Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o abstract
Article history: The chip formation for a Ti–6Al–4V alloy was studied at high cutting speeds combined with large uncut
Received 23 September 2012 chip thicknesses (0.1–0.25 mm). Orthogonal cutting tests were conducted by using uncoated carbide
Received in revised form tools on a specific ballistic set-up with cutting speeds from 300 m/min to 4400 m/min (5–75 m/s).
15 November 2012
A hypothesis on the mechanism of chip generation is proposed for this speed range validated by high-
Accepted 16 November 2012
Available online 29 November 2012
speed imaging system enabled direct observation of cutting process. A transition, from serrated more or
less regular with localized shearing and possible presence of cracking, to discontinuous at very high
Keywords: speed is observed.
Very high cutting speed The inclination of the segment Fseg is shown as resulting from the primary shear angle F that can be
Chip formation
modified by compression between the tool and the uncut part. A maximum value of 601 for Fseg is
Chip morphology
reached with increasing speed after which it decreases to 451 at very high speed.
Titanium alloy
Orthogonal cutting The cutting speed appears as the most important factor when compared with the uncut chip
thickness, in determining the formation of chips by affecting the frequency of segmentation, the shear
angles and the crack length.
The significant reduction of cutting forces occurring with increases in cutting speed was firstly
explained by the conflicting work hardening–thermal softening processes and then depended on
whether the deformation phase of the chip segment is occurred.
& 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0890-6955/$ - see front matter & 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2012.11.004
38 G. Sutter, G. List / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 66 (2013) 37–43
the occurrence of the chip segmentation. The first involves element method, that take into account all physical phenomena
adiabatic shear, favoured by the low thermal conductivity of the that occur in this domain.
titanium alloy, and the second involves crack initiation and
propagation. Based on observations from previous works includ-
ing experimental observations and simulations [5–9], Fig. 1 shows 2. Cutting experiments
schematically various stages of the shear localization evolution
leading to the formation of periodic serrated chips under rela- 2.1. Cutting tests
tively low or moderated cutting speeds. Fig. 1(a) presents the final
stage of the creation of a complete segment (I) which is oriented To study the machining of the Ti–6Al–4V titanium alloy in a
by an angle named fSeg and the beginning of a new shear band that wide range of conditions, cutting test were carried out on two
propagates from the tool tip. The new shear angle f is necessary experimental devices. A first range of cutting speeds was realized
lower than fSeg to respect the principle of volume conservation. on a NC lathe and a ballistic device is employed for higher cutting
Fig. 1(b) shows an intermediate stage of segment formation, the speeds. Identical type of uncoated carbide tools (SCMT 120408-235)
shear band is completely propagated with an intermediate shear without chip breaker was used on these two devices. The high-
angle fint and a form of straight line. The creation of segment (II) power NC lathe was equipped with a dynamometer KISTLER 9265B
begins with the shear banding. Crack initiation can be initiated and for the cutting force measurement. The significant diameter of the
propagated from the free surface to the tip, the shear band offering a workpiece (200 mm) was selected on the one hand to achieve high
privileged path for the fracture. cutting speeds and to the other hand to limit the effects of the
The range of very high cutting speeds when machining titanium curvature of the machined surface. Orthogonal cutting tests were
alloys is still however largely unexploited. The main reason is the performed by cutting discs with a width of 10 mm. The obtained
difficulty to achieve such speeds with conventional machine tools. speeds are ranged from 300 to 1200 m/min (5–20 m/s). The second
The results from the literature, exploring the very high speeds, device consists of a specific sensor that is used as a tools holding
typically use specific devices based on ballistic means that are fixture [13,14]. This sensor was mounted on a ballistic launcher (see
similar to the split Hopkinson bars [10–12]. These studies were Fig. 2) to complete the cutting speed range (12–80 m/s).
mainly interested in the appearance frequency of adiabatic shear The ballistic launcher consists of two coaxial tubes. Compressed
bands or the intensity of the chip segmentation. The mechanisms air of the gas gun was used to propel a projectile through a launch
of chip formation are quite different from those encountered at tube on the two cutting tools so as to ensure its rectilinear
conventional speeds because the plastic instability is more intense displacement. A set of strain gauges glued on the load sensor
and is accompanied by amplified phenomena of ductile or brittle supporting the tools records the axial component of the cutting
fracture. Due to the high speed, the dynamics of cutting itself is forces. A mutual domain of cutting conditions exists for the two
changed, particularly with regard to the chip removing. In this different experimental devices. The validation of the experiments is
paper, the field of very high speeds (up to 80 m/s) is explored, ensured by superposition of the results. With the good accessibility
combined with a large uncut chip thickness (up to 0.25 mm) in of the second device, an intensified camera can be placed close to
order to study the evolution of the chip morphology for the Ti– the cutting zone. Snapshots with high magnification may be taken in
6Al–4V titanium alloy. The dynamics of chip formation and the real time. However, due to the dynamical sequences of the serrated
significant mechanisms that predominate in the field of extreme chips for the explored cutting speeds, the photographs are not as
cutting speeds are studied. The proposed work is also important to sharp as the pictures obtained in the case of continuous chips for the
help to validate the numerical cutting models based on the finite same cutting speeds [15]. Nevertheless, some images are still usable
φ I
cutting φ cutting
I
cutting
I II
tool tool II tool
φι φιnt
A workpiece A workpiece A workpiece
receiving tube
intensified CCD camera
tools holding
fixture detail of cutting process
tool
specimen chip
launch tube
Support
specimen
Chip
strain gauge tool
cutting tool
and can adequately support the hypotheses on the mechanism of the initial shear similar to the one that describes the formation of
chip formation described in the following paragraphs. a continuous chip in the primary shear zone. Nevertheless, it may
be possible to have an order of magnitude for f by a geometric
analysis as suggested for example by Gente and Hoffmeister [11].
2.2. Geometry of the chip
Considering that an element of volume, characterized by the
angle f, the length p and the width d (cf. Fig. 4), is the source
In these experiments the chip shape was systematically
of a segment with the inclination fseg and the width dch, by
investigated at each cutting conditions using optical microscopy.
applying the condition of incompressibility in plastic deforma-
The chips produced were collected and polished to measure the
tion, we obtain the balance equation:
thicknesses t2max and t2min, dch the distance between each seg- !
ments and fseg the inclination angle, see Fig. 3. t1 d t 2max
t1 p ¼ ¼ dch dch tanfseg ð2Þ
From the values of t2max and t2min, the degree of segmentation sinf cosfseg
G was evaluated by:
Finally, with the assumption that the values of d and dch are
t 2max t 2min close (d ¼dch), the initial shear angle f may be estimated by the
G¼ ð1Þ
t 2max following equation:
0 1
As described in the introduction part, the shear angle f and
t 1
the inclination angle of a segment fseg are differentiated as shown f ¼ arcsin@ A ð3Þ
in Fig. 4. The angle fseg is actually measured on the collected t 2max =cosfseg dch tanfseg
chips while the shear angle f cannot be. The angle f represents
The frequency of serration f can be defined, as being the
number of segments produced per unit time. This frequency
was obtained for a continuous chip as follows:
Number of segments
f¼ ð4Þ
Time of cutting
d
Φ t1 3.2. Evolution of the shear angle
workpiece The study of inclination of the segment fseg and the initial shear
angle f can be useful for understanding the mechanism of chip
Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of the serrated chip. formation. When the cutting speed increases, the segment angle
40 G. Sutter, G. List / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 66 (2013) 37–43
Fig. 5. Chip morphologies for titanium alloy machined at different cutting speeds with two uncut chip thicknesses t1 ¼ 0.1 mm (1–6) and t1 ¼ 0.25 mm (7–12).
700 50
t1=0.25 (NC lathe)
600 40
seg [°]
t1=0.25 (BS)
30
t1=0.1 (BS)
400 20
t1=0.25 (NC lathe)
300 10
t1=0.25 (BS)
200 0
0 20 40 60 80
100 Cutting speed [m/s]
0
0 20 40 60 80
80
Cutting speed [m/s]
70
1.2 60
50
[°]
1
40
t1=0.1 (NC lathe)
0.8 30
t1=0.1 (BS)
20
t1=0.25 (NC lathe)
G
0.6
10
t1=0.25 (BS)
t1=0.1 (NC lathe)
0
0.4 0 20 40 60 80
t1=0.1 (BS)
Cutting speed [m/s]
0.2 t1=0.25 (NC lathe)
Fig. 7. (a) Inclination of the segment and (b) shear angle evolutions versus the
t1=0.25 (BS)
cutting speed.
0
0 20 40 60 80
Cutting speed [m/s] must be correlated with the evolution of the initial shear angle f
(Fig. 7(b)). Indeed, the shear angle tends to a value estimated to be
Fig. 6. (a) Maximum chip thickness t2max and (b) G, versus the cutting speed.
Experiments results obtained on a NC lathe and the ballistic set-up (BS). around 451. This is the limit value that is expected in the formation
of the continuous chips at very high cutting speeds. This trend was
fseg tends to a limit value around 601 (Fig. 7(a)), then falls also observed experimentally in the case of steels with low carbon
progressively towards a value around 451. The evolution of fseg content that mostly produce continuous chips, [15,16].
G. Sutter, G. List / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 66 (2013) 37–43 41
SERRATED CHIP
REGULAR
Cutting Cutting Cutting
tool tool tool
workpiece
workpiece workpiece
workpiece workpiece
workpiece
DISCONTINUOUS
Cutting Cutting Cutting Cutting
tool tool tool tool
CHIP
workpiece workpiece workpiece workpiece
Fig. 8. Schematic sequences of chips formation in Ti alloys machining for high cutting speed.
dynamics of chip removal as described in the previous section. extrusion [23] limits the decrease in cutting forces that then tend
The signal presented in Fig. 10 that defines the mean cutting to stabilize. At very high speed, as the segments are instantly
force shows a natural frequency of 119 kHz. This frequency is ejected, the cutting forces are expected to decrease.
correlated to the frequency of the segmentation f, deduced from As shown in Fig. 12, the frequency clearly increases with
the chip morphology and varying between 110 and 140 kHz. speed. The saturation observed beyond 40 m/s is consequential
On the evolution of the mean cutting force (Fig. 11 [3,11,18–22]), to the impossibility of measuring the spacing of the segments that
a rapid drop corresponding to the cutting speeds slower than are then detached. However, the frequency is necessarily less
5–10 m/s (300–600 m/mn) was observed. This could be explained than the asymptotic value. With the increasing depth of cut, the
by the predominant effect of thermal softening of the material as a frequency of segmentation is reduced but follows an increasing
result of a strong localized heating (low thermal conductivity). trend with speed. However, the trend seems to be less marked
This drop tends to slow down between 10 and 40 m/s (600– below 40 m/s.
2400 m/min). With increasing speed, the effect of dynamic strain
hardening and strain rate hardening is more competitive than the
thermal effects and limits the drop with speed. This trend may be 5. Conclusion
correlated with the saturation of the primary shear angle and the
shear angle of segmentation that were previously observed. The goal of this work was to propose a detailed analysis of
For the cutting speed ranging from 10 to 40 m/s, the segments geometry of the chip alloy Ti–6Al–4V. The originality of this
are increasingly deformed. This deformation is most clearly approach lies in the speed range explored varying between
observed for the small depth of cut (t1 ¼0.1 mm). The segments 300 m/min and 4400 m/min (5–75 m/s) that corresponds for
are submitted to a compression phase during their extrusion that carbide tools to the field of high speed (500 m/min) and very
could explain the slowdown in the fall of cutting forces. For the large high speed (upper 600 m/mn). This analysis helps to understand
depth of cut t1 ¼0.25 mm the compression phase is less clear. the process of chip formation and proposes a hypothesis of their
At speeds beyond 40 m/s (2400 m/min), the segments do not generation during high speed machining. The ability to save
have time to be evacuated. The cracking is not complete (the snapshots of the cut in progress has complemented the post-
crack length decreases) and a heel connects segments preventing mortem micrographic analysis of chips and strengthens the
their evacuation. The segment is then compressed between the hypotheses.
workpiece and the cutting tool. It is only after the compression The main results are:
phase that it leaves the cutting area. The energy consumed by the
– A monitoring of the evolution of the chip geometry is pro-
posed. Two main types were observed for the explored speed
0.25 range: (1) serrated more or less regular with localized shearing
500
0.20
OUTPUT SIGNAL [V]
0.05
200
-0.05
0.0 1.0x10-4 2.0x10-4 3.0x10-4 4.0x10-4 5.0x10-4 0
0 20 40 60 80 100
TIME [s]
Cutting Speed [m/s]
Fig. 10. Typical signal recorded during the cutting test on the ballistic set-up (BS), Fig. 12. Effects of the cutting speed on segmentation frequency in Ti alloy
corresponding to the specific cutting force: Vc ¼ 32 m/s t1 ¼ 0.1 mm. machining.
4000
Our Experiments
3000
Gente and Hoffmeister [11]
Hoppe [19]
Illgner [20]
cotterell [22]
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Cutting Speed [m/s]
Fig. 11. Specific cutting force evolution of Ti–6Al–4V after our experiments and previous results [3,11,18–22].
G. Sutter, G. List / International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture 66 (2013) 37–43 43
and possible presence of cracks and (2) discontinuous at very [2] A.K.M. Amin, A.F. Ismail, M.K. Nor Khairusshima, Effectiveness of uncoated
high speed. A transitional stage involving a compression stage WC–Co and PCD inserts in end milling of titanium alloy Ti–6Al–4V, Journal of
Materials Processing Technology 192 (2007) 147–158.
of the segments separates these two types. [3] J. Barry, G. Byrne, D. Lennon, Observations on chip formation and acoustic
– A process of creation and modification of the segments is emission in machining Ti–6Al–4V alloy, International Journal of Machine
proposed. Compared with previous results found in the litera- Tools and Manufacture 41 (2001) 1055–1070.
[4] S. Sun, M. Brandt, M.S. Dargusch, Characteristics of cutting forces and chip
ture, higher speeds and cutting tests with bigger uncut chip
formation in machining of titanium alloys, International Journal of Machine
thickness are proposed. At very high speed (Vc 445 m/s and Tools and Manufacture 49 (2009) 561–568.
t1 ¼0.25 mm), the chip formation follows a cyclic phase (repe- [5] Z.B. Hou, R. Komanduri, On a thermomechanical model of shear instability in
titive) which is reset after the formation and removal of a machining, CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology 44 (1995) 69–73.
[6] R. Komanduri, Z.B. Hou, On thermoplastic shear instability in the machining
segment. This is confirmed by photographs taken during of a titanium alloy (Ti–6Al–4V), Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A
machining. The chips are then of a regular triangular shape, 33 (2002) 2995–3010.
because they have no suffered compression phase. [7] M. Baker, An investigation of the chip segmentation process using finite
elements, Technische Mechanik 23 (2003) 1–9.
– The inclination of the segment Fseg results from the primary
[8] C.Z. Duan, M.J. Wang, J.Z. Pang, G.H. Li, A calculational model of shear strain
shear angle F amplified by a phase of compression more or and strain rate within shear band in a serrated chip formed during high speed
less intense. Consequently, Fseg is generally greater than or machining, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 178 (2006) 274–277.
equal to F. A maximum value of 601 for Fseg is also observed [9] M. Calamaz, D. Coupard, F. Girot, A new material model for 2D numerical
simulation of serrated chip formation when machining titanium alloy Ti–
with increasing speed and then returns to 451 at very high 6Al–4V, International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture 48 (2008)
speed. This trend reversal occurs more rapidly with t1. 275–288.
– Compared to the uncut chip thickness, the cutting speed [10] E. El-Magd, C. Treppmann, High speed quick-stop tests with the split
Hopkinson bar, In: Scientific Fundamentals of HSC (Ed. by Hrsg. H. Schulz),
appears as the most important factor in determining the chip
Carl Hanser Verlag, München – Wien, (2001) 199–201.
formation. It mainly affects the frequency of segmentation, the [11] A. Gente, H.W. Hoffmeister, C.J. Evans, Chip formation in machining Ti6Al4V
shear angles and the crack length. at extremely high cutting speeds, CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology 50
– The chip formation can explain the evolution of efforts with (2001) 49–52.
[12] A. Molinari, C. Musquar, G. Sutter, Adiabatic shear banding in high speed
cutting speed and more specifically the saturation observed at machining of Ti–6Al–4V: experiments and modeling, International Journal of
high speed. Plasticity 18 (2002) 443–459.
[13] G. Sutter, L. Faure, A. Molinari, A. Delime, D. Dudzinski, Experimental Analysis
of the Cutting Process and Chip Formation at High Speed Machining, 1997.
Initially (0–10 m/s), efforts drop due to the predominant effect
[14] G. Sutter, A. Molinari, Analysis of the cutting force components and friction in
of thermal softening of the material as a result of a strong high speed machining, Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering 127
localized heating (low thermal conductivity). (2005) 245.
With increasing speed (10–40 m/s), the effects of dynamic [15] G. Sutter, A. Molinari, G. List, X. Bi, Chip flow and scaling laws in high speed
metal cutting, Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering 134 (2012) 9.
strain hardening and strain rate hardening become more compe- [16] G. Sutter, Chip geometries during high-speed machining for orthogonal
titive than thermal effects and significantly limit the efforts drop cutting conditions, International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture
with speed. The chips are increasingly segmented with more 45 (2005) 719–726.
[17] V.P. Astakhov, Tribology of Metal Cutting, Tribology and Interface Engineer-
pronounced cracking. The frequency of segmentation results in a
ing Series, Briscoe, BJ (Ed.), (2006) 25–29.
reduction of cutting forces. However, if cracking is not complete, [18] H.W. Hoffmeister, A. Gente, T.H. Weber, Chip formation at titanium alloys
the segment remains trapped between the workpiece and the tool under cutting speed of up to 100 m/s, in: 2nd International Conference on
and is compressed before being expelled. The energy consumed High Speed Machining, PTW Darmstadt University, 1999 21–28.
[19] S. Hoppe, Experimental and Numerical Analysis of Chip Formation in Metal
limits the efforts drop and the forces tend to reach a plateau. Cutting, Ph.D. Thesis, Fakultät für Maschinenwesen der Rheinisch-Westfälischen
The higher speed (40–75 m/s) favours the expulsion of seg- Technischen Hochschule Aachen, 2003.
ments and hence the reduction of cutting forces. Increasing the [20] H.J. Illgner, Hochgeschwindigkeitsfräsen schwer zerspanbarer Legierungen,
Ph.D. Thesis, TH Darmstadt, Carl Hanser Verlag, 1990.
depth of cut accelerates the process of chip flow and may be
[21] S. Larbi, Contribution a l’étude de l’usinage a grandes vitesses de matériaux
combined with the speed effect. métalliques par simulation sur un banc d’essai a base de barres de
Hopkinson, Ph.D. Thesis, Université de Nantes, 1990.
[22] M. Cotterell, G. Byrne, Characterisation of chip formation during orthogonal
References
cutting of titanium alloy Ti–6Al–4V, CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science
and Technology 1 (2008) 81–85.
[1] A.E. Bayoumi, J.Q. Xie, Some metallurgical aspects of chip formation in cutting [23] G. Poulachon, A.L. Moisan, M. Dessoly, A contribution to the study of the
Ti–6 wt% Al–4 wt% V alloy, Materials Science and Engineering A 190 (1995) cutting mechanisms in hard turning, Mecanique and Industries 3 (2002)
173–180. 291–299.