You are on page 1of 7

Representation Theories Theory Explained Stranger Things (how is it relevant? How is it The Killing (how is it relevant?

How is it not
not relevant?) relevant?)

Representation is the process of creating meaning; whilst producers may try to Stereotypes are used to assert power as Dr Brenner is a Young female victim- stereotypical
fix meanings, audiences can resist this. stereotypical powerful male shown through his physical
appearance representing dominance (black suit, silvered Patriarchal male dominant society- Jan Meyer doubts
Stuart Hall (Representation The idea that stereotyping, as a form of representation, reduces people to a few slick back hair- well-kept). Sarah Lund (told her not to look anymore- she continues
& Stereotyping) simple characteristics or traits which leads to finding Nanna in the lake)
Patriarchal white male dominance- stereotypical.
The idea that stereotyping tends to occur where there are inequalities of power, Particularly during the 1980s. Theis looks for daughter whilst Penille stays at home
as subordinate or excluded groups are constructed as different or ‘other’ (e.g. helplessly (shown in the kitchen through cross cutting)
through ethnocentrism). Absence of gay characters and females in social power
(Eleven being hunted). May reference the 1980s time
Goes against the theory as Eleven and the boys are arguably the most powerful- period. Against: Female lead detective- breaks stereotypes as the
goes again ‘stereotypes assert power’ as we are positioned to follow the most powerful. As a mother she neglects her son- the car
outcasts not the bullies, Nancy not Steve and El who is a countertype. Against: Eleven is the only character with super powers; scene when she gets his sports team’s name wrong.
goes against stereotypes- particularly in genre. Joyce Workaholic- could arguably fit with more progressive
breaks stereotypes- pushes Hopper. stereotypes.

Media representations portray a wide range of different and contradictory Eleven shows diversity through her appearance. She is an Turkish Shop Keeper- tokenism (ethnicity)
messages about identity, which can be used by audiences to think through their enigma in relation to her gender. Shaven head, neutral
own identities. coloured hospital gown, orange top. No reference to Female lead character (most important- post-modern)
gender. Referred to as a boy by Benny. The word ‘Eleven’
David Gauntlett (Identity) Identities including gender and sexuality are now seen as less fixed than they has no gender indications. Racism is shown as a fault- unacceptable.
were in the past.
Reference to homosexuality by Joyce whispers “fag” to Against: reflects Danish culture- lack of diversity in
Online media allow people to express and explore their identities. Hopper- shows taboo of homosexuality in 80s- implies he ethnicity
is bullied.
Patriarchal society- lack of female characters
Against: due to set in 1980s, less diversity is shown
(tokenism) this is against as it is on Netflix (online media) No reference to any other sexuality
so it should so more diversity. Homosexuality is against
theory too. This could be as it is on a PSB channel, older/mature
audiences so stick to stereotypes. Also regulation could
restrict creative content. Low budget could restrict
diversity also.

Women are often objectified (viewed as sexual objects) in media Nancy is sexualised in bed when Steve comes to her room. Sarah’s first scene low angle shot of her hugging her
representations. He tries to unbutton her top. She is a stereotypical female partner (knickers are shown and only wearing a long shirt)
role. Steve views Nancy as a sexual object that he Nanna wears white night dress, strap is often down to
Van Zoonen (Feminist Van Zoonen emphasises the importance of gender being seen as socially and oppresses her (forceful- kissing in the toilets and breaking show sexualised.
Theory) culturally constructed, as a result gender can vary depending on cultural and into her room when she told him not to). Nanna is naked in the back of the boot- oppressed by men
historical contexts. (linked to Troels Hartmann)
Against: may encourage audience to support her as she Nudity is shown by Nanna’s look alike in Oliver’s bed.
Gender is expressed in a diverse range of ways on the internet. rejects Steve to enable character development. Could fit Implies oppression as he has left her to play video games-
with Steve in Season 2 also. used for sexual pleasure.
Joyce is meant to be a powerful role- arguably a lack of Against: Sarah Lund most powerful, doesn’t let men
respect if she was sexualised. oppress her (doesn’t listen to Jan Meyer’s advice).
Children (Eleven) – cannot be sexualised
Feminist critiques of the media focus on challenging patriarchal and sexist Intersectionality- Dr Brenner (patriarchal culture- most Patriarchal society- male dominant federal department.
representations. powerful social character) White, heterosexual, upper Sarah’s boss is male- male humour during the prank scene
class male, middle aged. Powerful due to physical before her leaving do (prop- sex doll).Wide shot at her
Intersectionality considers the ways in which multiple identities and systems of appearance; suits connotes sophistication and leavers. Sarah is partly oppressed by Jan Meyer not taking
Bell Hooks (Feminist Theory) oppression overlap, e.g. in relation to the multiple identities that create an importance. Surrounds himself in a scientist lab yet is not her seriously and questioning what she does- could imply
individual identity (gender, race, social class, sexuality, etc.). wearing the same clothes to everyone else. Always the how men view women in that industry.
last to walk into the room- Benny diner scene. Nanna being taken and killed by what we assume is a man
Hooks argues media representations often reflect these oppressive ideologies. Set in 1980s, some sexist gender role differences due to (Troels Hartmann’s campaign).
time period (Mr and Mrs Wheeler). Oliver’s scene- female oppression as he plays video games
after having sex (sexual object).
Against: Eleven is the most physically powerful. Main Troels Hartmann (intersectionality)- most powerful-
characters are children. Audience root for the heroes current Mayor is male- implies patriarchal society of
which goes against the ‘oppressive’ ideology- Brenner is Denmark.
represented as a villain. Joyce is a strong character that Theis- breadwinner of the family and tells Penille to stay
pushes Hopper to doing his job. at home while he looks for her.
Sarah leaves her job and Denmark for Sweden due to her
boyfriend.

Against: Sarah main character and exceeds stereotypes.


Key scene- eye line match when she notices the fishing
rods and that there is a lake nearby- ignores Jan Meyer’s
advice and looks at the lake and finds Nanna. Rings
boyfriend- casually said she is not leaving. Workaholic-
not maternal.
Butler argues that gender identity is not something we are born with, it is Steve is stereotypical- popular, jock (sporty), forceful for Theis- black leather jacket, hat- appears practical and
something expressed through the performance of gender roles. sex (teenager)- Nancy’s bedroom- unbuttons her top. dominant. Tells Penille to stay at home while he searches
Nancy- feminine (pastel colours; calm and caring)- for daughter- masculine trait. Theis threats Oliver against
Gender is constructed through the performance of socially learned behaviours bedroom (flowers) implies she is girly. To an extent she is the wall with force- stereotypical male.
Judith Butler (Gender rather than expressed by them. passive perhaps due to her geek stereotype. Penille- most screen time she is in the kitchen shown to be
Performativity) Mrs Wheeler- cooks the dinner, house wife, oppressed at helpless- passive. Sarah- sexualised- common trait in
Butler believes that gender and sexual identity cannot be categorised into home by her husband and kids. Mr Wheeler- breadwinner. television.
simple binary systems. Could imply 1980s home life. Dr Brenner and Hopper- Troels- womaniser- seen to enjoy female attention.
both in powerful position occupations- uniform and suits. Widower (grave of wife), secretary and another woman
Dr Brenner- cold yet dominant- locks Eleven in a room- who gives information- slight flirtation between them. In
lack of humanity. power- gives orders. The appeal to find Nanna and cancel
campaign is down to Troels. Implied to a villain- enigma
Against: Joyce- masculine in appearance and frantic. and cross cutting – male stereotype in tv.
Forceful and passionate. Eleven- questions sexuality. Will-
against stereotypes- damsel in distress (could imply Against: Sarah not being maternal- forgetting sons sports
sexuality stereotypes) club name (implies absence), does not move with her son
to Sweden with her boyfriend. Headstrong and driven-
workaholic.
The history of colonialism continues to influence attitudes to ethnicity in Racial hierarchy- western cultures in the 1980s imply that Caucasian place- Denmark relevant to the country. Racial
western societies. white race is most important, perhaps due to implicit hierarchy- white characters most powerful however due
racism (Lucas referred to as “midnight”). Lucas is a valued to relevance of current Danish population.
Paul Gilroy (Ethnicity and Postcolonialism suggests the ways in which colonial history continues to character yet still a token and a subordinate character.
Post-Colonial) influence attitudes to ethnicity with an assumption of the superiority of white Often aggressive (argues with Dustin) and later in the Token- Turkish shop keeper- some racism shown which
western cultures. season most opposed to Eleven. Dr Brenner and Hopper- shows there is some racism in Denmark however it is
people in occupations of power both white- as they have shown to be a flaw as Theis argues against colleague. Shop
The idea that civilisation -ism constructs racial hierarchies and sets up binary the most screen time implies most power. keeper has a lower paid position and therefore could be
oppositions. ‘racial hierarchy’. Binary opposite- victim (of racism) and
Against: Head teacher is an ethnic minority implying some of his stock.
important occupations are shared with diverse ethnicity.

Industries Theory Theory Explained Stranger Things (how is it relevant? How is it The Killing (how is it relevant? How is it not
not relevant?) relevant?)
The concentration of media ownership means the media industry is dominated For: Arguably Netflix is a conglomerate as it is a large For: DR is a PSB (public service broadcasting channel) that
by a small number of conglomerates, which limits the viewpoints represented. industrial company that uses digital integration and facilitates the needs of the Danish public (mass audience).
‘Netflix’ originals with its huge budget. It is a part of the European Broadcasting Union which
Curran and Seaton (Power Media concentration generally limits or inhibits variety, creativity and quality. supports one another financially across Europe.
and Media Industries) Against: Netflix is not a traditional conglomerate as it is an
Despite the development of online media the established major media online streaming service. Therefore as an example of Web Against: Lacking budget in comparison to popular new TV
organisations continue to be dominant. 2.0 they are able to be creative- Stranger Things is creative
streaming services. Due to minimal budget they are
through the hybrid genres and through its use of restricted with their creativity. The Killing had to be a
intertextuality to 80s and Stephen King. This is why the crime drama with a female lead to be relatable to their
show is so successful. audience for it to be successful yet still unconventional. –
Ties into Steve Neale’s theory (conform & subvert).
Media regulation is necessary to protect consumers and make sure media Against: No regulation for online streaming services. Some For: DR is regulated as it a PSB paid by the public. Post
industries act in the public interest, however this is being undermined by the self-regulation can be done by parents with limitations put water shed due to casual racism, nudity, implications of
development of a global online media culture. in place. Perhaps is why the show was so successful due to rape and death. It was shown on BBC 4- were so
Livingstone and Lunt audiences being able to watch the show (despite its horror successful it had its own slot on a Saturday when they
(Regulation) Traditional forms of media regulation are being challenged by the online and genre) without a watershed. scheduled subtitled foreign programmes.
globalised media culture resulting from technological developments such as the
internet. Many audiences can access different TV shows and films Ofcom regulate content on the BBC as a PSB- The Killing
of different genres which is why streaming services are so would have been post watershed on BBC 4.
Regulation is needed to make sure the media promotes public interests. successful.

Similarly to Curran and Seaton, Hesmondhalgh sees media industries as being For: high production cost (high budget)- minimalised risks For: DR minimalised risks by using relatable characters
dominated by a small number of conglomerates. by hybrid genres, stereotypical characters, three that subvert other TV shows/stereotypes by focusing on a
dimensional characters (got to know them), multi- female lead in a male dominated society. They used an
David Hesmondhalgh The high production costs and ease of reproduction and sharing of media narrative stranded narrative (engaging), intertextuality- ‘universal’ genre that many people understand (may have
(Cultural Industries) products means media industries use a number of methods to reduce risk. creative not many shows like this on the market. Winona been why it was so successful across the UK, Australia,
These include vertical integration, and the reliance on established genres, stars Ryder is well known- nominee for 2 Oscars. South America and Asia- led to American remake.
and narratives.
Against: Duffer Brothers were not well established or Vertical Integration through DR but horizontal through
experienced. Not any shows like this on the market. Young BBC and other countries worldwide.
actors- unknown.
Audiences Theory Theory Explained Stranger Things (how is it relevant? How is it The Killing (how is it relevant? How is it not
not relevant?) relevant?)
Albert Bandura (Media Bandura believes that the media can have a direct influence on the values and For: audience become anxious that the government are For: audience become anxious that the government are
behaviour of audience corrupt- do not tell the police everything they do. – first corrupt. They are behind the crimes and use their power
Effects) scene (running away- implies alien due to non-diegetic to their advantage. – through the dialogue by Jan Meyer
The idea that the media can implant ideas in the mind of the audience directly sound) ‘the car belongs to Hartman’s campaign office’

Media representations can directly and indirectly influence audience values and Could question in their belief of extra-terrestrial life or Over season it mentions how she died and used her
behaviours. their knowledge that we are not told about. First scene in power. People could be effected and copy it or have
lab when Alien chases the scientist. further anxieties.

Against: That the Demogorgon is real or that there is such Against: restrictive narrative- make our own judgements-
thing as a parallel universe- accessed by a tree. can’t believe it as don’t know enough about what is
Unrealistic. The reality of a person having super powers is happening- serial narrative. “Campaign office”- open to
unrealistic- eye line match turning off fan. As it is a hybrid multiple people, not just Troels. Creates enjoyment for
genre, the narrative is far- fetched. the audience to find out who did it.

Applies better as a series than an episode- we can reflect


and it is based on realistic crimes so it could happen-
further anxiety for the audience.
The complex representations common to Long Form TV
Drama are less likely to cause a direct effect on audiences.

George Gerbner (Cultivation Gerbner suggests that the media can influence the audience over a long period. For: audience become anxious that the government are For: audience become anxious that the government are
Gerbner found that people who watched a lot of television were likely to have a corrupt- do not tell the police everything they do. corrupt- do not tell the police everything they do.
Theory) more negative view of the world (mean world syndrome) than people who did Mean world syndrome- anxious about the government. Mean world syndrome- anxious about the government.
not watch a lot of television. Could question in their belief of extra-terrestrial life or
their knowledge that we are not told about. Revolves around The Killing- the murder/death of a
People who watched a lot of television were likely to have similar views – young girl
something he called ‘mainstreaming’. Against: sci-fi- not believable, set in 80s (past), happy
elements- friendship/teamwork themes Against: following the protagonist (Sarah)- hero, want her
The media can influence audience perceptions of the world over a long period to figure out the case. Restricted narrative- not massively
of time through the repetition of similar messages gory or graphic- only shown aftermath as opposed to the
death itself.
Stuart Hall (Reception The idea that communication is a process involving encoding by producers and Preferred- sympathise with kids, Joyce. Scared at Preferred- engaged- questioning Nanna’s whereabouts
decoding by audiences Demogorgon scenes- non-diegetic sound. Intertextuality and who killed her (conventional to a crime drama).
Theory) Producers encode preferred meanings into media texts, which audiences (enjoyment). Relate to characters- children? Suspense- on edge- Nanna’s chase scene. Prank scene
respond to in one of three ways. (Sarah Lund’s leavers). Clearly a crime drama. Serial.
Hall argues audiences respond to the preferred reading in one of three different Negotiated reading- sci-fi? Pre judge the series before
ways. watching it because of hybrid genre- sci-fi, 80s etc. People Negotiated- may not fully understand the culture of the
Audiences either accept the preferred reading (the dominant position), reject it that grew up in the 80s. People that work for the show as it is set in Denmark (gender/ethnic
(the oppositional position), or accept some elements but modify aspects to fit government. Ethnicity- unfair & inaccurate representation). Language.
their own views or experiences (negotiated position). representation Unrealistic genre- not relatable
Oppositional- foreign language TV Show- against watching
Oppositional- elderly people because of Netflix. Pre-judge with subtitles.
due to genre. Government.
Henry Jenkins (Fandom The idea that fans are active participants in the construction and circulation of For: Netlfix- international/recognisable- audiences may For: as spread to South America, Asia and Australia
textual meanings enjoy the series and rein act/create their own content. arguably it is ‘spreadable’ for fans. It was requested by
Media) The development of online media has allowed audiences to participate in media fans. Dr and ZDF enterprises distributed it internationally.
culture, adapting media products to create their own content which is shared Convergence culture- Justice for Barb meme- encouraged
with online audiences producers of S2 to introduce Barb’s parents Led to an American show produced by Fox 21- led to being
Audience members become textual poachers taking aspects from media texts on Netflix (mass audience).
to create their own content. Spreadability- actor of Will Byers interact with a fan
Convergence culture - media is shared, adapted, and consumed constantly on a discussion on Instagram about his sexuality. Against: lack of fandom media due to being a foreign
range of different platforms. language TV show. Restricted by the genre- not many
Spreadable media - content that is adapted by audience members for their own Against: even though it is on a streaming service it is still a developed characters and the subject is dark. Directed at
purpose and shared with others. highly paid production- Duffer Brothers make the adults- may not be as spreadable.
decisions. Fans are still consumers.
Clay Shirky ( End of Prosumers have different motivations to professional media producers. For: Netlfix- international/recognisable- audiences may For: as spread to South America, Asia and Australia
This can create cognitive surplus, where potentially large numbers of people enjoy the series and rein act/create their own content. arguably it is ‘spreadable’ for fans. It was requested by
Audience) give their time and expertise to create something (e.g. Wikipedia). fans.
Convergence culture- Justice for Barb meme- encouraged
Audiences can no longer be seen as a single mass of people. Audiences engage producers of S2 to introduce Barb’s parents Led to an American show produced by Fox 21- led to being
differently with media products across different platforms, with some audience on Netflix (mass audience).
members now creating or adapting media products themselves. Spreadability- actor of Will Byers interact with a fan S2 E2 actress of sarah lund was in the show- easter egg
discussion on Instagram about his sexuality.
Technological developments have changed the ways in which audiences engage Against: lack of fandom media due to being a foreign
with media culture, leading to the rise of user generated content and reducing Against: even though it is on a streaming service it is still a language TV show. Restricted by the genre- not many
the power of media producers to act as gatekeepers. highly paid production- Duffer Brothers make the developed characters and the subject is dark. Directed at
decisions. Fans are still consumers. adults- may not be as spreadable.
Media Language Theory Explained Stranger Things (how is it relevant? How is it The Killing (how is it relevant? How is it not
not relevant?) relevant?)

Roland Barthes (Semiotics Meaning is created by signs through connotation, which may naturalize For: Enigma codes- do not see the Demogorgon, restricted For: Enigma codes- do not see what happens to Nanna.
dominant values and ideologies. through the use of enigma- what happens to Will, Eleven Action- know she is being chased by someone. Enigma-
Theory) escapes, what the monster looks like. Action codes- Will is black costume- cannot see who the chaser is.
The idea that signs can function at the level of denotation, which involves the missing through narrative and through the wide shot of
‘literal’ or common-sense meaning of the sign, and at the level of connotation, the empty shed. Eleven has super powers- eye line match Action code- know she is found through the car.
which involves the meanings associated with or suggested by the sign to the fan that turns on.
Action code- cross-cutting shows the audience that Troels
is tied to the investigation. Enigma- don’t know why until
the end.
Tzvetan Todorov Todorov identifies the different stages of a narrative, moving from the everyday For: disruption-a disruption for all characters at different For: disruption is when Nanna goes missing.
life of the characters (equilibrium), the disruption to that (disequilibrium), and points. Main disruption is when Will goes missing. Follows Sarah as opposed to multiple characters- easier to
(narratology) the resolution of that disruption into a new equilibrium. follow Todorov’s theory. Disequilibrium- when Sarah
decides to cancel her plans to delay move to Sweden
Identifying the different stages of a narrative helps to reveal the values and Resolution- finding Nanna.
ideological messages it communicates. Against: begins on disruption (disrupts all characters) New state- finding the killer
Interpretative- multiple characters multi stranded
narrative (different stages for the characters) Against: begins on disruption (disrupts all characters)
Nancy doesn’t gain a disequilibrium No new state- serial layout
Some what multi-stranded- Troels Hartmann doesn’t
follow the stages. Doesn’t apply to all characters.
Steve Neale (Genre Theory) Genre conventions are not fixed, but evolve over time as producers subvert For: hybrid genre- mix of different genres- creative. For: subvert conventions of crime drama through female
established conventions, or use hybridity with other genres Subverts expectations of some genres e.g. horror- lead, men are shown to be arrogant, dismissive or
restricted, comedy- Dustin’s character, sci-fi conventional stereotypical. Multi stranded narrative subverts crime
Genre codes are also established beyond media products themselves through but(don’t see the alien). Eleven- a child yet an alien dramas as Nanna’s friends and family gain a lot of screen
sources such as reviews and marketing. time.

The idea that genres change, develop, and vary, as they borrow from and Against: still conventional to some extent- sci- fi- alien, It is conventional to a crime drama due to its realistic,
overlap with one another intertextuality makes it conventional restricted narrative (serial) and use of iconography.

Claude Levi Strauss Binary oppositions are pairs of opposed, conflicting forces. For: Alien Vs Human, Old vs Young, Government Vs State, For: Man VS Woman, Government Vs State, Known Vs
Identifying the pairs of binary oppositions which structure narratives can be Man Vs Woman Known Vs Unknown (restricted narrative) Unknown (restricted narrative)
(Structuralism) used to determine the ideological messages within a text.
Against: goes against Old Vs Young as Joyce stands up for Against: Sarah goes against the men (even though there
The idea that meaning is dependent upon (and produced through) pairs of Will. Joyce gets Hopper working- countertypes (Nancy are more of them- her boss puts her on the case to
oppositions and Steve- Nancy gets her way in the end). mentor Jan Meyer).

Jean Baudrillard (Post The idea that media images have come to seem more ‘real’ than the reality they For: Hyper reality is representing the reality of the 1980s For: Hyper reality represented through ethnicity. Only one
supposedly represent (hyper reality). using intertextual references. This may encourage a example of an ethnic minority. External audiences
modernism younger audience to believe in the reality represented of (international) may believe this ‘reality’ of Sweden. DR
Hyper reality is the idea that representations are now more powerful and ‘real’ the 80s. This is necessary for the narrative as the arguably as a PSB did this subconsciously due to ethnic
than reality. intertextual references are arguably what make the show majority in Denmark.
so successful as it is different to what is currently on the
Hyperreal representations don’t represent reality, instead they are market. Also young audiences believe the reality Patriarchal led society as a representation of Denmark.
representations of representations. represented which makes them buy into the themes and Sarah Lund being a token at the police station. All other
the show itself. characters in position of power are men. May make
In postmodern cultures representations are more powerful than reality, and external audiences believe in this reality of Denmark.
representations themselves no longer relate to reality. Hyper reality can be shown through the traditional
household environment- both parents married with a Representation of Troels Hartmann represented as liberal
stable home life (Mrs and Mr Wheeler- Mikes parents). positive man with wealth and an exciting love life
(appealing for audience)-. Although cross cutting with
Hyper reality of the ‘perfect alpha female’- Nancy. She is implications of him linked to the case could create social
both attractive and smart- makes her irresistible to Steve. anxiety for audiences regarding politicians.
In real life this may not be a reality.
Against:
Hyper reality of America not being ethnically diverse-
Lucas’ character being a token. As a ‘realist’ programme with attempted true to life
representations is difficult to link to theory due to its
Against: genre and current time setting. Could fit more with an
external audience who do not know so much about
Duffer Brothers chose to represent the Wheeler family as Denmark’s population and therefore believe the realities
struggling and damaged- lack of communication with represented. May be argued against by those that are
absent fathers and struggling mother. Shows reality of the from Denmark.
80s as this would have been common as opposed to all
traditional family life. More families were becoming There would be more ethnic minorities than one that is
divorced in 80s than previously. represented in Denmark. Used token to represent Theis
as a kind man during his introduced scene for the
Not believable as intertextual to the 80s- older audiences audience to establish a relationship with him.
may reject the representations. For example only one
female single parent- shown to be really struggling. There Would be more of a mixture of gender representation in
were more single parents during the 80s. Denmark than a token. Perhaps focused more so on Sarah
Lund for post-modern purposes than representing reality.
Nancy’s character gives audiences too high of
expectations that it is unbelievable in real life- difficult
reality to live up to which may be unrealistic being
attractive and smart with the popular boy at school.

Hyper reality of the tokenist representation of Lucas. Only


one representation of ethnic minority in America. In real
life there would not only be one black family. Creates the
representation that America was not diverse. We do not
see Lucas ‘family like we do with Mikes which is why it
caused social uproar and showed them in Season 2. Lucas
wasn’t seen as a character of racism but as an equal to the
other ‘outcasts’.

You might also like