Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cite this article as: PETROL. EXPLOR. DEVELOP., 2018, 45(2): 336–342. RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract: The slick-water polymer adsorption damage and control measures in shale were examined using a shale pack model of the
Ordovician Wufeng Formation–Silurian Longmaxi Formation in the Changning block of the Sichuan Basin. The adsorption law of slick
water under different displacement time, concentrations, pH values and temperatures of polymer were tested by traditional displacement
experiment and UV-Vis spectrophotometer. The adsorption equilibrium time was 150 min, the amount of adsorption was proportional to
the concentration of the polymer, and the maximum adsorption concentration was 1 800 mg/L. With the increase of pH value, the adsorp-
tion capacity decreased gradually, the adsorption capacity increased first and then decreased with the increase of temperature, and the ad-
sorption capacity was the largest at 45 C. The adsorption patterns of polymers on shale were described by scanning electron microscopy
and magnetic resonance imaging. It is proved that the adsorption of polymer on shale led to the destruction of the network structure of
anionic polyacrylamide molecules, and the shale adsorption conformation was characterized qualitatively. Finally, according to the ad-
sorption law and adsorption mechanism, it is proposed to reduce the adsorption quantity of polymer on shale surface by using hydrogen
bond destruction agent. The effects of hydrogen bond destruction on four kinds of strong electronegative small molecules were compared,
the hydrogen bond destroyer c was the best, which lowered the adsorption capacity by 5.49 mg/g and recovered permeability to 73.2%.
The research results provide a reference for the optimization of construction parameters and the improvement of slickwater liquid system.
Key words: shale; hydraulic fracturing; slick-water; polymer; shale adsorption; desorption
1 20 min
2 60 min
3 150 min
Note: the red represents pores, the blue represents polymer; the sample is 2.5 cm in diameter and 7.5 cm long.
even blocked by polymer adsorption, which is finally mani- static force and hydrogen bonding[35]. Because the Van der
fested as permeability damage. Wals force and electrostatic force are irreversible physical and
chemical phenomena, there are no effective solutions in the-
3.2. NMR imaging during shale displacement
ory and engineering. In order to reduce the adsorption capac-
The adsorption process of polymer during shale displace- ity of polymer on the shale surface, hydrogen bond destroyer
ment was imaged by NMR, and sagittal planes at different is used to destroy the hydrogen bonding between the polymer
displacement stages were selected to analyze (Table 1). After and the shale. Hydrogen bonding is a reversible force acting
displacement of 20 min, a large number of polymer signals on the shale surface by anionic polyacrylamide, and hydrogen
appeared in the dominant channels of shale, and similar ef- bonds can be easily destroyed by small molecules with strong
fects were shown on different sagittal planes. At this point, the electronegativity to reduce the adsorption capacity of polymer
polymer just broke through the end of the shale. After 60 min on shale. The effects of hydrogen bonding destruction of four
of displacement, all pore channels had polymer signals, the kinds of small molecules with strong electronegativity were
displacement pressure difference increased obviously, and the compared, and the experimental results are shown in Table 2.
shale permeability reduced greatly. NMR images at 150 min The “c” agent has the best effect of hydrogen bonding de-
show that the polymer in slick-water has made most pore struction, and it can reduce the adsorption capacity by 63.7%
throats radius decrease or even blocked. at the concentration of 1 000 mg/L. The “a” agent takes the
second place, and can reduce the adsorption by 55.7% at the
4. Measures to control adsorption damage
same condition. The “b” agent has the worst effect, and only
According to the classical force analysis of polymer flood- reduces the adsorption capacity by 36%. But the reduction of
ing, the main forces acting in adsorption and retention of adsorption capacity is not completely equivalent to the recov-
polymer in reservoir include the Van der Wals force, electro- ery degree of permeability damage. Therefore, dynamic dis-
339
GUO Jianchun et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(2): 336–342
Four shale pack models with the same porosity and perme-
ability were displaced with water for 120 min, and their per-
meabilities were all reduced by 18.6%. Then they were dis-
placed with slick-water with concentration of 1 000 mg/L, it is
obvious that their permeabilities were reduced by 40.2% fur-
ther. Finally, they were displaced with slick-waters of 1 000
mg/L concentration containing the four different types of hy-
drogen bonding destroyers, and the results show their perme-
Fig. 7. Dynamic verification of shale adsorption damage.
abilities recovered to various degrees (Fig. 7). Because the
adsorption force of the polymer acting on the shale surface forms to the Langmuir isothermal adsorption process. The
was destroyed, the polymer was desorbed from the rock adsorption equilibrium time is 150 min, the adsorption capac-
quickly, pore throat channels of rock were cleared, realizing ity is positively correlated with the concentration of polymer,
the recovery of residual permeability. The residual perme- and the limiting concentration is 1 800 mg/L. The amount of
abilities of the shale pack models can be recovered to 73.2%, adsorption decreases gradually with the increase of pH value.
68.3%, 57.8% and 49.4% by hydrogen bonding destroyers c, a, With the increase of temperature, the adsorption amount in-
d and b respectively. creases first and then decreases, the maximum adsorption
Although there is no method and theory in China and capacity is at 45 C.
abroad about recovering the fracturing fluid damage by de- Adsorption of the polymer will lead to the destruction of
stroying the adsorption force, the results of the study show the molecular network structure of the anionic polyacrylamide,
that the adsorption of polymer in slick-water on shale surface and the aggregated polymer molecules on shale surface leads
can cause permeability damage, and the hydrogen bonding to blocking of micro cracks and the reduction of pore throat
destroyer can reduce adsorption capacity of the polymer sig- radius.
nificantly, thus recovering the permeability damage caused by Hydrogen bonding is a reversible force of adsorption be-
polymer in slick-water. Therefore, considering the adsorption tween the shale surface and anionic polyacrylamide, and hy-
of polymer in shale reservoirs has engineering significance in drogen bonds can be easily destroyed by small molecules with
predicting and removing the slick-water fracturing fluid per- strong electronegativity to reduce the adsorption capacity of
meability damage, and determining the reasonable liquid pa- polymer on shale.
rameters and operation parameters. Permeability of shale pack models reduced by 18.6% by
clear water flooding, and the polymer flooding reduced the
5. Conclusions
permeability further by 40.2%. The “c” hydrogen bonding
The adsorption of anionic polyacrylamide in shale con- destroyer agent has the best effect. It can reduce the adsorp-
340
GUO Jianchun et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(2): 336–342
tion capacity by 5.49 mg/g and recover the permeability to [14] SUN Yongpeng, WU Qihua, WEI Mingzhen, et al. Experi-
73.2%. mental study of friction reducer flows in microfractures. Fuel,
In actual fracturing, shortening the operation time, reducing 2014, 131: 28–35.
the concentration of fracturing fluid and the relative molecular [15] XU Chengyuan, KANG Yili, YOU Zhenjiang. Review on
mass of the polymer are still the keys in designing low dam- formation damage mechanisms and processes in shale gas res-
age fracturing fluid system for shale. Hydrogen bonding de- ervoir: Known and to be known. Journal of Natural Gas Sci-
stroyer can remove the adsorption effect of the polymer, break ence and Engineering, 2016, 36: 1208–1219.
the limit of the conventional low damage fracturing fluid sys- [16] ZHANG J, ANTON K, ZHU D, et al. Development of new
tem and improve the development effect of shale reservoirs. testing procedures to measure propped fracture conductivity
considering water damage in clay-rich shale reservoirs: An
References example of the Barnett Shale. Journal of Petroleum Science
and Engineering, 2015, 135: 352–359.
[1] ZOU Caineng, DONG Dazhong, WANG Yuman, et al. Shale [17] WU Xiaohong, PU Hui, ZHU Kuangliang, et al. Formation
gas in China: Characteristics, challenges and prospects (II). damage mechanisms and protection technology for Nanpu
Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(2): nearshore tight gas reservoir. Journal of Petroleum Science
166–178. and Engineering, 2017, 158: 509–515.
[2] WU Lanyu, HU Dongfeng, LU Yongchao, et al. Advantageous [18] GONG Honghong, LIU Mingzhu, CHEN Jiucun, et al. Syn-
shale lithofacies of Wufeng Formation-Longmaxi Formation thesis and characterization of carboxymethyl guar gum and
in Fuling gas field of Sichuan Basin, SW China. Petroleum rheological properties of its solutions. Carbohydrate Poly-
Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(2): 189–197. mers, 2012, 88(3): 1015–1022.
[3] DONG Z, HOLDITCH S, MCVAY D. Resource evaluation [19] SZOPINSKI D, KULICKE W M, LUINSTRA G A, et al.
for shale gas reservoirs. SPE Economics & Management, Structure-property relationships of carboxymethyl hy-
2013, 5(1): 5–16. droxypropyl guar gum in water and a hyperentanglement pa-
[4] VINCENT M C. The next opportunity to improve hydrau- rameter. Carbohydrate Polymers, 2015, 119: 159–166.
lic-fracture stimulation. Journal of Petroleum Technology, [20] SUN Yongpeng, BAI Baojun, DAI Caili, et al. Permeability
2012, 64(3): 118–127. evolution study after breaking of friction reducer in near frac-
[5] BAI B, ELGMATI M, ZHANG H, et al. Rock characteriza- ture matrix of tight gas reservoir. Fuel, 2017, 204: 63–70.
tion of Fayetteville shale gas plays. Fuel, 2013, 105: 645–652. [21] SONG Zhaojie, LIU Lingbo, WEI Mingzhen, et al. Effect of
[6] WANG Y, MISKIMINS J. Experimental investigations of polymer on disproportionate permeability reduction to gas and
hydraulic fracture growth complexity in slickwater fracturing water for fractured shales. Fuel, 2015, 143: 28–37.
treatments. Environmental Science & Technology, 2010, [22] HUANG Weian, LEI Ming, QIU Zhengsong, et al. Damage
49(14): 8777–8785. mechanism and protection measures of a coalbed methane
[7] GUO Tiankui, ZHANG Shicheng, QU Zhanqing, et al. Ex- reservoir in the Zhengzhuang block. Journal of Natural Gas
perimental study of hydraulic fracturing for shale by stimu- Science and Engineering, 2015, 26: 683–694.
lated reservoir volume. Fuel, 2014, 128: 373–380. [23] BLANCHARD V, LASSEUX D, BERTIN H, et al. Gas/water
[8] QIAN Bin, ZHANG Juncheng, ZHU Juhui, et al. Application flow in porous media in the presence of adsorbed polymer:
of zipper-fracturing of horizontal cluster wells in the Experimental study on non-Darcy effects. SPE 99711, 2006.
Changning shale gas pilot zone, Sichuan Basin. Natural Gas [24] GRATTONI C A, LUCKHAM P F, JING X D, et al. Poly-
Industry B, 2015, 2(2/3): 181–184. mers as relative permeability modifiers: Adsorption and the
[9] DAYAN A, STRACENER S M, CLARK P E. Proppant dynamic formation of thick polyacrylamide layers. Journal of
transport in slickwater fracturing of shale gas formations. Petroleum Science and Engineering, 2012, 45(3/4): 233–245.
Journal of Petroleum Technology, 2009, 62(10): 56–59. [25] ZHANG Hongguang, YANG Qinmin, LU Jiangang. Dis-
[10] PALISCH T T, VINCENT M, HANDREN P J. Slickwater crimination of types of polyacrylamide based on near infrared
fracturing: Food for thought. SPE Production & Operations, spectroscopy coupled with least square support vector ma-
2010, 25(3): 327–344. chine. Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis, 2014, 34(4):
[11] KOSTENUK N H, BROWNE D J. Improved proppant trans- 972–976.
port system for slickwater shale fracturing. SPE 137818-MS, [26] CHEN Yanyan, XU Zuxin. Quantitative characterization of
2010. shale components based on infrared spectra and infrared spec-
[12] WU Leize, XUE Miao, LU Hongsheng. The study of shale gas tra of potassium bromide. Petroleum Geophysics, 2014, 12(4):
fracturing of slick-water system for Jiaoshiba block. Drilling 59–66.
& Production Technology, 2015, 38(6): 84–86. [27] LYU Kai, DAI Caili, ZHANG Ruoran, et al. Study on adsorp-
[13] ZHOU J, SUN H, STEVENS R F, et al. Bridging the gap be- tion characteristics of hydrophobically associating polymers in
tween laboratory characterization and field applications of formation porous media. Oilfield Chemistry, 2010, 27(4):
friction reducers. SPE 140942-MS, 2011. 391–394.
341
GUO Jianchun et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(2): 336–342
[28] XIAO Qinghua, SUN Hansen, YANG Yu, et al. Adsorption [32] KUTSEVOL N, NAUMENKO A, CHUMACHENKO V, et
properties of polyacrylamide on pulverized coal. Drilling Flu- al. Flocculative ability of uncharged and hydrolyzed graft and
id & Completion Fluid, 2013, 30(4): 46–48. linear polyacrylamides. Journal of Molecular Liquids, 2016,
[29] WIŚNIEWSKA M, CHIBOWSKI S, URBAN T. Modification 227: 26–30.
of the alumina surface properties by adsorbed anionic poly- [33] KOHLER T, HINZE M, MÜLLER K, et al. Temperature in-
acrylamide: Impact of polymer hydrolysis. Journal of Indus- dependent description of water adsorption on zeotypes show-
trial & Engineering Chemistry, 2014, 21(1): 925–931. ing a type V adsorption isotherm. Energy, 2017, 135:
[30] PARK H, HAN J, SUNG W. Effect of polymer concentration 227–236.
on the polymer adsorption-induced permeability reduction in [34] CIMINO R T, RASMUSSEN C J, BRUN Y, et al. Mecha-
low permeability reservoirs. Energy, 2015, 84: 666–671. nisms of chain adsorption on porous substrates and critical
[31] WIŚNIEWSKA M, CHIBOWSKI S, URBAN T. Adsorption conditions of polymer chromatography. Journal of Colloid &
properties of the nanozirconia/anionic polyacrylamide system: Interface Science, 2016, 481: 181–193.
Effects of surfactant presence, solution pH and polymer car- [35] SOMASUNDARAN P, WANG J, NAGARAJ D R. Adsorp-
boxyl groups content. Applied Surface Science, 2016, 370: tion and conformation of polysaccharide depressants on min-
351–356. erals. Korean Journal of Internal Medicine, 2005, 9(1): 20–24.
342