Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Article
Experiment Study on Dynamic Strength Characteristics of RST
Lightweight Soil
Academic Editor:
Copyright © 2019 Desen Kong et al. This is an open access article distributed under the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Lightweight soil mixed with rubber particles of scrap tires (RST lightweight soil) is a kind of
light material mixed by a certain ratio of raw soil, cement, rubber particles of scrap tires and
water. It has the characteristics of light weight and high strength. This kind of material can not
only reduce environmental pollution and resource waste, but also solve some geological
problems. It has wide application prospect in the field of geotechnical engineering. The
dynamic strength characteristics of RST lightweight soil were studied by indoor dynamic
triaxial experiment. The effects of confining pressure, cement content and rubber particles
content were the emphasis of analysis. It is found that the curves of lnNf~τd of RST lightweight
soil with different proportions are linear. The dynamic strength of RST lightweight soil
increases with the increase of confining pressure and cement content, and decreases with the
increase of rubber particles content. The more the cement content is, the less the influence of
confining pressure and rubber particles content will be. There is a linear growth relationship
between the dynamic strength index Cd, υd and the cement content, but the effect of cement
content on the cohesive force Cd is more significant than that of the angle of internal friction.
The variation trend of internal friction angle υd and cohesive force Cd is the same with the
incorporation ratio of rubber particles, both of which decrease with the increase of rubber
particles.
1
Hindawi Template version: May18
China are in the initial stage. In China, C.Y. Li ordinary Portland cement P.O 42.5 with a
[9] have compared the dynamic strength density of 3.1g/cm3.
characteristics of the improved rubber particles 100
a grain size/%
60
high dynamic strength, cohesive force and large
angle of internal friction.as light filling material, 40
in order to solve pipe trench backfill, vehicle
dumping, filled soil slope and subgrade 20
2
Hindawi Template version: May18
put into the constant temperature and humidity The dynamic strength experiment results
curing box for curing. After 24 hours of can be expressed in the form of dynamic
maintenance, it is taken out of the mold and put strength curve and dynamic strength index [13].
back for curing until the design age of 7 days. The dynamic strength curve usually use
dynamic shear stress τd=σd/2 on the surface of
the 45° and destruction when the vibration
2.2. Experiment Content frequency of the Nf on semilog coordinate the
The instrument used in this dynamic triaxial curve of the dynamic strength curve of sample.
experiment is mainly the DDS-70 Usually a curve is composed of four different
electromagnetic vibration triaxial experiment point at least. For better drawing the RST
system, as shown in Figure 2 [12]. lightweight soil dynamic strength curve, the
four different points should evenly distributed
as far as possible. Different ratio of RST
lightweight soil can be determine through the
experiment to the scope of a certain vibration
frequency under the action of dynamic shear
stress ratio. The dynamic strength index is the
dynamic stress corresponding to the failure of
20 circles of vibration on the dynamic strength
1-Computing systems;2-Electronic control system;3-Host system;4-
Static pressure control system;5-Air pump
curve. A set of Mohr circles of the sample is
made by drawing and then the specific values of
Figure 2. DDS-70 Dynamic Triaxial Cd and υd are obtained. The specific
Experiment System experiment loading scheme is shown in Table 1.
3
Hindawi Template version: May18
pressure under three different amplitude, set the increase in cement content, confining pressure
vibration frequency of infinity to specimen effect on the dynamic strength amplitude
strain to destroy the standard experiment to stop, decreases, and this is because the cement,
the final experiment result is shown in Figure 3. hydration products of cement hydration reaction
to produce more, these part of hydration
60
products fill the pores between the particles, the
50 other part will cement soil particles and rubber
40 particles together, which makes bonding force
d (kPa)
40
3=50kPa
shear stress strength and failure vibration 20
Mixing ratio of rubber crumbs 1.0
mc/ms=5%
number show a linear relationship in semi-log 10 mc/ms=10%
mc/ms=15%
coordinates. With the increase of confining 0
1 10 100 1000
pressure, the dynamic shear stress required for Nf
40 3=150kPa
curve of RST lightweight soil under different 30 Mixing ratio of rubber crumbs 1.5
mc/ms=5%
mc/ms=10%
confining pressures is basically parallel. The 20
mc/ms=15%
10
main reason that the dynamic strength of RST
0
lightweight soil increases with confining 1 10
Nf
100 1000
4
Hindawi Template version: May18
The effect trend of the main reason is the mixed soil, the hydration products of cement
increasing of the cement content. The part produce decreases, and bonding force between
hydration products of cement hydration reaction soil particles and rubber particles is abate,
to produce rubber particles and soil particles resistance ability of the load is reduced, so the
cementing together, another part fills some RST light soil strength decreases.
60
inside the light soil porosity. Overall it enhance
50
the capacity of the cementation between light
40
soil particles, so the RST lightweight soil
d (kPa)
30
enhanced ability to resist external load, showing 3=100kPa
70
from 10% to 15% range is big. The reason may
d (kPa)
60
be that, increased from 10% to 15%, the cement 50 3=150kPa
content is part of the cement hydration, thus the 40
Cement content 15%
Vr/Vs=0.5
strength improvement of RST lightweight soil 30 Vr/Vs=1.0
Vr/Vs=1.5
decreases. At the same time, it was found that 20
1 10 100 1000
Nf
with the increase of the content of rubber
(b)
particles, the increase of cement content on the
dynamic strength of RST lightweight soil Figure 5. Dynamic Strength Curves of RST
became smaller. This is because the higher the with Various Rubber particles
content of rubber particles, the lower the
content of cement, and the weaker the
cementation effect of cement hydration products. The variation trend of the curve in Figure 5
shows that the dynamic strength of RST
lightweight soil decreases gradually with the
3.3 Effect of Rubber Particle Content increase of the content of rubber particles.
In order to obtain the influence law of the Mainly because the RST of lightweight soil is
content of rubber particles on the dynamic mainly rely on the hydration products produced
strength curve of RST lightweight soil, dynamic by hydration of cement to soil particles and
strength loading experiments were carried out rubber particles cemented together. When the
on nine groups of samples (T11, T12, T13, T31, rubber particles increase in light soil, according
T32 and T33), and the dynamic strength to the design of the ratio of raw material of
experiment results were shown in Figure 5. rubber particles and soil, the lightweight soil
The variation trend of the curve in Figure 5 contains raw materials soil decrease relatively,
shows that the dynamic strength of RST and the cement content is relatively less in
lightweight soil decreases gradually with the mixed soil, the hydration products of cement
increase of the content of rubber particles. produce decreases, and bonding force between
Mainly because the RST of lightweight soil is soil particles and rubber particles is abate,
mainly rely on the hydration products produced resistance ability of the load is reduced, so the
by hydration of cement to soil particles and RST light soil strength decreases.
rubber particles cemented together. When the By comparing the dynamic strength curves
rubber particles increase in light soil, according of each group, it is found that these dynamic
to the design of the ratio of raw material of strength curves have the same change law,
rubber particles and soil, the lightweight soil which is the same as the change law of the
contains raw materials soil decrease relatively, dynamic strength curve of ordinary soil. It is
and the cement content is relatively less in also found that there is a linear relationship
5
Hindawi Template version: May18
between the dynamic shear stress and the to the Mole-Coulomb strength criterion, we can
loading times under the single-logarithmic obtain the dynamic strength index Cd, υd of soil
coordinates, which can be expressed by under different conditions by drawing the Mole
equation(1) : circle. According to the dynamic strength curve
obtained in the previous section, Mohr circles of
d a ln( N f ) b RST lightweight soil with different proportions
In (1), a and b are parameters related to were plotted. This section mainly analyzed the
experiment loading conditions and sample shear strength index when the vibration number
proportions. corresponding to the magnitude of 7.5 was 20
(Table 2) [15]. The results of the Mohr circle
4 . Dynamic Strength Index Analysis and shear envelope of RST lightweight soil at
different proportions are shown in Figure 6.
In soil dynamics, the Mole-Coulomb
strength criterion is still applicable. According
Table 2. Dynamic strength indices of RST under various mixing proportions
Sample number
Dynamic
strength indices T1 T1 T1 T2 T2 T2 T3 T3 T3
1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3
27. 16. 13. 37. 28. 21. 44. 32. 27.
Cd(kPa)
4 9 1 4 1 7 5 2 6
φd/(°) 20 19 17 24 23 20 26 25 22
lightweight soil has certain tensile properties
[16]. The main reason is that a certain amount
of cement is mixed into the mixed soil. Cement
cementation is the main source of the cohesive
force of RST lightweight soil. It is because of
(a) the presence of cement that the strength of RST
Cd=28.1kPa lightweight soil under stress is different from
φd=23°
that of normal soil. In general, when the soil is
/kPa
6
Hindawi Template version: May18
and the internal friction angle υd increased with lightweight soil has certain structural. Therefore
the increase of cement content. Cement content when rubber particles concentration increased,
increased from 5% to 15% make the cohesive the bonding force between particles in RST
force Cd increased from about 15kPa to about light soil will be weak, and therefore mixed soil
30kPa, internal friction angle υd increased from cohesive force Cd decreases constantly. At the
about 20° to 24° around only 2%, but the same time, when the mixing ratio of rubber
change of cohesive force amplitude variations is particles increase from 1.0 to 1.0, υd falling
larger than the effect of the angle of friction υd, speed is accelerated. The reason is that
s hows that the influence of cement content on compared with the soil particles surface, the
the cohesive force of Cd from the influence of surface of the rubber particles is relatively
the internal friction angle υd more significantly, smooth, and the more rubber particles in mixed
it also illustrates the hydration products of soil porosity, the greater the contact area
cement is mainly used to provide the RST light between particles decreases. The friction
soil cohesive force. between particles decreases when the sample is
50
under load, so the angle of internal friction υd
40 of RST light soil decreases gradually with
30 increase of rubber particles content.
Cd (kPa)
50
20
Vr/Vs=0.5 40
10 Vr/Vs=1.0
Vr/Vs=1.5
30
Cd (kPa)
0
4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Cement content (%)
20
(a) mc/ms=5%
28 10 mc/ms=10%
mc/ms=15%
0
24 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6
Mixing ratio of rubber crumbs
d (°)
20 (a)
30
16 Vr/Vs=0.5
Vr/Vs=1.0
Vr/Vs=1.5 25
12
4 6 8 10 12 14 16
d (°)
(b)
4.2 Effect of rubber particle content
Figure 8 shows the dynamic strength index Figure 8. Dynamic Strength Indices Curves
Cd and υd of RST lightweight soil. As indicated with Various Rubber Particles
by the curve of mixing ratio of rubber particles,
the cohesive force Cd and internal friction angle
υd of the RST lightweight soil have the same
5 . Conclusion
trend of variation as the incorporation ratio of In this paper, dynamic strength
rubber particles. characteristics of RST lightweight soil are
The reason that produced the change law is studied through a large number of dynamic
mainly due to the rubber particles content triaxial experiments, providing theoretical
increased, so the relative of the cement content reference for the application of RST lightweight
was reduced. And the function of cement is to soil in engineering. The main conclusions are as
perform cementation. Rubber particles are follows:
cemented together with soil particles through (1) The dynamic strength curve of RST
hydration products. It makes the RST lightweight soil was plotted with logarithm of
7
Hindawi Template version: May18
loading times as abscissa and dynamic shear and Technology Innovation Fund for graduate
stress as ordinate. lnNf~τd of RST lightweight students of the Shandong University of Science
soil with different proportion was found by and Technology (no. SDKDYC190120).
linear fitting of each group curve.
(2) The dynamic strength of RST References
lightweight soil increases with the increase of
[1] Q. H. Meng, “Dynamic response and explosion-
confining pressure and cement content, and resist-antprotection of subway tunnel under terrorist
decreases with the increase of the incorporation booming load,” Master’s Thesis, Shandong
ratio of rubber particles. For every 50kPa University of Science and Technology, Qingdao,
increase in confining pressure, the dynamic Shandong, China, 2010.
shear strength increases by about 30% to 40%. [2] V. R. Feldgun, A. V. Kochetkov, and Y. S. Kaminski,
It was also found that the effect of confining “Internal blast loading in a buried line tunnel,”
pressure and rubber particles on dynamic International Journal of Impact Engineering, vol. 2,
strength of light soil decreased with the increase no. 12, 2007.
of cement content. [3] G. N. Nurick, M. D. Gelman, and J. R. Fagnan,
(3) The relationship between the different “Deformation and tearing of blast-loaded stiffened
ratio of the dynamic strength index of RST square plates,” International Journal of Impact
lightweight soil Cd, υd and cement content Engineering, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 273–291, 1996.
increased linearly. The influence of cement [4] S. Yuen, K. Chung, and G. N. Nurick, “Experimental
content on the cohesive force Cd is more and numerical studies on the response of
quadrangular stiffened plates. Part Ⅰ: Subjected to
significant than internal friction angle. The
uniform blast load,” International Journal of Impact
cement content increased from 5% to 15%
Engineering, vol. 31, no. 1, pp. 55–83, 2005.
makes the cohesive force Cd from about 15kPa [5] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y Liu, “The
increases to about 30kPa, but the internal Environmental Study on Consolidated Undrained
friction angle υd only increased by 2%. The Triaxial Compression Tests on Lightweight Soil
variation trend of internal friction angle υd and Mixed with Rubber Chips of Scrap Tires,”
cohesive force Cd are the same with the EKOLOJI, vol. 27, no. 106, pp. 1503–1530, 2018.
incorporation ratio of rubber particles, both of [6] H. B. Liu, “Dynamic analysis of subway structure
which decrease with the increase of rubber under blast loading,” Geotechnical and Geological
particles. Engineering, vol. 27, no. 6, pp. 699–711, 2009.
[7] A. Zyskowski, and I. Sochet, “Study of the explosive
Data Availability process in a small scale experiment-structural
loading,” Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process
Industries, vol. 17, no. 4, 2004.
The data used to support the findings of this
[8] Z. X. Li, Y. Liu, and L. Tian, “Dynamic Response
study are included within the article.
and Blast-resistance Analysis of Double Track
Subway Tunnel Subjected to Blast Loading Within
Conflicts of Interest One Side of Tunnel,” Journal of Beijing University
of Technology, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 173–181, Feb,
The authors declare that they have no conflicts 2006.
of interest regarding the publication of this [9] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y. Xu, “Study on
paper. Calculation of Pile Sliding Interval of Large–
Diameter Steel Pipe Piles on Offshore Platforms,”
Mathematical Problems in Engineering, vol. 2019,
Funding Statement
Article ID 3549296, 8 pages, 2019.
[10] H. Zhao, I. Elnasri, and Y. Girard, “Perforation of
This study was financially supported by the aluminium foam core sandwich panels under
National Natural Science Foundation of China impactloading-An experimental study,”
(nos. 41372288), the Shandong Provincial International Journal of Impact Engineering, vol.
Natural Science Foundation (no. 34, no. 7, pp. 1246–1255, 2007.
ZR2019MEE027) and the Project of Science [11] X. Liu, Q. H. Sun, H. Jiang, and H. L. Bao,
8
Hindawi Template version: May18
“Experimental Research and Theoretical Analysis of [22] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y Liu, “The
Mechanical Behaviors of Fiber Reinforced Concrete Environmental Study on Consolidated Undrained
Segments,” Modern Tunnelling Technology, vol. S2, Triaxial Compression Tests on Lightweight Soil
pp. 1080–1090, 2018. Mixed with Rubber Chips of Scrap Tires,”
[12] T. H. Lv, “Studies on the Shock Compression EKOLOJI, vol. 27, no. 106, pp. 1503–1530, 2018.
Behaviors of Concrete and Steel Reinforced [23] G. C. Mays, J. G. Hetherington, and Rose T.A.
Concrete Based on the Split Hopkinson Pressure “Response to blast loading of concrete wall panels
Bar,” Doctor’s Dissertation, University of Science with openings,” Journal of Structural Engineering,
and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui, China, vol. 125, no. 12, pp. 1448–1450, 1999.
2018. [24] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y Liu, “Study of the
[13] D. S. Kong, and Q. H. Meng, “Shock responses of a force and deformation characteristics of subsea
metro tunnel subjected to explosive loads,” Journal mudmat-pile hybrid foundations,” Polish Maritime
of Vibration and Shock, vol. 31, no. 12, pp. 69–72, Research, Special Issue, vol. 25, pp. 43–53, 2019.
2012. [25] Rose T.A., and Smith P.D. “Influence of the
[14] W. F. Xiao, A. Matthias, and G. Norbert, Principal geometrical parameters of straight city
“Experimental and numerical investigations on the streets on positive and negative phase blast wave
shock wave attenuation performance of blast walls impulses,” International Journal of Impact
with a canopy on top,” International Journal of Engineering, vol. 27, no. 04, pp. 359–376, 2002.
Impact Engineering, vol. 131, 2019. [26] M Li, D. D. Li, Y. Y. Xu, and X. J. Wen, “Effects of
[15] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y Liu, “Study of the obstacle position and number on the overpressure of
force and deformation characteristics of subsea hydrogen combustion in a semi-confined
mudmat-pile hybrid foundations,” Polish Maritime compartment,” Journal of Nuclear Science and
Research, Special Issue, vol. 25, pp. 43–53, 2019. Technology, vol. 55, no. 6, 2018.
[16] F. Kiakojouri, and M. R. Sheidaii, “Numerical
Analysis of Steel I-Core Sandwich Panels Subjected
to Multiple Consecutive Blast Scenarios,” Iranian
Journal of Science and Technology, Transactions of
Civil Engineering, vol. 43, no. 1, 2019.
[17] S. V. Gladkovsky, S. V. Kuteneva, and S. N. Sergeev,
“Microstructure and mechanical properties of
sandwich copper/steel composites produced by
explosive welding,” Materials Characterization, vol.
154, 2019.
[18] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Z. M. Zhao, “Seismic
Interaction Characteristics of an Inclined Straight
Alternating Pile Group–Soil in Liquefied Ground,”
Advances in Civil Engineering, vol. 2019, Article ID
3758286, 12 pages, 2019.
[19] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Z. M. Zhao, “Seismic
Interaction Characteristics of an Inclined Straight
Alternating Pile Group–Soil in Liquefied Ground,”
Advances in Civil Engineering, vol. 2019, Article ID
3758286, 12 pages, 2019.
[20] D. S. Kong, M. X. Deng, and Y. Xu, “Study on
Calculation of Pile Sliding Interval of Large–
Diameter Steel Pipe Piles on Offshore Platforms,”
Mathematical Problems in Engineering, vol. 2019,
Article ID 3549296, 8 pages, 2019.
[21] Y. Xu, and D. S. Kong, “Calculation of Pile Running
Interval of Large–Diameter Steel Pipe Piles On
Offshore Platform,” Journal of Shandong University
of Science and Technology (Natural Science), vol.
38, no. 07, pp. 50–56, 2019.