You are on page 1of 5

Low Power Contacless

Voltage Sensor for IoT Applications


Antonio Delle Femine, Daniele Gallo, Carmine Landi, Alessandro Lo Schiavo, Mario Luiso
Department of Engineering
University of Campania “Luigi Vanvitelli”
Aversa (CE), Italy
{antonio.dellefemine, daniele.gallo, carmine.landi, alessandro.loschiavo, mario.luiso}@unicampania.it

Abstract—Due to advances in the fields of low power presented in literature, allowing employing an energy
electronics, computer science and communications, the diffusion harvester for the power supply [20]. Moreover, it has small
of sensors based on the Internet of Things is more and more dimensions and it is lightweight. All of its feature makes it
increasing. In particular, contactless sensing principles very attractive for the IoT applications. A similar approach is
represent enabling technologies for the IoT. This paper presents presented in [19]: however, it makes use of non-linear devices
a new contactless power line voltage sensor (from 0 V to 300 V) and phase shifters, which have power consumption not
with low power consumption in order to be suitable for IoT suitable for IoT applications and, moreover, compromise the
applications. It has been characterized with a high performance accuracy of the whole device.
electrical calibrator showing good accuracy (lower than 1 %) at
230 V. The paper is organized as follows. Section II discusses the
measuring principle and the architecture of the proposed
Keywords—voltage measurement, contactless, low power, system. Section III presents the implementation and the
sensor, internet of things experimental characterization of the devices with a high
performance electrical calibrator. Finally, Section IV draws
I. INTRODUCTION
the conclusions.
The demand of smart measurement systems, and
innovative sensors based on Internet of Things (IoT) methods II. THE PROPOSED SYSTEM
has increased thanks to the advances in the fields of low power The contactless system for power-line voltage
electronics, information technology and communications [1]. measurement is made up by a capacitive probe, a low-power
It is possible to realize new devices for different applications analog front-end and a low-power microcontroller, as shown
with big variety of sensing elements able to transmit the in Fig. 1. The contactless capacitive probe surrounds the line
information with minimal maintenance and without the cable with two metallic surfaces, the inner electrode and the
adoption of wires [2]. outer shield. This arrangement creates a capacitance
However, in order to allow the widespread diffusion of IoT between the line and the electrode, a capacitance between
devices, they must be simple to use and to install. In this the electrode and the shield and a capacitance between the
context, measuring devices adopting contactless sensing shield and the earth.
principles represent enabling technologies for the IoT. As the shield is driven by the low-power analog front-end
Contactless voltage and current sensors have numerous at the same voltage of the electrode, no current flows through
applications in electrical power systems. They are used for the capacitance . Thus, the current flowing through the
state monitoring of high voltage transmission line [2] capacitance is detected by the analog front-end in order to
appliance, load monitoring applications for smart home and determine the line voltage. Unfortunately, this current
industries [3]-[8], smart metering applications [9] and for depends not only on the line voltage, , but it also depends
condition monitoring and recording of electrical rotating on the value of the capacitance itself. In order to estimate
machines [10]. Established methods are available for non- the value , the analog front end generates a reference signal
invasive current measurement for direct current (dc) and at frequency higher than the line frequency and injects
alternating current (ac) applications such as Hall effect current it into the electrode. By detecting the whole current flowing
sensors [11], current transformers [12]-[15] with a high degree through the capacitance , including both a line frequency
of accuracy, etc. There are few non-invasive ac measurement
schemes using capacitive coupling based measurement of
transmission line voltage [16]-[19]. Even though some of the
cited solutions present high accuracy and some have been
employed for IoT applications, they all are characterized by a
high power consumption (related to IoT applications) which
makes them unprofitably usable for the IoT paradigm. In fact,
the high power demand makes necessary the use of a robust
power supply or, alternatively, a battery with a high capacity,
making the dimensions and the cost increasing: both of these
characteristics are against the widespread diffusion of the
solutions.
Starting from these considerations, in this paper, a new
power line contactless voltage sensor is presented. It has a Fig. 1. Scheme of the low-power contactless voltage measurement
very low power consumption, compared to most solutions system.

177
978-1-7281-0429-4/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE
Fig. 2. Block diagram of the low-power analog front end.

component and a reference frequency component, and by Finally, the negative peak detectors provide as output the
separating the two components, the measurement system is signal negative peaks, and , respectively.
able to estimate the value of the line voltage.
The microcontroller makes the difference between the DC
Differently from other implementations presented in voltage and , obtaining
literature [19], the analog front end is here designed in order
to minimize the power consumption, aiming at its use in a = − = (3)
wireless sensor node, possibly supplied by an energy Moreover, it makes the difference between the DC voltage
harvesting source [20]. This target is achieved by significantly and , obtaining
reducing the supply voltage down to = 3.3 , by using
only low-power operational amplifiers, MCP6242, and by = − = + (4)
devising a simpler analog processing circuit. An accurate In (3) and (4), and are the overall gains for the line
circuit design is developed in order to minimize the drawbacks signal and for the reference signal, respectively. is equal to
of the above choices, which consist in a lower signal-to-noise and it is a constant term due to the presence
ratio and in less performing integrated circuits. of the input capacitance . Equations (3) and (4) show that
The block diagram of the low-power analog front-end is the quantity , calculated by the microcontroller, depends
shown in Fig. 2. on and , while depends only on .
The oscillator, implemented through a simple Wien-bridge A calibration procedure, performed at an early stage by
circuit, generates the sinusoidal reference signal, , having disconnecting the probe to make null the capacitance ,
amplitude , frequency and a DC component = allows us to determine the value of . By subtracting this
/2, which is created by the DC level generator [21]. The value from (4), the microcontroller is able to determine
reference sinusoidal signal drives the non-inverting op-amp
= (5)
terminal, connected to the probe shield.
By using (3) and (5), the microcontroller can estimate the line
By applying the superposition principle at the voltage
voltage, that is
sources and , it is possible to calculate the output
voltage of the operational amplifier of the input stage, that is = (6)
_
=− +
where and are known quantities because they are
+ + (1) locally generated. Also and are known quantities. On
the other hand, can be measured by the microcontroller.
where is the gain resistance of the input stage and is
The initial calibration procedure can also be aimed at
the input capacitance at the inverting terminal of the determining the gain and offset errors affecting (6) and the
operational amplifier. The difference amplifier performs the resulting data can be used to correct (6) during normal
difference between the voltage in (1) and the reference
operation.
voltage. It also adds the DC voltage , in order to ensure a
proper bias. Thus, the output of the difference amplifier is From a design point of view, it should be noted that the
peak to peak voltage of signal should be lower than =
=− + 3.3 . This limits the amplitude of the signal , whose peak
+ + (2) to peak value is chosen to be equal to 2 . On the other hand,
the best accuracy is achieved if the two quantities to be
where is the gain of the differential amplifier. measured, i.e. the first two terms in the right hand side of (1),
The line-frequency low-pass filter, LPF, and the reference are comparable. Taking into account that is about 300
frequency band-pass filter, BPF, separate the two frequency times , the frequency of the reference frequency is chosen
components, generating the signals and , equal to about 300 times , i.e. = 2 15000 rad/s.
respectively. Finally, is chosen equal to the largest value that does not

178
gains, neglecting the gain errors, are = = 6. In order to
ensure a suitable accuracy of the difference amplifier, this was
implemented by means of a four-resistance topology with
resistor arrays.
For the low-pass filter, a 4th order Sallen-Key filter is
chosen for its compactness and the cutoff frequency is set just
above the line frequency, in order to attenuate the undesired
line harmonics. For the band-pass filter, a 4th order
Tow-Thomas biquad filter is chosen, in order to accurately
control the bandwidth. This is a critical design aspect. As the
line noise at frequency is amplified by the derivative
behavior of the input stage, a very narrow-band is desired.
Fig. 3. Prototype of the capacitive probe. However, a too narrow band leads to stability problems.
With reference to the peak detector, the negative type is
chosen, instead of the positive type, in order to obtain an
output voltage that is lower than the DC voltage. Accordingly,
a lower reference voltage can be chosen for the A/D converter,
leading to a better quantization resolution.
Moreover, in order to allow a fast discharge of the holding
capacitor, the negative peak detectors have a reset input
controlled by the microcontroller. As the capacitor is quickly
charged by an operational amplifier and it is slowly discharged
by a resistor, the reset control allows a quicker and accurate
measurement.
(a) III. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
A prototype of the capacitive probe, shown in Fig. 3, was
made with a rubber tube of 1 cm diameter and 15 cm length,
cut lengthwise to allow insertion of the line cable. The tube
was coated with silver paper both internally, to create the
probe inner electrode, and externally, to create the probe outer
shield.
A prototype of the low-power analog front-end was
implemented by means of a solderless breadboard, as shown
in Fig. 4. The value of the capacitance , measured by the
Keysight LCR meter U1733C, is 14 pF, while the value of the
capacitance is 140 pF.
(b)
The measured current drawn by the analog front-end
Fig. 4. (a) Prototype of the analog front-end with the probe. (b) Zoom of
the analog front-end circuit.
supply is less than 1.5 mA, as measured by the Keysight
E36313A shown in Fig. 5. Thus, the power consumption is
less than 5 mW, that is 100 times lower than the power
consumption of other analog front-ends presented in literature
for contactless power-line voltage measurement systems. In
particular, the full analog solution proposed in [19] is
characterized by a very high supply voltage and by a quite
complex circuit topology based on signal down-conversion by
mixing. Also the full digital solution proposed in [22] is
power-hungry, because it is based on a quite complex digital
signal processing (filtering, integration, scaling and so on) that
requires both a high-frequency and high-performing ADC
converters as well as a real-time signal processing by an ARM
Cortex-M4F microcontroller. On the other hand, the proposed
solution is aimed at simplifying the analog processing and, at
Fig. 5. Power supply of the low-power analog front end, measuring the the same time, at minimizing the microcontroller operation,
current drawn by the circuit. which only performs low-frequency and low-power ADC
conversions of DC signals and very simple mathematical
saturate the operational amplifier with the maximum value of operations.
.
The system has been characterized with a high
In order to keep the signal-to-noise ratio as large as performance electrical calibrator Fluke 6105A (up to 1000 V,
possible, the gain of the difference amplifier is set equal to 50 A, best accuracy 50 ppm) and with a digital storage
= 3, while the gains of the LPF and of the BPF are chosen oscilloscope (DSO) Lecroy MDA810 (12 bit, 1 GHz analog
equal to = 2. Thus, the resulting values for the overall bandwidth, 2.5 GHz maximum sampling rate). Voltages with

179
Peak-peak amplitudes of filter outputs
(a)

(a)

(b)

Outputs of peak detectors and DC level

(c)

(b)
VLINE_EST [V]

(d) Error [%]

Fig. 6. Screenshots of the oscilloscope showing the main circuit signals


in case that the line voltage is (a) = 100V, (b) =
150V, (c) = 230V, (d) = 300V.

amplitudes in the range of 10 V ÷ 300 V, root mean square


(rms) value, and frequency of 50 Hz have been generated.
The output signals of the system were measured through
the DSO. Oscilloscope screenshots obtained for =
100 , = 150 , = 230 and for = (c)
300 are shown in Fig 6. The upper yellow curve is
Fig. 7. Measurement results obtained by varying the amplitude of the
proportional to the line voltage , the red curve shows the line voltage . (a) Peak to peak amplitudes of the filter
output of the LPF, , the upper blue curve the peak detector outputs, and . (b) Outputs of the peak detectors,
output, , the green curve the output of the BPF, , the and , and DC level, . (c) Estimated values of the line
lower yellow curve the peak detector output, , and the voltage and errors, obtained by using the proposed analog front-
end.
lower blue curve the continuous signal .
Numerical results obtained by varying the amplitude of the to peak amplitudes of the filter outputs, and , are
line voltage are reported in Fig. 7. In particular, the peak shown in Fig. 7(a).

180
The DC outputs of the peak detectors, and , and [9] D. Porcarelli, D. Brunelli and L. Bennini, "Clamp-and-Forget: A self-
the DC level, , are reported in Fig. 7(b). The estimated sustainable non-invasive wireless sensor node for smart metering
applications," ELSEVIER Microelectronics Journal., vol. 45, no. 12,
values of the line voltage calculated by (6) and corrected with pp. 1671–1678, Dec. 2014.
the gain and offset errors measured in the calibration stage, are [10] G. D. Antona, P. Pennacchi, C. Pensieri and C. Rolla, "Turboalternator
shown in Fig. 7(c). The resulting error, between the estimated shaft voltage measurements," in Proc. IEEE International Workshop
line voltage _ and the actual value , is also on Applied Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS), Aachen, Sept.
reported in Fig. 7(c) and lies within a 4% band. 26-28, 2012, pp. 1-4.
[11] C. Xu, J. G. Liu, Q. Zhang, C. Xu and Y. Yang, "Investigation of the
IV. CONCLUSIONS thermal drift of open-loop Hall Effect current sensor and its
improvement," in Proc. IEEE International Workshop on Applied
This paper presents a new power line contactless voltage Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS), Aachen, Sept. 23-25, 2015,
sensor. Other than the possibility to measure voltage without pp. 19-24.
contact, it has the feature of low power consumption, which [12] E. Mohns, G. Roeissle, S. Fricke and F. Pauling, "An AC Current
makes it attractive for IoT applications. Transformer Standard Measuring System for Power Frequencies,"
IEEE Trans Instru. Meas., vol. 66, no. 6, pp. 1433-1440, June 2017.
It has been characterized with a high performance [13] Crotti, G., Delle Femine, A., Gallo, D., Giordano, D., Landi, C.,
calibrator, showing good performance over 230 V (lower than Letizia, P.S., Luiso, M., “Calibration of Current Transformers in
1 %) whereas higher errors (up to about 4 %) with lower input distorted conditions”, (2018) Journal of Physics: Conference Series,
voltages. 1065 (5), DOI: 10.1088/1742-6596/1065/5/052033
[14] A. J. Collin, A. Delle Femine, D. Gallo, R. Langella and M. Luiso,
Further research activities about the characterization "Compensation of Current Transformers' Non-Linearities by Means of
changing the frequency and the harmonic content of the input Frequency Coupling Matrices," 2018 IEEE 9th International
voltages are still in progress. Workshop on Applied Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS),
Bologna, 2018, pp. 1-6. doi: 10.1109/AMPS.2018.8494893
REFERENCES [15] G. Crotti, D. Giordano, A. Delle Femine, D. Gallo, C. Landi and M.
Luiso, "A Testbed for Static and Dynamic Characterization of DC
[1] A. Lo Schiavo, “Fully autonomous wireless sensor network for freight Voltage and Current Transducers," 2018 IEEE 9th International
wagon monitoring”, IEEE Sensors Journal, vol. 16, n. 24, pp. 9053 – Workshop on Applied Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS),
9063, Dec. 2016. Bologna, 2018, pp. 1-6. doi: 10.1109/AMPS.2018.8494873
[2] X. Sun, Q. Huang, Y. Hou, L. Jiang and P. W. T. Pong, "Noncontact [16] K. Zhu, W. K. Lee and P. W. T. Pong, "Non-Contact Capacitive-
Operation-State Monitoring Technology Based on Magnetic-Field Coupling-Based and Magnetic-Field-Sensing-Assisted Technique for
Sensing for Overhead High-Voltage Transmission Lines," IEEE Trans. Monitoring Voltage of Overhead Power Transmission Lines," IEEE
Power Delivery, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 2145-2153, Oct. 2013. Sens. J., vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 1069-1083, Feb.15, 2017.
[3] T. D. Huang, W. S. Wang and K. L. Lian, "A New Power Signature for [17] K. L. Chen, Y. Guo and X. Ma, "Contactless voltage sensor for
Nonintrusive Appliance Load Monitoring," IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, overhead transmission lines," IET Generation, Transmission and
vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 1994-1995, July 2015. Distribution, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 957-966, Feb. 2018.
[4] L. Yu, H. Li, X. Feng and J. Duan, "Nonintrusive appliance load [18] S. Kang, S. Yang and H. Kim, "Non-intrusive voltage measurement of
monitoring for smart homes: recent advances and future issues," in ac power lines for smart grid system based on electric field energy
IEEE Instrum. Meas. Magazine, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 56-62, June 2016. harvesting," IET, Electronics Letters, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 181-183, Feb.
[5] K. L. Chen, H. H. Chang and N. Chen, "A new transient feature 2017.
extraction method of power signatures for Nonintrusive Load [19] Shenil P.S. and B. George, "An Auto-Balancing Scheme for Non-
Monitoring Systems," in Proc. IEEE International Workshop on Contact AC Voltage Measurement," 2018 IEEE 9th International
Applied Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS), Aachen, Sept. 25- Workshop on Applied Measurements for Power Systems (AMPS),
27, 2013, pp. 79-84. Bologna, 2018, pp. 1-5. doi: 10.1109/AMPS.2018.8494863.
[6] M. Šíra and V. N. Zachovalová, "System for Calibration of [20] L. Costanzo, A. Lo Schiavo, M. Vitelli, “Power Extracted From
Nonintrusive Load Meters With Load Identification Ability," IEEE Piezoelectric Harvesters Driven by Non-Sinusoidal Vibrations”, IEEE
Trans Instru. Meas., vol. 64, no. 6, pp. 1350-1354, June 2015. Trans. on Circuits and Systems – I: Reg. Papers, vol. 66, n. 3, pp. 1291
[7] Del Prete, S., Delle Femine, A., Gallo, D., Landi, C., Luiso, M., – 1303, March 2019.
“Implementation of a distributed Stand Alone Merging Unit”, (2018) [21] A. Buonomo, A. Lo Schiavo, “Analysis and Design of Dual-Mode
Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1065 (5), DOI: 10.1088/1742- CMOS LC-VCOs”, IEEE Trans. on Circuits and Systems – I: Reg.
6596/1065/5/052042 Papers, vol. 62, n. 7, pp. 1845 – 1853, July 2015.
[8] G. Crotti, A. D. Femine, D. Gallo, D. Giordano, C. Landi and M. Luiso, [22] M. A. Haberman, E. M. Spinelli, "Noncontact AC Voltage
"Measurement of the Absolute Phase Error of Digitizers," in IEEE Measurements: Error and Noise Analysis," in IEEE Transactions on
Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement. doi: Instrumentation and Measurement, vol. 67, no. 8, pp. 1946-1953, Aug.
10.1109/TIM.2018.2888919 2018.

181

You might also like