Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 2
*Correspondence to: Rosemary Basson, MD, FRCP(UK), Clinical Professor, Department of Psychiatry, UBC, Purdy Pavilion, 2221,
Wesbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, Canada V6T 1Z9. Tel: +1-604-827-1323, E-mail: rosemary.basson@vch.ca
12 R. BASSON
(Meston and Buss, 2007). Emotional factors included
Multiple
incentives for sex
love and commitment and the expression of the same.
Other rewards -
Physical reasons included pleasure and experience seek-
Deliberate
emotional intimacy, ing, as well as reduction of stress. Goal attainment rea-
attention to
increased well being
stimuli sons included social status, resources, and even revenge.
The insecurity factors included a wish to boost self-
Arousal
triggers/ merges esteem, to fulfill a sense of duty, and to “mate guard.”
Sexual
satisfaction
with sense of This research supported the clinical observation that
desire
& absence Biological men and women have multiple sexual and non-sexual
of pain
factors reasons for initiating or agreeing to partnered sex: a
Appraisal
Arousal: sense of sexual desire/urge/drive is just one potential
Subjective of stimuli
underlying reason instead of being the prime mover of
+ ANS response
Psychological sexual initiation, as in the former model of human sexual
factors
response. The chief initiating reasons for men were phys-
Fig. 2.1. Human sexual response is depicted as a motivation/
ical: for women, emotional reasons predominated.
incentive-based cycle of overlapping phases of variable order.
Further study focusing on 327 women aged 18–66
A sense of desire may or may not be present initially: it can be
triggered alongside the sexual arousal resulting from attending years found that, for all women, 72% of their top 25 rea-
to sexual stimuli. Sexual arousal comprises subjective sons pertained to either sexual pleasure or love and com-
(pleasure/excitement/wanting more of the same) and physical mitment to the partner (Meston et al., 2009). Consistent
(genital and non-genital responses). Psychologic and biologic with their first study, emotional factors slightly predomi-
factors influence the brain’s appraisal of the sexual stimuli. nated over physical pleasure; reasons to do with insecu-
The sexual and non-sexual outcomes influence present rity and goal attainment were infrequent. It is readily
and future sexual motivation. ANS, autonomic nervous sys- apparent that neurologic disease interfering with sexual
tem. (Adapted from Basson, 2001b.) pleasure and/or causing partnership difficulties will
severely compromise sexual motivation in both men
the focus in men has typically been on erectile dysfunc- and women.
tion (ED) or premature ejaculation, they too may expe- Studies point to depression as a major cause of
rience a more generalized “sexual distress disorder,” reduced sexual motivation in otherwise healthy persons.
affecting desire, erectile function, and ease of orgasm This appears to be true also for patients with neurologic
(Carvalho et al., 2011). disease: increased sexual dysfunction was noted in
women with multiple sclerosis compared to controls only
when there was comorbid depression (Zivadinov et al.,
Sexual motivation
1999). Even when clinical depression is excluded, low
Recent empiric research indicates that motivation for or absent sexual interest is associated with having more
partnered sexual activity may be distinct from depressed and more anxious thoughts, and lower sexual
“solitary sexual desire,” as evidenced by sexual thoughts self-image than controls (Hartmann et al., 2004).
and fantasies, and that motivation for partnered sex is Neurologic illness can markedly lessen sexual self-image
far more relevant to sexual well-being. Of 65 men and from the associated altered appearances, mobility and
65 women complaining of markedly reduced or absent cognition changes, ability to provide self-care and be
interest in partnered sexual activity, some 75% contin- continent, and ability to be gainfully employed. Research
ued to report sexual thoughts, on average multiple times confirms individual differences in the effect of mood
per week for men and three-plus times per month for on sexuality: heterosexual men sometimes sense
women (McCabe and Goldhammer, 2013). This and increased desire for solitary sex, i.e., masturbation, when
other research has identified marked discrepancy depressed, but this is rarely reported by women or
between the person’s own self-diagnosis and clinicians’ homosexual men (Janssen et al., 2013).
diagnosis of low desire, the latter focusing on tradi- Empiric data on inhibitory and excitatory factors
tional markers of sexual thoughts and fantasies (King modulating the brain’s appraisal of sexual stimuli has
et al., 2007). suggested a “dual-control model” which posits that sex-
The majority of factors underlying and influencing ual arousal is influenced by both excitatory and inhibi-
sexual motivation reflect pleasure and emotional tory mechanisms. These determine a person’s tendency
intimacy. Some 1500 (mostly young) men and women to experience sexual excitation/inhibition (trait), and
identified 237 distinct reasons why they engaged in operate during any given sexual situation (state). Factor
sex: factor analysis produced four overall factors – analysis of questionnaires developed to explore how men
emotional, physical, goal attainment, and insecurity and women would respond to sexual situations with and
HUMAN SEXUAL RESPONSE 13
without problematic aspects indicated some differences (Natsal-3), involving 4913 men and 6777 women, the
between genders, notably the importance of “arousal adjusted odds ratio for relationship difficulties being
contingency factors” for women. Such factors reflect 2.89 and 4.10 respectively (Mitchell et al., 2013). Adjust-
the potential for emerging sexual arousal to fade or fail ment between couples is strongly linked to sexual desire
“unless things are just right.” In general, women show in a detailed questionnaire completed by 205 men and
higher inhibition, and men higher excitation (Bancroft 237 women from the general population (Carvalho and
et al., 2009). Exploring “dual control,” in men, two inhi- Nobre, 2010). Emphasized in qualitative study is,
bition factors emerged: fear of performance failure and especially for women, the importance of partner charac-
threat of performance consequences. A separate ques- teristics (Bancroft et al., 2009). There is preliminary evi-
tionnaire was developed for women. For them, inhibitory dence that, in monozygotic twin women, relationship
factors included concerns about relationship impor- factors play a key role in the development of sexual dys-
tance, sexual function, and arousal contingency. function (Burri et al., 2013). Stress originating within the
Investigating factors inhibiting sexual arousal is clearly couple, e.g., worry about the partner’s well-being, rather
relevant for neurologic patients, for whom there are yet than external stressors, has been shown to have an
further arousal contingency factors, e.g., for neurologic incremental effect upon sexual problems after adjust-
symptoms to be optimally controlled, and specific factors ing for relationship quality and psychologic factors
affecting the relationship, such as when the partner is the (Bodenmann et al., 2006). Whereas neurologic illness
caregiver as well as the sexual delegate. Impaired erection can greatly intrude into the interpersonal relationship,
or delayed orgasm from autonomic damage typically sometimes the illness can bring partners closer together
leads to fears about performance. Feared untoward emotionally.
outcomes include worsening of neurologic symptoms
after orgasm, e.g., the rigidity of Parkinson’s disease or
Appraisal of sexual stimuli: “information
neuropathic pain involving genital areas.
processing”
Sexual arousal can be heightened to problematic
levels in persons with neurologic disease, such as those Even with sufficient sexual motivation and the presence
receiving dopaminergic agonist treatment for Parkinson’s of adequate stimuli in a context satisfactory to the per-
disease (see Chapter 17), or patients suffering severe son, arousal and pleasure may not occur if attention is
injury to prefrontal lobes or to both amygdalae, as in not focused on the present moment, on the sexual stim-
the Kl€ uver–Bucy syndrome (see Chapter 6). uli, and on the intimacy of the situation. Review of the
literature on sexual arousal in 2009 confirmed a central
role for attentional processes in facilitating the subjec-
Sexual stimuli and sexual context
tive but also the physiologic components of sexual
Adequate sexual stimulation and an appropriate sexual arousal (DeJong, 2009). Sexual information is processed
context are essential components of human sexual in the mind both automatically and consciously. The sex-
response. The sexual stimuli may include erotic talking, ual nature of the stimuli is processed by the limbic sys-
sexual memories, as well as visual and physical stimula- tem, allowing genital congestion (observed to be quick
tion. The latter includes non-genital as well as genital, and “automatic” in women and slower but still involun-
and non-penetrative as well as penetrative genital tary in men). Interestingly, the objective measurement of
modalities. Choices of stimulation may be curtailed by automatic genital response in sexually healthy women is
neurologic disease: touches may not be felt or may cause comparable to the response in women complaining of
dysesthesiae; excessive salivation may hinder kissing; lack of sexual arousal (Laan and Both, 2008). Conscious
and immobility limit the giving of pleasure to the appraisal of the sexual stimuli and the contextual cues
partner. Clinical experience confirms the importance can lead to subjective arousal. The latter may be further
of contextual factors, including the need for privacy increased by awareness of the genital congestion of
from children and from caregivers; of pain relief; and arousal, which is more accurately registered and more
of freedom from undue fatigue. The interpersonal con- relevant to men’s experience than to women’s (Basson,
text is critical for many: a longitudinal 8-year study of 2001a). The subjective arousal will also be cognitively
women transitioning through menopause suggested that appraised – for instance, is this pleasurable and safe
feelings for the partner along with mood were the two or is this shameful or likely to have a negative conse-
most important factors determining sexual motivation quence? Cognitions such as these continually modify
(Dennerstein et al., 2002). both physiologic and subjective responses (Nobre and
Relationship difficulties were a major factor associ- Pinto-Gouveia, 2008).
ated with low sexual function in the recently published Focusing on non-erotic thoughts during sexual stim-
third National Survey of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles ulation, generated possibly by anxiety as first suggested
14 R. BASSON
by Barlow (1986), is associated with having sexual prob- components of arousal (subjective and genital) with
lems. A recent study of 253 men and women in long-term sexual interest/motivation into one diagnosis – sexual
relationships found that women tended to report non- interest arousal disorder. This contrasts with the previ-
erotic thoughts about their body image and the external ous DSM-IV (American Psychiatric Association, 1994)
consequences of sexual activity whereas men were more focus on a desire disorder due to lack of fantasies and
likely to report non-erotic thoughts about problematic desire, and an arousal disorder due to women’s report
sexual performance (Nelson and Purdon, 2011). Both of lack of lubrication and swelling.
men and women had some non-erotic thoughts about In contrast to women, men without neurologic
the emotional consequences of the sexual activity. (or vascular) disease generally have high correlations
Regardless of content, the more frequent the non-erotic between penile erection and subjective sexual arousal
thoughts, the more sexual dysfunction. Importantly, the (Chivers et al., 2010); however, there are many excep-
more difficult it was to refocus back on an erotic thought tions. For instance, sleep-related erections are mostly
uniquely predicted the intensity of sexual problems. This dissociated from erotic dreams or from subjective sex-
research is clearly relevant to patients with neurologic ual arousal. Psychophysiologic studies have found that
disease which frequently has a negative impact upon men can get erections in response to films of assault or
sexual self-image and/or sexual functioning. rape while experiencing no subjective arousal (Janssen
Previous research studying 490 men and women et al., 2002). In contrast, a psychophysiologic study
with and without sexual problems highlighted a number identified some 25% of men in a community sample
of significant correlations between automatic biased with minimal penile response to an erotic video while
thoughts, emotions, and sexual arousal. For both men their subjective arousal was similar to the remaining
and women, sadness and disillusion were positively 75% of men with recorded penile congestion (Janssen
related to negative cognitions and negatively associated et al., 2009).
with sexual arousal (Nobre and Pinto-Gouveia, 2008). So, in both men and women it is suggested that uncon-
Neurologic disease adds further sources of maladaptive scious processes underlie the automaticity of the genital
thinking as well as sadness and disillusion. response while subjective feelings of sexual arousal are
modulated by higher-level conscious cognitive pro-
cesses. Support for this theory includes experiments
Divergence of subjective and genital
where subliminal presentations of sexual stimuli trigger
responses
sexual responses in both men and women. However sub-
Investigators have found that, in sexually healthy women, liminal stimuli, in contrast to supraliminal ones, do not
a highly variable correlation exists between objective trigger subjective sexual arousal (Janssen et al., 2000;
measurement of genital congestion (as measured with Ponseti and Bosinski, 2010). In women but not in
the vaginal plethysmograph), subjective arousal (Laan men the automatic genital response can be elicited
et al., 2008; Chivers et al., 2010; Graham, 2010), and brain in response to a stimulus that is deemed simply sexual
activation patterns, as recorded from functional magnetic in a biologic sense and not erotic or potentially arousing,
imaging (Arnow et al., 2009). To examine arousal, women e.g., viewing a video of primates engaged in mating
viewed a neutral film followed by an erotic film, and the (Chivers et al., 2010).
percentage of increase in vaginal pulse amplitude was This complex physiology of variable linkage between
noted along with their ratings of subjective arousal. genital congestion and subjective arousal (itself hardly
Women with sexual arousal disorder typically showed distinguishable from desire) must be kept in mind during
increases in vaginal pulse amplitude in response to visual the assessment and management of autonomic neurop-
erotica similar to those of sexually healthy women (Laan athy disrupting erections and clitoral engorgement and
et al., 2008; Graham, 2010), but reported minimal or vaginal lubrication. For example, disruption of the sacral
absent sexual arousal during the erotic films, and they segments of the spinal cord from multiple sclerosis may
may report negative emotions. Similarly, their awareness be irrelevant to a woman’s lack of sexual arousal. Inat-
of genital sensations was minimal, correlating poorly tention to sexual stimuli due to lowered self-image, fears
with objective measurement of congestion in response of incontinence, and fatigue may prevent her subjective
to erotic stimuli. arousal: augmenting genital congestion pharmacologi-
In addition, the degree of congestion of clitoral struc- cally would not be of benefit. In contrast, a man with
tures and vaginal circulation is not accurately perceived similar pathology will likely be distressed by both his
by women in general; it is clear that women’s arousal ED and his lack of subjective arousal from sensing
(physical/genital or subjective) cannot be measured genital engorgement: phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibi-
by their estimation of genital swelling and vaginal tors may restore objective engorgement and subjective
lubrication. DSM-5 criteria for sexual disorder merge arousal.
HUMAN SEXUAL RESPONSE 15
Sexual outcome Few incentives:
changes to relationship
A rewarding experience and outcome, emotionally and low expectation concentration
physically, will enhance present and subsequent sexual Possibly no of reward sensation
emotional intimacy
motivation. Sexual satisfaction has received less study ability to
or well being
than sexual function/dysfunction, but would appear to self-stimulate,
mobility for
be a more relevant entity. New questionnaires, notably intercourse
Natsal-SF (Mitchell et al., 2012), now reflect the impor- Sexual
Sense of Desire
satisfaction not triggered
tance of sexual satisfaction, in contrast to many previous & possible pain
Depression
Fatigue, pain
instruments modeled on DSM-IV (American Psychiatric neurological
Medication
symptoms
Association, 1994), in turn modeled on a linear sexual Arousal: Appraisal
response depicting desire/urge which triggered Subjective of stimuli
erection/lubrication, leading to orgasm/ejaculation and ANS damage
Low self image
then “resolution” of genital effects. distractions
There can be satisfaction despite dysfunction. Fig. 2.2. The sexual response cycle may be weakened at all
Dissatisfaction may occur in the context of a functional stages by neurologic disease. Incentives lessen as intimacy
response. Nevertheless, particularly in men, concerns between partners is altered and expectation of reward fades.
about sexual outcome in terms of sexual performance Reduced sensation and mobility limit the effectiveness of stim-
and consequences of sexual activity are common ulation. Attention to stimuli is interrupted by distractions about
(Bancroft et al., 2009). Women’s satisfaction may or illness or sexual outcome or by difficulties in concentration.
may not include orgasm(s) (Graham, 2010) but usually Appraisal of stimuli is negatively affected by depression, med-
requires freedom from any pain and freedom from part- ication, or pain, thereby precluding subjective arousal. A sense
ner dysfunction (Heiman et al., 2008), and a positive of desire may not be triggered. Autonomic involvement limits
physical arousal and orgasm. The outcome is unsatisfactory
emotional conclusion. Men’s satisfaction is thought to
and lessens any future motivation. ANS, autonomic nervous
more frequently require orgasm and ejaculation. Recent system. (Adapted from Basson, 2001b.)
study confirms strong links between sexual satisfaction
and sexual motives (Stephenson et al., 2011). When the
motivation is focused on a specific sexual outcome, Devaluing Censoring arousal
to prevent sexual
stimuli
e.g., erection or orgasm or the act of intercourse, and this behavior