Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SYMPOSIUM
MATERIALS & ADVANCE MANUFACTURING (M&AM) TECHNICAL SESSION
AUGUST 7-9, 2018 - NOVI, MICHIGAN
ABSTRACT
FeMnAlC alloys exhibit lower density (6.5-7.2 g/cm3) than traditional military steels (7.9 g/cm3)
while maintaining similar energy absorption capabilities. Material substitutions in legacy systems
must meet existing form/fit/function requirements, limiting opportunities for lightweighting of
existing designs. This study examines production and material properties of thick plate with a
nominal chemistry of 30% Mn, 9%Al and 1%C, in the wrought condition.
Due to the high aluminum and carbon content, there are unique challenges to large scale (45+
ton heat) production versus typical armor steel chemistries. Lab-scale wrought and production
material are characterized, comparing microstructure, and mechanical properties. Processing
practices including teeming flux and rolling temperature are discussed. The high manganese
content of this alloy presents challenges for welding and machining practices, such as limited
compatibility of weld wires and substantial work hardening during many basic fabrication
operations. Mechanical property data and micrographs from initial gas metal arc welding and
machining are presented and discussed.
To date, the majority of work in this general alloy parameters need to be developed. Results from
chemistry has focused on thin sheet for automotive preliminary welding trials on small scale plate with
or small scale heats (500 lb) produced via vacuum commercially available welding consumables are
induction melting (VIM) or sand castings. [2] discussed, as well as observations from machining.
Production of thick plate in quantities appropriate The paper is organized as follows: primary
for Army ground vehicles presents additional lessons learned from each industrial pour, results
challenges, both in steel making and integration of from rolling and forging, heat treatment results,
material. This steel is fully austenitic and non- welding practices and characterization, and
magnetic, which can cause issues for handling in machining practices.
some plate production facilities. Welding and
machining parameters also must be developed for INDUSTRIAL POUR – SEPTEMBER 2016
successful integration into vehicle platforms. All pours were conducted by Ellwood Quality
Steels (EQS), in New Castle, PA using an eccentric
INTRODUCTION bottom tapping (EBT) electric arc furnace, and
FeMnAl steel has previously been evaluated in ingots were bottom poured. During this first
the cast form and in wrought form as produced by industrial heat, four 12”x54” ingots were
small-scale methods. [2] Material maturation for successfully cast. One of these ingots is shown in
armor application must address a number of key Figure 2.
areas: manufacturability, ballistic performance,
blast performance, weldability, machinability,
mechanical characterization for modeling and
simulation, and corrosion protection. This paper
focuses on the manufacturability and weldability,
with some discussion of machinability.
The effort to transition to large scale production is
pursuing arc furnace melting and bottom-fill
teeming of ingots which will then be hot rolled and
aged. There are many parameters which must be
evaluated that affect final chemistry,
microstructure, surface quality, defects, and overall
yield.
Figure 1 shows a typical process flow for
production of wrought FeMnAl plate.
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 2 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 3 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 4 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
Figure 6: Forged billet rolled to 0.5” thick plate at a such as centerline piping.
soaking temperature of 2128°F. Plate is ~ 6’ wide.
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 5 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 6 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 7 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
relative to the weld is shown in Figure 14. fracture transitioning to a brittle failure. The weld
metal underwent a fully ductile failure. Further
work to understand the root cause of the poor base
metal impact toughness is ongoing.
Tensile Results
Three tensile specimens were taken through the
plate thickness. Tensile curves for the base metal
are presented in Figure 16. The elastic modulus was
measured at 131 MPa for all specimens, with no
systematic variation between the plate faces and
Figure 14. Layout of test samples on welded plate core. However, the ultimate tensile strain and total
elongation showed a distinct difference between the
Charpy Results center and the face: the center samples are shown
Specimens for Charpy testing were machined in red, with faces in green and blue. Strain to failure
subsized from the ASTM E23 standard dimensions: or center samples ranged from 40%-50%, while
therefore, trends, rather than absolute values, are faces ranged from 50%-65% total elongation. This
discussed here. Absolute values should not be is believed to be due to the residual stress state of
directly compared to other testing. Typical the wrought plate from the rolling process. Further
specimen cross-section was 7.5mmx10mm. work regarding residual stress in these materials is
ongoing.
Samples were tested at -40°F.
The base metal showed substantially reduced
performance relative to the HAZ or weld material:
the base metal had an average breaking energy of
8.9J, the weld center had an average breaking
energy of 41.1J, and the HAZ had the highest
breaking energy, of 73.0 J. This trend in breaking
energies is reflected in the characteristic fracture
surface of the three areas, shown in Figure 15.
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 8 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
Welded Microstructure
Samples of the welded FeMnAl plate were
mounted and polished to a 1μm diamond finished,
and etched with 5% Nital, shown in Figure 19. Due
to the stainless steel filler metal, this etchant had
little effect on the weld metal, and hence grain
structures are not obvious. Polarizers were used to
help identify grain boundaries.
Figure 18. Tensile specimen post-testing showing small Figure 20. ER 316L filler on cast FeMnAl base plate
tear at the interface between the fusion zone and base with (upper left) composite EDS map, (upper right) SEM
metal. image (lower purple) Mn concentration (lower teal) Al
concentration (lower orange) Cr concentration (lower
While radiography showed full fusion,
yellow) Ni and (lower red) C concentration.
microstructural analysis showed an unmixed type
region at the edge of the fusion zone. Based on the manganese concentration, as well as
the chromium content, the porous region appears to
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 9 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
be entirely within the base metal: this is consistent the double vee groove. The cutting tool used was
with the hypothesis that this is an unmixed region. brand new, and retained for post-analysis.
It is currently hypothesized that this zone melted Stereoscopic images of the cutting bit and swarf are
during welding, but did not mix with the bead, and presented in Figure 22.
then due to system constraints and thermal
expansion coefficients, solidification resulted in the
formation of voids. Gleeble simulation of the
welding process will be undertaken soon to explore
this. During welding, the welders commented that
the pool did not flow well, another potential
hallmark of mixing issues.
Hardness
A microhardness map was prepared via Struers
Durascan, with a Vicker’s microindenter. Results
are presented in Figure 21. The weld bead is softer
than the base metal, as expected, but some
softening of the heat affected zone is observed. The
boundary zone is not obviously visible in this
particular analysis, despite concerns about the
mechanical properties of that region. Further
detailed hardness mapping of the porous region is
planned for future work.
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 10 of 11
Proceedings of the 2018 Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)
CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES
Wrought FeMnAl plate was successfully
produced using common, commercially viable [1] US Army PM Abrams, Abrams Special Topic:
large scale practices. Initial results also show Transportability IPT Briefing, 2015.
promise for weldability and machinability of this [2] R. Howell and J. Montgomery, Advancements in
Steel for Weight Reduction of P900 Armor Plate,
material. Further optimization of heat treatment, Survivability Materials Branch ARL, 2008.
welding and machining practices is required, as
[3] R. A. Howell, Microstructural Influence on Dynamic
well as additional characterization of industrially- Properties of Age Hardenable FeMnAl Alloys, Rolla:
produced plate. Missouri S&T, 2009.
[4] K. Sebeck, R. Gerth and R. Thyagarajan, "Abrams
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Weight Reduction Study," TARDEC Report #29078,
The information, data, or work presented herein Warren, 2017.
was conducted as an Advanced Vehicle Power [5] Y.-B. Kang, M.-S. Kim, S.-W. Lee, J.-W. Cho, M.-S.
Technology Alliance (AVPTA) "Extended Park and H.-G. Lee, "A Reaction BetweenHighMn
HighAlSteaalandCaO-SiO2-Type Molten MoldFlux:
Enterprise" project funded by the U.S. Army Tank Part II. Reaction Mechanism,Interface Morphology,
Automotive Research, Development and and Al2O3 Accumulation in Molten Mold Flux," Met.
Engineering Center (TARDEC), U.S. Department Trans B, vol. 44B, p. 309, 2013.
of Defense (DoD), Department of the Army. [6] O. Zambrano, "A General Perspective of Fe-Mn-Al-
AVPTA is Chartered under the auspices of the C Steels," Arxiv Cond-Mat 1707.01920, 2017.
Department of Energy / DoD Memorandum of
High Mn, High Al Steels for Thick Plate Armor Applications…, Sebeck et al.
Page 11 of 11