(Updated) Syllabus

vice)
MaranawHotelv. NLRC–
238SCRA190(illegaldismissal;right
UNIVERSI
toappeal)
TY OF *Magtajasv.PryceProperties–
MAKATIS 234SCRA255(localordinanceagains
CHOOLO tPAGCOR)
FLAWCO *Bennisv. Michigan-No.94-
NSTITUTI 8729March4,1996(confiscatedcar)
ONALLA *Cruzanv.Dir.Missouri-No.88-
WII 1503June25,1990(informedeuthana
blooming sia)
JMMPromotionandManagemen
ARTICLEIII- BILLOFRIGHTS t,Inc.v.CA–
260SCRA319(OFWdeployment
PrimacyofHumanRightsandEnforcement ban) Dansv.People–
Republicv.Sandiganbayan,GR1047 285SCRA504(righttocounsel)
68,July21,2003 Oplev.Torres–
Mijaresv. 293SCRA141(readwithK
Ranada,GR139325,April12,2005 MUv.Dir.Gen.)(nationalI
(AlienTortAct) Dsystem)
Montesclarosv.Comelec,
SECTION1. GR152295,July7,2002(Sk
electionpostponed)
HierarchyofRights Tanv.People–
PhilippineBloomingMills 290SCRA117(lumber)
EmployeesOrg.
v.PhilippineBloomingMillsCo.Inc.,5
1
SCRA189,June5,1973(hierarchyofr
ights)
DueProcess:InGeneral
Tupasv.CA-
193SCRA597,1991(latepetition)
Asilov. People–645SCRA41
(deprivationofpropertywithoutdueprocess;de
molition)
I.SubstantiveDueProcess
*UnitedStatesv.Toribio-
15PHIL.85(readwithYnotv.Interm
ediateAppellateCourt)
(carabaoslaughterhouse)
*Churchill v. Rafferty - 32 PHIL.
580 (read with People v. Fajardo)
(billboards as nuisance)
*Peoplev.Fajardo-
104PHIL.443(notallowedtobuildon
hislotasitcoverstheview from
plaza)
*Ermita-MalateHotel
&MotelOperatorv. CityofManila-
20SCRA849(readwithCityof
Manilav.
Laguio;WhiteLightv.CityofManila)
(curbimmortality;licensefee)
*Ynotv.IntermediateAppellateCourt
-148 SCRA659 (transportof
carabao)
*Balacuitv.CFI-163
SCRA182(discounttochildreninmov
iehouse)
National Dev’t Co. and New Agrix
v. Phil Vet. Bank - 192 SCRA 257
(dissolved mortgages)
ACCFAv. CUGCO-
30SCRA649(fringebenefits;c
ollectivebargainingagreemen
t) Agustinv. Edu-88
SCRA195(EarlyWarningDe
69S
CR
Cruzv.Flavier, A1(
GR135385,De inp
cember6,2000( utta
IPRA;regaliad xes
octrine) )
SmithKlinev. Beltranv.
CA,GR121267 SecretaryofHealth,476SCR
,Oct.23,2001(p A168
harmaceutical (commercialbloodbankphas
patent) edout)
Peoplev. Dela Ongv.Sandiganbayan,470S
Piedra,350 CRA1(ill-
SCRA163(ille gottenwealth;spouse)
galrecruitment *LucenaGrandTerminalv.
) JACLiner,452SCRA174(exclusivef
Estradav. ranchise)
Sandiganbayan,GR148560,No *CityofManilav.
v.19,2001(plunder,voidforvagu Laguio,455SCRA308
eness) (sauna,massageparlors,nightclubs)
PilipinasKaov.CA,GR105014, *Bayanv.Ermita,GR169848,April2
Dec.18,2001 5,2006 (nopermit,norally)
(unpublishedmanualofoperatio *KMUv.Dir.Gen.487SCRA623(uni
ns) Philsav. Sec.of formIDsystem)
DOLE,GR103144,Apr.4,2001 *Mirasolv.DPWH490SCRA318(m
(unpublishedillegalexactionme otorcycleprohibition)
mo) *Parrenov.C
*Chavezv.Romulo,431SCRA534(ri OA523SCR
ghttobeararms) A390(pensi
*GSISv.Montescarlos,434SCRA44 onbannedfor
1 (survivorshippensionclaim) UScitizen)
Romualdezv.Sandiganbayan,435SC Esponcillav.
RA371(corruption;no BagongTany
preliminaryinvestigation) ag529SCRA
*C 654
hav (memberben
ezv eficiaries)
.C BFv.
OM CityMayor5
EL 15SCRA1
EC, (reclassificat
437 iontocomme
SC rcialzones)
RA *St.Lu
415 ke’sv.
(ca NLRC5
ndi 17SCR
dat A677(r
ebil egulati
lbo onofpro
ard fession)
s) Carlosv
.DSW
ST D526S
AR CRA13
T 0(taxcr
OF editsan
GR dtaxded
OU uctions
P1 )
RE Perezv.
PO LPG53
RT 1SCRA
431(pe
AB naltyon
AK percyli
AD nderbas
Av. is)
Er *MMDAv.
mit Viron530SCRA341(powerofMMD
A)
a,4
1
*Sec.of p
DNDv.Manalo568SCRA42(amparo o
) t
S s
J )
S SECv.
v Interport567SCRA354(showcauseo
. rder)
D BAN
D ATv.
B COM
5 ELEC
7 595S
0 CRA
S 477(s
C alaryf
R orpoll
A watch
4 ers)
1 Peopl
0 ev.
( Siton
m 600
a SCR
n A476
d (vagr
a ancyl
t aw)
o *WhiteLightv.
r CityofManila576SCRA416(washup
y rates)
d CREBAv.R
r omulo614S
u CRA605(cr
g editablewit
t hholdingtax
e ;MCIT)
s SouthernH
t emispherev
i .ATC632S
n CRA146(as
g -
) applieddoct
rine)
S *Roxasv.Macapagal-
J Arroyo630SCRA211(writof
S amparo/habeascorpus)
v *Meralcov.Lim
. 632SCRA195(writof habeasdata)
Pollov.
A KarinaConstanti
t no,GR181881,Oc
i tober8,2011
e (righttoprivacy)
n Sto.Tomasv.Pan
z eda685SCRA245
a (illegalrecruitme
5 nt)
4 DeLimav.Gatdula,GR204528,Feb
5 19,2013(writofamparo)
S Fernandov.St.
C Scholastica’sCollage,GR161107,
R March12,2013
A Ligotv.Republic,GR176944,Marc
9 h6, 2013
2 Republicv.
( Roque,GR204603,Sep.24,2013(voi
o dforvagueness)
i BankersAssociationofthePH
l v.COMELEC,GR206794,Novembe
d r26,2013-Manila
e MemorialPark
2
v.DSWD,GR175356,December3,20 o. Gozum v. Liangco 339 SCRA 253
13 p. Soriano v. Angeles 339 SCRA 253
Legaspiv.CityofCebu,GR159110,D q. Villanueva v. Malaya 330 SCRA
ecember10,2013(immobilizingofcar 278
) r. Almendras v. Asis 330 SCRA 69
*RemmanEnterprisesv. s. Dayot v. Garcia 353 SCRA 280
ProfessionalRegulatoryBoard,GR t. People v. Hapa GR 125698 July 19,
197676,Feb4 , 2014 2001
(realestatedeveloper’srighttodisp u. Aguirre v. People GR 144142
oseproperty) August 23, 2001
*Disiniv. v. Puyat v. Zabarte 352 SCRA 738
SecretaryofJustice,GR203335,Feb1 w. Baritua v. Mercader 350 SCRA 86
8,2014(CybercrimeLaw) x. Barbers v. Laguio 351 SCRA 606
*Imbongv. y. People v. Herida 353 SCRA 650
Ochoa,GR204819, z. People v. Medenilla GR 1311638
April8,2014(RHL Mar. 26, 2001
awvoidforvaguene aa. People v. Rivera GR 139180 July
ss) U.E.v. 31, 2001
Pepanio– bb. People v. Basquez GR 144035 Sept.
689SCRA250 27, 2001
*Garciav.Drilon–699 SCRA352 cc. Cooperative Development v.
NagkakaisangMaralitav.Sitio– DOLEFIL GR 137489 May 29, 2002
697SCRA359 dd. Garcia v. Pajaro GR 141149 July 5,
Burgosv. Esperon– 2002
715SCRA208(writof amparo) ee. Briaso v. Mariano, GR 137265, Jan.
*Caramv 31, 2003
.Segui– ff. Macias v. Macias, GR 1461617,
732 Sept. 3, 2003
SCRA86 gg. Albior v. Auguis, AM P-01- 1472,
(adoptio June 6, 2003
nnotsubj hh. Republic v. Sandiganbayan, GR
ecttoam 152154, Nov. 18, 2003
paro) ii. Ty v. Banco Filipino Savings and
Herman Mortgage Bank, 422 SCRA 649
oOilMan jj. People v. Larranaga, 421 SCRA 530
ufacturin kk. R. Transport v.
gv.TRB Philhino494SCRA630
–
742SCR
A397
*Misonv.Gallegos–
760SCRA363(writof amparo)
*Zaratev.
AquinoIII,GR220028,November10,2015(wr
itof amparo/habeasdata)
II. ProceduralDueProcess
A.JudicialProceedings
1. InGeneral
a. BancoEspanol37P 921
(jurisdictionoverperson)
2. AspectsoftheProceedings
a. Galvezv. CA237 SCRA685
b. State Prosecutors v. Muros 236
SCRA 505
c. Martinezv.CA237SCRA575
d. Espeleta v. Avelino 62 SCRA 395
e. Rabino v. Cruz 222 SCRA 493
f. Ysmael v. CA 273 SCRA 165
g. Carvajal v. CA 280 SCRA 351
h. People v. Castillo 289 SCRA 213
i. Cosep v. Peo. 290 SCRA 378
j. People v. Galleno 291 SCRA 761
k. Oil v. CA 293 SCRA 26
l. Rodrigo v. Sandiganbayan GR
125498 Feb. 18, 1999
m. People v. Hui 338 SCRA 2000
n. People v. Cabiles 341 SCRA 2000
3
-
4
ll. 5
TransMiddleEastv.Sandiganbayan49 J
9SCRA308 a
mm. Uy v. First Metro 503 SCRA 704 n
nn. Deutsche Bank v. Chua 481 SCRA .
672 2
oo. People v. Santos 501 SCRA 325 5
pp. Victoriano v. People 509 SCRA 483 ,
qq. Santos v. DOJ 543 SCRA 70 1
rr. DBP v. Feston 545 SCRA 422 9
ss. Ruivivar v. OMB 565 SCRA 324 9
tt. Borromeo v. Garcia 546 SCRA 543 9
uu. Cesa v. OMB 553 SCRA 357
vv. DAR v. Samson 554 SCRA 500 ww. d
Hilario v. People 551 SCRA 191 .
xx. Pastona v. CA 559 SCRA 137
yy. Bibas v. OMB 559 SCRA 591 P
zz. Espina v. Cerujano 550 SCRA 107 e
aaa. Geronga v. Varela 546 SCRA 429 o
bbb. OMB v. Magno GR 178923, Nov. p
27, 2008 l
ccc. Avenido v. CSC 553 SCRA 711 e
ddd. Romuladez v. COMELEC 553 v
SCRA 370 .
eee. Multi-Trans Agency v. Oriental 590
SCRA 675 S
fff. Siochi v. BPI, GR 193872, October a
18, 2011 n
ggg. Catacutan v. People 656 SCRA 524 c
hhh. Mortel v. Kerr 685 SCRA 1 (clear h
violation and errors of counsel) e
iii. Gravides v. COMELEC 685 SCRA 382 z
(error of counsel) G
jjj. Tua v. Mangrobang 714 R
SCRA248(TPO) 1
2
3. PublicityandT.V.Coverage 1
a. 0
Webbv.deLeon247SCRA652(rapecase,medi 3
a) 9
b. Peoplev. O
Teehankee249SCRA54(murderofHultman,m c
ediacoverage) t
c .
. 1
8
P ,
e 2
o 0
p 0
l 1
e e. Perezv.EstradaA.M.No. 01-4-03-
v SCJune29,2001
. f. Perezv.EstradaA.M.No. 01-4-03-
SCSept.13,2001(Estrada’splundercasemedia
S coverage)
a g. Peoplev. Roxas–628SCRA378
n
c B.Ad
h minis
e trati
z ve;Q
G uasi-
R Judic
1 ialPr
2 ocee
1 dings
0 ;Arbi
3 trati
9 on
4
2
1 S
. C
R
I A
n 1
G 2
e 5
n
e b
r .
a
l F
; a
a b
d e
m l
i l
n a
i v
s .
t
r C
a A
t 2
i 8
v 2
e
d S
u C
e R
p A
r 2
o 5
c 6
e c. Josonv. Exec.Sec.290SCRA279
s d
s .
a. AngTibayv.CIR69P
635(dueprocessinadministrativeproceedings) B
b. Dazonv. Yap–610SCRA19 u
c. s
Shuv.Dee723SCRA512(NBIwithoutjudi u
cialorquasi-judicialpower) e
g
2. JudgesandDisciplinaryProcess o
a. OCAv.Pascual259 SCRA604 v
b. Valenzuelav. Bellosillo322 SCRA536 .
C
3. AspectsoftheProceedings A
a G
. R
9
L 5
u 3
m 2
i 5
q M
u a
e r
d .
v 1
. 1
,
E 1
x 9
e 9
v 9
e
a e
2 .
8
5
C s
S a
C l
v v
. .
L T
u o
c r
a c
s i
G t
R a
1 3
2 3
7 0
8 S
3 C
8 R
J A
a 1
n 5
. 3
2
1 h
, .
1
9 V
9 e
9 l
a
f y
. o
v
N .
P C
C o
v m
. e
l
B e
e c
r 3
n 2
a 7
b S
e C
3 R
3 A
2 7
1
S 3
C i
R .
A
7 R
4 a
m
g
. o
r
S a
u n
m v
m .
a J
r a
y r
D d
i i
s n
m e
i 3
s 2
6
6 1
S 9
C 9
R 9
A
2 l
0 .
8
G
j o
. v
.
I C
m o
m m
a e
m l
v e
. c
C G
o R
m 1
e 4
l 7
e 7
c 4
3 1
2 M
2 a
S y
C 1
R 0
A ,
8 2
6 0
6 0
k 1
. m
.
V
i M
l o
l l
a l
r a
o n
s e
a d
v a
. v
C .
o U
m m
e a
l c
e o
c b
G G
R R
1 1
3 4
3 0
9 1
2 2
7 8
N J
o u
v n
. e
2 6
9 ,
, 2
7
0 2
0 1
1 5
1
n -
. 5
2
C ,
r J
u a
z n
v .
. 2
C 2
S ,
C 2
G 0
R 0
1 3
4
4 s
4 .
6
9 S
N p
o o
v u
. s
2 e
7 s
, C
2 a
0 s
0 i
1 m
o. i
Codillav.DeVeneciaGR150605Dec.10,2002 r
p. o
AssociatedCo v
mmunication .
sv.DumlaoG
R136762Nov C
.21,2002 A
q. ,
Villarosa 1
v.Pomperada, 3
AdminCaseN 6
o.5310,Jan.28 9
,2003 1
r 1
. ,
F
A e
l b
a .
u 1
y 1
a ,
v 2
. 0
C 0
o 3
m
e t
l .
e S
c y
, v
G .
R
1 C
5 A
8
,
G
R
1
4
7
5
7
2
,
F
e
b
.
2
7
,
2
0
0
3
9
l
4
u. Namilv.Comelec,GR15040,Oct.28,2003 9
v 3
. S
C
B R
a A
u 3
t 9
i 2
s x. Erecev.Macalingay552SCRA320
t z
a .
v
. M
C a
o r
m c
e e
l l
e o
c v
, .
G
R B
1 u
5 n
4 g
7 u
9 b
6 u
- n
9 g
7 5
, 5
O 2
c S
t C
. R
2 A
3 5
, 8
2 9
0
0 a
3 a
.
w S
. E
C
O v
f .
f
i I
c n
e t
o e
f r
p
O o
M r
B t
v 5
. 6
7
C S
o C
r R
o A
n 3
e 5
10
4 .
b C
b a
. s
C t
a i
l l
i l
n e
i j
s o
a s
n 5
v 8
. 1
R S
o C
a R
q A
u 3
i 2
n 0
6
3 f
0 f
S .
C
R O
A M
4 B
5 v
6 .
c E
c v
. a
I n
B g
P e
v l
. i
s
A t
t a
i 5
e 8
n 1
z S
a C
6 R
1 A
3 3
S 5
C 0
R g
A g
5 .
1 P
8 h
dd.Domingov.OMB577SCRA476 i
e l
e E
. x
Z p
a o
m r
b t
a v
l .
e
s P
v e
11
a C
r O
l M
C E
i L
t E
y C,
6 70
0 1S
8 C
S R
C A
R 78
A 6
2 oo.Mirov. Mendoza,710 SCRA371
8 pp.DOHv. Phil.Pharmawealth,691SCRA421
0 qq.GMAv.COMELEC 734SCRA88
rr. ApoCementCorporationv. Mingson740
h SCRA383
h
.
O 4. ExtraditionProceedings
M a. Sec.of Justicev.Lantion343SCRA377
B b. Cuevasv.MunozGR140520Dec.18,2000
v c. Gov’t.of U.S.Av.
. PurgananGR148571Sept.24,2002
R d. Rodriguezv.
e PresidingJudge,483SCRA290
y e.
e Gov’t.ofHongkongv.Olalia,GR153675April1
s 9,2007
6
5 5. Arbitration
8 a. RCBCv.BancodeOro687SCRA583
S
C C.AcademicDiscipline
R
A 1.InGeneral
6 a. Angelesv. Sison112SCRA26
2 b. Malabananv. Ramento129SCRA359
6 c.
ii. Guzmanv.NU142SCRA699(dueprocessi
Pichayv. nacademicdiscipline)
OfficeoftheD d. Alcuazv. PSBA161SCRA7
eputyExecut e. Nonv.JudgeDames185SCRA523
iveSecretary f.
677SCRA40 ADMUv.Capulong222SCRA644(fraterni
8 ty)
jj. g. U.P.v. Ligot-Telan227 SCRA342
Arroyov h. Gov.Colegiode
. DOJ681 SanJuandeLetran683SCRA358
SCRA181(fa
ct- D.DeportationProceedings
findingandjo
intcommitte 1. InGeneral
e) a. LaoGiv.CA180SCRA756
kk.Jalosjosv.COMELEC,GR205033,June b. Domingov.Scheer,421SCRA468
18,2013
(motupropioissuanceofCOMELEC E.Regul
Resolution) ations:F
ll. Posadasv. ixingof
Sandiganbayan,GR168951and169000,July1 Ratesan
7,2013(denialofMR) dRegul
m ationof
m. Professi
Gundayaov.COMELEC,GR205233,Feb18,2014
nn on
.C
oa 1. Rates
lit a. Philcomsatv.Alcuaz180SCRA218
io b. Radiocomv.NTC184SCRA517
nv c. Macedav.ERB199SCRA454(fixingrates)
. d.
12
GlobeTelecomv.NTC,435SCRA110(substan
tialevidencefrom priorruling)
2.Profession
a.Coronav.UHPAP283SCRA31 (pilot)
F
.
D
i
s
m
i
s
s
a
l
s
,
S
u
s
p
e
n
s
i
o
n
s
,
R
e
i
n
s
t
a
t
e
m
e
n
t
s
,
e
t
c
.
…
1. Dismissalin
GovernmentBoardsandCommissions
13
0
4
a S
. C
R
A A
b 3
a 7
l 2
o
s d
v .
.
G
C
o
S
n
C
z
-
a
1
l
9
e
6
s
S
v
C
.
R
C
A
S
8
C
1
-
2
b 2
. 6
S
G C
S R
I A
S 6
v 6
. e
C .
S
C G
- o
2 .
0 v
1 .
S N
C P
R C
A -
6 2
6 7
1 1
c S
. C
R
M A
a 4
c 4
a 7
y
a f
y .
o
n C
g H
v R
. v
O .
p C
l S
e C
- -
2
14
2 v
2 .
7 Z
S o
C z
R o
A b
4 r
2 a
d
g o
. -
4
U 8
y 7
v S
. C
C R
O A
A 1
- 6
3 j
2 .
8
S P
C A
R G
A C
6 O
0 R
7 v
h .
.
C
L A
a ,
m G
e R
1
y
8
r
5
a
6
v
6
. 8
,
P D
a e
n c
g e
i m
l b
i e
n r
a 1
n 3
- ,
3 2
2 0
2 1
S 1
C
R
A 2. Dismissalin PrivateSector
1 a
1 .
7
H
i e
. l
l
N e
P n
C i
15
c 1
v 0
. ,
1
S 9
i 9
e 7
t
e d
- .
1
9 A
5 p
S a
C r
R e
A n
1 t
7 e
9 v
b .
.
N
* L
S R
a C
l ,
a G
w R
v 1
. 1
N 7
L 6
R 5
C 2
- e
2 .
0
2 L
S o
C p
R e
A z
7 v
c .
.
A
C l
o t
n u
t r
i a
v s
. -
N 6
L 4
R 7
C S
, C
G R
R A
1 5
1 6
9 6
2
5
3 3. PreventiveSuspension
A a
p .
r
i A
l l
16
o .
n
z C
o S
v C
. -
C 5
a 7
p 6
u S
l C
o R
n A
g 7
- 8
2 7
4 d
4 .
S
C C
R a
A r
8 a
0 b
b e
. o
v
C .
a C
s A
t 6
i 0
l 7
l -
o S
– C
C R
o A
3
v 9
. 4
B G
a .
r O
b r
e d
r i
s n
2 a
9 n
0 c
S e
C /
R S
A t
7 a
1 t
7 u
t
c e
. /
M
B e
a m
c o
s C
a i
s r
a .
r /
v R
17
u o
l p
e l
s e
a. v
*Peoplev.Nazario165S .
CRA136(“manager”,v
oidforvagueness) d
b e
.
l
F a
r
a P
n i
c e
i d
s r
c a
o -
v 3
. 5
0
C S
A C
- R
1 A
9 1
9 6
S 3
C
R END OF GROUP 1 REPORT
A
5 START OF GROUP 2 REPORT
9
5 H.MotionforReconsideration
c a
. .
M M
i e
s d
a e
m n
i i
s l
O l
r a
. v
v .
. C
D S
O C
F -
- 1
2 9
3 4
8 S
S C
C R
R A
A 2
6 7
3 8
d. *Estradav.
SandiganbayanGR148560Nov.19,2001 b
(plunder,voidforvagueness) .
e
. M
e
P n
e d
18
i C
o R
l A
a 4
v 6
. 9
e
C .
S
C S
- a
2 l
2 o
1 n
g
S a
C v
R .
A C
2 A
9 -
5 2
6
c
9
.
S
C
R
R
o A
d 5
r 3
i 4
g f
u .
e
z B
v e
. r
n
P a
r r
o d
j o
. v
6 .
- C
2 A
4 -
7 2
S 7
C 5
R S
A C
5 R
2 A
8 4
1
d 3
. g
.
L
a C
z a
o s
v u
. e
C l
S a
C v
- .
2 O
3 m
6 b
S u
19
d 7
s 5
m A
a u
n g
- u
2 s
7 t
6 7
S ,
C 2
R 0
A 0
6 2
3
5 l
h .
. Cordenillov. ExecutiveSecretary-276SCRA652
i. Chuav. CA-287 SCRA33 G
j o
. n
z
D a
e l
l e
a s
C v
r .
u C
z S
v C
. -
A 4
b 9
e 0
l S
l C
e R
- A
3 7
5 4
2 1
S m
C .
R
A B
6 e
9 r
1 b
k o
. s
o
R v
o .
d
r C
i A
g -
u 4
e 9
z 4
v
. S
C C
A R
, A
G 5
R 8
1 3
3 n
4 .
2
20
P S
o -
n 6
t 5
e 8
j S
o C
s R
v A
. 4
9
D 7
e q
s .
i
e A
r r
t r
o o
- y
5 o
9 v
2 .
S
C R
R o
A s
6 a
4 l
H
o o
. m
e
N o
A w
E n
C e
O r
R s
v -
. 6
E 8
R 4
C S
- C
6 R
5 A
3 2
S 9
C 7
R
A r
6 .
4
2 Y
p l
. a
y
I a
m v
p .
e
r G
i a
a c
l o
v t
. t
-
G 6
S 8
I 9
21
S R
C A
R 8
A 4
4 2
5
2 K. Appeal
s. Moldexv.Villabona- a
675SCRA615(motionforreco .
nsiderationnotallowed)
A
I. Suretyship l
a b
. a
v
S .
t D
r e
o p
n u
g t
h y
o O
l m
d b
I u
n d
s s
u m
r a
a n
n
c -
e 2
v 5
. 4
S
C C
A R
A
- 7
2 5
0 3
5
S b
C .
R
A T
6 e
0 l
5 a
n
J. TariffandCustomsCode v
a .
.
C
F A
e -
e 2
d 0
e 2
r S
v C
. R
C A
A 5
- 3
1 4
9 c
7 .
S
C A
22
r 8
i f
s .
v
. B
N u
L i
R l
C d
- i
2 n
0 g
0 C
S a
C r
R e
A v
2 .
4
6 M
a
d c
. a
r
R a
i e
v g
e -
r 6
a 8
v 7
. S
C C
S R
C A
- 6
2 4
4 3
0
S g
C .
R
A D
4 i
3 o
e n
. a
v
S .
i B
n a
g l
s e
o r
n g
v u
. e
N -
L 6
R 8
C 8
- S
2 C
7 R
4 A
2
S 2
C
R
A
3
5
23
n
e
2
L. ClosureProceedings ,
a.CB 1
v.CA 9
220S 9
CRA 5
536
(relati M. Biddings
vecon a
stituti .
onalit
y) C
b o
. n
c
R e
u r
r n
a e
l d
B O
a f
n f
k i
v c
. i
C a
A l
1 s
6 v
2 .
S
C V
R a
A s
2 q
8 u
8 e
c z
. ,
2
P 4
h 0
i S
l C
. R
M A
e 5
r 0
c 2
h
a N. UDHA–
n R.A.7279;Squatting;Procedureforrelocation;s
t ummaryabatement
s a.
v Perezv.v.Ma
. drona668SC
RA696(notn
C uisancepers
A e)
G
R O. CancellationofPropertyRights/Privileges
1 a
1 .
2
8 A
4 m
4 e
J r
u i
24
c .
a
n A
I B
n A
t K
e A
r D
- A
F v
a .
s E
h r
i m
o i
n t
v a
. 4
6
O 9
P S
1 C
9 R
7 A
S 1
C (
R E
A -
4 V
0 A
9 T
L
b a
. w
)
A d. British
l AmericanTobaccov.Camac
l ho562SCRA511and(MR)5
i 85SCRA36
a (expansivetaxcategory)
n e.
c DPWHv.SpousesTec
e son,GR179334,July1,2013(d
o eprivationof propertywithout
f expropriationproceeding)
D
F P.
L AdministrativeandPreliminaryInvestigation-
O Ombudsman
v a
. .
L
a R
g o
u x
e a
s s
m v
a .
2
5 V
4 a
S s
C q
R u
A e
5 z
6 G
5 R
1
c 1
25
4 2
9 1
4 4
4 0
J ,
u J
n a
e n
1 u
9 a
, r
2 y
0 2
0 1
1 ,
2
b 0
. 1
5
O
c
a 7.EqualProtectionofLaw(domatrixofallcases;asteri
m skforrecit)
p
o P
v e
. o
O p
m l
b e
u v
d .
s
m C
a a
n y
3 a
2 t
2 -
S 6
C 8
R
A P
1 H
7 I
c L
. Serapiov. Sandiganbayan,GR148468,Jan.28,2003 .
d 1
. 2
E ,
s 1
t 8
r (
a i
d n
a d
v i
. g
o e
m n
b o
u u
d s
s p
m e
a o
n p
, l
G e
R )
2
1 I
26
c
h
o
n
g
v
.
H
e
r
n
a
n
d
e
z
-
1
0
1
P
H
I
L
.
1
1
5
5
(
r
e
t
a
i
l
t
r
a
d
e
)
*Villegasv.
HiuChiongTsaiP
aoHo-86
SCRA270(empl
oymentpermit)
Dumlaov.COME
LEC-96
SCRA392(youn
gvretiredelective
official)
Goesartv.
Cleary-
335US464(femal
ebartenders)
*OrmocSugarCentralv.OrmocCity-
L-
23794February17,1968(lawspecific
for
OrmocSugarCentral)
Bascov.PAGCOR-
May14,1991(gambling)
Republicv. Sandiganbayan–
230SCRA711(deedofassignmentby
De’Venecia)
27
n–
262SCRA122
Bina (attorney-
yv. clientprivilege
Dom ) Sisonv.
ingo- Ancheta–
201S 130SCRA654
CRA (taxonprofessi
508( onals)
poor Marcosv
buria . CA –
lassi 278SCR
stanc A843(pe
e) ndingcri
NPC minalcas
v.De e)
Guz Nolasco
man v.COM
– ELEC–
229S 275SCR
CRA A762(C
801( OMELE
polic Cpower)
eretir Phil.Jud
eme gesv.
nt) Prado–
Tole 227
ntino SCRA70
v. 3(franki
Secr ngprivile
etary ges)Oliv
of arezv.
Fina Sandiga
nce– nbayan–
249S 248SCR
CRA A700
628( (busines
E- spermits
VAT )
) GMCv. Torres–
Him 196SCRA216(non-
residentvresidentalienemploy
agan
mentpermit) Segoviav.
v.Pe
Sandiganbayan-
ople-
288SCRA328(OMBpowertos
237S
uspend)
CRA
Chavezv.PCGG–
538(
GR130716December9,1998(witnessin
PNP
forfeiturecases)
susp
Telebapv.COMELEC–
ensi
289SCRA337(mediainprovidingfr
on)
eeairtimetoCOMELEC)
Alm
Tiuv.CA–
onte
GR127410January20,1999(Subic
v.Va
NavalBase)
sque
Lacsonv.ExecutiveSecretary
z–
–GR128096January20,1999
244S
(SBjurisdiction) Sorianov.
CRA
CA –
286(
GR123936March4,1999(fin
OM
ancialcapacityinprobationca
Bco
ses)
mpla
Aguinaldov.COMELEC–
int)
GR132774June21,1999
Limv.Pacquing-
(incumbentofficials)
240SCRA649(revokedjai-
Loongv.COMELEC,305SCRA832(sp
alaifranchise)
ecialelectionforgovernor)
ConferenceofMaritimeManningv.POE
InternationalSchoolv.Quisumbing–
A-243SCRA666(landbasedv.sea-
GR128845June1,2000(salaryforfor
based
eignhires)
OFW)
DeGuzmanv.COMELEC,GR12911
Regalav. 8,July19,2000
Sandiganbaya
28
(electionofficerstootherstations (oild
andfixedsalaryforpollwatchers) epot
Bayanv.Zamora,GR138 bein
570,October10,2000(Vi gda
sitingForcesAgreement nger
) Peoplev. ous)
Mercado,GR116239,No Gob
vember29,2000 enci
(deathpenalty) ong
Peoplev. v.
Jalosjos,3 CA5
24SCRA6 50
89(exemp SCR
tionofelec A30
tiveofficia 2(O
l) MB
Lopezv.C pow
A,GR144 erto
573,Sept. susp
24,2002( end)
OMBAct) MI
Philrecav. Sec.of AA
DILG,GR140376,June10,200 v.Ol
3(withdrawaloftaxexemption ong
) Farinasv. apo
ExecutiveSecretary,GR14738 543
7,Dec.10,2003 SCR
(appointiveofficials) A26
Dimaporov. 9(pu
HRET,GR158359,Mar.23,2004(congr blic
essionalcandidate) bidd
GSISv. ing)
Montescarlos,434SCRA441(marriedp Nic
ensioners) ola
In re Request of Assistant Court sv.
Administrators, 440 SCRA 16 Ro
(compensationfor judiciary) mul
*CentralBankEmployeesAss’nv. o–
BangkoSentralng 578
Pilipinas,446SCRA299 SC
(readwith*BritishAmericanTobaccov RA
.SecofFinance,2008)(classificationba 438
sedon salary- (V
relativeconstitutionality) FA
Mirasolv.DPWH(supra.Substantive)( mil
motorcyclevothervehicles) itar
InreRequestof ym
ACA495SCRA432(compensati em
onforCTAandMTCjudges) ber
Dimayugav.OMB495 )
SCRA461(OMBpowertocondu Ser
ctpreliminaryinvestigation) ran
*Yc ov.
asue Gal
giv. lant
PAL –
569 582
SCR SC
A46 RA
7(ob 254
esefl (O
ight FW
atte vlo
nda cal
nt) wor
SJS ker
v. )
Atie *Peoplev. Siton–
nza5 600SCRA476(vagrancy)
45S *Leagueof Citiesv.COMELEC–
CR 608SCRA636(pendingbillsforcities-
A92 cityhoodlaws)
29
*Q PCandmilitarycourt)
uin Arroyov.
tov DOJ(supra.,Procedu
. ralDueProcess)
CO Sto.Tomasv.Paneda685SCRA245
M (illegalrecruitment)
EL Inthematterof
EC thebrewingcontroversiesintheelections
– oftheIBP,AM09-5-2-Sc,April
61 11,2013(supraArt3, Sec1)
3S
CR
A3
85(
app
oin
tiv
eof
fici
al)
CR
EB
Av.
Ro
mu
lo–
61
4S
CR
A6
05(
sup
ra.)
(M
CI
T)
NPCv. Pinatubo–
616SCRA611(manufacturersand
processorsofaluminumsteel)
Biraogov. PTC–637
SCRA78(truthcommission)
Leaguev.
COMELEC
–643
SCRA149(p
endingbillsc
ityhoodlaw)
PAGCORv.
BIR–
645SCRA33
8(PAGCOR
subjecttotax
)
Gancaycov.QuezonCity–
658SCRA853(demolitionofbuildinga
gainstBuilding
Code)
Mendozav.People,GR183891,October
19,2011
BureauofCustomsv.Teves,GR18170
4,December6,2011(IRRdoesnotviol
ate
EPC)
Pichayv. Officeof
theDeputyExecutiveSecre
tary(supra.)(appointiveoff
icials) Alvarezv.
People677SCRA673(nota
llaccusedcharged)
Garciav.
People677SCRA75
0(convictionunderR
30
Aquinov.
PhilippinePortsAuthority,GR181973,Ap
ril17,2013
Garciav. Drilon,GR179267,June25,2013
NationalArtistforliteratureAlmario,GR1
89028,July16,2013
LandTransportationFranchisingandRegu
latoryBoardv. StrongholdInsurance,Gr
200740,October2,2013
Imbongv.Ochoa,GR20
4819,April8,2014(RHL
aw)(supraArtIII,Sec1)
SpousesDacudaov.DOJ
,GR 188056,Jan8,2013
Goldenwayv. Equitable–693SCRA439
R
e
m
m
a
n
v
.
P
R
B
R
E
S
(
s
u
p
r
a
.
)
E
s
p
i
n
a
s
v
.
C
O
A
-
7
2
0
S
C
R
A
3
0
2
Disiniv.SecretaryofJustice(supra.)
*Peoplev.Jumanan-722SCRA108
Bartolomev. SSS-740SCRA78
*Villanueva,v.JBC–755SCRA182
*Ferrerv. Bautista–760SCRA692
*1-Unitedv. COMELEC–755SCRA441
31
Section 2.
When is a search a “search”?
Valmonte v. General de Villa - 178 SCRA 211,
(MAIN) and 185 SCRA 665 (MR)
Guazon v. De Villa - 181 SCRA 623
*SJS v. DDB 570 SCRA 410 (mandatory drug testing,
requirement of a valid search)
Requisites of a valid warrant

*People v. Veloso - 48 PHIL. 169 (John Doe warrant,
description personae)
Alvarez v. CFI - 64 PHIL. 33 (search at night)
*Stonehill v. Diokno – 20 SCRA 383 (general
warrants, rule on exclusion_
*Central Bank v. Morfe – 20 SCRA 507 (general
pattern of business)
*Bache & Co. v. Ruiz - 37 SCRA 823 (depositions
made by clerk)
Placer v. Villanueva - 126 SCRA 463
Burgos, Sr. v. Chief of Staff, AFP - 133 SCRA 800
(general warrant) File with Blythe as of 27 Oct 2016
17
32
Corro v. Lising - 137 SCRA 541 Uy v. BIR, GR 129651, October 20, 2000 (superseding
*Soliven v. Makasiar - 167 SCRA 394 (judge not warrant)
required to personally examine) Vallejo v. CA - 427 SCRA 658 (more than one
Salazar v. Achacoso - 183 SCRA 145 offense)
Board of Comm. (CID) v. Dela Rosa - 197 SCRA 853 People v. Del Norte - 426 SCRA 383
*Lim, Sr. v. Judge Felix – 194 SCRA 292 Mayo v. Penalosa – Fermo – 582 SCRA 1
(certification used by judge) People v. Nunez – 591 SCRA 394
Silva v. Pres. Judge of RTC of Negros Or. - 203 SCRA Borlongan v. Pena – 626 SCRA 633
140 (property not covered by warrant) Sy Tan v. Sy Tiong – 613 SCRA 98
Allado v. Diokno - 232 SCRA 192 (not proven crimes) People v. Tuan – 628 SCRA 226 File with Blythe as of 27
Ortiz v. Palaypayon - 234 SCRA 391 (no personal Oct 2016
examination of witnesses and complainants) 18
People v. Martinez - 235 SCRA 171 (warrantless
search)
Munez v. Arino - 241 SCRA 478
Cabilao v. Sardido - 246 SCRA 94
De los Santos-Reyes v. Montesa - 247 SCRA 85
Webb v. De Leon - 247 SCRA 652 (supra, Procedural
Due Process) (evidence need not be conclusive)
Agcaoili v. Molina - A.M. No. MTJ - 94-979, 249
SCRA 482
People v. Woolcock - 244 SCRA 235
Tambasen v. People - 246 SCRA 184
Manlavi v. Gacott - 244 SCRA 50
Columbia Pictures v. CA – 237 SCRA 367
Columbia Pictures v. CA – 262 SCRA 219
Roberts v. CA – 254 SCRA 307 (Pepsi number case)
20th Century Fox Film v. CA – 164 SCRA 655 (no
mastertape)
Republic v. Sandiganbayan - 255 SCRA 438
Ho v. People – 280 SCRA 365 (personal determination
of probable cause)
People v. CA – 291 SCRA 400
Pastrano v. CA – 281 SCRA 287
People v. Lagao – 271 SCRA 51
Gozos v. Tac-an – GR 123191 December 17, 1998
Flores v. Sumalig – 290 SCRA 568
Kho v. Makalintal – GR 94902-06 April 21, 1999
Paper Industries v. Asuncion – GR 122092 May 19,
1999
Gov’t of USA v. Purganan, GR 148571, Sept. 21, 2002
(probable cause)
Cupcupin v. people, GR 132389, Nov. 19, 2002
People v. Gonzales, GR 121877, Sept. 12, 2001
People v. Molina - 352 SCRA 179
People v. Salunguit, GR 133254, Apr. 19, 2001
Del Rosario v. People, GR 142295, May 31, 2001
*People v. Francisco, GR 129035, Apr. 22, 2002
(different address of house)
People v. Mamaril - 420 SCRA 662
People v. de los Reyes - 441 SCRA 305 (leading
questions not searching)
Okabe v. Gutierrez - 429 SCRA 685 (reiterates Lim v.
Felix)
Sony v. Espanol – 453 SCRA 360
Betoy v. Coliflores 483 SCRA 435
Dizon v. Veneracion, AM RTJ-97-1376, July 20, 2000
Abdula v. Guiani, 326 SCRA 1
Raro v. Sandiganbayan, GR 108431, July 14, 2000
Tolentino v. Malanyaon, AM RTJ-99-1444, August 3,
2000
Savage v. Taypin, 331 SCRA 697
People v. Baula, GR 132671, November 15, 2000
Nala v. Barroso, Jr. GR 153087, Aug. 7, 2003
People v. Venecario, 420 SCRA 280
Microsoft Corp. v. Maxicorp., Inc, 438 CSRA 224
Miranda v. Tuliao 486 SCRA 377
Kho v. Lanzanas 489 SCRA 444
People v. Choi 497 SCRA 547
David v. Arroyo 489 SCRA 160
Yousef Al-Ghoul v. CA, G.R. No. 126859, September
4, 2001 (place searched not in the warrant)
33
Del Castillo v. People – 664 SCRA 430 (test-buy People v. Mendoza – GR 109279-80 January 18, 1999
operation) People v. Doria – GR 125299 January 22, 1999 File with
HPS Software v. PLDT – 687 SCRA 426 Blythe as of 27 Oct 2016
Republic v. Roque, GR 204603, Sep. 24, 2013 19
WWW Corp v. People, GR 161106, Jan 13, 2014
Ocampo v. Abando, Gr 176830, Feb 11, 2014
Century v. People 709 SCRA 177
Unilever v. Tan, GR. 179367, January 29, 2014
Microsoft v. Farajallah 735 SCRA 34
PLDT v. Alvarez, 718 SCRA 94
Dela Cruz v. People, 730 SCRA 655
Laud v. People, 741 SCRA 239
Petron v. Ong, GR 199371, February 3, 2016
Ogayan v. People – 768 SCRA 670
Warrantless searches and seizures.

People v. Rodriguez - 232 SCRA 227
*MHP v. CA - 226 SCRA 227 (boy scout; enough
time to apply for the warrant)
People v. Saycon - 236 SCRA 329
*People v. CFI - 101 SCRA 86 (moving vehicle)
*Roan v. Gonzales - 145 SCRA 687 (custodial legis)
Nolasco v. Pano - 147 SCRA 509 (person of accused)
Papa v. Mago – 22 SCRA 857 (Bureau of Customs)
People v. Lo Ho Wing – 193 SCRA 122 (drug case –
Hong Kong)
*People v. Malmstedt – 198 SCRA 401 (bus to
Sagada)
*Posadas v. CA - 188 SCRA 288
Bagalihog v. Fernandez - 198 SCRA 614
People v. Sibug - 229 SCRA 489
People v. Garcia - 235 SCRA 371
People v. Cuachon – 238 SCRA 540
People v. Merabueno – 239 SCRA 197
People v. Pablo - 239 SCRA 500
People v. De Gracia - 233 SCRA 716
People v. Santos - 236 SCRA 686
People v. Acol - 232 SCRA 406
People v. De Lara - 236 SCRA 291
*Aniag v. COMELEC - 237 SCRA 424 (gun ban;
checkpoint)
People v. Fernandez – 239 SCRA 174
People v. Barros - 231 SCRA 557
People v. Figueroa - 248 SCRA 679
People v. Balingan - 241 SCRA 277
People v. Tabar – 222 SCRA 144
Veronia School District. 47 J v. ACTON - June 26,
1995
Manlavi v. Gacott - 244 SCRA 50
People v. Velasco - 252 SCRA 135
People v. Lua - 256 SCRA 539
People v. Juatan – 260 SCRA 532
People v. Leangsiri - 252 SCRA 213
Hizon v. CA – 265 SCRA 517
People v. Que – 265 SCRA 721
People v. Cuizon - 256 SCRA 329
People v. Bagista – 214 SCRA 63
*Malacat v. CA – 283 SCRA 159 (fast moving eyes)
People v. Salazar – 266 SCRA 607
People v. Encinada - 280 SCRA 72
Mustang Lumber v. CA – 257 SCRA 430 (trucks with
lumber)
Padilla v. CA – 269 SCRA 402
People v. Gatward – 267 SCRA 785
People v. Sotto – 275 SCRA 191
People v. Lising – 275 SCRA 804
People v. Lacerna – 278 SCRA 561
*People v. Aruta – 288 SCRA 626
People v. Montilla – 285 SCRA 703
People v. Cuenco – GR 128277 November 16, 1998
Españo v. CA – 288 SCRA 558
People v. Correa – 285 SCRA 679
34
*Asuncion v. CA – GR 125959 February 1, 1999 People v. Villaroel – 693 SCRA 549
(shabu in vehicle) Antiquera v. People – 712 SCRA 339
People v. Valdez – GR 127801 March 3, 1999 Sales v. People – 690 SCRA 141
Austria v. NLRC, GR 124382, August 16, 1999 (?) People v. de Jesus - 690 SCRA 180 File with Blythe as of
Marcelo v. Sandiganbayan, 302 SCRA 102 27 Oct 2016
People v. Mendoza, 301 SCRA 66 20
People v. Sevilla, GR 124077, September 5, 2000
People v. Figueroa, GR 134056, July 6, 2000
People v. Che Chun Ting, GR 130568-69, March 21,
2000
People v. Escano, 323 SCRA 754
People v. Hindoy, G.R. No. 132662, May 10, 2001
People v. Deang, GR 128045, August 24, 2000
People v. Gonzales, G.R. No. 121877, September 12,
2001
People v. Valdez, GR 129296, September 25, 2000
(plain view)
People v. Lacap, G.R. No. 139114, October 23, 2001
People v. Johnson, GR 138881, December 18, 2000
People v. Uy, 380 SCRA 100 (in flagrante)
People v. Que- Ming Kha, GR 133265, May 29, 2002
(plain view)
People v. Salanguit, 356 SCRA 683
People v. Aspiras, 376 SCRA 596
Caballes v. CA, 373 SCRA 221
*People v. Canton, GR 148825, Dec. 27, 2002 (airport
search)
People v. Asis, GR 142531, Oct. 15, 2002 (waiver)
People v. Libnao, GR 136860, Jan. 20, 2003
People v. Macalaba, GR 146284, Jan. 20, 2003
People v. Sarap, GR 132165, Mar. 26, 2003
People v. Tudtud, GR 144037, Sept. 26, 2003
People v. Suzuki, GR 120670, Oct.23, 2003
People v. Ayangao - 427 SCRA 428
People v. Pendatun, 434 SCRA 198
People v. Peralta - 426 SCRA 472
Rieta v. People, 426 SCRA 273
People v. Huang – 439 SCRA 350 (plain view)
Unilab v. Isip – 461 SCRA 574 (plain view)
Salvador v. People – 463 SCRA 574 (moving vehicle
and customs search)
Amante v. Serwelas – 471 SCRA 348 (moving
vehicle)
People v. Penaflorida 551 SCRA 111
People v. Cabacoba 557 SCRA 475
People v. Bohol 560 SCRA 232
People v. Dumangay 566 SCRA 290
People v. Aguitay 566 SCRA 572
Ching v. People 569 SCRA 711
People v. Lopez GR No. 181441, Nov. 14, 2008
Ambant v. CA 553 SCRA 295 (plain view)
Eugenio v. People 549 SCRA 433 (entry of plea)
People v. de la Cruz 555 SCRA 329 (entry of plea)
People v. Concepcion 556 SCRA 421 (entry of plea)
People v. Alunday 564 SCRA 135 (entry of plea)
Revaldo v. People – 585 SCRA 341
Abelita v. Doria – 596 SCRA 220
Valeroso v. CA – 598 SCRA 41
People v. Rivera – 597 SCRA 299
Dolera v. People – 598 SCRA 484
Esquillo v. People – 629 SCRA 370
Rebellion v. People – 623 SCRA 343 (drugs)
People v. Araneta – 634 SCRA 475 (drugs)
People v. Tan – 634 SCRA 773 (drugs)
People v. Sembrano – 628 SCRA 328 (drugs)
People v. Mariacos – 621 SCRA 327
People v. Racho – 626 SCRA 633 (entry of plea)
People v. Aminola – 630 SCRA 384
Fajardo v. People – 639 SCRA 194
People v. de los Reyes – 656 SCRA 417
Luz v. People – 667 SCRA 421
Martinez v. People – 693 SCRA 549
35
People v. Candidia – 707 SCRA 494 Larranaga v. CA – 287 SCRA 521
*Disini v. Sec. of Justice, GR 203335, February 18, People v. Olivarez – GR 77865 December 4, 1998
2014 People v. Cabilles – 284 SCRA 199
People v. Colantiao – 727 SCRA 20 People v. Pacistol – 284 SCRA 520
People v. Edaño – 729 SCRA 255 People v. Barrientos – 285 SCRA 221 File with Blythe as
Cresencio v. People – 741 SCRA 319 of 27 Oct 2016
Castro v. People, GR 212260, November 26, 2014 21
Sanchez v. People – 741 SCRA 294
Dela Cruz v. People, GR 209387, January 11, 2016
Searches and seizures “of whatever nature and for

whatever purpose.”
*Material Distributors v. Natividad - 84 PHIL. 127
(Rules of Court – production of documents)
Oklahoma Press v. Walling - 327 US 186 (limited
rights of corporation)
*Camara v. Municipal Court - 387 US 523 (housing
inspector)
Warrantless arrests
*Harvey v. Defensor-Santiago - 162 SCRA 840
(pedophilia)
*People v. Aminnudin - 163 SCRA 402 (disembarking
from ship)
People v. dela Cruz - 184 SCRA 416
*People v. Burgos - 144 SCRA 1 (seditious materials;
arrested while plowing)
*Umil v. Ramos - 187 SCRA 311 (Main) and October
3, 1991 (MR) (continuing offense)
People v. Sucro - 195 SCRA 388
People v. Kalubiran – 196 SCRA 644
People v. Alvarez – 201 SCRA 365
*Go v. CA – 206 SCRA 138 (arrested without warrant
six days after commission)
People v. Briones - 202 SCRA 708
*People v. Mengote - 210 SCRA 174 (looking side to
side)
People v. Simon - 234 SCRA 555
People v. Manlulu - 231 SCRA 701
People v. Yap - 229 SCRA 787
People v. De Guzman - 231 SCRA 737
People v. Rabang - 187 SCRA 682
People v. Agustin - 240 SCRA 541
People v. Lopez - 246 SCRA 95
People v. Rayray - 241 SCRA 1
People v. Flores - 243 SCRA 374
People v. Manzano - 248 SCRA 239
Velasco v. CA - 245 SCRA 677
People v. Nitcha - 240 SCRA 283
People v. Rivera - 245 SCRA 421
People v. Samson - 244 SCRA 146
People v. Rodrigueza – 205 SCRA 791
People v. Sequino – 264 SCRA 79
People v. Solayao – 262 SCRA 255
People v. Lapura - 255 SCRA 85
People v. Nazareno – 260 SCRA 256
People v. Silan - 254 SCRA 491
People v. Alolod – 266 SCRA 154
People v. Mahusay – 282 SCRA 80
People v. Alvario – 275 SCRA 529
Larranaga v. CA – 281 SCRA 254
*Manalili v. CA – 280 SCRA 400 (drug user with red
eyes and swaying side to side)
Bernarte v. CA – 263 SCRA 323
Filoteo v. Sandiganbayan – 263 SCRA 222
People v. Herbias – 265 SCRA 571
People v. Salvatierra – 276 SCRA 55
People v. Hernandez – 282 SCRA 387
People v. Jayson – 282 SCRA 166
OCA v. Barron – A.M. RTJ 98-1420 October 8, 1998
People v. Aruta – (supra, Warrantless Searches) 288
SCRA 626
36
People v. Galleno – 291 SCRA 761 People v. Abrenica. G.R. No. 136267, July 10, 2001.
People v. Tidula – 292 SCRA 596 People v. Huang Zhen Hua, 439 SCRA 350
Boneng v. People, 304 SCRA 252 People v. Torres 501 SCRA 591
People v. Navarro – GR 129566 October 7, 1998 Cruz v. People – 578 SCRA 447
Cojuangco v. Sandiganbayan – GR 134307* Revaldo v. People – 585 SCRA 341 File with Blythe as of
Bagawali v. People – GR 133563 March 4, 1999 27 Oct 2016
People v. Bensil – GR 120163 March 10, 1999 22
People v. Nullan – GR 126303 April 14, 1999
People v. Silvano – GR 127356 June 29, 1999
Cadua v. CA, GR 123123, August 19, 1999
People v. Garcia, GR 126252, August 30, 1999
People v. Balluda, GR 114198, November 19, 1999
People v. Elamparo, GR 121572, March 31, 2000
People v. Chua Uy, 327 SCRA 335
People v. Cubcubin, GR 136267, July 10, 2001
People v. Compacion, G. R. No. 124442, July 20, 2001
People v. Montano, GR 130836, August 11, 2000
People v. Zheng Bai Hui, GR 127580, August 22,
2000
People v. Beriarmente, G.R. No. 137612, September
25, 2001
Posadas v. Ombudsman, GR 131492, September 29,
2000
People v. dela Cruz, GR 138516-17, October 17, 2000
People v. Bongalon, 374 SCRA 289 (consent, in
flagrante, waiver)
People v. Vinalon, GR 135542, July 28, 2002 (recent
commission of crime)
People v. Recepcion, GR 141923, Nov. 13, 2002 (hot
pursuit, waiver of illegality)
People v. Sanus, GR 135057, Sept. 17, 2002
People v. Mendez, GR 147671, Nov. 21, 2002 (arrest 4
days late)
People v. Avendano, GR 137407, Jan. 28, 2003
People v. Libnao, GR 136860, Jan. 20, 2003
People v. Eugenio, GR 146805, Jan. 16, 2003
David v. Arroyo, GR 171390, May 3, 2006
Dizon v. Lambino 498 SCRA 233
People v. Escordial, 373 SCRA 585
People v. Butulfo, GR 143790, May 7, 2002
People v. Baccoy, GR 134002, Sept. 12, 2002
People v. Billaber, 421 SCRA 27
People v. Yang, 423 SCRA 82
People v. Cadley, 425 SCRA 495
People v. Peralta, 426 SCRA 472
People v. Ejandra, 439 SCRA 364
People v. Del Rosario, 305 SCRA 740
People v. Bolasa, GR 125754, December 22, 1999
People v. Gomez, 325 SCRA 61
People v. Buluran, 325 SCRA 476
People v. Gallarde, 325 SCRA 38
People v. Ereno, 326 SCRA 157
People v. Gamer, 326 SCRA 664
People v. Logarto, 326 SCRA 693
People v. Legaspi, GR 117802, April 27, 2000
People v. Baniguid, GR 137714, September 8, 2000
People v. Zaspo, GR 136396, September 21, 2000
People v. Emoy, GR 109760, September 27, 2000
People v. Baylon, GR ________, October 18, 2000
People v. Madraga, GR 129294, November 15, 2000
People v. Gopio, GR 133925, November 29, 2000
People v. Pasudag, G.R. No. 128822, May 4, 2001
People v. Liwanag, G.R. No. 120468, August 15, 2001
(waiver)
People v. Pralta, 426 SCRA 472
People v. Kimura, 428 SCRA 51
San Agustin v. People, 432 SCRA 392
People v. Mantung, GR 130372, July 20, 1999
People v. Rondero, GR 125687, December 9, 1999
Del Rosario v. People, G.R. No. 142295, May 31,
2001
People v. Estrada, GR 124461, June 26, 2000
37
People v. Agojo – 585 SCRA 652
Abelita v. Doria – 596 SCRA 220
Zalameda v. People – 598 SCRA 537
People v. Quebral – 606 SCRA 247
People v. Ara – 609 SCRA 304
People v. Santos - 564 SCRA 135
People v. Ng – 639 SCRA 88
People v. Manlangit – 639 SCRA 455
People v. Uyboco – 640 SCRA 146
People v. Dequena – 640 SCRA 111
People v. Cruz – 652 SCRA 286
Miclat v. People – 656 SCRA 539
People v. Buenaventura – GR 184807, November 13,
2011
Ambre v. People – 678 SCRA 552
Goco v. People, GR 198694, Feb 13, 2013 (without
probable cause)
People v. Alejandria, GR 192913, June 13, 2013
People v. Cogaed – 731 SCRA 427
Sydeco v. People 740 SCRA 288
Pestillos v. Generoso – 739 SCRA 337
Commendiante v. People – 763 SCRA 587
Ongcoma Hadji v. People – 768 SCRA 584
38
*Gonzales v. COMELEC - 27 SCRA 835 (early
Section 3. nomination of candidates)
Eastern Broadcasting v. Dans, Jr. - 137 SCRA
Privacy; Exclusionary Rule 628 (courts and quasi-tribunals guidelines)
*Ayer Prod. PTY. LTD. v. Judge Capulong - 160
*Salcedo-Ortanez v. CA – 235 SCRA 111 (wiretap) SCRA 865 (public figure)
*Zulueta v. CA - 253 SCRA 699 (husband and wife Roxas v. De Zuzuarregui – 527 SCRA 446 (articles
privacy) about acts of SC justices)
*People v. Marti - 193 SCRA 57 (search by private Fortun v. Quisayas – 690 SCRA 623
person) Ramirez v. CA – 248 SCRA 590
People v. Mendoza – GR 109279-80 January 18, 1999
Waterous Drug Corp. v. NLRC – 280 SCRA 735
Ople v. Torres - (supra, Substantive)
People v. Aruta – (supra, Warrantless Searches)
Gutang v. People, GR 135406, July 11, 2000
People v. Lim, GR 141699, Aug. 7, 2002
People v. Bongcuaran, GR 143944, July 11, 2002
KMU v. Dir. - Gen. of NEDA 487 SCRA 623 (read
with Ople)
Republic v. Roque, GR 204603, Sep. 24, 2013
Imbong v. Ochoa, GR 204819, April 8, 2014 (RH
Law) (supra Art III, Sec 1)
Disini c. Secretary of Justice, GR 203335, Feb 18,
2014 (Cybercrime Law) (supra Art 3, Sec 1)
Sesbremo v. CA 720 SCRA 107(reiterates principle
that guaranty against illegal searches and seizures does
not apply against private parties)
Waiver of Rights under Sec. 2 and Sec. 3
*People v. Damaso – 212 SCRA 547 (personal waiver)

*Spouses Veroy v. Layague – 210 SCRA 97 (search of
persons, not of materials)
People v. Evaristo - GR 93828 December 11, 1992
Pastrano v. CA – (supra, Requisites of Warrant)
Habeas Data
*Vivares v. St. Theresa’s College – 727 SCRA 92
Lee v. Ilagan – 738 SCRA 59
Cam v. Almario, GR 212174, October 14, 2014
Zarate v. Aquino, III (supra.)
SECTION 4.
Prior Restraint
*Near v. Minnesota - 238 US 697 (malicious articles

against officials)
*Freedman v. Maryland - 380 US 51 (judicial
determination)
*New York Times Co. v. US - 403 US 713 (top secret
information)
Tolentino v. Sec. of Finance - GR 115444 October 30,
1995
Alexander v. US - 113 S. Ct. 2766, 125 L. Ed. 2d. 441
INC v. CA - GR 119673 July 26, 1996
David v. Arroyo – (supra)
Chavez v. Gonzales, GR No. 168338, Feb. 15, 2008
Newsounds v. Dy – 583 SCRA 333 (content-based
restraint)
GMA v. COMELEC – 734 SCRA 88 (supra.)
Subsequent punishment
*People v. Perez - 45 PHIL. 599 (dangerous tendency

rule)
*Dennis v. US - 341 US 494 (overthrow of
government)
39
Hazelwood School Dist. v. KUHLMEIER - 484 US
260
Fernando v. CA 510 SCRA 351
Assembly and petition

Speech and the Electoral Process
Navarro v. Villegas - 31 SCRA 73
Sanidad v. COMELEC - 181 SCRA 529 PBM Employees v. PBM - 51 SCRA 189
National Press Club v. COMELEC – 207 SCRA 1 JBL Reyes v. Mayor Bagatsing - 125 SCRA 553
*Adiong v. COMELEC - March 31, 1992 (election Malabanan v. Ramento - 129 SCRA 359
propaganda) Tolentino v. Sec. of Finance – (supra, Equal
RAOsmeña v. COMELEC – 288 SCRA 447 Protection) Acosta v. CA – 334 SCRA 486
ABS CBN v. COMELEC – 323 SCRA 811 *Bayan v. Ermita, GR 169838, April 29, 2006 (no
*SWS v. COMELEC –GR 147571, May 5, 2001 permit no rally and CPR)
(election surevey before election) Imbong v. Ochoa, Pader v. People, GR 139157, February 8, 2000
GR 204819, April 8, 2014 (RH Law) (supra Art III,
Sec 1)
*Diocese of Bacolod v. COMELEC, GR 2015728,
January 21, 2015
Ejercito v. COMELEC – 742 SCRA 210
*1-United v. COMELEC (supra.; read with Adiong)
*SWS v. COMELEC – 755 SCRA 124
*Davao City v. Aranjuez – 758 SCRA 235
Commercial Speech
*Rubin v. Coors Brewing - 131 L. Ed. 2d 532

(1995) (liquor labels)
Cincinnati v. Discovery Network - 123 L. Ed. 2d 99
(1993) (news racks; aesthetics) City of Ladue v.
Gilleo - 129 L. Ed. 2d 36 (1994) (sinage in house)
Disini v. Secretary of Justice, GR 203335, Feb. 18,
2014 (supra Art. 3, Sec. 1)
Unprotected Speech
Libel
*Policarpio v. Manila Times - 5 SCRA 148

(protected if true, and done in good faith)
*Lopez v. CA - 34 SCRA 116 (wrong picture of
person)
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan - 376 US 254
(public official – actual malice) Rosenbloom v.
Metromedia, Inc. - 403 US 29 (nudist magazines)
Gertz v. Robert Welch - 418 US 323 (private
person) Hustler v. Magazine - 485 US 46
In Re Jurado AM No. 90-5-2373, 4 LR 19 Aug’90
In Re Jurado - 243 SCRA 299 (articles about
corruption in judiciary)
Vasquez v. CA – GR 118971 September 15, 1999
Borjal v. CA – GR 126466 January 14, 1999
Vicario v. CA – GR 124491 June 1, 1999
Jalandoni v. Drilon, 327 SCRA 107(reiterates
Borjal)
Arafiles v. Philippine Journalists, Inc., 426 SCRA
336
Baguio Midland Courier v. CA, 444 SCRA 38
Obscenity
*Miller v. California - 37 L. Ed. 2d 419 (mailing of

adult materials)
*Gonzales v. Kalaw-Katigbak - 137 SCRA 717
(Obscene movie)
*Pita v. CA - 178 SCRA 362
Barnes v. Glen Theater - 498 US 439
F.C.C. v. Pacifica Foundation - 438 US 726
Renton v. Playtime Theater - 475 US 41
Bethel School Dist. v. Fraser - 478 US 675
40
Centeno v. Villaon-Pornillos – 236 SCRA 197
(fraudulent solicitations) Lee v. Weisman – U.S. No.
90-1014 June 24, 1992 (rabbi in graduation)
Church of the Lukumi v. City of Hialeach - No. 91-948
June 11, 1993 (animal sacrifice)
Lamb’s Chapel v. School District - No. 91-2024 June
7, 1993 (film series regarding values played in school
by religious institution)
Long v. Basa, G.R. No. 134963-64, September 27,
2001 (basis of religious organization is the belief)
INC v. CA, 259 SCRA 529 (remarks about the bible in
a TV show)
*Estrada v. Escritor, AM P-02-1651, August 4, 2003
and 429 SCRA 1 (court official with live-in partner;
benevolent neutrality)
In re Request Muslim Employees – 477 SCRA 648
Iglesia Filipino Independiente v. heirs of Taezo, G.R
179592, February 3, 2014
Romulo v. People – 728 SCRA 675
Diocese of Bacolod v. COMELEC, GR 205728,
SECTION 5. January 21, 2015
*Perfecto v. Esidra – 763 SCRA 323
Non-establishment of region
*Aglipay v. Ruiz - 64 PHIL. 201 (postage stamps

incidental benefit to religion)
*Garces v. Estenzo - 104 SCRA 510
School District v. Schempp – 10 L 2d 844 (reading of
bible)
*Board of Education v. Allen - 392 US 236 (providing
textbooks to schools)
*Lemon v. Kurtzman - 403 US 602 (salary subsidy to
teachers)
*Tilton v. Richardson - 403 US 672 (construction
grants to schools)
Country of Allegheny v. American Civil Liberties
Union - 57 LW 504 (government endorsement to
crèche and menorah)
Zobrest v. Catalina - No. 92-94 June 18, 1993 (aid to
deaf student in religious school) Capitol Square
Review Board v. Pinette & Ku Klux Klan – U.S. No.
94-780 June 29, 1995 (cross in public forum)
Manosca v. CA - 252 SCRA 412
Islamic Da’wah v. Executive Secretary – GR 153888,
July 9, 2003 (halal certification) Taruc v. de la Cruz –
453 SCRA 123
UCCP v. Bradford UCC – 674 SCRA 92 (SEC’s
authority)
Imbong v. Ochoa, GR 204819, April 8, 2014 (RH
Law) (supra Art III, Sec 1)
Free Exercise of Religion
*Victoriano v. Elizalde, 59 SCRA 94 (closed shop

agreements)
*Cantwell v. Connecticut - 310 US 296 (prior
restraint)
*US. v. Ballard - 322 US 78 (good faith in believing)
American Bible Society v. City of Manila - 104 PHIL.
386 (selling bibles)
*Ebralinag v. Division Superintendent - 219 SCRA
256 and (MR) December 29, 1995 (flag ceremony)
Wisconsin v. Yoder - 406 US 205 (Amish students not
required to go to school upon reaching 15)
Pamil v. Teleron - 86 SCRA 413
McDaniel v. Paty - 435 US 618
Goldman v. Weinberger - 54 LW 4298 (yarmulke in
military) German v. Baranganan - 135 SCRA 514
(rally in St. Jude Chapel) Tolentino v. Sec. of Finance
– (supra, Equal Protection)
41
Right to Form Association
TUCP v. NBC - 173 SCRA 33

SSS Employees v. CA – 175 SCRA 686
SECTION 6. *Manila Public School Teachers v. Laguio, Jr. – 200
SCRA 323
Liberty of Abode and Right to Travel UPCSU v. Laguesma – 288 SCRA 15
Sta. Clara Homeowners v. Gaston, 374 SCRA 396
*Villavicencio v. Lukban, 39 PHIL 778 (deported *Padcom v. Ortigas Center, GR 146807, May, 9, 2002
prostitutes) (automatic membership of buyer)
*Marcos v. Manglapus - 177 SCRA 668 (right to
return in the country not included)
Silverio v. CA - 195 SCRA 760
Santiago v. Vasquez - 217 SCRA 633
Marcos v. Sandiganbayan - 247 SCRA 127 SECTION 9.
*Yap v. C.A., G.R. No. 141529, June 6, 2001
(not disallowed, merely requiring certification Expropriation in General; Reversion
from Mayor prior to change of residence)
Mirasol v. DPWH (supra) Heirs of Alberto Suguitan v. City of Mandaluyong, GR
OAS v. Macarine – 677 SCRA 1 135087, March 14, 2000
Republic v. Roque, GR 204603, Sep. 24, 2013 (right NHA v. Heirs of Isidro Guivelondo, GR 15441, June
to travel and bail) (supra Art III, Sec 19, 2003
1) Mactan v. Lozada – 613 SCRA 618 (reversion)
Vda. De Ouna v. Republic – 642 SCRA 384
(reversion)
Power to Undertake Expropriation Case.
Iron and Steel Authority v. CA – 249 SCRA 538

SECTION 7. (substitution of the Republic) Philippine Press Institute
v. COMELEC - 244 SCRA 272
Information and Access to Official Records Telebap v. COMELEC – (supra, Equal Protection)
Estate of Heirs of the Late Ex-Justice JBL v. City of
*Legaspi v. CSC - 150 SCRA 530 (eligibility of Manila, 422 SCRA 551
sanitarians) Lagcao v. Labra, GR 155746, Oct 13, 2004
*Valmonte v. Belmonte, Jr. - 170 SCRA 256
Aquino-Sarmiento v. Morato - 203 SCRA 515 Rights of Owner Before Expropriation
Osmeña v. COMELEC – (supra, Speech and Electoral
Process) Echegaray v. Sec. of Justice – GR 132601 Greater Balanga v. Mun. of Balanga – 239 SCRA 436
October 12, 1988 (rights prior to expropriation) Velarma v. CA – 252
Chavez v. PCGG – GR 130716 December 9, 1988 SCRA 406
Gonzales v. Narvasa, GR 140835, August 14, 2000 Solanda v. CA – 305 SCRA 645 (ejectment before
Chavez v. PEA, GR 133250, July, 9, 2002 actual expropriation) Republic v. Salem - 334 SCRA
Hilado v. Reyes 496 - SCRA 282 320 (title not cancelled until paid)
Sabio v. Gordon 504 - SCRA 704
Bantay v. COMELEC – 523 SCRA 1 Elements of "Taking"
Berdin v. Mascarinas – 526 SCRA 592
Chang v. NHA – 530 SCRA 335 *Republic v. Vda. de Castelvi - 58 SCRA 336 (rent by
Neri v. Senate, GR 180643, March 25, 2008-09-23 and military; elements of taking) Garcia v. CA - 102
MR (executive privilege) Suplico v. NEDA, GR SCRA 597
178830, July 14, 2008 City Government v. Judge Ericta – 122 SCRA 759
Akbayan v. Aquino, GR 170516, July 16, 2008 *US v. Causby - 328 US 256 (navigable airspace)
(JEPEPA diplomatic negotiations) People v. Fajardo - 104 PHIL. 443
Province of North Cotabato v. GRP Panel, GR 183591, Republic v. PLDT - 26 SCRA 620 (capacity of govt to
October 14, 2008 (MOA- require PLDT to contract with them) NPC v. – 206
AD peace negotiations not exempted) SCRA 520
Guingona v. COMELEC – 620 SCRA 448 *Penn Central Transportation v. NY City - 438 US 104
(not taking, there is still control of the owner)
Antolin v. Domondon – 623 SCRA 163
Ruckelshaus v. Monsanto - 467 US 9
Center for People v. COMELEC – 631 SCRA 41
Francisco v. TRB – 633 SCRA 470
Initiatives v. PSALM – 682 SCRA 602
Privatization and Management Office v. Strategic
Alliance, GR 200402, June 13,
2013 (right and duty in relation to Article 2, Sec 28)
Cocofed v. COMELEC, GR 207026, August 6, 2013
*Sereno v. Committee, GR 175210, February 2, 2016
(minutes of EO486)
SECTION 8.
42
NPC v. Manubay – 437 SCRA 60 Heirs of Spouses Tria v. Land Bank, GR 170245,
NPC v. San Pedro - 503 SCRA 333 July 1, 2013
NPC v. Tiangco – 514 SCRA 674 DPWH v. Spouses Tecson, GR 179334, July 1, 2013
LBP v. Imperial – 515 SCRA 449 (FMV at taking) (supra Art II, Sec 1) NPC v.
NPC v. Bongbong – 520 SCRA 290 YCLA, GR 193936, December 11, 2013 (FMV at
Tan v. Republic – 523 SCRA 203 taking)
NPC v. Ibrahim – 526 SCRA 149 NPC v. Zabala – 689 SCRA 554 (Judicial function)
NPC v. Purefoods – 565 SCRA 17 (right of way for LBP v. Gallego – 702 SCRA 377 (prompt payment)
transmission lines) NPC v. Capin – 569 SCRA 648 *Republic v. BPI – 705 SCRA 650 (consequential
(right of way for transmission lines) PNOC v. damages proper if other property impaired)
Maglasang – 570 SCRA 560 (lease not basis for *NPC v. Manalastas, GR 196140, January 27, 2016
taking)
NPC v. Co – 578 SCRA 243 (right of way for Judicial Review
transmission lines) NPC v. Villamor – 590 SCRA 11
(right of way for transmission lines) NPC v. *De Knecht v. Bautista - 100 SCRA 660 (EDSA
Maruhom – 609 SCRA 198 (right of way for extension ; social impact)
transmission lines) *Manotoc v. NHA - 150 SCRA 89 (
*OSG v. Ayala – 600 SCRA 617 (free parking
spaces in malls)
NPC v. Tuazon – 653 SCRA 84 (right of way for
transmission lines) Cabahug v. NPC – 689 SCRA
666 (right of way for transmission lines)
"Public Use"
*Sumulong v. Guerrero - 154 SCRA 461 (housing is

for public use)
*Phil. Columbian Assn. v. Hon. Panis – 228 SCRA
668 (housing project) Manosca v. CA – 252 SCRA
412
Province of Camarines Sur v. CA – 222 SCRA 173
Reyes v. NHA, GR 147511, Jan. 20, 2003
Masikip v. Pasig 479 SCRA 391
Didipio v. Earth Savers v. Gozun 485 SCRA 586
Barangay v. CA – 518 SCRA 649
Manapat v. CA – 536 SCRA 32
Mactan v. Tudtud – GR 174012, November 14,
2008
City of Manila v. Tan Te – 658 SCRA 88 (socialized
housing)
Just Compensation
*City of Manila v. Estrada - 25 PHIL. 208 (judicial

review of just compensation) Manila Railroad v.
Paredes - 31 PHIL. 118
Municipality of Daet v. CA - 129 SCRA 665
NPC v. CA - 129 SCRA 665
EPZA v. Dulay - 149 SCRA 305
Maddumba v. GSIS - 182 SCRA 281
Berkenkotter v. CA – 216 SCRA 584
Meralco v. Pineda – 206 SCRA 196
NPC v. CA – 254 SCRA 577
Land Bank v. CA – 249 SCRA 149 and (MR) 258
SCRA 404
Panes v. VISCA – 264 SCRA 708
Republic v. CA – 263 SCRA 758
NPC v. Henson – GR 129998 December 29, 1998
Santos v. Landbank, GR 137431, Sept. 7, 2000
(CARL, payment not in cash) Sigre v. CA, GR
109568, Aug. 8, 2002 (CARL, just compensation)
NHA v. Heirs of Isidro Guivelondo, GR 154411,
June 19, 2003
CIR v. Central Luzon 492 SCRA 575
CIR v. Bicolandia 496 SCRA 176
Mactan v. Urgello – 520 SCRA 515
*San Roque v. Republic – 532 SCRA 493
Sy v. Local Govt of Quezon City, GR 202690, June
5, 2013
Cortes v. Ombudsman, GR 187896-97, June 10,
2013
43
*Republic v. De Knecht - 182 SCRA 141 (EDSA
extension) Militante v. CA, GR 107040, Apr. 12,
2000
END OF GROUP 2 REPORT
START OF GROUP 3 REPORT
SECTION 10.
*Home Building and Loan Assn. v. Blaisell -

290 US 398 (extended mortgage redemption)
*Rutter v. Esteban - 93 PHIL. 68 (unreasonable
delay of 8 years) Del Rosario v. Delos Santos - L-
20589-90
*Abella v. NLRC - 152 SCRA 140
Phil. Vet. Bank Employees v. Phil Vet. Bank - 189
SCRA 14
*Presley v. Bel-Air Village Asso. - 201 SCRA 13
(commercial zone) Tolentino v. Sec. of Finance - 235
SCRA 630 (supra, Equal Protection) Siska
Development v. Office of the President - 231 SCRA
674
Philconsa v. Enriquez - 235 SCRA 506
*Miners Association v. Factoran - 240 SCRA 100
Lim v. Pacquing - 240 SCRA 649
*Ortigas v. Feati Bank – 94 SCRA 533
Juarez v. CA – 214 SCRA 475
FPIB v. CA - 252 SCRA 259
CMMA v. POEA - 243 SCRA 666
PNB v. O.P. - 252 SCRA 5
Eugenio v. Drilon - 252 SCRA 106
JMM v. CA – (supra, Substantive)
C & M Timber v. Alcala – 273 SCRA 402
Republic v. Agana – 269 SCRA 1
Producers v. NLRC – GR 118069 November 16, 1998
Blaquera v. Alcala – GR 109406 September 11, 1998
Meralco v. Province of Laguna, 306 SCRA 750
City Government v. Reyes – GR 127708 March 25,
1999
Harrison Motors Corp v. Navarro, GR 132269, April
27, 2000
Bardillon v. Brgy. Masili, GR 146886, Apr. 30, 2003
Philreca v. Sec. of DILG, GR 143076, June 10, 2003
Republic v. Rosemoor Mining and Development Corp,
426 SCRA 517
Chavez v. COMELEC, 437 SCRA 415
Alvarez v. PICOP 508 SCRA 498
Lepanto v. WMC 507 SCRA 315
Republic v. Caguioa – 536 SCRA 193
Land Bank v. Republic – 543 SCRA 453
Serrano v. Gallant – 582 SCRA 254
Alvarez v. PICOP – 606 SCRA 444
Surigao v. ERC – 632 SCRA 96
Hacienda Luisita v. PARC – 653 SCRA 154
Goldenway Merchandising Corp v. Equitable PCI, GR
195540, March 13, 2013
Pryce Corp v. China Banking Corp, GR 172302, Feb
18, 2014
Victorio v. Pacific Plans, GR 193108, December 10,
2014 (reiterates Pryce)
*SWS v. COMELEC (supra.)
44
SECTION 11. FREE ACCESS TO COURT
Re: Letter Dated April 18, 2011 of Chief Public Atty

Acosta requesting exemption from payment of
sheriff’s expenses, AM 11-10-03-O, July 30, 2013,
(sheriff’s expenses as hindrance to access to court)
SECTION 12.
I. Custodial Investigation, In General
A. Definition
People Pavillare, GR 129970, April 5, 2000

People v. Bandula - 232 SCRA 566
Navallo v. Sandiganbayan - 234 SCRA 175
Sebastian v. Garchitorena, GR 114028, October 18,
2000
OCA v. Sumulong, 271 SCRA 316
People v. Almanzor, GR 124918, July 11, 2002 (no
need for counsel) People v. Valdez, GR 129296,
September 25, 2000
People v. Marra - 236 SCRA 565
People v. Labtan, G.R. No. 127493, December 8, 1999
Manuel v. NC Construction – 282 SCRA 326
People v. de la Cruz, GR 137405, Sept. 27, 2002
*People v. Camat- 256 SCRA 52
People v. Evangelista - 256 SCRA 611
People v. Andan – 269 SCRA 95
People v. Artellero, GR 129211, October 2, 2000
People v. De Jesus – 213 SCRA 345
People v. Legaspi, GR 117802, April 27, 2000
B. Rationale
*Miranda v. Arizona 384 US 436 (Miranda Rights)

People v. Canton, GR 148825, Dec. 27, 2002
II. Instances of Custodial Investigations
People v. Lim - 196 SCRA 809

People v. Bolanos – 211 SCRA 262
People v. Salazar – 266 SCRA 607
45
People v. Bandula - 232 SCRA 566
People v. Isla- 278 SCRA 47
People v. Jimenez - 204 SCRA 719
People v. Castro – 274 SCRA 115 People v. Cortes, 323 SCRA 131
People v. Isla- 278 SCRA 47 People v. Rous - 242 SCRA 732
People v. Casimiro, GR 146277, June 20, 2002 People v. Espanola – 271 SCRA 689
People v.Zuela - 325 SCRA 589
III. Miranda Rights Safeguarded by the Bill of People v. Macabalang - 508 SCRA 282
Rights in Relation to Custodial Investigations *Tanenggee v. People – 699 SCRA 639
A. Procedural Requirements c. Effective and Vigilant Counsel Defined
Miranda v. Arizona- 384 US 436 (supra.)

People v. Mahinay – GR 122485 February 1, 1999
People v. Camat - 256 SCRA 52
B. Duty of an Officer During Custodial

Investigation

People v. Salcedo – 273 SCRA 473
C. When the Rights of Custodial Investigation May

Be Invoked
People v. Loveria - 187 SCRA 47

2000
People v. Tan – 286 SCRA 207
D. The Right to Remain Silent
People v. Bandin – 226 SCRA 299

People v. Lacbanes – 270 SCRA 193
People v. Morico – 246 SCRA 214
People v. Ang Chun Kit – 251 SCRA 660
People v. De Las Marinas – 196 SCRA 504
People v. Castro – 274 SCRA 115
People v. Enriquez – 204 SCRA 674
E. The Right to Counsel
a. When to Invoke
People v. Sunga, GR 126029, Mar. 29, 2003 (city legal

officer) People v. Labtan, G.R. No. 127493, December
8, 1999
People v. Sapal, GR 124526, March 17, 2000
People v. Lamsing - 248 SCRA 471
People v. Maqueda - 242 SCRA 565
People v. Macam – 238 SCRA 306
People v. De Jesus – 213 SCRA 345
People v. Dimaano – 209 SCRA 819
People v. Compil - 244 SCRA 135
b. When Presence of Counsel is Required
People v. Rodriguez - 232 SCRA 227 – artellero and

rodriguez was convicted of murder; extrajudicial
confession of co-appellant Rodriguez of artillero’s
conspiracy; they were brought to police at 5pm,
rodriguez’ confession was taken at 2pm of the 4 days
later. Atty was called only on the fourth day whn
accused was already investigated and made the
confession. 4 fundamental requisites f admissibility of
confession. When they were arrested, they were
already the suspects, so custodial investigation insued,
hence, the right to invoke right to counsel.requisite
number 2 was lacking.
Estacio v. Sandiganbayan – 183 SCRA 12
46
i. Failure to Object to Confession Made
Without Counsel
People v. Gonzales, GR 142932, May 29, 2002
*People v. Sunga, GR 126029, Mar. 29, 2003 (city
legal officer) People v. Velarde, GR 139333, July
18, 2002
People v. Culala, GR 83466, October 13, 1999
People v. Gerolago – 263 SCRA 143
People v. Paule – 261 SCRA 649
People v. Delmo, GR 130078, Oct. 4, 2002
People v. Lucero - 249 SCRA 425
People v. Espanola – 271 SCRA 689
People v. Bacor – GR 122895 April 30, 1999
People v. Sahagun – 274 SCRA 208
People v. Taliman, GR 109143, October 11, 2000
People v. Espiritu – GR 128287 February 2, 1999
People v. Barasina - 229 SCRA 450
People v. Alegria - 190 SCRA 122
People v. Suarez – 267 SCRA 119
People v. Parojinog - 203 SCRA 673
People v. Baello – 224 SCRA 218
Galman v. Pamaran – 138 SCRA 295
People v. Jerez – 285 SCRA 393
People v. Ranis, GR 129113, Sept. 17, 2002
People v. Dumalahay, 380 SCRA 37
People v. Pamon – 217 SCRA 501
People v. Cabiles – 284 SCRA 199
People v. Gallardo, 323 SCRA 318
People v. Base, GR 109773, March 30, 2000
People v. Obrero, GR 122142, May 17, 2000
Cariaga v. People – 626 SCRA 231
*People v. Ibañez – 698 SCRA 161 (duty of counsel
to explain)
d. Independence
People v. Porio, 376 SCRA 596
e. Competence
People v. Suela, supra, 373 SCRA 163
f. Assistance After Start of Custodial

Investigation
People v. Matigunas, 379 SCRA 56
People v. Suela, supra.
g. Valid Confession with Counsel

People v. Tablon, 379 SCRA 280
People v. Principe, GR 135862, May 2, 2002
People v. Oranza, GR 127748, July 25, 2002
People v. Canicula, GR 131802, Aug. 6, 2002
Tangengge v. People, GR 179448, June 26,
2013 (proscription applicable only in custodial
investigation)
Manila Water Compant v. Rosario, GR 188747,
January 29, 2014 (administrative investigation)
h. Confession Without Counsel

People v. Casimiro, GR 146277, June 20, 2002
People v. Ochate, GR 127154, July 30, 2002
People v. Mendez, GR 147671, Nov. 21, 2002
(reiterates P. v. Morada) People v. Lauga – 615
SCRA 548
Lumanog v. People – 630 SCRA 42
People v. Tumaco – 610 SCRA 350l
People v. Bokingo – 655 SCRA 313
People v. Uy – 649 SCRA 236
People v. Bokingo – 655 SCRA 313
People v. Uy – 649 SCRA 236
People v. Soriano – 693 SCRA 404
47
People v. Tamayo, GR 137856, July, 30, 2002
People v. Samus, GR 135957, Sept. 17, 2002
People v. Mole, GR 137366, Nov. 27, 2003
j. Right to Be Informed
People v. Manriquez, GR 122510-11, March 17, 2000

Magtoto v. Manguera - 63 SCRA 4
People v. Camat- 256 SCRA 52
People v. Sabban – 260 SCRA 630
People v. Barlis - 231 SCRA 426
People v. Samolde, GR 128551, July 31, 2000
People v. Sevilla, GR 124077, September 5, 2000
People v. Muleta – GR 130189 June 25, 1999
People v. Tizon, GR 133228, July 30, 2002
People v. Llenaresas - 248 SCRA 629
People v. Cajara, GR 122498, September 27, 2000
People v. Manriquez, GR 122510-11, March 17, 2000
People v. Samolde, GR 128551, July 31, 2000
IV. Waiver of Rights
A. Requisites of a Valid Waiver
a. Must Be in Writing and in the Presence of

Counsel
People v. Taliman, GR 109143, October 11, 2000
People v. Gomez – 270 SCRA 432
People v. Cabintoy – 247 SCRA 442
People v. Corullo – 289 SCRA 481
People v. Olivarez – GR 77865 December 4, 1998
People v. Ruelan - 231 SCRA 650
Malacat v. CA – (supra, Warrantless Arrests) People v.
Bacor, 306 SCRA 522
People v. Quidato – GR 117160 or 6 October 1, 1998
b. Must Be Voluntary, Knowing and Intelligent
People v. Nicolas - 204 SCRA 191

V. Extrajudicial Confessions
A. Difference Between Admission and Confession
Ladiana v. People, GR 144293, Dec. 4, 2002

People v. Maqueda - 242 SCRA 565
B. Requisites for Valid Extrajudicial Confession
People v. Dano, GR 117690, September 1, 2000

People v. Pagaura – 267 SCRA 17
People v. Calvo – 269 SCRA 676
People v. Tan – 286 SCRA 207
People v. Olivarez – GR 77865 December 4
People v. Base, GR 109773, March 30, 2000
People v. Continente, GR 100801-02, August 25, 2000
People v. Naag, 322 SCRA 710
People v. Fabro – 277 SCRA 19
People v. Sinoc – 275 SCRA 357
People v. Alicando - 251 SCRA 293
People v. Maneng, GR 123147, October 13, 2000
People v. Llanes, GR 140268, September 18, 2000
48
Navallo v. Sandiganbayan - 234 SCRA 175
Kimpo v. Sandiganbayan - 232 SCRA 53
People v. Deang, GR 128045, August 24, 2000 D. Administrative Investigation

People v. Espanola – 271 SCRA 689
People v. Nicolas, GR 135877, Aug. 22, 2002
People v. Sabalones – 294 SCRA 751
People v. Mahinay, 302 SCRA 455
People v. Obrero, GR 122142, May 17, 2000
People v. Capitle – 639 SCRA 373
Jesalva v. People – 640 SCRA 253
People v. Capitle – 639 SCRA 373
C. Voluntariness
People v. Santos – 283 SCRA 443
People v. Alvarez, GR 140388-91, Nov. 11, 2003
Astudillo v. People - 509 SCRA 302
Jesalva v. People – 640 SCRA 253
D. Presumptions
People v. Maneng, GR 123147, October 13, 2000
People v. Vallejo, GR 144656, May 9, 2002
People v. Sahagun – 274 SCRA 208
People v. Sabban – 260 SCRA 630
People v. Ranis, GR 129113, Sept. 17, 2002
People v. Rous - 242 SCRA 732
People v. Parojinog - 203 SCRA 673
People v. Montiero – 246 SCRA 786
People v. Ruelan - 231 SCRA 650
People v. Aquino – GR 123550-51 July 19, 1999
People v. Tolentino, 423 SCRA 448
People v. De Vera, G.R. No. 128966, August 18, 1999
People v. Santos – 283 SCRA 443
Santos v. Sandiganbayan, GR 71523-25, December 8,
2000
People v. Magdamit – 279 SCRA 423
People v. Aquino, GR 130742, July 18, 2000
People v. Hernandez – (supra, Warrantless Arrests)
People v. Sabalones – 294 SCRA 751
People v. Calvo – 269 SCRA 676
People v. del Rosario, G.R. No. 131036, June 20, 2001
E. To Whom Such Confession Can Be Used

Against
Santos v. Sandiganbayan, GR 71523-25, December 8,
2000
Tan v. People, G.R. No. 134298, August 26, 1999
F. Lawyer Given by Police Investigator; Valid

Confession
Aquino v. Paiste, 555 S 255
G. Exceptions
VI. When Custodial Investigations May Not

Apply
A. Preliminary Investigation
People v. Judge Ayson - 175 SCRA 216
B. Voluntary Surrender
People v. Taylaran – 108 SCRA 373
*People v. Chavez – 735 SCRA 728
C. Audit Examination
49
M. Incident to a Lawful Arrest
People v. Enriquez – 204 SCRA 674
Marcelo v. Sandiganbayan – GR 109242 January 26,
Manuel v. NC Construction – 282 SCRA 326 1999
Remolona v. Civil Service Commission, G.R.
No.13747, August 2, 2001
2000
Escleo v. Durado, AM no. P-99-1312, July 31, 2002
Anonymous Complaint against Lyn Maceda – 720
SCRA 27
Luspo v. People - 739 SCRA 133
De Castro v. People - GR 171672, February 2, 2015
E. Not in Police Custody

People v. Tobias – 266 SCRA 229
OCA v. Sumulong, 271 SCRA 316
F. Police Line-up
General Rule
People v. Piedad, GR 131923, Dec. 5, 2002 (no need
for counsel) People v. Lamsing – 248 SCRA 471
People v. Frago - 232 SCRA 653
*Gamboa v. Judge Cruz - 162 SCRA 675
People v. Salvatierra – 276 SCRA 55 (supra,
Warrantless Arrests) Dela Torre v. CA – 294 SCRA
196
People Pavillare, GR 129970, April 5, 2000
People v. Timple - 237 SCRA 52
People v. Dimaano – 209 SCRA 819
People v. Tolentino, 423 SCRA 448
People v. Martinez, 425 SCRA 525
People v. Sultan, GR 130594, July 5, 2000
People v. Escordial, 373 SCRA 585 (line- up after
custodial investigation starts, requires counsel)
Exceptions
People v. Hatton – 210 SCRA 1
People v. Gamer, 326 SCRA 660
People v. Teehankee, Jr. – 249 SCRA 54 (supra,
Procedural) People v. Meneses – 288 SCRA 95
G. Spontaneous Statements
People v. Barrientos – 285 SCRA 221
Arroyo v, CA - 203 SCRA 750
People v. Dumantay, 307 SCRA 1
People v. Morada – GR 129723 May 19, 1999
People v. Ulit, 423 SCRA 374
H. Marked Money
*People v. Linsangan – 195 SCRA 784
I. Booking Sheets
*People v. Ang Chun Kit – 251 SCRA 660
J. Paraffin Test
People v. Gamboa – 194 SCRA 372
K. When Body of the Accused is Examined

People v. Sinoc – 275 SCRA 357
People v. Piedad, GR 131923, Dec. 5, 2002 (no need
for counsel) Gutang v. People, GR 135406, July 11,
2000
People v. Paynor – 256 SCRA 611
L. Taking of Pictures
People v. Gallarde, 325 SCRA 835
50
People v. Lumandong, 327 SCRA 650
VII. The Exclusionary Rule

A. Violation of Rights
People v. Hermoso, GR 130590, October 18, 2000
People v. Pinlac - 165 SCRA 675
People v. Bacamante - 248 SCRA 47
People v. Montes – GR 117166 December 13, 1998
People v. Salcedo – 273 SCRA 473
People v. Macoy – 275 SCRA 1
People v. Arceo - 202 SCRA 170
People v. Atrejenio – GR 120160 July 13, 1999
Tan v. People, G.R. No. 134298, August 26, 1999
People v. Binamira – 277 SCRA 232
People v. Turingan – 282 SCRA 424
People v. Pagaura – 267 SCRA 17
People v. Quidato – GR 117401 October 1, 1998
People v. Sequino – 264 SCRA 79
People v. Paglinawan, 324 SCRA 97
People v. Bravo, GR 13562
People v. Bariquit, GR 122733, October 2, 2000
People v. Malimit – 264 SCRA 167
People v. Rivera – 245 SCRA 421
People v. Meneses – 288 SCRA 95
People v. Paburada, GR 137118, December 5, 2000
People v. Lapitaje, GR 132042, Feb. 19, 2003
B. Immunity against Self-Incrimination

Galman v. Pamaran – (supra, Custodial Investigation)
C. Re-enactments
People v. Suarez – 267 SCRA 119
D. Applicability to Aliens
People v. Wong Chuen Ming - 256 SCRA 182
E. Verbal Confessions
People v. Deniego – 251 SCRA 626
People v. Bonola – 274 SCRA 238
People v. Suela, 373 SCRA 163 (confession to private
party) People v. Taboga, 376 SCRA 500 (confession to
private party) People v. Baloloy, GE 140740, Apr. 12,
2002 (res gestae) People v. Guillermo, 420 S 326
Guting v. People – 770 SCRA 334
F. Co-Accused not Bound

G. Who May Raise the Question

People v. Balisteros - 237 SCRA 499
H. When Must the Objection Be Raised

People v. Samus, GR 135957, Sept. 17, 2002
People v. Montilla – 285 SCRA 703
People v. Salvatierra – 276 SCRA 55
Gamboa v. Judge Cruz - 162 SCRA 675
*Macasiray v. People – 291 SCRA 154
I. Admissible Evidence
People v. Espiritu, 302 SCRA 533
51
VIII. Rights After Custodial Investigation
People v. De Guzman - 194 SCRA 191
52
3
(
1
SECTION13. 0
g
RighttoBail u
i
Lavidesv. CA,324SCRA321 d
Peoplev. e
Gako,GR135045,December15,2000 l
*Yapv.CA,GR1 i
41529,June6,20 n
01(excessiveife e
qualtocivilliabil s
ity) Fortunav. )
Sitaca,AMNo.R
TJ-01- C
1633,June19,20 h
01 u
JinggoyEstradav.Sandiganbayan,G. v
R.No.148965,February26,2002 .
Gov’tof D
USAv.HonPurganan,GR148571,Se o
pt.24,2002 l
Serapiov. a
Sandiganbayan,GR148468,Jan.28,2 l
003 o
*Gov’tof s
Hongkongv.Hon.Olalia,A –
pril19,2007 2
(righttobailinextraditionca 6
ses) 0
Peoplev.Sandiganbayan– S
529SCRA764 C
*Enrilev. Sandiganbayan– R
GR213847,August18,2015 A
3
WaiveroftheRight 0
9
Peoplev. Magsucangv.JudgeBalgos,AMno.M
JudgeDonato&RodolfoSalas– TJ-02-142,Feb.27,2003
198SCRA130
Peoplev. Mapalao-197SCRA79 RighttoBailofMilitaryPersonnel
ExcessiveBail Commendadorv.Gen.de Villa -

200SCRA80
*
D AspectsoftheRighttoBail
e
L Sulev. Biteng-AMMTJ-95-
a 1018,243SCRA524
C Paderangav.CA–247 SCRA741
a Asst.ProvincialProsecutorChin v.
m JudgeGustilo,etal.AMNo- RTJ-94-
a 1243,247SCRA
r 175
a Peoplev. Nitcha–240SCRA283
. Padillav. CA –260SCRA155
v Paradav.Veneracion–269SCRA371
. Obosav.CA–266SCRA281
E Moslaresv.CA–291SCRA440
n Catiisv. CA482SCRA71
a
g
e SECTION14.
-
4 DueProcess
1
S Peoplev.
C Boras,GR127495,December22,200
R 0
A Peoplev.
53
Horio,GR137842,August23,2001
MilitaryTribunal
Olaguerv. Military-150SCRA144
Tanv.Barrios-190SCRA685
Presumptionofinnocence
*UnitedStatesv.Luling-
324PHIL.725
Peoplev. Mingoa-92PHIL.856
*Dumlaov.COMELEC-95
SCRA392
Pamintuanv. People-234SCRA63
Marquezv. COMELEC–
243SCRA538
54
d
e
Hizonv.CA–265SCRA517 n
Peoplev. c
Caranguian,GR124514,July6,2000 e
Peoplev.
Aquino,GR130742,July18,2000 Maliwatv. CA-256SCRA718
Peoplev. Peoplev. Buemio–265SCRA582
Guillermo,GR111292,July20,2000 Peoplev. Ramilla–
Peoplev. GR127485July19,1999
Balacano,GR127156,July31,2000 Marquezv. Sandiganbayan–
Peoplev. 641SCRA175
Mansueto,GR135196,July31,2000
Sorianov. RighttoCounsel
Angeles,GR109920,August31,2000
Peoplev. *Peoplev.Holgado-86 PHIL.752
Fajardo,GR128583,November22,2000 Unitedv. Ash-413U. S. 300
Ruedav.Sandiganbayan,GR129064,N Peoplev. Rio–201 SCRA702
ovember29,2000 Salawv.NLRC-202SCRA7
Peoplev. Carillov. People-229SCRA386
Baulite,G.R.No.137599,October8,200 Peoplev. Macagaling-237SCRA299
1 DeGuzmanv.Sandiganbayan-256
Ruzolv. Sandiganbayan,GR186739- SCRA171
960,April17,2013 Peoplev. Cuizon-256SCRA329
Aguilarv. Peoplev. Cabodoc–263SCRA187
DOJ,GR197522,Sept.11,2013 Peoplev. Echegaray–267 SCRA682
Peoplev. Reyesv. CA –267SCRA543
Cadidi,GR191 Peoplev. Serzo–274SCRA553
263,October1 Dansv.People–285SCRA504
6,2013(supra Amionv. Chiongson–AMNo.RTJ-97-
ArtIII, Sec2) 1371January22,1999
Peoplev. Peoplev. Ambray–
Atienza,GR19 GR127177February25,1999
1756,Novemb Peoplev. Bolatete–
er25,2013 GR127570February25,1999
Peoplev. delaCuesta–
GR126134March2,1999
R Peoplev. Lakindanum–
i GR127123March10,1999
g Peoplev. Cantos–
h GR129298April14,1999
t Peoplev. Alba–GR131858-
t 59April14,1999
o Peoplev. Onabia–
B GR128288April20,1999
e Peoplev. Bermas–
H GR120420April21,1999
e Peoplev. Pedres–
a GR129533April30,1999
r Peoplev. Acala–GR127023-
d 25May19,1999
a Peoplev. Puertollano–
n GR122423June17,1999
d Peoplev. Bonghanoy–
t GR124097June17,1999
o Peoplev. Larena–GR121205-
P 09June29,1999
r Peoplev. Nuñez–
o GR128875July8,1999
d Peoplev. Ramilla–
u GR127485July19,1999
c Peoplev.
t Sesbreno,G.R.No.121764,September8
i ,1999
o Peoplev.
n Santoclides,G.R.No.109149,Decembe
o r21,1999
f Peoplev.
Salonga,G.R.No.131131,June21,2001
E Peoplev. Bagas,G.R.No.
v 104383,July12,2001
i Peoplev.
55
Liwanag,G.R.No.120468,August15,2
001
Peoplev. Bernas,377SCRA391
Peoplev.
Caralipio,GR137766,Nov.27,2002
Sia v. People504SCRA507
Brionesv. People–588SCRA362
Villanuevav. People–644SCRA356
AbsenceofViolation
Peoplev.
Aquino,GR129288,March30,2000
56
Peoplev. Espejon,377SCRA412
Peoplev. Lavador,377SCRA424
Villanuevav.People,GR135098,April1 Peoplev. Hermanes,379SCRA190
2,2000 Peoplev. Portugal,379 SCRA212
Peoplev. Baluya,380SCRA533
Presenceof Violation Peoplev. Arofo,380SCRA663
Peoplev. Cana,GR139229,June6,2002
Peoplev. Nadera,324SCRA490 Peoplev.
Callanganv. People493SCRA269 Soriano,GR135027,July3,2002
Peoplev.
RighttoBeInformed Radam,GR138395,July18,2002
Peoplev.
*Peoplev.Regala–113SCRA613 Abala,GR135858,July,23,2002
Enrilev. Salazar-186SCRA217 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Taguba-229 SCRA188 Romero,GR137037,Aug.5,2002
Peoplev. Barte-230SCRA401 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Vitor-245SCRA392 Magtibay,GR142985,Aug.6,2002
Sabinianov.CA–249SCRA24 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Reyes-242SCRA264 Miclat,GR137024,Aug.7,2002
Peoplev. Legaspi-246SCRA206 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Ramos-245SCM405 Guardian,GR142900,Aug.7,2002
Peoplev. Namayan-246SCRA646 Peoplev.
Pechov. People–262SCRA518 Ocampo,GR145303,Aug.7,2002
Peoplev. Laurente-255SCRA543
Peoplev. Rosare–264SCRA398
Peoplev. Evangelista-256 SCRA611
Peoplev. Cruz–259SCRA109
Peoplev. DeGuzman–265SCRA228
SaludImson-Souwehav.Rondez–
279SCRA258
Peoplev. Manansala–273SCRA502
Peoplev. Palomar–278SCRA114
Peoplev. Ortega–276SCRA166
Peoplev. Antido–278SCRA425
Peoplev. Sadiosa–290SCRA92
Peoplev. Villamor–
GR12444October7,1998
Peoplev. Rosare–264SCRA398
Peoplev. Llaguno–285SCRA124
Peoplev. Bugayong–
GR126518December2,1998
Peoplev. Manalili–294SCRA220
Peoplev. Dimapilis–
GR128619December17,1998
Peoplev. deGuzman–289SCRA470
Peoplev. Quitlong–292SCRA360
Peoplev. Perez–
GR122764September24,1998
Peoplev. Renido–288 SCRA369
Peoplev. Venerable–290SCRA15
Peoplev. Lozano–
GR125080September25,1998
Peoplev. Padilla–
GR126124January20,1999
Peoplev.
Acosta,G.R.No.142726,October17,20
01
Peoplev. de la PenaG.R.No.138358-
59Nov.19,2001
Peoplev.
Abino,G.R.No.137288,December11,2
001
Peoplev. Tan,GR116200-
02,June21,2001
Peoplev. Tagana,GR137608-
09,July6,2001
Peoplev.
Alcalde,GR139225,May29,2002
Peoplev.
Mejeca,GR146425,Nov.21,2002
Peoplev. Esurina,374,SCRA429
Peoplev. Togud,375SCRA291
57
Jacov. People–689SCRA276
Pielagov. People0 693SCRA476
Peoplev. Peoplev. Manansala–695SCRA70
delAyre,GR139788,Oct.3,2002 Espinov. People–700SCRA570
Peoplev. Sevillav. People–732SCRA687
Caliso,GR131475,Oct.14,2002 Peoplev.
Peoplev. ChiChanLiu,GR189272,January21,20
Buado,GR137341,Oct.28,2002 15
Peoplev.
Alemania,GR146221,Nov.13,2002
Peoplev.
Terible,GR140635,Nov.18,2002 Relationship
Peoplev.
Victor,GR127904,Dec.5,2002 Peoplev. Cepedon,542S 550
Peoplev. Velasquez,377SCRA219 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Talan,GR177354,November14,2009
Lachica,GR143677,May9,2002 Peoplev. Estrada–610SCRA222
Peoplev. Peoplev. Corpuz–577SCRA465
Sajolga,GR146684,Aug.21,2002 *
Peoplev. P
Ramos,GR142577,Dec.27,2002 e
Peoplev. o
Mascarinas,GR144034,May28,2002 p
Peoplev. Sanchez,375SCRA355 l
Peoplev. e
Abayon,GR142874,July,31,2002 v
Peoplev. .
Gavina,GR143237,Oct.28,2002 R
Peoplev. e
Orbita,GRGR136591,July11,2002 g
Dadov. i
People,GR131421,Nov.18,2002 n
Santosv. o
People,GR14761,Jan.20,2002 –
Peoplev. Bon,GR149199,Jan.28,2003 5
Peoplev. 8
Llanto,GR146458,Jan.20,2003 2
Peoplev. S
Migrante,GR147606,Jan.14,2003 C
Peoplev. Dy,GR115326- R
37,Jan.16,2003 A
Peoplev. 1
Lapitaje,GR132042,Feb.19,2003 8
Peoplev. 9
Ostia,GR131804,Feb.26,2003
Peoplev. NatureofOffense:DifferentOffense;
Ganete,GR142930,Mar.28,2003 SameOffense;
Garciav.
People,GR144785,Sept.11,2003 Peoplev. Paglinawan,324SCRA97
Peoplev. Peoplev. Paramil,GR128056-
Villanueva,GR138364,Oct.15,2003 57,March31,2000
Burgosv. Evangelistav. People,GR108135-
Sandiganbayan,GR123144,Oct.15,200 36,August14,2000
3 Peoplev. Puzon,GR123156-
Peoplev. 59,August29,2000
Rote,GR146188,Dec.11,2003 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Rata,GR145523- Valdesancho,G.R.NO.137051-
24,Dec.11,2003 52,May30,2001
Andayav.People493SCRA539 Peoplev.
Peoplev. Estrada–583SCRA302 Dawisan,G.R.No.122095,September1
Peoplev.Abella–610 SCRA19 3,2001
Peoplev.Pangilinan– Mapasv. People,544SCRA85
GR183090,November14,2011 Pactolinv.
Senadorv. Sandiganbayan,554SCRA136
People,GR201620,March6,2013 Peoplev. Hu,567SCRA697
Neriv. Sevillav. People–732SCRA687
Sandiganbayan,GR202243,August7,2 Peoplev. ChiChanLiu–745SCRA476
013
Disiniv.Sandiganbayan,GR169823-
24,September11,2013
Senadorv.
People,GR201620,March6,2013
58
Peoplev.Watimar,GR121651-
52,August16,2000
END OF GROUP 4 REPORT Peoplev.
Gabiana,GR123543,August23,2000
START OF GROUP 5 REPORT Peoplev.
BanihitGR132045,August25,2000
Peoplev.
AbsenceofQualifyingCircumstance
Gutierrez,GR132772,August31,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Villanueva,GR135330,August31,2000
Ronato,G.R.No.124298,October11,19
Peoplev. Melendres,GR133999-
99
4001,August31,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Bayron,G.R.No.122732,September7,1
Mendez,GR132546,July5,2000
999
Peoplev. Alarcon,GR133191-
Peoplev.
93,July11,2000
Abella,G.R.No.131847,September22,
Peoplev.
1999
Baybado,GR132136,July14,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Gallo,G.R.No.124736,September29,1
Surilla,GR129164,July24,2000
999
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Campaner,GR130500,July26,2000
Panique,G.R.No.125763,October13,1
Peoplev.
999
Balacano,GR127156,July31,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Villaraza,GR131848-
Aguinaldo,G.R.No.130784,October3,
50,September5,2000
1999
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Baniguid,GR137714,September8,200
Tabion,G.R.No.132715,October20,19
0
99
Peoplev. Bali-
Peoplev.
Balita,GR134266,September15,2000
Torio,G.R.No.132216,November7,19
Peoplev.
99
Cajara,GR122498,Sepember27,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Alfanta,G.R.No.125633,December9,1
Nogar,GR133946,September27,2000
999
Peoplev. Magtrayo,GR133480-
Peoplev.
82,October4,2000
Flores,G.R.No.123599,December13,1
Peoplev. Taguba,GR112792-
999
93,October6,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Ramon,G.R.No.130407,December15,
DelaCuesta,GR133904,October5,2000
1999
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Villar.,322 SCRA390
Arves,GR134628,October13,2000
Peoplev. Bernaldez,322SCRA762
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Flores,322SCRA779
Baldino,GR137269,October13,2000
Peoplev. Palanco,322SCRA790
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Bacule,323SCRA734
Baltazar,GR130610,October16,2000
Peoplev. Bartolome,323SCRA836
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Bayona,327SCRA190
Francisco,GR136252,October20,2000
Peoplev. Siao,327SCRA231
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Bayzo,327SCRA771
Sarmiento,GR134768,October25,200
Peoplev.Delos
0
Santos,GR121906,August5,2000
Peoplev. Gallarde,325SCRA835
Peoplev. Fraga,GR134130-
Peoplev. Crispin,327SCRA167
33,April12,2000
Peoplev. Paramil,GR128056-
Peoplev.
57,March31,2000
Licanda,GR134084,May4,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Gallego,GR130603,August15,2000
Sabredo,GR126114,May11,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Alicante,GR127026-
Tejada.G.R.No.126166,July10,2001
27,May31,2000
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Lalingjaman,G.R.No.132714,Septemb
Traya,GR129052,May31,2000
er6,2001
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Mamac,GR130332,May31,2000
Mercado,G.R.No.139904,October12,2
Peoplev.
001
Decena,GR131843,May31,2000
Estradav.
Peoplev.
SandiganbayanG.R.No.148560,Nov.1
Lomibao,GR135855,August3,2000
9,2001
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Marahay,GR120625-
Canonigo,GR133649,August4,2000
29,Jan.28,2003
Peoplev. Cruz,GR128346-
Peoplev.
48,August14,2000
59
Montemayor,GR124474,Jan.28,2003
60
Peoplev. Rafon–532SCRA370
Peoplev. Domingo–538SCRA733
Peoplev. *
Delim,GR142773,Jan.28,2003 P
Peoplev. e
Acosta,GR140402,Jan.28,2003 o
Peoplev. Caloza,GR138404- p
06,Jan.28,2003 l
Peoplev. Layoso,GR14773- e
76,Jan.22,2003 v
Peoplev. Baldogo,GR128106- .
07,Jan.24,2003 C
Peoplev. h
DelaCruz,GR175954,December16,20 i
08 n
Peoplev. g
DelaCruz,GR174371,December11,20 –
08 5
Andresv. People–588SCRA830 3
Sambilonv. People–591 SCRA405 8
Valenzuelav. People–596SCRA1 S
C
R
A
NumberofOffenses
1
1
Peoplev.
7
Tresballes,G.R.No.126118,September
Peoplev. Ceredon,542SCRA550
21,1999
Peoplev. Pascual,569 SCRA534
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Aure,569SCRA836
Gerona,G.R.No.126169,December21,
Peoplev.
1999
Diocado,GR170567,November14,200
Peoplev.
8
Pambid,GR124453,March15,2000
Peoplev.Canares–579SCRA582
Peoplev.
Peoplev.Aboganda–585SCRA1
Alvero,GR134536,April5,2000
Peoplev. Jimenez–586 SCRA580
Peoplev. GuiwanGR117324-
Peoplev. Lazaro–596SCRA587
8,April27,2000
Peoplev.
Noviolation
Surilla,GR129164,July24,2000
Peoplev. Rama,379SCRA477
Peoplev. Escoro,376 SCRA670
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Pascual,379 SCRA235
Cuyugan,GR146641,Nov.18,2002
Peoplev. Conde,380SCRA159
Peoplev. Montinola,543SCRA412
Peoplev.
Miranda,GR142566,Aug.8,2002
DateofCommissionofCrime
Peoplev.
Roque,GR130569,Aug.14,2002
Peoplev. Narito,G.R.No.
Peoplev.
132058,October1,1999
Segovia,GR138974,Sept.29,2002
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Magbanua,G.R.No.12888,December3,
Caralipio,GR137766,Nov.27,2002
1999
Peoplev.
Peoplev.
Cantomayor,GR145522,Dec.5, 2002
Ladrillo,G.R.No.124342,December8,
Peoplev. sarazan,GR123269-
1999
72,Jan.22,2003
Peoplev. Ferolino,GR131730-
Peoplev.
31,April5,2000
Taperla,GR142860,Jan.16,2003
Peoplev. Gianan,GR135288-
Peoplev. Lizada,GR143468-
93,September15,2000
71,Jan.24,2003
Peoplev.
Peoplev. Dy,GR115326-
Trelles,GR137659,September19,2000
37,Jan.16,2003
Sumbangv.GeneralCourtMartialPRO-
Batulananv. People502SCRA35
Region6, GR140188,August3,2000
Peoplev.Corpuz482SCRA435
Arambulov.Laqui,GR138596,October
12,2000
Peoplev.
Capinpin,GR118608,October30,2000
Peoplev.
Capinpin,GR118608,October30,2000
Peoplev. Tagana,G.R.Nos.137608-
09,July6,2001
Peoplev. Bidoc506SCRA481
Peoplev. Ibañez–523SCRA136
61
Sorianov.
Angeles,GR109920,August31,2000
Soledadv. People–644SCRA258 Almendrav.Asis,AMRTJ-
Torresv. People–655SCRA720 1550,April6,2000
Peoplev.
Rightto SpeedyTrial ZhengBaiHui,GR127580,August22,2
000
Peoplev. Peoplev.
Sesbreno,G.R.No.121764,September9 Genosa,GR135981,September29,2000
,1999
TaiLimv.Courtof
Appeals,G.R.No.131483,October26,1
999
*Condev.Rivera-45PHIL.650 Righttoa PublicTrial
Nepomucenov.Sec.of
NationalDefense-108SCRA658 *InReOliver-333U. S.237
Peoplev. Gines-197 SCRA481 G
Abadiav. CA-236SCRA676 a
Gonzalesv.CA-232SCRA667 r
Cadalinv.POEA–238SCRA721 c
Peoplev. Tampal–244SCRA202 i
Dacanayv. People-240SCRA490 a
v
Guerrerov. CA -257 SCRA703
.
Dizonv. Lopez–278SCRA483
D
Luzarragav. Meteoro,AM00-
o
1572,August3, 2000
m
SolarEntertainmentandPeoplev.Hon.H
i
ow,GR140863,August22,2000
n
DeZuzurreguiv.Rosete,GRAMno.MT g
J-02-1426 o
Peoplev. Dy,GR115326- -
37,Jan.16,2003 L
Lumanlawv. Peralta482SCRA396 -
Padillav. Apas487 SCRA29 3
Peoplev. Hernandez499SCRA688 0
Uyv. Adriano505SCRA625 1
Benaresv. Lim 511SCRA100 0
Gaasv. Mitmug,553SCRA535 4
Albertv.Sandiganbayan–580
SCRA279
Tanv.People–586SCRA139 CompulsoryProcess
Tallov.People–588SCRA520
Olbesv.Buemio–607SCRA336 Fajardov.Garcia-98 SCRA514
Jacobv. Sandiganbayan–635 SCRA94
Brazav.SAndiganbayan,GR195032,Fe
b20,2013
Peoplev.
Castaneda,GR208290,December11,20
13
Roallosv. Epople–712SCRA593
Cov.NewProsperityPlastic–727
SCRA503
Bonsubrav.Xerro,GR205952,February
11,2015
RighttoImpartialTrial
*Mateo.Jr, v. Villaluz-50 SCRA18

Peoplev. CA–262SCRA452
Maliwatv. CA–256SCRA718
Tabuenav. Sandiganbayan–
268SCRA332
Peoplev. Adora–275SCRA441
Cosepv. People–290SCRA378
Peoplev. Castillo–289SCRA213
Peoplev. Vaynaco–
GR126286March22,1999
Peoplev.
Estrada,GR130487,June19,2000
ImpartialityofaJudge
62
v
.
Peoplev.Yambot,GR120350,Octobe S
r13,2000 a
n
RighttoConfrontation,toCross- d
Examine,ortoMeetWitnessFacetoFace i
g
*Tamparv.Usman-200SCRA652 a
Peoplev. Digno-250 SCRA237 n
Peoplev. Miyake– b
279SCRA180Peoplev. Narca– a
275SCRA696 y
Peoplev. Quidato– a
GR117401October1,1998 n
Peoplev. Crispin,327SCRA167 -
Peoplev. Libo- 2
on,G.R.NO.136737,May23,2001 5
Carriagav.C.A.,G.R.No.143561,Jun 3
e6,2001 S
Peoplev. C
Rivera,G.R.No.139180,July31,2001 R
Peoplev. A
Monje,GR146689,Sept.27,2002 7
Victorinov. People509SCRA483 7
Herrerav. Sandiganbayan– 3
579SCRA32 (
HoWaiPangv. People– n
GR1716229,October19,2011 o
v
TrialinAbsentia;RighttoBePresent i
o
*Carredov.People-183SCRA273 l
Peoplev. Ravelo-202SCRA655 a
Peoplev. Rivera-242SCRA26 t
Peoplev. Tabag–268SCRA115 i
Paradav.Veneracion–(supra,Rightto o
Bail) n
)
Admissibilityof Evidence
B
Peoplev. o
Morial,G.R.No.129295,August15,2 l
001 a
Peoplev. l
Tulin,G.R.No.111709,August30,20 i
01 n
v
SECTION15.(HABEAS CORPUS) .
O
SECTION16. c
c
Rightto SpeedyDispositionof Cases i
a
Peoplev. n
Sesbreno,G.R.No.121764,Septembe o
r9,1999 –
*Binayv. 2
Sandiganbayan,G.R.No. 6
120681,October1,1999 6
(reasonabledelay) S
Gonzalesv. C
Sandiganbayan-199 R
SCRA299(noviolation) A
S 2
o 0
c 3
r (
a v
t i
e o
s l
63
a A
t 6
i 0
o Dutertev.
n Sandiganbayan–
) 289SCRA721(prelimin
A aryinvestigation,violati
n on) Marcosv.
g Sandiganbayan–
c GR126995October6,
h 1998(violation)
a Roquev.O
n mbudsman
g –
c GR129978
o May12,19
v 99(violatio
. n)
Cervantesv
O .
m Sandiganb
b ayan–
u GR108595
d May18,19
s 99(violatio
m n)
a Dansalv.
n Fernandez,
– 327SCRA
2 145(noviol
6 ation)
8 Domingov.Sandiganbayan,322SCR
S A655(noviolation)
C Castillov.
R Sandiganbay
A an,GR10927
3 1,March14,2
0 000(noviolat
1 ion)
( Rarov.Sandi
v ganbayan,G
i R108431,Jul
o y14,2000
l DelaPenav. Sandiganbayan,G.R.
a No.144542,June29,2001
t Lopezv.Ombudsman,G.R.No.14052
i 9,September6,2001
o Leev. People,Gr137914,Dec.4,
n 2002
) Peoplev.
Monje,GR146689,Sept.27,2002
L Ty-Dazov.
a Sandiganbayan,374SCRA200
m Guianiv.
b Sandiganbayan,GR146897,Aug
i .6,2002(delayinpreliminaryinve
n stigation)
o Avillav.Reyes479SCRA334
v Enriquezv.Officeof
. OMB,545SCRA618
D OMBv.Jurado,561SCRA135
e Pereav. People,544SCRA532
V Gaasv. Mitmug,553SCRA335
e Roquerav. Chancellor–
r 614SCRA723
a Lumanogv.People–630SCRA42
– SpousesDacudaov.DOJ,GR188056,
2 Jan8,2013
7 Conscolluelav.
5 Sandiganbayan,GR191411,July15,2
S 013
C Peoplev.
R
64
Sandiganbayan.GR188165,Decemb
er11,2013(pendingcases)
65
l
o
Borjav.Sandiganbayan–691 -
SCRA421 6
4
SECTION17. P
H
RightAgainstSelf-Incrimination I
L
*UnitedStatesv.Navarro-3 .
PHIL.143(rationale) 4
*UnitedStatesv.TanTeng-23 8
PHIL.145(substancesemittedtoprov 3
eSTDinfection) Chavezv.CA–L-
*UnitedStatesv.OngSiuHong-36 29169,Aug.19,1968
PHIL.73 (discharge) *Cabalv. Kapunan,Jr. -L-
*Villaflorv.Summers- 19052(forfeitureproceedings)
41PHIL.62(pregnancytest) *Pascual,Jr. v.
* BoardofMedicalExa
B miners-L-
e 25018(revocationof
l license) Peoplev.
t Gamboa-
r 194SCRA372(paraff
a intest)
n P
v e
. o
p
S l
a e
m v
s .
o
n C
- a
5 n
3 c
P e
H r
I a
L n
. -
5 2
7 2
0 9
( S
w C
r R
i A
t 5
i 8
n 1
g (
) p
a
B r
e a
r f
m f
u i
d n
e t
z e
v s
. t
C )
a
s P
t e
i o
l p
66
l Peoplev. Go–237SCRA73
e Regalav. Sandiganbayan–
v 262SCRA122
. Peoplev. Malimit–264SCRA167
Galmanv. Pamaran–
T (supra,CustodialInvestigation)
r Peoplev.
a Banihit,GR
n 132045,Au
c gust25,200
a 0(relatetoT
- anTeng)
2 Peoplev.
3 Besonia,42
5 2SCRA21
S 0
C Sabiov.Gordon504 SCRA704
R Benaresv. Lim 511SCRA100
A StandardCharteredv.
4 Senate–
5 541SCRA546(legislat
5 iveinquiryis notself-
( incriminating)
x Peoplev. Fielded–737SCRA455
-
r
a S
y
, E
n
o C
t T
a
I
v
O
i
o N
l
a 1
t
i 8
o
n .(
)
P
A
l O
m L
o
n I
t
T
e
v I
.
V C
a A
s
q L
u
e B
z
E
–
2 L
4
4 I
S E
C
R F
A
S
2
8 ;
6
67
I 197SCRA378
Baylo
N sisv.
Chave
V
z-
O 202SC
RA40
L
5(mod
U ifiedb
yRobi
N nPadil
la)
T
People
A v.
Muno
R
z-
Y 170SC
RA10
S 7
Peoplev. Amigo-252SCRA43
E *
P
R
e
V o
p
I l
T e
v
U .
D
E
E c
h
S e
) g
a
S r
a
E y
–
C 2
6
T
7
I S
C
O R
N A
6
1 8
2
9 (
d
. e
a
Cruel, t
Degra h
dingo p
rInhu e
manP n
unish a
ment; l
Exces t
siveFi y
nes )
*Peoplev. P
Estoista-93 e
PHIL.647(rec o
ommendedex p
ecutivecleme l
ncy) Peoplev. e
Dapitan- v
68
. CaramResourcesv.Contreras-
237SCRA724(check).
T
o
n
g
k
o
–
2
9
0
S
C
R
A
5
9
5
Echegarayv. SecretaryofJustice–
12LR32N’98
Padillav. CA –(supra,Rightto Bail)
Peoplev. Alicante,GR127026-
27,May31,2000
Limv.People,GR149276,Sept.27,20
02
Peoplev.
Gabiana,GR123543,August23,2000
Peoplev.
Horio,GR137842,August23,2001
Pagdayawonv. Sec.of
Justice,GR154569,Sept.23,2002
Perezv.People,544SCRA532
Disiniv.SecretaryofJustice,GR2033
35,Feb.18,2014(supra.)
*
C
o
r
p
u
z
v
.
P
e
o
p
l
e
–
7
2
4
S
C
R
A
1
SECTION20.
Imprisonmentfor Debt
*Lozanov.Martinez-
146SCRA323(check)
69
3
6
T ,
i J
o a
m n
i .
c 2
o 2
v ,
. 2
C 0
A 0
– 3
G (
R c
1 h
2 e
2 c
5 k
3 )
9
M
a SECTION21.
r
c D
h i
4 s
, m
1 i
9 s
9 s
9 a
( l
t a
r t
u P
s r
t e
r l
e i
c m
e i
i n
p a
t r
) y
I
R n
e v
c e
u s
e t
r i
d g
o a
v t
. i
o
P n
e ;
o N
p o
l
e J
, e
G o
R p
1 a
3 r
3 d
0 y
70
a
l
Attachmentofjeopardy n
o
*Peoplev. Ylagan-58 PHIL.851 t
Peoplev. Balisacan-L-26376 r
Cincov. Sandiganbayan- e
202SCRA726 v
Peoplev, Vergara-221SCRA560 i
Navallov. Sandiganbayan- e
234SCRA175 w
Galvezv. CA-237 SCRA685 a
Cunananv. Arceo-242SCRA88 b
Peoplev. Tampal-244SCRA202 l
Peoplev. Montesa-248SCRA641 e
DeLa Rosav.CA –253SCRA499 )
Peoplev. Leviste-255SCRA238 P
Peoplev. Cawaling–293SCRA267 e
Cudiav.CA–284 SCRA173 o
Tecsonv.Sandiganbayan,G.R.No.12 p
3045,November16,1999 l
Dimatulacv. Villon– e
GR127107October12,1999 v
Peoplev. Maquiling– .
GR128986June21,1999 C
Peoplev. Nitafan–GR707964- A
66February1,1999 –
Binayv. 6
Sandiganbayan,G.R.No.120681,Oct 2
ober1, 1999 6
Limpangogv. Courtof S
Appeals,G.R.No.134229,November C
26,1999 R
Floresv.Joven,GR129874,Dec.27,2 A
002 3
Mirandav.Tuliao486SCRA377 5
Cabov. 2
Sandiganbayan491SCRA264 Brazav.SAndiganbayan,GR19503
Romualdezv.Marcelo497 SCRA89 2,Feb20,2013(validpleaandobjecte
P dtoany furtherconductof
e reinvestigation)(supraArtIII,Sec14
o )
p Digitalv.Cantos–710 SCRA514
l Quiambaov. People–735SCRA345
e Peoplev. DeLeon–754SCRA147
v Saldarriagav. Panganiban–
. 755SCRA627
T Asistiov. People–756SCRA256
e
r
r T
a e
d r
o m
, i
5 n
5 a
8 t
S i
C o
R n
A o
8 f
4
( J
a e
c o
q p
u a
i r
t d
t y
71
;
E
x
i
s
t
e
n
c
e
;
N
o
n
-
T
e
r
m
i
n
a
t
i
o
n
*Bulaongv. People-17SCRA746
Bustamantev.Maceren-
48SCRA155
Peoplev. Obsania-L-24447
Rivera,Jr. v,People-189SCRA331
Dizon-Pamintuanv. People-
234SCRA63
COMELECv.CA-229SCRA501
Peoplev. Bans-239SCRA48
StateProsecutorsv. Muro-
236SCRA505
Peoplev. Bellaflor-233SCRA196
Guerrerov. CA -257 SCRA703
Teodorov. CA-258 SCRA603
Cuidiav. CA –284SCRA173
Peoplev. Lising–285SCRA595
Peoplev.
Araneta,GR125894December11,19
98,95OG4556
Cuisonv. CA–289SCRA159
Peoplev.
CA,GR128986June21,1999
Peoplev.
Serrano,G.R.No.135451,September
30,1999
Baranganv. Courtof
Appeals,G.R.No.123307,November
29,1999
Peoplev.
Velasco,GR127444,September13,2
000
Tupazv.ULEP,G.R.No.127777,Oct
ober1, 1999
Peoplev. Verra,GR134732
72
v
.
Mercialesv.CA,379SCRA345
Posov. Mijares,AMNo.RTJ-02- L
1693,Aug.21,2002 o
Peoplev. g
Alberto,GR132374,Aug.22,2002 a
Condradav. n
People,GR141646,Feb.28,2003 ,
Peoplev. G
Romero,GR144156,March20,2003 .
R
Peoplev.
.
Espinosa,GR153714,Aug.15,2003
N
Orientev. People–513SCRA348
o
Pacoyv.Cajigal–534SCRA338
.
Summervillev. Eugenio–
1
529SCRA274
3
Herrerav.Sandiganbayan–
5
579SCRA32
0
Javierv. Sandiganbayan–
3
599SCRA324
0
Cov.Lim–604SCRA702
-
Lejanov. People–639SCRA760
3
Bangayonv.
3
Bangayon,GR172777,October19,2011
,
Goodlandv.Co,GR196685,December1
J
8,2011
u
l
Ruleon“SuperveningFacts” y
2
*Melov. People-85 PHIL.766 0
*Peoplev. Buling-107PHIL.712 ,
2
SameOffenses 0
0
*Peoplev.Tiozon-198SCRA368 1
Lamerav.CA-198SCRA186 .
Gonzalesv.CA-232SCRA667
Peoplev. Turda-233 SCRA702 P
Peoplev. Manungas-231SCRA1 o
Peoplev. Deunida-231SCRA520 t
Peoplev. Fernandez-239SCRA174 o
Peoplev. Quijada–259SCRA191 t
Peoplev. Ballabare–264SCRA350 v
Peoplev. Calonzo–262SCRA534 .
Peoplev. Benemerito–264SCRA677 P
Peoplev. Tobias–266 SCRA229 e
Peoplev. Manoyco–269SCRA513 o
Peoplev. TanTiongMeng– p
271SCRA125 l
Peoplev. Sadiosa–290SCRA92 e
Peoplev. Sanchez–291SCRA333 ,
Peoplev. Saley–291SCRA715 G
Peoplev. Juego– R
GR123162October13,1998 1
Peoplev. Ganadin– 4
GR129441November27,1998 3
Peoplev. Balasa– 5
GR106357September3,1998 4
Paluayv.CA–293 SCRA358 7
Peoplev. Mercado304SCRA504 ,
Peoplev.Yabut,G.R.No.115719,Octob J
er5,1999 u
Peoplev. Ong,322SCRA38 n
Peoplev. Meris,GR117145- e
50,March28,2000 2
P 6
e ,
o 2
p 0
l 0
e 2
73
Peoplev. CA,423SCRA605 e
Ramiscalv.Sandiganbayan499SCRA3 v
75 i
Peoplev. Comila–517SCRA153 e
Diazv.Davao–520 SCRA481 w
Merencillov. People–521SCRA31 b
Lapasaranv. People–578SCRA658 y
Ivlerv. Modesto–635SCRA191 P
Peoplev. Ocden–650SCRA124 e
Peoplev. t
Lalli,GR195 i
419,October t
12,2011(traf i
fickinginper o
son) n
Albertov.CA f
– o
699SCRA10 r
4 C
Disiniv.SecretaryofJustice,GR203335, e
Feb18,2014(supra) r
t
i
No o
A r
p a
p r
e i
a
l Peoplev. Sandiganbayan,376SCRA74
f Yuchengcov.CA,376SCRA531
r
o
m
A
c
q
u
i
t
t
a
l
;
I
n
s
t
a
n
c
e
s
o
f
V
o
i
d
A
c
q
u
i
t
t
a
l
;
R
74
Peoplev. Nazareno–595 SCRA438
Peoplev. Duca–
SanVicentev. 603SCRA159(voidacquittal)
People,GR132081,Nov.26,2002 Mupasv.
Peoplev. People,GR18936
CA,GR132396,Sept.23,2002 5,October12,201
Peoplev. 1(voidorderonde
Sandiganbayan491SCRA185 murrer)
Peoplev. CA–516SCRA383 Almuetev.People
Peoplev. Laguio–518SCRA393 –693SCRA167
P Villarealv.
e Alegre,GR166995,January13,2014
o Peoplev. Go-&32SCRA216
p Peoplev. CA–GR183652
l
e Parties
v
. Metrobankv.Meridiano,G.R.No.118
251,June29,2001
D
u
m
l OrdinanceandStatute
a
o *Peoplev.Relova-148SCRA292
–
5 AppliedtoImpeachment
8
0 Estradav. Desierto,GR146710-
S 15andGR146738,March2,
C 2001andMR-GR146710-
R 15and146738,April3,2001
A Peoplev. Logan,G.R.No.135030-
4 33,July20,2001.
0
9 SECTION22.
(
v Ex PostFactoLawsandBillsofAttainder
o
i *Peoplev.Ferrer-
d 48SCRA382(subversionact)
a *
c V
q ir
u a
i t
t a
t v
a .
l S
) a
n
d
T
i
i
g
u
a
v
n
.
b
C
a
A
y
–
a
5
n
8
-
6
2
0
S
2
C
S
R C
A R
1 A
1 6
8 8
Peoplev. DeGrano–588SCRA550
75
0 .
(
P M
C a
G p
G a
c -
h _
a ?
rt _
e S
r C
) R
T A
ri 3
n 4
i [
d 2
a 0
d 0
v 8
. ]
C
A R
- e
2 p
0 u
2 b
S l
C i
R c
A v
1 .
0
6 E
Peoplev. Taguba-229 SCRA188 u
Peoplev. Sandiganbayan– g
211SCRA241 e
Cov.CA–227SCRA444 n
Rosalesv.CA-255SCRA123 i
Subidov. Sandiganbayan– o
266SCRA379 -
Sesbrenov.CBAA–270SCRA360 5
Peoplev. Burton–268SCRA531 4
*Lacsonv. 5
ExecutiveSecretary,GR1
28096January20,1999(jur S
isdictionof SB) Peoplev. C
Nitafan,GR107964- R
66February1,1999 A
Fajardov.CA,GR128508February1, 3
1999 8
Peoplev. 4
Valdez,GR127663March11,1999 Valerosov. People-546SCRA450
Peoplev. Presidentialv. Desierto-
Ringor,G.R.No.123918,December9, 548SCRA295
1999 SpousesDacudaov.DOJ,GR188056,
Peoplev. Jan8,2013
Magbanua,G.R.No.128888,Decemb SeniorCitizenParty-
er3,1999 Listv.COMELEC,GR206844-
Republicv. 45,July23,2013(resolutionv.
Desierto,GR136506,Aug.23,2001 penallaws)(supraArt3, Sec1)
Peoplev.Torres-501SCRA591 Republicv.
S Roque,GR204603,Sep.24,2013
a Disiniv.SecretaryofJustice,GR2033
l 35,Feb.18,2014(supra)
v
a
d
o
r
v
76
Frivaldov.COMELEC–
257SCRA727(applicationforrepatr
ARTICLEIV- CITIZENSHIP ationretroactstothe day
ofapplication)
Labo,Jr, v. COMELEC-176SCRA1
SECTION1. Labo,Jr, v.
COMELEC–
Vallesv.COMELEC,GR137000,Au 211SCRA297(threemo
gust9, 2000 desof
OngChiav. acquiringcitizenship)
Republic,GR127240,March27,200 Aznarv.Osmena-
0 185SCRA703
Mercadov
.
ChildrenofFilipinofathersormothers Manzano–
GR13508
Gatchalianv.BoardofCommissioner 3May26,1
s– 999(dual-
197SCRA853(noprooftoinvalidatefi citizenshi
liation to p)
Filipinofather) Tabasov.
*Tecsonv.Comelec,423SCRA277(F CA500SC
PJcase,illegitimatesonof RA9
*Maquilingv.COMELEC,GR19564
aFilipinofather;
9,April16,2013(renouncingcitizensh
recognizedpaternity)
ip)
Gov.Ramos–598SCRA266
Gonzalesv.Rennisi–614SCRA292
Nocollateralattack
Cabilingv. Fernandez–
625SCRA566
Vilandov. HRET–656SCRA17
Paragraph(3)
SECTION2
*Co.v. ElectoralTribunal-
*Bengsonv.
199SCRA692(electionofcitizenship
HRET,G.R.No.142840,May7,2
–positiveacts)
001 (natural-
*Republicv. Sagun–666SCRA321
borncitizenshipreacquired
afterrepatriationifnatural-
Paragraph(4)
bornfrom thebeginning)
*Sov.Republic–513SCRA267 Corderov. COMELEC–
580SCRA12
*Davidv.
Lossofcitizenship
Agbay,GR199113,March18,2015
Yu v.Defensor-Santiago- *Poe-
Llamanzaresv.COMELEC,GR2216
169SCRA364(expressedrenun
97,March8,2016
ciationfrom externalacts)
Frivaldov. COMELEC-
174SCRA245
Section4
*Reyesv.COMELEC,Gr207264,October22,2013(admi
ssion)(supraArtIII, Sec1)
Section5
*AASJS-
Calilungv.Datumanong,G.R.No.16
0869,May11,2007(dualcitizenship
v dualallegiance)
77
ARTICLEV -“SUFFRAGE”
SECTION1
SECTION2
*Macalintalv.COMELEC,GR157013,July10,2003
(absenteevoting)
*Nicolas-Lewisv.COMELEC
497SCRA649(absenteevoters/dualcitizensneednot
complywithresidency)
Labo
,Jr,
v.
CO
ME
LEC
–
(supr
a,Cit
izens
hip)
Rom
uald
ezv.
RTC
–
226S
CRA
408
*KabataanParty-Listv.
COMELEC,GR221318,December15,2015
o
y
SpecialRegistrationBeforeGeneralElectio e
ns e
s
Akbayanv. v.
COMELEC,GR147066,March26,20 C
01 A
–
(s
u
p
ARTICLEXIII-
SOCIALJUSTICEANDHUMANRIGHTS r
a,
R
SECTION1 i
g
PolicytoRemoveInequities h
tt
*InternationalSchoolAlliance o
of F
Educatorsv.Quisumbing,GR1 o
28845,June1,2000 r
(salarydifferencebetweenforei m
gnandlocalhires)
A
SECTION3. s
s
Labor o
ci
*EagleSecurityv.NLRC- at
173SCRA479(protectionofworkers i
–solidaryliabilityof employers) o
S n
S )
S D
E e
m V
p e
l r
a
78
v. s
N t
L l
R e
C –
– 1
2 9
0 2
0 S
S C
C R
R A
A 3
4 9
3 6
9 Jacintov.CA–281SCRA657
Republicv. CA-180SCRA428 TelefunkenEmployeesUnionv.CA,
M GR143013-14,December18,2000
P Lanzaderasv.AmethystSecurity,GR
S 143604,June20,2003
T StandardCharteredBankEmployees
A vConfesor,GR114974,June16,2004
v Agabonv.
. NLRC,GR158693,Nov.17,2004
TheProvinceofCamarinesNortev.G
L onzales,GR185740,July23,2013(se
a curityof tenure)
g AbbottLaboratoriesv
u .
i Alcaraz,GR192571,J
o uly23,2013(security
( oftenure)
s SMEBankv.DeGuz
u man,GR184517,Oct
p ober8,2013(security
r oftenure)
a GMAv.
, Pabriga,GR176
R 419,November2
i 7,2013(security
g oftenure)
h DiamondTaxic.
t Llamas,Gr1907
t 24,March12,20
o 14(securityoften
F ure)
o
r
m SECTION4.
A AgrarianReform
s
s Assn.ofSmallLandownersv.Sec.of
o Agrarian Reform-
c 175SCRA343(retention limits,
i judicialreviewofjustcompensation;
a revolutionaryexpropriation)
t Tanakav.Japan-7Minshui1523
i LuzFarmsv.Sec. of
o AgrarianReform–192
n SCRA5(agriculturedoesnot
) includepoultry andlivestock)
Nataliav. DAR–225SCRA278
U Phil.VeteransBankv.CA,GR132767,
n January18,2000
i Daezv.CA,GR133507,February17,2
o 000
n
v
.
N
e
79
Bautistav. Araneta,GR135829,February22,2000
Corpusv.Grospe,GR135297,June8,2000
Heirsof Santosv.CA,GR109992,March7,2000
Padunanv.DARAB,GR132163,Jan.28,2003
*HaciendaLuisitav.PARC–GRNo.171101,July5,2011
Heirsof
SECTION9 Sanduetav.Robles,GR203204,November20,2013(Cong
resslimitations)
UrbanlandReform SECTION18.
Deev.CA,GR108205,February15,20 PowersoftheCommissiononHumanRights
00
Reyesv. *Carinov.CH
NHA,GR147511,Jan.20,2003 R-
204SCRA483
SECTION10. (noadjudicato
rypower,noco
UrbanLandReformandHousing ntempt)
EPZAV.CHR
*Macasianov. NHA–224SCRA236 ,et. al.–
Jumawanv.Eviota–234SCRA524 208SCRA125
Filstreamv.CA–284SCRA716 (noinjunctive
*Peoplev.Leachon– power)
GR108725September25,1998(justa *Simonv.CHR–229SCRA117(no
ndhumanemanner) injunctivepower)
e
ARTICLEXIV-
c EDUCATIONSCIENCEANDTECHNOLOGY,ART
SCULTUREANDSPORTS
t +
i SECTION1
o NaturalandPrimaryRightof Parents
n Meyerv.Nebraska-262US390
Piercev. SocietyofSisters-
1 262US510
Wisconsinv. Yoder-406US205
7 Ginsbergv.NewYork-390US629
4 Q
u
) a
l
i
t
B y
a
u n
d
d a
c
g c
e
e s
s
t i
b
i
*CHREmployeesv.CHR496SCRA2 l
26 (fiscalautonomy) i
t
y
80
o
f
e
d
u
c
a
t
i
o
n
a
l
s
y
s
t
e
m
*DECSv. SanDiego-180
SCRA534(failedNMATthrice,po
wertoregulateadmission)
Nonv.JudgeDames-
185SCRA523
SECTION3
DutyofInstitutions
*MiriamCollegev.CA,GR127930,D
ecember15,2000
(obsceneschoolpaper)
SECTION5.
81
Academicfreedomof“institutionsofhigher
learning".
*Garciav.Faculty
Admission,68
SCRA277
(deniedadmission
totheology)
BMEv.JudgeAlfo
nso-
176SCRA304
Lupangcov.CA-160SCRA848
*Universityof
SanCarlosv.
CA-
166SCRA570(fr
eedomtogiveho
nors)
CapitolMedical
CentervCA-
178SCRA493
Reyesv. CA –194SCRA402
Tanv.CA–199SCRA212
Camachov.Coresis,GR134372,Au
g.22,2002
CivilServiceCommissionv.Sojor–
554SCRA160
Reginov.
PangasinanCollegesofS&T,GR156
109,Nov18,2004
InternationalSchoolofManilav.IS
AE,GR167286,Feb.5,2014(standa
rdofefficiency forteachers)

(Updated) Syllabus

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

(Updated) Syllabus

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

vice)

Requisites of a valid warrant

Warrantless searches and seizures.

Searches and seizures “of whatever nature and for

Waiver of Rights under Sec. 2 and Sec. 3

*People v. Damaso – 212 SCRA 547 (personal waiver)

*Near v. Minnesota - 238 US 697 (malicious articles

*People v. Perez - 45 PHIL. 599 (dangerous tendency

Assembly and petition

*Rubin v. Coors Brewing - 131 L. Ed. 2d 532

*Policarpio v. Manila Times - 5 SCRA 148

*Miller v. California - 37 L. Ed. 2d 419 (mailing of

*Aglipay v. Ruiz - 64 PHIL. 201 (postage stamps

Free Exercise of Religion

*Victoriano v. Elizalde, 59 SCRA 94 (closed shop

TUCP v. NBC - 173 SCRA 33

Power to Undertake Expropriation Case.

Iron and Steel Authority v. CA – 249 SCRA 538

*Sumulong v. Guerrero - 154 SCRA 461 (housing is

*City of Manila v. Estrada - 25 PHIL. 208 (judicial

END OF GROUP 2 REPORT

START OF GROUP 3 REPORT

*Home Building and Loan Assn. v. Blaisell -

Re: Letter Dated April 18, 2011 of Chief Public Atty

I. Custodial Investigation, In General

People Pavillare, GR 129970, April 5, 2000

*Miranda v. Arizona 384 US 436 (Miranda Rights)

II. Instances of Custodial Investigations

People v. Lim - 196 SCRA 809

A. Procedural Requirements c. Effective and Vigilant Counsel Defined

Miranda v. Arizona- 384 US 436 (supra.)

B. Duty of an Officer During Custodial

People v. de la Cruz, GR 137405, Sept. 27, 2002

C. When the Rights of Custodial Investigation May

People v. Loveria - 187 SCRA 47

D. The Right to Remain Silent

People v. Bandin – 226 SCRA 299

E. The Right to Counsel

People v. Sunga, GR 126029, Mar. 29, 2003 (city legal

b. When Presence of Counsel is Required

People v. Rodriguez - 232 SCRA 227 – artellero and

f. Assistance After Start of Custodial

g. Valid Confession with Counsel

h. Confession Without Counsel

People v. Manriquez, GR 122510-11, March 17, 2000

IV. Waiver of Rights

A. Requisites of a Valid Waiver

a. Must Be in Writing and in the Presence of

b. Must Be Voluntary, Knowing and Intelligent

People v. Nicolas - 204 SCRA 191

A. Difference Between Admission and Confession

Ladiana v. People, GR 144293, Dec. 4, 2002

B. Requisites for Valid Extrajudicial Confession

People v. Dano, GR 117690, September 1, 2000

People v. Deang, GR 128045, August 24, 2000 D. Administrative Investigation

E. To Whom Such Confession Can Be Used

F. Lawyer Given by Police Investigator; Valid

VI. When Custodial Investigations May Not

E. Not in Police Custody

K. When Body of the Accused is Examined

START OF GROUP 4 REPORT

VII. The Exclusionary Rule

B. Immunity against Self-Incrimination