Become a member Sign in Get started

Mikael Colville-Andersen Follow

Nov 4 · 4 min read

The Quickest Tra<c Planning Guide for Modern Cities You’ll Ever See

Back in 2014, the news in Copenhagen was that the modal share bikes
exploded between 2012 and 2013, from 36% to 45%. A whopping 9%
increase in people arriving at a destination in the City of Copenhagen for
work or education. That had never happened anywhere before. At the same
time, the modal share for motorists fell from 27% to 23%.

We were in the midst of one of the greatest urban transport experiments in

the world, and didn’t really realise it.

For years I’ve espoused the beneMts of following the simple traNc planning
guide at the top of this article. Prioritise the three, inherently inter-modal
transport forms on the left — bikes, pedestrians and public transport — and
make driving a car a pain the ass. Make it the slower option, make it more
expensive and diNcult, and you’re on your way to a bright transport future.
I call it A2Bism. It’s what every human who has ever lived wants the most:
to go quick from A to B. Humans are like rivers — we’ll always seek out the
quickest route.

So what happened between 2012 and 2013 in Copenhagen? The City made
it a pain in the ass to drive a car. Not on purpose, mind you. The
construction of a new Metro line, with 17 stations, was underway and, in a
glorious coincidence of bad municipal communication, the city also dug up
streets to upgrade the pipes for our district heating. The city was one big
squiggly line — primarily for cars. In biannual surveys since the 1990s, a
continuous majority of Copenhageners have declared that their primary
reason for riding a bike is the fact that it’s the quickest way from A2B. The
City inadvertently enabled them to go to the next level, at the expense of car
traNc.

Fast-forward to late 2019. The new Metro ring line has just opened. The
contstruction hoarding has been removed and roads are returning to how
they were before the work began. This great urban experiment is going to
go one of two ways. Either the City learns from it and keeps that squiggly
line or we just return to the car-centric status quo we started with.

I’ve never been a fan of the Metro expansion. A city this size doesn’t need a
metro — it needs tramways like so many other cities in Europe. I don’t
advocate shoving citizens underground. They should be on street level on
foot, on bicycle and in trams. My colleagues around Europe basically point
and laugh when I tell them that we have bus routes with 50,000 passengers
a day and the City ISN’T building tramways. The main problem in
Copenhagen is that we have so much money and we have delusions of
grandeur.

But hey. I guess I didn’t succeed in talking the city out of building the metro
expansion. The new M3 line doesn’t go anywhere new. It just spins around
in a circle and goes to places that have been easily accessible by bike for over
a century. The Metro has been falsely advertising travel times for years.
Advertising station to station, but not the Mrst and last mile to and from the
station. I sent out a team a few years ago to map travel times using real
world scenarios and — no surprise — the bike usually beats the Metro in
Copenhagen.

There are more great statistics from the glorious period of 2012–2013. The
average bike trip length in Copenhagen rose 35% from 3.2 km to 4.2 km
between 2012 and 2013. That means that the oft-quoted statistic about how
Copenhageners cycle 1.2 million km a day needed to be upgraded to
2,006,313 km per day.

When the results of the travel survey came out back in 2014, journalists
were scrambling for answers. Two researchers at DTU were “surprised”.
They were quoted in the Danish press as saying things like, “uh… the City’s
new bridges and traNc calming on certain streets seem to have worked.
Giving cyclists carrots encourage cycling.”

The detail they forgot was that the new cycling bridges weren’t Mnished yet,
nor was the traNc calming on Amagerbrogade. The Nørrebrogade stretch is
from 2008. Cycling rose on that street by 15% but that was BEFORE 2012.
Duh. Basically, there hadn’t been much carrot dangling in this city for a few
years. So forget about THAT hastily thunk up theory.

It was simply a combination of construction sites and district heating pipes

being upgraded. It was a fantastic urban experiment.

In the original feasibility study for the new M3 line, I found an alarming
statistic buried in the document. It was estimated that cycling levels in the
city would drop by 2.8% after the completion of the new line. Then we saw
that fantastic, unexpected rise of 9% between 2012 and 2013.

Can we now expect a drop in the modal share for bikes of 12% in
Copenhagen? Perhaps. You read it here Mrst.

Unless, of course, the City of Copenhagen has the cajones to embrace this
experiment and use it to Mnally make The Leap — as described by author
Chris Turner — into the future of our city. Expanding and widening the
cycle tracks. Reallocating space from falling car traNc to bicycles and public
transport. The new BRT route in Copenhagen is a good step. Let’s see how
much farther we can go. Designing cities instead of engineering them.

They can listen to me or they can just listen to the simple logic of children.

The Lulu Fixes Cities

Watch later Share

The citizens have shown us that they will be on our side if we do the right
thing.

Otherwise, this rich petri dish experiment will just rot and be forgotten.

Cycling Copenhagen Public Transportation Metro Urbanism

30 claps

WRITTEN BY

Mikael Colville-Andersen Follow

Urban playmaker, designer, host of The Life-Sized City tv series

about urbanism. Author of “Copenhagenize”. Impatient Idealist.

Write the Lrst response

More From Medium

Also tagged Cycling Top on Medium Top on Medium

San Francisco has a massive yet How To Wake Up at 5 A.M. Want a data science job? Use the
solvable unprotected bike lane Every Day weekend project principle to get
problem Bryan Ye in Bet… Humans it
Oct 3 · 15 min read
Humans 38K
Stephen Braitsch Daniel Bo… Data Science
Nov 4 · 5 min read 12 Data3Science
Nov · 4 min read 1.7K

Discover Medium Make Medium yours Become a member

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium
Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center deliver the best stories for you to your homepage — and support writers while you’re at it. Just
stage - with no ads in sight. Watch and inbox. Explore $5/month. Upgrade

About Help Legal