AYTONA VS CASTILLO

Posted by kaye lee on 11:22 PM

4 SCRA 1 G.R. No. L-19313 January 19 1962 [Midnight Appointment]

FACTS:
On December 29, 1961, Outgoing President Carlos Garcia appointed petitioner
Dominador Aytona as ad interim Governor of the Central Bank. Aytona took the
corresponding oath. On the same day, at noon, President-elect Diosdado Macapagal
assumed office; and on the next day, he issued administrative order no. 2 recalling,
withdrawing, and cancelling all ad interim appointments made by former President
Garcia. There were all-in all, 350 midnight or last minute appointments made by the
former President Garcia. On January 1, President Macapagal appointed Andres
Castillo as ad interim Governor of the Central Bank. Aytona instituted a case (quo
warranto) against Castillo, contending that he was validly appointed, thus the
subsequent appointment to Castillo by the new President, should be considered void.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the 350 midnight appointments of former President Garcia were valid.

RULING:
No. After the proclamation of the election of President Macapagal, previous President
Garcia administration was no more than a care-taker administration. He was duty bound
to prepare for the orderly transfer of authority the incoming President, and he should not
do acts which he ought to know, would embarrass or obstruct the policies of his
successor. It was not for him to use powers as incumbent President to continue the
political warfare that had ended or to avail himself of presidential prerogatives to serve
partisan purposes. The filling up vacancies in important positions, if few, and so spaced
to afford some assurance of deliberate action and careful consideration of the need for
the appointment and the appointee's qualifications may undoubtedly be permitted. But
the issuance of 350 appointments in one night and planned induction of almost all of
them a few hours before the inauguration of the new President may, with some reason,
be regarded by the latter as an abuse Presidential prerogatives, the steps taken being
apparently a mere partisan effort to fill all vacant positions irrespective of fitness and
other conditions, and thereby deprive the new administration of an opportunity to make
the corresponding appointments.