Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. How did the Israel – Palestine conflict start in the first The 1948 war ended with Israel roughly controlling the
place?
territory that you will see marked on today's maps as "Israel";
The conflict has been going on since the early 1900s, when the everything except for the West Bank and Gaza, which is where
mostly-Arab, mostly-Muslim region was part of the Ottoman most Palestinian fled to (many also ended up in refugee camps in
Empire and, starting in 1917, a "mandate" run by the British neighboring countries) and are today considered the Palestinian
Empire. Hundreds of thousands of Jews were moving into the area, territories. The borders between Israel and Palestine have been
as part of a movement called Zionism among mostly European disputed and fought over ever since. So has the status of those
Jews to escape persecution and establish their own state in their Palestinian refugees and the status of Jerusalem.
ancestral homeland. (Later, large numbers of Middle Eastern Jews
That's the first major dimension of the conflict: reconciling
also moved to Israel, either to escape anti-Semitic violence or
the division that opened in 1948. The second began in 1967, when
because they were forcibly expelled.)
Israel put those two Palestinian territories under military
Communal violence between Jews and Arabs in British occupation.
Palestine began spiraling out of control. In 1947, the United
Nations approved a plan to divide British Palestine into two
mostly independent countries, one for Jews called Israel and one 2. Why is Israel occupying the Palestinian territories?
for Arabs called Palestine. Jerusalem, holy city for Jews and
Israel's military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza began
Muslims, was to be a special international zone.
in 1967. Up to that point, Gaza had been (more or less) controlled
The plan was never implemented. Arab leaders in the region saw it by Egypt and the West Bank by Jordan. But in 1967 there was
as European colonial theft and, in 1948, invaded to keep Palestine another war between Israel and its Arab neighbors, during which
unified. The Israeli forces won the 1948 war, but they pushed well Israel occupied the two Palestinian territories. (Israel also took
beyond the UN-designated borders to claim land that was to have control of Syria's Golan Heights, which it annexed in 1981, and
been part of Palestine, including the western half of Jerusalem. Egypt's Sinai Peninsula, which it returned to Egypt in 1982.)
They also uprooted and expelled entire Palestinian communities,
Israeli forces have occupied and controlled the West Bank ever blur the borders and expand land that Israel could claim for itself in
since. It withdrew its occupying troops and settlers from Gaza in any eventual peace deal.
2005, but maintains a full blockade of the territory, which has The Israeli occupation of the West Bank is all-consuming
turned Gaza into what human rights organizations for the Palestinians who live there, constrained by Israeli
sometimes call an "open-air prison" and has pushed the checkpoints and 20-foot walls, subject to an Israeli military
unemployment rate up to 40 percent. justice system in which on average two children are arrested
Israel says the occupation is necessary for security given its every day, stuck with an economy stifled by strict Israeli border
tiny size: to protect Israelis from Palestinian attacks and to provide control, and countless other indignities large and small.
a buffer from foreign invasions. But that does not explain the
settlers.
Settlers are Israelis who move into the West Bank. They are 3. Why is there fighting today between Israel and Gaza?
widely considered to violate international law, which forbids an On the surface, this is just the latest round of fighting in 27
occupying force from moving its citizens into occupied territory. years of war between Israel and Hamas, a Palestinian militant
Many of the 500,000 settlers are just looking for cheap housing; group that formed in 1987 seeks Israel's destruction and is
most live within a few miles of the Israeli border, often in the internationally recognized as a terrorist organization for its attacks
around surrounding Jerusalem. targeting civilians — and which since 2006 has ruled Gaza. Israeli
Others move deep into the West Bank to claim land for Jews, out forces periodically attack Hamas and other militant groups in
of religious fervor and/or a desire to see more or all of the West Gaza, typically with air strikes but in 2006 and 2009 with ground
Bank absorbed into Israel. While Israel officially forbids this and invasions. The latest round of fighting was sparked when
often evicts these settlers, many are still able to take root. members of Hamas in the West Bank murdered three Israeli youths
who were studying there on June 10. Though the Hamas members
In the short term, settlers of all forms make life for
appear to have acted without approval from their leadership, which
Palestinians even more difficult, by forcing the Israeli government
nonetheless praised the attack, Israel responded by arresting large
to guard them with walls or soldiers that further constrain
numbers of Hamas personnel in the West Bank and with air strikes
Palestinians. In the long term, the settlers create what are
against the group in Gaza.
sometimes called "facts on the ground": Israeli communities that
After some Israeli extremists murdered a Palestinian youth in One-state solution: The first is to erase the borders and put
Jerusalem and Israeli security forces cracked down on protests, Israelis and Palestinians together into one equal, pluralistic state,
compounding Palestinian outrage, Hamas and other Gaza groups called the "one-state solution." Very few people think this could be
launched dozens of rockets into Israel, which responded with many viable for the simple reason of demographics; Arabs would very
more air strikes. So far the fighting has killed one Israeli and 230 soon outnumber Jews. After generations of feeling disenfranchised
Palestinians; two UN agencies have separately estimated that 70- and persecuted by Israel, the Arab majority would almost certainly
plus percent of the fatalities are civilians. On Thursday, July 17, vote to dismantle everything that makes Israel a Jewish state.
Israeli ground forces invaded Gaza, which Israel says is to shut Israelis, after everything they've done to finally achieve a Jewish
down tunnels that Hamas could use to cross into Israel. state after thousands of years of their own persecution, would
never surrender that state and willingly become a minority among
That get backs to that essential truth about the conflict today:
a population they see as hostile.
Palestinian civilians endure the brunt of it. While Israel targets
militants and Hamas targets civilians, Israel's disproportionate Destruction of one side: The second way this could end is
military strength and its willingness to target militants based in with one side outright vanquishing the other, in what would
dense urban communities means that Palestinians civilians are far certainly be a catastrophic abuse of human rights. This is the
more likely to be killed than any other group. option preferred by extremists such as Hamas and far-right Israeli
settlers. In the Palestinian extremist version, Israel is abolished and
But those are just the surface reasons; there's a lot more going on
replaced with a single Palestinian state; Jews become a minority,
here as well.
most likely replacing today's conflict with an inverse conflict. In
the Israeli extremist version, Israel annexes the West Bank and
Gaza entirely, either turning Palestinians into second-class citizens
4. How is the conflict going to end?
in the manner of apartheid South Africa or expelling them en
There are three ways the conflict could end. Only one of them
masse.
is both viable and peaceful — the two-state solution — but it is
Two-state solution: The third option is for both Israelis and
also extremely difficult, and the more time goes on the harder it
Palestinians to have their own independent states; that's called the
gets.
"two-state solution" and it's advocated by most everyone as the
only option that would create long-term peace. But it requires
working out lots of details so thorny and difficult that it's not clear of "land swaps" in exchange for settler-occupied territory — but
if it will, or can, happen. Eventually, the conflict will have dragged it's still hard. The more time goes on, the more settlements expand,
on for so long that this solution will become impossible. the harder it becomes to create a viable Palestinian state.
Those are all very difficult problems. But here's the thing: time
is running out. The more that the conflict drags on, the more
difficult it will be to solve any of these issues, much less all of
them. That will make it harder and harder for Israel to justify
keeping Gaza under blockade and the West Bank under
occupation; eventually it will have to unilaterally withdraw, which
the current leadership opposes, or it will have to annex the
territories and become either an apartheid-style state that denies
full rights to those new Palestinian citizens or abandon its Jewish
state.