. It shows that
the extract’s ability to inhibit such microbe compared to the commercial antibacterial,
The results shows that there is a big difference between the resulting clearing zone and
antimicrobial index of Coleus blumei leaf crude extract and the Chloramphenicol disc. It also
shows that the extract can’t inhibit various bacteria, in fact it only inhibited S. aureus. Another
22
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
one is that it shows that the extract shows low to no effectivity to P. aeruginosa and K.
According to review of the related literature of Park, Uddin, Xu, Kim, and Lee (2008),
entitled “Biotechnological applications for rosmarinic acid production in plant.” It states that
Rosmarinic acid do have antibacterial property. It was also supported later by Ekambaram et al
(2016), where it shows that Rosmarinic Acid shows great inhibition on the surface proteins of
MSCRAMM’s. This substance is the active agent that made the extract show antibacterial
23
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
CHAPTER V
Conclusions:
The researcher concluded that the crude extract from Coleus blumei leaves can inhibit
bacteria. But the results shows that it can’t inhibit various bacteria, in fact it only inhibited S.
aureus. It also showed that the extract have a lower antibacterial ability compared to the
commercial product. It is also showed that the crude extract have a low antibacterial effectivity
24
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Recommendations:
The researcher would like to recommend for the future researchers to use other kinds of
extracting method to determine if it affects the antibacterial capability of the extract. The
researcher would also like to recommend to test the plant to other kinds of bacteria to know
which bacteria will show the greatest inhibition made by the plant’s extract.
25
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Bauer, N., Vuković, R., Likić, S., & Jelaska, S. (2015). Potential of Different Coleus blumei
Tissues for Rosmarinic Acid Production. Food Technology and Biotechnology, 53(1), 3-10.
doi:10.17113/ftb.53.01.15.3661
2. Chi-Square Independence Test – What and Why? (n.d.). Retrieved February 5, 2019, from
https://www.spss-tutorials.com/chi-square-independence-test/
3. crude extract. (n.d.) Farlex Partner Medical Dictionary. (2012). Retrieved February 5 2019
from https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/crude+extract
4. Ekambaram, S., Perumal, S., Balakrishnan, A., Marappan, N., Gajendran, S., &
5. Infectious diseases. (2018, January 03). Retrieved September 22, 2018, from
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/infectious-diseases/symptoms-causes/syc-
20351173
7. Obena, R. P., & Guevara, A. P. (2001). Biological Activities of Sterols and Triterpenes from
the Leaves of Coleus blumei Benth. [Abstract]. Natural Products Chemistry. Retrieved
8. Park, S. U., Uddin, M., Xu, H., Kim, Y., & Lee, S. (2018). Biotechnological applications for
26
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
Retrieved August 15, 2018, from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/234109466_Biotechnological_applications_for_ro
smarinic_acid_production_in_plant/download.
9. Pseudomonas aeruginosa in Healthcare Settings. (2018, March 09). Retrieved September 28,
10. Poonsawat, T. (2014). Why do we extract dried, ground plant material instead of fresh one?
https://www.researchgate.net/post/Why_do_we_extract_dried_ground_plant_material_inste
ad_of_fresh_one
11. Ragasa, C. (2001). Diastereomeric Diterpenes from Coleus blumei. CHEMICAL &
12. Saraswati & Katnoria, Jatinder & Nagpal, Avinash. (2016). Analytical techniques for
13. Simon, S. (2016). Why do we extract dried, ground plant material instead of fresh one?
https://www.researchgate.net/post/Why_do_we_extract_dried_ground_plant_material_inste
ad_of_fresh_one
14. Sivamani, R. K., Ma, B. R., Wehrli, L. N., & Maverakis, E. (2012). Phytochemicals and
Naturally Derived Substances for Wound Healing. Advances in Wound Care, 1(5), 213-217.
doi:10.1089/wound.2011.0330
15. Staphylocococcus aureus (food poisoning). (n.d.). Retrieved September 21, 2018, from
http://www.bccdc.ca/health-info/diseases-conditions/staphylocococcus-aureus
27
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”
16. What is Klebsiella Pneumoniae Infection? (n.d.). Retrieved September 28, 2018, from
https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/klebsiella-pneumoniae-infection#1
17. Upadhyay, R. K. (2014). Why do we extract dried, ground plant material instead of fresh
https://www.researchgate.net/post/Why_do_we_extract_dried_ground_plant_material_inste
ad_of_fresh_one
28
Research Expo 2019 Theme: “Diffusing Cognition, Yielding Reactions.”