Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WIMjournalpaper
WIMjournalpaper
Performance Analysis of
Debt and Equity Schemes at Birla Sun Life Mutual Funds
With Reference to Reliance and ICICI Prudential Debt and Equity Mutual
Funds
Authors:
Abstract
Mutual funds are considered as one of the best available investment options as compare
diversification, by reducing risk & maximizing returns. The basic need and objective of
the study is to analyze the performance of Debt and Equity Schemes of Birla Sun Life
Mutual Fund with reference to Reliance and ICICI Mutual Funds and to know in which
kind of fund the investor would like to invest in. The data collected from the secondary
sources. The analysis and interpretation has been done and finally conclusions are
drawn.
Key Words: Mutual Funds, Debt and Equity Schemes and Performance analysis
Published in ‘WIM Journal of Management’ Volume -2, Issue 2, January 2012. ISSN-
0975-5063
INTRODUCTION
The mutual fund industry has been in India for a long time. This came into
existence in 1963 with the establishment of Unit Trust of India, a joint effort by the
Government of India and the Reserve Bank of India. The year of 1993 marked the
beginning of a new era in the Indian mutual fund industry with the entry of private
players like Morgan Stanley, J.P Morgan, and Capital International. SEBI (Security
Exchange Board of India) was established under which all the mutual funds in India were
required to be registered. SEBI was set up as a governing body to protect the interest of
investor. By the end of 2008, the number of players in the industry grew enormously with
46 fund houses functioning in the country. With the rise of the mutual fund industry,
Today AMFI ensures mutual funds function in a professional and healthy manner thereby
Mutual funds are considered as one of the best available investment options as
compare to others alternatives. They are very cost efficient and also easy to invest in.
The biggest advantage of mutual funds is they provide diversification, by reducing risk &
maximizing returns. India is ranked one of the fastest growing economies in the world.
Despite this huge progression in the industry, there still lies huge potential and room for
growth. India has a saving rate of more than 35% of GDP, with 80% of the population
who save. These savings could be channel zed in the mutual funds sector as it offers a
Further tapping rural markets in India will benefit mutual fund companies from
the growth in agriculture and allied sectors. With subsequent easing of regulations, it is
estimated that the mutual fund industry will grow at a rate of 30% - 35% in the next 3 to
As it can be noted, there is huge growth and potential in the mutual fund industry.
The development of this sector so far has been commendable and with the above positive
The basic need of the study to analyze the performance of Debt and Equity
Schemes of Birla sun life Mutual Fund and to know in which kind of fund the investor
To analyze the performance of debt and equity schemes of the Birla Sun Life MF
company over a period of time with reference to Reliance and ICICI MFs.
SCOPE OF THE STUDY
This study is to understand the crucial role of mutual fund in the market.
It will cover the theoretical frame work of debt and equity schemes in Birla sun
To analyze the performance of debt and equity schemes of Birla sun life mutual
Data collection
the comparison purpose of Birla schemes with other mutual funds referred
The data collected from the secondary sources is refined carefully and the necessary
information is taken. The analysis is in this way, each month we observe changes in the
NAV, AUM, Standard deviation, Sharpe Ratio, Portfolio Turnover, for each and every
fund of Birla Mutual Fund. And after that the comparative study of Birla Mutual Fund
has done with the ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund and Reliance Mutual Fund
Evaluation Parameters
Following are the evaluation parameters on the basis of which the analysis and
3. Expense Ratio
4. Standard Deviation
5. Sharpe Ratio
6. Beta
The value of a collective investment fund based on the market price of securities held in
its portfolio. NAV per share is calculated by dividing net assets of the scheme /number of
Units outstanding.
It is used to gauge how much money a fund is managing. Mutual Funds use this as a
measure of success and comparison against their competitors; in lieu of revenue or total
revenue they use total 'assets under management'. The difference between two AUM
net new assets (NNA) inflow/(outflow) and structural effects of the company.
Expense ratio
The percentage of the average daily assets that the fund charged as its management
Standard Deviation
Standard deviation is a measure of total risks of a fund. In other words it measures the
volatility of returns of a fund. It indicates the tendency of the funds NAV to rise and fall
in a short period. It measures the extent to which the NAV fluctuates as compared to the
Sharpe Ratio
The Sharpe ratio represents trade off between risk and returns. At the same time it also
factors in the desire to generate returns, which are higher than those from risk free
returns. Mathematically the Sharpe ratio is the returns generated over the risk free rate,
per unit of risk. Risk in this case is taken to be the fund's standard deviation. As standard
deviation represents the total risk experienced by a fund, the Sharpe ratio reflects the
returns generated by undertaking all possible risks. It is thus one single number, which
represents the trade off between risks and returns. A higher Sharpe ratio is therefore better
Beta
Beta is a statistical measure that shows how sensitive a fund is to market moves. If the
Sensex moves by 25 per cent, a fund's beta number will tell you whether the fund's
returns will be more than this or less. The beta value for an index itself is taken as one.
Equity funds can have beta values, which can be above one, less than one or equal to one.
By multiplying the beta value of a fund with the expected percentage movement of an
Insufficient time to cover and present all schemes of Birla sun life mutual fund
Technical tools have some disadvantages which have impact on Debt and Equity
schemes.
The study does not provide any predictions or forecast of the selected schemes.
EQUITY FUNDS
Equity funds are considered to be the more risky funds as compared to other fund
types, but they also provide higher returns than other funds. It is advisable that an
investor looking to invest in an equity fund should invest for long term i.e. for 3 years or
more. There are different types of equity funds each falling into different risk bracket. In
the order of decreasing risk level, there are following types of equity funds:
Growth Funds
Specialty Funds
Diversified Equity
Value Funds
various sectors (like infrastructure companies etc.) are known as Debt / Income Funds.
Debt funds are low risk profile funds that seek to generate fixed current income (and not
capital appreciation) to investors. Although debt securities are generally less risky than
equities, they are subject to credit risk (risk of default) by the issuer at the time of interest
or principal payment. To minimize the risk of default, debt funds usually invest in
securities from issuers who are rated by credit rating agencies and are considered to be of
"Investment Grade". Debt funds that target high returns are more risky. Based on
Assured Return
Brla Sun Life Asset Management Company Ltd. (BSLAMC), the investment
managers of Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund, is a joint venture between the Aditya Birla
Group and the Sun Life Financial Services Inc. of Canada. The joint venture brings
together the Aditya Birla Group's experience in the Indian market and Sun Life's global
experience.
Established in 1994, Birla Sun Life Mutual fund has emerged as one of India's leading
flagships of Mutual Funds business managing assets of a large investor base. Our
solutions offer a range of investment options, including diversified and sector specific
equity schemes, fund of fund schemes, hybrid and monthly income funds, a wide range
Birla Sun Life Asset Management Company has one of the largest team of
research analysts in the industry, dedicated to tracking down the best companies to invest
in. BSLAMC strives to provide transparent, ethical and research-based investments and
Birla Sn Life Dividend Yield plus: The Investment objective of the scheme is to
portfolio of dividend paying companies that have a relatively high dividend yield. The
protection during falling equity markets. The scheme would therefore aim to build a
protection and a strong possibility of capital gains. Investing in stocks with high
proportion of the Scheme's equity investments will be made in relatively liquid large
Birla Sun Life Tax Relief 96: An open ended equity linked savings scheme (ELSS)
with the objective of long term growth of capital through a portfolio with a target
Birla Sun Life Income Fund: The investment objective of the Scheme is to generate
Birla Sun Life Short Term Fund: The investment objective of the Scheme is to
diversified portfolio of debt and money market securities with relatively low levels of
Reliance Tax Saver: The primary objective of the scheme is to generate long-term
Reliance Income Fund: Aims to generate optimal returns consistent with moderate
Reliance Short Term Fund: It aims to generate stable returns for investors with a
maturity.
securities.
ICICI Prudential Fmcg Fund: To generate long term capital appreciation through
investments made primarily in Fast Moving Consumer Goods sector that are
income securities and also to generate long term capital appreciation by investing a
ICICI Short Term Fund: To generate income through investment in basket of debt
DATA ANALYSIS:
Interpretation:
As per the given table-1, performance analysis of Birla sun life dividend yield
plus NAV (65.79 to 77.50), AUM (370.55 to 384.83), Sharpe ratio(0.33 to 0.52)
and Beta (0.77 to 0.82) has increased in 2010 where as expense ratio( 2.26 to
2.32) and Standard Deviation increased in 2009 from 30.41 to 33.53 and
decreased to 32.82.
In Birla sun life MNC equity scheme, performance of NAV was increased from
151.58 to 191.61 and AUM was increased from 197.40 to 204.75 where as
expense ratio increased in 2009 up to 2.49 and decreased to 2.38 in 2010, standard
In Birla sun life tax relief, NAV (161.73 to 83.27), expense ratio (2.25 to 2.00),
Sharpe ratio (0.25 to 0.23) has decreased in 2010 where as AUM (700.70 to
Table 2: Performance Analysis of Debt Schemes of Birla Sunlife (BSL) Mutual Fund
Interpretation:
In Birla sun life income fund, NAV (28.97 to 34.45) and expense ratio (1.50 to
2.01) has increased in 2010 where as AUM has decreased from 518.75 to 366.39
preceding years.
In Birla sun life ultra short term, NAV (151.58 to 191.61), AUM (197.40 to
204.75) and beta (0.28 to 0.40) has increased in 2010 where as expense ratio (2.49
to 2.38), standard deviation (27.39 to 26.89) and beta (0.85 to 0.70) has decreased
in 2010.
Table 3: Performance Analysis of Equity Schemes of Reliance Mutual Fund
Interpretation:
7428.96), Sharpe ratio (0.111 to 0.42), Beta (0.90 to 1.01) has increased in 2010
where as Expense ratio (1.84 to 1.79) and Standard deviation (44.57 to 37.07) has
Sharpe ratio (0.04 to 0.75), Beta (0.89 to 1.07) has increased in 2010 where as
expense ratio (2.68 to 2.21) and Standard deviation was 1.13 in 2007, it has
In Reliance tax saver, NAV (20.99 to 19.42), AUM (2548.62 to 2151.92), Expense
ratio (1.93 to 1.89), Standard deviation (4.45 to 3.13) has decreased in 2010 where
as Beta (0.86 to 0.87) and Sharp ratio (0.06 to 0.27) has increased when compared
Interpretation:
In Reliance Income fund, NAV (25.33 to 31.28), AUM (80.27 to 330.55) has
2010.Standard deviation was 8.74 and Sharpe ratio was 0.79 in 2010.
In Reliance short term plan, NAV (10.18), AUM (2605.65), Standard deviation
Interpretation:
369.19), Expense ratio (2.30 to 2.27), Sharpe ratio (0.45 to 0.25) and Beta (0.94 to
0.83) has decreased in 2010 where as Standard deviation had increased to 29.78 in
2010.
(20.51 to 28.04) and Beta (0.68 to 1.03) has increased in 2010 where as Expense
ratio remained constant i.e. 2.50 and Sharpe ratio (0.48 to 0.40) has decreased in
2010.
1159.48), Standard deviation (32.10 to 37.01) and Beta (0.81 to 0.97) has
increased in 2010 where as Expense ratio has decreased from 2.22 to 2.04 in
2010.
Interpretation:
In ICICI Prudential Income fund, NAV (23.56 to 30.40) has increased where as in
AUM was 2547.98 in 2008 and decreased to 789.51 in 2010. Expense ratio (2.06
In ICICI Prudential short term, NAV (15.28 to 19.38), AUM (627.51 to 2184.51)
has increased in 2010 where as Expense ratio was high in 2009 i.e. 1.70 and
FINDINGS:
Diversified type:
• Reliance Mutual fund: NAV, AUM, Beta, Sharpe ratio has increased.
Sector type
• Reliance Mutual fund: NAV, AUM, Beta, Sharpe ratio has increased.
• ICICI Prudential mutual fund: NAV, AUM, Standard Deviation has increased.
Tax planning
• ICICI Prudential mutual fund: NAV, AUM, Standard Deviation, Sharpe ratio has
increased.
Income fund
• Reliance Mutual fund: NAV, AUM has increased where as Expense ratio
remained constant.
• ICICI Prudential mutual fund: NAV has increased where as all other ratios
decreased.
• ICICI Prudential mutual fund: NAV, AUM has increased where as all other ratios
decreased.
CONCLUSIONS
Based on scheme wise performance Reliance Pharma fund is the fund which has
higher performance when compared to ICICI and Birla Sun Life mutual fund.
According to ICRA, Reliance short term fund is placed first when compared to
Based on Diversified Growth type, Birla Sun Life mutual fund’s performance is
higher than the Reliance and ICICI mutual funds as per ICRA results.
Based on Tax Planning, Birla Sun life mutual fund’s performance is higher than
Birla Sun life revises scheme name for Birla Sun Life Short Term Fund. The new
Birla Mutual Fund has declared dividend under its open ended schemes - Birla
Sun Life Tax Plan, Birla Sun Life Equity Fund, Birla Sun Life Top 100 Fund and
Mutual funds are affordable for most individuals. The market is going day by day
and websites provide the investor with much information. Investing has become
The good performance of the economy and stock markets in the last couple of
For the rapid development in economy SEBI should encourage the rural investor
S.K.Gupta, Nisha Aggarwal and Neeti Gupta (2009): “Financial Institutions and
www.birlasunlife.com,
www.Amfi.com
www.Reliancemutual.com
www.ICICIpruamc.com
www.valueonlineresearch.com,