Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No 1/P1, 1/P2,
1/P3, 51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada, Karnataka State.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.0 General
In the recent past, increase in the personal income and leisure, early retirement, and
development in transportation network has significantly contributed for the increased
tourism demand. Today, tourism and recreation is part of the contemporary lifestyle for
individuals and families. Tourism has grown as an economically integrated industry
and became one of the world's largest industries, bringing enormous wealth to host
countries, and tourism has developed as one of the most dynamic and fastest growing
sectors of economy. In fact, travel and tourism have become a basic human need as it
brings the people close to experience the serenity of the divine nature.
The coastal tourism can be defined as tourism of the coastal environment and its natural
& cultural resources. Most coastal tourism takes place along the sea shore and in the
water body immediately adjacent to the shoreline. Coastal zones have been recognized
as favorite places for recreational tourism activities. The ‘Karnataka Tourism Policy
2015- 2020’ has earmarked Mangaluru, Udupi, Kundapur, Muradeshwar, Karwar &
Gokarna areas for coastal tourism development projects.
The Hon’ble Chief Minister of Karnataka in the budget speech of 2007-08 had
announced the setting up of a golf course with related activities on Public private
partnership (PPP) mode in Thanir Bhavi area of Mangalore Taluk to encourage and
promote the tourism in the coastal areas of the state. In this regard, Karnataka State
Industrial & Infrastructure Development Corporation (KSIIDC) has proposed an 18-
hole golf course, golf club & resort along with other hospitality services in an area of
135 acres in Thanir Bhavi, Bengre Village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada District,
Karnataka. The proposed site is situated on peninsular stretch of land on road towards
the Kolur Bridge.
An advertisement for the request for the request of proposal was issued on 2.6.2010 and
the due date for the submission of bids was 30.12.2010. Nineteen parties purchased the
RFP documents and finally three bids were received. The bids were evaluated based on
the annual authorization fee offered by the bidders. The bid evaluation committee
recommended that the project to be awarded to highest bidder, i.e. Consortium of Opus
Hotels and Resorts Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore and M/s. Laguna National Golf & Country
Club Ltd., Singapore. The agreement copy has been attached as Annexure 1. The
Karnataka Tourism policy 2015-2020 promotes the setting up a Tourism Infrastructure
Company for development of tourism infrastructure and support facilities through
dedicated SPVs, PPP frameworks, Joint Ventures, and other appropriate structures.
The proposed construction of Beach Resort and Golf Course is located at Sy.Nos. 1/P1,
1/P2, 1/P3, 51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada,
Karnataka State.It is spread across 135 acres of land which is just 8-10 Kms away from
Mangalore city. The Proposed project falls under the CRZ-II, and hence, attracts the
provisions of CRZ Notification, published in Gazette of India, Extraordinary Part-II,
Section-3, sub-section (ii) of Ministry of Environment & Forest dated 06.01.2011.
1.1 Geography
Mangalore, officially known as Mangaluru, is a sea port city located in the state of
Karnataka. The name Mangalore (Mangaluru) is after the Goddess Mangala Devi. It is
known as Kudla in Tulu, Kodial in Konkani, Maikāla in Beary , Mangaluru in Kannada.
It is located about 352 kilometres (220 mi) west of the state capital, Bengaluru between
the Arabian Sea and the Western Ghat mountain ranges. It is the administrative
headquarters of the Dakshina Kannada District. The city has a tropical climate and lies
in the path of the Arabian Sea branch of the South-West monsoons. Mangalore's port
handles 75 per cent of India's coffee and cashew exports.
1.1.2 Demographics
1.1.3 Transportation
The city is called the Gateway of Karnataka. Mangaluru by virtue of its closeness to the
cost makes it accessible by all forms of transport: road, rail, air and sea. It is the only city
in Karnataka to have an International Airport and a Major Seaport. Mangaluru is well
serviced by Air, Sea, Road and connecting Mangalore to major cities of Karnataka and
beyond. Mangalore port is one of the five ports through which foreigners will be able
to enter India through with electronic visa. The efficient transportation system and the
proximity of Mangalore to the Arabian Sea and the Western Ghats make it an attractive
tourism location for domestic and foreign tourists.
1.1.4 Road
Five national highways connect Mangalore with various parts of Karnataka and India.
1. NH-17 (now NH-66) connects Mangalore with Udupi, Karwar, Mumbai, Goa,
Kochi, Trivandrum and Kozhikode.
2. NH-275 also connects Mangalore with Bangalore via Mysore. It starts at Bantwal
near Mangalore city and passes through Madikeri, Mysore and Mandya. It ends
at Bangalore spanning a total length of 378 kilometres .
3. NH-13 (now NH-169) connects Mangalore Shimoga.
4. NH-48 (now NH-75) connects Mangalore with Vellore, Bangalore, Kunigal,
Hassan and Sakleshpura.
5. NH-73 connects Mangalore to Tumkur via Charmadi, Mudigere and Belur.
1.1.5 Rail
Rail connectivity in Mangaluru was established in 1907. A metre gauge railway track,
built through the Western Ghats, connected Mangaluru with Hassan. The metre gauge
track was converted to a broad gauge track connecting Mangalore to Bangalore via
Hassan. The re-gauged track was opened to freight traffic in May 2006 and passenger
traffic in December 2007. The track network in the Mangaluru area is based on a
triangular pattern, with Mangaluru Central, Mangaluru Junction and the Netravati
River railway bridge at the vertices of the triangle.
A railway siding leads from Mangaluru Central to the historic old Railway Goods-Shed
in the old Port, Bunder area of Mangaluru city. For a year 1929–1930, the longest
running train in undivided India originated from Mangaluru Central. This was The
Grand Trunk Express from Mangaluru to Peshawar. The train covered the distance
from Mangaluru to Peshawar on the Khyber Pass in 104 hours. After 1930 the route of
the Grand Trunk Express was curtailed and the train originated from Mettupalayam,
Coimbatore.
1.1.6 Airways
Located around 13 Kms from Mangaluru Railway Station is Mangaluru Airport (IATA:
IXE, ICAO: VOML), also known as the Bajpe airport, is an international airport serving
the coastal city of Mangalore, India. It is one of the only two International airports in
Karnataka, the other one being Kempegowda International Airport, Bangalore. Several
daily flights connect Mangalore with most major cities in southern and western India as
well as many major cities in the Middle East. The airport, then the Bajpe Aerodrome,
was opened on 25 December 1951 when then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru arrived
on a DC-3 Dakota aircraft.
Table 1.2: Airlines and destinations operation from Mangaluru International Airport
Airlines Destinations
Air India Mumbai
Air India Abu Dhabi, Bahrain, Dammam, Doha, Dubai–
Express International, Kuwait, Muscat
IndiGo Bangalore, Mumbai, Patna
Jet Airways Abu Dhabi, Bangalore, Chennai, Delhi, Dubai–International, Mumbai
SpiceJet Belgaum, Bangalore, Dubai–International, Hyderabad, Mumbai
The New Mangaluru Port “an ISO 9001:2008 & 14001:2004 certified port”, the only
Major Port of Karnataka was declared as the 9th Major Port on 4th May 1974. The major
commodities exported through the Port are Iron Ore Concentrates & Pellets, Iron Ore
Fines, POL Products, Granite Stones, Containerized Cargo, etc. The major imports of the
Port are Crude and POL products, LPG, Coal, Limestone, Timber logs, Finished
Fertilizers, Liquid Ammonia, Phosphoric Acid, Other Liquid Chemicals, Containerized
cargo, etc.
The proposed Beach resort and Golf course project is located at Sy.No 1/P1, 1/P2, 1/P3,
51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada, Karnataka State.
It is spread across135 acres of land, with the 18 hole golf course in an area of 113.67
Acres, Golf Club and Resort in an area of 21.33 Acres. Geographically, the proposed
project is located Longitude ranges from 74°49’5.901” to 74°49’44.83” East and Latitude
ranges from 12°50’50.3” to 12°52’14.136” North at an elevation of about 4m to 6 m above
mean sea level (MSL).
Project site
Gurpur (Kudumbur Hole) River (Backwater) is adjacent to the project location flowing
at an Aerial distance of 0.5 Km. On the eastern side lies Jokatte village, Western side lies
Ruchi Soya Factory, Northern side lies the river and Southern side lies KISCO factory.
The area falls under South West Coastal Zone area, CRZ - II as per CRZ Notification
2011. CRZ map of the project site has been enclosed as Plate No. 1. The project layout
has been superimposed on the CRZ Map by IRS, Anna University, Chennai and the
same is attached as Plate No.2
Fig 2.2: Google Image showing the location of the project site
Sl.
Information Details
No.
1 Name of the Project Proposed Beach Resort and Golf course Project
2 Name of the applicant Mr. Prakash Shetty
Sy.No 1/P1, 1/P2, 1/P3, 51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre
3 Location/Sy. Nos village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada,
Karnataka State.
4 Total site area 135 Acres (546326 Sqm)
The Project site is bordered the Arabian Sea on the West, The Gurpur river flows to the
East of the project site. The project site could be reached from Mangalore city by road
and Bengre Ferry line. The Estuary of the Gurpur and Nethravthi river lies on the
Southern side of the project site. An area of 7 Km radius surrounding the proposed site
was considered as the study area.
The climate in the region of the proposed project area i.e., Bengre village region is
tropical. Most months of the year are marked by significant rainfall. The short dry
season has little impact. This climate is considered to be Tropical Monsoon climate –
‘Am’ according to the Koppen-Geiger climate classification. The average annual
temperature in Bengre village is 27.1°C and the precipitation averages to 3781 mm.
2.2.3 Rainfall:
The normal annual rainfall over the district varies from about 3000 mm to about 3900
mm. It is the minimum in the southern and south western parts of the district. About
85% of the annual rainfall occurs during the monsoon months i.e., June to August. Post -
monsoon season yields about 8% and the balance of annual rainfall from December to
March. This district on the West Coast of India experiences a typical maritime climate.
The district is marked by heavy rainfall, high humidity and oppressive weather in hot
season. Generally, the weather is hot and humid throughout the year. In the eastern
part of the district i.e., along the Western Ghats, the weather is comparatively cooler
than in the western coastal areas. The relative humidity varies from 65 to 96 percent
during the winter season period between December 2016 and February 2017.
Coastal ecosystems are the world’s most productive; here sunlight saturates the
shallow, nutrient rich coastal waters. Algal beds, seagrass meadows, reefs, estuaries and
mangroves provide food and shelter for vast quantities of fish, shellfish, and other
marine organisms. Because of the high productivity and the transportation facilities,
including the trans-oceanic, this coastal zone has been densely populated since ancient
times.
The soil in the district is mostly lateritic type, found distributed in the Pediplain area
characterised by high iron and aluminium content. Lateritic soil is mostly red in colour
and yellow loamy, pale to bright red colors are also seen. Lateritic soil is suitable for
Paddy, Sugarcane, Arecanut and Plantation crops, viz. crops like Cardamom &
plantains. Loamy red soils are distributed in the lower reaches of valleys. Red lateritic
soil is the most dominant soil type in the area. The texture of the soil varies from fine to
coarse. The soil in valleys and intermediate slopes is rich in loam whereas in upper
slopes it is much coarse in nature. The soil responds well to irrigation and other soil -
management practices. Silty and loamy soils are of transported origin and are found
mostly along river banks and in valley plains. They have good infiltration capacity and
are well-suited for agriculture due to their fertility.
and alluvium over the gneisses and continental type of sedimentary deposits with
dolerite and norite dikes. The basin consists of gneisses of the peninsular geneissic
complex with enclaves of high grade supracrystals. The average annual maximum
temperature is 320 C and minimum is 210 C. Annual average rainfall is ~3785 mm. Of
which about 80% is received during the southwest monsoon (June - August) months.
2.2.8 Seismicity:
It is proposed to develop an eighteen (18) holes PGA standard golf course. The area for
the development of the golf course will be 460006.17 Sqm (113.67 Acres). This will
reduce the level of soil erosion from wind and water and the dust generated during the
preparation of the area. The Golf course comprises of roughs, fairways, tees,
greens. The roughs will be irrigated twice a week during the non rainy months and
fairways, greens, tees every alternate day including summer during the non rainy
months. In addition we will be using a salt resistant grass which not be affected in case
the tide water overflow onto the course. To irrigate the golf course only treated
wastewater will be used in order to reduce the fresh water demand. Hence no fresh
water is required. And also the golf course will not be irrigated during the monsoon
season as the grass will survive on the monsoon rain itself. In case it doesn’t rain for 3
days then nominal water will be used on the greens, tees during the monsoon months.
The average water demand for the golf course is of 700 to 800 KLD as per site
conditions.
The total power demand for the proposed project will be 1500 KVA and will be met by
Mangaluru Electricity Supply Company (MESCOM).
The solid waste generated from the proposed project will be disposed as per MSW
Rules 2016. Quantity of Solid waste generated for the proposed project is estimated to
be 800 Kg/Day. The construction debris generated during the construction phase will
be used within the project site for leveling & back filling the low laying area. The total
quantity of such waste produced is estimated based on 0.425 kg per day per capita. The
solid waste generation is estimated as follows:
Source Population Per capita generation of waste (kg/d) Total waste (kg/d)
The total cost of the proposed project is 175 Crores including Building construction,
landscape area and golf course development cost.
3. DESCRIPTION OF ENVIRONMENT
An area of 7 Km radius surrounding the proposed site was considered as the study
area. This chapter comprises the description of the existing environmental status of the
study area with reference to the prominent environmental components. The existing
environmental setting is considered to judge the baseline conditions which are
described with respect to climate, hydro-geological aspects, atmospheric conditions,
water quality, soil quality, ecology, socio-economic profile, land-use pattern, places of
archaeological importance etc.
This report presents the primary data generated during the study period Winter
(December 2016 to February 2017) and the secondary data collected from various
Government and semi-Government organizations. Secondary data, from various
scientific studies conducted in the study area by various organizations, has also been
collected, compiled and interpreted.
The predominant wind direction during Winter 2016-17 is from East to West direction
with average wind speed between 4.48 m/s. Maximum relative humidity value is
around 98 per cent. Minimum temperature recorded is 22.8 °C and Maximum
temperature is 27 °C. The Wind Rose diagram for the study period i.e., Winter 2016-17
is given in Fig- 3.3 The Frequency Distribution for the month of December 2016, January
and February 2017 are given in Annexure 2. The details pertaining to Maximum &
Minimum Temperature, Relative Humidity, Rainfall, Wind Speed and Wind Direction
for the months of December 2016, January and February 2017 are given in Annexure 3
respectively.
NORTH
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
WEST EAST
WIND SPEED
(m/s)
>= 11.1
8.8 - 11.1
5.7 - 8.8
SOUTH
3.6 - 5.7
2.1 - 3.6
0.5 - 2.1
Calms: 1.48%
Fig 3.1: Wind rose diagram for the winter season December 2016 to February 2017
Pre-calibrated Combined Dust Samplers (PM10 & PM2.5) has been used for monitoring
the existing AAQ status. Significant parameters viz., Particulate Matter (size less than 10
µm and less than 2.5 µm - PM2.5), Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) and Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2),
Hydro carbons and VOC were monitored in the Core and Buffer Zones. Ambient Air
Quality locations are given in Table 3.2 and Fig 3.2
40
30
20
10
0
SO₂ NO₂ PM₁₀ PM₂.₅
Min 4.83 8.77 3.13 8.33
Max 12.65 16.53 35.63 14.75
Avg 7.04 13.29 25.43 10.74
The observed levels of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the study period of
Winter 2016-17 season. Concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during
the Winter 2016-17 season are represented graphically in Fig 3.4. Average
concentrations of both particulate matter and gaseous pollutants are within the
NAAQS. Maximum concentration of PM10 is observed at this location compared with
the concentrations of other pollutants.
40
30
20
10
0
SO₂ NO₂ PM₁₀ PM₂.₅
Min 6 8.49 22.25 8.18
Max 17.15 19 45.13 18
Avg 10.55 13.69 31.05 10.54
Fig 3.4: Graphical representation of baseline air quality at Port Warf, Kasba
Bazar,Bundar.
The observed levels of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the study period of
Winter 2016-17season. Concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the
Winter 2016-17season are represented graphically in Fig 3.5. Average concentrations of
both particulate matter and gaseous pollutants are within the NAAQS. Maximum
concentration of PM10 is observed at this location compared with the concentrations of
other pollutants.
Concentration, µg/Nm3
40
30
20
10
0
SO₂ NO₂ PM₁₀ PM₂.₅
Min 4.19 8.87 11.38 5.38
Max 11.25 15.6 30.13 20.38
Avg 7.38 12.10 20.23 11.57
Fig 3.5: Graphical representation of baseline air quality at Sultan Battery area
The observed levels of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the study period of
Winter 2016-17season. Concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the
Winter 2016-17season are represented graphically in Fig 3.6. Average concentrations of
both particulate matter and gaseous pollutants are within the NAAQS. Maximum
concentration of PM10 is observed at this location compared with the concentrations of
other pollutants.
30
20
10
0
SO₂ NO₂ PM₁₀ PM₂.₅
Min 4.84 8.56 12.88 5.75
Max 10.48 15.59 33.25 20
Avg 7.43 11.95 21.86 12.28
Fig 3.6: Graphical representation of baseline air quality at Hotel River View, Bangra
The observed levels of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the study period of
Winter 2016-17season. Concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOX collected during the
Winter 2016-17season are represented graphically in Fig 3.7. Average concentrations of
both particulate matter and gaseous pollutants are within the NAAQS. Maximum
concentration of PM10 is observed at this location compared with the concentrations of
other pollutants.
40
20
0
SO₂ NO₂ PM₁₀ PM₂.₅
Min 5.25 9.81 35.88 11.88
Max 26.33 27 56.88 28.33
Avg 13.52 15.87 47.10 19.57
Fig 3.7: Graphical representation of baseline air quality at KIOCL, Junction on NH-66
3.3.1.6 Observation/Interpretation
The NAAQ Standards for PM10, PM2.5 an gaseous pollutants SO2 and NO2 are given in
the Table 3.2 below.
The results of the analysis show that, the baseline air quality of all monitoring locations
sampled in the core and buffer zones of the study area are well within the limits
stipulated by the pollution control board, although utmost care will be taken to control
and mitigate the air pollution by adopting methods as proposed in the environmental
management plan.
The existing water resources, both surface and ground water with the corresponding
significance are identified within the study area (7 km radial distance) around project
site. The representative sampling locations for surface water and groundwater are
selected through reconnaissance to assess the existing status of water quality in the
impact zone. Physico-chemical, nutrient, Oxygen demand, bacteriological and
biological parameters having relevance to public health and aesthetic significance are
selected to assess the water quality status with special attention to raw water resource
and to evaluate anticipated impact due to the project activities. The proposed project
comes in CRZ II area. The project region falls in the western coastal plains and ghats
agroclimatic zone with mean annual rainfall of more than 200cm.
The water samples were collected from the available ground water and surface water
sources and have been analyzed to assess the quality of water. The locations showing
Surface and Ground Water monitoring stations is given in Fig 3.8.
presented in Table 3.5 and Fig. 3.6. Water sample analysis reports are attached as
Annexure 5.
Total Hardness as
1118 941 1006 1050 300 600
CaCO₃
Calcium as Ca 945 810 862 895 75 200
Magnesium as Mg 173 131 144 155 30 100
Total Suspended
311 206 244 285 -- 100
Solids
The soil is mostly lateritic type, found distributed in the Pediplain area characterised by
high iron and aluminium content. Lateritic soil is mostly red in color and yellow loamy,
pale to bright red colours are also seen. The normal mineral compositions of site are
altered by alteration in soil condition. Existence of flora & fauna depends upon the
quality of soil in the area. The soil characteristics like physical, chemical, erosion index,
soil fertility has bearing on the surrounding environment. Therefore the quality of soil
plays a major role in planning proper mitigative measures and green belt development
by the project proponent and also for the construction of building for different
purposes.
Five locations were selected for analyzing the soil quality status both in core & buffer
zone. The soil samples were collected from the buffer areas. The samples have been
analyzed for physico-chemical parameters. The details of the soil sampling locations
with distance from the core zone are given in Table. 3.6. The locations showing soil
monitoring stations is given in Fig 3.9.
Table 3.6: Soil Sampling Locations
Code Name of Sampling Location
S1 Project site, Tannerbavi
S2 Port Warf, Kasba Bazar
S3 Sultan Battery, Boloor
S4 Hotel River View, Kuloor
S5 KIOCL Junction, Panambur
The noise levels were monitored using an electronic sound level meter for winter
season at different sites. The noise levels measured at 5 locations in the months of
December 2016, January 2017 and February 2017 and the results obtained are given
below in Table 3.8, 3.9& 3.10 and the graphical representation of the same are given in
Fig. 3.11, 3.12 & 3.13. The analysis report of noise samples for the months of December,
January and February 2016 collected from five locations in core and buffers zones of the
study area are enclosed as Annexure No. 7
50
40
30 Lmin Day
20 Lmax Day
10
0 Leq Day
Project site 1 Port Warf, Sultan Battery Hotel River KIOCL, Junction
Kasba Bazar area View, Bangra on NH-66
Location
80
Noise level, dB
60
Lmin Day
40
Lmax Day
20 Leq Day
0
Project site 1 Port Warf, Sultan Battery Hotel River KIOCL, Junction
Kasba Bazar area View, Bangra on NH-66
Location
50
40
30 Lmin Day
20 Lmax Day
10
Leq Day
0
Project site 1 Port Warf, Sultan Battery Hotel River KIOCL, Junction
Kasba Bazar area View, Bangra on NH-66
Location
pollution control board, although utmost care will be taken to control and mitigate the
noise generation during the construction and operation of the proposed project.
The middle of the 18th century saw birth of industrialization, which increased during
19th & 20th century and exploded in 21st century. The resources produced over and
sustained for thousands of years were exploited and squandered for the luxuries of few
humans. An unsustainable exploitation of resources has exploded pollution, so was the
inevitable result. Thus, a chain of events of exploitation consumption- pollution-
depletion and further exploitation started responding the imbalance and determination
of ecological system.
Developing economies like India is in transition and undergoes huge changes in the
industrial landscape, The expanding industrial landscape in India requires to strike a
balance between industrial development and physical environment so as to reduce the
intensity of the impacts of the industrialisation on the environment.
Objectives
Following are the objectives of the study:
• To generate baseline data from field observations;
• To compare the data so generated with authentic past records to understand changes;
• To characterize the environmental components like land, water, flora and fauna;
• To understand the present biodiversity;
• To identify susceptible sensitive and critical areas (environmental hotspots);
• To understand impact of industrial activities on the flora and fauna;
• To predict changes as a result of impact in the composition and functioning of
components of the ecosystem.
A participatory and consultative approach was followed for executing the assignment
on Biodiversity assessment of the project site and adjacent region in consultation with,
front line officials of the Forest Department and local villagers on existing biodiversity
of the region and the forest management aspects. Literature survey included review of
forest working plan and other published records related to biodiversity and ecology of
the region.
Methodology
We have examined the flora and fauna of Thannir Bhavi, Dhakshin Kannada District,
Mangalore Taluk, Karnataka. The Proposed Site is in CRZ Classification (CRZ - II). We
have gone around the core area and a seven kilometre of buffer zone around all the
direction of the Proposed Site and recorded the flora and fauna and recorded the
biodiversity falling in River basin, stream area, agricultural bunds, forest area, avenue
plantations, house backyards etc.,. In each of the land use, we have identified the
species and recorded. Besides recording the plant species, other biodiversity aspects in
the form of endemic status, conservation status and life form have been collected from
the literature.
Vegetation : All out search method was carried out in all landscape elements of the
region enlisting grass, sedges, herbs, climbers, lianas, shrubs and trees. Species were
identified on the spot.
South Canara district is one of 30 districts of the state Karnataka, India. The district has
a cross-section (Western Ghats) of Karnataka’s natural attributes; Mangalore is situated
on the backwaters formed by convergent mouths of Netravathi and Gurpura rivers;
consequently it has waters on south and west sides. It is 350 Kms west of the Bangalore
& lies between the Western Ghats to the east and the sea to the west. It is lulled by the
gentle breeze of the Arabian Sea in summer, but lashed by the furious rain-bearing
winds during the monsoon (June to September). Mangalore is blessed with abundant
rivers – Netravati, Gurpur, Gangolli, Sitanadi and Swarnanadi. The rich alluvial
deposits on either side of the river banks provide fertile soil for paddy cultivation.
Sheltered by the soaring Western Ghats on the east and bordered by the blue waters of
the Arabian Sea, Mangalore is blessed with abundant groves of areca nut and coconut
palms, rainfall, fertile soil, lush vegetation; pristine beaches and rich cultural heritage.
Coastal ecosystems are the world’s most productive; here sunlight saturates the
shallow, nutrient rich coastal waters. Algal beds, seagrass meadows, reefs, estuaries and
mangroves provide food and shelter for vast quantities of fish, shellfish, and other
marine organisms. Because of the high productivity and the transportation facilities,
including the trans-oceanic, this coastal zone has been densely populated since ancient
times.
The following biodiversity eco-systems were surveyed and characterized along with
threats and pressures.
1. Mangrove vegetation
2. Estuaries Biodiversity
3. Fresh Water Biodiversity
4. Marine Biodiversity
5. Coastal Vegetation (Psamophytic species).
6. Coastal ecologically sensitive habitats.
Sea coast: The coastline includes both rocky and sandy beaches as well as about 5 Kms
broad coastal zone. Vegetation was studied which include the beaches, agricultural
lands, human habitations, forests, grasslands and other natural or manmade vegetation.
Estuaries, creeks and other backwaters. The coastal landscape is heterogeneous and
contains of vegetational elements, such as: Evergreen forest, semi-evergreen forest;
secondary moist deciduous forest, scrub, mangroves, beach vegetation, planted groves
of trees, horticultural gardens, agricultural fields where various crops are cultivated,
grasslands, household gardens.
Fisheries: Fishing in Marine, Inland, Brackish water & Fresh water; Major type of
fish catch are Oil Sardine, Mackerel, Ribbon fish, Pink pearch, Prawns,
Squilla, Squids & Cuttlefish.
G. balticum +
Leptocylindricus sp. -
Licmophora gracillis +
Licmophora sp. -
Mastogloia splendia -
Melosira numuloides +
Melosira striata -
Navicula inflexa +
N. smithii -
Navicula sp. +
Nitzchia frigid -
N. lanceolata -
N. paleacea ++
N. panduriformis +
N. pungens +
N. sigma -
Nitzschia sp1 +
Nitzschia sp2 -
Pinularia viridis +
Pinularia sp. +
Pleurosigma anqulatum +
P. elongatum +
P. delicatum -
Pleurosigma sp. +
Progonoia sp. -
Pseudo-nitzschia sp. +
Raphoneis sp. +
Rhizosolania alata +
R. robusta +++
Rhizosolenia sp. -
Skeletonema costatum ++
Synedra sp. -
Thallassiothrix longissima +
Thalassiosira sp. +
Triceratium sp. +
CYANOBACTERIA
Anabaena sperica
Chroococcus sp. ++
Lyngbya martensiana +
Merismopedia sp. +++
Microcystis aureginosa -
Oscillatoria animalis -
O. cortiana +
O. lemnetica +
O. limosa +
Oscillatoria pseudogeminata -
O. brevis -
Oscillatoria salina
Oscillatoria tenius
Phormidium angustissimum +
Phormidium lucidu +
P. tenue
Plectonema boryanum +
Synechocystis salina +
DINOFLAGELLATES
Cerecium minutum +
Cerecium sp. -
Dinophysis coudata +
Noctiluca scintillans +
Prorocentrum micans +
PLANKTONIC GREEN ALGAE
Chlamydomonas sp. +
Chlorella sp. -
Pediastrum boryanum -
Pediastrum sp. +
Spirogyra sp. +
Ulothrix -
The Project proposed area devoid of natural vegetation. The demarcated area contains
only a isolated patch of Acaica auriculiiformis and Casuarina equisetiolia, which are non
native trees. There is no reserve forest or protected area around Thannir Bhavi,
Dhakshin Kannada District, Mangalore Taluk, Karnataka. The falls under the coastal
Zone area. The region presents an area wide range of altitudes, aspects, slopes,
drainage, and spills giving rise to a variety of locality factors reflected in the occurrence
of number of forest types from tropical semi-evergreen. The dominant species observed
in the study area Commercial crops and Plantation crops (Coconut, Arecanut, Cashew)
Artocarpus heterophyllus, Careya arborea, Mimosops elengi, Tectona grandis, Vitex altisima.
Bambusa bambos breaks were also observed throughout the semi-evergreen and moist
deciduous forest types.
The Plant species, Aquatic Flora and Fauna in study area documented in and around 7-
km radius of the project site and the list of Phytoplankton, Zooplankton, small
mammals, reptiles and birds reported for the region were given in Table (3.13 – 3.22)
objective of this section is to provide a baseline status of the study area covering 10 km
radius around the project site, so that temporal changes due to the project activities on
the surroundings can be assessed in future.
3.8.1 Objectives
The objectives of the land use studies are:
o To determine the present land use pattern,
o To determine the temporal changes in land use pattern due to construction and
operation phase,
o To analyze the impacts on land use due to quarrying activities in the study area,
o To give recommendations for optimizing the future land use pattern viz-a-viz
growth of industrial activities in the study area and their associated impacts.
The land use / land cover classification standardized by the Department of Space, for
mapping different agro-climatic zones has been presented here. The present
classification system has four major classes as mentioned below:
(2) Agricultural Land: This comprises areas primarily used for raising agricultural
crops, vegetables and plant material of medicinal and commercial values.
(3) Forest: Forest is defined as all land bearing vegetative association dominated by
trees of any size, exploited or not, capable of producing wood or other forest products
and exerting an influence on climatic or water regimes, or providing shelter for wildlife
and live stock.
(4) Wasteland: Land having potential for development of vegetation cover but not being
used due to constraints which include salt affected land, eroded land and water logged
area.
(5) Water bodies: This comprises area persistently covered by water such as rivers/
streams/ reservoirs/ tanks, lakes/ ponds and canals.
(6) Others: This class includes shifting cultivation, grass land / grazing land and snow
covered / glacial land.
3.8.3 Methodology
The land use of the study area has studied by analyzing the available secondary data as
the latest village wise census of 2011. The proposed project site extends over an area of
914 acres. The Area statement with break up details of Land use is given in Table- 3.19
Building Names
1. Resort
Lower Ground 4847
Upper Ground 4210
First Floor 4227
Second Floor 4808
Third floor 4808
Total plinth area 22900
2. Spa 1144
3. Convention Centre 3355
4. Service Block (G+2) 1416
5. Golf Club
Ground Floor 1416
First Floor 1416
Viewing Tower 400
Total Plinth Area 9508
6. Small Rooms
Ground Floor 500
The digital elevation map has also been provided which explains the contours and
terrains of the study area. The highest elevation point of the study area is found to be
6m above MSL and the lowest elevation point of the study area is found to be 4m above
the MSL. The digital elevation map has shown as Fig 3.21.
Fig 3.15: Digital elevation map showing the 7 km radius around the project location
A primary data collection by doing sample survey of the villages under buffer zone was
conducted. The first hand information regarding number of population, occupation,
literacy level etc., were obtained from the latest census data 2011. There are no
inhabited villages within the project area. Hence, this Socio-economic study was
conducted in the buffer-zone only. The villages where the socio-economic survey was
conducted are Gollapalle, Ragimakulapalle, Palasamudram, Devulacheruvu, Gudipalle
and Tungodu. The socio economic condition is summarized below in Table 3.21 and
graphically shown in Fig 3.22. The detailed list with villages surveyed in the 7 Km
buffer zone of study area is enclosed as Annexure XVI.
Population Details:
1% 0%
1% 0%
10%
22%
Total No of House Holds
Population Total
Population M
44%
22% Population F
S.C M
S.C F
S.T M
S.T F
Population Lit.
Female Lit. 42%
21%
Population Lit.
Male Lit.
Male Lit.
21%
Female Lit.
Population Illiterate
Male Illiterate
Female Illiterate
Total Worker
Non Worker Female Population Total Worker Population
13% 15% Total Worker Male
Non Worker Male Total
7% Worker Total Worker Female
Male Main Worker Population
10%
Main Worker Male
Non Worker
Population Main Worker Female
Main Worker Total
20% Population Marginal Worker Population
Worker
14% Female Marginal Worker Male
5%
Marginal Worker Female
Marginal
Worker Female Non Worker Population
0% Marginal
Non Worker Male
Marginal Worker Main Worker Main Worker Male
Worker Male Population Female 10% Non Worker Female
1% 1% 4%
A study on traffic density was conducted during the study period. Training of counting
techniques was provided to local workers engaged for the monitoring. Standard pro-
forma was supplied to the trained personnel for recording the data. The traffic study
has been conducted to know the existing traffic scenario and assess the impact of
increase in traffic due to the proposed project. This study would help to assess the
adequacy of the existing roads for the increased traffic and subsequent pollution load.
The traffic study was conducted on the NH 66 near Baikampady Industrial Estate,
Mangalore. The study considered both the roads leading to Mangalore and Karwar on
opposite directions. A detailed Traffic management study has been enclosed as
Annexure 8.
4.0 Introduction
The impacts (both beneficial and adverse) of project and its allied activities of the
project have been assessed and presented in respect of air, noise, water, land, biological
and socio-economic in this chapter. The control measures to mitigate various
environmental impacts are also highlighted.
The construction and operational phase of the proposed Golf course and beach resort
comprises various activities, each of which may have either positive or negative impact
on environmental attributes. The proposed project activities would impart impact on
the environment in two distinct phases:
The likely impacts due to proposed activities and mitigation measures are described for
the following environmental components as shown in table below.
Table 4.1: Anticipated impacts and mitigation measures during construction and
operation phase of the project
economic
conditions.
7 Traffic Pattern Slight increase in Material will be brought in batches so that
traffic congestion there is no sudden increase of traffic volume
at one particular time.
Operation phase
1 Land There will be a Waste management practices like 3 R’S
environment change in land principle will be adopted.
use pattern.
Increased solid
waste generation
2 Air Particulate and Green Belt Development on periphery and
environment gaseous open areas. Adequate stack height will be
emissions from maintained for DG sets.
vehicle
movement and
DG sets
3 Noise Minor impact Green belt area will be planted which acts as
environment inside premises noise barriers.
4 Water Increased Roof top rain water harvesting for RWH
environment demand plan. STP will be adopted to treat generated
& pressure on sewage and use of treated sewage water for
water resources. flushing and gardening purpose.
Sewage
generation.
5 Biological Positive impact Landscaping will help in reducing adverse
environment impact on air and noise quality.
6 Socio economic Positive impact Development of physical and social
infrastructure. Increased job opportunities
in operation and maintenance work.
7 Traffic pattern No adverse Parking facility will be provided.
impact
The proposed project will have marginal impacts on local socio-economic condition of
the people residing in the area. The construction Golf course and Beach resort would
provide temporary employment, which may consist of locals too. The estimated
employment generation from the project is about 350 nos. This would improve the
socio-economic condition of the local population. The operation of the proposed project
would result in positive impacts such as economic development and generation of
employment opportunity.
5.0 Introduction
The Environmental monitoring is the primary tool for assessing the prevailing quality
of air, water, noise & soil etc., which helps in suggesting and taking mid-course
corrections, if found negatively impacted. Monitoring of various environmental
parameters for Ambient Air Quality, Water Quality, Noise Levels, Soil quality testing
will be carried out in and around the project site and in buffer zone to ascertain the
following:
This monitoring shall be periodic and comply with the guidelines of statutory
authorities. Necessary funds will be allocated by the project proponent for the same, as
environmental protection has been identified, as an integral part of proposed project.
Frequent advice sought from appropriate authorities, will go long way in improving the
environment. The frequency of monitoring of various environmental components is
given in Table 5.1.
The environmental attributes and its frequency of monitoring are given below.
All the meteorological parameters will be recorded and the observations will be
analyzed through-out the study period and during the post clearance phase as per the
stipulated guidelines, the parameters monitored will be as follows.
o Maximum and minimum temperature
o Relative humidity
o Wind velocity and direction
o Rainfall
The ambient air quality has been monitored for PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NOx parameters
as part of the baseline studies at 5 locations and frequency of monitoring was as per the
Terms of Reference (TOR) Guidelines and the results were compared with the CPCB
norms. The regular monitoring will be carried out in the same locations/stations during
the project implementation stages, the locations are as follows,
Code Locations
A1 Project Site 1, Opp. Coast Guard Ship
Station
A2 Port Warf, Kasba Bazar, Bundar
A3 Sultan Battery area
A4 Hotel River View, Bangra, Kulur
The Particulate dust sampler APM-451 and Respirable Dust Sampler (RDS) have been
used for monitoring the ambient air pollutants like PM10, PM2.5 & gaseous pollutants etc.
Unit μg/m3
Four ground water samples and two surface water samples were collected and
analyzed as per IS 3025 method during the baseline studies. Same number of samples
will be analyzed as part of regular monitoring programme, the monitoring locations are
as given below;
Code Locations
SW 1 Estuarine water at Port Warf
SW 2 Gurupur river water(Brackish) at Sultan Battery
SW 3 Gurupur river water at Hotel River View
SW 4 Gurupur river water(brackish) at KIOCL Jn
GW Project site 1
The water quality has been analyzed for all the physical, chemical and biological
parameters as per the standards / norms (IS 3025 protocol). The sampling and analysis
methods followed as per BIS standards. The water quality is monitored for all the
samples, which are collected from the above mentioned sources.
The ambient noise level has been monitored at the following locations and results are
compared with CPCB standards. The environmental monitoring program will be
carried out during the project implementation stage as per the regulatory guidelines at
regular intervals; the locations are as specified in below table.
Code Locations
N1 Project site 1
N2 Port Warf, Kasba Bazar
N3 Sultan Battery area
N4 Hotel River View, Bangra
N5 KIOCL, Junction on NH-66
The quality of the soil has been be monitored once in study period as per IS 2720, IS
1498 and other applicable procedure. The locations of the stations are as follows.
Code Locations
Project site, Tannerbavi
S1
Port Warf, Kasba Bazar
S2
Sultan Battery, Boloor
S3
Hotel River View, Kuloor
S4
KIOCL Junction, Panambur
S5
6.0 Introduction
The project proposal comprises of construction of proposed Beach resort and Golf
Course at Survey Nos. Sy.No 1/P1, 1/P2, 1/P3, 51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre village,
Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshina Kannada, Karnataka State. The proposed project shall yield
following benefits:
Opus Laguna Golf & Resorts Private Limited shall take up some community welfare
activities under Corporate Social Responsibility and contribute to improve social
infrastructures like education and health care system etc.
The direct employment opportunities with Opus Laguna Golf & Resorts Private
Limited may be limited due to the specialized nature of the job but the opportunities
exist mainly with the contractors and sub-contractors. These agencies will be persuaded
to provide the jobs to local residents on a preferential basis wherever feasible.
The project shall provide employment potential under unskilled, semi-skilled and
skilled categories. The employment potential shall increase with the start of
construction activities, reach a peak during construction phase and then reduce with
completion of construction activities. During construction phase the project provide
employment opportunity of about 400 labors and during operation phase about 350
nos. of employment opportunities.
7.0 General
The most enjoyed activities /recreational pursuits in Beach Resorts are swimming,
sunbathing, playing, relaxing, boating and water sport related leisure and recreational
activities. In the context of conservation and sustainable development of the coastal
zone, key management issues of coastal environments become one of managing
amenity interactions of the range of these uses. These activities will have impact during
design, planning, and execution of the project. Proper planning is needed to prevent or
minimize these impacts. Sustainable development strives to ensure that natural and
cultural systems are in balance with each other and within themselves. Therefore it is
necessary that we have to incorporate the environmental and social safeguards while
planning, design execution and implementing coastal infrastructure project. EMP aims
at controlling pollution at the source level to the possible extent with the best techno-
economically feasible and available methodology before they are discharged.
The impacts due to the project during the construction phase are identified to include
Air, Noise and soil during excavation phase, movement of earth and building
materials, liquid and solid wastes generated due to construction labor during the
period. The following are the suitable measures that will be adopted during
construction phase
A main source of air pollution is from operation of DG set of capacity 1500 KVA used
only during the power failure. Hence pollution is going to be very less. Preference shall
be given to Low sulphur DG sets. Apart from this pollution from the vehicular
movement, the area is covered by fully green belt so there will not be any air pollution
anticipated.
The main source of noise during operation phase will be due to the movement of
vehicles of tourists, users/residents of the Resort facilities including Golf Course users.
developed all along the boundary and on the periphery/ within the premises which
acts as noise barrier and helps in attenuation of noise.
The contamination of soil by spilled fuel and lubricants from equipments such as DG
sets, vehicles as well as due to improper storage and disposal of solid waste. Golf course
maintenance requires use of various chemicals such as fertilizers, weedicides and
pesticides. Hence the proponent envisages maximum use of biopesticides and
biofertilizers for maintaining the golf course. The philosophy of solid waste
management will be to encourage the Four R’s of waste i.e. waste reduction, reuse,
recycling, and recovery (materials & energy). This will result in lesser reliance on land
filling. A Golf course presents the opportunity to meet a need for recreational amenities,
while preserving green space and serves as a protective buffer by providing
stabilization against erosion.
Water conservation and measures have been planned for groundwater recharging
through rainwater harvesting including all possible potential for reuse and recycling of
water. The Golf course will promote the proper use and conservation of water
resources. As the proposed project area is vast, storm water management system has
been proposed to reduce the raw water consumption.
To collect Rainwater vertical pipes from the terrace / roof areas are taken into the shafts
provided for the purpose. These pipes are then dropped down to the ground floor level
and get terminated at the ceiling level of the ground floor wherein they are connected to
main headers of required higher sizes running suspended at ceiling level with the help
of brackets to support them. These rainwater pipes are then dropped down to the
ground level to connect to the catch basins and Hume pipe network, and finally pass
through the storm water drain present surrounding the periphery of the each building
& finally to the drain surrounding the entire building area and this water will recharge
the ground water via rain water harvesting pits and the excess/overflow from the drain
is connected to rain water harvesting tank /storm water collection sump. As the area
involved is very vast, the anticipated generation of storm water will be of huge
quantity, hence it is proposed to construct the rain water harvesting pond at the low
lying area of the project site. This water will be treated according to the requirement by
providing a filtration unit and then re-used for the domestic purposes.
Q= Runoff in m3/sec
The total volume of storm water discharged will be calculated by considering 15min of
maximum rainfall. The calculations are done as per the statuary guide lines. This run off
from the roof area will be diverted to roof top rainwater collection sump and finally
stored in rainwater collection pond. This water shall be used for domestic purposes
after the necessary treatment.
Total Run off from the entire area would be 815 m3 (Say 820 m3 )
Hence there will be huge quantity of runoff from the proposed area, so the rain water
harvesting pond is proposed to be provided in the low lying area within the site.
Trees and shrubs will be grown on the sides of play area. Vegetated surfaces such as
vegetated podiums and open grid paving will be done. Green area of the project will be
around 5405.0 Sqm. Trees with large canopy will be grown on the periphery and grass
and shrubs on the podium. Some of the trees proposed are listing down in the below
Table 7.1.
Table 7.1 Shrubs and Tree Species Proposed:
Disaster response is a multi-layered activity which starts from awareness about them at
an individual and household level and goes up to community and civil administration
level. Organizations with formal assemblage of people, either for residential or non-
residential also need to identify and widely make known the natural hazards likely in
their premise and ways of mitigating them in at the time of crisis.
The term Disaster, Hazard and Vulnerability have been defined as follows:
economic or environmental losses and impacts which exceeds the ability of the
affected community or society to cope using its own resources.” - UN
International Strategy for Disaster Reduction, (UNISDR)
b. A Disaster is a "Situation or event, which overwhelms local capacity,
necessitating a request to national or international level for external assistance;
an unforeseen and often sudden event that causes great damage, destruction and
human suffering". - Centre for Research of Epidemiology of Disaster (CRED),
Belgium
c. Hazard is a natural physical event which has a potential to convert into a
disaster, causing widespread injury or deaths and damage to public or private
property or the environment.
d. “Vulnerability means inability to resist a hazard or respond when a disaster has
occurred. It depends on several factors such as people’s age and state of health,
local environmental and sanitary conditions, as well as on the quality and state of
local buildings and their location with respect to any hazards.” – UNISDR.
Disasters are often classified according to their cause i.e. natural or manmade.
A. Natural disasters:-
Flood, Earthquake, Tsunami, Cyclone, Landslide, etc.
B. Manmade disasters:-
Air crash, Railway accident, Industrial accident, Bomb blast, etc.
A Disaster Management Plan (DMP) is prepared by considering all the factors required
for management and mitigation of adverse effects of any small or big disaster. Some
man-made disasters can be avoided by proper design, adequate maintenance and good
house-keeping.
The DMP therefore needs to be related to the identification of sources from which
hazards can arise and the maximum loss scenario that can take place in the concerned
area. The project proponent should adhere to all the laws regulating the construction of
the proposed resort.
low probability of occurrence and low to moderate severity. However, preparedness for
any event is of paramount importance to the Resort and Golf course project.
a. Proposed location of the Resort is on a barrier beach between Gurpur River and
the sea. In event of high torrential rain caused by a cyclone, there could be bank-
breach on the river causing short circuiting of flow of water through over the
barrier beach subjecting the Resort site to voluminous inundation.
b. Route of evacuation to mainland town runs parallel to the seashore thus the
evacuation route is partially exposed to effect of tsunamigeneic waves.
c. Some occupants of the Resort may be foreign tourists who might not have
appropriate local threat perception and may be from non-english speaking
vi. The buildings will not have any overhang not supported from
the roof structure/truss/purling through structural tie-ins. No gravity-resting
canopy, pargolas, etc. will be constructed in the buildings.
vii. Braches of trees will be cropped so as not to interfere with the window openings
or form canopy above the buildings.
viii. All weak trees which may cause fall hazards during high wind conditions
will be uprooted or sawed at breast height. No trees with spreading canopy or
branches will be maintained at the two pole structure or near outdoor power
incomer structures.
ix. Internal roads and parking will be designed in annular manner so that vehicles
may not need to reverse for going out of the Resort.
x. A high power paging system will be installed in the Resort covering all the
building foyers, corridors, amenities and outdoor areas for mass
communications.
xi. Residual current circuit breakers will be installed on all electrical fittings to
eliminate risk of electrocution during any event of inundation.
xii. Personnel and occupant movements in the Resort will be documented at the gate
for rapid head count.
xiii. 5 kg DCP type fire extinguishers will be installed within 30 m travel span in
all the buildings. 5 kg CO2 type extinguishers will be placed near electrical
board room, near outdoor power incomer structure and in the kitchen.
The Resort management will follow organization structure as shown in Figure 8.1.
Responsibilities of the individual team member are described as follows.
d. The Resort will stock HSD fuel in 200 l MS drums for DG and vehicles so that
they are no dependant on a filling station supply in time of crisis.
e. All vehicles in the duty of the Resort will be kept monsoon worthy by end of
May.
f. One vehicle capable of carrying 6-8 people should be on duty with the Resort at
all times.
g. Security incharge will be responsible for maintaining a First Aid Box and an
Emergency Tool Kit, as listed in Table 3.2.
a) Resort Manager will be the overall incharge of all Resort functions. He will be the
link between District/local Administration and the Resort.
b) Resort Manager will be empowered to take necessary commercial and personnel
decisions in the event of any natural disaster.
c) Resort Manager may or may not be resident in the resort. He will be available to
assist the Resort Duty Officer during any emergency.
d) He will be responsible for emergency medical aid agreement with a nearby
hospital. He will keep updated about key persons in the Local Administration
who may contact him during any emergency.
e) He will be authorized to talk to media in case of any public declaration regarding
the Resort to be made.
f) He will be responsible for adherence of all structural safeguards and stocking of
consumable pertaining to emergency management. He will be responsible
periodic mock drills in the Resort.
g) In event of his absence, all his responsibilities will be undertaken by the senior
most Resort Duty Officer who is not on duty at the time of emergency.
a) Resort Duty Officer will be the person incharge of the overall operations of the
Resort corresponding to his shift of duty. Resort Duty Officers will be present in
all shifts on relieving basis. Resort Duty Officer will act as On-Scene
Commander for all emergency actions in the Resort.
b) He will coordinate with the Security Incharge for effective message
transmission to all occupants and mustering of all occupants at the
assembly point near the Gate Complex of the Resort.
c) All utilities and amenities such as DGs, emergency/backup power,
communication will be operated under his instructions.
d) He will take the decision for evacuation of occupants and employees of the
Resort in consultation with the Resort Manager/Acting Resort Manager.
f) He will ensure that all windows shutters are closed and secured. All loose
windows will be sealed by duct tape.
Table 8.2 Contents of First Aid Box and Emergency Tool Kit
Cyclones are huge revolving storms caused by winds blowing around a central
area of low atmospheric pressure. In the northern hemisphere, cyclones are called
hurricanes or typhoons and their winds blow in an anti-clockwise circle. In the southern
hemisphere, these tropical storms are known as cyclones, whose winds blow in a
clockwise circle. Cyclones develop over warm seas near the Equator. Air heated by the
sun rises very swiftly, which creates areas of very low pressure. As the warm air rises, it
becomes loaded with moisture which condenses into massive thunderclouds. Cool air
rushes in to fill the void that is left, but because of the constant turning of the Earth on
its axis, the air is bent inwards and then spirals upwards with great force. The swirling
winds rotate faster and faster, forming a huge circle which can be up to 2,000 km across.
At the centre of the storm is a calm, cloudless area called the eye, where there is no rain,
and the winds are fairly light.
Following measures are recommended to the occupants before, during and after a
cyclone:
a) All occupants will keep their identification papers (photo IDs, passport, VISA
and currency notes secure in a waterproof sling bag
b) Occupants will keep their cellular phones charged and in switched on mode
c) Occupants will identify their next of kin and their contact numbers with the
Resort at the time of registration
d) Occupants will be vigilant towards any paging announcement and will follow
the instructions swiftly and decisively.
e) Occupants will not make long calls on their cellular phones as it may cause the
airwave to be crowded and hinder necessary communications.
a) Ensure that you and your family members are wearing strong shoes and suitable
clothing.
b) Take your Emergency Kit and your Evacuation Kit and commence your
Evacuation Plan.
c) Turn off all electricity, gas and water and unplug all appliances if inside the
Resort or at any location functioning as cyclone shelter.
d) Keep your Emergency Kit close at hand.
e) Bring your family into the strongest part of the house. This may even be a
bathroom covered from all sides.
f) Keep listening to the radio for cyclone updates and remain indoors until advised.
g) If the building begins to break up, immediately seek shelter under a strong table
or bench or under a heavy mattress.
h) Beware of the calm eye of the cyclone. Some people venture outdoors during the
eye of the cyclone, mistakenly believing that the cyclone has passed. Stay inside
until you have received official advice that it is safe to go outside.
The time immediately after a cyclone is often just as dangerous as the initial event itself.
Many injuries and deaths have occurred as a result of people failing to take
proper precautions while exploring collapsed buildings and sightseeing through
devastated streets. Once you have been advised that the cyclone has passed you must
adhere to the following:
a) Listen to your radio and remain indoors until advised or contacted by the Resort
personnel.
b) If you are told to return to the Resort, , do so using the recommended
routes communicated by the Resort Duty Officer.
c) Do not go sightseeing.
d) Do not use electrical appliances which have been wet until they are checked for
safety.
e) Boil or purify your water until supplies are declared safe.
f) Stay away from damaged powerlines, fallen trees and flood water. g. If your
building has become uninhabitable due to cyclone damage, contact Resort
Administration to prioritize a cleanup.
A tsunami is a series of fast moving waves produced during large scale ocean
disturbances. A tsunami can occur with very little warning; caused by a variety of
natural or technological events, such as earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, explosions,
landslides, and meteorite impacts. Tsunami is different from regular ocean waves in
several ways:
A tsunami is a series of sea waves that are extremely long. As a tsunami crosses
a deep ocean the length from crest to crest may be as much as 150 kilometres and
these waves can travel at speeds of 1,000 km/h.
As a tsunami leaves the deep water of the ocean and travels to the shallower
water near the coast, the tsunami slows and the wave height increases. This
process is called shoaling.
A tsunami that is unnoticeable at sea, because of its long wave lengths, may
reach several metres or more in height by the time that it reaches the coast.
Regular ocean waves move in the water from the surface down to around 150m
deep, but a tsunami moves in the water all the way to the seafloor. Therefore the
volume of water that is moved by a tsunami is significantly more than the
amount moved by regular ocean waves.
As many tsunami are a series of waves, there is often more than one wave and
the first wave may not be the largest.
Depending on whether the first part of a tsunami to reach the shore is a crest or a
trough, it may appear as a rapidly rising or falling tide.
Even a small tsunami can be very dangerous to swimmers and mariners.
Because of the limited warning time for a tsunami, it is very important for the occupants
to quickly follow the instructions given by the Resort Management.
Following measures are recommended to the occupants before, during and after a
tsunami.
k) Tsunami move significantly faster than normal wind-driven waves and can
move faster than people can run. Once you see the tsunami it may be too late to
escape. The backwash of a tsunami is extremely dangerous. As the large volume
of water recedes back towards the ocean, it may carry debris and people back to
sea with it. Hold on to a tall, strong structure if waves have reached you. Do not
enter the water if you are at a dry or high place.
l) Even a small tsunami may cause strong turbulence and very dangerous currents.
DO not wade through water of unknown depth and current.
m) Do not return to coastal areas/low lying areas until an all-clear is given by
emergency services or public officials.
a) Wait for the Resort Management to contact you and ask you to come back to the
Resort.
b) Do not go near flooded and damaged areas until the emergency services or
public officials advise that it is safe to return.
c) Do not drink unboiled tap water until water supplies have been declared safe.
d) Do not eat food which has been immersed in flood waters.
e) Do not use gas or electrical appliances in the Resort which have been immersed
in flood waters until they have been checked and declared safe.
The DMP has been prepared before the Resort has been constructed and has
become operational. The DMP must be revised immediately after construction of the
Resort is over and it is ready to accept occupancies so that relevant details of the Resort
pertaining to emergency preparedness are re-documented and made suitable for actual
implementation.
8.11.1 Fire:
Occurrence of fire requires fuel, heat and oxidizer. Fire disasters are most common of
the emergencies which can occur at a resort site. Sometimes they occur in circumstances
that are unexpected or unpredictable. Fire incidences can be natural or human
generated.
Types of fires
1. Natural: Natural fires are generated by volcanic eruption, lightning and the like.
Earthquake and storms can cause devastating fires due to short circuits in
damaged houses, fallen power cables, ignition of spilled fuels, gas leakages, etc.
Proper insulation, meticulous wiring, leak proof storage etc. should form a part
of disaster preparedness.
2. Manmade: Faulty electrical circuits, defective electrical wiring, poor
maintenance of “boilers/electrical equipment”, cooking gas leakages, etc can
cause fires. Similarly, accidental leakage of flammable liquids and careless
disposal of lighted cigarette buds can also cause devastating fires.
3. List of Major Fire Hazards:
Flammable chemicals: Paints, Aerosols, Fuels, etc.
Flammable substances: Furniture, Upholstery, Dry Grass, etc.
Processes involving open flame: Cooking, Smoking, etc.
Heat producing devices: Dryers, Heaters, Hot Plates, etc.
Electrical equipment: Short circuits and malfunctioning equipment.
8.11.3 Floods
Fortunately, Karnataka is not prone to severe flooding due to its hilly topography
combined with excellent network of drainage provided by rivers and flood plains. In
particular the project site is free from flooding hazards.
Prepared by METAMORPHOSISSM Projects Consultants Private Ltd. Bengaluru Page 102
EMP Report For Proposed Construction Beach Resort & Golf Course At Survey Nos. Sy.No 1/P1, 1/P2,
1/P3, 51/P1 & 52/P2 at Bengre village, Mangaluru Taluk, Dakshin Kannada, Karnataka State.
8.11.4 Cyclones
Cyclones are caused by atmospheric disturbances around a low-pressure area with
swift and often destructive air circulation. They cause violent storms and heavy rains.
The air circulates inward in an anticlockwise direction in the Northern hemisphere and
clockwise in the Southern hemisphere. As per the accepted classification of Cyclones,
Karnataka falls in Category II of low vulnerability.
Cyclones are classified into five different levels on the basis of wind speed. They are
further divided into the following categories according to their damage capacity.
01 120-150 Minimal
02 150-180 Moderate
03 180-210 Extensive
04 210-250 Extreme
8.11.5 Tsunamis
The Indian coastal belt has not recorded many severe tsunamis in the past. Few
tsunamis are known to have occurred in Indian Ocean. The multi hazard situation on
the West coast of India is presented in the following table.
Table 8.5 Multiple Hazard Data for West Coast of India
8.11.7 Explosion
This refers to air-borne or grounded detonation of explosive devices on or near targets.
The detonator can be carried by hand, delivered by vehicles, hurled as projectiles, or
placed in the usual supplies to the Resort/Hotel building. The detonators can be non-
nuclear type or nuclear type. Explosions almost instantaneously damage the built
environment. If more devices than one are used in a chain, then the duration of the
threat is enhanced and the extent of damage is greater. The extent of damage is
determined by the type, quality and quality of possibilities – from non-structural
element loss, structural element damage, structural elements collapse, to progressive
failure of part/ whole building.
8.11.8 Arson
This refers to initiation of fire at or near targets. The fire can be initiated by direct
contact or by a projectile carrying an accelerant. The threat can last from minutes to
hours. The extent of damage is determined by the type and quality of device/accelerant
used in arson, and by the type of materials present at or near targets. Again, damage
can vary over the whole spectrum – from non-structural element loss, structural
elements damage, structural element collapse, to progressive failure of “part/whole”
resort.
8.11.11 Epidemics
Apart from the natural and transnational movement of pathogenic organisms, their
potential use as weapons of biological warfare and bio-terrorism has becomes far more
important now than ever before. Utilization of organisms causing smallpox and anthrax
by terrorist group can cause great harm and panic. Biological agents are living
organisms or their toxic products that can kill or incapacitate people, livestock, and
plants.
8.11.12 Bio-terrorism
Bio-terrorism can be defined as the use of biological agents to cause deaths, disability or
damage mainly to human beings. The three basic groups of biological agents, which
could be used as weapons, are bacteria, viruses, and toxins. Most biological agents are
difficult to grow and maintain. Many breakdown quickly when exposed to sunlight and
other environmental factors, while others, such as anthrax spores, persist very long.
Biological agents can be dispersed by spraying them into the air, by infecting animals
that carry the disease to humans and by contaminating food and water. Potentially,
hundreds of human pathogens could be used as weapons; however, public health
authorities have identified only a few as having the potential to cause mass casualties
leading to civil disruptions.
There are a number of causes why biological weapons are potentially more powerful
agents of mass casualties leading to civil disruption. Biological agents can be
disseminated with readily available technology. Common agricultural spray can be
adapted to disseminate biological pathogens of proper particle size to cause infection in
human population over great distances.
The perpetrators can use natural weather conditions, such as wind and temperature
inversions as well as existing building infrastructures (e.g. ventilation system) or air
movement related to transportation (e.g. subway trains and cars passing through
tunnels) to disseminate these agents. The expense of producing biological weapons is
far less than that of creating other weapon systems.
The mere mention of the word plague conjures up deadly images because, historically it
has already demonstrated a potential to kill millions of people across the globe. It is a
disease that results from an infection by non-motile, gram-negative Coccobacillus
Yarsinia pestis. This is another weapon, besides smallpox, which can cause devastation.
A vaccine for plague does exist, however, it is no longer being produced and it does not
demonstrate efficacy against infection spread through aerosols. Botulism or Botulinum
toxins are a deadly toxic substance that can be produced in an animal, a plant, or a
microbe. The toxins cause a serious disease in humans. Toxins are natural and non-
volatile and generally do not penetrate intact skin, as in case of chemicals weapons.
There are different types of toxins and they are immunologically distinct, meaning that
antibodies developed against one do not cross-react against others.
D.G. Sets Mechanical hazards and fire Low: The DG sets are used only in
hazards in: Lube oil system case of power failures, which are
Cable galleries Short circuits rare. The lubrication oil and diesel
are stored in small quantities.
Power Fire and explosion Low: Transformers are always
Transformers kept in the open, with proper
fencing, and isolated from
buildings.
Electrical Fire in cable galleries and Medium: The risk may arise from
Control room switches. Static electricity due to low quality of insulation material
improper earthing and bonding. bad maintenance or alterations by
Fire, in earthing and bonding untrained manpower. It may also
may result in Power failure. arise from voltage fluctuations.
Terrorist attack, Forced acquisition of building Low: The project is not a high
blasts etc. and hostage situation may result priority target. The location is in a
from terrorist attacks. rural setting and not in a prime
area.
Mob attack Agitated mob attack will result Low: The area is residential, rural
in life and property damage. and peaceful, hence no such
disturbance is likely
8.13.1 Fire:
The following basic precautions are recommended:
Good house-keeping.
Compulsory use of ashtrays while smoking.
Prompt repair of faulty electrical appliances.
High voltage points and instruments to be secured and labeled prominently.
Switches and fuses to conform to correct rating of circuit.
Welding /Cutting jobs to be carried out under strict supervision.
Fire Rescue drills to be carried out at regular intervals.
Elementary fire fighting training to occupants.
8.13.2 Earthquake:
BIS codes relevant to the project site shall be adopted for building standards
Heavy items such as pictures and mirrors to be hanged away from beds, settees,
and other sitting places.
Overhead light and fixtures to be braced securely.
Heavy/large objects to be stored on lower shelves.
All breakable items such as bottled foods, “glasses/china ware”, etc. shall be
stored in lower level closed cabinets with latches.
Repair defective electrical wiring and leaky gas connections. These are potential
fire hazards.
Water heaters, LPG cylinders, etc., to be secured by strapping these to wall studs
and bolting to the floor.
Weed killers, pesticides, and flammable products will be stored securely in
closed cabinets with latches, in bottom shelves.
Safe places to be identified, indoors and outdoors, for safe occupation of the
occupiers during tremors. numbers (of doctors, hospitals, police, etc) to be
displayed in each resort “villa/room’ and also in other service areas of the resort.
Emergency “telephone/cell”
8.13.3 Floods
Sewerage and storm water systems to be checked at regular intervals for their
proper functioning.
Provision will be made to harvest most of the rain water from the proposed site.
This will reduce the water shortage as well as runoff water on the site.
8.13.4 Cyclones
Periodical checking of all resort buildings for structural faults, to secure loose
tiles, and to carry out timely repairs, will be resorted to.
Periodical removal of dead wood or dying trees close to the villas to be
undertaken.
Hurricane lanterns filled with kerosene, battery operated torches and enough dry
cells will always be made available during emergencies.
8.13.5 Tsunamis
An earthquake that lasts 20 seconds or longer in a coastal area, may cause
tsunamis.
When the shaking stops, people will be moved quickly to higher ground away
from the coast. A tsunami may be coming within minutes.
Work with local emergency services and officials to help affected people and
those likely to be affected.
Provide tips for conducting earthquake drills.
Actions to be taken to prevent impact of Cyclone
Residents/visitors will be advised to stay tuned to weather advisories broadcast
on radio or TV.
Radios and TVs in Resort lobbies/restaurants etc. will also be activated for the
benefit of residents/guests.
All windows and external doors of the resort complex will be shut and
appropriately secured to withstand high wind speeds.
Extra food, which can be eaten without cooking, and surplus drinking water will
be stocked for the benefit of residents/guests to tide over long power failures
and damage to F&B infrastructure.
Hurricane lanterns, torches and other emergency lights will be made available.
All loose and unsecured materials which can fly and cause damage due to strong
winds, will be removed to safe locations and/or securely fastened.
Electrical mains will be switched off except for emergency utilities.
The management will be continuously in touch with the State Disaster
Management Authority and scrupulously follow its instructions with respect to
the need for evacuation of the resort or any other eventuality.
Maintaining constant liaison with agencies who can forewarn of likely disasters
such as IMD (India Meteorological Department), National Tsunami Warning
Centre etc.
Train staff in handling firefighting equipment
Defining a organ gram for handling emergency situations eg. Identification of a
works main controller, incident controller etc. so as to have coordinated response
to attend to emergencies. Conduct mock drills at regular intervals
Identify an emergency control centre having maps, utility drawings such as
electrical, fire fighting etc.
Evidently, a golf course based resort which thrives on greenery and breathtaking
landscape as its main ingredients, is fully compatible with the proposed majestic ocean-
view project site, in the remote undeveloped and (mostly) barren corner of Tannirbhavi
region in Manguluru taluka of Dakshina Kannada. Unlike mega-housing projects and
industries, a Golf Resort is socio-ecologically and environmentally most desirable
because of its major attributes, listed below:
• Causes no demographic influx.
• Enhances the green cover of the locality.
• Creates jobs that match the “skills/talent”, available locally.
• Leads to spin-off businesses, which also are green in nature.
• Involves no loss of native tree cover.
• Promotes harvesting of rainwater to the maximum extent possible.
• Reclaims a vast stretch of highly eroding coastal premonitory and rocky plateau
and converts it into a stable and lush green ocean view landscape.
• Encourages ventures of ornamental gardening, flowering plants, lawn making
and plant nurseries.
• Promotes organic manures and pesticides.
• Encourages highly efficient and water saving irrigation technology.
9.2.4 Potential of soil erosion during earthworks (cut & fill) and landscaping for golf
Course and Resort Construction.
a) Major earthworks will be conducted during the dry season.
b) The peripheral contour of each elevated sub-grade will be secured by a
combination of strong bunds/trenches, silt fences and gabions.
c) The entry and exit of all earthwork dumpers and machinery shall be effected
only through a few designated openings, monitored round the clock.
d) In case of unexpected heavy rains, the earth material will be promptly covered
with synthetic covers and kept handy on site.
e) Geotextile covers available commercially will be widely used to prevent erosion
and allow proper establishment of turf grass for Tees, fairways and Greens.
Further, as per need and availability materials such as Netted Erosion Control
Blankets, Turf Reinforcement Mats and other Rolled Erosion Control products
will be used for securing turf, lawns and other plants after hydroseeding.
f) The technique of installing sod on prepared bare soil surface will also be used to
establish turf, quickly without erosion.
9.2.5 Large quantity of water required for establishment and maintenance of golf
course.
a) A versatile grass species called Paspalum will be used to establish the golf turf.
This grass is drought tolerant, salinity resistant and shows luxuriant growth at
low levels of nutrients/pesticide applications. It is expected to reduce the
irrigation water requirement by 40-50%.
b) During heavy monsoon rains (June to October) in Mangalore (3000 mm), the
irrigation is further reduced substantially.
c) The elaborate and well designed system of water harvesting, proposed by the
proponent consists of rain water collection from all roofs for ground water
recharge and diversion of runoff water during rains into the lakes for storage and
use. This will maintain the ground water level and provide for supplementary
irrigation.
d) The proponent is also exploring the possibility of sustainable borewell water
extraction on approval of the Ground Water Authority.
e) Irrigation water requirement will be rationed by its need-based use, determined
by weather station data, tensiometers, neutron probes and computerized
techniques such as specialized sprinkler heads and drip irrigation will be used to
increase water application efficiency which n turn will reduce water requirement
and run-off.
f) Treated effluent water from STP will be recycled for appropriate users such as
flushing, irrigation and cooling towers.
9.2.6 Water pollution and possible toxicity due to application of fertilizers and
pesticides.
a) The well established principles of Integrated Pest Management will be adopted
to reduce the use of pesticides.
b) Only easily bio-degradable pesticides having low “persistence/residual effect”
will be used.
c) Use of conventional pesticides will be supplemented by the application of bio-
pesticides.
d) Use of chemical fertilizers will be supplemented by use of bio-fertilizers and
manures and their quantities rationalized by need-based application determine
on the basis of soil analysis.
e) The volume and flow of runoff carrying ‘nutrients/pesticides’. Will be controlled
by efficient irrigation and ‘containment/diversion/infiltration’, respectively.
f) A series of structures such as, dikes, check dams, infiltration basins, trenches,
grassed waterways, grass swales, roughs and lakes will be used for the said
purpose of runoff control.
g) Storage and handling of ‘fertillzers/pesticides’ formulations for their
applications on the field, will be located under the roof a dedicated shed
designed for the purpose. The rinsed water from this activity will be treated for
safe disposal.
9.3 Conclusion
The EIA/EMP report has thoroughly assessed all potential environmental impacts
likely to be generated by the project, which are expected to be of temporary and
reversible in nature. The proposed mitigation measures for the sub-projects are
sufficient. All negative impacts, envisaged during the “post-construction/operation”
phase of the project, present no major environmental and ecological concerns, and
hence the project is socio-economically and environmentally sustainable.
The details of the EIA Co-coordinators and Functional Area Experts involved in the
project are given in Table 9.1.
EIA Coordinator
Name: Mrs. Sreelekha K. Srinivasulu
Baseline Data Collection: Winter 2016-17 (Dec 16, Jan & Feb 17)
Contact Information: "PRAKRUTI BHAVAN"
#200, 1st & 2nd Floor, 1st Cross, 40th Main,
Behind Central Silk Board, BTM Layout II Stage,
Bengaluru-560 068, Karnataka, INDIA.
Date: 14/07/2017
Table 10.1: Details of Functional Area Experts and EIA Team Members