S.

no Comments Response

1 Have we carried out Elasto plastic analysis Yes, the stresses induced in all the
if so, the stresses are within the limit? structural components are directly
compared with the yield strength.

2. assessment of deformations is Yes, Deformations observed are within

considered. the limits.
3. Leakage criteria is considered or not. Considered, Resulting Gasket Contact
pressure is within the allowable limit.
Please refer the slide 19 in the
presentation.
4. stress estimation is used for elastic-plastic Calculation Variables as per ASME VIII
formulation
5. performed voltage assessment w.r.t ISO No
13628-7?
6. What kind of stress -strain curve is used True stress Vs Plastic Strain curve
for this test case? generated using Multilinear isotropic
Hardening curve fitting technique as per
ASME VIII Div2
7. Load calculation for force created by load, Yes, sealing diameter of the gasket is yet
numerical or analytical thermal to be confirmed, we have completed the
calculation is carried out? analysis default sealing dia.
8. Load calculation for force created by load, Analytical calcs done for End Cap effect
numerical or analytical thermal load, please refer slide 8 in the
calculation is carried out? presentation.
9. For the pipe model loading with moment we are working on it with iterating the
is considered moment magnitudes.
10. Method of simplifying the model – what Full model considered for the analysis.
kind of properties is considered (for
example, symmetry properties)
11. Modelling of the weld Assumed as full penetration weld.