OBLICON CASES

2020 2ND EXAM COVERAGE

ARTICLES 1226-1229 OBLIGATIONS WITH A PENAL CLAUSE
Equitable reduction of penalty even if there is non-performance
LIGUTAN v CA 376 S 560
Other cases:
1. PRYCE CORP v PAGCOR 458 S 164
2. FLORENTINO v SUPERVALUE 533 S 156
3. DIAMOND BUILDERS v COUNTRY BANKERS 540 S 194
4. RIVERA v SPS. CHUA 746 S 1
5. BUENAVENTURA v METROPOLITAN BANK 799 S 239
1231 – 1232 PAYMENT
1. MULTI-INTERNATIONAL v MARTINEZ 774 S 574
2. CINCO v CA 603 S 108
3. ONG BUN v BPI 859 S 80 (PERALTA)
EFFECT OF DEATH – STRONGHOLD INSURANCE v REPUBLIC–
ASAHI 492 S 179
1234-1235 – EXCEPTIONS TO COMPLETE DELIVERY OR SERVICE TO
EXTINGUISH AN OBLIGATION THRU PAYMENT/PERFORMANCE
WERR CORPORATION v HIGHLANDS PRIME 817 S 145 (JARDELEZA)
1236-1237 – EFFECTS OF PAYMENT MADE BY A THIRD PERSON
CASE: JALANDONI V ENCOMIENDA 819 S 43 (PERALTA)
1240 – TO WHOM SHALL PAYMENT BE MADE
1. PNB v TAN 256 S 44
2. CULABA v CA 427 S 721
3. ALLIED BANKING v LIM SIO WAN 549 S 504
4. DELA CRUZ v CONCEPCION 684 S 74
1241 – PAYMENT TO AN INCAPACITATED ; TO A THIRD PERSON – ITS
EFFECTS AND ITS EXCEPTIONS
1242 – PAYMENT MADE IN GOOD FAITH
1. NATIONAL POWER CORP v IBRAHIM 750 S 711
1245 – DATION IN PAYMENT
- What law governs dation in payment upon perfection
CASES:
1. ESTANISLAO v EAST WEST BANKING GR#178537 02/11/08
2. TAN SHUY v MAULAWIN 665 S 604
3. VILLARTA v TALAVERA, JR. 783 S 242
4. DALISAY INVESTMENTS v SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM 860 S 554
(VELASCO, JR.)
5. KAREN NUNEZ ET. AL v PALMA GR#224466 MARCH 27, 2019
(CAGUIOA)
1249 – PAYMENT BY DELIVERY OF PROMISSORY NOTES/BILLS OF
EXCHANGE/OTHER MERCANTILE DOCUMENTS; EXCEPTIONS
EVANGELISTA v SCREENEX, INC. 845 S 131 (SERENO)
1250 EXTRAORDINARY INFLATION/DEFLATION
1. EQUITABLE PCI v NG SHEUNG NGOR 541 S 223
2. ALMEDA v BATHALA MARKETING 542 S 470
1251 – PLACE OF PAYMENT
1252 – APPLICATION OF PAYMENT
1. PREMIERE DEV. BANK v CENTRAL SURETY 579 S 359
2. ESPINA v CA 06/22/2000
3. TAN v CHINA BANKING 800 S 635
4. SINAMBAN v CHINA BANKING 752 S 621
5. TAN v CHINA BANKING 800 S 635 (PEREZ)
1253 – 1254 ABSENCE OF STIPULATION WHERE PAYMENT BE APPLIED
1. MARQUEZ v ELISAN CREDIT 755 S 31
1255 PAYMENT BY CESSION OR ASSIGNMENT
 - DISTINGUISHED FROM DATION IN PAYMENT
VILLALUZ v LAND BANK 814 S 466 (JARDELEZA)
1256-1261 TENDER OF PAYMENT AND CONSIGNATION
- REQUISITES
- EXCEPTIONS TO PRIOR TENDER
CASES:
1. PABUGAIS v SAHIJWANI 423 S 509
2. BENOS v LAWILAO 509 S 549
3. CACAYORIN v ARMED FORCES AND POLICE 696 S 311
4. PHILIPPINE NATIONAL BANK v CHAN 820 S 161 (DEL CASTILLO)
1261-1265 LOSS OF THE THING DUE
- EFFECTS; EXCEPTIONS
1266-1267 DOCTRINE OF UNFORESEEN EVENTS IN OBLIGATIONS TO DO
- EFFECTS; REQUISITES
1. PHILIPPINE NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION v CA 272 S 183
2. MAGAT, JR. v CA 337 S 298
3. TAGAYTAY REALTY v GACUTAN 761 S 87
4. COMGLASCO CORP. v SANTOS CAR CHECK CENTER CORP. 754 S
481 (REYES)
5. POON v PRIME SAVINGS BANK 793 S 141 (SERENO)
6. ILOILO JAR v COMGLASCO 815 S 1 (MENDOZA)
1270-1274 CONDONATION OR REMISSION OF THE DEBT
- CONCEPTS; KINDS
- IF EXPRESS – REQUISITES
1275-1278 MERGER OR CONFUSION
1279-1290 – COMPENSATION
- CONCEPT; KINDS
- REQUISITES – LEGAL COMPENSATION
- EFFECTS OF ASSIGNMENT
- INSTANCES WHEN COMPENSATION IS PROHIBITED
CASES:
1. BPI v CA 255 S 571
2. PNB v CA 259 S 174
3. EGV REALTY v CA 310 S 657
4. METROPOLITAN BANK v TONDA 338 S 254
5. PHILTRUST v ROXAS 772 S 323
6. MARPHIL EXPORT v ALLIED BANKING 803 S 627
7. CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING v ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY
SYSTEM 824 S 295 (SERENO)
1291-1304 NOVATION
- CONCEPT; KIDS; REQUISITES
1. LICAROS v GATMAITAN GR#142838 09/09/01
2. GARCIA v LLAMAS 417 S 292
3. RICARZE v CA 515 S 302
4. LEDONIO v CAPITOL DEVELOPMENT 526 S 379
5. BPI v DOMINGO 754 S 245
6. INTERPORT RESOURCES v SECURITIES SPECIALIST 792 S 155
7. FIGUERA v ANG 795 S 175
8. PARDIGM DEVELOPMENT v BPI 826 S 267 (REYES)
9. SPOUSES CELONES v METROPOLITAN BANK GR#215691
NOVEMBER 21, 2018 (TIJAM)
10. FOOD FEST, INC v ROMUALDO SIAPNO, ET AL. GR#226088
FEBRUARY 27, 2019 (PERALTA)
11. VICENTE HENSON v UCPB INSURANCE (EN BANC) GR#223134
AUGUST 14, 2019 (PERLAS-BERNABE)
12. MODOMO v SPS. LAYUG GR#197722 AUGUST 14, 2019
(CAGUIOA)