Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MARKING SCHEME
EXAMINATION PAPER: ACADEMIC SESSION
2017/2018
Campus Greenwich and International Partners
Faculty Business
Level 6
Duration 3 HOURS
INSTRUCTIONS TO CANDIDATES
Section A is compulsory. Answer Three (3) questions in Section B.
Section A
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 1 of 21
Approved
Background
Das Plc is a thriving supermarket that specialises in the production of South Asian food and
drink and has its headquarters in the UK. The business has fully established a chain of 20
supermarkets across major cities of the UK.
The company seeks to expand its business overseas. The Chief Financial Officer (CFO) has
proposed an expansion to Doaba; the original country from which the company imports its
produce. Das Plc is highly popular in the country of Doaba and has been recognised by the
Government for its ethical values. Das is known to pay its workers a fair wage and is
committed to its custom duty whilst exporting goods.
The Chief Executive Officer welcomes the idea of supplying its produce in Doaba however is
concerned about the increased competition against competitors, a problem that was almost
non-existent for Das in the UK market. The CFO has promised that the business will be able
to distinguish its product ethically by promoting Fairtrade and promises to provide top quality
produce.
Proposed Investment
The CFO’s projected cash flows from the project are presented in the chart in the local
currency of Daoba Rupees (₹):
7.6
7.45
7.4 7.32
7.2
7 6.95
6.8
6.6
6.4
Years
₹ Rupees/£ 82 84 86 86 87
The project is estimated to cost ₹15 million for the initial set up. Capital allowances are
available on the initial investment in plant and machinery on a straight line basis at the rate of
25% per year. A further Initial investment of working capital of ₹500,000 would be financed
by a loan from a local bank, at an annual interest rate of 10%. The bank loan should be paid
off at the end of the 5 year period.
Das plc will remit all its profits to the UK at the end of each year. A double taxation treaty
exists between the UK and Doaba. Doaba tax is 25% while that in the UK is 30% after all
interest and capital allowances are removed. Both countries consider that tax is paid in the
year in which profits are made.
Project Evaluation
Das plc is currently reviewing the capital structure of its company to ensure that it minimises
its cost of capital (WACC). The financial information of the company as at 1 January 2018 is
as follows:
£000
Ordinary shares, £1 each 15,000
Reserves 10,000
7% preference shares, £1 each 10,000
10% irredeemable bonds 15,000
50,000
The current share price of Das Plc on the AIM stock exchange stands at £3.26. The company
has also recently paid out a dividend of 60 p for each share held with a growth rate of 3.5%.
Other sources of finance are preference shares and 10% coupon bonds. The preference shares
have a price of 95p while bonds are at £103.
b) Compute the Net Present Value (NPV) of the 5-year project. (18 marks)
c) Discuss some of the advantages of the NPV investment appraisal method. (10 marks)
(a)
Equity (Ke):
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 3 of 21
Approved
Some students used 25% instead of 30% tax. I don’t penalise them and therefore give
full marks for irredeemable bonds:
b)
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = WACC
Market % cost
Source (000)- Value (₹'000) Cost (£'000)
a) b) (a x b)
Equity (15,000 x £3.26) 48,900 22.5 11,026.95 (2 marks)
Preference (10,000 x
£0.95) 9,500 7.4 703 (2 marks)
Bonds(150 x £103) 15,450 6.8 1,050.6 (2 marks)
73,850 12,779.6 (1 mark)
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 4 of 21
Approved
NPV calculation:
Capital allowances are straight line basis: 25% of 15 million initial investment
= ₹ 3.75 million
Interest of 10% of ₹500,000 = ₹ 50,000 Or ₹ 0.05m
marks
Year 0 1 2 3 4 5
Cashflow (₹ m) 6.95 7.32 7.45 7.59 7.86
Capital Allowances (CAs) (3.75) (3.75) (3.75) (3.75) (3.75) 1
Interest (₹ m) - 10% (0.05 (0
) .05) (0.05) (0.05) (0.05) 2
Taxable Profit 3.15 3.52 3.65 3.79 4.06 1
Doaba Tax 25% (0.79) (0.88) (0.91) (0.95) (1.02) 1
Profit after tax 2.36 2.64 2.74 2.84 3.04 1
Add back CAs 3.75 3.75 3.75 3.75 3.75 1
6.11 6.39 6.49 6.59 6.79
Initial Investment((₹ m ) (15)
Working Capital ((₹ m)- (0.5) 1
Loan 0.5 (0.5) 1
Project Cashflow (15) 6.11 6.39 6.49 6.59 6.29 1
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 5 of 21
Approved
(c) Each point that is well explained gets 2 marks, A max of 10 marks
Takes account of the time value of money
Takes account of the amount and timing of cash flows
Uses cash flows rather than accounting profit
Takes account of all relevant cash flows over the life of the project
Can take account of both conventional and non-conventional Cash flows
Can take account of changes in discount rate during the life of the project
Gives an absolute rather than a relative measure of the desirability of the
project
Can be used to compare all investment projects.
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 6 of 21
Approved
SECTION B
Question Two
May plc has 10 million ordinary shares in issue and its current market price is £8.00 per share.
The company wishes to embark on a major expansion programme and, given its current high
level of financial gearing, has decided to raise new equity of £4 million.
The company is seeking your advice on a number of potential share issue methods:
(i) A rights issue at 25% discount to the current market price;
(ii) A deep discounted rights issue at 50% discount;
(iii) A placing of shares with institutions at 12 ½% discount to the current market price.
Required:
a) Calculate the theoretical ex rights price under options (i) and (ii) (8 marks)
b) An investor, Mr. Khan that owns 1000 shares is concerned that he will not be able to
buy shares in the rights issue given that he feels that he holds enough investment in
May plc shares and would like to diversify to another investment. Demonstrate to Mr.
Khan whether he will lose value if he does not buy shares in the rights issue and advise
him on the best possible outcome. Consider a scenario where the company chooses the
cheaper rights issue option of a deep discount. (5 marks)
c) Calculate the effect on Mr. Khan’s wealth if the company chooses to raise money
through a placing of shares under option (iii). (5 marks)
d) Comment on why UK insurance companies and pension funds may prefer companies,
in which they invest, to have rights issues rather than placings to raise new equity
capital. (2 mark)
a) Option 1:
Rights issue price: £8 * 0.75 = £6 (1 mark)
£4m/ £6 = 0.66m shares
Number of rights = 10m / 0.66m shares = 15 (1 mark)
For every 15 shares an old holder had he has the right to get one additional share in
issue,
Option 2:
Deep discount:
Price of issue: £8 * 0.5 = £4 (1 mark)
£4m/ £4 = 1m shares
Number of rights = 10m :1m = 10 old shares to 1 new share. (1 mark)
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 7 of 21
Approved
Sell rights
Cash from sale = 100 * 3.636 = £363.6 (1 mark)
Value of shares after rights issue = 1000 shares * 7.636 = 7636
Net wealth = £364 + 7636 = £8000 (1 mark)
Doing Nothing: Only gives 1000 shares *7.636 = 7636 as net wealth (1 mark)
The wealth effect when he sells rights or buys shares in the rights issue is all adding up to
£8000. However, he will lose out from doing nothing.
d) A rights issue will avoid the dilution of wealth unlike the placing of shares.
(2 mark)
Question Three
Tepo Productions, a digital printing company, currently has 1.5 million 50p ordinary shares in
issue, which are listed on the Alternative Investment Market (AIM), where they are currently
priced at 150p. £1 million 7% debentures make up the remainder of the company’s capital
structure. The debentures, which are redeemable in exactly three years, are also quoted on
AIM. They are currently quoted at £105. The company does not have access to a quoted beta
factor for its shares but, from experience, you consider that shares in Tepo Productions are on
average about 15% more volatile than the market. The company pays tax at the rate of 25%.
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 8 of 21
Approved
a) Calculate Tepo Productions weighted average cost of capital using market values
Assume that the current risk free rate of return is 3% and the market rate of return is
10% (10 marks)
b) Describe how the Dividend Valuation Model can be used to estimate a company’s cost
of capital. (2 marks)
c) What practical problems are associated with calculating the WACC (8 marks)
Cost of equity
Ke = Rf + β(Rm - Rf)
Ke = 3 + 1.15(10 -3) = 11.05% - 2marks
5+ .04 x2 = 5.17 %
.04+4.66
It would, therefore, appear to be most applicable to situations where investors obtain the
majority of their return from dividends rather than share price growth.
c. Calculating the different elements of finance is not always easy, eg, certain securities may
be traded irregularly and it is difficult to determine a market price such as the ordinary shares
of a private company. A similar problem may also arise with obtaining the market value of
bonds, particularly convertible bonds.
Leasing can also present problems when trying to calculate the average cost of capital. Many
leases provide finance on a medium to long term basis and should therefore be included in the
cost of capital calculations, and it is often difficult to accurately determine the capital value of
lease payments.
Another complication can relate to debt where interest payments are the subject of swap
agreements with the main issue being whether the cost of capital of the debt should reflect the
interest rate when the loan was first raised or the interest rate agreed in the swap.
The accuracy of the calculated cost of capital depends very much on the reliability and
applicability of the various different models used.
Difficulties also arise when determining which sources of finance should be included in the
weighted average cost of capital (WACC).
The usual rule is that if finance is being used to fund the long term investments of a company
it should be included in the calculations, and short term financing arrangements such as trade
creditors would not be included.
However, if a short term method of finance, such as a bank overdraft, was being used on an
ongoing basis it could be argued that it is being used to finance long term assets and therefore
should be included in the weighted average cost calculations.
Another problem is deciding what weightings should be attached to each different source of
finance.
Difficulties in finding the market values of securities will also have an impact, through the
weightings on the cost of capital that are applied to the different sources of finance. Market
values are usually preferred to book values. However market values may be hard to find or in
the case of bank loans may simply not exist.
Additionally problems may be experienced by companies that have raised debt finance in
foreign currencies, as the value of these debts will have to be translated into sterling against
an often unpredictable foreign currency market.
Question Four
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 10 of 21
Approved
The following information provides the returns of Sonia plc shares and the market index
returns respectively over the last eight quarters:
Dividends of Sonia plc in the last five years have increased at a rate of 1%. The current
dividend on 7th October 2017 is 84p.
The rate of return of the risk-free rate is 0.9% and the correlation coefficient between the
shares of Sonia plc and the market is 0.2.
a) Calculate the required rate of return of Sonia plc using the Capital Asset Pricing Model
(CAPM) (12 marks)
Total 20 Marks
a)
2
βs = (σs σm ρs, m)/ σ m
= (1.62 × 1.63 x 0.2)/2.66 = 0.1985 (2 marks)
= 0.93% (2 marks)
(Total marks: 12)
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 12 of 21
Approved
Question Five
Detailed information of a 10-year government bond is listed in the table below. As a financial
advisor you are considering to recommend to your clients whether to investment in this bond.
Required:
(a) Explain why there is an inverse relationship between interest rates and bond
prices.
(3 marks)
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 13 of 21
Approved
(c) Calculate the market price of the 10-year bond above at the time of issue
(5 marks)
(d) Calculate the market price of the bond if the yield to maturity is reduced by
0.5% in one year’s time.
(5 marks)
(e) Based on (c) and (d), what will the total return of this bond be after one year’s
time?
(3 marks)
(Total 20 marks)
Question 5
a)
Higher interest rates reduce the present value of cash inflows associated with bond and hence
reduce its prices. (3 marks)
b)
The return on a coupon bond comes from two sources:
– The difference between the purchase price and the principal value.
– Periodic coupon payments
(4 marks)
PV of coupon: 6*7.538
45.23 (2 marks)
d)
reduce by 0.5% implies 5.5% -->5.0%
PV of coupon: 6*7.108
42.65 (2 marks)
e)
Total return:
=9.0% (1 mark)
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 15 of 21
Approved
Question Six
The following data comes from the financial statements of Umbrellas Ltd (a retail store) for
the year ended 31st December 2017.
Balance sheet
£ million £ million
Non –current assets
Tangible assets 5,500
Longrun investments 20 5520
Current assets
Inventory 620
Accounts Receivable 60
Investments- Short-term 55
Cash at Bank 32 767
3700
Earnings per share over the last thirteen years has grown from £0.30 to £2.10. Over the
same period the company has steadily increased the dividend payable from £0.20 to £0.80
per share. Umbrellas has also provided the following additional information:
The total market value of the company’s shares as at 31st December 2017 was £7
billion.
The average equity premium is currently 10%. The current risk free rate of return is
6% and Umbrellas’ beta is 0.7.
The debentures are currently trading at £104.
The balance sheet shows the nominal value of the debentures.
The buildings are undervalued in the balance sheet by £50 million.
It is expected that 20% of the accounts receivable shown in the balance sheet will be
bad debts.
It is estimated that £40 million of the inventory shown in the balance sheet will prove
to be unsaleable.
The short-term investments have a current market value of £75 million.
The average price earnings ratio for other similar supermarkets is currently 15.
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 16 of 21
Approved
a) Calculate the value of Umbrellas Ltd using a net asset valuation method. 8 marks
b) Calculate the value of Umbrellas Ltd , using a price earnings based method. 3 marks
c)Explain three disadvantages for each of the methods in (a) and (b) above. 9 marks
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 17 of 21
Approved
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 18 of 21
Approved
DIVIDEND MODELS
Constant dividend
Ke = Div
MV (Po)
Dividend Growth
Ke = D1 +g
MV (Po)
MV (Po) = D1/(ke – g)
Standard Deviation
σx = √Σ((xi – x̄ )2pi)
i=1
n
Ri
S tan dard deviation, σ=
√ ∑(Ri -
i=1
n
{ R̄ )2
¿
rj = rf + ß(rm – rf)
Beta of a Security
βj = (σj σm ρjm)/σm2
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 20 of 21
Approved
May 2018
Finance – EXAM - Marking Scheme
FINA1027
Page 21 of 21