Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CLIENT I CONSULTANT
MODEL SERVICES AGREEMENT
F IDIC has now published the "White Book Guide" which includes
comments on clauses in the Model Services Agreement and notes
towards .the preparation of Appendices A, B and C ("Scope of Servi-
ces", "Personnel, Equipment, Facilities and Services of Others to be
Provided by the Client" and "Remuneration and Payment").
I t may also be helpful for users to refer to the other FlDIC publi-
cations, such as:
- Selection by Ability
© FIDIC 1991 3
. ,.:
AGREEMENT 7
OBLIGATIONS OF 7. Information 12
THE CLIENT 8. Decisions 12
9. Assistance 12
10. Equipment and Facilities 12
11. Client's Personnel 12
12. Services of Others 12
© FlDIC 1991 5
CONDITIONS OF THE
CLIENT/CONSULTANT
MODEL SERVICES
AGREEMENT
STANDARD CONDITIONS
DEFINITIONS AND
INTERPRETATION
DEFINITIONS 1. The following words and expressions shall have the meanings assigned
to them except where the context otherwise requires:
(i) "Project" means the project named in Part II for which the
Works are to be provided. '
(iv) "Client" means the party named in the Agreement, who em-
ploys the Consultant, and legal successors to the Client and
permitted assignees.
(vi) "party" and "parties" means the Client and the Consultant and
"third party" means any other person or entity as the context
reqmres.
© FIDIC 1991 9
OBLIGATIONS
OF THE CONSULTANT
SCOPE OF 3. The Consultant shall perform Services relating to the Project. The Scope
SERVICES of the Services is stated in Appendix A.
DUTY OF CARE 5. (i) The Consultant shall exercise reasonable skil1, care and diligence
AND EXERCISE in the performance of his obligations under the Agreement.
OF AUTHORITY
(ii) Where the Services include the exercise of powers or performance
of duties authorised or required by the terms of a contract between
the Client and any third party, the Consultant shall:
(a) act in accordance with the contract provided that the details
of such powers and duties are acceptable to him where they
are not described in Appendix A.
CLIENT'S 6. Anything supplied by or paid for by the Client for the use of the Con-
PROPERTY sultant shall be the property of the Client and where practicable shall
be so marked. When the Services are completed or terminated the
Consultant shall furnish inventories to the Client of what has not been
consumed in the performance of the Services and shall deliver it as
directed by the Client. Such delivery shall be regarded as an Additional
Service.
© FIDIC 1991 11
PERSONNEL
SUPPLY OF 13. The personnel who are sent by the Consultant to work in the country of
PERSONNEL the Project shall have been physically examined and found fit for their
assignments, and their qualifications shall be acceptable to the Client.
REPRESENTATIVES 14. For the administration of the Agreement each party shall designate the
official or individual to be his representative.
CHANGES IN 15. If it is necessary to replace any person, the party responsible for the
PERSONNEL appointment shall immediately arrange for replacement by a person of
comparable competence.
(i) such request shall be in writing stating the reasons for it and
(ii) the party making the request shall bear the cost of replacement
unless misconduct or inability to perform satisfactorily is
established as the reason.
© FIDIC 1991 13
Indemnity 18.2
So far as the applicable law permits, the Client shall indemnify the
Consultant against the adverse effects of all claims including such
claims by third parties which arise out of or in connection with the
Agreement:
(i) except insofar as they are covered by the insurances arranged
under the terms of Clause 19.
(ii) made after the expiry of the period of liability referred to in
Clause 17.
Exceptions 18.3
Clauses 18.1 and 18.2 do not apply to claims arising:
(i) from deliberate default or reckless misconduct, or
(ii) otherwise than in connection with the performance of obligations
under the Agreement.
INSURANCE 19. The Client can request in writing that the Consultant
FOR LIABILITY
AND INDEMNITY (i) insures against his liability under Clause 16.1,
(ii) increases his insurance against liability under Clause 16.1 over
that for which he was insured at the date of the Client's first
invitation to him for a proposal for the Services,
(iii) insures against public/third party liability,
(iv) increases his insurance against public/third party liability over
that for which he was insured at the date of the Client's first
invitation to him for a proposal for the Services,
(v) effects other insurances.
INSURANCE 20. Unless otherwise requested by the Client in writing the Consultant shall
OF CLIENT'S make all reasonable efforts to insure on terms acceptable to the Client:
PROPERTY
(i) against loss or damage to the property of the Client supplied or
paid for under Clause 6.
(ii) against liabilities arising out of the use of such property.
© FIDIC 1991 15
ABANDONMENT. 27. By Notice of the Client 27.1
SUSPENSION OR (i) The Client may suspend all or part of the Services or terminate
TERMINATION the Agreement by notice of at least 56 days to the Consultant who
shall immediately make arrangements to stop the Services and
minimise expenditure.
(ii) If the Client considers that the Consultant is without good reason
not discharging his obligations he can inform the Consultant by
notice stating the grounds for the notice. If a satisfactory reply is
not received within 21 days the Client can by a further notice
terminate the Agreement provided that such further noti~e is given
within 35 days of the Client's fmmer notice. ·
(i) when 28 days after the due date for payment of an invoice he has
not received payment of that part of it which has not by that time
been contested in writing, or
RIGHTS AND 29. Tennination of the Agreement shall not prejudice or affect the
LIABILITIES accrued rights or claims and liabilities of the parties.
OF PARTIES
After termination of the Agreement, the provisions of Clause 18 shall
remain in force.
© FIDiC 1991 17
(c) impose taxes or differential rates of exchange for the
transfer from abroad of Foreign Currency into the Client's
country by the Consultant for Local Currency expenditure
and subsequent re-transfer abroad of Local Currency up to
the same amount such as to inhibit the Consultant in the
performance of the Services or to result in financial
disadvantage to him,
the Client warrants that such shall be deemed circumstances
justifying the application of Clause 26 if alternative financial
arrangements are not made to the satisfaction of the Consultant.
DISPUTED 34. If any item or part of an item in an invoice submitted by the Consultant
INVOICES is contested by the Client, the Client shall give prompt notice with
reasons and shall not delay payment on the remainder of the invoice.
Sub-clause (ii) of Clause 31 shall apply to all contested amounts which
are finally determined to have been payable to the Consultant.
INDEPENDENT 35. The Consultant shall maintain up-to-date records which clearly
AUDIT identify relevant time and expense.
Except where the Agreement provides for lump sum payments, not later
than twelve months after the completion or termination of the Services,
the Client can at notice of not less than 7 days require that a reputable
firm of accountants nominated by him audit any amount claimed hy
the Consultant by attending during normal working hours at the
office where the records are maintained.
© FIDIC 1991 19
~ Page 21
IIIDIC
'¢.!1:1
The Executive Committee of FIDIC recommended at its 132nd Executive
Committee Meeting on November 27, 1995, that these proposed revisions to
clauses 43 and 44 be included in all future sales of the 2nd Edition 1991 of the
"White Book".
Subject to Clause 17, any claim for loss or damage arising out of breach or
termination of the Agreement, shall be settled between the Client and the
Consultant. If this negotiation is not successful, the parties will jointly agree to
the appointment of a Mediator to assist the parties to reach an amicable
resolution of their dispute, a procedure that is private and without prejudice.
ARBITRATION 44
If the mediation fails, with the agreement of the parties, the Mediator will record
.those facts that the parties have agreed. All other matters in dispute will be
referred to an Arbitrator, who will be allowed access to the recorded and agreed
facts only. The Mediator's role will cease on the appointment of the Arbitrator.
He will not be available to appear as a witness in the arbitration, or to provide
any additional evidence obtained during the mediation.
The arbitration will be conducted in accordance with the rules stipulated in Part
II in force at the effective date of the agreement on the basis that the parties
agree to waive their rights to any form of appeal. insofar as such waiver can
validly be made.
8 December 1995.
SETTLEMENT
OF DISPUTES
CLAIMS FOR 43. Subject to Clause 17, any claim for loss or damage arising out of breach
LOSS OR or termination of the Agreement shall be agreed between the Client and
DAMAGE the Consultant or failing agreement shall be referred to arbitration in
accordance with Clause 44.
ARBITRATION 44. Any dispute or claim arising out of or relating to this Agreement
or the breach, termination or invalidity thereof, shall be settled by
arbitration in accordance with the Rules stipulated in Patt II in force at
the effective date of the Agreement.
The parties agree to comply with the awards resulting from arbitration
and waive their rights to any form of appeal insofar as such waiver can
validly be made.
© FIDIC 1991 21
CONDITIONS OF PARTICULAR APPLICATION
1. Definitions
Reckoned from
22. Commencement
Completion
Agreed Compensation
for overdue payment percent per day
--
Currencies of payments
--
Rate of exchange to
currency of Agreemen t
Ruling language _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
© FIDIC 1991 23
37. Principal place of business _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
41. Notices-----------------
Telex Nr
Facsimile telephone Nr
Consultant's a d d r e s s · - - - - - - - - - - - -
Facsimile telephone Nr
© FIDIC 1991 25
B. Additional Clauses
.il
27
© FIDIC 1991
j
APPENDIX A
SCOPE The Scope of the Consultant's Services as finally negotiated and agreed
OF SERVICE should be clearly expressed in Appendix A.
See the White Book Guide for additional details on how to complete
this Appendix.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
,1
I
I
I
I
i © FIDIC 1991 29
APPENDIX B
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
i © FIDIC 1991 31
APPENDIX C
- methods of payment;
- price changes;
- taxation; and
- contingencies
© F1DIC 1991 33
Cut line for" 8.5 x 1 J" format -<
•
[f)
:~---·-*··----------'---·-··-··-:-~
F
i
..
' ·'
~
\
·Tendering Procedure
Page
Foreword 1
Acknowledgements 2
Introduction 3
Procedural Flowchart 5
Procedure and Notes 9
3
PROCEDURAL FLOWCHARTS I of III
I I
- ->~
I I
2.1 I
. PREPARE PREQUALIFICATION
I
DOCUMENTS COMPRISING:
PREPARATION OF I • LETIER OF INVITATION I
PREQUALIFICATION I • INFORMATION ABOUT I
I PREQUALIFICATION PROCEDURE "
DOCUMENTS • PROJECT INFORMATION
I
I I
• PREQUALIFICATION APPLICATION
I I
I I
I PLACE PREQUALIFICATION I
ADVERTISEMENT IN PRESS, EMBASSIES
2.2 I
ETC. AS APPROPRIATE STATING:
I
I I
INVITATION TO I
• EMPLOYER & ENGINEER
I
• OUTLINE OF PROJECT
PREQUALIFY I (SCOPE, LOCATION, PROGRAMME, I
I SOURCE OF FINANCE) I
I • DATES FOR ISSUE OF TENDER DOCUMENTS I
& SUBMISSION OF TENDERS
I I
• INSTRUCTIONS FOR APPLYING FOR
I I
PREQUALIFICATION
I • MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR I
I PREQUALIFICATION I
I • SUBMISSION DATE FOR CONTRACTORS' I
I PREQUALIFICATION DATA I
2.3
I
:
ISSUEPREQUALIF-ICATION DOCUMENTS &
QUESTIONNAIRES REQUESTING FROM EACH
COMPANY/JOINT VENTURE:
I
.... I
"'
REQUEST PREQUALIFICATION
DOCUMENTS
ISSUE & I • ORGANISATION & STRUCTURE ""I
SUBMISSION OF I • EXPERIENCE IN THE INTENDED I
I TYPE OF WORK & THE REGION I
PREQUALIFICATION I • RESOURCES: I
DOCUMENTS I -MANAGERIAL
I
-TECHNICAL
I -LABOUR I
I -PLANT I ---
I
I
• FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
• CURRENT CONTRACT COMMITMENTS I
,...... COMPLETE & SUBMIT PQ
DOCUMENTS & QUESTIONNAIRES
I • LITIGATION HISTORY I
I I
2.5
I --------
I
.... -- I
I
SELECTION OF I PREPARE LIST OF TENDERERS I
I I
TENDERER$ I I
I I
I
'II
,.. I
2.6 I ···---------- I
NOTIFICATION I
I NOTIFY ALL SELECTED TENDERER$
I ...,... ACKNOWLEDGE & CONFIRM
~I
OF APPLICANTS I .... I INTENTION TO SUBMIT TENDER
I I
....
LIST OF TENDERERS 5
III of III
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURE FOR THE OPENING AND
EVALUATION OF TENDERS
---=·====:=======f~~====~*===
.----·-
5.1
-
1
====~~=====-================~
ESTABLISH COMFORMITY AND
I COMPLETENeSS OF TENDERS
REVIEw OF • REJECT SUBSTANTIALLY UNRESPONSIVE
TENDERS I TENDERS
~~~~----~----------~
"'---~~------·--------~--·------+-l--------"'!------------------...1
I
~~-----~--. ~-~-----------~--···-----------~~·-------~-~~-
~------~--~~---------- ---------------------------------~·-,
5.2 I ----~-----~-..
I
....
~---'~~~------------
5.3 I ASSESS TENDERS IN ACCORDANCE WITH
ADJUDICATION OF I EVALUATION CRITERIA
TENDERS I RAISE FURTHER POINTS REQUIRING ...
I
CLARIFICATION, IF ANY
COMPLETE EVALUATION
·.,....----"""_,"JI
1 PROVIDE CLARIFICATION
I CHECK WITH FUNDING AGENCY
5.4 I REJECT NON-CONFORMING TENDERS &
REJECTION OF I ADVISE TENDERER($) CONCERNED
ALL TENDERS I
'----·
r-·-----·--·-· - I
I
"'I,..
I , - - - - - - - - - - - 0 . ____________ ~~~~--..
I
I
6.0 I I
AWARD OF
CONTRACT
I
I
I
I
DECIDE ON CONTRACT AWARD, IF
NECESSARY AFTER PRE-AWARD DISCUSSIONS
... I
.... I
I
I
I
I
ATTEND PRE-AWARD
DISCUSSIONS, IF REQUIRED
I
6.1 I r- - - ___y________---.
ISSUE LETTER I
l I I
I
..""I --~-
OF ACCEPTANCE
I
I
I
ISSUE LETTER OF ACCEPTANCE l..o~~ I
I~ I
I
ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT
I
~----------
I
I I
I I
6.2 I
- - -
...,.._ _~
~I u-~succESSFUL TENDERERs --
ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT
--l
TENDERER$
I
I '------------------------~~ I I
~------~-----------r---------·--·--~--·-----~--------------1
7
Procedure and Notes
The project strategy defines the way in which the project will be
implemented, determines the role of each party involved and, where
appropriate, specifies the way the project will operate. To a large degree
contractual relationships between the parties and their individual rights,
duties and risks are thereby also determined by the project strategy.
As soon as the project strategy has been decided, the employer, assisted
by his engineer, should establish procurement methods and forms of
tendering to be used in the project.
9
1.2 Preparation of Programmes
The tendering procedure, as described in this document, implies that
certain activities have to be carried out in connection with each part of
the project for which a separate tender is to be called.
Calling tenders for a given part of the project should be carried out in
compliance with the overall programme.
11
2.0 PREQUALIFICATIO N OF TENDERERS
2.1.1 General
13
2.2 Invitation to Prequalify
The employer/engineer should publish a notice inv1tmg interested
contractors to apply for prequalification documents, stating that tender
documents will be issued only to a limited number of companies/joint
ventures selected by the employer/engineer as having the necessary
qualifications to perform the work satisfactorily.
The period between the notice of invitation to pre qualify and the latest
date for the return of completed applications should not be less than
four weeks_
15
It should he noted that some financing or other institutions require that
all contractors possessing the stipulated experience and resources
should he pre qualified without any restriction on the total number.
17
3.1.3 Instructions to Tenderers·
General
The instructions to tenderers should state that the employer does not
bind himself to award a contract to any of the tenderers.
Documents
19
Domestic Preferences
Tenderers should be advised if and how domestic preferences will be
applied in the evaluation of tenders.
Tender Securities
The requirements for a tender security, if any, will be determined by the
circumstances of each project. If a tender security is required, a form
should be included in the tender documents. A standard form of tender
security is shown in Appendix III. The amount and currency(ies) of the
security should be stated. In all cases the surety or sureties must be
satisfactory to the employer. If a tender security has been requested, any
tender which has not been so secured will be rejected.
a. that it shall remain in full force and effect until the earliest of
b. subject to this Bond being in full force and effect, the Surety shall
pay the full amount specified in this Bond upon receipt of a written
certificate from the Authority stating that
21
Any special rules regarding treatment of taxes, duties and other
fiscal matters in the tender.
Validity period of the tender.
Any documents other than those issued as part of the tender
documents which the tenderer must include with his tender (e.g.
technical description or drawings, proposed methods of
construction, proposed environmental protection measurements,
proposed programme, schedule of key staff, quality control).
Procedure for issuing addenda to the tender documents.
Procedure for dealing with queries raised by tenderers.
Instructions for packing, labelling and addressing the .tender
(including a supply of standard labels if this is the practice of the
employer).
Procedure to be adopted for tenderers to inspect the site of the
works.
Procedure for inspecting any special documents not issued with the
tender documents (e.g. site investigation reports).
Circumstances under which alternative offers may be submitted.
Confidentiality of tender documents.
Procedure for the return of tender documents by unsuccessful
tenderers (if required).
Procedure for dealing with requests for extension of time by
tenderers.
Arrangements for the opening of tenders.
Procedure for dealing with arithmetic errors found in tenders during
evaluation.
Rules relating to disqualification/rejection of tenders (e.g. late
arrivals, altered figures, incomplete submissions and deviations).
Any unusual features of the particular tendering process.
Information about the evaluation criteria
23
3.1.8 List of Additional Information required from
the Tenderers
The employer/engineer should specify any additional information that
tenderers are required to submit with their tenders. To ensure
completeness and uniformity between tenderers, a suitable form should
be prepared and issued as part of the tender documents.
The estimates of cash flow will not become part of the contract as the
figures may have to be reviewed and adjusted as the work proceeds.
Expenditure under provisional sums will affect the figures, and so also
will changes in the source of supply of goods and modifications to the
programme or the extent of the works.
The list is not exhaustive. It should be clearly stated which items form
part of the evaluation and which items are to be incorporated into the
contract.
~-------------·--------
25
ii
!
II
3.4 Tenderers' Queries
Tenderers' queries can be handled by correspondence or by tenderers'
conference or by a combination of these methods.
The intended method or methods should be described in the instructions
to tenderers.
Correspondence Method
Tenderers should be instructed that queries will not be accepted by_ the
employer/engineer unless received 28 days before the date for
submission of tenders.
27
5.0 EVALUATION OF TENDERS
31
The evaluation of tenders can generally be considered to have three
components. The components may include:
Technical evaluation
conformity with specifications and drawings
comparison of any proposed alternatives (if allowable) with the
requirements of the tender documents
design aspects for which the contractor is responsible
methods of construction and temporary works
environmental considerations
quality assurance
programme
Financial evaluation
capital cost
discounted cash flow and nett present value
programme of payments
financing arrangements
currencies
securities
interest rates
downpayments!retentions
daywork rates
contract price adjustment proposals
33
6.0 AWARD OF CONTRACT
The letter of acceptance should identify the contract and the works to be
executed by the contractor as well as the contract price which the
employer will pay to the contractor in accordance with the terms of the
contract. Where the contract includes FIDIC Conditions of Contract for
Works of Civil Engineering Construction, Fourth Edition, the general
terms of the insurance policies must be agreed with the selected tenderer
before the letter of acceptance is issued.
35
6.3 Preparation of Contract Agreement
The contractor should normally be required to sign a contract agreement
with the employer. The employer/engineer should prepare the contract
agreement which should include the following documents:
Letter of Acceptance and Memorandum of Understanding
Letter of Intent (if applicable)
The Tender
Conditions of Contract
Specification
Drawings
Bill of Quantities
and such other documents that are intended to form the contract
37
TENDERING PROCEDURE
MODELS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF PROJECTS
IMPLEMENTATION REFERENCE TENDERING BASIS EMPWYER'S/ENGINEER'S TE!\'DERER'S ROLE EMPLOYER'S/ENGINEERS AWARD CRITERION 1
> )>
MODEL ROLE IN TENDER PHASE IN TEl'IDER PHASE ROLE IN EVALUATION
PHASE ""C
""C
BUILD "BDD" Detailed design • Prepare tender documents incl. detailed • Submit lender price for construe- • Evaluate incoming tenders based • Lowest evaluated price
m
z
design. specification and schedules of tion based on schedules of on the tender evaluation criteria
costs/bills of quantities costs/bills of quantities prepared
from the detailed design
-><c
-
from the preliminary design
DESIGN AND BUILD "DB" Performance requirements • Prepare tender documents incl.
conceptual design, petformance
. Submit preliminary design and
tender price for construction
• Evaluate incoming tenders based
on the tender evaluation criteria
• Economically or financially
most advantageous offer
requirements, specification and schedules
of costs
DESIGN, BUILD. OPERATE AND "'DBOT'' Outline of the project and • Prepare tender documents incl. • Submit preliminary design and
tender price for construction,
• Evaluate incoming tenders based
on the tender evaluation criteria
• Economically or financially
most advantageous offer
TRA.'ISFER performance requirements conceptual design. performance
requirements, specification and schedules operation and maintenance. and
of costs transfer
DESIGN, BUILD A!\'D OPERATE "DBO'. Outline requirements and • Prepare tender documents. perfonnance • Submit conceptual design and cost
per unit of output
• Evaluate incoming tenders based
on the tender evaluation criteria
• Lowest evaluated price per
unit of output
output requirements requirements, specification and schedules
of cost per unit of output
VJ
\0
APPENDIX II
Standard
Prequalification form
for contractors
comprising pages:
A Title page
B Notes to applicants
C Structure and organisation 1
D Structure and organisation 2
E Financial statement
F Joint Venture
G Resources: personnel 1
H Resources: personnel 2
I Resources: plant
J Resources: other
K Experience: geographical
L Experience: relevant projects completed
M Experience: all projects in progress
N Additional information
comprising i.a.
- Quality Assurance Systems
- Environmental Policy
- Litigation History
Note:
Supplies of this form are available
in A-4 size from
FIDIC Secretariat, P.O. Box 86, 1000 Lausanne 12, Switzerland.
Tel. +41 21 653 50 03, Telefax +4121 653 54 32.
41
43
45
APPENDIX Ill
FORM OF TENDER SECURITY
By this Bond W e , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
(hereinafter called "the Tenderer") and We (name of bank or insurance company) whose
registered office is at
(hereinafter called "the Surety") are held and firmly bound unto _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
Whereas the Authority has invited the Tenderer and other persons to complete tenders in similar
terms for the construction/supply and installation of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
and works associated therewith (hereinafter called "the Works") and to submit the same for the
consideration of the Authority, and the Tenderer proposes to submit to the Authority a tender
(hereinafter called "the Tender") in accordance with such invitation, this Bond shall provide
security to the Authority that the Tenderer will honour certain obligations to be undertaken by liim
in the Tender in accordance with the following conditions.
i. Ldatej, being [ ] days from [submission date], the date stipulated by the Authority for
the submission of tenders, or any prolongation of such date above notified to the
Authority by the Tenderer and the Surety in writing;
ii. in the event of acceptance of the Tender by the Authority, the date upon which the
Tenderer provides a performance security to the Authority in accordance with the terms
of the contract thereby made between them, or
iii. in the event of acceptance by the Authority of a tender for the Works from a third party,
the date upon which such third party provides the relevant performance security.
b. subject to this Bond being in full force and effect, the Surety shall pay the full amount
specified in this Bond upon receipt of a written certificate from the Authority stating that
i. the Tenderer has withdrawn his Tender during the validity of this Bond, or
ii. the Tenderer has failed to provide a performance security to the Authority in
accordance with the tenns of the contract between them upon acceptance of the Tender.
No alteration in the terms of the Tender, nor any forbearance or forgiveness in or in respect of any
matter or thing concerning the Tender on the part of the Authority, nor any objection from the
Tenderer shall in any way release the Surety from any liability under this Bond.
The benefit of this Bond shall not be assignable by the Authority and upon its ceasing to be in full
force and effect the Authority shall return the same to the Tenderer.
For and on behalf of the Tenderer _ _ __ For and on behalf of the Surety ~~--'--
Signed by - - - - - · - - - - - - - - - Signed by _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
in the capacity of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ in the capacity of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
and by ___________ and by _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____
47