Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Figure 1: Computer generated image of the proposed Thermal Energy Storage Tank (Source: James Cook University, 2007)
ABSTRACT
James Cook University has built Australia’s largest central-energy chilled water plant incorporating stratified chilled water storage
to provide the cooling requirements to all 28 academic buildings within its Townsville campus. The project reduces electrical demand
and thus operating and transport costs, greenhouse gas emissions and maintenance, and provides the university with new refrigeration
plant that has a projected economic life of 30 years.
Keywords — Central Energy Plant, (CEP), chilled water, dynamic control system, maximum demand, Thermal Energy Storage, TES
• High Voltage (HV) electrical 40 per cent from 9.9MW to 5.4MW refrigerated air conditioning systems
reticulation on site is fragile and non- (2010 scenario) avoiding any high is high and represents a significant part
homogeneous with little spare capacity voltage feeder upgrades. It will also of the University’s operating costs.
to meet foreseeable load growth. provide a relatively ‘flat’ or consistent
Using available benchmark data, the
• There is no master plan for the site electrical demand, which frees up
University has identified that campus
services with poor ‘as-built’ drawing capacity on site, allowing capacity
electrical energy costs are significantly
records, thus making it difficult to for future campus expansion, and/or
higher than comparable facilities
locate or plan alterations to existing allows the utility provider to use this
including most notably the Cairns
underground services. capacity elsewhere.
Campus of the JCU and Charles Darwin
• Utility power bills are in the order • Reduced electricity operating costs University both of which are located
of $2.7M pa. by approximately 30 per cent from in similar climatic regions and both
$3,200,000 to $2,260,000, saving in incorporate stratified chilled water
• Site power maximum demand is the order of $940,000 pa (based on Thermal Energy Storage (TES) systems.
7.3MW (2007) with the utility feeders the current cost of electricity) by 2010.
(consumer mains) capable of 9MW. Due to the strategies adopted in the
• Reduced greenhouse gas emissions early development of the campus (1967)
attributable to the University from each building is served by its own small
Building Program 43,000 tonnes to 31,000 tonnes, cooling plant (water cooled and air
Expansion Drivers saving approximately 12,000 tonnes cooled) generating chilled water to satisfy
CO2 per year by 2010 (this is the the building’s cooling requirements. As a
JCU has an ambitious building equivalent to taking approximately
development program which will expand consequence, more than 28 small isolated
2650 cars off the road). chilled water plants currently exist on
the site to include an additional 25,200m2
of air-conditioned floor area by 2010 and a • Reduced maintenance costs and campus. The plants are of varying age
further 25,000m2 by 2015. The resolutions transport costs associated with (from 2 to 35 years old) and efficiency,
to the following identified drivers are servicing 28 different chillers, pump and many are air-cooled and highly
critical to the development program: groups, cooling towers and the like. inefficient during peak load periods.
The savings are categorised into new The large number of cooling plants also
• The 2010 building program results in high maintenance costs, as the
plant versus old plant maintenance
extrapolated maximum demand cost of maintenance for air conditioning
and central plant versus distributed
of 9.9MW would exceed the utility systems is strongly related to the number
plant. The combined benefit is
provider’s available capacity for the of system elements and travel distance.
anticipated to be more than half
site of 9MW. This would prompt an Many of the small plants have exceeded
the current maintenance costs.
expensive utility power upgrade and or are close to the end of their economic
site wide high voltage power upgrade • New refrigeration plant with a
life and major plant replacement costs
with a fourth ‘feeder’ or supply to the projected economic life of 30 years
will be incurred during the next five
site being required. and improved system reliability
years. The redundant equipment
(redundancy).
• The building program for 2015 will be recycled and sold off.
would also exceed the site high • Reduction in noise pollution
generated by multiple air conditioning The Douglas Campus is about to embark
voltage maximum feeder capacity
plant compared with the central plant on a major expansion program which
by approximately 3MW necessitating
and acoustic treatment. will result in the construction of 8 new
a fourth feeder and upgrades of the
buildings by 2010 and effectively increase
onsite high-voltage trunk cabling and • A building services master plan the air conditioned floor area by over
transformers network. that includes a central spine of 35 per cent.
underground service trenches
Engineered Solution throughout the campus, which
2.0 SITE EXPANSION
streamlines existing services, and
to the Project Drivers allows for future development DRIVERS
JCU Townsville is building Australia’s programs.
With an ambitious building program
largest Central Energy Chilled Water
increasing the academic air conditioning
Plant incorporating Stratified Chilled
Water Storage to provide the cooling
1.0 INTRODUCTION floor area from 69,000m2 (2007) to
The Townsville Douglas Campus of 94,200m2 (2010) and a further 25,000m2
requirements of all 28 existing academic
the JCU represents a typical medium (2015), the following drivers were
buildings. The project is due for
sized University Campus and comprises acknowledged:
completion by April 2009.
approximately 28 academic and service 1. Electrical infrastructure to the
Implementation of the proposed new buildings with a total air conditioned site has an upper limit of 9MW
system after completion of the current floor area in excess of 69,000m2 in 2007. maximum demand. The current
campus expansion projects planned for The campus is situated in the coastal site maximum demand (2007) was
2010 will yield the following benefits: tropics and therefore peak summer air recorded at 7.3MW. On a pro-rata
• Reduction of the instantaneous conditioning loads are high and there is basis future demand up to 2015 could
maximum electrical demand a year round requirement for cooling. be approximately 12MW, well above
for the site by approximately Consequently annual energy usage of the site infrastructure limitations.
SE P TE M B E R 2 0 0 9 • Eco l ibri u m 31
FORUM
FAN
Simple and intuitive to use, no training required.
A single screen interface allows all information to be accessed and
viewed quickly.
Simple to use selection filters allow you to short list your options
SELECTION
quickly and easily.
Dynamic simulation of fan performance under variable speed control
shows adjusted power, sound and flow characteristics.
Selection results table can be tailored to return only your chosen
AT YOUR
performance criteria.
Click headings to sort on any column in the results table,
e.g. sound, absorbed power, BCA compliance etc.
Web based for online updates; data and specifications always
FINGERTIPS.
up to date.
Includes fan sound attenuation options.
BCA Section J5.2 2009 compliance instantly visible for all selections.
Broader selection options including Chicago Blower centrifugal fans.
Full project schedule and datasheet functions.
Easy export of all data to clipboard and auto save functions to
protect your work.
TM
WARM WATER
PRIMARY CHILLED
WATER PUMP INDIVIDUAL BUILDINGS
DAY TIME TANK MASS THERMAL SECONDARY CHILLED
CHARGE CYCLE ENERGY STORAGE WATER PUMP
CHILLER
COOL WATER
TERTIARY CHILLED WATER PUMPS
Day-time operation
WARM WATER
PRIMARY CHILLED
WATER PUMP INDIVIDUAL BUILDINGS
NIGHT TIME TANK MASS THERMAL SECONDARY CHILLED
CHARGE CYCLE ENERGY STORAGE WATER PUMP
CHILLER
COOL WATER
TERTIARY CHILLED WATER PUMPS
Night-time operation
Central Energy Plant (CEP) is the chilled water system, except that the of the water. This head thus improves
centralised plant for the district cooling. chiller plant takes the form of one efficient the efficiency of the CEP/TES interface.
It contains the chillers, cooling towers, centralised plant rather than 28 different
The CEP building houses:
pumps and thermal energy (chilled cooling plants. The central energy plant
water) storage tank. It offers the benefits has a design Coefficient Of Performance • three 4.2MW centrifugal high
of high efficiency, central plant, reduced (COP is a measure of efficiency) of 6 efficiency chillers, with provision for
maintenance, ease of expansion and at summer conditions of 33°C dry bulb an additional two chillers in the future
technological upgrades as technology and 27°C wet bulb. • primary and secondary chilled water
advances. On large centralised plant such pumps (with variable speed drives)
as this, ‘redundancy’ or back-up systems
are included in the system architecture,
3.0 ENGINEERING • condenser water pumps (with variable
speed drives)
which allows for continuous supply in DESIGN RESPONSE
• four 5.1MW cooling towers
the event of a component failure. The design solution proposed a new (with variable speed drives on the
Thermal Energy Storage (TES) makes use Central Energy Plant (CEP) integrated fans) with provision for a 5th tower
of periods of the day or night when the site with a Thermal Energy Storage (TES)
• CEP office
demand for cooling is less than the average element. The final engineering design
response was determined by comparing • low voltage and high voltage
demand, by running central chilled water switch room
plant during these times to chill return several computerised energy models of
the site. (Refer to section 4.1.) • the building is air conditioned
water (from 15°C) back to chilled water (at
rather than mechanically ventilated
6°C). During times when the site demand The chiller and water storage facility
to prolong plant life and prevent
exceeds the average demand (typically is located in the southeast part of the
condensation (corrosion) issues.
in the afternoon), the chilled water is campus at sufficient elevation to ensure
drawn from the storage tank. From here, that water level in the thermal storage The 12 mega litre TES tank contains
the pre-cooled water is then reticulated tank represents the highest point in the specially engineered top and bottom
throughout the campus and delivered to chilled water network, thus ensuring water diffusers to allow the water leaving
fan coil units within each building. The the ‘static head’ or pressure floods all or entering the tank to do so without
installation of air-conditioning systems the chilled water pipework, preventing turbulence. This allows the chilled and
within the buildings themselves remains air pockets from being trapped in the returning warm water to stratify within
essentially the same as any conventional pipework, and thus affecting flow the one single tank.
Site Power Profile 2007 & 2010 (20th Feb)–Status Quo Approach
tank. The secondary pumps pressurise
12000 the main water spine throughout the
campus, and the tertiary pumping
systems control the flow of chilled water
10000
in each building. They are controlled to
deliver a variable water flow to match
8000 the instantaneous cooling demand with
a fixed pressure setting throughout the
Power (kWe)
Figure 4: Chiller Plant Contribution to Maximum Demand (Source: MGF, 2006) A detailed computer model of the
electrical and refrigeration demand
The water is pumped out of the bottom 7.8kM of underground uninsulated of the campus was developed during
of the TES tank with a variable speed piping which is fed to each building. The the feasibility study to determine the
pumping system to match the site cooling primary pumping system pumps water impact of the proposals on energy usage
demand. The water is distributed to through the chillers and into the TES profiles and energy costs. The model was
Site Power Profile 2007 & 2010 (20th Feb) – CEP/TES Solution
cooled machines proposed
10000 for incorporation in the CEP.
9000
• It will allow chilled water to be
generated at night during off-peak
8000 tariff periods when electricity costs are
7000
lower and ambient air temperatures are
lower are more favourable, and stored
6000 in the TES tank for use the next day.
Power (kWe)
conditions as a function of time. directly on high voltage were able to be steel roof members proved a cost saving
The focus of the energy modelling and used. The chillers comprise an11kV motor of approximately $40,000 in capital cost.
building management control system and high voltage soft starter kit to enable
the site high voltage reticulation to be Avoided insulation: Medium Density
was to create an innovative solution that
directly coupled to the chillers without the Polyethylene (MDPE) piping has been
is dynamic (alive) and which constantly
need to reduce the 11kV to 415V power used for irrigation and water reticulation
changes its operating parameters to
supply (industry standard). Conventional for some time. Chilled water distribution
reflect the seasonal variance. The plant
practice would be to use motors that in buildings is generally constructed
operation is governed by an algorithm
operate on low voltage, which incur in metal pipes that require thermal
which is based on seasonal ambient
transformer efficiency losses, transformer insulation, normally 50mm polystyrene.
conditions, and also considers the input
capital cost, switchgear and switchboard By using MDPE pipework to reticulate
from temperature and humidity sensors.
capital cost; increased building floor area the chilled water throughout the campus,
to house additional indoor transformers insulation was avoided, and the greater
3.4 Further System Efficiencies 12M pipe lengths available reduced
and savings in long term maintenance.
Value adding to this project over and The estimated savings in avoiding these the number of joints, flexibility in the
above the CEP/TES design, included was $800,000 in capital cost. installation, and flexibility for future
the control strategy of the central plant; branch take offs, thus providing savings.
the selection of the high voltage chiller Reduced plant-room structure: Typically The wall thickness of the 500mm diameter
motors; the CEP piping arrangement to plant pipe work is suspended from the MDPE is 29.6mm which is directly
reduce the roof steel member sizes and roof structure, thus increasing the size buried in a compact sand fill, offering
selection of the underground reticulated of these structural elements. By using an high thermal performance, and inherent
chilled water piping (7.8kM). innovative chilled water pipe manifold vapour barrier and mechanical protection
arrangement where five headers were with the MDPE outer surface of the pipe.
Using high voltage equipment: The chiller stacked above each other on support
selected is a result of further energy frames, the weight of the headers High water temperature differential:
modelling with a three stage compression (majority of piping weight) was carried The chilled water on site has a fixed
centrifugal chiller selected. Due to the directly by the floor slab and not the steel supply temperature of 6°C and return
size of the plant, motors that operate roof framing. The reduction in size of the temperature of 15°C, which gives
• # 1 in performance …worldwide
• Largest global producer of Enthalpy Wheels
• The first choice of engineers /consultants …
worldwide
• Received AHRI Performance Award for
100% Success Rate for 7 consecutive years
Members of
green building council australia
member
CERTIFIED PERFORMANCE
www.bigfootsystems.com.au
BA/DRI/944C
www.drirotors.com
Contact our Australian Rep. Office Tel.: 08 92762307• Fax: 08 9375 7989
Mob. 0412932317• Email: sundermalkani@bigpond.com
Or, for QLD, NSW & ACT, Contact our Agent: Automatic Control Co. Pty Ltd., Brisbane
Tel: 07 3808 9400 • Fax: 07 3808 6955 • Mob. 0413 051 590 Pro Pipe Supplies Pty Ltd, 13-15 Main Street, Beverly, SA5009
Email: dfroes@automaticcontrol.com.au t: +61 8 8268 8633 enquiries@propipesupplies.com.au
USA | Brazil | Europe | Turkey | Malaysia | Thailand | Philippines | China | Korea | Japan | Australia
SE P TE M B E R 2 0 0 9 • Eco l ibri u m 37
FORUM
Caution tape
COMPACT FILL
Electrical and
data trunk cabling
MDPE branch
pipe for chilled water
a 9° temperature differential. electrical and mechanical services for the 3. Services corridor and common
Conventional systems tend to operate site was conceived. This enabled future trench arrangement.
on a 6–7° differential. Using a greater designers and building expansions to
differential requires 25 per cent lower utilise the parameters set for consistence As part of the high voltage study it was
flow rate, and thus requires less pumping and simplicity across the site. The Master revealed that the existing site network
energy and smaller pipes, 160mm to planning for the university comprises was frail and exposed to failure with
560mm ø. However this also required three key areas: non-homogenous conductors and three
the air-handing units within the building independent feeds. As part of the high
1. Standard for site wide chilled water
to be calibrated for these less common voltage upgrade, all conductors are
supply temperatures and pressures
parameters and the chillers to work for future building connections as upgraded to a homogenous size and ring
harder to restore the 6°C water during detailed above. main units were installed to enable back
the night time cooling cycle. feeding and system backup / redundancy.
2. High voltage (HV) site upgrade and
Services Master Plan: During the course rationalisation for future building The civil works created known service
of the design, a master plan of the program. corridors on site with a common trench
Greenhouse Gas
33,643 Tonnes CO2 24,729 Tonnes CO2 43,000 Tonnes CO2 31,000 Tonnes CO2
Generation per year
Table 1: Model Predictions for proposed and business-as-usual systems (Source: MGF, 2006)
SE P TE M B E R 2 0 0 9 • Eco l ibri u m 39