You are on page 1of 5

J Mater Cycles Waste Manag (2001) 3:88–92 © Springer-Verlag 2001

SPECIAL FEATURE: ORIGINAL ARTICLE Chemical Feedstock Recycling (2)

Eiko Obuchi · Masaki Suyama · Katsuyuki Nakano

Decomposition of mixed plastics consisting of polypropylene and


polyethylene terephthalate into oils over titania/silica catalysts

Received: July 19, 2000 / Accepted: October 20, 2000

Abstract as solid fuel, 0.4% is used as liquefaction and/or blast


The catalytic decomposition of mixed plastics consisting of furnace feed stock, 16.7% is used as fuel for power genera-
polypropylene (PP) and polyethylene terephthalate (PET) tion, and 14.0% is being incinerated for thermal utilization.
has been investigated over titania/silica catalysts at 698 K. Of the remaining 55.8% of waste plastics, 22.5% is in-
The yield of oil produced was about 70%, and the large cinerated and 33.3% is sent to landfill disposal sites.
amounts of C18+ hydrocarbons this contained was from the Homogeneous plastics in industrial wastes can be used
aromatics in PET. Gas was also produced, including C3–C5 after regeneration and easily converted into monomers.
hydrocarbons. The carbon-number fractions in the oil was However, because of the heterogeneity and dirtiness of
influenced by the PET/(PP + PET) ratios and the catalyst waste plastics in municipal waste, the cost involved in sep-
weight. The titania/silica catalysts could be used repeatedly, arating, collecting, transforming, and washing it is very high,
and after they had been fouled, could be regenerated. From and so the proportion which is recycled is low. Although in
the Fourier Transform Infrared (FT–IR) spectroscopic data 1997, the Japanese government decided on guidelines to
of adsorbed pyridine on the catalyst surface, most of the convert thermoplastic resin into fuel oils, only 10 000 tons
acid sites of the titania/silica catalysts were found to be of waste plastics have been converted into fuel or blast
Lewis sites where the hydride abstracted from PP pyroly- furnace fuels to date (all the statistics given above were
sates react with PET pyrolysates to form oil and gas. obtained from the Plastic Waste Management Institute’s
homepage.) At present, there are a few operational plants
Key words Polypropylene · Polyethylene terephthalate that treat polyolefin resin, but the process is far from
(PET) · Oil production · TiO2/SiO2 catalyst · Lewis acid site perfect. It is very complicated, and the catalyst used is deac-
tivated owing to the deposition of coke-like substances on
the catalyst surface. In addition, since chlorine in polyvinyl
Introduction chloride (PVC) forms hydrogen chloride, which causes cor-
rosion of the reactors, an intermediate treatment is required
Since plastics are convenient materials and indispensable to for PVC. All municipal plastic waste also contains PET
daily life, the amount of plastics produced increases yearly, resin, which must be removed at the inlet stage of the
and the total reached about 14 million tons in Japan in 1998. system because pyrolysates of PET form large amounts of
Consequently, the increase in waste plastics has given rise carbon and/or phthalic acids, which choke up the reactor
to numerous environmental problems. In 1998, the total and prevent continuous operation. The amount of PET
amount of waste plastics was about 10 million tons, with consumption and waste continues to rise, and it would be
municipal waste and industrial waste in a 50 : 50 ratio. To impossible to remove PET completely from municipal
reduce the amount of waste plastics, new waste treatment plastic waste. Consequently, it is necessary to develop a
laws and changes in the infrastructure have been intro- system that can treat all types of plastic without any sepa-
duced, so that 44.2% of waste plastics are now recycled. Of ration process.
this 44.2%, 12.7% is being regenerated, 0.7% is being used In a previous paper,1 we reported that polyethylene
(PE), polypropylene (PP), and polystyrene (PS) were con-
verted into oils over a TiO2 catalyst supported on silica
beads which had macropores.The pyrolysates of plastics can
E. Obuchi · M. Suyama · K. Nakano (*) diffuse into the inner pores of the beads, be adsorbed on the
Department of Chemical Engineering, Fukuoka University, 8-19-1
Nanakuma, Johnan-ku, Fukuoka 814-0180, Japan
active sites, and then be decomposed to lower molecular
Tel. +81-92-871-6631; Fax +81-92-865-6031 weight hydrocarbons. In this system, the process is simpli-
e-mail: knakano@fukuoka-u.ac.jp fied because it has the advantage that the pyrolysis and
89

catalysis of the plastics can proceed in the same reactor. The alyst bed and was liquefied and stored in a condenser cooled
purpose of the present work is to study the decomposition in an ice bath. For the preliminary experiment, we under-
of mixed plastics consisting of PP and PET over TiO2/SiO2 took a study to investigate whether different packing styles
catalysts, and to investigate which operating conditions for the PP and PET would produce different amounts of oil
influence product composition and the mechanism of oil and different oil compositions. The first sample was a sand-
production. In addition, we tried to regenerate the catalysts wich of PET between two layers of PP. The other was a
in order to use them repeatedly. sample of PP and PET which had been homogeneously
fused. A comparison of the oils produced indicated that
both samples could be decomposed into similar oils over a
Experimental TiO2/SiO2 catalyst. As the sandwich-type sample is easier
to set up, it was decided to use this type for the following
Preparation of catalyst2,3 experiments. The product gas and oil (liquid) were analyzed
using gas chromatographs equipped with an Flame Ioniza-
Silica beads with a mean pore diameter of about 50 nm (Fuji tion Detector (FID) (Autosystem, Perkin-Elmer, Norwalk,
Silysia Chemical, Kasugai, Japan; 5–10 mesh and 86 m2/g CT, USA) and a thermal conductivity detector (TCD) (G-
Brunauer Emmett Teller (BET) surface area) were im- 2800, Yanaco, Bunseki Kogyo, Kyoto, Japan). We measured
mersed in an isopropanol (IPA, C3H7OH) solution contain- the weight of the oil produced and the volume of the gas
ing titanium tetraisopropoxide (TIP, Ti(OC3H7)4) (molar produced. We estimated the weight of the gas by measuring
ratio, TIP : IPA = 1 : 2) and left overnight. After the hydroly- the distribution of hydrocarbons produced. The “sample
sis of TIP in humidified air, the treated beads were calcined holder residue,” i.e., the residue that was left in the sample
at 773 K for 2 h. Thus, a 20 wt. % TiO2/SiO2 catalyst was holder, and the “adsorbed substance,” i.e. the substance that
obtained. was adsorbed on the catalyst, were both estimated by
The characterization of the catalyst was made using measuring their mass before and after the reaction.
FT–IR (1600 series, Perkin Elmer, USA) spectroscopic data
of pyridine adsorbed in the catalyst.
Regeneration of the used catalyst
Experimental operation
The used catalyst was regenerated as follows. The catalyst
The apparatus consisted of a vertical tubular Pyrex reactor was packed in the reactor and heated to between 673 and
(26 mm diameter and 900 mm length) in an electric furnace 773 K at an air-flow rate of 150 ml min-1. As CO2 was pro-
with temperature controller, as shown in Fig. 1. The TiO2/ duced by combustion of the “adsorbed substance” on the
SiO2 catalysts were packed in the reactor below the sample catalyst surface, the amount of CO2 was measured by gas
holder, which was packed with a mixture of PP and PET. A chromatography (GC) (TCD). When no further CO2 could
nitrogen stream was set at a flow rate of 40 ml min-1. At 698 be detected other than the amount of CO2 in the air, we con-
K, pyrolysis gas from mixed plastics passed through the cat- sidered that the catalyst had been regenerated completely.
The regenerated catalyst was then used in the experimen-
tal operations.

Results and discussion

PET itself did not convert into oils over a TiO2/SiO2 cata-
lyst and formed a milk-white solid which was probably a
kind of phthalic acid. The reason for this may be the fact
that pyrolysates of PET contain aromatic compounds
and oxygen, but lack hydrogen. We hoped that PET would
decompose when the PP pyrolysates, which have a higher
hydrogen content, were mixed with them over macroporous
TiO2/SiO2. We expected that PET could be completely
decomposed into oils under the conditions indicated by the
shaded area in Fig. 2. Outside this area, solid material was
produced in the oils. A comparison of the carbon-number
fractions in the oils produced from the PP and the mixture
of PP and PET at a catalyst weight of 7.5 g, when the
PET/(PP + PET) ratios were 0 and 0.15, respectively, can
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of the apparatus. 1 N2 gas bomb; 2 needle
valve; 3 silica gel dryer; 4 reactor; 5 sample holder; 6 catalyst; 7
be seen in Fig. 3. It was found that oil produced from the
electric furnace; 8 temperature controller; 9 thermocouple; 0 sam- mixture of PP and PET contained smaller amounts of
pling tee; - condenser; = ice bath; q soap-film flow meter C5–C17 hydrocarbons (except for C8) and larger amounts of
90

Fig. 2. Operating conditions that produce oil with no solids Fig. 4. Changes in carbon-number fraction due to the changes in
PET/(PP + PET) ratios

Fig. 3. Changes in carbon-number fractions due to the changes in


PET/(PP + PET) ratios (0 and 0.15) and reaction temperatures (723 K
and 698 K, respectively)
Fig. 5. Comparison of the product distributions from a mixture of PP
and PET over different weights of catalyst at 698 K
C18+ hydrocarbons compared with the oil from PP. As the
PET ratio increased, this tendency became stronger, as
shown in Fig. 4. This is because C18+ hydrocarbons are found the amount of gas, because the heavier components were
in the aromatics in PET. If the PET/(PP + PET) ratio is decomposed on the surface of the catalyst. The gas pro-
greater, the oil produced contains some solids as mentioned duced consisted mainly of C3–C5 hydrocarbons, and this is
above. potentially useful as a fuel. PET molecules contain oxygen
The comparison between the product distributions and which may be converted into CO, CO2, and other oxy-
the carbon-number fractions in the oil produced over dif- genated compounds. CO and CO2 were detected in the gas
ferent weights of catalyst can be seen in Figs. 5 and 6, respec- produced, and from the composition of these gases, the mass
tively. Figure 5 shows the weight percentage of oil produced, balance of oxygen was about 60% over the TiO2/SiO2 cata-
gas produced, sample holder residue, and adsorbed sub- lyst. Since other oxygenated compounds did not appear in
stance on the catalyst. Not all examples reach 100% of the the gas and oil produced, we assume that the oxygen is con-
total weight, and this is attributed to the residue left on the verted into water and oxygen gas, which is difficult to detect
reactor wall. At PET/(PP + PET) = 0.15 and a catalyst using gas chromatographic analysis, as in this experiment.
weight of 2.5 g, the oil yield was about 70%, but this The TiO2/SiO2 catalyst was used repeatedly, as shown in
decreased with increasing catalyst weight. The greater the Fig. 7. A mixture of PP and PET (PET/(PP + PET) = 0.15)
catalyst weight, the lighter the oil fraction and the larger was converted into oils without the formation of solids up
91

Fig. 8. FT–IR spectra of adsorbed pyridine on the TiO2/SiO2 catalyst:


Fig. 6. Comparison of carbon-number fractions of oils produced from (a) before the adsorption of pyridine; (b) after the adsorption of pyri-
a mixture of PP and PET over different weights of catalyst dine; (c) the differential spectrum

Table 1. Assignment of infrared absorption bands of adsorbed pyri-


dine in the range 1700–1400 cm-1
Vibration mode PyB (cm-1) PyL (cm-1)

8a 1640–1634 1615–1592
19a 1490–1478 1490–1471
19b 1542–1525 1461–1437

hard coke is difficult to burn off and high temperatures of


around 823 K are usually required. However, in order not
to sinter the catalyst in the regeneration process, it was
heated to only 773 K.
We analyzed the surface of the catalyst to clarify the
mechanism of the plastic decomposition reaction.The acidic
character of the TiO2/SiO2 was proved by the pyridine
adsorbed on the catalyst using FT–IR spectroscopy. In
Fig. 7. Yields of oil produced with repeated uses of fresh and regen- general, pyridine combines with Lewis acid sites to form
erated TiO2/SiO2 catalysts coordinated pyridine (PyL), and with Brønsted acid sites
to form pyridinium ion (PyB). The assignment of infrared
absorption bands of adsorbed pyridine in the range
to the 8th run in fresh catalyst. It was found that the yield 1700–1400 cm-1 is shown in Table 1. Infrared spectra of
of oil produced increased gradually, and this oil included TiO2/SiO2 catalyst surfaces before and after adsorption of
heavier components with repeated use of the catalyst. In the pyridine and their differential spectrum are shown in Fig. 8.
9th run, the mixture of PP and PET could not be completely The peaks were found to be at 1446, 1490, and 1608 cm-1, as
converted into oils owing to the formation of the solids shown in Fig. 8. They correspond to the peaks of coordi-
derived from PET pyrolysates, and therefore the catalyst nated pyridine shown in Table 1.4 Although the peak at
was then regenerated as described above. The yield of oil 1490 cm-1 may be considered to be the Brønsted acid site,
for the regenerated catalyst was almost the same as for the we considered it to be the Lewis acid sites because no other
fresh catalyst until the 7th run. We had discovered that we peaks for Brønsted acid sites were found on the TiO2/SiO2
could use the TiO2/SiO2 catalyst repeatedly and regenerate catalyst from these spectra. Consequently, we conclude that
it successfully. However, the fact that the number of the acid sites on the TiO2/SiO2 catalyst are almost identical
repeated uses of the catalyst decreased was assumed to be to the Lewis acid sites.
because the regeneration was incomplete, or because sub- Lewis acid sites are known to abstract hydrides from
stances which were not removed were adsorbed strongly adsorbed hydrocarbons to break down long-chain hydro-
on the catalyst. In general, coke consists of both “hard” carbons via b-scission reaction.5 In a previous paper,1 we
(nonvolatile) and “soft” (volatile) coke. Whereas soft coke found that hydrogen was formed in the gas phase when
is easily burned off at a relatively low temperature in air, Pt–TiO2/SiO2 catalysts were used. This phenomenon is
92

thought to be due to the surface migration of hydrides to The yield of oils and their carbon-number fractions changes
react with protons on the platinum surface. We therefore with changes in PET/(PP + PET) ratios and catalyst weight.
suggest that the production mechanism of oil from mixed The TiO2/SiO2 catalyst could be regenerated and used
plastics consisting of PP and PET over a TiO2/SiO2 catalyst repeatedly. Oil and gas production is due to the reaction of
is as follows. First, pyrolysates of PP and PET are separately hydrides abstracted from PP pyrolysates on the Lewis acid
adsorbed on the catalyst surface. Second, the hydride is sites with PET pyrolysates. The oil and gas produced could
abstracted from the PP pyrolysates on the Lewis acid sites be used as fuel after this catalytic transformation.
and moved to the PET pyrolysates.5 Finally, the PET
pyrolysates pick up the hydride and form hydrogen-rich Acknowledgments We would like to thank the Plastic Waste Manage-
compounds which break down into lighter hydrocarbons ment Institute for their financial support.
via b-scission reaction. The rest of the pyrolysates are left
on the catalyst surface as a coke precursor or “adsorbed
substance.”
The action of the Brønsted acid sites, however, is cur- References
rently still being investigated using an Al2O3 catalyst. More
research is needed in order to understand the relationship 1. Obuchi E, Nakano K (1994) Catalytic decomposition of plastic
between the acid sites of the catalyst and the oil production wastes into fuel oils over titania supported on silica. Proceedings of
the Taipei-Kyushu Joint Symposium on Chemical Engineering and
mechanism. on Transport Phenomena and Applications, Taipei, 253–257
2. Matsuo K, Nakano K (1988) Performances of platinum metal
catalysts supported on titania-coated silica prepared from metal
Conclusion organics. Appl Surf Sci 33/34:269–276
3. Obuchi E, Sakamoto T, Nakano K, Shiraishi F (1999) Photocatalytic
decomposition of acetaldehyde over TiO2/SiO2 catalyst. Chem Eng
Mixed plastics consisting of PP and PET were converted Sci 54:1525–1530
into oils up to PET/(PP + PET) = 0.45, without the forma- 4. Rajagopal S, Marzari JA, Marinda R (1995) Silica–alumina-
supported Mo oxide catalyst: genesis and demise of Brønsted–Lewis
tion of solids, over a TiO2/SiO2 catalyst at 698 K in a nitro- acidity. J Catal 151:192–203
gen stream. The yield of the oil produced was about 70%, 5. Guerzoni FN, Aboot J (1994) Catalytic cracking of a Gippsland
and this oil contained large amounts of C18+ hydrocarbons. reduced crude on zeolite catalysts. J Catal 147:393–403

You might also like