11/23/2019 Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Solution to Black Hole Information Paradox | Quanta Magazine

A BST R AC T I O N S B LOG

Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Fate of Black Holes

By C H A R L I E W O O D

November 19, 2019

Calculations involving a higher dimension are guiding physicists toward a misstep in Stephen Hawking’s legendary black hole
analysis.

20

Lucy Reading-Ikkanda/Quanta Magazine

ike cosmic hard drives, black holes pack troves of data into compact spaces. But ever since

L Stephen Hawking calculated in 1974 that these dense spheres of extreme gravity give o
and fade away, the fate of their stored information has haunted physicists.
heat

The problem is this: The laws of quantum mechanics insist that information about the past is never
lost, including the record of whatever fell into a black hole. But Hawking’s calculation contradicted
this. He applied both quantum mechanics and Albert Einstein’s theory of gravity to the space around a
black hole and found that quantum jitters cause the black hole to emit radiation that’s perfectly
random, carrying no information. As this happens the black hole shrinks and eventually disappears.

But does its information disappear with it, meaning quantum mechanics is wrong? Or does the problem
lie with Einstein’s theory? When forced to choose, many physicists back the quantum rule and suspect
that information somehow escapes in the black hole’s radiation, which in that case isn’t random after

https://www.quantamagazine.org/hologram-within-a-hologram-hints-at-solution-to-black-hole-information-paradox-20191119/ 1
11/23/2019 Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Solution to Black Hole Information Paradox | Quanta Magazine

all. Figuring out how the information gets out should point the way past Einstein’s theory to a more
complete quantum theory of gravity. Yet after 45 years of grappling with this “black hole information
paradox,” no one has pinpointed the alleged misstep in Hawking’s calculation.

Now, though, several noted black hole physicists think they may be closing in on a solution. Not even
the researchers themselves fully grasp the physical implications of the math they explore in a recent
paper. But in the abstract mathematical threads, they and others see the outlines of a bridge to the
black hole’s interior, an escape route for trapped data. They located this hidden path using an
imperfectly understood technique for spying on a black hole from a higher dimension.

“It’s magic,” said Ahmed Almheiri, a physicist at the Institute for Advanced Study (IAS) in Princeton,
New Jersey, who co-authored the recent paper. “We know how to prove” that the shift in perspective
works, he said, “but we don’t have a complete understanding of why this is happening.”

Raphael Bousso, a physicist at the University of California, Berkeley and an expert on the information
paradox, said of the new work, “I nd it interesting enough that I’m really working hard” to
understand it.

Abstractions navigates promising ideas in science and mathematics. Journey with us and join the
conversation.

See all Abstractions blog

https://www.quantamagazine.org/hologram-within-a-hologram-hints-at-solution-to-black-hole-information-paradox-20191119/ 2
11/23/2019 Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Solution to Black Hole Information Paradox | Quanta Magazine

The dimension-hopping technique that’s key to the new development is known as holography. Just like
a credit card hologram that pops out from a at sticker, a system like a black hole can be viewed in two
equivalent ways. There’s the familiar view of a black hole as a volume of space in which gravity is so
strong, and the fabric of space-time bends so steeply inward, that not even light can climb out.
Alternatively, the black hole can be thought of as a holographic projection from a at system of
quantum particles that remains gravity-free. Following the discovery of this duality by Juan
Maldacena, a physicist at IAS, in 1997, physicists have peered at many mysteries from these
complementary angles. They’re now using the holographic approach to try to track the ow of
information through a black hole.

First, a pair of papers that appeared in May analyzed how a black hole’s information content changes
as the object ages. In one of the papers, Almheiri and co-authors considered a simpli ed gravitational
black hole in two dimensions that’s equivalent to a one-dimensional system of quantum particles.
They found that at rst, as the black hole gobbles up matter and gets bigger, its information content
increases. But then, in its old age, as radiation starts spitting data back out, its information content
decreases, diverging from Hawking’s description. Geo rey Penington of Stanford University
independently came to similar conclusions. The papers found a new way to reproduce the conventional
wisdom that information should safely escape black holes, but they stopped short of explaining how it
does so — or where Hawking’s math went wrong.

The latest paper, posted online in late August, went further, o ering a new way to think about
Hawking’s math.

Holographers usually walk down a one-way street from a gravity- lled volume to a quantum atland,
where the math is easier. But in this new work, Almheiri, Maldacena and their IAS collaborators Raghu
Mahajan and Ying Zhao tried strolling both ways.

They took a 2D black hole and separately considered its two elements: the matter inside it, and the
gravity produced by that matter. As before, they viewed the 2D gravity as the hologram of 1D quantum
particles. But they treated the black hole’s matter like the at part of a second hologram, letting these
2D quantum particles pop into a 3D image. This strategy created an Inception-like hologram within a
hologram. “It seemed like it was a really crazy thing,” Almheiri said, “but we took a chance.”

While information appeared trapped in the black hole’s interior in 2D, the researchers found that after
the hologram popped o the page, portions of the black hole interior became geometrically linked to
portions of the exterior, providing an escape route for information. Consequently, outgoing black hole
radiation may look random to a passing astronaut doing simple experiments, Almheiri says, but
rigorous study would reveal subtly hidden information — the outcome many have been hoping for.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/hologram-within-a-hologram-hints-at-solution-to-black-hole-information-paradox-20191119/ 3
11/23/2019 Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Solution to Black Hole Information Paradox | Quanta Magazine

What Happens if You Fall Into a Black Hole?

Video: David Kaplan explores one of the biggest mysteries in physics: the apparent contradiction
between general relativity and quantum mechanics.

Filming by Petr Stepanek. Editing and motion graphics by MK12. Music by Steven Gutheinz.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/hologram-within-a-hologram-hints-at-solution-to-black-hole-information-paradox-20191119/ 4
11/23/2019 Hologram Within a Hologram Hints at Solution to Black Hole Information Paradox | Quanta Magazine

The holographic connection between the black hole’s interior and exterior supports an old hunch that
considering the two together should somehow resolve the information paradox. “They are providing
very signi cant new evidence in favor of that rule,” Penington said.

But experts stress that while the higher-dimensional bridge may let the information out, a detailed
account of how it is encoded in the radiation is still lacking. “This is the beginning of a theoretical
understanding of what’s going on in terms of radiation,” said Netta Engelhardt, a physicist at the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology who worked with Almheiri on the May publication, “but it’s not
an operational description for how to extract the information.”

The 3D view also helps clarify why 2D black holes eventually diverge from Hawking’s calculation. The
theorists traced the changes in the information content of the black hole by measuring the areas of
related geometric surfaces in the 3D hologram. The area of the smallest such surface gives the
information content. But as this surface grows, a second one eventually replaces it as the smallest.
Continuing to track the rst surface reproduces Hawking’s error, but switching to the second one
corrects the math by showing that the information contained in the black hole starts to drop.

In this way, the hologram within a hologram gives the desired answer to the question of what happens
to a 2D black hole’s information. Most experts assume that if the reasoning is correct, it should carry
over to higher-dimensional black holes like those in our universe. A common concern, however, is that
the authors might be reading too much meaning into this abstract calculation.

R E L AT E D :

1. Why Stephen Hawking’s Black Hole Puzzle Keeps Puzzling

2. Newfound Wormhole Allows Information to Escape Black Holes

3. Philosophers Debate New ‘Sonic Black Hole’ Discovery

4. The Double Life of Black Holes

Don Marolf, a physicist at the University of California, Santa Barbara who worked on the spring paper
with Almheiri, Engelhardt and Henry Max eld, praised the new work as a concrete model
demonstrating the earlier papers’ claims. However, Marolf worries that holography may not be as wise
a guide as Almheiri and Maldacena hope, because it’s possible to hop between dimensions on many
di erent paths. The route found in the new paper seems to work, but Marolf cautions that other
holographic constructions might disagree. For this reason, he said, “we’d all like to be able to do
something intrinsic to this 2D theory without invoking holography as a magic black box.”

Indeed, in ongoing work, Almheiri’s team and a number of other groups are pursuing a more grounded
description that they hope will reach the same conclusions as their hologram-within-a-hologram
proof without leaning on the crutch of the extra dimension.

But even if the fancy holography tricks don’t stand, black hole researchers express excitement that
Hawking’s information paradox is able to transport them to the boundaries of known physics. “On the
map that says, ‘Here be dragons’ — the quantum gravity [theory] that we’re searching for — the
dragons are a lot closer than we thought,” Bousso said.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/hologram-within-a-hologram-hints-at-solution-to-black-hole-information-paradox-20191119/ 5