Hasil Analisa Ragam

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JD1

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 18,000 10 1,800 . .
Intercept 675,000 1 675,000 . .
ULG 18,000 2 9,000 . .
K ,000 2 ,000 . .
D ,000 2 ,000 . .
K*D ,000 4 ,000 . .
Error ,000 16 ,000
Total 693,000 27
Corrected Total 18,000 26

a. R Squared = 1,000 (Adjusted R Squared = 1,000)

Karena datanya sama lihat pada data

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JD2

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 18,222 10 1,822 16,400 ,000
Intercept 972,000 1 972,000 8748,000 ,000
ULG 16,222 2 8,111 73,000 ,000
K ,222 2 ,111 1,000 ,390
D ,667 2 ,333 3,000 ,078
K*D 1,111 4 ,278 2,500 ,084
Error 1,778 16 ,111
Total 992,000 27
Corrected Total 20,000 26

a. R Squared = ,911 (Adjusted R Squared = ,856)

Ket : tdk ada interaksi nyata, K tdk berpengaruh nyata, D tdk berpengaruh nyata
Karena nilai sig ≥ 0,05
 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JD3

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 17,259 10 1,726 6,319 ,001
Intercept 1213,370 1 1213,370 4442,169 ,000
ULG 14,296 2 7,148 26,169 ,000
K ,963 2 ,481 1,763 ,203
D ,963 2 ,481 1,763 ,203
K*D 1,037 4 ,259 ,949 ,461
Error 4,370 16 ,273
Total 1235,000 27
Corrected Total 21,630 26

a. R Squared = ,798 (Adjusted R Squared = ,672)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JD4

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 12,889a 10 1,289 6,629 ,000

Intercept 1452,000 1 1452,000 7467,429 ,000
ULG 10,889 2 5,444 28,000 ,000
K 1,556 2 ,778 4,000 ,039
D ,222 2 ,111 ,571 ,576
K*D ,222 4 ,056 ,286 ,883
Error 3,111 16 ,194
Total 1468,000 27
Corrected Total 16,000 26

a. R Squared = ,806 (Adjusted R Squared = ,684)

 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JD5

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 17,704 10 1,770 13,186 ,000
Intercept 1760,148 1 1760,148 13110,069 ,000
ULG 12,519 2 6,259 46,621 ,000
K 2,296 2 1,148 8,552 ,003
D 1,407 2 ,704 5,241 ,018
K*D 1,481 4 ,370 2,759 ,064
Error 2,148 16 ,134
Total 1780,000 27
Corrected Total 19,852 26

a. R Squared = ,892 (Adjusted R Squared = ,824)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JD6

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 18,000a 10 1,800 . .

Intercept 675,000 1 675,000 . .
ULG 18,000 2 9,000 . .
K ,000 2 ,000 . .
D ,000 2 ,000 . .
K*D ,000 4 ,000 . .
Error ,000 16 ,000
Total 693,000 27
Corrected Total 18,000 26

a. R Squared = 1,000 (Adjusted R Squared = 1,000)

Cek datanya sama dg JD1?

 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JD7

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 14,148 10 1,415 8,042 ,000
Intercept 960,037 1 960,037 5457,053 ,000
ULG 12,519 2 6,259 35,579 ,000
K ,296 2 ,148 ,842 ,449
D 1,185 2 ,593 3,368 ,060
K*D ,148 4 ,037 ,211 ,929
Error 2,815 16 ,176
Total 977,000 27
Corrected Total 16,963 26

a. R Squared = ,834 (Adjusted R Squared = ,730)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JD8

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 19,037a 10 1,904 6,632 ,000

Intercept 1213,370 1 1213,370 4227,226 ,000
ULG 16,074 2 8,037 28,000 ,000
K ,963 2 ,481 1,677 ,218
D 1,407 2 ,704 2,452 ,118
K*D ,593 4 ,148 ,516 ,725
Error 4,593 16 ,287
Total 1237,000 27
Corrected Total 23,630 26

a. R Squared = ,806 (Adjusted R Squared = ,684)

 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JD9

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 12,889 10 1,289 6,629 ,000
Intercept 1452,000 1 1452,000 7467,429 ,000
ULG 10,889 2 5,444 28,000 ,000
K 1,556 2 ,778 4,000 ,039
D ,222 2 ,111 ,571 ,576
K*D ,222 4 ,056 ,286 ,883
Error 3,111 16 ,194
Total 1468,000 27
Corrected Total 16,000 26

a. R Squared = ,806 (Adjusted R Squared = ,684)

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS1
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) KD (J) KD J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

K1D1 K1D2 1,3333* ,35573 ,035 ,0678 2,5988

K1D3 1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -,2655 2,2655

K2D1 1,3333* ,35573 ,035 ,0678 2,5988

K2D2 1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -,2655 2,2655

K2D3 1,3333* ,35573 ,035 ,0678 2,5988

K3D1 1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -,2655 2,2655

K3D2 1,3333* ,35573 ,035 ,0678 2,5988

K3D3 1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -,2655 2,2655

*
K1D2 K1D1 -1,3333 ,35573 ,035 -2,5988 -,0678
K1D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D2 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D1 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K1D3 K1D1 -1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -2,2655 ,2655
 K1D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K2D1 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K2D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D3 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K3D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K3D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
*
K2D1 K1D1 -1,3333 ,35573 ,035 -2,5988 -,0678
K1D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K1D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D2 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D1 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D2 K1D1 -1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -2,2655 ,2655
K1D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K1D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D1 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K2D3 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K3D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K3D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
*
K2D3 K1D1 -1,3333 ,35573 ,035 -2,5988 -,0678
K1D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K1D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D2 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D1 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D1 K1D1 -1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -2,2655 ,2655
K1D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K1D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D1 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K2D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D3 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
K3D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988
 K3D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D2 K1D1 -1,3333* ,35573 ,035 -2,5988 -,0678
K1D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K1D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K2D2 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K2D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655
K3D1 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D3 -,3333 ,35573 ,987 -1,5988 ,9322
K3D3 K1D1 -1,0000 ,35573 ,186 -2,2655 ,2655

K1D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988

K1D3 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655

K2D1 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988

K2D2 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655

K2D3 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988

K3D1 ,0000 ,35573 1,000 -1,2655 1,2655

K3D2 ,3333 ,35573 ,987 -,9322 1,5988

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,190.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JS1
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

KD N 1 2

K1D2 3 ,0000
K2D1 3 ,0000
K2D3 3 ,0000
K3D2 3 ,0000
K1D3 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D1 3 ,3333 ,3333
K2D2 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D3 3 ,3333 ,3333
K1D1 3 1,3333
Sig. ,987 ,186
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are
displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,190.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS2

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 13,481a 10 1,348 2,173 ,080

Intercept 19,593 1 19,593 31,582 ,000
ULG 1,407 2 ,704 1,134 ,346
K 1,407 2 ,704 1,134 ,346
D 6,741 2 3,370 5,433 ,016
K*D 3,926 4 ,981 1,582 ,227
Error 9,926 16 ,620
Total 43,000 27
Corrected Total 23,407 26

a. R Squared = ,576 (Adjusted R Squared = ,311)

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS2
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) D (J) D J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

D1 D2 -,6667 ,37130 ,203 -1,6247 ,2914

D3 -1,2222* ,37130 ,012 -2,1803 -,2642

D2 D1 ,6667 ,37130 ,203 -,2914 1,6247
 D3 -,5556 ,37130 ,319 -1,5136 ,4025
D3 D1 1,2222* ,37130 ,012 ,2642 2,1803

D2 ,5556 ,37130 ,319 -,4025 1,5136

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,620.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JS2
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

D N 1 2

D1 9 ,2222
D2 9 ,8889 ,8889
D3 9 1,4444
Sig. ,203 ,319

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,620.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS3

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 8,889 10 ,889 ,800 ,632
Intercept 21,333 1 21,333 19,200 ,000
ULG ,222 2 ,111 ,100 ,905
K 2,889 2 1,444 1,300 ,300
D 2,667 2 1,333 1,200 ,327
K*D 3,111 4 ,778 ,700 ,603
Error 17,778 16 1,111
Total 48,000 27
Corrected Total 26,667 26

a. R Squared = ,333 (Adjusted R Squared = -,083)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS4

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 3,333a 10 ,333 ,571 ,814

Intercept 5,333 1 5,333 9,143 ,008
ULG ,667 2 ,333 ,571 ,576
K 1,556 2 ,778 1,333 ,291
D ,000 2 ,000 ,000 1,000
K*D 1,111 4 ,278 ,476 ,753
Error 9,333 16 ,583
Total 18,000 27
Corrected Total 12,667 26

a. R Squared = ,263 (Adjusted R Squared = -,197)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS5

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 6,370a 10 ,637 1,658 ,177

Intercept 4,481 1 4,481 11,663 ,004
ULG ,519 2 ,259 ,675 ,523
K 4,741 2 2,370 6,169 ,010
D ,074 2 ,037 ,096 ,909
K*D 1,037 4 ,259 ,675 ,619
Error 6,148 16 ,384
Total 17,000 27
Corrected Total 12,519 26

a. R Squared = ,509 (Adjusted R Squared = ,202)

K
 Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS5
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) K (J) K J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

*
K1 K2 ,8889 ,29222 ,020 ,1349 1,6429

K3 ,8889* ,29222 ,020 ,1349 1,6429

*
K2 K1 -,8889 ,29222 ,020 -1,6429 -,1349
K3 ,0000 ,29222 1,000 -,7540 ,7540
K3 K1 -,8889* ,29222 ,020 -1,6429 -,1349

K2 ,0000 ,29222 1,000 -,7540 ,7540

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,384.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JS5
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

K N 1 2

K2 9 ,1111
K3 9 ,1111
K1 9 1,0000
Sig. 1,000 1,000

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,384.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.
 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JS6

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 9,926 10 ,993 1,897 ,122
Intercept 10,704 1 10,704 20,460 ,000
ULG 3,630 2 1,815 3,469 ,056
K ,296 2 ,148 ,283 ,757
D 2,741 2 1,370 2,619 ,104
K*D 3,259 4 ,815 1,558 ,233
Error 8,370 16 ,523
Total 29,000 27
Corrected Total 18,296 26

a. R Squared = ,543 (Adjusted R Squared = ,257)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS7

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 13,926a 10 1,393 2,245 ,072

Intercept 23,148 1 23,148 37,313 ,000
ULG ,074 2 ,037 ,060 ,942
K 3,630 2 1,815 2,925 ,083
D 2,074 2 1,037 1,672 ,219
K*D 8,148 4 2,037 3,284 ,038
Error 9,926 16 ,620
Total 47,000 27
Corrected Total 23,852 26

a. R Squared = ,584 (Adjusted R Squared = ,324)

KD

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS7
Tukey HSD
 Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) KD (J) KD J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

K1D1 K1D2 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211

K1D3 -1,6667 ,64310 ,262 -3,9545 ,6211

K2D1 1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -1,2878 3,2878

K2D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545

K2D3 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211

K3D1 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211

K3D2 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878

K3D3 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545

K1D2 K1D1 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K1D3 -2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -4,2878 ,2878
K2D1 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K2D2 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
K2D3 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K3D1 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K3D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K3D3 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K1D3 K1D1 1,6667 ,64310 ,262 -,6211 3,9545
K1D2 2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -,2878 4,2878
*
K2D1 2,6667 ,64310 ,016 ,3789 4,9545
K2D2 1,3333 ,64310 ,521 -,9545 3,6211
K2D3 2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -,2878 4,2878
K3D1 2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -,2878 4,2878
K3D2 1,6667 ,64310 ,262 -,6211 3,9545
*
K3D3 2,3333 ,64310 ,044 ,0455 4,6211
K2D1 K1D1 -1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -3,2878 1,2878
K1D2 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
*
K1D3 -2,6667 ,64310 ,016 -4,9545 -,3789
K2D2 -1,3333 ,64310 ,521 -3,6211 ,9545
K2D3 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
K3D1 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
K3D2 -1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -3,2878 1,2878
K3D3 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K2D2 K1D1 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K1D2 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K1D3 -1,3333 ,64310 ,521 -3,6211 ,9545
 K2D1 1,3333 ,64310 ,521 -,9545 3,6211
K2D3 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K3D1 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K3D2 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K3D3 1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -1,2878 3,2878
K2D3 K1D1 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K1D2 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K1D3 -2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -4,2878 ,2878
K2D1 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K2D2 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
K3D1 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K3D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K3D3 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K3D1 K1D1 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K1D2 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K1D3 -2,0000 ,64310 ,112 -4,2878 ,2878
K2D1 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K2D2 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211
K2D3 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K3D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K3D3 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K3D2 K1D1 ,0000 ,64310 1,000 -2,2878 2,2878
K1D2 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K1D3 -1,6667 ,64310 ,262 -3,9545 ,6211
K2D1 1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -1,2878 3,2878
K2D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545
K2D3 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K3D1 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211
K3D3 ,6667 ,64310 ,976 -1,6211 2,9545
K3D3 K1D1 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211

K1D2 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545

K1D3 -2,3333* ,64310 ,044 -4,6211 -,0455

K2D1 ,3333 ,64310 1,000 -1,9545 2,6211

K2D2 -1,0000 ,64310 ,814 -3,2878 1,2878

K2D3 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545

K3D1 -,3333 ,64310 1,000 -2,6211 1,9545

K3D2 -,6667 ,64310 ,976 -2,9545 1,6211

Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,620.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JS7
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

KD N 1 2

K2D1 3 ,0000
K3D3 3 ,3333
K1D2 3 ,6667 ,6667
K2D3 3 ,6667 ,6667
K3D1 3 ,6667 ,6667
K1D1 3 1,0000 1,0000
K3D2 3 1,0000 1,0000
K2D2 3 1,3333 1,3333
K1D3 3 2,6667
Sig. ,521 ,112

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,620.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS8

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 11,926 10 1,193 2,800 ,032
Intercept 6,259 1 6,259 14,696 ,001
ULG 1,185 2 ,593 1,391 ,277
K ,519 2 ,259 ,609 ,556
D 3,852 2 1,926 4,522 ,028
K*D 6,370 4 1,593 3,739 ,025
Error 6,815 16 ,426
Total 25,000 27
Corrected Total 18,741 26

a. R Squared = ,636 (Adjusted R Squared = ,409)

KD

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS8
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) KD (J) KD J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

*
K1D1 K1D2 -2,0000 ,53287 ,035 -3,8957 -,1043

K1D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957

K2D1 -1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -2,8957 ,8957

K2D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623

K2D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957

K3D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957

K3D2 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290

K3D3 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623

*
K1D2 K1D1 2,0000 ,53287 ,035 ,1043 3,8957
*
K1D3 2,0000 ,53287 ,035 ,1043 3,8957
K2D1 1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -,8957 2,8957
K2D2 1,6667 ,53287 ,109 -,2290 3,5623
*
K2D3 2,0000 ,53287 ,035 ,1043 3,8957
*
K3D1 2,0000 ,53287 ,035 ,1043 3,8957
K3D2 1,3333 ,53287 ,299 -,5623 3,2290
K3D3 1,6667 ,53287 ,109 -,2290 3,5623
K1D3 K1D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
*
K1D2 -2,0000 ,53287 ,035 -3,8957 -,1043
K2D1 -1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -2,8957 ,8957
 K2D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K2D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K3D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K3D2 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290
K3D3 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K2D1 K1D1 1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -,8957 2,8957
K1D2 -1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -2,8957 ,8957
K1D3 1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -,8957 2,8957
K2D2 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
K2D3 1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -,8957 2,8957
K3D1 1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -,8957 2,8957
K3D2 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K3D3 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
K2D2 K1D1 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K1D2 -1,6667 ,53287 ,109 -3,5623 ,2290
K1D3 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K2D1 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290
K2D3 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K3D1 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K3D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K3D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K2D3 K1D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
*
K1D2 -2,0000 ,53287 ,035 -3,8957 -,1043
K1D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K2D1 -1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -2,8957 ,8957
K2D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K3D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K3D2 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290
K3D3 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K3D1 K1D1 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
*
K1D2 -2,0000 ,53287 ,035 -3,8957 -,1043
K1D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K2D1 -1,0000 ,53287 ,637 -2,8957 ,8957
K2D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K2D3 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957
K3D2 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290
K3D3 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K3D2 K1D1 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
 K1D2 -1,3333 ,53287 ,299 -3,2290 ,5623
K1D3 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
K2D1 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623
K2D2 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K2D3 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
K3D1 ,6667 ,53287 ,932 -1,2290 2,5623
K3D3 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290
K3D3 K1D1 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290

K1D2 -1,6667 ,53287 ,109 -3,5623 ,2290

K1D3 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290

K2D1 -,6667 ,53287 ,932 -2,5623 1,2290

K2D2 ,0000 ,53287 1,000 -1,8957 1,8957

K2D3 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290

K3D1 ,3333 ,53287 ,999 -1,5623 2,2290

K3D2 -,3333 ,53287 ,999 -2,2290 1,5623

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,426.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JS8
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

KD N 1 2

K1D1 3 ,0000
K1D3 3 ,0000
K2D3 3 ,0000
K3D1 3 ,0000
K2D2 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D3 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D2 3 ,6667 ,6667
K2D1 3 1,0000 1,0000
K1D2 3 2,0000
Sig. ,637 ,109

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,426.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JS9

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 11,556a 10 1,156 5,943 ,001

Intercept 8,333 1 8,333 42,857 ,000
ULG ,222 2 ,111 ,571 ,576
K 6,222 2 3,111 16,000 ,000
D 2,667 2 1,333 6,857 ,007
K*D 2,444 4 ,611 3,143 ,044
Error 3,111 16 ,194
Total 23,000 27
Corrected Total 14,667 26

a. R Squared = ,788 (Adjusted R Squared = ,655)

KD

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JS9
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) KD (J) KD J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

*
K1D1 K1D2 1,6667 ,36004 ,006 ,3858 2,9475

K1D3 ,6667 ,36004 ,652 -,6142 1,9475

*
K2D1 2,0000 ,36004 ,001 ,7192 3,2808

K2D2 2,0000* ,36004 ,001 ,7192 3,2808

 K2D3 1,6667* ,36004 ,006 ,3858 2,9475
*
K3D1 1,6667 ,36004 ,006 ,3858 2,9475

K3D2 2,0000* ,36004 ,001 ,7192 3,2808

*
K3D3 1,3333 ,36004 ,038 ,0525 2,6142
*
K1D2 K1D1 -1,6667 ,36004 ,006 -2,9475 -,3858
K1D3 -1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -2,2808 ,2808
K2D1 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K2D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K2D3 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D1 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K3D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K1D3 K1D1 -,6667 ,36004 ,652 -1,9475 ,6142
K1D2 1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -,2808 2,2808
*
K2D1 1,3333 ,36004 ,038 ,0525 2,6142
*
K2D2 1,3333 ,36004 ,038 ,0525 2,6142
K2D3 1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -,2808 2,2808
K3D1 1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -,2808 2,2808
*
K3D2 1,3333 ,36004 ,038 ,0525 2,6142
K3D3 ,6667 ,36004 ,652 -,6142 1,9475
*
K2D1 K1D1 -2,0000 ,36004 ,001 -3,2808 -,7192
K1D2 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
*
K1D3 -1,3333 ,36004 ,038 -2,6142 -,0525
K2D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K2D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D1 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D3 -,6667 ,36004 ,652 -1,9475 ,6142
*
K2D2 K1D1 -2,0000 ,36004 ,001 -3,2808 -,7192
K1D2 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
*
K1D3 -1,3333 ,36004 ,038 -2,6142 -,0525
K2D1 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K2D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D1 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D3 -,6667 ,36004 ,652 -1,9475 ,6142
*
K2D3 K1D1 -1,6667 ,36004 ,006 -2,9475 -,3858
 K1D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K1D3 -1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -2,2808 ,2808
K2D1 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K2D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K3D1 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K3D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
*
K3D1 K1D1 -1,6667 ,36004 ,006 -2,9475 -,3858
K1D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K1D3 -1,0000 ,36004 ,196 -2,2808 ,2808
K2D1 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K2D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K2D3 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K3D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142
K3D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
*
K3D2 K1D1 -2,0000 ,36004 ,001 -3,2808 -,7192
K1D2 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K1D3 -1,3333* ,36004 ,038 -2,6142 -,0525
K2D1 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K2D2 ,0000 ,36004 1,000 -1,2808 1,2808
K2D3 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D1 -,3333 ,36004 ,988 -1,6142 ,9475
K3D3 -,6667 ,36004 ,652 -1,9475 ,6142
*
K3D3 K1D1 -1,3333 ,36004 ,038 -2,6142 -,0525

K1D2 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142

K1D3 -,6667 ,36004 ,652 -1,9475 ,6142

K2D1 ,6667 ,36004 ,652 -,6142 1,9475

K2D2 ,6667 ,36004 ,652 -,6142 1,9475

K2D3 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142

K3D1 ,3333 ,36004 ,988 -,9475 1,6142

K3D2 ,6667 ,36004 ,652 -,6142 1,9475

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,194.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets
 JS9
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

KD N 1 2 3

K2D1 3 ,0000
K2D2 3 ,0000
K3D2 3 ,0000
K1D2 3 ,3333 ,3333
K2D3 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D1 3 ,3333 ,3333
K3D3 3 ,6667 ,6667
K1D3 3 1,3333 1,3333
K1D1 3 2,0000
Sig. ,652 ,196 ,652

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,194.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB1

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 23,704 10 2,370 3,436 ,014
Intercept 7,259 1 7,259 10,523 ,005
ULG 5,630 2 2,815 4,081 ,037
K 7,185 2 3,593 5,208 ,018
D 3,630 2 1,815 2,631 ,103
K*D 7,259 4 1,815 2,631 ,073
Error 11,037 16 ,690
Total 42,000 27
Corrected Total 34,741 26

a. R Squared = ,682 (Adjusted R Squared = ,484)

 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects
Dependent Variable: JB2

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 15,481a 10 1,548 ,816 ,619

Intercept 31,148 1 31,148 16,410 ,001
ULG 4,963 2 2,481 1,307 ,298
K 7,185 2 3,593 1,893 ,183
D ,074 2 ,037 ,020 ,981
K*D 3,259 4 ,815 ,429 ,785
Error 30,370 16 1,898
Total 77,000 27
Corrected Total 45,852 26

a. R Squared = ,338 (Adjusted R Squared = -,076)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB3

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 27,333a 10 2,733 2,852 ,030

Intercept 21,333 1 21,333 22,261 ,000
ULG 12,667 2 6,333 6,609 ,008
K 6,889 2 3,444 3,594 ,051
D 2,889 2 1,444 1,507 ,251
K*D 4,889 4 1,222 1,275 ,321
Error 15,333 16 ,958
Total 64,000 27
Corrected Total 42,667 26

a. R Squared = ,641 (Adjusted R Squared = ,416)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB4

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 10,593a 10 1,059 2,080 ,092

Intercept 7,259 1 7,259 14,255 ,002
ULG 7,185 2 3,593 7,055 ,006
K 1,185 2 ,593 1,164 ,337
D ,519 2 ,259 ,509 ,610
K*D 1,704 4 ,426 ,836 ,522
Error 8,148 16 ,509
Total 26,000 27
Corrected Total 18,741 26

a. R Squared = ,565 (Adjusted R Squared = ,293)

ULG

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JB4
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

1,00 2,00 ,3333 ,33641 ,593 -,5347 1,2014

3,00 -,8889* ,33641 ,044 -1,7569 -,0209

2,00 1,00 -,3333 ,33641 ,593 -1,2014 ,5347
*
3,00 -1,2222 ,33641 ,006 -2,0903 -,3542
3,00 1,00 ,8889* ,33641 ,044 ,0209 1,7569
*
2,00 1,2222 ,33641 ,006 ,3542 2,0903

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,509.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JB4
a,b
Tukey HSD

ULG N Subset
 1 2

2,00 9 ,0000
1,00 9 ,3333
3,00 9 1,2222
Sig. ,593 1,000

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,509.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB5

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 18,889a 10 1,889 2,194 ,078

Intercept 21,333 1 21,333 24,774 ,000
ULG 8,222 2 4,111 4,774 ,024
K 2,000 2 1,000 1,161 ,338
D 2,000 2 1,000 1,161 ,338
K*D 6,667 4 1,667 1,935 ,154
Error 13,778 16 ,861
Total 54,000 27
Corrected Total 32,667 26

a. R Squared = ,578 (Adjusted R Squared = ,315)

ULG

JB5
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

ULG N 1 2

3,00 9 ,1111
2,00 9 1,2222 1,2222
1,00 9 1,3333
Sig. ,054 ,965

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,861.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB6

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 5,037a 10 ,504 1,110 ,411

Intercept 3,704 1 3,704 8,163 ,011
ULG 2,074 2 1,037 2,286 ,134
K 1,407 2 ,704 1,551 ,242
D ,074 2 ,037 ,082 ,922
K*D 1,481 4 ,370 ,816 ,533
Error 7,259 16 ,454
Total 16,000 27
Corrected Total 12,296 26

a. R Squared = ,410 (Adjusted R Squared = ,041)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB7

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 11,037a 10 1,104 2,433 ,055

Intercept 10,704 1 10,704 23,592 ,000
ULG 6,741 2 3,370 7,429 ,005
K ,074 2 ,037 ,082 ,922
D 1,852 2 ,926 2,041 ,162
K*D 2,370 4 ,593 1,306 ,310
Error 7,259 16 ,454
Total 29,000 27
Corrected Total 18,296 26

a. R Squared = ,603 (Adjusted R Squared = ,355)

ULG

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JB7
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

1,00 2,00 ,6667 ,31753 ,121 -,1527 1,4860

3,00 -,5556 ,31753 ,218 -1,3749 ,2638

2,00 1,00 -,6667 ,31753 ,121 -1,4860 ,1527
*
3,00 -1,2222 ,31753 ,004 -2,0415 -,4029
3,00 1,00 ,5556 ,31753 ,218 -,2638 1,3749
*
2,00 1,2222 ,31753 ,004 ,4029 2,0415

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,454.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JB7
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

ULG N 1 2

2,00 9 ,0000
1,00 9 ,6667 ,6667
3,00 9 1,2222
Sig. ,121 ,218
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are
displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,454.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JB8

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 2,593a 10 ,259 ,757 ,666

Intercept ,926 1 ,926 2,703 ,120
ULG ,519 2 ,259 ,757 ,485
K 1,852 2 ,926 2,703 ,097
D ,074 2 ,037 ,108 ,898
K*D ,148 4 ,037 ,108 ,978
Error 5,481 16 ,343
Total 9,000 27
Corrected Total 8,074 26

a. R Squared = ,321 (Adjusted R Squared = -,103)

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: BB1

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 16,730a 10 1,673 4,650 ,003

Intercept 716,623 1 716,623 1991,643 ,000
ULG 15,436 2 7,718 21,450 ,000
K ,045 2 ,023 ,063 ,939
D ,570 2 ,285 ,792 ,470
K*D ,679 4 ,170 ,472 ,756
Error 5,757 16 ,360
Total 739,110 27
Corrected Total 22,487 26

a. R Squared = ,744 (Adjusted R Squared = ,584)

 Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: BB1
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

1,00 2,00 ,3333 ,28277 ,482 -,3963 1,0630

3,00 1,7444* ,28277 ,000 1,0148 2,4741

2,00 1,00 -,3333 ,28277 ,482 -1,0630 ,3963
*
3,00 1,4111 ,28277 ,000 ,6815 2,1408
*
3,00 1,00 -1,7444 ,28277 ,000 -2,4741 -1,0148

2,00 -1,4111* ,28277 ,000 -2,1408 -,6815

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,360.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

BB1
Tukey HSDa,b

Subset

ULG N 1 2

3,00 9 4,1000
2,00 9 5,5111
1,00 9 5,8444
Sig. 1,000 ,482

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,360.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: BB2

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
a
Corrected Model 9,539 10 ,954 2,688 ,041
Intercept 702,451 1 702,451 1979,640 ,000
ULG 5,544 2 2,772 7,812 ,005
K ,644 2 ,322 ,908 ,425
D 1,626 2 ,813 2,291 ,135
K*D 1,603 4 ,401 1,129 ,380
Error 5,323 15 ,355
Total 734,640 26
Corrected Total 14,862 25

a. R Squared = ,642 (Adjusted R Squared = ,403)

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: BB2
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

1,00 2,00 ,7903* ,28945 ,039 ,0384 1,5421

3,00 1,0778* ,28081 ,004 ,3484 1,8072

*
2,00 1,00 -,7903 ,28945 ,039 -1,5421 -,0384
3,00 ,2875 ,28945 ,592 -,4643 1,0393
3,00 1,00 -1,0778* ,28081 ,004 -1,8072 -,3484

2,00 -,2875 ,28945 ,592 -1,0393 ,4643

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,355.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

BB2
a,b,c
Tukey HSD

ULG N Subset
 1 2

3,00 9 4,8000
2,00 8 5,0875
1,00 9 5,8778
Sig. ,586 1,000

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,355.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 8,640.
b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of
the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not
guaranteed.
c. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: BB3

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 9,279a 10 ,928 3,032 ,047

Intercept 516,873 1 516,873 1688,683 ,000
ULG 7,354 2 3,677 12,014 ,002
K ,525 2 ,263 ,858 ,453
D ,160 2 ,080 ,261 ,775
K*D ,826 4 ,207 ,675 ,624
Error 3,061 10 ,306
Total 624,700 21
Corrected Total 12,340 20

a. R Squared = ,752 (Adjusted R Squared = ,504)

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: BB3
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

1,00 2,00 1,04* ,324 ,023 ,15 1,93

 3,00 1,52* ,309 ,002 ,68 2,37
*
2,00 1,00 -1,04 ,324 ,023 -1,93 -,15
3,00 ,48 ,279 ,246 -,28 1,24
*
3,00 1,00 -1,52 ,309 ,002 -2,37 -,68

2,00 -,48 ,279 ,246 -1,24 ,28

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,306.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

BB3
a,b,c
Tukey HSD

Subset

ULG N 1 2

3,00 9 4,88
2,00 7 5,36
1,00 5 6,40
Sig. ,300 1,000

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,306.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 6,608.
b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of
the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not
guaranteed.
c. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JBB1

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 1431,076a 10 143,108 3,958 ,007

Intercept 12313,613 1 12313,613 340,560 ,000
ULG 257,402 2 128,701 3,560 ,053
K 1106,887 2 553,443 15,307 ,000
D 58,942 2 29,471 ,815 ,460
K*D 7,844 4 1,961 ,054 ,994
Error 578,511 16 36,157
Total 14323,200 27
Corrected Total 2009,587 26

a. R Squared = ,712 (Adjusted R Squared = ,532)

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JBB1
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) K (J) K J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

*
K1 K2 10,1333 2,83459 ,007 2,8192 17,4475

K3 -5,3000 2,83459 ,180 -12,6142 2,0142

*
K2 K1 -10,1333 2,83459 ,007 -17,4475 -2,8192
*
K3 -15,4333 2,83459 ,000 -22,7475 -8,1192
K3 K1 5,3000 2,83459 ,180 -2,0142 12,6142
*
K2 15,4333 2,83459 ,000 8,1192 22,7475

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 36,157.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JBB1
a,b
Tukey HSD

K N Subset
 1 2

K2 9 12,8333
K1 9 22,9667
K3 9 28,2667
Sig. 1,000 ,180

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 36,157.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JBB2

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 5,617a 10 ,562 7,162 ,000

Intercept 1916,898 1 1916,898 24442,149 ,000
ULG ,605 2 ,303 3,858 ,043
K 4,241 2 2,120 27,037 ,000
D ,570 2 ,285 3,632 ,050
K*D ,201 4 ,050 ,642 ,640
Error 1,255 16 ,078
Total 1923,770 27
Corrected Total 6,872 26

a. R Squared = ,817 (Adjusted R Squared = ,703)

ULG

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JBB2
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound
1,00 2,00 -,1778 ,13202 ,391 -,5184 ,1629
*
3,00 -,3667 ,13202 ,034 -,7073 -,0260
2,00 1,00 ,1778 ,13202 ,391 -,1629 ,5184
3,00 -,1889 ,13202 ,349 -,5295 ,1518
*
3,00 1,00 ,3667 ,13202 ,034 ,0260 ,7073

2,00 ,1889 ,13202 ,349 -,1518 ,5295

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,078.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JBB2
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

ULG N 1 2

1,00 9 8,2444
2,00 9 8,4222 8,4222
3,00 9 8,6111
Sig. ,391 ,349

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,078.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JBB2
Tukey HSD
 Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) K (J) K J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

K1 K2 ,6667* ,13202 ,000 ,3260 1,0073

K3 -,2778 ,13202 ,121 -,6184 ,0629

*
K2 K1 -,6667 ,13202 ,000 -1,0073 -,3260
K3 -,9444* ,13202 ,000 -1,2851 -,6038
K3 K1 ,2778 ,13202 ,121 -,0629 ,6184
*
K2 ,9444 ,13202 ,000 ,6038 1,2851

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,078.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JBB2
a,b
Tukey HSD

Subset

K N 1 2

K2 9 7,8889
K1 9 8,5556
K3 9 8,8333
Sig. 1,000 ,121

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,078.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9,000.
b. Alpha = 0,05.

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable: JBB3

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 8,096a 10 ,810 2,341 ,067

Intercept 1725,805 1 1725,805 4989,678 ,000
ULG 2,390 2 1,195 3,455 ,058
K 1,812 2 ,906 2,619 ,106
D 3,133 2 1,567 4,530 ,029
K*D ,409 4 ,102 ,296 ,876
Error 5,188 15 ,346
Total 1781,260 26
Corrected Total 13,285 25

a. R Squared = ,609 (Adjusted R Squared = ,349)

ULG

Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JBB3
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) ULG (J) ULG J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound
*
1,00 2,00 -,7778 ,28577 ,039 -1,5201 -,0355

3,00 -,5333 ,27724 ,166 -1,2535 ,1868

*
2,00 1,00 ,7778 ,28577 ,039 ,0355 1,5201
3,00 ,2444 ,28577 ,676 -,4978 ,9867
3,00 1,00 ,5333 ,27724 ,166 -,1868 1,2535

2,00 -,2444 ,28577 ,676 -,9867 ,4978

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,346.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

D
 Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable: JBB3
Tukey HSD

Mean Difference (I- 95% Confidence Interval

(I) D (J) D J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

D1 D2 ,4764 ,28577 ,250 -,2659 1,2187

D3 -,3569 ,28577 ,444 -1,0992 ,3853

D2 D1 -,4764 ,28577 ,250 -1,2187 ,2659
D3 -,8333* ,27724 ,023 -1,5535 -,1132
D3 D1 ,3569 ,28577 ,444 -,3853 1,0992
*
D2 ,8333 ,27724 ,023 ,1132 1,5535

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,346.
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0,05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

JBB3
a,b,c
Tukey HSD

Subset

D N 1 2

D2 9 7,8111
D1 8 8,2875 8,2875
D3 9 8,6444
Sig. ,244 ,437

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = ,346.
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 8,640.
b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of
the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not
guaranteed.
c. Alpha = 0,05.