Date: Date:

Group No. Group No.

TRAIT CRITERIA TRAIT CRITERIA

1 (18pts) 2 (20pts) 3(23 pts) 4(25 pts) 1 (18pts) 2 (20pts) 3(23 pts) 4(25 pts)

Identifies Student has Student Student Student Identifies Student has Student Student Student
facts and difficulty locates facts locates facts accurately facts and difficulty locates facts locates facts accurately
opinions locating facts and opinions and opinions locates facts opinions locating facts and opinions and opinions locates facts
in an article in the article. in the article and opinions in in an article in the article. in the article and opinions in
Explanation is and gives a the article and Explanation is and gives a the article and
weak. reasonable gives a clear weak. reasonable gives a clear
explanation. explanation. explanation. explanation.
Content Shows no Provide Provide Comprehensive Content Shows no Provide Provide Comprehensive
evidence of minimal moderate insight, evidence of minimal moderate insight,
insight, insight, insight, understanding, insight, insight, insight, understanding,
understanding understanding understanding and reflective understanding understanding understanding and reflective
or reflective and reflective and reflective thought about or reflective and reflective and reflective thought about
thought about thought about thought about the topic by thought about thought about thought about the topic by
the topic. the topic. the topic. building a the topic. the topic. the topic. building a
focused focused
reasoning reasoning
around a around a
specific issue specific issue
Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation Presentation
was brief and was brief and was thorough. was very was brief and was brief and was thorough. was very
not organized. mostly It was evident thorough. not organized. mostly It was evident thorough.
organized. that student Evidence that organized. that student Evidence that
(or students) the student (or (or students) the student (or
put a good students) spent put a good students) spent
amount of quality time in amount of quality time in
effort into this preparation effort into this preparation
project. was clearly project. was clearly
evident. evident.
Collaboration The members The members The members The members Collaboration The members The members The members The members
never worked sometimes worked from always worked never worked sometimes worked from always worked
from others’ worked from others’ ideas from others’ from others’ worked from others’ ideas from others’
ideas. It seems others’ ideas. most of the ideas. It was ideas. It seems others’ ideas. most of the ideas. It was
as though only However, it time. And it evident that all as though only However, it time. And it evident that all
a few people seems as seems like of the group a few people seems as seems like of the group
worked on the though certain everybody did members worked on the though certain everybody did members
presentation. people did not some work but contributed presentation. people did not some work but contributed
do as much only some equally to the do as much only some equally to the
work as others. people are presentation. work as others. people are presentation.
carrying the carrying the
presentation presentation