Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This report is published by Agensi Kaunseling dan Pengurusan Kredit (AKPK). Great care has
been taken to ensure the accuracy of the information in this report. However, AKPK cannot
accept responsibility for any error or omission or any liability resulting from the use or misuse
of any such information. The views and opinions in this report may be used for information
purposes only.
5 Foreword
6 Executive Summary
7 Key Findings
53 Conclusion
56 Appendices
67 References
AKPK Financial Behaviour Survey 2018
Acknowledgements to:
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 5
FOREWORD
This inaugural large-scale survey is a major For this survey, we acknowledge the
milestone for Agensi Kaunseling dan contribution of our team of research advisors:
Pengurusan Kredit (AKPK) in realising its i. Professor Dr Zainuddin Awang, Universiti
vision ‘to create a society that is financially Sultan Zainal Abidin (UniSZA)
savvy’, ‘to be recognised as the trusted ii. Associate Professor Dr Cordelia Mason
provider of financial education to adult (Co-author), Universiti Kuala Lumpur
consumers’, and ‘to continue to promote (UniKL)
financial prudence’; and to accomplish iii. Associate Professor Dr Hawati Janor,
its mission ‘to make prudent financial Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM)
management a way of life’. iv. Associate Professor Dr Mohamad Fazli
Sabri, Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM)
The survey is inspired by other global and v. Assistant Professor Dr Maya Puspa Rahman,
national research initiatives on financial literacy International Islamic University Malaysia
and financial well-being by the World Bank, (IIUM)
the OECD, the Consumer Financial Protection vi. Associate Professor Dr Vinitha Guptan,
Bureau of America and Bank Negara Malaysia. Saito University College
This research focuses on financial behaviour
that forms a part of financial literacy. However, We would also like to express our appreciation
it differs from the previous studies mentioned to our nationwide respondents who participated
in that it also explores the impact of financial in the survey and to our AKPK team who
behaviour on financial well-being. steadfastly managed this inaugural research
project. The team members’ full commitment
Understanding financial behaviour and the and high level of professionalism are valuable
state of financial well-being is of paramount assets which AKPK can leverage on towards
importance. Firstly, insights on these could building a strong research culture that will drive
facilitate the development and refinement AKPK forward in achieving its goal of enhancing
of initiatives to promote prudent financial financial literacy among Malaysians.
management as a key driver towards attaining
financial well-being. Secondly, the low It is our sincere hope that this research report
financial literacy rate in Malaysia, found to would benefit various stakeholders such as
be below average and ranked 26th among policy makers, regulators, academicians, the
30 participating countries in the OECD 2016 financial services industry, consumer associations,
report, calls for attention to measure the level consumers and other relevant parties.
of financial wellness in Malaysia. Finally, the
results of this survey could be used as a guide Let us all strive to improve the financial well-
in the curriculum development of financial being of all citizens of our nation.
literacy modules, and as empirical data to
derive effective key messages for the relevant Azaddin Ngah Tasir
stakeholders. Chief Executive Officer
6 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AKPK embarked on this research to study towards paying loan instalments and credit
the financial behaviour and financial well- card payment.
being of Malaysian Working Adults (MWAs)
who form the largest segment of clients in The other main focus of this study is the
the financial services industry. Specifically, financial well-being among MWAs. Financial
the study focuses on the financial behaviour well-being is a state where people can fully
of MWAs in terms of their spending, savings meet their current and ongoing financial
and debt management. The respondents obligations, feel secure about their financial
were profiled according to gender, age future and are able to make choices for them
group, ethnicity, marital status, number of to enjoy life (Consumer Protection Bureau,
dependants, employment, type of industry, 2017). Financial well-being is associated with
designation, monthly income and region. financial literacy, financial behaviour and skills.
The study describes the MWAs’ financial
behaviour according to their heterogeneous This study was conducted using a self-
profiles. The study also determines the administered survey questionnaire. Over
level of financial well-being among MWAs 3,500 completed surveys were collected
and tries to answer the question of whether nationwide. The key findings on financial
good financial behaviour leads to better behaviour and financial well-being are
financial well-being. It aims to identify the outlined on pages 7, 8 and 9.
MWAs who are financially comfortable
as opposed to those who are financially Financial behaviours among MWAs have much
challenged. room for enhancement and the importance of
doing so is paramount given their current
Financial behaviour in the scope of this study state of financial well-being. Based on
is a function of spending behaviour, savings, the insights gained from this study, it is
retirement and investment as well as debt recommended that initiatives be carried out
management. Spending behaviour among on issues pertaining to indebtedness, cost of
MWAs covers their behaviours in terms of living, home ownership, and income structure
preparing a spending budget, assessing by industry. It also highlighted the importance
affordability before spending and deciding of financial education that can shape better
what to do if they have surplus money. In financial behaviour which in turn, leads to
order to describe the savings behaviour better financial well-being. With an improved
among MWAs, the study asked how much understanding of the landscape of financial
they save, whether they have retirement behaviour and state of financial well-being,
plans and why they are unable to save. To the relevant stakeholders could provide
complete our understanding of the financial effective financial education initiatives.
behaviour among MWAs, we looked at
debt management aspects – the level of
debt, composition of loans taken, attitude Enjoy reading!
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 7
KEY FINDINGS
Behaviour
• Almost a quarter (24%) falls on the good and exemplary score range
• Another quarter miserably sat on the low and weak score range
• Only 10% of MWAs falls under the comfortable category and a mere 6% are
in the elated mode
• Almost half fall under need attention and under pressure categories
Northern
Region
Region
19%
East Coast
Region
14% East
Central Region Malaysia
36% 14%
Southern
Region
17%
Gender Age
Male
48%
Ethnicity
Marital Status
Single
23%
Married
74%
Divorced/Single Parent
3%
Number of Dependants
6 or more 5%
5 7%
4 12%
3 15%
2 18%
1 10%
No Dependants 33%
Highest Qualification
Employment Sector
Designation
Senior
Executive Management
35% 3%
Manager
14%
Non-Executive
48%
Monthly Income
FINANCIAL
BEHAVIOUR
14 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
1.1 INTRODUCTION
In this study, the measurement of financial and investment behaviour, as well as debt
behaviour is based on three areas covered by management behaviour. The indicators that
the AKPK financial education modules which fall under each area of financial behaviour are
are spending behaviour, savings, retirement summarised in Table 1.
What is the level of financial behaviour among the survey also found that on average, their
MWAs? This survey found that the financial behaviour on debt management is the highest
behaviour of MWAs is at the score of 7.02. This (7.47) followed by their behaviour on savings,
indicates that the overall financial behaviour retirement and investment (6.94) and their
across three dimensions as illustrated in Chart spending behaviour, which scores lowest at
1 is at the reasonable level between a score 6.89.
of 6 to 8. Looking further into each dimension,
6.94
6.89
How do the scores differ between the profiles difference among Gender, Age, Number of
of respondents? Based on a statistical Dependants, Employment Type and Income
analysis (ANOVA, refer Appendix 1) it is Level with regard to their financial behaviour
proven that there is statistically significant scores.
16 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
1.2 SPENDING BEHAVIOUR Those who earn more than RM10,000 score
6.65 while those earning between RM8,001
In the area of financial spending, the survey to RM10,000 score the lowest average score
asks whether respondents prepare a spending (6.60); indicating that those from the higher
budget, assess affordability before spending, income bracket are less likely to plan their
recorded all their spending, spend according spending.
to plan and spend on essential items rather
than on their wants. The full results are It is observed that those who are more
provided in Appendix 2. Some of the findings financially challenged i.e. those who have
are detailed below: more dependants to care for and those in
the lower income groups are more likely to
PREPARE A SPENDING BUDGET prepare a spending budget.
On average, females with an average
score of 7.04 are more likely to plan their
spending compared to males who score
6.79. In terms of age, those most serious Females are more
likely to plan their
in preparing a spending budget fall under
the 50-59 group (7.00), followed by these
groups: 20-29 (6.96), 30-39 (6.89) and 40- spending compared
49 (6.88).
to males
Government employees are most likely to
plan their spending, scoring an average of
7.12; followed by the self-employed (6.84),
and those working in the private sector
(6.73). In terms of job designation, non-
executives have the highest average score
of 7.04 and are closely tailed by the senior
management who score only 0.02 lower at
7.02. Executives scored an average of 6.81
whilst managers score 6.76, which stood at
the lowest average score point.
Male 6.79
Gender
Female 7.04
20 - 29 6.96
30 - 39 6.89
Age
40 - 49 6.88
50 - 59 7.00
Private 6.73
Self-employed 6.84
ASSESSING AFFORDABILITY BEFORE The average scores of the four age groups do
SPENDING not differ significantly with the highest at 7.92
Assessing whether you can afford something for the 50-59 group and the lowest at 7.69 for
before making a purchase promotes financial the thirties range. This indicates that MWAs
well-being. What does this survey tell us about do assess affordability before spending.
the purchasing behaviour of the MWAs?
Those over 50 years old are more conscious
The survey results show that female about affordability. This could perhaps be due
respondents have a slightly higher average to the fact that they are approaching retirement
score (7.84) than males (7.75) – indicating that age. For those in the 30s, some possible reasons
females are more likely to assess affordability for them scoring the lowest average score are
before spending. due to their need to start or raise a family, and
having to buy a house or a car.
Male 7.75
Gender
Female 7.84
20 - 29 7.85
30 - 39 7.69
Age
40 - 49 7.87
50 - 59 7.92
No Dependants 7.73
No. of
1 to 5 7.82
dependants
6 or more 7.83
Private 7.71
Self-employed 7.49
1.3 PROPENSITY TO SAVE any savings in the last six months. A little
AMONG MALAYSIAN more than half of the respondents (53%)
WORKING ADULTS are only able to save between 1% to 10% of
their income; 16% can only save between
The state of savings among MWAs leaves 11% to 20 % of their income and a mere
much to be desired. Almost two out of 13% could save more than 20% of their
every ten people (18%) are unable to make income.
1% to 5% 6% to 10%
20 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
On average, females save a higher percentage self-employed who only save 6.89% of their
(10.18%) of their income compared to monthly income. Position and income also
males (8.85%). Those in the age groups correlate to the ability to save of the working
of 20-29 and 50-59 save more than those adults. The higher the position, the more one
in the 30-49 age group. Those with more saves. In terms of income, those who earn
dependants save less as they need to spend between RM8,000 and RM10,000 save the
on essential items. Savings are highest for most. The groups which save the least are
those working in private companies, followed those who earn less than RM2,000 who can
by the government employees and finally the only save 5.54% of their income.
Male 8.85%
Gender
Female 10.18%
20 - 29 10.43%
30 - 39 8.93%
Age
40 - 49 9.38%
50 - 59 10.50%
No Dependants 10.57%
No. of
1 to 5 9.10%
dependants
6 or more 8.23%
Private 10.29%
Self-employed 6.89%
8.22
7.18
7.15
6.50
5.94
5.69 5.27
6.20 6.40 6.60 6.80 7.00 7.20 7.40 7.60 7.80 8.00
Male 7.09
Gender
Female 7.17
20 - 29 6.97
30 - 39 6.88
Age
40 - 49 7.30
50 - 59 7.79
No Dependants 7.02
No. of
1 to 5 7.20
dependants
6 or more 7.06
Private 7.03
Self-employed 6.86
1.4 DEBT MANAGEMENT The self-employed are less likely to pay their
loan instalments on time, scoring below
MWAs’ ATTITUDE TOWARDS PAYING average at 6.76 while those who work in the
LOAN INSTALMENTS government score above average at 8.03,
Chart 9 summarises the average financial compared to private sector employees at
behaviour scores for the sub-groups in terms 7.87. Non-executives struggle to pay their
of loan management skills i.e. paying loan loan instalments on time.
instalments on time. The average overall score
is 7.85. Profiled by gender, female MWAs MWAs earning less than RM4,000 are
score an average of 8.01 point compared to challenged to pay their loan instalments on
males who score 7.68, i.e. below average. By time. As expected, the ability to pay loan
age group, those in the 20-29 (7.69) and 30- instalments on time generally increases as one
39 (7.81) groups score below average while earns more. This is supported by the scores
those from the 40-59 group are more likely to recorded as follows: 8.01 for those earning
pay loan instalments on time. between RM4,001 to RM6,000, 8.21 for the
RM6,001 to RM8,000 income bracket, and
Those with 1 to 5 dependants are most likely 8.62 for those earning more than RM10,000.
able to pay loan instalments on time scoring Although at an above-average score of
above average by 0.03 points at 7.88. Those 8.09, the group earning between RM8,001
with more than 5 dependants and those with to RM10,000 score lower than those in the
no dependant score lower than average at RM6,001-RM8,000 income bracket. See
7.82 and 7.75 respectively. Appendix 4 for full results.
The self-employed
are most
challenged in
paying loans on
time
24 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
Male 7.68
Gender
Female 8.01
20 - 29 7.69
30 - 39 7.81
Age
40 - 49 7.95
50 - 59 8.01
No Dependants 7.75
No. of
1 to 5 7.88
dependants
6 or more 7.82
Private 7.87
Self-employed 6.76
Chart 10: Paying more than 5% Minimum Payment, Average Score of 6.82
Male 6.54
Gender
Female 7.09
20 - 29 6.83
30 - 39 6.88
Age
40 - 49 6.81
50 - 59 6.66
No Dependants 6.88
No. of
1 to 5 6.75
dependants
6 or more 6.82
Private 6.86
Self-employed 6.38
62%
56%
59%
23%
24%
23%
52%
46%
49%
44%
35%
39%
17%
13%
15%
For the 40-49 age group, housing loans top the More than half of the 50-59 age group are
list. At this age, most MWAs are still servicing still servicing car and housing loans. More
their housing loans as well as car loans. than a third (40%) are still servicing personal
Personal loans are tapering off for this group and credit card loans, and more than one in
but credit card loans show a surge compared ten are servicing non-bank loans. The level
to the younger age groups where almost half of indebtedness may be an area of concern
of this age segment have credit card loans. for this group.
90%
80%
70%
Percentage of Loan Ownership
Car
60%
Housing
50%
Credit Card
40% Personal
30%
20%
Non-bank
10% Education
0%
20-29 30-39 40-49 50-59
Age Group
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 29
60%
54%
58%
25%
16%
26%
56%
26%
39%
34%
58%
42%
18%
11%
7%
60%
59%
48%
23%
23%
23%
35%
65%
39%
45%
34%
39%
13%
18%
13%
TYPES OF LOANS TAKEN BY MWAs people among this group are pursing life-long
CLUSTERED BY JOB DESIGNATION education.
Among senior management personnel, 73% Those at the managerial level are laden with
have car loans, 70% have housing loans, loans where 71% of them have housing loans,
61% have credit cards, 58% have personal 69% take car loans, 62% have credit cards,
loans, 16% have non-bank loans and 6% have 40% service personal loans, 18% pay off their
education loans, indicating that only a few education loans and 9% have non-bank loans.
53%
64%
69%
73%
24%
27%
18%
55%
42%
40%
58%
26%
51%
62%
61%
18%
11%
16%
6%
9%
Housing Car Education Personal Credit Card Non-bank
Non-executive
and senior
management
level of the
MWAs are the
highest takers
of non-bank
loans compared
to other
designation
groups
32 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
The executive level workers are also years of age would rather spend on essential
exposed to debts with different types of items. A few questions can be raised as to why
loans, namely housing loans (56%), car loans youngsters are more casual about spending
(64%), credit cards (51%), personal loans compared to the more cautious senior citizens
(42%), education loans (27%) and non-bank who are about to retire. Could it be that
loans (11%). those in the younger age bracket have not
accumulated as much debt as the rest and
Despite getting a lower pay range, the are therefore more carefree about spending?
non-executives are also exposed to various Does the high average score of ‘pay off debt’
types of debts in the following percentages: suggests that a debt-ridden individual would
personal loans (55%), car loans (53%), be less likely to invest or spend for wants as
housing loans (40%), credit cards (26%), he does not have much to invest or indulge
education loans (24%) and non-bank loans in the first place?
(18%). This group could be from those at
the lower age group too as indicated by So, how did the respondents rank the six
almost one in four (24%) of the respondents choices given? The survey found that only
who are still paying for their education. The the age factor influences MWAs’ decision
fact that 18% of them are taking non-bank on how they would spend their excess
loans suggests that they may not yet have money. Paying off debt is what the MWAs
high credit worth. choose to do first if they have excess money.
Subsequently, most will spend on essentials
before considering savings for retirement
EXCESS MONEY and other reasons. Being pre-occupied
When given six choices of what they would with settling their debts and working hard
do if they have surplus money, paying off to save for various needs as well as for
debts tops the selection for those between retirement might be the reasons why the
the ages of 50 and 60. On the other hand, the MWAs place investing and spending on
youngest group comprising those of 20-29 wants as their lowest priorities.
Age
Overall
20 – 29 30 – 39 40 – 49 50 - 60
Pay Debt 1 1 (7.69) 2 (7.58) 1 (7.69) 1 (7.68) 2 (7.88)
Spend on Essentials 2 2 (7.61) 1 (7.65) 2 (7.55) 2 (7.60) 3 (7.73)
Save for Other than Retirement 3 3 (7.44) 3 (7.51) 3 (7.30) 3 (7.50) 4 (7.64)
Save for Retirement 4 4 (7.17) 4 (7.00) 4 (6.91) 4 (7.32) 1 (7.89)
Invest 5 5 (5.91) 5 (5.86) 5 (5.78) 5 (5.94) 5 (6.30)
Spend on Wants 6 6 (5.73) 6 (4.96) 6 (5.25) 6 (5.44) 6 (5.48)
PART 2
FINANCIAL
WELL-BEING
34 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
A person is said to be able to make ends meet In this study, one is considered to have
when he is in a financial position to cover his financial resilience if his financial position is
daily expenses, can afford to buy the items enough to cover an emergency expenditure
he want and does not resort to borrowing to of RM1,000, medical costs of RM2,500 and
buy basic needs. three months’ expenses if retrenched.
Male 6.05
Gender
Female 6.35
20 - 29 6.11
30 - 39 5.98
Age
40 - 49 6.36
50 - 59 6.75
No Dependants 6.27
No. of
1 to 5 6.18
dependants
6 or more 6.21
Private 6.09
Self-employed 5.82
Non-Executive 5.91
Executive 6.46
Designation
Manager 6.71
MWAs’ SCORES ON THE THREE score of 6.02, and ‘financial resilience’ has the
DIMENSIONS OF FINANCIAL WELL- lowest score. This shows that in describing
BEING the level of financial well-being, MWAs are
Based on the financial well-being framework characterised more by their ability to make
used in this survey, the results show that ends meet compared to being financially
MWAs scored highest in the ‘ability to make comfortable or resilient. This indicates the
ends meet’ at 6.79. ‘Feeling comfortable with need for intervention to address this gap in
current financial position’ registers a lower order to enhance their financial well-being.
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 37
2.3 ABILITY TO MAKE ENDS to cover their daily needs (score 7.24) and
MEET most of them do not need to borrow to
buy basic needs (score 7.23). However, less
This survey shows that MWAs are generally are able to buy the things they want (score
in a financial situation where they are able 5.92).
The segments of MWAs who are most almost three out of ten or 28% need to
vulnerable in terms of financial well-being are borrow to buy essential goods. Half of this
the divorced, the self-employed, those working group have personal loans and 21% of them
in the army, police or enforcement sector, and borrow from non-bank institutions. More than
those earning less than RM2,000. The low one-third (33% and more) males, the self-
mean scores for these groups reveal that their employed, those earning less than RM2,000.
financial well-being may be compromised See Appendix 5 for full results.
and it is highly probable that they might not
be able to cover the expenses of their daily WANTS ARE OUT OF REACH FOR MANY
needs. See Appendix 5 for full results. Almost half of the respondents indicate
that they cannot afford to buy their
WHICH SEGMENTS NEED TO BORROW wants. Those who work in these three
TO BUY BASIC NEEDS? categories i.e. manufacturing, army, police &
Not being able to afford essential goods enforcement,and agriculture & commodity
and resorting to borrowing is quite prevalent are the most challenged in this regard. See
among MWAs. Of the respondents surveyed, Appendix 5 for full results.
Of the respondents
surveyed, almost three
out of ten or 28%
need to borrow to buy
essential goods
2.4 HOW COMFORTABLE comfort and having extra money at the end of
ARE MWAs ABOUT THEIR the month. Luxuries such as holidays costing
CURRENT FINANCIAL at least RM4,000 are not affordable to more
SITUATION? than half of MWAs. Being comfortable with
one’s financial position implies that there will
Of the five indicators used to measure be less stress over one’s financial matters.
‘financial comfort’, MWAs are more confident The findings of this survey (see Chart 19)
of achieving their long-term financial goals indicate that the more comfortable one is with
compared to achieving their short-term goals. his financial position, the better his financial
However, they are less confident of retiring in well-being.
Chart 20: Income vs Mean Score for Having Excess Money at the End of the Month
10
Mean (I have extra money at the end of the month),
Money at the End of the Month
Mean Score for Having Excess
overall at 6.00
8
6.46 6.93 6.93
6.29
5.57
6 5.21
0
Less than 2001 to 4001 to 6001 to 8001 to More than
2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 10000
Income Group
Of the three criteria, only about two in three Four to five out of 10 people in these
MWAs are able to fork out RM1,000 in case vulnerable groups cannot afford the RM1,000
of an emergency while 36% of the total emergency expenses (see Appendix 6 for
respondents are not able to do so. Less full results).
than six out of ten people can afford to pay
RM2,500 for medical costs, and slightly more
than half can cover three months of expenses 53% of MWAs
if retrenched. earning less than
ABILITY TO PAY RM1,000 IN CASE OF
RM2,000 cannot
AN EMERGENCY afford the RM1,000
Who are exposed to financial distress in times
of emergency? The profiles of MWAs who are
emergency expenses
most susceptible to being distress are:
• those who earn less than RM2,000 (53%)
• the divorcees (44%)
• the Self-employed (44%)
• MWAs working at the non-executive level
(43%)
• those aged between 30-39 years old
(41%)
43% 41%
ABILITY TO PAY RM2,500 MEDICAL • who work in the manufacturing sector (56);
EXPENSES AMONG MWAs • are self-employed (56%);
Who among the MWAs are unable to pay • who work at the non- executive level
RM2,500 for medical expenses? The survey (54%);
shows that he categories of people who are • who earn between RM2,000 – RM4,000
least able to cover the RM2,500 medical costs (52%);
are those: • are in the 30-39 age group (51%); and
• who earn less than RM2,000 (66%) • are in the 20-29 age group (49%)
• w h o w o r k i n t h e a r m y, p o l i c e o r
enforcement sector (57%); (See Appendix 6 for full results).
ABILITY TO COVER THREE MONTHS’ • who work at the non- executive level (60%);
EXPENSES IF RETRENCHED • are in the 30-39 age group (60%); and
Who among the MWAs are able to cover • who earn between RM2,000 – RM4,000
three months’ expenses if retrenched? Not (59%);
many are able to do so. The profiles of • are in the 20-29 age group (58%)
people who are not able cover three months’
expenses if retrenched are those:
(See Appendix 6 for full results).
• who earn less than RM2,000 (70%)
• who work in the manufacturing, army,
police or enforcement sectors (61%);
Those working in
the manufacturing
and the army, police
& enforcement
sectors are the least
able to cover three
months of expenses
if retrenched
PART 3
KEY TO
FINANCIAL
WELL-BEING
46 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
7.46 7.47
8 7.17
6.31
6 5.70
0
Poor Below Reasonable Good Superior
Secondly, this study also shows a positive acquiring financial knowledge. Financial
relationship between the levels of financial education is thus a critical way forward to
knowledge and financial well-being (Chart enhance financial well-being.
23), further confirming the importance of
8 7.33
6.65
6.22
5.22 5.69
6
0
Poor Low Reasonable Good Superior
Thirdly, a positive relationship between being score is applicable for all income
financial behaviour and financial well-being range groups (Chart 25). Thus, promoting
(Chart 24) is also evidenced from the data. good financial behaviour is impactful for
What is most encouraging is that the study all income groups. And this, as explained
also found that the relationship between earlier, could be done by enhancing financial
the levels of behaviour and financial well- knowledge.
7.62
8 7.19
6.23
6 5.26
4.46
0
Weak Low Reasonable Good Exemplary
Chart 25: Financial Behaviour and Financial Well-being Scores based on Income Range
RM4,001 - RM6,000
RM2,001 - RM4,000
6.00 Less than RM2,000
4.00
2.00
0.00
Weak Low Reasonable Good Exemplary
7.98
8 7.12 7.07 7.05 7.06
6.27
5.85
6
4.98
0
No 1% to 6% to 11% to 16% to 21% to 26% to More
Savings 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% than 30%
The goal of getting a good return on as those in the youngest age category are
investment increases in importance as one already placing it as one of their top three
ages, while the appetite to buy cars and priorities.
houses decreases. A late start into thinking
about returns on investment could be The interest to upskill generally decreases as
due to lack of capital when entering the one ages but peaks slightly for those aged
job market. For MWAs, owning a house is 40-49. The motivation to prepare for job loss
important and having this perspective starts decreases as those in the twenties get into
early on. The same goes for retirement their thirties, then picks up again as they enter
planning which enjoys a good head start their forties and fifties.
10.00
9.50
9.00
6.00
Luxurious
5.50 Holiday
5.00
20-29 30-39 40-49 50-59
Age Group
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 51
9.50
9.00
Retire Comfortably
8.50
Ready for Emergency
Settle Debt Faster
Financial Goal Score
8.00
Return on Investment
6.50
Purchase Car
6.00
Luxurious
5.50
Holiday
5.00
Less than 2001 to 4001 to 6001 to 8001 to More than
2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 10000
Income Range
52 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
9.50
9.00
Ready for Emergency
Retire Comfortably
8.50
Settle Debt Faster
Buy House
Return on Investment
8.00
Prepare for Loss of Job
Financial Goal Score
7.50
Purchase Car
7.00 Give Back to Society
6.50
6.00 Upskill
5.50
5.00
Luxurious
4.50 Holiday
4.00
No 1% to 6% to 11% to 16% to 21% to 26% to More
savings 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% than 30%
Percentage of Income Saved
CONCLUSION
54 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
THE FINANCIAL WELL-BEING AMONG achieve their strong desire to escape the
MWAs IS AT A DISMAL LEVEL grips of indebtedness as evidenced from
The financial well-being of MWAs is in their concern about settling their debts as
a compromised position and warrants fast as they could. Facilitation, including
immediate attention. This is evidenced equipping MWAs with sound financial
from the survey which shows that a notable knowledge, must be intensified to fuel
number of MWAs are unable to make their aspiration to develop good financial
ends meet, uncomfortable with their habits as they are finding it so hard to save.
current financial situation and lack financial This is despite the fact that some MWAs
resilience. Many do not have money for do plan their spending budget and assess
emergency needs, medical expenses, and affordability before spending. Some of them
cannot cover three months’ expenses if are also prudent and do not buy on impulse;
retrenched. Almost 3 out of 10 MWAs need choose to pay debts if they have surplus
to borrow to buy essential goods which leads money; and start retirement planning early,
to high indebtedness. This problem needs to and consistently take this aspect of financial
be nipped in the bud. planning seriously. If left unattended, high
indebtedness will continue to plague us.
HIGH INDEBTEDNESS IS AN ISSUE THAT Concerted effort by various stakeholders to
EMPLOYERS NEED TO GRAPPLE WITH address the issue would be more impactful.
High indebtedness persists despite rigorous For example, employers could explore
efforts to enhance financial literacy. plausible solutions to solve the challenge
Intervention is needed to help MWAs of high indebtedness among MWAs.
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 55
APPENDICES
Feeling Comfortable
Demographic
Savings, Retirement
Financial Resilience
Debt Management
and Investment
Spending
Position
Overall
Overall
Meet
Gender 0.07 0.00 0.45 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.02
Marital Status 0.10 0.05 0.22 0.42 0.05 0.03 0.22 0.14
Employment Type 0.00 0.00 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Type of Industry 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Highest
0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Qualification
Income range 0.00 0.12 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Number of
0.01 0.00 0.23 0.13 0.11 0.09 0.36 0.13
Dependants
Note: The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 57
Appendix 2: Spending
I assess my affordability
something
I want
items
plan
Whole Sample 6.31 6.92 7.8 7.41 7.61 5.27
Male 6.08 6.79 7.75 7.37 7.58 5.31
Gender
Female 6.52 7.04 7.84 7.46 7.63 5.23
20-29 6.33 6.96 7.85 7.50 7.65 4.96
30-39 6.27 6.89 7.69 7.29 7.55 5.25
Age
40-49 6.26 6.88 7.87 7.40 7.60 5.44
50-59 6.50 7.00 7.92 7.69 7.73 5.48
Malay/Bumiputera 6.39 7.05 7.83 7.45 7.68 5.34
Chinese 5.93 6.44 7.64 7.14 7.49 4.97
Ethnic
Indian 6.32 6.90 7.95 7.73 7.29 5.27
Others 6.73 7.01 7.78 7.47 7.55 5.38
Single 6.23 6.79 7.78 7.42 7.49 4.98
Marital
Married 6.33 6.95 7.82 7.42 7.64 5.35
Status
Divorce 6.65 7.13 7.43 7.30 7.64 5.51
No Dependants 6.20 6.81 7.73 7.35 7.41 5.06
1 6.40 6.89 7.63 7.32 7.61 5.15
2 6.27 7.03 7.91 7.52 7.78 5.24
Number of
3 6.41 6.95 7.78 7.46 7.66 5.28
Dependants
4 6.37 7.00 7.98 7.40 7.69 5.71
5 6.36 6.85 7.82 7.41 7.76 5.42
6 or more 6.56 7.09 7.83 7.59 7.78 5.80
Private 6.16 6.73 7.71 7.27 7.57 5.19
Employment Government 6.46 7.12 7.95 7.57 7.67 5.32
Self-employed 6.34 6.84 7.49 7.34 7.49 5.44
58 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
I assess my affordability
something
I want
items
plan
Finance/
6.36 7.01 8.13 7.63 7.64 5.02
Accounting
Manufacturing 5.95 6.36 7.14 6.98 7.38 5.40
Education 6.32 6.94 7.77 7.38 7.74 5.13
Engineering 6.26 6.79 7.76 7.27 7.70 5.39
Health 6.45 7.19 7.86 7.55 7.68 5.42
Type of Army/Police/
Industry 6.20 6.89 7.44 7.22 7.49 5.24
Enforcement
Agriculture &
6.23 6.77 7.71 7.50 7.74 4.96
Commodity
Property &
6.49 7.33 8.00 7.48 7.56 5.28
Township
Services 6.36 6.98 7.98 7.51 7.64 5.47
Others 6.27 6.66 7.43 7.24 7.34 5.38
Non-Executive 6.40 7.04 7.78 7.49 7.62 5.33
Executive 6.27 6.81 7.89 7.39 7.67 5.13
Designation Manager 6.07 6.76 7.76 7.30 7.54 5.26
Senior
6.55 7.02 7.87 7.60 7.75 5.26
Management
Less than 2000 6.19 6.86 7.66 7.40 7.55 5.33
2001 to 4000 6.43 6.92 7.76 7.39 7.52 5.21
investment/business
When I have excess
retirement
retirement
spending
Whole Sample 7.11 7.13 6.88 7.17 7.44 5.91
Male 6.96 7.09 6.96 7.06 7.30 6.14
Gender
Female 7.25 7.17 6.80 7.26 7.57 5.69
20-29 7.30 6.97 6.33 7.00 7.51 5.86
30-39 6.96 6.88 6.69 6.91 7.30 5.78
Age
40-49 7.09 7.30 7.27 7.32 7.50 5.94
50-59 7.31 7.79 7.51 7.89 7.64 6.30
Malay/Bumiputera 7.18 7.18 6.84 7.18 7.43 5.92
Chinese 7.01 7.06 7.11 7.26 7.52 6.17
Ethnic
Indian 7.06 6.97 6.61 6.85 7.27 5.41
Others 6.68 7.05 6.93 7.10 7.50 5.54
Single 7.22 6.97 6.66 6.96 7.45 5.82
Marital Status Married 7.09 7.18 6.95 7.22 7.43 5.93
Divorce 6.75 7.25 6.59 7.50 7.49 5.97
No Dependants 7.20 7.02 6.73 7.06 7.46 5.86
1 6.91 7.04 6.78 6.91 7.22 5.87
2 7.29 7.25 7.10 7.37 7.57 5.81
Number of
3 7.04 7.17 6.75 7.11 7.41 5.85
Dependants
4 7.09 7.29 7.02 7.24 7.33 6.09
5 6.83 7.26 7.07 7.42 7.49 6.13
6 or more 6.91 7.06 6.98 7.28 7.51 6.07
Private 6.97 7.03 6.93 7.09 7.37 5.90
Employment Government 7.29 7.29 6.89 7.25 7.57 5.84
Self-employed 6.91 6.86 6.53 7.15 7.08 6.29
60 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
investment/business
When I have excess
retirement
retirement
spending
Finance/Accounting 7.37 7.42 7.56 7.48 7.70 6.27
Manufacturing 6.33 6.42 6.30 6.92 7.18 5.78
Education 7.08 7.08 6.77 7.10 7.44 5.74
Engineering 7.13 7.13 6.80 7.08 7.38 6.01
Health 7.29 7.27 6.61 7.41 7.53 5.78
Army/Police/
Type of Industry Enforcement 7.22 7.14 6.23 7.30 7.38 5.61
Agriculture &
7.29 7.10 7.43 7.09 7.31 6.12
Commodity
Property & Township 7.16 7.39 6.78 7.06 7.38 5.69
Services 7.30 7.24 7.04 7.15 7.53 5.88
normally pay my
excess money, I
payment) of my
instalments on
I ALWAYS pay
5% (minimum
I pay my loan
When I have
credit card
more than
debts
time
Whole Sample 7.85 6.82 7.69
Male 7.68 6.54 7.69
Gender
Female 8.01 7.09 7.70
20-29 7.69 6.83 7.58
30-39 7.81 6.88 7.69
Age
40-49 7.95 6.81 7.68
50-59 8.01 6.66 7.88
Malay/Bumiputera 7.79 6.65 7.79
Chinese 8.10 7.47 7.51
Ethnic
Indian 7.73 6.85 7.45
Others 7.83 6.61 7.51
Single 7.81 7.02 7.56
Marital Status Married 7.86 6.78 7.74
Divorce 7.72 6.43 7.59
No Dependants 7.75 6.88 7.54
1 8.09 7.06 7.58
2 8.17 7.03 7.85
Number of
3 7.65 6.68 7.74
Dependants
4 7.78 6.58 7.78
5 7.71 6.40 7.82
6 or more 7.82 6.82 7.92
Private 7.87 6.86 7.62
Employment Government 8.03 6.87 7.79
Self-employed 6.76 6.38 7.57
62 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
normally pay my
excess money, I
payment) of my
instalments on
I ALWAYS pay
5% (minimum
I pay my loan
When I have
credit card
more than
debts
time
Finance/Accounting 8.39 7.32 7.73
Manufacturing 7.44 6.59 7.35
Education 7.82 6.97 7.77
Engineering 7.90 6.63 7.91
Health 7.86 6.84 7.74
Type of Industry
Army/Police/Enforcement 7.59 6.27 7.74
Agriculture & Commodity 7.75 6.17 7.67
Property & Township 8.10 6.83 7.53
Services 7.94 6.89 7.83
Others 7.08 6.38 7.35
Non-Executive 7.67 6.68 7.69
Executive 8.15 6.94 7.72
Designation
Manager 8.11 7.11 7.68
Senior Management 8.16 7.22 7.98
Less than 2000 7.17 6.72 7.51
2001 to 4000 7.83 6.73 7.65
4001 to 6000 8.01 6.66 7.74
Monthly Income
6001 to 8000 8.21 6.98 7.90
8001 to 10000 8.09 7.41 7.71
More than 10000 8.62 7.67 7.95
Central Region 8.11 7.04 7.65
East Coast Region 7.48 6.81 7.64
Region Northern Region 7.78 6.70 7.78
Southern Region 7.67 6.80 7.62
East Malaysia 7.87 6.48 7.84
FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS 63
(Negative Statement),
% scored more than 5
essential goods
Borrow to buy
needs
(Negative Statement),
% scored more than 5
essential goods
Borrow to buy
needs
retrenched, % scored
months’ expenses if
scored more than 5
bills of RM2,500, %
Ability to cover 3
for emergency,
more than 5
retrenched, % scored
months’ expenses if
scored more than 5
bills of RM2,500, %
Ability to cover 3
for emergency,
more than 5
REFERENCES
ANZ Banking Group Limited (2018). Financial Wellbeing, a Survey of Adult in New Zealand
Asian Institute of Finance (2015). Finance Matters. Understanding Gen Y. Bridging the
Knowledge Gap of Malaysia’s Millennial
68 FINANCIAL BEHAVIOUR AND STATE OF FINANCIAL WELL-BEING OF MALAYSIAN WORKING ADULTS
THE TEAM
Patrons
Puan Nor Fazleen Zakaria, General Manager Operations
Puan Nor Akmar Yaakub, Head of Financial Education Department
Advisors:
Professor Dr Zainuddin Awang, Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin (UniSZA)
Associate Professor Dr Cordelia Mason (Co-Author), Universiti Kuala Lumpur (UniKL)
Associate Professor Dr Hawati Janor, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM)
Associate Professor Dr Mohamad Fazli Sabri, Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM)
Assistant Professor Dr Maya Puspa Rahman, International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM)
Associate Professor Dr Vinitha Guptan, Saito University College
Research Assistants
Mohd Azril Khairul Anuar
Ikhwan Haziq Aminudin
Siti Najihah Mohamed Azlan
ISBN 978-983-44004-9-1
9 789834 400491